The Clash: Should trans women participate in female sports?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @bettyswunghole3310
    @bettyswunghole3310 3 роки тому +951

    Women athletes: you know what you need to do. Boycott this woke nonsense and form your own leagues and teams. Vote with your feet. The *overwhelming* majority of public opinion is with you.

    • @bensomberg
      @bensomberg 3 роки тому +64

      Women do have their own teams. The problem is that they are being infiltrated by men.

    • @buildmotosykletist1987
      @buildmotosykletist1987 3 роки тому +30

      @Betty... : Womens sport has been taken over by the far left using the cover of "feminism". If anyone starts up an independent competition they will face administrative barricades from government. But I agree, if women want to remain competitive in sport then they must stand up and fight or pack their bags.

    • @daniellebcooper7160
      @daniellebcooper7160 3 роки тому +87

      I'd say 99% of the population would support them. People are getting fed up with WOKERS.

    • @birdman6813
      @birdman6813 3 роки тому +36

      Women athletes of the world! Pull your bloody socks up! These people are obviously saying you're not good Enough!

    • @roncollins9222
      @roncollins9222 3 роки тому +28

      Trans Athletes form your own teams and leagues.... But is there any money in it...? ? ?

  • @hope9935
    @hope9935 3 роки тому +656

    Please don’t call Kellie Jay intolerant. She holds the line not to be unkind but to be kind to all women and the following generations of girls (we are half the population). It is Peter who is intolerant of women having their rights. Unbelievable that women are now in this position.

    • @rossrainwater5619
      @rossrainwater5619 3 роки тому +25

      Eve Becher, Exactly ! This is all in the Agenda 21.. Thought long ago by the Tyrants then..Rockefeller and Rothschild. In their Agenda ,which thanks to Corrupt Governments And the likes of Peter Tatchell, It’s all to actually diminish Women, ..here in America we have So Called Men in high schools saying they’re Trans Women, Demanding To Enter young women’s Showers, Toilets, And Being allowed to do so... Peter is here along with all the other pushers of this very sinister agenda, to demoralize our young women... It’s pure Misogyny!.....and now we have last week of November 15 th, Pedophiles Demanding RESPECT, for their Sexual Feelings towards Children ! They want to be called PEOPLE who are Attracted to MINOR PEOPLE! This is Also in the Plan To destroy Western Culture, “ Corrupt the Children “. “ Vulgarize And Sexualize Children’s Clothing “. Etc..Time To Stand Up for our Women and Girls. The Beautiful Kellie Jay is Correct here. Many many of us will never refer to Caitlin Jennings as SHE, It’s Jennings , who was a Fine Athlete years ago, who decided to change his gender.. we could care less.. Enuf said. Basically I have a inkling this is a case of lots of wrinkles and Little Else. My best to all Humans both Male and Female. Thanks to the Creator it’s a Perfect Duo.

    • @daniellebcooper7160
      @daniellebcooper7160 3 роки тому +7

      Thats WOKE for you.

    • @MarciaMatthews
      @MarciaMatthews 3 роки тому +35

      It’s kindness to tell the truth.

    • @phamnuwen9442
      @phamnuwen9442 3 роки тому +37

      Recognizing reality, that a man is a man; that A is A, is not intolerance.

    • @wildcampingharry
      @wildcampingharry 3 роки тому +12

      Couldn’t agree more.

  • @techtipsuk
    @techtipsuk 3 роки тому +822

    Love Kelly Jay. Talks sense and is rather nice. Men competing in woman’s sport no matter what they’ve gone through is absolutely bollocks.

    • @ladylove3636
      @ladylove3636 3 роки тому +42

      Most of which they have mostly external but a few internal too. Womens sports need to be XX only which would solve that issue x

    • @Dancestar1981
      @Dancestar1981 3 роки тому +39

      I agree women’s sport for biological women only

    • @maggieashton2111
      @maggieashton2111 3 роки тому +7

      Absolutely no way. Maybe be a swan in the ballet Swan Lake instead. !

    • @richardlloyd2589
      @richardlloyd2589 3 роки тому +25

      @@ladylove3636
      Have said same. Male=xy, female=xx. Simple DNA test, job done.

    • @ladylove3636
      @ladylove3636 3 роки тому +11

      @@richardlloyd2589 there are a miniscule amount of those with slight variation, but science knows also if they are a variation of XX or XY. A simple test would get those with Y and internal testes, doping, out of women's sports x

  • @johnpemberton655
    @johnpemberton655 3 роки тому +126

    “There is a category trans-women can compete in, it’s called the mens category” 😂😂😂😂 **BOOOM**

    • @leonharrison800
      @leonharrison800 Рік тому

      We can choose athletes on muscles,size and weight. Problem solved.

    • @susanhopemason
      @susanhopemason 10 місяців тому +3

      ​@@leonharrison800And lung capacity, bone density, wing span, center of gravity, and every other way in which men and women are built differently and have different physical capabilities due to those physical differences.

    • @leonharrison800
      @leonharrison800 10 місяців тому

      @susanhopemason
      There are Transgender women who compete according to weight and height with women and who are beaten by women!!! Not all unequal! And there are sports where winning is not all that matters!!!!
      Transgender women are not all "cuckoo women " out to destroy womens sport or be predatory!!!

  • @raia9
    @raia9 3 роки тому +124

    "Tatchell says "I'm a human rights activist" - what these people fail to realize is women as 51% of the human race also have or should have human rights ie a level playing field for sport. Go Kellie-jay we love you.

    • @lollypton4572
      @lollypton4572 2 роки тому

      Tatchell is a pedophile apologist. He should be eliminated from all public debate.

    • @andyhalstead3949
      @andyhalstead3949 Рік тому +7

      Tatchell also stated that not all sex with children is abusive. He's a very dangerous individual. I've been saying this for years, and yet nobody has argued about it .

    • @spectre8788
      @spectre8788 Рік тому +4

      Tatchell doesn’t care about women - has no use for women

  • @eveeve9758
    @eveeve9758 3 роки тому +661

    Kellie-Jay is brilliant. Thank you for speaking the truth and standing for women

    • @Bob-ts2tu
      @Bob-ts2tu 3 роки тому +31

      standing up for all of us with a sense of fairness and common sense

    • @stanettiels7367
      @stanettiels7367 3 роки тому

      She’s a rabid feminist. Her ideology is at the root of the problems. Identity politics and intersectionality, something she’s played up to for years, is now going against her and affecting her, and only now it’s a problem. Although I absolutely agree with her on this issue her ideology is cancerous. Her and her ilk were the genesis of this nonsense.

    • @eveeve9758
      @eveeve9758 3 роки тому +3

      @@stanettiels7367 ideology? That women don’t have penises? 😆

    • @stanettiels7367
      @stanettiels7367 3 роки тому +1

      @@eveeve9758
      It’s not just about that. She’s a radical feminist.

    • @jackpringle2771
      @jackpringle2771 3 роки тому +9

      I love Kellie-Jay! She’s gorgeous and speaks the truth

  • @oldmantwitch5557
    @oldmantwitch5557 3 роки тому +281

    Why is it, almost always men, telling women, what is good for their sport, and making the rules?

    • @ladylove3636
      @ladylove3636 3 роки тому +14

      Patriarchy mate x

    • @pommiebears
      @pommiebears 3 роки тому +18

      Exactly. I wouldn’t call myself a feminist at all….. but this is just a bloody cheek. lol.

    • @hooligan9794
      @hooligan9794 3 роки тому +1

      Where exactly do you get that from. Do you even know the gender composition of the Olympic committee?
      It's also about men and women's sport. It's more relevant to women for obvious reasons....
      Oh wait sorry, you were engaging in pathetic virtue signalling.
      Well done Mark, you're one of the good ones!

    • @birdman6813
      @birdman6813 3 роки тому +2

      It's not men telling women. It's women telling women. Just ask them!!

    • @oldmantwitch5557
      @oldmantwitch5557 3 роки тому +6

      @@hooligan9794 The members of the IOC.
      PRESIDENT:
      Thomas BACH (M).
      VICE-PRESIDENTS: Zaiqing YU (M) Ser Miang NG (M) John COATES (M) AC Nicole HOEVERTSZ (F).
      Members: Robin E. MITCHELL (M) Denis OSWALD (M) Nenad LALOVIC (M) Ivo FERRIANI (M) Prince Feisal AL HUSSEIN (M) Nawal El MOUTAWAKEL (F) Mikaela COJUANGCO JAWORSKI (F) Gerardo WERTHEIN (M) Kristin KLOSTER AASEN (F) Emma TERHO (F).
      Director in charge : Christophe DE KEPPER (M).
      Top 16 positions. 11 men, 5 women.
      Mostly men.

  • @draculaslapdog3133
    @draculaslapdog3133 3 роки тому +320

    Is this guy for real? Men have an advantage over women, something we have known since the birth of humanity.

    • @richardfox6595
      @richardfox6595 3 роки тому +20

      No he's always been a lunatic but on rare occasions he's accidentally been right. Not this time.

    • @alexsdb9712
      @alexsdb9712 3 роки тому +17

      Exactly. And there are heavily built women, but it's different than a heavily built male version. Also, the muscle fibres are different, and the skeletal system is totally different.

    • @HelloKittykat21
      @HelloKittykat21 3 роки тому +5

      @@richardfox6595 Not right either when he's advocating for adults to be able to have sex with children because it does not harm them. He's a monster and he wants to try telling all the children that were abused in care homes or by church members or the girls in the grooming scandals that they haven't really suffered any harm!

    • @mfoltz3720
      @mfoltz3720 3 роки тому +2

      @@HelloKittykat21 that’s shocking he said that. Was it in a publication he contributed to you or is there a video clip of this? 😱

    • @HelloKittykat21
      @HelloKittykat21 3 роки тому +5

      @@mfoltz3720 He campaigns for lowering the age of consent, There is something not right with him.

  • @colinweir5807
    @colinweir5807 3 роки тому +51

    All the woman athletes want is a level playing field. Keep woman's sport for woman.

  • @herbertlongfellow7702
    @herbertlongfellow7702 2 роки тому +48

    Kellie-Jay is so great at debating. She's calm, too the point, makes all her points without butting in or talking over anyone. She is fantastic.

    • @WatchDMP
      @WatchDMP 2 роки тому +3

      This topic should should be the easiest to debate as she does .. Sadly it is not..smh

    • @Quest4Horror
      @Quest4Horror Рік тому +1

      This shouldn’t have to be debated in the first place.

  • @ConesuelaLadyTailor
    @ConesuelaLadyTailor 3 роки тому +376

    It is interesting how men like Tatchell believe they have the authority to tell women they must accept his (a male) definition of what a woman is and women must not challenge it. If they do dare to challenge his definition they will be labelled as someone who is full of hate.
    It is blatant misogyny.

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +37

      He should identify as a bellend

    • @sidnotvicious8442
      @sidnotvicious8442 3 роки тому +24

      On the Left a gay person is considered more important than a straight one, and as he normally only deals with people sympathetic to the Left he normally only gets agreement to his bigotry. As a result he believes his anti-women views are more important than honesty and common sense. The fact he knows a very puny man who fits into a minor Ladies' football team, he thinks all Trans people should be considered in the same way. Even man-shaped 6' 6" men.

    • @deeceecorfield8103
      @deeceecorfield8103 3 роки тому +6

      @@sumthingwickedly Ha ha ha!!! Absolutely spot on Shona!!!!

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +2

      @@deeceecorfield8103 i can't sing but I'm betting you'd like to hear me 😂😂😂

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +4

      @@deeceecorfield8103 furthermore he should identify as a spunktrumpet and f*** off

  • @1986kerrichinchilla
    @1986kerrichinchilla 3 роки тому +241

    Tatchell is neither trans or a woman yet he thinks he has a right to discuss and choose for women what they can and cannot have to themselves

    • @pommiebears
      @pommiebears 3 роки тому +53

      Right? Isn’t it wonderful to be told what is best for women, by a man wanting biological men to play women’s sports?

    • @1986kerrichinchilla
      @1986kerrichinchilla 3 роки тому +25

      @Anika Well your iddy biddy friend is still male, their bones are denser, their muscles strong, their body is built different and women dont exist to validate your iddy biddy friend. Find a male football team to play with with other iddy biddy males

    • @dawnhauton7543
      @dawnhauton7543 3 роки тому +21

      I am sick and tired of men telling me , a woman, what to de ... I thought people had died for the rights of women to self determine .....

    • @hbalint88
      @hbalint88 3 роки тому

      @@1986kerrichinchilla but they validate if they dont know that she is trans anyway

    • @michaelmcgee335
      @michaelmcgee335 4 місяці тому

      He’s a half-wit.

  • @patriciathewisher2315
    @patriciathewisher2315 3 роки тому +553

    As Tatchell.has written about his belief that children 'having sex' with adults is harmless, then it's hardly surprising he's all on for men beating the crap out of women in women's sports and causing women serious harm, etc. No idea why anyone wants to hear the dangerous nonsense he spouts. Kellie Jay is wonderful and it's ludicrous to suggest that if she won't lie to validate blokes that somehow that problem is hers.

    • @roncollins9222
      @roncollins9222 3 роки тому +24

      And nobody mentioned Women's boxing...!

    • @alexandradugan2301
      @alexandradugan2301 3 роки тому +62

      He is disgusting. Im shocked any news sources even platform him.

    • @MarI-Posa
      @MarI-Posa 3 роки тому +21

      @@alexandradugan2301 No one should be non platformed. Much better that we hear Mr Tatchell views.

    • @johnxforce4
      @johnxforce4 3 роки тому +28

      It’s funny how only in sports trans women but rarely trans men you get to see… why is that.. is it because women know that they are at an disadvantage in most sports against men and that men that identify as women then participate in women’s events are sh*t in the male division..

    • @thomasneedham1224
      @thomasneedham1224 3 роки тому +27

      Say what now? I knew there was something wrong with this guy. I hate predators this.

  • @The_Burning_Sensation
    @The_Burning_Sensation 2 роки тому +30

    Unbelievable. The jury isn't "out" on the advantages of testosterone. That just flies in the face of reality.

  • @beat1riz
    @beat1riz 3 роки тому +12

    Short answer: no.
    Long answer: Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

  • @elleygray02776
    @elleygray02776 3 роки тому +193

    A Male has aprox' 20% more muscle mass than a Woman.
    Which equates to a 20 metre head start when racing against a woman in a 100 metres sprint.
    I'm kinda old fashioned ..
    But I call that CHEATING ...

    • @Double_Vision
      @Double_Vision 3 роки тому +10

      It's 2021, Newspeak dictates that we call that "Tolerance".

    • @Dancestar1981
      @Dancestar1981 3 роки тому +12

      It is cheating

    • @phoebewashington2709
      @phoebewashington2709 3 роки тому +3

      Remember when the East German female athletes were disqualified because of their testosterone levels?

    • @tallthinkev
      @tallthinkev 3 роки тому +2

      @@phoebewashington2709 And their willy's!

    • @schnabel5347
      @schnabel5347 3 роки тому +1

      @@phoebewashington2709 Yes, and the swim team too. They found a way to cheat taking testosterone without getting caught. This transgender nonsense finds a way to legalize it.

  • @jazztheglass9996
    @jazztheglass9996 3 роки тому +144

    If Tatchel told me water was wet I would get a second opinion

  • @phoebewashington2709
    @phoebewashington2709 3 роки тому +90

    Tatchell: "we have to be very very careful before we exclude people" - as he argues for women to be excluded from their own spaces and sports.

  • @montanacreed5826
    @montanacreed5826 2 роки тому +4

    Since when has participation in sport been a right?

  • @dougieroberts7045
    @dougieroberts7045 3 роки тому +21

    Kelly is 100% correct. Nice to hear somebody talking sense in a world that is slowly going mad.
    Kelly isnt being intolerant, she is being honest, why on earth is honesty frowned upon just to please a man who thinks hes a woman.

  • @markbev7032
    @markbev7032 3 роки тому +236

    Why should a mediocre man take the place of a women on a women's team?

    • @loubieloujones5698
      @loubieloujones5698 3 роки тому +12

      Precisely. It's totally misogynistic

    • @pankakesnotstellar
      @pankakesnotstellar 3 роки тому +21

      @Bree Dayzed aka men.

    • @pankakesnotstellar
      @pankakesnotstellar 3 роки тому +13

      @Bree Dayzed there's only one way you're a woman, by lying. No reputable medical organisation in the world parrots twaw...I've a very simple logic test for you: if you're a woman, what is the trans for?

    • @lizrogers4819
      @lizrogers4819 3 роки тому +9

      @Bree Dayzed no all that's needed is a solid foundation in COMMON SENSE.

    • @angela3900
      @angela3900 3 роки тому +13

      @Bree Dayzed How can you be a 'woman' when you were born and raised a male? A woman is an adult female human being. As a biological woman, I find it insulting for the word woman to be subjective when being a woman is based on science not feelings.

  • @WillCamx
    @WillCamx 3 роки тому +235

    Your question should be "Should men be allowed to compete in women's sport" because that's what they are.

    • @Moira_Gloucestershire
      @Moira_Gloucestershire 3 роки тому +1

      Trans women are women

    • @jasperhorace7147
      @jasperhorace7147 3 роки тому +35

      @@Moira_Gloucestershire No they are not. They only think they are!

    • @willtheclimatealarmistsall7728
      @willtheclimatealarmistsall7728 3 роки тому +31

      @@Moira_Gloucestershire
      If you dig up the skeleton of a trans woman in few years, it'll undesputably be a man's skeleton.
      People can't magically become something just by thinking they're that thing.

    • @phoebewashington2709
      @phoebewashington2709 3 роки тому +16

      @@Moira_Gloucestershire women are women. men are men.

    • @stevenesbitt3528
      @stevenesbitt3528 3 роки тому +2

      By what standard?

  • @R_Pennington
    @R_Pennington 3 роки тому +372

    "I want this conversation to END, not to continue." Gosh, that was refreshing to hear. And as always: Kellie-Jay... NEVER... loses.

    • @maly2ts408
      @maly2ts408 Рік тому

      If trans people want to take part in sport let them have there own games

  • @habichiblah7534
    @habichiblah7534 Рік тому +2

    Go Kelly. I'm a man, and this sidelining of women over the last few years has sickened me. So glad someones standing up for real WOMEN. That Tatchell think is floundering like the rest of them. No sense to talk - none at all.

  • @richardkuehn7015
    @richardkuehn7015 2 роки тому +4

    Thatchell is being so disingenuous as everybody knows there are massive differences between male and female physiology.

  • @BlytheInBlack
    @BlytheInBlack 3 роки тому +176

    The IOC is despicable for this. Women should not have to compete against men. We will not put up with this.

    • @stuartwright8421
      @stuartwright8421 3 роки тому +5

      Er! Have you never heard of "feminism". Women competing against men is "THE" central tenet of feminism. In certain cases even with an unfair advantage e.g. quotas or women only shortlists. So now we have a culture full of women doing a fine impression of 2nd rate men! And surprise, surprise; feminism has not created happier women!

    • @ameliam7898
      @ameliam7898 3 роки тому +6

      @@stuartwright8421 3rd & 4th wave feminism lost the plot for sure

    • @ohwellwhateverr
      @ohwellwhateverr 3 роки тому +4

      @@stuartwright8421 There are many different kinds of feminism. The Suffragettes (considered by many to be the first feminists) campaigned for single-sex spaces (previously there were only shared bathrooms and harassment was rife to the point that women refused to use them). Now, though, we have a whole subset of women who consider themselves feminists and trans allies who are actually trying to demolish single-sex spaces. While other feminist groups, lesbians and normal sensible people are defending the necessity of sex-based segregation. Feminism is too varied to summarise as one thing.

    • @MaidenOfMusic
      @MaidenOfMusic 3 роки тому +5

      @@stuartwright8421 I don't think most feminists would argue that women should be competing against men in sports, where men have a distinct biological advantage. Feminism (at least the kind that I resonate with and understand), aims to achieve equality of opportunity in areas such as the workforce, where women are equally capable as men. You say feminism hasn't created happier women...I'd be interested to hear how you came to such a confident conclusion. If it weren't for women's rights, I wouldn't be allowed to vote, get a job, or own property. In fact, I would be considered property.

    • @stuartwright8421
      @stuartwright8421 3 роки тому +1

      @@MaidenOfMusic Sociologists & psychologists, with nothing better to do, ascertained, through study, that the West's most unhappy person is:-"Female" age 42 with a successful, lucrative career. Unmarried & childless.Feminism was "never" about equality. It was always about power, privilege & entitlement. Tell me the last time you saw quotas & short lists for women to operate high cranes on building sites in winter?! If it's admitted that men have a distinct physical (& I would argue intellectual) advantage then the whole ridiculous concept of equality is a fallacy. Born from delusion or mendacity. Given maximum freedom of opportunity men & women make very different choices. Men & women were meant to cooperate not compete with each other.

  • @lizenglish6130
    @lizenglish6130 3 роки тому +195

    Kellie-Jay Keen is brilliant. She talks absolute sense and won’t be bullied.

    • @divasbraidz
      @divasbraidz 2 роки тому +2

      It's easy to be brilliant even genius when your opponent is as delusional as they are.

    • @kinglear5952
      @kinglear5952 2 роки тому

      What was she doing with all her brilliance before she started on this subject?

  • @jessam4875
    @jessam4875 3 роки тому +172

    I’m absolutely aghast that this is the time I’m living in. I can’t believe I’m watching women’s rights be abolished right in front of my eyes.

    • @joelanderson5285
      @joelanderson5285 3 роки тому

      And they are using the same tactics to do it that feminist themselves used to plow over those of us who opposed the excesses of feminism. What comes around goes around eh.

    • @tahu1349
      @tahu1349 3 роки тому

      Most honorable men agree that only women born as women should be allowed to compete in biologically born women sports. But sadly third wave feminism silenced those honorable men. So they can't or won't speak up..... But wasn't there an argument that there is no difference between men and women (from an ideological viewpoint) - by feminists ?......... Remember 25,000 men, women and children die of starvation everyday in the world........Just to put this issue into perspective........

    • @realyzze
      @realyzze 3 роки тому +2

      @@joelanderson5285 no

    • @realyzze
      @realyzze 3 роки тому +9

      @@tahu1349 no feminist ever denied that there is difference in biology of males and females. they talked about personalities, they argued that women are also human and not a sexist stereotype

    • @joelanderson5285
      @joelanderson5285 3 роки тому +1

      @@realyzze Sorry Re but I was there. Hell, feminists at one point claimed that all the physical differences in size and strength between men and women were due to socialization. They planted car bombs ( fake ones but still) on the cars of neuroscientists and even wrote science denialist books like "delusions of gender".

  • @maxtroy
    @maxtroy 3 роки тому +23

    I’m a man on testosterone replacement therapy due to a head injury I had that massively lowered my natural level. Throughout I was training in the gym to lift the heaviest weights I could. Within 3 months of starting therapy my lifting in the gym DOUBLED. I went from exhausted all the time / inability to recover quickly to having what seems like boundless energy and recovery just isn’t an issue now.
    Testosterone is literally nature’s anabolic steroid.

    • @billj4525
      @billj4525 Рік тому

      You doubled your strength though? Wow your levels must have been really low if you got that much stronger. I know most of the people I knew said they gained a few pounds on their lifts when going on TRT, but doubled strength is insane. Glad you had such good results in the gym and elsewhere in you life.

  • @sfg5620
    @sfg5620 3 роки тому +13

    Kellie Jay speaks for women's rights in such an articulate way!

  • @BigBenn2014
    @BigBenn2014 3 роки тому +182

    Perhaps if male tennis players self identified as women and entered the women’s tennis at Wimbledon, we’ll finally see this nonsense for what it is, as the women get pushed out of their own competition.

    • @barleyafloat
      @barleyafloat 3 роки тому +4

      That would be funny. Beat the bourgeoisie at their own game. I like it

    • @andipandi5641
      @andipandi5641 3 роки тому +6

      only if they can do the highly erotic groans..

    • @barleyafloat
      @barleyafloat 3 роки тому

      @@andipandi5641 🤢🤢🤢

    • @Svoorhout85
      @Svoorhout85 3 роки тому +2

      South Park had a great scene about that.
      ua-cam.com/video/URz-RYEOaig/v-deo.html

    • @dickenscider7328
      @dickenscider7328 3 роки тому +8

      Even that manly Serina Williams has said she would be annihilated by any pro man tennis player.

  • @bettyswunghole3310
    @bettyswunghole3310 3 роки тому +260

    Even if we overlook the initial fallacy (namely: there exists such a thing as "trans women". There doesn't.), the answer to the question "Should 'trans women' compete in female sports?" is obviously "No. What a ridiculous suggestion.".

    • @asmrplushpaws
      @asmrplushpaws 3 роки тому +2

      Sports shouldn't be gendered.

    • @jeanwyldbore4985
      @jeanwyldbore4985 3 роки тому +18

      @@asmrplushpaws It isn't. It is sexed.

    • @annscott3114
      @annscott3114 3 роки тому +6

      @@asmrplushpaws Why is that then? What is the REASONING behind your statement? I'm guessing you wont reply because I've seen other comments you've made on other issues and they are all about sentiment and no substance... typical virtue signaler.

    • @stonehengeconstructioncc1705
      @stonehengeconstructioncc1705 Рік тому +1

      Why is Peter not advocating for transgender men to compete against biological men in sports? Obviously, it is because there isn't an advantage there. And why is Peter only advocating for the participation of transgender women in women sports? Why is he not advocating for other privileges that biological women enjoy, such as being afforded the opportunity to get womb transplants for the purpose of being able to give birth naturally? There is a lot to being a woman that transgender women can fight for other than infringing on the rights of biological women,🙄

  • @user-tc7lb6rr4r
    @user-tc7lb6rr4r 3 роки тому +143

    Utterly insane ruling…this has nothing to do with transphobia, it’s just common sense, no one is upset over trans men competing against men..so there you have it, it’s purely trying to protect women in their spaces!

    • @markbev7032
      @markbev7032 3 роки тому +30

      Its pure hatred of women

    • @andrewcharley1893
      @andrewcharley1893 3 роки тому +6

      There is no room in today's world for common sense. Thinking it can now get you jailed.

  • @rosaob5842
    @rosaob5842 3 роки тому +14

    Peter Tatchell normally speaks with wisdom and compassion. But on this subject he is so wrong! The jury is not out on testosterone levels, nor is out on ribcage, lungs and heart size nor muscle percentage nor hip angulation. Wake up Peter you're being used and women are suffering!

  • @RIANAVENTER
    @RIANAVENTER 2 роки тому +2

    No trans persons in women's sport. Women should boycott any event where the field is not level.

  • @barleyafloat
    @barleyafloat 3 роки тому +81

    No. They are MEN

  • @petewhitehouse5835
    @petewhitehouse5835 3 роки тому +93

    Tatchell is an embarrassment to people called Peter

    • @davidloughlin2238
      @davidloughlin2238 3 роки тому +4

      I would go further and say he is an embarrassment to those even not called Peter😀. He talks such absolute rubbish.

    • @catrionamacfarlane4949
      @catrionamacfarlane4949 3 роки тому +3

      He obviously likes the sound of his own voice.

    • @whdunstew2169
      @whdunstew2169 8 місяців тому

      Lol

  • @windingvines1
    @windingvines1 3 роки тому +77

    Refusing to participate in someone's sexual fantasy now called intolerant ffs.

  • @fenwelder2474
    @fenwelder2474 3 роки тому +2

    How on earth did we get to this point.

  • @xz3024
    @xz3024 3 роки тому +4

    Peter, you are not a human rights defender. If you were, you wouldn't applaud measures that discriminate half the population.

  • @LS-hq1qe
    @LS-hq1qe 3 роки тому +98

    That bloke is as confused as those that he defends

    • @CA-ee1et
      @CA-ee1et 3 роки тому +8

      He sees the 'trans rights' fight today as if it was the gay rights battle of the 80s, where he was assaulted and people exercised their moral disgust at him. However there is a massive world of difference. For a start gay men who said they were gay were telling the truth; men who claim they are really women are lying. And for another thing the trans lobby has woke big business, the civil service and God knows who on its side, the gay rights crowd never had any of that.

  • @birdman6813
    @birdman6813 3 роки тому +78

    "The jury is still out on whether high testosterone is an advantage". What a load of bollocks!

    • @sianais
      @sianais 3 роки тому +4

      They should legalize doping then. They are the flat earthers of gender. "Show me the science, or more research" means "I won't accept anything not twisted to prove me right" to them. God help us.

    • @ynotnilknarf39
      @ynotnilknarf39 3 роки тому

      @@sianais Maybe you should look at some actual science regards 'flat earth', read beyond what you're being sold before comparing it to the tripe spouted by this nut job (As in I agree with the fact testosterone increaes performance as do other factors in those born males).
      I've a science background and I'm intrigued by what's been discussed People are indoctrinated from out the womb by 'our world is a sphere' and so much more, maybe just maybe you're not understanding the arguments and are easily led by those whom are pushed as being respectable/leaders in their field? You only need look at the last 20+ months to see how leaders in their field are liars, cowards, lack integrity, ignore the science truth and attempt to pillory/discredit it with their own 'science', they've an agenda being fed by the true global powers to supress freedoms and control the human race whilst living in absolute luxury

    • @raia9
      @raia9 3 роки тому +4

      We used to call it a lie.

  • @s13hgp
    @s13hgp 3 роки тому +150

    No, certainly not. There should be a catergory for cross-dressing men to compete in.

    • @patriciathewisher2315
      @patriciathewisher2315 3 роки тому +33

      I agree but the poor dears don’t want their own category nor their own spaces cos they seem to think it’s somehow their human right to be in all women’s spaces and places. As the vast majority are AGP, part of his whole fetish is to gain validation as ‘women’. I’m sick to death of the way people try to pretend that evident physical differences between males and females magically disappear as soon as some deluded bloke wants validation. It all reveals how little actual women are valued and respected in this world and if this continues unabated there will be no such thing as women’s sport before very long.

    • @1986kerrichinchilla
      @1986kerrichinchilla 3 роки тому +23

      @@patriciathewisher2315 They see women as props to validate their feelings, what women want or need doesnt matter.

    • @Moira_Gloucestershire
      @Moira_Gloucestershire 3 роки тому +2

      No certainty not. Cross dressers compete with women.

    • @areviewer8514
      @areviewer8514 3 роки тому +4

      & Butch Lesbians trying to be Men

    • @sidnotvicious8442
      @sidnotvicious8442 3 роки тому +7

      @@patriciathewisher2315 I agree with you. But where on Earth are the feminists? Here they've got real unfairness to women, and on an increasing scale, but mostly remain silent while looking for minor issues to go ballistic about.

  • @lizib3378
    @lizib3378 3 роки тому +11

    Bravo to your bravery for speaking your truth
    I'm with you Kelly Jay

  • @trevorluft6032
    @trevorluft6032 2 роки тому +2

    That would be fraud a man “appearing”as a woman competing in woman’s sports

  • @Musical_Man_Guitar
    @Musical_Man_Guitar 3 роки тому +76

    It is not intolerant to not tell a lie. It is intolerant to expect someone else to tell a lie because YOU want them to!

  • @MoominJude
    @MoominJude 3 роки тому +77

    I would be horrified if a big hairy man was in my toilet or changing room and they shouldn’t be allowed to participate in ladies sport. They can be who they want to be, but not in women’s supposedly safe spaces or sport.

    • @jax9349
      @jax9349 3 роки тому +3

      I don't suppose the men would be overly impressed if I went and pissed in their urinals!

  • @angelaharvey2034
    @angelaharvey2034 3 роки тому +163

    Discriminating against adult human females appears to be very acceptable in 2021. I am quite appalled. Whether it is the elimination of female language (women called bleeders, cervix havers, or as Peter Tatchell said in a previous interview, describing Kelly-Jay and women as "non trans woman"!). It is very apparent that the reason why there was separate sport for women and men was that women were at a physiological disadvantage when compared to men. A mediocre man can beat an elite woman in sport.

    • @accountformelyknownasarsen3072
      @accountformelyknownasarsen3072 3 роки тому +22

      Totally agree Angela. For years it was straight white men who were under constant attack and whilst its still open season on them, the lunatic brigade have turned their attention to adult human females as well. They are actively trying to take away your identity. Its utterly disgraceful and its incredibly dangerous. Not only will they end up destroying the hopes and dreams of talented young sportswomen but they`ll end up bloody getting someone killed in the process. Utter madness.

    • @j.harrison6744
      @j.harrison6744 3 роки тому +27

      As a straight bloke l know i'm telling women what to do, but, feminists need to abandon the Left. From Islam to the Trans issue, the Left too easily throw women under the bus.

    • @loubieloujones5698
      @loubieloujones5698 3 роки тому +11

      I'm incensed. Incandescent. Tatchell's arguments are weak & frankly infantile.

  • @pdanciger
    @pdanciger 2 роки тому +3

    Why don't we ever get trans men competing with men that is the question..

  • @supermansbigsister3012
    @supermansbigsister3012 2 роки тому +8

    God bless Kellie-Jay Keen.. The world needs more women like her..

  • @SayMyNameSeries
    @SayMyNameSeries 3 роки тому +46

    Peter T is not even making any sense. It's beyond ridiculous. He's definitely not speaking for all gay people. I've actually met him a few times and he's a shit stirrer at times. I want to shake Kellie Jay's hand. Thank her for staying rooted in reality.

  • @sumthingwickedly
    @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +131

    Peter is a professional protester about any old shite that's popular

    • @charlytaylor1748
      @charlytaylor1748 3 роки тому +7

      I admire the guy. He's put himself on the line many times. Unfortunately he's about 90% wrong these days.

    • @jeantaylor9908
      @jeantaylor9908 3 роки тому +14

      Shonda McDonald, maybe but I think as he is a gay man his misogyny runs deep. So his support of trans is another way to express his misogyny!!!

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +4

      @@jeantaylor9908 tbf stonewall ran out of traction gay marriage done pretty much gays done so need a new agenda and it's not clever weirdo crap we can't get on board with. He's not a trans so not his fight he's a professional protester and his argument is keep arguing although I'm talking shit so i get airtime

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +2

      @@charlytaylor1748 He's a professional protester what he done years ago was effective now it's bs and he's spinning on the coat tails of hyperbole instead of saying my jobs done basically a prock

    • @loungejay8555
      @loungejay8555 3 роки тому +4

      But it's not "popular" though, that's the thing; most people think that this is all madness.

  • @peterweaver1248
    @peterweaver1248 3 роки тому +84

    I applaud Kellie-Jay for sticking to her beliefs in the face of woke speech.

  • @barriewilliams4526
    @barriewilliams4526 2 роки тому +3

    At the age of 85, I preferred it when there were men, women, boys, girls & when gay meant being happy🙃

  • @1964paulsmith
    @1964paulsmith Рік тому +2

    He is supposedly a human rights campaigner, but doesn't seem to care about the rights of biological women.

  • @jillturner8680
    @jillturner8680 3 роки тому +57

    Every time a man participates in women's sport, a woman loses out. An aspiring young female athlete will wonder what's the points.

    • @MrMadmanUSA
      @MrMadmanUSA 3 роки тому +3

      Imagine working your whole life to be the top woman's athlete and then you go to the Olympics and get beat by a trans person. Just pathetic

  • @David8n
    @David8n 3 роки тому +33

    The transphobic argument is nonsense. Not letting adults in children's sport wouldn't make you adultist. Not letting heavyweight boxers in the flyweight class wouldn't make you sizeist. Not letting able bodied in the Paralympics wouldn't make you ablist. Not letting cars in motorcycle racing doesn't make you carist. I could do this for hours.
    Transphobia argument is totally special pleading.

  • @pommiebears
    @pommiebears 3 роки тому +62

    I don’t actually like a man telling me that, he wants biological men, to compete in women’s sports. Exactly who is he to tell women who we should have to compete with? It’s beyond rude.

    • @joelanderson5285
      @joelanderson5285 3 роки тому +4

      I keep seeing comments like this. It isn't men or some sort of avatar of a gender doing anything. This is coming from the far left, he is just their speaker.

    • @reneep.1978
      @reneep.1978 Рік тому

      @@joelanderson5285 You keep seeing comments like these because it is leftist men who are running the narrative on trans-women's rights and notice also that none of them say anything about trans-men's rights on these same issues; do you ever wonder why that is? Could it be that it will contradict their assertions about trans-women?
      Now, here's some questions for you:
      - how would you feel about a trans man telling you what it is to be a man?
      - how would you feel if a trans man insisted that they be allowed to come into your male only spaces?
      - how would you feel if something you had worked really hard for was taken away from you by a trans-man just because they are trans?
      - how would you feel about them telling you that you have no say on these issues? that you just had to accept it and say nothing?
      - how would you feel if your future success was threatened if you spoke out against them?
      These things are happening to women right now and if you take the time to think long and hard about these questions and answer them honestly to yourself maybe, then you will understand why you keep seeing comments like Pommie Bears; instead of being dismissive of these concerns and just palming it off as just the leftists speaking and thereby not important.

    • @joelanderson5285
      @joelanderson5285 Рік тому

      @@reneep.1978 Your describing the white male experiance :).

  • @gillianstapleton8566
    @gillianstapleton8566 2 роки тому +3

    It’s called cheating…

  • @Rayblondie
    @Rayblondie Рік тому +2

    Obviously NO. They are obviously not real women and have a man's strength that makes it unfair.

  • @debjane7
    @debjane7 3 роки тому +68

    This is the end of women’s sport.

    • @OrwellsHousecat
      @OrwellsHousecat 3 роки тому +2

      No big loss. Nice whilst it lasted eh

    • @debjane7
      @debjane7 3 роки тому +10

      @@OrwellsHousecat I smell misogynistic Incel.

    • @joannehunter8475
      @joannehunter8475 3 роки тому +2

      @@OrwellsHousecat Don’t like women do you? Bless!

    • @OrwellsHousecat
      @OrwellsHousecat 3 роки тому

      @@joannehunter8475 I love wmn.
      I'm not impressed by wmns sports.
      Why are conflating the two?

  • @karllambert9827
    @karllambert9827 3 роки тому +59

    Truth and honesty needs to be told and the respect for all the hard work these women put in to compete against each other, and to have a man come in saying he or she is now a woman and must be allowed to compete is just wrong wrong wrong no truth no honesty and no respect.

  • @jont39
    @jont39 3 роки тому +52

    Kelly Jay you diamond one of the amazing WOMEN that are not afraid of saying what powerful MALE politicians are too scared to do.

  • @dman5ful
    @dman5ful 3 роки тому +8

    Thank you for speaking up for women Kelly Jay ❤️❤️

  • @tomlindsay5619
    @tomlindsay5619 Рік тому +1

    Kellie-Jay is a very smart lady. She would normally have a back-and-forth discussion. For this one, she just sat back and let Peter make an absolute fool of himself.

  • @alexo2675
    @alexo2675 3 роки тому +50

    The gay activist is talking about all the average losers in sports. Everyone else is talking about the winners. There can only be one winner and she must win it fairly.

  • @oldsongsnew8797
    @oldsongsnew8797 3 роки тому +68

    She's right.

  • @bensomberg
    @bensomberg 3 роки тому +23

    I wish the moderator would have shut up and let Kellie Jay speak. Peter was a very poor spokesman for the trans point of view. Of course men shouldn’t participate in women’s sports and what the IOC has done is cowardly. I will not watch the Olympics if this ruling is not changed.

  • @jenleigh342
    @jenleigh342 2 роки тому +2

    I'm DISGUSTED that this is even a QUESTION. A human born as a MAN should compete with MEN. PERIOD. Men are BIOLOGICALLY STRONGER THAN WOMEN, therefore it is RIDICULOUS for a TRANS WOMEN, ( Who is not a real WOMEN ) to compete with BIOLOGICALLY BORN FEMALES. I can't BELIEVE that we are discussing this.....Kelly has my FULL SUPPORT. I am SICK OF HEARING about TRANS RIGHTS..🙄🤮🤢🙄🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮🤮

  • @liszaf3976
    @liszaf3976 3 роки тому +1

    All women competitors should refuse to compete, period!!!!!

  • @lezbefriends4837
    @lezbefriends4837 3 роки тому +38

    The host calling Kelly intolerant for not using she for Caitlyn Jenner is just B's, the whole reason that we're in this trouble in the first place is because of the polite lie we've been doing, if people want to politely lie for their friends that's their business but it isn't intolerant to speak the truth.

    • @divasbraidz
      @divasbraidz 2 роки тому +1

      He apologized so fast when he said he himself just shows how pitiful he is

  • @our-days-are-short8254
    @our-days-are-short8254 3 роки тому +35

    NO NO NO NO NEVER!

  • @pumpkinpumpkin1947
    @pumpkinpumpkin1947 3 роки тому +71

    I really do despair about how little the sporting bodies care about keeping womens sports fair and safe for female athletes. It must be so dispiriting to be a female athlete at the moment. No-one male should ever be allowed to compete against female athletes in women's sports. Completely unfair to the female athletes this will destroy women's sport if allowed to continue.

    • @Gingerblaze
      @Gingerblaze Рік тому

      That seems to be the plan

    • @billj4525
      @billj4525 Рік тому

      Absolutely, it completely makes a mockery out of women's sports.

  • @Jay-iu5bi
    @Jay-iu5bi 3 роки тому +3

    Yet again we have a man telling women how they should think and feel, and that they should just shut about it.

  • @Cdr_Mansfield_Cumming
    @Cdr_Mansfield_Cumming 2 роки тому +1

    Why is it Tatchell ignores the cases of a man who was nowhere in cycling, put on make up, called himself a woman and smashed the women cycling championship. Then the case of the college swimmer who got as far as the college lewugecin the USA. He entered the women's event claiming to be a woman and broke the US national record. He finished ahead of the 2nd place swimmer in the World Swimming Championship trials a clear 10 seconds ahead. On the podium, you had two little women and a 6ft 2in man wearing a woman's swimsuit.

  • @paulhealey6129
    @paulhealey6129 3 роки тому +65

    Kelly jay is a real women with a real cervix !!

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +3

      Bigot transphobe 🤯🤯🤣🤣

    • @ricochet2977
      @ricochet2977 3 роки тому +8

      And Peter lost his balls a long time ago.

    • @paulhealey6129
      @paulhealey6129 3 роки тому +2

      @Anika yes you are so right with that analogy 👍

  • @sueedwards9334
    @sueedwards9334 3 роки тому +19

    Why does GB news give this sick man any air time at all? How can anyone think it is ok for any man to just say he’s a woman and then compete with women??

  • @zanderboy27
    @zanderboy27 3 роки тому +56

    Pater Tatchell just broke my f*cking brain.

    • @ConesuelaLadyTailor
      @ConesuelaLadyTailor 3 роки тому +17

      Your brain is fine. It is Tatchell's brain that is broken.

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +4

      Could be worse he could have broke your back 🤣🤣🤣

    • @lexiwilson9501
      @lexiwilson9501 3 роки тому +1

      @@sumthingwickedly OMG . . . ha ha

    • @sumthingwickedly
      @sumthingwickedly 3 роки тому +2

      @@lexiwilson9501 sorry couldn't resist I'm obviously a phobe 🤣

    • @birdman6813
      @birdman6813 3 роки тому +1

      @@sumthingwickedly Yep, saw the movie...Heath Ledger on the rise...

  • @madhavi108
    @madhavi108 2 роки тому +1

    This shouldn’t even be debatable. Of course boys and men should not participate in WOMEN’s sports. No debate.

  • @bertybertface1914
    @bertybertface1914 2 роки тому +1

    People will watch the female competions if they don't do something to block Trans athletes. It's not about feelings. It's about what fair.

  • @mygranmathinksimcool
    @mygranmathinksimcool 3 роки тому +88

    I love watching Kellie Jay's face when she listens to people talk shite 😂

    • @janethuxley4220
      @janethuxley4220 3 роки тому +6

      So do I, I LOVE her. 😊

    • @janettomlinson389
      @janettomlinson389 2 роки тому +1

      Me too I just watch her face and marvel at her masterclass. I love her too!

    • @joefoley1480
      @joefoley1480 2 роки тому

      Shay Woulahan thank you

  • @orsonkart4794
    @orsonkart4794 3 роки тому +34

    The Olympics have become pointless for many !

    • @MrMadmanUSA
      @MrMadmanUSA 3 роки тому

      More so now. It is now just a joke.

    • @MysticDragonForce
      @MysticDragonForce 3 роки тому

      New Zealand's sportswoman of the year... was a man...

  • @pizzaboy3946
    @pizzaboy3946 3 роки тому +41

    No. There, that's saved 25 minutes.

  • @liszaf3976
    @liszaf3976 3 роки тому +3

    Absolutely not, never, they are men biologically so will have an advantage of strength, what about women's rights!!!!

  • @madeyoulook6392
    @madeyoulook6392 3 роки тому +2

    I'm a fat bloke and I feel discriminated against because I haven't put in the life long training, sacrificed the diet I want to eat as opposed to the diet top athletes must adhere to, given up on a social life to dedicate to my chosen sport and continually get discriminated against by losing to those who have 🤷 fat, lazy blokes feelings matter too, stop the genocide !!!
    Tatchell must have got a brain injury that time Mugabe's security guards rag dolled him.
    Why is this argument solely directed at woman's sport? Why are we not seeing these issues in men's sport? Does that not speak volumes?

  • @missmercurys
    @missmercurys 3 роки тому +45

    We do not allow kids to compete against adults, able bodies to compete against disabled or heavy weight against light weight. Men and women are different. This whole conversation is ridiculous and sexist. Good on Kellie Jay.

  • @andrewwillgoss8604
    @andrewwillgoss8604 3 роки тому +25

    Well said Kellie
    Tatchell is a monster.

  • @phil122333
    @phil122333 3 роки тому +60

    is he high. men have a massive advantage. People live in cookoo land

    • @hardworker645
      @hardworker645 3 роки тому

      👍👍

    • @evolassunglasses4673
      @evolassunglasses4673 3 роки тому +5

      It will destroy women's sport.

    • @Dan_Therapist
      @Dan_Therapist 3 роки тому

      transwomen are women..

    • @Dan_Therapist
      @Dan_Therapist 3 роки тому

      @MrCheebz i know, I'm a libertarian. It doesn't cost me anything to refer to someone by their preferred pronoun. Live and let live. They don't impede on my freedoms and i sure as hell dont.
      So if they say they are women, fine by me. We can stay out of each other's way and still live in a society. No animus

  • @philipmulville8218
    @philipmulville8218 2 роки тому +3

    The IOC is a disgrace.

  • @raggycat6821
    @raggycat6821 2 роки тому +3

    Bodies win sporting competitions, not identities. Allowing men to compete with women is clearly wrong and I'm fed up of all the gas-lighting going on around this issue.

  • @flagstafup5857
    @flagstafup5857 3 роки тому +19

    Chromosomes must differentiate male and female sports in future. XX XY

  • @shirleyottewell220
    @shirleyottewell220 3 роки тому +33

    Well said Kelly. It's great to hear someone speak the truth fearlessly.

  • @lexiwilson9501
    @lexiwilson9501 3 роки тому +29

    Kelly-Jay crushing it as usual, even the mighty Peter Tatchell was left floundering like a washed-up fish. He's become increasingly redundant since gays have become more accepted in wider society.

    • @sgm_13
      @sgm_13 2 роки тому +2

      That explains why he roots for TRAs who define same s.x attraction as g.nital f.etishism that should be unlearned. He wants to be relevant again.

    • @lexiwilson9501
      @lexiwilson9501 2 роки тому +1

      @@sgm_13 He should go abroad to the Middle-East and defend womens' and gays' rights there where he's most needed.

    • @u-kneeque
      @u-kneeque 2 роки тому

      @@lexiwilson9501
      No thanks. Keep him. You reap what you sow. We love having normal families.

    • @lexiwilson9501
      @lexiwilson9501 2 роки тому

      @@u-kneeque Me too, but not where you are.

  • @forfar4fife5
    @forfar4fife5 3 роки тому +2

    Kellie-Jay is far to intelligent to debate with that ignoramus

  • @PenzancePete
    @PenzancePete 3 роки тому +2

    No.
    Next question please.

  • @karllambert9827
    @karllambert9827 3 роки тому +29

    What we are finding is that many people in powerful jobs have them jobs with no rights to be there and need ousting from said job ASAP

  • @masontiptoe
    @masontiptoe 3 роки тому +23

    Why is it always the weak men wanting to compete in women’s sports and not the other way round?

  • @markbev7032
    @markbev7032 3 роки тому +24

    Tatchell, your pants are on fire 🔥

  • @mrsnobby4999
    @mrsnobby4999 2 роки тому +1

    The Rio olympics 800m womens race, the gold,silver and bronze places in the final, were all men identifying as women!

  • @eindhovendegekste168
    @eindhovendegekste168 2 роки тому +1

    Sports are segregated by sex, not gender.
    That old tool is not making any sense.