This is one of my favorite episodes, whenever there is something unsolved that people say "I wonder why that happened?" I say "Because The Doctor failed to stop it.". LOL
Wonder what happened with Covid...I like to think the earth went through a horrible ordeal and Covid was the aftershock of whatever the Doctor did not quite manage to completely divert.
It’s a great day when my favorite reactors upload Doctor Who reactions to iconic episodes. All of the River episodes are awesome on rewatch because you know stuff. Rewatches are brilliant.
"When I first met the Doctor, he knew everything about me." It's amazing to see that line from the season opener play out in real time. It's also lovely to see the Doctor so protective of River throughout.
Jay - almost every reaction misses something that Mels says when she starts to regenerate - Last time, I was a toddler, in the middle of New York. Back in 6x02 at the end, you saw a little girl in the alley, regenerating. So somehow she regenerated into Mels and ended up growing up with Amy and Rory!
One thing I always wondered about rivers diary is, is it bigger on the inside ? I mean it’s quite small considering how many adventures she has and with it being shaped like a tardis does it have more pages on the inside than the outside 🤔
Well, considering it was a gift from the Doctor and Time Lords have perfected the "bigger on the inside" technology (such as the TARDIS and the Doctor's pockets)... I'd say it's highly likely.
@@leeci33 yeah I know that cause that is said in The wedding of River song still could be bigger on the inside, she only says her diary is almost full but we don't know how big the book is it could still be full and bigger on the inside at the same time cause she has a lot to write in her diary especially if you also heard the Diary of River Song Audio Books from Big Finish cause there are a lot of those and are really amazing cause River meets almost every Doctor in those even the classic ones worth a listen if you interested in River like I am
Doctor Who has "minisodes" - mini episodes between the official episodes. Most aren't pivotal to the plot of the show but there's a couple about River that _are_ crucial to River's story. They can be found on UA-cam (and on the DVD/bluray extras). I believe they're called Bad Night, Good Night, First Night, Last Night, Up All Night. Pls react to those
Well, I can agree... River Song is my favourite character in Doctor Who! (not counting the Doctor) I have loved every episode that she has been in! And the Doctor's and River's relationship is so interesting, comlicated but very lovely.
Considering your episode rate, even if you sped up to an episode a week youll likely be catching up to release as we go into the next doctor/just after they start in a few years time, which feels wild. But when you do catch up, I feel like you'll be the reactor with the most personal connection to the show
Please react to the night and the doctor minisodes. I agree too. River is is the best character in the Whoverse. Brilliant, beautiful, kickass. Everything I want to be lol 11 is 2nd best in the show. 📘💗
@@leeci33 I honestly have no idea and I stopped this video immediately. It could be that the episode was missing from where I was watching it from or my memory is damaged... I shall locate this episode and watch it! How exciting that there's a "new" episode to watch 🥰
What brought me to this channel? A hot looking guy named Jay. What kept me here? Same thing BUT also I'm in love with his bursting personality! Top tier reactions.
When I was 17, I used to think and hoped for my favorite trio, Amy, Rory, & Caleb to save *Anne Frank* and her family from Hitler's reign of terror! 😆😂 Note: "Caleb" is the name I gave Matt Smith's 11th doctor! 😁
@@leeci33 I'm glad you asked! 😊 Right here: 1st - Franklin 2nd - Robert 3rd - Harold 4th - Larry 5th - Aaron 6th - James 7th - Maurice 8th - Silas War - Abraham 9th - Jerome 10th/14th - Evan 12th - Gilbert 13th - Alyssa And for 15th, still thinking for a name for him.
I should sue the BBC, I wrote about a "Ship" constructed by tiny creatures so they could "EXPLORE" human-kind. MANY years before the episode of Dr. Who was even filmed!
There is a doctor who short where the matt smith doctor takes river to the singing towers before her mission to the library i wish to say more but as river says, Spoilers
The entire "The Doctor is dying" plot is incredibly boring, we know he's not dying that's a foregone conclusion, so there's zero tension. the only question is how he's going to weasel his way out of being dead.
For me this is when the season starts to weaken. It felt like everything after the mid season finale was rushed to me. This is one of the better of the episode for its humor but…
Hey Jay, been watching since nov 2023 and I've seen all your Doctor Who reactions. I love your reactions. But I'm so sorry to point it out but I feel that I must say that you've gotten more and more unhealthy looking. Normally I'd never dream of leaving such a comment, it's none of my business right, how dare I shame someone for their looks etc. but honestly I'm genuinely worried. Like I lie down at night and sometimes I wonder If your health degrades and I never said anything, I wouldn't be able to live with that, knowing I could've reached out and offered my support and encouragement, you know? I hope you find resources to get healthy and take better care of yourself soon. Please take care of yourself, buddy.
"You named your daughter...after your daughter".
This is one of my favorite episodes, whenever there is something unsolved that people say "I wonder why that happened?" I say "Because The Doctor failed to stop it.". LOL
LOVE IT 😆
Wonder what happened with Covid...I like to think the earth went through a horrible ordeal and Covid was the aftershock of whatever the Doctor did not quite manage to completely divert.
It’s a great day when my favorite reactors upload Doctor Who reactions to iconic episodes. All of the River episodes are awesome on rewatch because you know stuff. Rewatches are brilliant.
These were great episodes , but iconic episodes are relative. I think the iconic episodes are in the classic era. Those are what I grew up with.
@AmyWarriorPrincess I grew up with the original too but these are some iconic episodes! River has alot of banger episodes
"When I first met the Doctor, he knew everything about me." It's amazing to see that line from the season opener play out in real time. It's also lovely to see the Doctor so protective of River throughout.
In a previous episode, river said she was taught by the best to fly the tardis, and the doctor was busy that day. Busy dying😅
In all the years I’ve loved matts run I never caught that 😂
This run of episodes is a masterpiece of television writing
Jay - almost every reaction misses something that Mels says when she starts to regenerate - Last time, I was a toddler, in the middle of New York. Back in 6x02 at the end, you saw a little girl in the alley, regenerating. So somehow she regenerated into Mels and ended up growing up with Amy and Rory!
The Doctor and River have a lot of secrets that the rest of us aren't privy to, and I think it makes them so much more interesting as a couple.
saying "privy" is such an clever way to excuse a very bad written relationship that basically lacks everything that makes a a romance "Good!"
Great episode. I quote the Doctor's rules to myself when I need them. Particularly "time is not the boss of you" & "never run when you're scared."
One thing I always wondered about rivers diary is, is it bigger on the inside ? I mean it’s quite small considering how many adventures she has and with it being shaped like a tardis does it have more pages on the inside than the outside 🤔
Well, considering it was a gift from the Doctor and Time Lords have perfected the "bigger on the inside" technology (such as the TARDIS and the Doctor's pockets)... I'd say it's highly likely.
It's MUCH thicker by the "end" of her story, and a lot more tattered.
@@LeeKeels yeah but a dying tardis also lets the bigger to the outside maybe the book does as well
It’s has the exact right amount of pages to fit her story.
@@leeci33 yeah I know that cause that is said in The wedding of River song still could be bigger on the inside, she only says her diary is almost full but we don't know how big the book is it could still be full and bigger on the inside at the same time cause she has a lot to write in her diary especially if you also heard the Diary of River Song Audio Books from Big Finish cause there are a lot of those and are really amazing cause River meets almost every Doctor in those even the classic ones worth a listen if you interested in River like I am
7:09 “Let ourself in. Wanna kick you in your mustache” 😂😂😂
Doctor Who has "minisodes" - mini episodes between the official episodes. Most aren't pivotal to the plot of the show but there's a couple about River that _are_ crucial to River's story. They can be found on UA-cam (and on the DVD/bluray extras). I believe they're called Bad Night, Good Night, First Night, Last Night, Up All Night. Pls react to those
I’ll be reacting to them and uploading them all together before 6x09 reaction :)))
Fun fact when that girl in the first episode of the season regenerates river’s theme is playing.
Well, I can agree... River Song is my favourite character in Doctor Who! (not counting the Doctor) I have loved every episode that she has been in! And the Doctor's and River's relationship is so interesting, comlicated but very lovely.
River Song is my fav character too and I love this season and her story so much
I live river song and I truly think she's the best companion even though they don't have a traditional companion relationship
…and *that’s* why she doesn’t regenerate in the Library. Because she used them all on him.
Big reveal and Hitler's in a cupboard 😂
Considering your episode rate, even if you sped up to an episode a week youll likely be catching up to release as we go into the next doctor/just after they start in a few years time, which feels wild. But when you do catch up, I feel like you'll be the reactor with the most personal connection to the show
I just noticed a few episodes ago how much Jay looks like Rory.
The last centurion is in a league of his own but THANK YOU!!!! AHHHHH 😄💙
Please react to the night and the doctor minisodes. I agree too. River is is the best character in the Whoverse. Brilliant, beautiful, kickass. Everything I want to be lol 11 is 2nd best in the show. 📘💗
Yes the River minisodes are crucial to her story.
Will be reacting to them and posting them all before episode 9 reaction :))
I... I think I've never seen this episode before!? How is that possible?? I've rewatched the earlier series several times 😮
How is that possible! Start over from the eleventh hour right now!
@@leeci33 I honestly have no idea and I stopped this video immediately. It could be that the episode was missing from where I was watching it from or my memory is damaged... I shall locate this episode and watch it! How exciting that there's a "new" episode to watch 🥰
@@ym10up ya this is where the robot came from for the silence arc
What brought me to this channel? A hot looking guy named Jay. What kept me here? Same thing BUT also I'm in love with his bursting personality! Top tier reactions.
Happy to have you here 😁 thank you so much!!!
When I was 17, I used to think and hoped for my favorite trio, Amy, Rory, & Caleb to save *Anne Frank* and her family from Hitler's reign of terror! 😆😂
Note: "Caleb" is the name I gave Matt Smith's 11th doctor! 😁
Lol at Caleb! What names do you have for the others?
@@leeci33 I'm glad you asked! 😊 Right here:
1st - Franklin
2nd - Robert
3rd - Harold
4th - Larry
5th - Aaron
6th - James
7th - Maurice
8th - Silas
War - Abraham
9th - Jerome
10th/14th - Evan
12th - Gilbert
13th - Alyssa
And for 15th, still thinking for a name for him.
@@leeci33 Also, for the companion, Sarah Jane, I call her *SJ* for short! 😁
Love your reaction videos! Keep up the great reviews!!! ❤❤
i sometimes wish i could forget series so i could watch them again for the first time lol but just as fun seeing someone react who hasnt seen it
Thanks, Jay! ⏳ More greatness yet to come.
Thanks for watching!! Can’t wait for it all :))
@@JayPerView You're very welcome. 🌱 I hope I'm fortunate enough to see your reactions to key moments.
Thanks for a great review, one of my favourite episodes, I never tire of watching it.
People go to this episode thinking it's just a filler, but it sure ain't one!
I LOVE LOVE LOVE this episode 😍🇬🇧
Incredible episode AND reaction! 😊
Thank you 😁
I love watching your reactions, you're so expressive and gorgeous, and its awesome that you love the same dr who arcs as i do!
Thank you so much for the compliments!!! Glad you’re enjoying the reactions 😁
@@JayPerViewI'm thankful that you do them! I look forward to your vids every day! :)
I should sue the BBC, I wrote about a "Ship" constructed by tiny creatures so they could "EXPLORE" human-kind. MANY years before the episode of Dr. Who was even filmed!
Another one of my favorites!
There is a doctor who short where the matt smith doctor takes river to the singing towers before her mission to the library i wish to say more but as river says, Spoilers
i hope u realized until now amy is nebula from avengers and also the hot chick from jumanji? :)
YESSS!!! Karen Gillan is amazing 😁😁
yes she is, but david tennant era is still my favorite, and i`m up to date with doctor who!/torchwood/sarah jane adventures/class :)
Crazy
you did review forest of the dead
Fanfrickintastic ep
This why Moffat run was better than RTD
The entire "The Doctor is dying" plot is incredibly boring, we know he's not dying that's a foregone conclusion, so there's zero tension. the only question is how he's going to weasel his way out of being dead.
😂💖🙏👋🤣🍿🍫🥤🤞
For me this is when the season starts to weaken. It felt like everything after the mid season finale was rushed to me. This is one of the better of the episode for its humor but…
Then church on ruby road
Hey Jay, been watching since nov 2023 and I've seen all your Doctor Who reactions. I love your reactions. But I'm so sorry to point it out but I feel that I must say that you've gotten more and more unhealthy looking. Normally I'd never dream of leaving such a comment, it's none of my business right, how dare I shame someone for their looks etc. but honestly I'm genuinely worried. Like I lie down at night and sometimes I wonder If your health degrades and I never said anything, I wouldn't be able to live with that, knowing I could've reached out and offered my support and encouragement, you know? I hope you find resources to get healthy and take better care of yourself soon. Please take care of yourself, buddy.
AA I love this episode so much!!! It’s so nice to see someone new reacting to the first few seasons of doctor who.
🫶🫶