Giant Great White Shark Eaten By MONSTER Mystery Finally Solved
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 січ 2023
- Let's dive into how this great white shark eaten by a monster mystery was finally solved!
Suggest a topic here to be turned into a video: bit.ly/2kwqhuh
Subscribe for more! ► goo.gl/pgcoq1 ◄
Stay updated ► goo.gl/JyGcTt goo.gl/5c8dzr ◄
For copyright queries or general inquiries please get in touch: hello@beamazed.com
Legal Stuff.
Unless otherwise created by BeAmazed, licenses have been obtained for images/footage in the video from the following sources: pastebin.com/sDha7AGa
If you want to jump to the answer, it starts at 25:05.
All that comes before is, in my opinion, interesting but far too long drawn out.
Thanks bro.
Thank you!
THNX
Ty
thanks!
Hey I remember this story. Thanks for bringing it back. What ever killed the shark didn't have to swallow it whole, it just might have just bit off a piece which had the tracker attached to it.
Most likely
But if only cut of that part it can’t have that much accuracy to just leave the tag and it wouldn’t be useful for the predator if it just fit like 1 tiny part
And also it showed that when it was casually swimming something with so much power with sheer determination took it to the deep waters and prob fed on it since all that work for just to let the shark escape ?
You are significantly smarter than they are making the scientists appear to be
If I remember correctly the temperature changes that the tag read led them to believe it wasn't just the piece with the tag on it.
I and a friend were surfing in the early 1970's at Clifford Bay NZ. We had "long boards", not the skimpy little things you see these days. I think my board was 8 foot. Anyway, we were lying on the boards paddling out to a point break about 300 metres offshore on a dull overcast summers day. Suddenly my mate sat up on his board, turned, was on his knees and paddling back past me to shore and as he went by, he quietly said "shark". I didn't really comprehend his message and I dozily raised myself up on the board to look eyeball to eyeball with a huge Great White [he looked to be twice the size of my board - but hey, it was big]. I froze and watched him as he watched me and he gracefully moved without any effort, through the crystal clear water about a board length in front of me. We kept eye contact until he got so far across from me that he flicked his eye back to the front and continued his quest for fish that may have been disoriently by the surf - so I presumed. I got up on my knees and paddled that board right up onto the beach! We opened a couple of bottles of beers and drank them down with the froth we had made from our shaking hands!. I haven't been surfing since then; in my 70's now and don't think I ever will be back on a board! When you see just how powerful these creatures are, how with only muscle rippling they can move through the water, you realise that you are in their domain and there at their pleasure.
I watched them from a boat eating a dead whale about 6 km off sth Australia shore and you’re right they move through the water effortlessly and gracefully. People naturally try to out swim sharks as a natural reaction but we are wasting our time. It’s impossible.😂
My dad's board in the late 60's was 8 feet long, made entirely of wood and weighed at least 60 Lbs! Was your board anything like THAT??
Cool story.. I love the water but Jaws affected me in going out far in ocean water. I live in Maine and a woman was eaten right off shore in front of her daughter as they swam in York Maine. It was a 17 foot great white
if that was spotted in china or vietnam, we would of brought it to the shore and have a bbq in 30 minutes
Water is connected to sharks.
This is like a movie project that was sent to Netflix and stretched to 12 episodes.
Lmao gotta fill that runtime somehow
"How much misinformation and fearmongering would you like me to add?"
*_"YES"_*
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
epic comment ! pretty much sums it up and yeah the ocean is huge WE DONT KNOW SQUAT.
Fear mongering or not a billionaire Asian who was a
gene scientist was turned in for having a secret massive tank built under his mansion. And he was said to have re-create a meg!!
The video was great though, wouldn't have been nearly as fun if he was just like "Big shark ate small shark"
Go watch a scientific channel if you want no fluff or storytelling and only want sentences that are facts after facts. Sheesh.
"There's always a bigger fish."
-Qui-Gon Jinn
So true 👍
Not always.
"A big fish is caught with big bait"
-Sun Tzu, The Art of War
The impetus for Racism
Exactly
The tagged shark Alpha was 2,7 meters long (9 feet), which is less than half the size of the largest great white shark ever recorded (7 meters/23,5 feet).
Sharks are famously opportunists and can perfectly well decide to be cannibalistic if hungry enough.
They can also dive very deep, especially larger specimens dive to lower depths than the smaller ones.
To reiterate the size difference between the tagged female and the largest recorded great white;
Shark Alpha was half a meter (2,7 feet) longer than André the Giant, and the largest specimen was 1,2 meters or four feet and change longer than the tallest giraffe recorded (George, at 5,8 meters/19 feet)
Notice he calls it "the giant shark" near the beginning too. This majorly detracts credibility.
yards...
never been so thankful for the "most replayed" timeline thing.
14-16ft is a normal size of a Great White they are considered big after that , The largest recorded was 23 ft with 20 ft GWs seen regularly 50 years ago now they are very rare.
A 16 foot Great White is not exactly abnormal, Great Whites are known to grow up to 20' in length. Granted, 20 footers are very uncommon these days because they've been hunted so heavily in the past, thanks in no small part to the movie Jaws, but they can grow that large. So a 16 footer, while quite large for a Great White these days, is hardly anything abnormal.
well said, true
Some years back off the coast of Australia, a great white was hauled in from a shark net. Prob 4m or so IIRC. Poor shark was dead cos a huge bite had been taken out of it. Half metre jaw diameter, which equates to a 6.5-7m great white. So there's at least 1 out there
Deep Blue as they named a huge female Great White is around 24 feet long or 7+ meters. I live in South Australia and have been seeing Whites here since I was 4 years old, i'm over 60 now and I can assure you 18 footers have been seen often here with some sightings of 20+ feet recorded. I've had an easy 18 footer come up to our boat while snapper fishing with my father in the 1960s which was the length of our boat which was 18 feet. Numerous others saw the same shark which attacked a couple of the other boats
@@Antipodean33 No deep blue is estimated to be 20-21 feet long
@@Antipodean33people forget that female shark exist and it's a living fossil of a beast
Soo, take what seems like a fantastic, mysterious riddle and turn it into a 30 minute story filled with crazy theories about a "Jurassic Park" type explanation is certainly ONE way to go...
Around 40 years ago, I was having a conversation with a retired fisherman whom at one time had also captained the URI research vessel out of Narraganset RI. I asked him what the strangest thing he had ever brought up in his nets was. He initially told me left over torpedoes and such from WWII. There is still a sunken U-boat off block island to this day. So, I said to him I was interested in strange sea life. His response was a 25 foot long, 5,000-pound great white shark came up in his net once. It was 1 mile off Charlestown beach in RI (Block Island sound). At that time, I didn't know that great whites usually didn't exceed 16 feet. After all I grew up with Jaws lol. All these years later I hear about megalodon and ever since I cannot help but be suspicious that he had in fact caught a young megalodon. They cut it up and tossed it overboard if I remember correctly because there was no market for that type of fish then. His catching incident happened approximately 80 years ago as it happened about 40 years before he told me the story. He was in his 80's at the time of the conversation. This a true story. It was a pity he hadn't taken a picture of it.
I call bs
A long time ago I vowed never to swim in the ocean. As soon as you enter the water you become part of the food chain.
On thing I won’t do been to the beach no swimming though
Same here. Ocean equals death.
It’s far more dangerous to get in a car
@@jonnytlong that argument is BS
@@BillyJ244 how do you figure that? I’m 52 and have surfed since I was five. I’ve only met someone who was bit once and that was when he was fishing and was a tiny scar. The ocean is probably more safe than staying in your house. It would be nice if everyone thought like you and stayed out though, now that I think of it. No clueless tourists in the way would be great.
I've seen a 9 foot shark attacked by a 12 foot shark, then get chewed to pieces by 6 others after being incapacitated by the first big bite. I've seen feeding frenzies with several different predators competing for pieces of the victim. Perhaps a giant squid grabbed the shark & dove with it, as they would, then some other sharks followed it down to try to get a piece of the pie, and one of them ended up with the tracker.
But is there anything in the ocean that warm other than marine mammals? fish arent' THAT much warmer than surround ambient water temp are they? Don['t tell me they're the same as ambient bc sea turtles are warmer than ambient (when in cold waters) at least that's what the world's foremost leatherback expert told me in person in costa rica one beautiful starlit night 18 yrs ago
That still does not explain the internal temperature issues of the tag reading
That also does not explain why that bigly squid would make the shark into a pie.
@@thomaswu9094 thermal vents effect maybe
I had a stroke reading that
So after all the rambling, they still do not know what exactly ate the shark lmfao.
I didnt think they would
Their first mistake was assuming that the shark was dead because the tracker was removed.
And the second: Why the same shark couldn't have eaten the sensor that came off its back? Sharks can eat trash... Even tires!
He ate the tracker, cause when it was found, it was bleeched out, from stomach acid!
Around Australia and Guadalupe Island most of the great whites that are tagged tend to be between 11 and 18 feet in length so a 17 ft great white seems less likely to have gigantism and more likely to be an adult of average size. Shark Alpha was just a very unlucky juvenile.
Agreed. Hell, the longest ones are in the 20-25 foot range.
@@o-mangaming5042 😊ul
@@o-mangaming5042 And that's what we've caught and formally documented (though rarely). ocean life being what it is today, it's safe to say almost all species had larger specimens 100 yrs ago or more. Heck, even 50 yrs ago.
That all adds up to there is (or has been recently) larger white sharks than "only" 7 meters.
I didn[t like how narrator called the 9ft great white as "huge" that's not even avg, bud! Then again, I say that from the comfort of my very dry office hundreds of miles from the ocean and probably 1000 miles from the nearest white shark
why did they bother tagging the 9’er ? had’nt heard of that seeming waste of time since that size of fish are likely to become edibles’ rather than the (larger ones) providing migration Data !!
@@thomasmacginnes100 I think it’s cause they happened along a swarm of sharks and were tagging as many as they could to get as much data as possible. The swarm wasn’t too far off the shore because they were attracted to the whale carcasses, and so they were easier to tag. That’s just my guess though.
I love how the title says this incident is finally solved, while the show itself covers a variety of possible explanations... all of which are based on relatively little actual evidence.
Makes for an interesting video... I'll give 'em that!
So annoying when they do that!
Imagine tagging a Huge shark.. just to find out it was eaten by a much bigger monster shark...
I have been to sea thousands of times, and this frightens me
@@Fr0styJade Yeah, a literal sea monster eaten by an even bigger sea monster, its not safe
I remember seeing the first part of this story and its good that you have solved the puzzle of what happened
Give the cameraman a price for getting inside the predator's stomach to take that photo
I had read that great white sharks average about 18 feet, so I'm not sure why a great white shark with gigantism would only measure 16 feet. 🤔
Nice storytellinng and vídeo production! Well done.
How are you feeling right now?
The increase in temperature could have been from a thermal vent. It doesn’t mean it was swallowed for sure.
How about a naturally occurring Sperm Whale? Not the certainly-extinct Melvillei but a very large modern specimen. I have heard that they can dive to very great depths and feed on Colossal Squid. Also, did anyone test the tag for DNA? Good presentation by the way.
I agree. Sperm whales have been known to feed on sharks.
Makes sense good job
Makes sense too
It was a larger great white that ate it.
@@normacunningham8913 it doesn’t have to me
They are not at the top. Orcas are.
I believe sperm whales are the oceans top predator.
But orcas don’t eat white , only their liver
sperm whales are.
Lol nop omega giga giant squid is. I forgot his name has never been filmed only corpse found.
Collosal squid? Tbh they are just campers. The only difference beetween collosal and giant is that collosal has more packs of meat cause of how deep they live. Giant squids are way more active and present than they are.@@spudbencer7179
Why of course it’s godzilla :P
YEAAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!
GODZILLA APPROVED LIFE
Ah yes
Stop blaming godzilla he a good boy
There is something else down there more deadly than all of them put together
The shark didn't have to be eaten whole for the tracker to be bitten off...
Maybe is was that black demon shark that has been reported quite a few tine now.
Fun fact: There is a well known case of sharks disapearing from a big ocean tank expo. The keepers thaught that bigger sharks/predators were eating them but they could not prove it and couldnt cut them open either. So they kept their vigil and eventually caught the culprit. The big pride of the tank a huge octopus had developed a taste for shark. It hunted from them at night and then dragged them back to his hole to gobbled them up.
Wasn't that just a whale shark?
What about great blue the female 20 foot shark great white shark she is about 80 years old
I figured if there were deep sea vents that could have been where the sudden heat came from. They're not really detailing how long the heat remained or more about the biometrics. I guess the scientists know better than me though lol.
Me when they mentioned Australia “ Huh , it’s always something going on with animals over their” 😂😂
Huh, *there’s* always something going on with animals over *there*
you're welcome
Success is not built on success. It's built on failure, It's built on fraustration. it's built on fear that you have to overcome. I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life
You are right.!
That is why I had to start forex trading 2months ago and l now am making benefits from it.!
My first investment with Victoria Alejandro gave me profit of over $80,000 Us dollar....
And I can even say she is the sincere broker I know....
O' Yes I'm a living testimony of Mrs Victoria Alejandro.!
I love how you can take what seems like a simple question and trace it back to show how what seems simple turns out to be quite complex. Best of all, you make it quite entertaining.
Yes, they make it entertaining by using incorrect and exaggerated statements.
I love how you can take what seems like a simple question and and regurgitate every conspiracy theory about the ocean
It had been "Jaws", God dammit.
That means they're full of shit dude.
@stinkbug4321 don't use the Lord's name in vain like that
It's Christmas eve.... Santa would've craved some sushi😂
Wow! It even has it's own internal lighting!
The mountains, caves, valleys, hills, the terrain, of unexplored ocean floors is way bigger then anything we have of dry land. It's crazy!!!!!
It is, but it's more crazy that our planet was once covered by nothing but water.
Depending on how the tracker was attached to the fin, I believe that whatever creature attacked the shark, resulted in the tracking device detaching from the shark ( along with a chunk of the dorsal fin and falling into an underwater vent of some sort and rising in temperature, before floating to the surface after the flesh it was attached to was either; melted, eaten, or the tag somehow became removed in which it floated to the surface. I'm not sure how plausible that is but let me know what you think, is this a plausible theory?
Edit: Nevermind I just found out the video just takes 25 minutes to tell you what actually happened...
Studies of white sharks in the gulf in the gulf found that they maintain a constant body temperature of about 26.5°C (almost 80°F). Was a larger great white or a Tiger.
5 minutes actually
No it didn’t. It was just another theory. A great white with gigantism ? And then quickly diving to 1,900 feet ? Why do that ?
@@lisacolbert5987 Couldn't handle swimming when it had the added weight of a second great white shark in it???
@@lisacolbert5987 To drown it most likely - as stupid as it sounds drad a shark in reverse and it will drown
Oh wait it’s Australia 🇦🇺 😂
this stuff made me very curious
You seem to forget the shark might not have been eaten at all, but only had a chunk taken out by the fin, thereby the tracker was ingested with 20 pounds of shark bite. The sensor could have been regurgitated soon after and not gone through the stomach.
But why did the shark waited until it dived that deep down before eating “just the fin”. The video said that the shark ate the alpha shark only after it dived deep deep down
27:16
The idea of a massive cannibal shark is as equally terrifying as an unknown creature.
If anything this has shown a new behavior pattern for a specific population of great whites. As for the larger shark plummeting to deep depths to eat the shark, lots of great white attacks on people have a resulted in the sharks dragging the victim to the bottom and tearing the person to pieces on the seafloor.
This occurred in that horrific attack in Tasmania where the father/daughter duo we're diving for scallops. When the father failed to surface, she dove down look for him and saw a great white pinning him to the seafloor tearing him up.
Sharks either impact from below, or rapidly descend when they capture prey to disorient prey.
the pinning is common for sharks because it gives them leverage and they can hold the victim whilst attacking versus pushing on the victim inadvertently while killing and/or consuming and the prey is pushed further from them - a horrific example
Omg Way to brighten someone's day my dude 👍 I bet yer just a riot at parties f#&k! I can't imagine the ptsd that poor girl developed. JESUS CHRIST! I can grantee she never set foot in water or even on a boat again. As much as i love the beach I would have moved to the desert.
all sharks are cannibals
This does not show any new behavior pattern for a specific population of great whites at all....
The depth the tag changed temp at was not that deep. They said later they have been recorded as deep as 4k
GW attacks are not common and you have no way of recording or showing recordings of the behavior that you are saying is common. Going to the bottom of the ocean to eat there... you are making that up
Scallops are shallow water animals so they were relatively shallow which is why the story went that way. Whites bite and thrash if the object is large (whales) or they bite and shake to get a mouthful as their teeth are not meant to chew by crushing.
This event is not endemic of all GW attacks
Sharks dive to get away from other sharks the same reason predatory animals on land grab something and try to run off with it. As not to share
When you weren't just assuming things you were either making them up and asserting them as scientifically proven fact or repeating something someone else said that you are now asserting as fact
A 16 ft great white is not even really big for a great white.
Fish are cannibalistic by nature.
That's a 20 footer.... 25, 3 tons of him! Thank you, a great video!
Nova Scotia is seeing some INCREDIBLY large sharks. Even seeing them swimming within Halifax Harbour. These are massive mothers.
Could have easily been several normal great white sharks. They've got footage of several attacking one injured female shark that an attempted mate had injured. How did they come to the conclusion it was an irregular giant 16ft great white?
If it's a swarm attack they'll tear the tag off during an attack, either making the tag float or eaten on the spot. So it won't be possible to get the "sharp turn>plunging down>temperture spike" data.
The tag data suggested a behavior pattern only single predator can make, that's why their first hypothesis was already "a super predator".
Honestly, this was my question..how would they know it was 16 ft. Deep Blue, is like 20 ft..right?
What really made me wonder, is the deep dive, before ingestion.
I don't pretend to know what ate the 9ft white shark, however, I do find it quite strange.
@yuurou7927 so wouldn't the tag measure the base temperature of the 🦈 even if it was swimming away while getting chunks of it bitten off and then when the tag portion was ripped off and eaten register the same levels?
@@somejerkbagnow your just negatively stating your opinions when it was already explained.
@@kokujinn timestamp where that was explained dickhead
Whoever narrated this has the most amazing and fun and calming voice ever. I listen to a lot of ghost stories, etc. I wish he would narrate some. He could almost rival Natures Temper! Great job Dude!!!!
Too true
Shark Alpha could've been eaten by something we haven't discovered yet.
Not sure why 16 feet is somehow a "super shark" it is a large white shark, but 16 to 20 feet or so is far from unheard of. The largest female I believe was around 21 feet and incredibly heavy bodies at almost 2 ton. That would make it twice as long as probably about 3 to 4 times heavier than the shark that was eaten. Also it could have just taken a large bite from the smaller shark swallowing the tracker then diving down. Not really that crazy.
Exactly.
Can we get all your teachers/past teaches together to celeb this man
You my friend are swag😎
Celebrate
I'm not sure why its natural for people to want crazy theories to be true, I guess they bored.
My thoughts exactly 😊
Just a minor point. Even if the squid was cold blooded, would the chemical reactions from digestion cause the stomach temp be higher??? Has this been tested??
My wife's exact question. Lol
It's actually a good theory, but come to think of it, the temperature found would be too high for any chemical compound to produce in such a large body of ocean water. The culprit creature would need to have a very thick body and guts(insulation), covering its "hot" digestion system, to keep such high temperature in an immeasurable body of freezing ocean water and depth. An orca would fit de description better, even a bigger great white, but I still have my doubts
Giant squid have a beak that it eats with it doesn’t swallow its food in big bites so it definitely wasn’t a squid.
i liked the way of narration, the twists and animation too.
it's for children, sooo take that however you will. It's why he speaks so slow and clear. For ESL speakers as well, though.
Being attached specifically to the base of the dorsal fin, are we absolutely sure the tag didn't just get removed and tossed overboard by shark poachers where it sank to the bottom before getting accidentally mistaken for prey by a reasonably sized creature that hunts by sensing movement, and consumed THAT way? You know, Occam's razor and all that. Remember, the tag was not necessarily tracking the shark the entire time, just itself.
Very interesting video. Makes you think of the possibilities of what is lurking in the unexplored depths of our oceans.
Could be a mosasaur because they were real millions of years ago but 80% of the ocean hasn't been explored so it could've been anything for all we know
I honestly think an orca killed the shark, ripped out its liver as they do often. Great white liver is an orcas favourite meal. Then other sharks scavenged the remains, another great white ate the part that had the tag. They are warm blooded. That’s what happened folks no matter how much you want it to be a a Megladon. 😝 🦈
@@kieranhart5776 bro shut up please, no one asked you.
Also, then how did it end up 1900 feet below the deep ocean? That can’t be the explanation.
Maybe an Archelon? They would have been big enough to eat a 9 foot great white and since it was a enormous sea turtle there's a possibility it was carnivorous
The first time I ever heard this "mystery" presented, I thought that the shark itself did not need to be eaten, it just had to be something that took a bite where the tracker was located. Like many internet mysteries it has been way overblown and pseudoscienced to death.
You have a point there
It's so wild to think about that only 20% of the worlds water is discovered....there is bound to be some crazy shit in some of the depths in the ocean
I remember a story about some South African fishermen finding a massive tooth among their catch which, when analysed by scientists, was determined to be a Megaladon tooth that was only 10,000 years old.
I'm more fascinated by the fact a tiny little computer board was out in the middle of the ocean, 1,000 feet deep, and still ended up on shore. Thousand of tons of trash are just floating out there for years but this little computer board made it home.
It would have to be its size, weight, and current at the time, which is why more trash appears on particular beaches than on others.
Wow I never would have thought a 9 foot shark could weigh 2000 lbs ,that’s amazing
The 16ft did. Derp
When the tracker was analyzed, it said that the shark dove very deep, suddenly and abruptly, yet held the same external temperature. Meaning it was probably swallowed whole.
Witch means it is a probity a moasasaur or a megalodon
@@oliverrey4170 Megalodon was a coastal predator not a deep sea one. We would have seen it.
Mosasarus is defo extinct though Monitor Lizards could easily start Mosasaur 2.0 if they wanted to start going back into the ocean.
Or another shark, in an effort to save itself from getting injured itself, blindsided it from above, ripped a chunk off and kept going down. They tag the fin, it doesn't necessarily cover the rest of the body. Or a sperm whale, since they duke it out with Giant Squids a lot and found an easier meal in that shark
@@kieranhart5776 nobody said megladon shut up
We33
Mosasaur only lived in shallow water as well.
We have such beautiful beaches in Australia, but EVERYTHING you mentioned in this video is why I don't go deeper than my knees 🦈
Everything in Australia seems out to get you 🫤
More likely a propeller ripped it off and it got untangled, then It fell to the bottom where it was eaten before being vomited out
Nope
That doesn't account for the lack of temperature change in the monitor
@Ghost Malone fair point, perhaps it could have been to it not reading it properly.
Bruh
Those tags are designed to float when they come off, sinking isn't an option. And sharks don't generally get hit by boat propellers or ship screws.
In WWII there was a British ship that threw out some depth charges and had a crazy "alligator looking" specimen float up to the top (killed by the charges) & which was verified by a ton of the crew who saw it. I think it's definitely still out there, whatever it was. Not to mention salt water crocodiles, which get Enormous, are known to live out at sea.
how about this. giant squid grabs a shark and does a rapid deep dive to a warm seabed vent where it chows down at leisure.
South West of Western Australia is over 1100km from the range of the estuarine (salt water) crocodile. There's no way a cold blooded tropical reptile could survive in the freezing southern ocean around Esperance or Albany W.A, the region where this shark was killed. My money as a former local would be on a much bigger great white (3 meters is barely an adult) or an Orca.
@@Some1inFNQ my money is on an Orca, but that's not nearly as exciting or imaginative as some unknown alligator-like sea beast 😂
MOSASAURUS
But crocs breath air & can't dive that deep. Idk I say still unsolved.
5:46 oceangate be like
keep in mind that deep blue is roughly bigger than 20 feet, we saw her a lot of time in some discovery specials during shark week
Not only are 20ft or more Great white sharks a fairly common sight. But hammer heads and tiger sharks occasionally get 18ft or more.
Exactly. The kid in the video acts like a 16 foot great white is some rare phenomenon lol
It's pretty common knowledge that a 9 foot great white is on the small end and likely a youngish shark. 17 footers are large but not uncommon. The average female is between 12 and 16 feet with Deep Blue being between 19-21 feet. Super fun video but I am reasonably sure gigantism didn't play a role.
Yeah I always felt like these videos try to up play the size of the eaten shark to be to big when besides what you pointed out there are other Sharks that can hit the 20 feet mark.
Is the Megalodon.
a 16 foot great white does not mean gigantism. Gigantism isn't even mentioned in cases of larger ones.
i just want the answer brooo😭😭😭😭😭😭
Honestly, the fact remains that this could have also just been the Top Dorsal Fin where the tracking device was attached, just bitten off instead of the entire Shark itself actually eaten whole.. the fact that something much larger exists is in fact possible and I do believe there actually is. My opinion is the tracking device and Dorsal Fin Portion was the only portion in fact eaten by perhaps another shark in warmer waters at surface level before submerging to the depths before its body temp cooled, or an unknown warm blooded undiscovered creature... ;-) just another possibility ;-)
yep its probably whats the case or similar it unattached somehow
as cool as it is too imagine a huge monster consuming a shark whole is
thats just it, cool
would also be cool to be wrong
I'm sticking with Orca. Because the readings came back that the tag was dragged to that depth at a warm temperature we assume the whole shark was with it. As we know from the beginning of the video the shark was tagged on the back of It's dorsal fin. That means an Orca could've easily taken a chunk out of it. They're also a creature known to waste their food. I watched three chase a mum and baby whale for over three hours ( David Attenborough ) only to eat the baby's jaw and f*ck off like a bunch of pr*cks lol. They also use penguins for sport and eat very little of them after they're done. I'll wait for further evidence but my money's still on the Orcas being the culprit for this one 🤷♀
Orcas go after the dorsal? That doesn't seem logical. They generally grab a pectoral when upside down and flip it end to end they are so frikken strong! At least that's what's been documented. They then hold it until the shark drowns then gobble up the liver. they don't appear to actually eat anything else just the liver.
yeah i wouldnt put any stock in information supplied by the same govt that used 9/11 to bomb themselves and blames afghan or sinks the Titanic but hey the Rothchilds got off right before right, or the govt that claims their president died to a magic bullet, or that sub that randomly went explodey
The temperature of the tracker was too high for it to have been consumed by an orca, and for it to of been wasted and dropped to the ocean floor
If you’re diving deeper it doesn’t get warmer. The only explanation is a belly of an animal. Orcas don’t dive that deep either. I will say this. We have no idea what’s on this planet. Everything hasn’t been explored and species they claim has been extinct is found live and well
bruh how could an orca eat a shark whole☠️
You have the bloop sounds backwards. The first sound you played was the original recording, the second one that sounded like nothing was the sped up one.
I will never enter your channel for taking this damn long
Spoiler alert. It was a 16 foot shark that had gigantictism and was cannibalistic
It's the common exscuse to cover up about the meg...could be babey megs..who really knows..
Sharks are cannibalistic...
Btw a 16’ white isn’t nearly as big as they get. They grow to 23’ very common
Yes, lots of examples of great whites over 16ft. All females given the chance will grow larger than 16ft.
16 ft is common, but 23 feet is the maximum size estimated. Since the largest shark ever measured was 21 ft, a 20 ft Great white is pretty rare guys.
But tbh i do beleive that if it git eaten by a
Shark, that thing would be at least 23 feet and may be even bigger.
Yeah back in 1970s there wasn't a lot of huge Great White because of no protection species but because of that, Great Whites have rebounded and they are surviving to greater age and 20ft. isn't that rare!
Yeah Deep Blue is supposedly the largest recorded and video recorded on several occasions now. Think she's just over 20 foot. But yeah a 15+ foot would definitely take down a 9 foot no problem.
how was the signal from the tag which was deep underwater able to be received if radio signals can't really travel underwater?
One thing I wonder about, why hasn't oceanographers created a mechanical fish with camera and lighting that can be remotely maneuvered to the deepest depths of the oceans?
The body temperature is one of the best clues. I would have liked Orcas as a hypothesis, but they are too warm. A very large great white was another possibility because unlike many fish the great white can run slightly warmer than its surroundings. But, not that warm.
Actually, the recorded temperature matches that of a white shark's stomach. They have an average stomach temp. of 26°C.
@@miniscool5613
So meaning a bigger Great White. Could have finished off Shark Alpha. Only one shark could fit that description. No other then the legendary Submarine. A larger Great White shark very intelligent one at that. Then again Submarine must be dead by now.
Orcas usually only eat the livers, they don't normally eat any other bits.
@@miniscool5613
😂❤😅
Going back to the question on whether squids eat sharks frequently or not, based on the fact that we only got either one or very few occurances of sharks alive from squid attacks, I can assume that there are 2 possibilities. 1. Squids rarely attack sharks, and if they did it would be for self defense, thats why we only find a few attacks. 2. Squids frequently eat sharks and they are so efficient at killing them that almost none make it out alive.
Id say 2 it would be pretty common i think squid would eat anything considering they fight sperm whales
Try to think how practical it would really be for a squid (even a really big one) to kill a shark, all they've got are tentacles and a beak. A squid could wrap a shark up with its tentacles but what good is that going to do? The shark weighs more, is significantly more powerful and can't be choked/restrained. The beak of squid/octopus are pretty strong but they're not exactly designed for doing lethal damage to a large shark, sharks are exceptionally hard to kill so unless that beak is big enough to bite a shark in half it's just not going to be practical for a quick kill.
@@DjDolHaus86 shark could rip tentacles off to
@@DjDolHaus86 No, squid/giant squid, are really vicious when they hunt. It's also not like a sword fight where it's a clash of tentacles and shark teeth; squid grab onto their prey with these barbed tentacles and drag them down to the depths, cutting and lashing them with tentacles and beak and killing anything that needs to breathe at the surface or that needs to move to breathe. I think you are overestimating the shark's defenses and underestimating how predatory and scary everything else in the ocean is. It's kinda like with how people think the karate masters will be able to beat these UFC guys, but the UFC guys are usually just way bigger and destroy them.
I think the problem would be squids big enough to eat sharks lives in a depth where great white and most sharks don't swim at. So I don't think squids would often hunt them
The formidable creature confronted Jaws, proving to be its equal in the battle of monsters.
LOL, the radio transmitter was eaten not the whole great white shark.
I’m curious why a giant cannibal shark is accepted as a solution when it is also cold-blooded and that exact criterion was used to eliminate several other of the theories
They couldnt figure out the answer & ran out of time for the project & had to post perhaps
Great Whites and similar members (Makos, Salmon Sharks, etc.) are actually WARM blooded. That's why the can be in colder water than some other shark species.
Alternatively, the tracker could have been bitten off by another shark during a feeding session and then Alpha was torn apart in a blood frenzy. That's not unheard of either.
Also, I have no doubt that certain 'archaic' creatures live in the depths of the ocean. Like the dude said, 80% of it remains unexplored. Humans are only apex on land, and are just another prey creature in the water.
Btw, _"blood frenzy"_ is *such* a disturbing descriptor, extremely chilling...🥶
If the shark is being digested by a stomach acid that might raise the temperature. It should not be that difficult to find out what kind of stomach acid other squids have and see if digesting shark meat would raise the temperature like that.
Orcas Got A Free Quick 9 Footer Lunch 😂
If there's a cannibalistic great white shark with gigantism swimming around in the oceans it's probably extremely rare and the only one of its kind, and other sharks probably wouldn't want to hang around near it.
Alpha was chased 2x by its killer on 2 different days. The young shark quickly dove deep as it's evasive behavior, but was at last caught in the depth on its second dive.
The killers internal temp was warmer than great whites, but too cold to be a mammal. In fact, the internal temp actually matches up to those of the leatherback sea turtle. But, as we all know, leatherbacks are jellyfish predators and not shark eaters, and even the largest of them would not dare tackling a 9 ft great white. The data showed that after being eaten, the killer stayed up near the surface for 8 days maintaining that temp until the tag was "excreted" from the killers digestive tract.
The 8-day digestive period further proves its not the handiwork of a large shark as sharks digest and excrete their waste in a matter of a couple of days. The 8 day period also matches up to those of the leatherback, therefore, this leads to what some think may be a giant undiscovered species of predatory turtle. I'm not sure if I remembered this correctly, there was a sighting decades ago by a fisherman of a gigantic shell-less looking sea turtle of roughly 38ft in length, and I believe that witness may have also took a photograph of the creatures head and a bit of the neck sticking out of the water...
I'd like to add that after the tracker was found, the team went out with a sonar equipped boat to look for the culprit in the vicinity and got sonar contact 60+ ft below the boat, an 35ft object swimming slowly.. so at 35ft. It definitely wasn't a great white shark. The size doesn't match, the internal body temp doesn't match.
interesting
First off the Temp of a great white shark is close enough to the tag shown , also white sharks are cold blooded so there body temp will change just based off how much they are moving and the surrounding water. They have data of a core white shark in about the same temp of water at around 80 degrees *F. On top of that since they are a fish there sizes can be far more different then just based off age and any data taken for getting a white shark core temp could be different based off size , where is the data that says that can not be a factor? Then trying to say that a great white only rakes 2 days to complete it's eating and waste cycle does not hold up since they have found a lot of different stuff in sharks stomachs that were in there longer then 2 days , The tracker was made out of materials that a shark stomach is not able to digest the same way they would of things of there normal diet. last the swimming around the same spot for 8 days does not mean anything since if a shark ate something that size it would not be looking for food the next day and was probably just hanging around to digest it's meal and as pointed out in this video or other data that the area is known to have white sharks and we also know that a shark will hang around the spot area for lengths of time.
all hat said your theory is not the craziest I have seen and over the years it has been pointed out while white sharks are apex predator's they have weaknesses that other sea life has figured out to exploit. Large shark for the most part do not mess with dolphins even though you would think they would be an easy meal but dolphins have learned to bash sharks in the gills . These are things that make your theory not impossible but I still think it was just a bigger shark and again the shark being called "big" at 9 feet is not true and a 16 feet white shark is big but they have proven to have come across white sharks that get over 20 feet and while I cannot say for sure it sounds much more likely then a deformed sized turtle that you forget needs to breath air and at most a leatherback is thought to be able to hold it's breathe in cold water for up to 7 hours but only with very vety little movement and it seems like it would be very hard for a turtle to drag a shark down to those depths and eat it without coming up for air within a short time frame.
@@tonysobon4669there is one thing wrong with your theory though sharks won't try and eat another shark unless it was small enough to not pose a threat sharks don't like to waste all their energy with hunting so if it thinks it's pray is too much of a fight and they might lose they won't even bother shark blood also contains a chemical that works like an alarm when exposed to water and it's been studied that the smell of sharks blood makes other sharks in the area scatter and run away so if it did eat the shark it wouldn't just sit around they don't like the smell of the blood with how sharks hunt and act around each other it's unlikely it was another shake that killed it unless it was literally doubled it's size
@@tonysobon4669this is not against your side or ops just something about sharks and orcas
one thing I found funny about this story is how like humans gave generational trauma to most animal species the same is true for orcas
They attack anything even mooses (except humans in the wild) with zero need to eat and kill for fun and is a proven fact that if an orca is near by a shark even great white will stear clear of the area for a while
So the part where it's a heavy shark and orca population is weird as both can be territorial to even their own species not related in orcas case so it's odd that many sharks stay in that area also with the squid at night as a threat it's really puzzling
The latest theories about Livyatan Melvillei going extinct actually have to do with their *prey* going extinct. They were thought to prey primarily on smaller warm-blooded whales, the precursors of our baleen whales. These in turn depended on widely scattered, abundant patches of krill in the warm waters they swam in, and right behind them were Megalodon and Livyatan Melvillei.
But when the waters turned cold, the krill these small whales depended on began to gather in much colder waters, and concentrate. Big whales - VERY big whales - had the insulation necessary to survive those cold waters, the giant mouths to take large batches of krill, and most importantly they could fast for a good part of the year - the small whales could not. So the little guys went extinct because they couldn't handle the changed patterns of their prey. What took their place, the ancestors of giants like Right Whales, Bowhead Whales, and Blue Whales, were far too big for even these mega-predators to eat. One slap of the flukes of a Blue Whale would be enough to fatally damage even a Megalodon or Livyatan. And so when the little whales went, so did Megalodon and Livyatan Melvillei, starved to extinction by the loss of their primary prey.
we watched this as part of our home schooling on friday and my six year old has asked to watch it every day since then. i am not exaggerating. (to be fair, it’s only sunday. but i know when my child is starting a trend…) anyway, your voice is incredibly soothing to listen to and i just want to express my appreciation for the fact that, if i’m going to have to listen to this video at LEAST daily (and possibly multiple times daily), at least it’s rather pleasant to listen to.
when i have it memorized, i’ll do a lip sync reaction video to it. 😜
just wanted to update. it’s tuesday. little one is still watching this every day. today we have watched it twice.
WE ARE STILL WATCHING THIS. WE ARE UP TO A MINIMUM OF TWICE A DAY. I KNOW THESE COMMENTS WON’T BE SEEN FOR 13 YEARS. I JUST WANT THOSE FUTURE VIEWERS TO KNOW I AM SURVIVING.
If only school was this interesting during the long boring, wasted years of my youth.
Perhaps the 'tracker' simply fell off the shark and many different array of species of a normal sized fish simply ate it.
Or the tracker fell off and the shark just swam away.
It was Julia the sea monster heard on March 1, 1999, I think it's because her sound seems like a monster to me xd
I thought it was a colossal squid, but the cannibal gigantism shark makes a lot of sense. As much as I'd like to hear that there's some new mystery unsolved concerning leviathans of lucid size, I think I'd sleep easier if nothing of the sort existed.
That said...
The ocean always has unsolved mysteries, right?
It didn't have gigantism. Great whites can reach 20 ft in length. 16 ft is average size for females, but they can get bigger without having gigantism. Deep Blue is 20 ft and still doesn't have gigantism.
Wow I had misconception for their size
Still though, if the smallest are 13 ft and the largest are 20 ft, it feels like the larger one would have to have an extra couple meters before being able to devour another and drag it down hundreds of meters through the ocean.
@@theashrebornagain Or it could just bite the chunk of flesh that had the tracker out.
I believe it was a squid, either giant or colossal. I’ve seen sharks with suction cup markings, matching with squid tentacles.
I’ve read people’s comments regarding ocean 🌊 mystery & many known & unknown ocean 🌊 beasts roaming in the deepest parts. 95% of our oceans unexplored, we only explored 5% still haven’t listed all names of ocean marines because of huge numbers of varieties. Now let’s talk about the unknown & unexplored part we never ventured in & what lies near the surface or in deepest part. As u know ? 71% of our planet 🌎 is blue which means it’s water & only 29% is land & within our land territory we have soo many monsters & mysteries too solve about but still much is unknown, over vast worlds territory. If aren’t familiar what’s lurking about in our remote lands but how is possible, for us to know what’s underneath our ocean 🌊 there’s demonic ocean beasts or prehistoric monstrous deadliest marines might be lurking 👀 in our oceans looking for their next supper. For example Pacific Ocean is the largest among all oceans on earth has area bigger than all lands of 7 continents, imagine what type of marine life or maybe paranormal monsters lurking in our oceans may caused instant kill of Alpha Shark
Thanks for using the Metric system too !
I think sharks are great but scary sea animals. Sharks seems so interesting to me. I like watching shark stuff .
Dive with them . They are SO SO very graceful. When relaxed, they are so graceful and peaceful. The "scary" factor is quickly forgotten in my experience.
Are you certain it wasn't Aquaman from Atlantis? He's known to have super human strength and can swim very fast in water.
Atlantis is no joke ,, I know where it was, and my best friend is an Atlantian.
Livyatan melvillei was discounted but maybe a male sperm whale which is described by Britannica, "Males attain a maximum length of about 24 metres (78.7 feet) and weigh up to 50 metric tons (55.1 tons)" could eat a 16' shark. Further in Brittanica, "Sperm whales are deep divers, commonly reaching a depth of about 350 metres (1,150 feet), and have been found tangled in cables more than 1,000 metres (3,280 feet) below the surface."
Add cameras to the tracker to future expeditions.
did you really try to ease me into the crazy with a dinosaur? xD
I think shark alpha may not be necessarily dead. There was a struggle between the shark and another shark or whale. The tag came off and most probably wound up in the mouth of a shark or whale that dives that deep. Sperm whale is 1 candidate. It could also stay without air for hours.
Wonderful narration with cute chuckles involved
Maybe it was what ever made 'the bloop' sound :o
Shark isn't only a cannibal but wants it well done
I like these kinds of videos
I honestly think an orca killed the shark, ripped out its liver as they do often. Great white liver is an orcas favourite meal. Then other sharks scavenged the remains, another great white ate the part that had the tag. They are warm blooded. That’s what happened folks no matter how much you want it to be a a Megladon. 😝 🦈
@@kieranhart5776 it couldn’t have been it was a different temperature remember
@@kieranhart5776 if u think about it an orca does not rip,tear or thrash it's pray it comes up and smashes the prays underside to paralize and eat it + orcas do not go that deep and usually do not sudenly veer away from there feeding places