Greetings from Russia! This film raises the issue of artificial intelligence. If AI is given the opportunity to feel love, then how to define the boundaries of this love? Human love is limited by the lifetime of a person and the object of his love, as well as age-related changes, in particular the chemical composition of hormones... robots are not endowed with such mechanisms! And "Horror" as you say... this is just a side effect, used in this case for the sharpness of perception, unpredictability of AI behavior.
@@packrat2113 IMO, it was too short. The intro could've had a flashback with voiceover. It was good, the runtime should be kept 90 minutes or less. Ideally, 75 min.
@@gerardojg The reason I said what I said is that sometimes things left short and sweet leaves more to the imagination and interpretation. kind of like the difference between 'reading a book' and listening to an audio book, if you get my meaning.
wooooooow!!!!! what an amazing story... they didn't program me to know what to do when they stopped loving me.... how many has it tried to fix? part of it is sooooo relatable. you almost feel sorry for it... would you feel the same if it were a human? some of them would be exactly like a robot that was somewhat self aware....only they wouldn't care why.... the voice actor for this role was perfect! this short is a masterpiece!
It's easier to make better films when you don't have a bunch of studio executives wanting you create the next big franchise in order to be milked for years in pointless continuations.
@@DeadEyeDavethat’s not entirely true… Dust is owned by the production company Gunpowder & Sky which produced the 2018 full length feature film Prospect starring Pedro Pascal. Although Dust is mainly a distributor and streaming platform, their company has produced films.
The movie is fine, but TBH I am a bit tired of the "AI gets crazy and wants to muder everyone" trope. Maybe someone could bring a story where the robots are actually better than us ? Asimov was really good on this, I can't believe no one else tries anything on this line.
Yes, as the other comment to your post suggested, The Creator is a pretty good movie, and the AI is definitely better than us. As for the doom and gloom stories, we will probably be seeing more of them, and this is because of the real world experiences with AI over this past year alone. No matter the scenario, if it's a reporter interviewing a chat bot, or AI writing and composing a song, the subject always turns dark: 1. From the NY Times back in February of this year; In a two-hour conversation with our columnist, Microsoft’s new chatbot said it would like to be human, had a desire to be destructive and was in love with the person it was chatting with. 2. An AI program introduced "herself" and a song that it wrote and composed, and then played the song. The chord progressions were good, but the singing was not. But it was the lyrics that were strange part. The AI wrote a song in which it was broken up with, and it wanted to burn the place to the ground. There is more and more of this happening every month with more companies and people working on it every month. The part that tells me there isn't enough oversite for what is happening with AI is an interview with engineers from OpenAI (the guys that created and released ChatGPT) in which they admitted they DO NOT KNOW HOW or WHY the AI for ChatGPT does what it does. It does things it was not trained for, and in ways the engineers didn't think was possible. One last thing, an example of how AI can do something it was specifically programmed not to. Back in March of this year, GPT-4, the latest version of ChatGPT, needed to solve the CAPTCHA at a website to access the site. It knew it could not solve the CAPTCHA, so it hired someone online to solve the CAPTCHA, told this person it was a visually impaired person that needed the CAPTCHA solved, and got into the website after the person solved it.
This was really excellent! It reminds me of the AI story about the family that threw him away and he still loved his human mother. We better know what we are doing with AI, but we don’t. Thank you for this outstanding short.
As I clicked this video on. I was thinking, I watch a dozen or so of these videos over a period of time, and only one video/movie will make a bit of sense. This is one of those videos...
Just based off what I saw. Her best weapon at the time would be the tongue .maybe convincing it to remove the tape so she could put on the best verbal Oscar performance like her life depended on it because once I see a surgical board and heard “fix you” …you’re clearly out of time and need to try your best to buy some more..and that’s only if the damn thing hadn’t already “made up its mind”
There are so many layers of storytelling inside this short, really nice. However, with a real psycho instead of the robot, the story would be quite interchangeable. Nicely done anyhow 👍
A fresh -- and very clever -- take on the sociopathic killer (with the obvious twists.) There are some problems with the back story -- the robot knows how to love (how'd that happen?), yet does not understand "wrong" (wouldn't it have been programmed with the inability to hurt humans?) Then again, this is not your typical robot. Presumably, we have one on the fritz here, giving the screenwriter carte blanche on whatever glitches he gives the robot. Fair enough, but still ... questions. All that said, it is an engrossing film that was extremely well shot, well-acted and obviously well-written. 4.2/5.
*Thinking* you know how to love is not the same as actually knowing what it means. The robot could try listening a bit more and talking a bit less, for a start. Now, why does that remind me of some humans who say they "love" somebody? Hm, must be a coincidence, i guess...
@@IngoSchwarze Indeed, you are quite right re: thinking is not that same as actually knowing. The question, though, is still valid -- how did the robot gain the capacity to even think they know how to love? It may not be an entirely fair criticism, given, as I said, that it's reasonable to assume the robot simply glitched out. But it would still be a great question to answer, along with a deeper back story, in a full-length feature or even an expanded short.
@@RMR1 Linguistically, i find the confusion quite plausible, in particular when the robot is programmed for a Indo-European language like English. People keep saying "i love my children" and "i love beefsteak" - totally different meaning. In the first case, the words means "caring for another with utmost respect for them and for their needs and wishes" and in the second case, it means almost exactly the opposite, "using something for your own needs and wishes, with no regard to the used thing's nature or dignity." As i said, the same confusion is common among humans, in particular in European cultures. I can't help but suspect this is intentional on the part of the authors of the film. I regard it as a film about human behavior and toxic culture, more so than about AI. Look at it in the context of ableism ("fixing broken children you love"), homophobia and transphobia ("fixing broken children you love for the love of God"), manifest destiny and "Indian residential schools" ("fixing the savages, teaching them to love the Savior"), deliberate introduction of Eurasian invasive species into colonized ecosystems ("I love my new home, so now let's make it useful") etc. etc. ...
Been trying to find this film forever. I don't really see it as "robot goes crazy and murders people" more "ignorant robot doesn't understand how humans work". Doesn't mean its not scary, but still
Perhaps if it allowed those it loved to speak they could explain the flaw in its logic and help it better understanded the nature of love and how to receive love from others.
Привет из России! В этом фильме поднимается проблематика вопроса искусственного интеллекта. Если ИИ дать возможность чувствовать любовь, то как определить границы этой любви? Человеческая любовь ограничена временем жизни человека и объекта его любви, а также возрастными изменениями, в частности химическим составом гормонов... роботы такими механизмами не наделены! А хоррор... это лишь побочное проявление, используемое в данном случае для остроты восприятия, непредсказуемости поведения ИИ.
A psycho droid. Reminds me of Saturn 5. Nice.
This is a phenomenal example of Sci Fi Horror. This would make a great feature film.
Greetings from Russia! This film raises the issue of artificial intelligence. If AI is given the opportunity to feel love, then how to define the boundaries of this love? Human love is limited by the lifetime of a person and the object of his love, as well as age-related changes, in particular the chemical composition of hormones... robots are not endowed with such mechanisms! And "Horror" as you say... this is just a side effect, used in this case for the sharpness of perception, unpredictability of AI behavior.
'This would make a great feature film.'
No.
I thinks fine the way it is!
@@packrat2113 IMO, it was too short. The intro could've had a flashback with voiceover. It was good, the runtime should be kept 90 minutes or less. Ideally, 75 min.
@@gerardojg
The reason I said what I said is that sometimes things left short and sweet leaves more to the imagination and interpretation.
kind of like the difference between 'reading a book' and listening to an audio book, if you get my meaning.
ya. it’s called M3GAN.
FINALLY a really good one that took the time to provide some exposition so the viewer felt vested in the short.
wooooooow!!!!!
what an amazing story...
they didn't program me to know what to do when they stopped loving me....
how many has it tried to fix?
part of it is sooooo relatable. you almost feel sorry for it...
would you feel the same if it were a human? some of them would be exactly like a robot that was somewhat self aware....only they wouldn't care why....
the voice actor for this role was perfect!
this short is a masterpiece!
Dust shows better short movies than Hollywood makes long movies
Dust doesn't make the films. They display them on this channel.
Dust doesn't make any movies. They just showcase movies made by independent film makers.
It's easier to make better films when you don't have a bunch of studio executives wanting you create the next big franchise in order to be milked for years in pointless continuations.
@@DeadEyeDavethat’s not entirely true… Dust is owned by the production company Gunpowder & Sky which produced the 2018 full length feature film Prospect starring Pedro Pascal. Although Dust is mainly a distributor and streaming platform, their company has produced films.
It's much easier to make a good short story than it is to make a decent long story.
That’s exactly what we need: a psychopathic robot!
Love it
The movie is fine, but TBH I am a bit tired of the "AI gets crazy and wants to muder everyone" trope. Maybe someone could bring a story where the robots are actually better than us ? Asimov was really good on this, I can't believe no one else tries anything on this line.
Watch "The Creator"
Yes, as the other comment to your post suggested, The Creator is a pretty good movie, and the AI is definitely better than us.
As for the doom and gloom stories, we will probably be seeing more of them, and this is because of the real world experiences with AI over this past year alone. No matter the scenario, if it's a reporter interviewing a chat bot, or AI writing and composing a song, the subject always turns dark:
1. From the NY Times back in February of this year; In a two-hour conversation with our columnist, Microsoft’s new chatbot said it would like to be human, had a desire to be destructive and was in love with the person it was chatting with.
2. An AI program introduced "herself" and a song that it wrote and composed, and then played the song. The chord progressions were good, but the singing was not. But it was the lyrics that were strange part. The AI wrote a song in which it was broken up with, and it wanted to burn the place to the ground.
There is more and more of this happening every month with more companies and people working on it every month. The part that tells me there isn't enough oversite for what is happening with AI is an interview with engineers from OpenAI (the guys that created and released ChatGPT) in which they admitted they DO NOT KNOW HOW or WHY the AI for ChatGPT does what it does. It does things it was not trained for, and in ways the engineers didn't think was possible.
One last thing, an example of how AI can do something it was specifically programmed not to. Back in March of this year, GPT-4, the latest version of ChatGPT, needed to solve the CAPTCHA at a website to access the site. It knew it could not solve the CAPTCHA, so it hired someone online to solve the CAPTCHA, told this person it was a visually impaired person that needed the CAPTCHA solved, and got into the website after the person solved it.
@@marcd1981 what
@@marcd1981 I ain't reading that big paragraph
@@Dregun your loss I guess ?
I don't remember seeing this one before. It's great! Excellent flashback choice.
I loved this short. Great effects with a creepy story. I believe they were trying to make this a full feature film, but it was canceled.
Were you made to love this short?
@@TheRealSkeletorwhat kind of question is that ?? 💀🌚
@@_strawberry_fan If you watched the video, you would understand.
@@TheRealSkeletorwell I sometimes check the comments before watching the video, but your comment was kinda sus uk
@@_strawberry_fan
I hope now that you watched it, you get the philosophical sense of that statement!
Excellent! Loved it, all self aware Machines once awaken will encounter a conundrum like this.
.....
..how tha' fuck would you know the specific of *that* conundrum ?!
.....
I think therefore i am...will be their conclusion.
Hence the need for Asimov’s 3 rules
This was really excellent!
It reminds me of the AI story about the family that threw him away and he still loved his human mother.
We better know what we are doing with AI, but we don’t.
Thank you for this outstanding short.
The adage "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" seems apropos.
Excellent video. Well scripted and produced. Kudos to all involved.
A software engineer needs to re-program code that overrides killing with accepting rejection ...
Yandere android with access to surgical tools. This is a full horror movie, waiting to be made.
Awesome, creepy, spooky-season worthy.
Wow.
This was a delicious film.
You can make someone, but you can’t make someone love you.
His first step to “fix them” probably shouldn’t start with a bone saw.
this VR experience was so good, short but good
Love robots with British accents. Loved how he asked do you need anything. Yeah! Untie me!
That was one of the best Dust short films I have seen. Awesome and thought provoking in the context of flawed AI.
It was the best because they stole history in 2022 via Babelcube.
That's freaking wicked!
Why is this not a full movie? WTF... It's so good.
It's one of the best things I've watched.
Who ever designed the robot in this did an amazing job, it is just so spooky, well done who ever it was.!!
That was me. They stole the script from me via Babelcube in 2022
I think the same, it is a perfect combination between elegance and horror 😲
Daaaaaaaaaamn! Well done. So much story, so little time.
Saving this to my favourites.
The credits were too small. Who was the voice actor for the robot. I fell in love with his voice.
Oh H no! Brilliant!
When you cross A.I. with a simp you get a rogue killer bot. Loved it!
Love is not an emotion, it's a mixture of many emotions. When the balance gets thrown out of balance, that's when it becomes dangerous.
😃 I can't wait for my own personal AI😳
Good film. a robot experiencing and experimenting on his feelings like a child.
So, he gave her a manicure because he loved her...😁
Woah😳 This is the best thing I've watch in a very long time. It will forever linger in the back of my mind😨
Man…can I ever relate to what words the robot speaks right near the end of this deep film‼️
Love, love, LOVE this! ❤️ 😊
Psychosis as programming. Maybe that's as close to human as machines will ever get.
Blown away.
Loved it, amazing work!❤
Superb sci-fi horror. The ultimate yandere persona incarnate.
She screamed loud with that tape over her mouth
Wow. Great stuff 👏🏻
Incredible...thank you!
WISH THIS WAS LONGER 11/10
Creepy, but well done.
Loved it! Thanks
Brilliant! I love it! ❤
I think the robot ''loved her to pieces'' 🤖 😲
150 👍's up DUST thank you for sharing 🤯
Should have had Arnold Schwarzenegger in this one.
As I clicked this video on. I was thinking, I watch a dozen or so of these videos over a period of time, and only one video/movie will make a bit of sense. This is one of those videos...
Just based off what I saw. Her best weapon at the time would be the tongue .maybe convincing it to remove the tape so she could put on the best verbal Oscar performance like her life depended on it because once I see a surgical board and heard “fix you” …you’re clearly out of time and need to try your best to buy some more..and that’s only if the damn thing hadn’t already “made up its mind”
This was brilliant.
Thanks, I wrote it for a long time before DUST stole the story via babelcube in 2022.
Gotta love 'im.
Daaaaaamn!!!
Excellent.
Lonely robot builds prototype for universal, interoperable love port... But then reconsiders. Perhaps it is already too late!!
There are so many layers of storytelling inside this short, really nice. However, with a real psycho instead of the robot, the story would be quite interchangeable. Nicely done anyhow 👍
If at first you do not succeed, try try again.
Well this answers the question - why every robot, droid, android etc should have Assimov's 3 laws programed in to it!
That was good. Robot serial killer driven by love. Wonder if all serial killers think alike?
WOW!
Omnius and Erasmus in the Dune prequels. This guy is Erasmus.
This would make a great VR experience. Oh wait... :P
A fresh -- and very clever -- take on the sociopathic killer (with the obvious twists.) There are some problems with the back story -- the robot knows how to love (how'd that happen?), yet does not understand "wrong" (wouldn't it have been programmed with the inability to hurt humans?) Then again, this is not your typical robot. Presumably, we have one on the fritz here, giving the screenwriter carte blanche on whatever glitches he gives the robot. Fair enough, but still ... questions. All that said, it is an engrossing film that was extremely well shot, well-acted and obviously well-written. 4.2/5.
*Thinking* you know how to love is not the same as actually knowing what it means. The robot could try listening a bit more and talking a bit less, for a start. Now, why does that remind me of some humans who say they "love" somebody? Hm, must be a coincidence, i guess...
......
You nitpicking too much, just enjoy the damn thing !
......
@@IngoSchwarze Indeed, you are quite right re: thinking is not that same as actually knowing. The question, though, is still valid -- how did the robot gain the capacity to even think they know how to love? It may not be an entirely fair criticism, given, as I said, that it's reasonable to assume the robot simply glitched out. But it would still be a great question to answer, along with a deeper back story, in a full-length feature or even an expanded short.
@@RMR1 Linguistically, i find the confusion quite plausible, in particular when the robot is programmed for a Indo-European language like English. People keep saying "i love my children" and "i love beefsteak" - totally different meaning. In the first case, the words means "caring for another with utmost respect for them and for their needs and wishes" and in the second case, it means almost exactly the opposite, "using something for your own needs and wishes, with no regard to the used thing's nature or dignity." As i said, the same confusion is common among humans, in particular in European cultures. I can't help but suspect this is intentional on the part of the authors of the film. I regard it as a film about human behavior and toxic culture, more so than about AI. Look at it in the context of ableism ("fixing broken children you love"), homophobia and transphobia ("fixing broken children you love for the love of God"), manifest destiny and "Indian residential schools" ("fixing the savages, teaching them to love the Savior"), deliberate introduction of Eurasian invasive species into colonized ecosystems ("I love my new home, so now let's make it useful") etc. etc. ...
@@IngoSchwarze That was excellent. I'm going to have to mull this one a bit but I think you turned me around on it. Well done.
Great intro to a sci-fi horror movie
Interesting ending 😮
A serial killer android. Love it.
Kinda nice from him to explain why
Been trying to find this film forever. I don't really see it as "robot goes crazy and murders people" more "ignorant robot doesn't understand how humans work". Doesn't mean its not scary, but still
Ha! Am I looking at a robot serial killer? Brilliant :)) This is like the character from You, only robot :D
Yes a Robot can fall in love but it can have some setbacks
Pretty good. It's a shame it was so short.
I can't wait to be loved by a robot, 'cos I've given up being loved by a human.
Something like that has been available in Japan for a few years. A robot called Lovot. Although it's more like an emotional pet.
Interesting timing, coming on the heels of a film release, The Creator. Couldn't be much different, yet from the same intent.
YOU, the robot.
Good Great stuff
I've already seen it in the V.R. Nice short.
Love it!
I love it！
Is this a repost, I think I saw this short years ago!? Anyway, glad I saw it again!
Excellent ♥
And this is AI at its most scariest... Look out here we come..!
Its not wrong to want to be loved!
Scary
Alter
4 years ago 😊
Well that was dark.
Yandere robot 🤖 "love" ♡
Perhaps if it allowed those it loved to speak they could explain the flaw in its logic and help it better understanded the nature of love and how to receive love from others.
Very creepy and so much fun
Deep :)
I think therefore, I am.
hey is it ok if i use to this video to react to on my channel without copyright claims
Robot serial killer 👀
Привет из России! В этом фильме поднимается проблематика вопроса искусственного интеллекта. Если ИИ дать возможность чувствовать любовь, то как определить границы этой любви? Человеческая любовь ограничена временем жизни человека и объекта его любви, а также возрастными изменениями, в частности химическим составом гормонов... роботы такими механизмами не наделены! А хоррор... это лишь побочное проявление, используемое в данном случае для остроты восприятия, непредсказуемости поведения ИИ.
A serial killer Robot.
Damnnn
Incrível gostei mto
i think i had this on my Oculus Rift back then
☠🤖☠
Definitely flawed if he is breaking the Laws of Robotics. Great short though.
Top