Persona 4 vs 4 Golden Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 78

  • @heppuplays9125
    @heppuplays9125 3 роки тому +228

    I like how the original actually had that late 90s to early 2000s Tv effect thing( i can't remember what its callled and i'm too lazy to look it up)

    • @designRpt
      @designRpt  3 роки тому +80

      static?

    • @heppuplays9125
      @heppuplays9125 3 роки тому +80

      @@designRpt yeah that it was like 3am when I wrote that I'm not usually that dumb

    • @ocsjc13
      @ocsjc13 2 роки тому +2

      @@designRpt lol🤣

    • @bluballs3329
      @bluballs3329 2 роки тому +26

      Well they technically both have it, it just looks nicer in P4, since it has the scan lines and the coloring around the screen. In P4G it only has the scan lines and they are harder to see.

  • @yannispirou101
    @yannispirou101 3 роки тому +123

    I haven't played the vanilla version, but... Holy shit, the visual improvement is significant...

    • @daisukegori2112
      @daisukegori2112 Рік тому +9

      Gold removed the vocals of the main character and some cutscenes.

    • @TonyAlexander-on4sy
      @TonyAlexander-on4sy Рік тому +1

      @@daisukegori2112 like what

    • @SycoticForeverNeverAF
      @SycoticForeverNeverAF Рік тому +9

      @@daisukegori2112No it didnt lmao

    • @YouGottaShootEmInTheHead
      @YouGottaShootEmInTheHead 9 місяців тому

      @@TonyAlexander-on4sy You can literally see the timing of the Persona 4 dialogue bubbles and the game transitions....

    • @AntonioGrady-qt7zn
      @AntonioGrady-qt7zn 9 місяців тому

      ​@@YouGottaShootEmInTheHeadyeah and golden is longer which does not indicate cut cutscenes

  • @ellagage1256
    @ellagage1256 4 роки тому +198

    The extra fog really sets a darker mood in the PS2 version

    • @UOHCUNY
      @UOHCUNY 10 місяців тому +3

      Typical Persona fan lmaoooo

    • @Dopamiin3
      @Dopamiin3 8 місяців тому +8

      @@UOHCUNYbait

  • @74Vidgamer
    @74Vidgamer 3 роки тому +172

    I actually prefer the moodier look of the PS2 original.

    • @JayAreAitch
      @JayAreAitch 2 роки тому +67

      More fog, and a more sickly yellow palette. P4 was never as sunshine-and-rainbows as post-Golden marketing would have you believe.

    • @orenz.272
      @orenz.272 2 роки тому +5

      @@JayAreAitch Very True

  • @TheAleatoryFramesz
    @TheAleatoryFramesz 3 роки тому +38

    I love the fog and yellow atmosphere on ps2

  • @ゴンタ-u7i
    @ゴンタ-u7i 2 роки тому +37

    It's looks less foggy but the game is "about fog" I prefer the ps2 graphics

  • @GudangInternet
    @GudangInternet 2 роки тому +16

    The tv display when fighting is better

  • @naylisyazwina6836
    @naylisyazwina6836 3 роки тому +21

    2:58 Ah the mc's voice in Persona 3 or just Sasuke's and Ben 10's voice actor. I love him. Also love teen Gwen and Terra's voice actor

    • @nonphantom
      @nonphantom Рік тому +1

      also spider man lol

    • @saidbrizzo2187
      @saidbrizzo2187 28 днів тому

      If you think about it when he does junpei Victory pose while wearing the Gekko High Uniform its technically MC doing an impression of his friend lol

  • @WednesdayMan
    @WednesdayMan 4 роки тому +69

    Persona 4 PS2 graphically looks better in terms of 3d elements, and this is made clearer with emulation.
    however Persona 4 Golden on PC has the better 2d Assets but they look like redrawn assets, the clearest giveaway of this is the quality of them, and even the textures were altered between the 2, Persona 4 Golden for some reason altered the atmosphere created by the PS2 original, yes everything seen in the PC version is basically what you'll get from the Vita version graphically (except for resolution which is 476p)

    • @designRpt
      @designRpt  4 роки тому +21

      i do get what u mean, you can also see that elements on the ps2 backgrounds were "alive" and some went static or completely missing in Golden but i also like the removal of the yellow or blue tints, making everything clear both in exploration and battles, but they did keep the static effects even if sort of reduced and did improve lots of assets, background elements and textures in a good way

    • @WednesdayMan
      @WednesdayMan 4 роки тому +17

      @@designRpt well I prefer the original PS2 look, that's the look they went for, and considering the foggy nature of the TV world the PS2 version properly captures this, the reasons for toning the effects down was most likely screen size, since at the Time the screens of 23 inches and up to 52 inches were expected for use on the game (Yes 52 Inch TVs were a thing in 2008) and the Vita (original model) was equipped with a 5 inch OLED display, there are definitely changes that show they were avoiding burn in, such as with the first dungeon, where the fog was white in the PS2 version, but changed to black in Golden.
      so yes Golden Did many alterations out of Necessity for the Vita, however these changes are completely pointless for the PC and PSTV/PS-Vita TV and were kept as a result of ATLUS not wanting to once again re-work Persona 4 in order to undo the graphical alterations they did to make it better for the Vita's screen as well as adjusting the new Golden exclusive areas to match the PS2 graphical style, (probably just the new golden exclusive dungeon, considering Okina city actually has a map in the PS2 version).
      so yeah the only reasons for a lot of the graphical alterations was just to accommodate for the Vita's screen and hardware

    • @designRpt
      @designRpt  4 роки тому +4

      @@WednesdayMan i still think for PC, give the more powerful platform its being launched on, it should have gotten an option for using both the fullscreen effects of the Original or the more clean look of the Golden version

    • @krazyk5993
      @krazyk5993 4 роки тому +2

      No. Just no. I'm sorry I know you must have a lot of love for the oh version but both the psvita and pc versions are factually better looking.

    • @WednesdayMan
      @WednesdayMan 4 роки тому +8

      @@krazyk5993 no it's not factually better.
      that's a very subjective opinion.

  • @impachoblue1301
    @impachoblue1301 3 роки тому +47

    Honestly, the look and feel of the original is better to me. I also just nit pick a lot, and I hate the changes to lots of little things. From battle party portraits being outside the "tv area" on screen, battle portraits changed, additional orange color added to a lot of stuff, shuffle time got a massive overhaul and is nowhere near the same or as challenging. The game feels easier on very hard than it did hard for ps2.
    Elemental icons adjusted to have that square around them, dia/ media sound differences, and I can keep goin all day.
    I hate when so much stuff that didnt even need to be touched, was touched.

    • @designRpt
      @designRpt  3 роки тому +5

      very good point! looking at it in that prespective i must agree :S damn

    • @insertnamehere658
      @insertnamehere658 2 роки тому +7

      Shuffle time is much more fun in golden though. Yes, golden is easier, but is much more fun, which is, at the end of the day, what we play games for. Agree with the feel though. Golden looks too saturated, even when you tone it down in the settings, and and I don't like the removal of fog.

    • @mizzix
      @mizzix 2 роки тому +3

      @@insertnamehere658 some people may have more fun if it's more challenging though. Im not one of those people, but op might be and it's important to remember that

    • @dannkettle4106
      @dannkettle4106 Рік тому +5

      Yeah it's also frustrating when you love the original P4 version but all everyone talks about now is Golden.

    • @supernightslash
      @supernightslash Рік тому +1

      No to mention: the font for HP/SP counter numbers in battle have been changed and they look so tacky and rushed...

  • @masterofthetech7618
    @masterofthetech7618 2 роки тому +15

    how did atlus make the anime cutscenes worse in the golden version

  • @MyGawd-
    @MyGawd- Рік тому +14

    I'm 2 years late to this but people preferring the original over Golden is *insane* to me, I think they're both fine, but Golden just looks so much better lmao

    • @manimanistatue
      @manimanistatue 11 місяців тому

      but Golden is missing visual effects and has lower quality assets from being a Vita port..

    • @jackson3475
      @jackson3475 6 місяців тому +3

      Well yeah, but it's a game about fog and a TV world, not about high quality image and the handheld dimmension.
      People probably like vanilla P4 better because of immersion.

    • @badutturu1144
      @badutturu1144 16 днів тому +1

      A year late but its actually not insane you know? They just have better taste than you, its nothing complicated at all.

    • @randomisaac5959
      @randomisaac5959 11 днів тому +1

      ​@@badutturu1144 5 Days late, no one has better taste than the other. People just prefer different things. It's ok if you disagree. Don't mean you have better taste or vice versa.

  • @Z7SMAD
    @Z7SMAD 3 роки тому +15

    I finish the original one in ps3

    • @Z7SMAD
      @Z7SMAD 3 роки тому +1

      @Mark Gaming have fun I heard golden is pretty good

    • @naylisyazwina6836
      @naylisyazwina6836 3 роки тому +3

      I'm planning to play right after I'm done with the last chapter of Uncharted 2 today on my PS3

    • @naylisyazwina6836
      @naylisyazwina6836 3 роки тому +2

      @Mark Gaming nice. I don't have a Vita or I would have just played that one. I played Persona 3 on my psp. I'm planning on a Switch next year or two

    • @dairhat
      @dairhat 2 роки тому +2

      @@naylisyazwina6836Persona 3, 4, and 5 is coming to Nintendo Switch! :D

    • @JellyJman
      @JellyJman Рік тому +1

      Same, finished my ps2 save on the fat ps3 with backwards compatibility

  • @IAMNOTRANA
    @IAMNOTRANA 2 роки тому +12

    I'm fine with golden but I absolutely hate the awful instant text. I prefer them animated and such.

  • @troev
    @troev 9 місяців тому

    i love static noise from original

  • @bryantnonya8704
    @bryantnonya8704 2 роки тому +4

    I like persona 4 better on the PS Vita but I have long since sold my PS Vita and can only play it through emulation on aether so at the moment I like the PS2 version better LOL

    • @conorrynne9694
      @conorrynne9694 2 роки тому +7

      Persona 4 Golden (the version that released on Vita) got a PC port. You can pick it up on Steam.

    • @bryantnonya8704
      @bryantnonya8704 2 роки тому +1

      @@conorrynne9694 unfortunately I only have my smartphone but aethersx2 is a great way to play persona 3 and persona 4.
      Honestly it's been a godsend considering how stagnant emulation on Android has become and I would highly recommend it regardless because it allows you to have a portable version of some classics like final fantasy 10 devil May cry 3 Gran Turismo 3 Street fighter 3 third strike dead or alive 2 hardcore virtual fighter 4 evolution persona 3 persona 4 okami and many others...
      Some of the more graphically intensive games won't run at full speed but compatibility is very good and the emulator is free so there's not much to complain about...

    • @raevedlstar2455
      @raevedlstar2455 Рік тому

      Looks like that's not the case anymore lol

  • @ryans1892
    @ryans1892 3 роки тому +43

    I like the original PS2 version the best. Golden adds a lot of unnecessary content that does nothing.

    • @trots4940
      @trots4940 3 роки тому +22

      Actually most of those additional contents are good and they improve the player interaction.
      Like the fact that in Golden version you can walk around the shopping district when Dojima goes to the gas station in the beginning of the game, and there you can see and talk to some important characters (Like Saki and her brother). This way, the game universe becomes more "alive" and it introduces some info/characters.
      Obviously a few contents aren't necessary, but i believe most of them are important and/or cool.

    • @yunarukami14
      @yunarukami14 3 роки тому +9

      You’re joking?

    • @juhrodrigues6306
      @juhrodrigues6306 10 місяців тому +3

      You probably never played it lol

  • @TallTapper
    @TallTapper 8 місяців тому

    i agree