Siskel & Ebert Review The Films of...Paul Thomas Anderson
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 бер 2024
- A chronological compilation of Siskel & Ebert (and others later) reviewing the films of Paul Thomas Anderson
This is kind of a "mini-sode" (like the Farrelly brothers one I did) since it only covers 5 films, but it's a good one. And yes, Siskel was only alive for the first two films, so the title will be seen as a tease by those who don't know that, but it's the name of my series (and Ebert is still on most of these)
And this might as well be called "Ebert defends the films of Paul Thomas Anderson"
Primarily for educational purposes, but enjoy however you see fit!
For more of this series:
• Siskel & Ebert Review ... - Фільми й анімація
A chronological compilation of Siskel & Ebert (and others later) reviewing the films of Paul Thomas Anderson
This is kind of a "mini-sode" (like the Farrelly brothers one I did) since it only covers 5 films, but it's a good one. And yes, Siskel was only alive for the first two films, so the title will be seen as a tease by those who don't know that, but it's the name of my series (and Ebert is still on most of these)
And this might as well be called "Ebert defends the films of Paul Thomas Anderson"
Primarily for educational purposes, but enjoy however you see fit!
For more of this series:
ua-cam.com/play/PLjog8SEXXlNV9hSA2USQDeuz-Njrkhuar.html&si=9MBkX8IAqz2l-B1b
Ebert continues to prove himself as a man ahead of his time.
He gave Dawn of the Dead top stars in 1978, an unrated and super edgy film for it's time. Was he always right? No, he was human thankfully. He really was the most thoughtful critic of all time and since his passing the idea of a critic has suffered for a boatload of reasons, if he was still alive he would likely balance this.
He knew a movie was great before we did. He was very progressive in his reviews of film and could spot directorial choices that were misogynistic and also call out art when it was in fact rallying against misogyny. He understood the importance of Spike Lee as a new voice in American cinema, regardless of what your opinion of him might be. He also didn't shy away from movie as entertainment and didn't stand atop his high brow pedestal. @@megazillion2946
@@megazillion2946 Dawn Of The Dead 78 was a masterpiece , the sequel was crap !!!! Don't even comment back to me because it's going directly out the other ear !!!! Ur opinion is 🗑️😂
@@maralinekozial9131 Sry, I maybe didn't phrase that right. To be clear Dawn of the Dead (78) is my favorite film of all time and I love his review of it! My old band even put out a album of Goblin covers from Dawn of the Dead that Claudio Simmoneti thought was great and Tom Savini said he played it in his shop. Best movie ever, for real. It's part of my artistic DNA.
Gold. ua-cam.com/video/iqCS6OMfBBI/v-deo.html
Boogie Nights, Magnolia & There Will Be Blood are 10/10 films for me. There Will Be Blood is an all time classic & one of the best films ever made, IMHO.
How could anyone dislike Magnolia? Let alone a film critic? 🙄🤷♂️
No wonder I’ve never seen that lady again.
I love Magnolia...but it doesn't hurt to try and understand we've all got different tastes. I can certainly understand someone not liking it.
@@RossComptonthe19th everyone has the right to their own opinion, but I didn't think they had good arguments. I have friends that don't like Magnolia either, but they usually have trash tastes in general lol. But I hear ya 👍
Its very devisive
Not my favorite.
Thank you for posting all these, they are awesome. Keep them coming, much appreciated.
you continue to impress. you are creating a wonderfully comprehensive collection of great reviews. on behalf of movie fans and siskel/ebert fans everywhere, THANKS!
this is the one i’ve been waiting for
Hard Eight is PTA's most underrated film. One of his very best imo.
the story completely comes together. that joyce chick is clueless
If Hard Eight came out as not PTA first film, it'd get Academy talk.
great series keep it up
We never learned what Gene thought of the frogs 😭 Even PTA says it should have been shorter.
Definitely would have loved to see them argue about Magnolia. Or maybe they would agree, who knows. The substitute critics all hated it with a passion.
I love the movie but agree he could have cut some things.
I heard Punch Drunk Love was inspired by PTA’s relationship with Fiona Apple
The magnolia section aha
How about Robert Altman next?
Definitely coming at some point!
Hard Eight is a damn fine movie.
Wow idk if I've ever heard Ebert give it to Siskel in a good way. "That's good" right at the end of his Hard Eight take.
Gene Siskel would’ve loved punch drunk love. I think he slowly started to appreciate Adam Sandler as an actor.
Is Kulhawik's critic card revoked yet?
Ebert is just the goat
I don't ever remember seeing any blk n wht slides in There Will Be Blood ever!!! & Ive seen it 40 times !!!! Was those scenes only shown in the movie theater or something????
It's from a bonus feature on the dvd
ao scott michael phillips gives punch drunk love a rent it
I rewatched TWBB last month, for the first time in 10 years... To be honest i found it not as good as i remember, felt a bit dull really.
Three times Ebert had another film critic on the show tell him what a pretentious mess Magnolia is.
3 nobodys
@@josephgrimes3886 Oh okay, Odysseus.
And he stood up to those wrong people every time
And Magnolia is regarded as a classic today.
@@Tolstoy111 Is it? I rarely see it discussed in the same way that Boogie Nights, There Will Be Blood, or even The Master are. Magnolia is a mess.
Siskel totally whiffed on Boogie nights.
Magnolia is the silliest movie you can watch.
magnolia was sensational, wildly ambitious, hugely enjoyable, an amazing cast with terrific performances and very nearly perfect. it is NOT for formulaic film fans
@@josephgrimes3886almost all characters in this movie behave like angry, dramatic teenagers, movie is cringy as shit
most movies are. enjoy the formula@@damazywlodarczyk
most movies are. stick to the formula@@damazywlodarczyk
I dunno, I've seen Joker.
Ebert absolutely nailed Boogie Nights. Siskel did not.