You're so down to earth and rational in the points you make. Your expertise (sorry, im not a photography person, so never heard of you before, but now subscribed) shines through in your breakdown critique, even for someone like me who knows little of the industry. What a contrast to the 'tech-bro-dude' video you critique. To be honest I got tired of listening to him in your video--He's probably a nice guy, just trying to make a living, but I wish UA-camrs would focus more on the a concise message they want to get across, and less on the 'how-can-I-fit-every-single-monetizing-tactic-into-every-video-I-make' method of making videos: make a list; sound super-upbeat; have super-cool background with LED bling; add a "wait for the end where I show you secret tip" tagline in the first 10 seconds.
What you bring out best in this video is the fact that there are 2 different types of shooting styles for automotive photography. Joseph covered the basic entry-level Instagram shots well, something that only needs a single exposure, and is quick to take, quick to post. The hobby/IG photographers will be happy with this, and 95% of people on social media will be happy with it as well. (Until they watch this video) 😂 You hit home that professional car photography is a completely different world. As someone who did a few marketing campaigns with Ford, working with a friend on a shoot for JLR was something OF ANOTHER LEVEL. I love how you started off with the fact that all brands are different, and their tier system for shoots is so different as well. Was really cool to see these things put into a video! 🙌🏽
Literally changing the car photography scene in youtube! Really glad you are making videos that really show what the real difference between a professional photographer and instagram photographer. Thanks a lot for all the useful information in every single video Michael - it brings so much valuable insight that otherwise no one talks about.
I want to express my appreciation for your videos. They have been incredibly informative, and it's clear from your presentations that working with you would be a great experience. Your level of success stands out, especially as I’ve yet to transition this pursuit into a full-time endeavor. The distinction between someone with some proficiency and a true professional like yourself is unmistakable.
OMG thank you! I cannot count how many times I've seen videos of people who have never been working professionals in the space giving out advice that is usually not totally accurate.
That guy is far from a professional and shouldn't be giving tips on automotive photography. Glad there's a few channels like yours on here. Diamond in the rough! 🙌
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I’m not even here for “car photography” I’m here for photography. Except I’m in Italy now trying to nail awesome shots of these Fiat 500’s in their natural habitat.
Found you through the Automotive Photography Collective group on fb. You really seem to know what you are doing and Im so glad I found your channel because I want to make car photography my living. Currently going to motorsports events and such since I enjoy them a lot but its hard to make this your job. Well done!!
One thing I feel that is missing in Joseph's video (and almost all of YT photography) is the "why" behind the photoshoot and shot selection, which is more established in your examples. For me, answering that and keeping it in mind during a shoot solves the "what and how should I photograph" questions. I'd like to hear more about your lens selection. I do almost everything at 85 & 200 for exteriors and 24,35, 85 for interiors. I do Bring-A-Trailer style shoots for a dealership so I'm filling the frame with the car and details for online lookers/buyers. I have the space, so I shoot with as long a focal length as possible. Interiors, I'm always trying to avoid glare and my reflection, so longer helps. Are you shooting wide mostly due to the emphasis on environmental shots? For interiors, is it a perspective preference or to show as much as possible, even in detail shots?
I think the WHY is crucial and the biggest thing most photographers lack. Need to study art history so you know why art exists before you can apply it to your photography
I love finding new creators in the video/photo space. Although thats not what my channel is about, it’s a passion of mine. As much as I want to love what you’re doing, I think it’s really unfortunate when creators break other creators down to build themselves up. You’ve got clear knowledge of your craft. Focusing on building others up will get you so much further, while at the same time not promoting a toxic culture that does more harm than good.
Your honesty is appreciated. Unfortunately, I’m a lone voice in criticizing the current state of this industry. While I could have been harsher, I believe it’s important to call out these "influencers
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I understand what you’re saying and I appreciate your honest response. I’m a professional in my industry as well and I fully understand the spread of misinformation from other creators whom I disagree with. Let me maybe offer a different approach… what if instead of tearing another creator down, you reached out to collaborate on a video maybe showing different techniques etc. I have creators in my space that I disagree with, I shout them out any positive way I can then simply agree to disagree when necessary. In this format we both build each other up, grow our channels, spread positivity and build our own voices to ensure our messages get spread. Simply put, we can choose to try and mute others or build our own voice loud enough it’s heard over the others.
Good idea, Justin. And you know what? I've tried connecting with some to collaborate in a positive way. Unfortunately, i was either met with attitude or crickets. So there's not even a chance to agree to disagree, but instead others in my niche prefer the you do you, I do me. I hope it's different in your hair styling field. I actually watched your Airstrait review. a while back (I have long ass hair).
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal thank you man! I appreciate that. I totally understand where you’re coming from with reaching out to creators and hearing nothing. I’ve reached out to a lot (that I’m actually friends with now) and got zero response because they never saw the messages…or at least that’s what they said! lol. It’s a struggle for sure, maybe I can help in some way. If you want, hit me up on Instagram, I may have a connection to some people. Happy to help where I can. You seem solid, I sincerely believe you can create a massive voice and work with others collaboratively during that process. Again, I appreciate the honest chat man!
Absolutely admire your work. I am not car photographer-I do more of portraits & fashion but I always learn from you and your video’s . Highly professional and skilled photographer that talk about skills and business not ego. Keep good work . Thank you
Thank you so much for making this. There is so much boloney on the internet. I am an avid amateur photog and creative so I really dig the real-world perspective. PS: my family are JLR dealers, so thanks for the stunning work you do!
This video is gold. Finally someone roasts amateurs giving advice like professionals while making basic mistakes themselves. I'm waiting for the next video like this. And of course we want to see how to take shots in motion, sideways.
You remind me of Scott from Tin House Studios on youtube. Spitting actual facts about the industry. He is in the commercial world though and loves to be brutally honest. youtubers LOVE to make up genres like "I'm a model photographer" for example. Where some industries don't even exist (but do on youtube, just a fake reality).
Great advice Michael. I enjoy watching you share your knowledge and experience here on YT - wish you did it more often - and the fact you are able to back all your suggestions up with some incredible images produced for big brands makes you a top channel for me. I dont know the guy you reviewed but I watch many YT 'car photographers' and there are many who come across like they know everything but have no mass distributed material other than a load of likes on IG. Please do more like this!
Indeed great video. I don’t think that you were rude. When you have the facts it’s easy to learn. Again. Please make More videos like this. They are super helpful. Best to you
Oh man you left me hangin' on the motion blur!!! Hahahah. Yes, yes... oh and also yes I would love to see a video on how you achieve those motion blur shots. I have an idea how you do it but I may be wrong.
I really enjoyed this video. I like your calm demeanor but to the point approach. It was quite amusing. Keep going and giving the straight advice we need.
The difference between a youtuber and a professional photographer, one with a true skillset the knows the subject matter. I watched this guys video and couldn't make it past his 2nd "must do"
I watched several of Don Giannatti classes and videos and the difference between someone with a good camera and a true professional photographer is miles apart. And like everything no two people have the same tastes but when you're working with high-end products and top art directors then a person with a camera isn't going to cut it.
I love the energy and enthusiasm the guys has. The problem is that he's trying to communicate to begginers the worst way, 'everything wrong' about car photography. Is not easy at all. The hard work the brain does to create a new way of seeing a car, it's downgraded to something look easy, wrong and awful. Thanks for exposing that some things are not that easy.
Interesting video, I appreciate the clarification on some of the terms. However I do believe Garcia was onto something about LED headlights. They have an operating frequency which can be detected by a camera in some instances. Lowering your shutter speed can and does allow you the refresh rate issue to be mitigated. I have shot some BMW's in the past where the refresh rate was out of sync so it would appear that one light was on and the other was not. Your comment however, about the lens flare, is still true and valid.
Great video, man! I think Joseph's shots are good guidelines. Definitely shots to consider for sure when you're doing a car photoshoot. 5:45, agreed. that white balance...can REALLY vary. I think lighting is the key factor for these specific settings. F/2.8 got me thinking they are doing this when the sun just BARELY hanging on. lol
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Yeah I mean his work is good and I don’t want to make fun of him but I just think car photography is running 2 different roads. The business road where it really is about „professional“ photography and the enthusiast road where they know more about the cars than their camera. I don’t want to hurt anybody here, but these people tend to say a lot of wrong things in photography and those are always the loudest. I really appreciate your YT channel! Even though I‘m more of a studio photographer it’s very interesting and definitely helps a lot for everyone interested in photography.
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I also wanted to ask if you could show how you‘d go for an interior detailed shot. Do you do HDR or do you also include flashes?
Thanks for your question. I want to be clear that I have no opinions about the character of other UA-camrs. My opinions are only on what they say in their content. That being said, I could make 1 about one of his videos. Do you have one in mind?
"The Landscape Shot" Then shows a Starbucks or Gas Station... The location is just as important in my car photography as the car itself. I don't think of it as one specific shot to get... This is definitely aimed at the hype IG photographers.
As a motorcycle and car photographer, I was very disappointed by how much confidence combined with totally untrue quotes the guy made. Thanks for making it right. You know, there are those who do things and those who take a couple shots and immediately brag about it. By the way cool shots that you’ve done!
Love this video, but I think the main difference is I consider these 2 different routes. There’s speed and quality or there’s taking your time and quality. Although some of his tips and terminology is definitely wrong, not everyone wants to spend 30-1 hour on one photo on the location. They want to be done within an hour or 2, edit the next day. The Lightroom photographer I like to call it or editorial in some cases. You and I are definitely more quality over quantity and most of your viewers are too, his viewers are not. But I love this video because it does showcase the differences between the 2! Obviously you’re wayy more technical and specific than him and other UA-cam car photographers.
Question could he use polarized lens to get rid the “flare” hehe had to, but yah or could he use nd filter to reduce light coming in? Btw when my mom was buying rav4 I saw that group shot of Lexus Rx really love it “my nick name for that style is ballroom shot and group when they are in row” the artist in me chicken skin just looking at it because the way you highlight each car each window with different color tones with each car that what made my chicken skin..
It's a tricky one, because Joseph is just creating youtube content for an audience of probably non-car shooters or hobbiest crowd. Those of us who have been working in the commercial ad sector for long enough have a very different view on how car photography needs to be done because of industry experience. It's maybe comparing apples and pears a bit. But then again, we're all just making youtube content too.
Thanks Seagram. My main criticism was him coming across as a pro and expert, potentially misleading the YT audience. Also trying to full a void and offer my perspective with "industry experience". People, as always, will believe whatever they want to believe.
I dont think you were too harsh at all. The difference between a pro and a You Tuber. The one teaches the other hypes to get more followers and likes, Personally I like longer FL in the 85-200 range but I am not shooting the environmental shots you do
Portraying yourself 'real professional' and superior to the fellow youtuber but yet don't know the difference between flickering issues in electronic shutter cameras and the flaring. Guess who's still living with old gen cameras and making a mockery of himself?
Thanks for your comment. Electronic shutter banding are uniform lines across the entire frame - this isn't. We have no idea if he's using electronic shutter at all (even though his Sony has this feature), so you're presuming. The lens flare shapes are directly aligned to the headlight shape/size. This is just basic logic, not software engineering logic.
I'm late to the party. Maybe the video didn't deserve to be dissected like that; the guy never claimed to be a professional photographer though he uses the 'pro' moniker as clickbait in the title. He's trying to make a buck off social media and puts out videos that he thinks would go viral among a certain audience. Shooting cars is a subniche on instagram and there are people out there teaching how to edit those videos. Flashy colors, speed ramps, stupid gimbal moves, plethora of effects slapped on in AE. A different world from yours, albeit both are focused on cars. Apples to oranges.
I don't see a problem expressing my opinion about someone else's opinion. Just like you are expressing your opinion to me. My only problem is when people telling me I cannot or should not share mine.
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Ay man look, if you wanna be condescending fine. This isn't an attack but it seems that's your style of choice when it comes to critique so you can't be critiqued or told anything. I used to be like that. You want your ego stroked and you want validation. I suggest therapy and getting the f*ck over yourself. You're incredibly talented but you're also very immature.
Garcia is full of bull💩. I’m no expert I only shoot motorsports from behind the fences but I’ve been behind a camera for Film video and stills for over 30 years and I would never give this stupid advice that he’s given. And I just became a follower of yours because you do great work.
Points taken, but this cat's got five TIMES the subscribers you have. Nit picking him makes you look petty and envious. I agree with a lot of your critique, but the tone doesn't reflect well on you. (I was expecting you to criticize his haircut next.) Rather than picking on others, show us the RIGHT way to do it. Be positive and it will serve you better.
You're so down to earth and rational in the points you make. Your expertise (sorry, im not a photography person, so never heard of you before, but now subscribed) shines through in your breakdown critique, even for someone like me who knows little of the industry. What a contrast to the 'tech-bro-dude' video you critique. To be honest I got tired of listening to him in your video--He's probably a nice guy, just trying to make a living, but I wish UA-camrs would focus more on the a concise message they want to get across, and less on the 'how-can-I-fit-every-single-monetizing-tactic-into-every-video-I-make' method of making videos: make a list; sound super-upbeat; have super-cool background with LED bling; add a "wait for the end where I show you secret tip" tagline in the first 10 seconds.
Kudos to you for not only commenting, but also subscribing as someone "outside" of photography. This means so so much. Thank you!
I like this, so I subscribed.
About 1% of photographers on UA-cam are working "professionals", the other 99% are "professional UA-camrs" .
Cheers,
Feels good to be in the 1%, if only if was also in the top 1% fiinancially.
You really show the difference between a professional and a hobbiest
What you bring out best in this video is the fact that there are 2 different types of shooting styles for automotive photography.
Joseph covered the basic entry-level Instagram shots well, something that only needs a single exposure, and is quick to take, quick to post. The hobby/IG photographers will be happy with this, and 95% of people on social media will be happy with it as well. (Until they watch this video) 😂
You hit home that professional car photography is a completely different world. As someone who did a few marketing campaigns with Ford, working with a friend on a shoot for JLR was something OF ANOTHER LEVEL.
I love how you started off with the fact that all brands are different, and their tier system for shoots is so different as well. Was really cool to see these things put into a video! 🙌🏽
Yes totally agree with you!
Literally changing the car photography scene in youtube! Really glad you are making videos that really show what the real difference between a professional photographer and instagram photographer. Thanks a lot for all the useful information in every single video Michael - it brings so much valuable insight that otherwise no one talks about.
Awesome! Thank you! Comments like yours motivate me to keep going, even though making these videos is way more work than I thought.
I want to express my appreciation for your videos. They have been incredibly informative, and it's clear from your presentations that working with you would be a great experience. Your level of success stands out, especially as I’ve yet to transition this pursuit into a full-time endeavor. The distinction between someone with some proficiency and a true professional like yourself is unmistakable.
Wow, thank you for your kind words! It's comments like your that guide this channel with the hope that I can help more photographers. Cheers!
OMG thank you! I cannot count how many times I've seen videos of people who have never been working professionals in the space giving out advice that is usually not totally accurate.
Great video! You managed to explain your points like a true pro, whilst being respectful to the creator.
Glad it was helpful!
My first reaction video. Tried to be nice. What do you think of Joseph's opinions?
Motion blur video would be very welcome. Thank You.
That guy is far from a professional and shouldn't be giving tips on automotive photography. Glad there's a few channels like yours on here. Diamond in the rough! 🙌
@@dustinlopez-wallis2706 Thank you!
What about tips for cleaning car's paint out of reflections?
@@papiezak that’s coming.
IMHO, your UA-cam channel will skyrocket! There's a major difference between "professional" photographers and "professional" youtubers.
Thank you! I hope so - it's a lot of work!
5:17 make the damn video this is gold.
Alright - Damn it! LOL
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I’m not even here for “car photography” I’m here for photography. Except I’m in Italy now trying to nail awesome shots of these Fiat 500’s in their natural habitat.
Thanks again! Have a coffee on me during one of those crazy, never-ending shoots. Be well.
Thank you so much! Coffees for the weekend!
Found you through the Automotive Photography Collective group on fb. You really seem to know what you are doing and Im so glad I found your channel because I want to make car photography my living. Currently going to motorsports events and such since I enjoy them a lot but its hard to make this your job. Well done!!
Awesome, thank you!
I'd like to see that Porsche Taycan video! Always good to have a breakdown from a pro
Love it!
Thanks!!
One thing I feel that is missing in Joseph's video (and almost all of YT photography) is the "why" behind the photoshoot and shot selection, which is more established in your examples. For me, answering that and keeping it in mind during a shoot solves the "what and how should I photograph" questions. I'd like to hear more about your lens selection. I do almost everything at 85 & 200 for exteriors and 24,35, 85 for interiors. I do Bring-A-Trailer style shoots for a dealership so I'm filling the frame with the car and details for online lookers/buyers. I have the space, so I shoot with as long a focal length as possible. Interiors, I'm always trying to avoid glare and my reflection, so longer helps. Are you shooting wide mostly due to the emphasis on environmental shots? For interiors, is it a perspective preference or to show as much as possible, even in detail shots?
I think the WHY is crucial and the biggest thing most photographers lack. Need to study art history so you know why art exists before you can apply it to your photography
I love finding new creators in the video/photo space. Although thats not what my channel is about, it’s a passion of mine. As much as I want to love what you’re doing, I think it’s really unfortunate when creators break other creators down to build themselves up. You’ve got clear knowledge of your craft. Focusing on building others up will get you so much further, while at the same time not promoting a toxic culture that does more harm than good.
Your honesty is appreciated. Unfortunately, I’m a lone voice in criticizing the current state of this industry. While I could have been harsher, I believe it’s important to call out these "influencers
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I understand what you’re saying and I appreciate your honest response. I’m a professional in my industry as well and I fully understand the spread of misinformation from other creators whom I disagree with. Let me maybe offer a different approach… what if instead of tearing another creator down, you reached out to collaborate on a video maybe showing different techniques etc. I have creators in my space that I disagree with, I shout them out any positive way I can then simply agree to disagree when necessary. In this format we both build each other up, grow our channels, spread positivity and build our own voices to ensure our messages get spread. Simply put, we can choose to try and mute others or build our own voice loud enough it’s heard over the others.
Good idea, Justin. And you know what? I've tried connecting with some to collaborate in a positive way. Unfortunately, i was either met with attitude or crickets. So there's not even a chance to agree to disagree, but instead others in my niche prefer the you do you, I do me. I hope it's different in your hair styling field. I actually watched your Airstrait review. a while back (I have long ass hair).
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal thank you man! I appreciate that. I totally understand where you’re coming from with reaching out to creators and hearing nothing. I’ve reached out to a lot (that I’m actually friends with now) and got zero response because they never saw the messages…or at least that’s what they said! lol. It’s a struggle for sure, maybe I can help in some way. If you want, hit me up on Instagram, I may have a connection to some people. Happy to help where I can. You seem solid, I sincerely believe you can create a massive voice and work with others collaboratively during that process. Again, I appreciate the honest chat man!
Absolutely admire your work. I am not car photographer-I do more of portraits & fashion but I always learn from you and your video’s . Highly professional and skilled photographer that talk about skills and business not ego.
Keep good work . Thank you
Wow, thank you!
Thank you so much for making this. There is so much boloney on the internet. I am an avid amateur photog and creative so I really dig the real-world perspective. PS: my family are JLR dealers, so thanks for the stunning work you do!
You are so welcome!
everyone's an expert on youtube until an actual working photographer posts content
This video is gold. Finally someone roasts amateurs giving advice like professionals while making basic mistakes themselves. I'm waiting for the next video like this. And of course we want to see how to take shots in motion, sideways.
Glad it was helpful!
You remind me of Scott from Tin House Studios on youtube. Spitting actual facts about the industry. He is in the commercial world though and loves to be brutally honest. youtubers LOVE to make up genres like "I'm a model photographer" for example. Where some industries don't even exist (but do on youtube, just a fake reality).
Yep - love Scott's channel. He's great
Thank you for being my inner voice. :)
My pleasure! LOL
Great advice Michael. I enjoy watching you share your knowledge and experience here on YT - wish you did it more often - and the fact you are able to back all your suggestions up with some incredible images produced for big brands makes you a top channel for me. I dont know the guy you reviewed but I watch many YT 'car photographers' and there are many who come across like they know everything but have no mass distributed material other than a load of likes on IG. Please do more like this!
I appreciate that! Thank you! Will do more!
You are awesome, nothing more to say! Thanks for your insights and all the info, really, really help!
Thank you so much!
you are completely roasting him through the video 😂😂
gently 😜
Indeed great video. I don’t think that you were rude. When you have the facts it’s easy to learn. Again. Please make
More videos like this. They are super helpful. Best to you
5:15 Yes, please show us!
Done and uplaoded!
Oh man you left me hangin' on the motion blur!!!
Hahahah. Yes, yes... oh and also yes I would love to see a video on how you achieve those motion blur shots. I have an idea how you do it but I may be wrong.
Just uploaded yesterday - hope you like it!
I really enjoyed this video. I like your calm demeanor but to the point approach. It was quite amusing. Keep going and giving the straight advice we need.
The difference between a youtuber and a professional photographer, one with a true skillset the knows the subject matter. I watched this guys video and couldn't make it past his 2nd "must do"
Thanks!
I watched several of Don Giannatti classes and videos and the difference between someone with a good camera and a true professional photographer is miles apart. And like everything no two people have the same tastes but when you're working with high-end products and top art directors then a person with a camera isn't going to cut it.
Really happy I came across this account. Love your explanations! New sub !
Welcome aboard!
Great video. I will be looking to do a consultation with you one of these days.
Email me anytime!
Fantastic educational video 😊
Thank you!
"UA-cam is the worst place to learn photography." Proceeds to school everyone watching the video. Very misleading! Can't wait to watch more! :)))
“ very misleading! Can’t wait to watch more” is also misleading. 😜
I love the energy and enthusiasm the guys has. The problem is that he's trying to communicate to begginers the worst way, 'everything wrong' about car photography. Is not easy at all. The hard work the brain does to create a new way of seeing a car, it's downgraded to something look easy, wrong and awful. Thanks for exposing that some things are not that easy.
Yes! Brilliant video, and let's see that Porsche Taycan video ;)
Done and uplaoded!
Interesting video, I appreciate the clarification on some of the terms. However I do believe Garcia was onto something about LED headlights. They have an operating frequency which can be detected by a camera in some instances. Lowering your shutter speed can and does allow you the refresh rate issue to be mitigated. I have shot some BMW's in the past where the refresh rate was out of sync so it would appear that one light was on and the other was not.
Your comment however, about the lens flare, is still true and valid.
@@ShootingDave I believe light flickering is something to do with Hz.
I seen a video explaining it way more than I could, so I won't even try lol.
Taycan Video please! Would love to see the strategy for that motion blur!
Uploaded!
I suppose virtual rig.
Nice reaction and very good explained! I think Joseph can thank you for your suggestions for improvement.
I hope so and thank you for watching. Please share if you can.
Nice video! Would love to see a video on the motion blur.
we DEFINETLY want to see a video about the porsche taycan shots
Done and uplaoded!
Great video, man! I think Joseph's shots are good guidelines. Definitely shots to consider for sure when you're doing a car photoshoot.
5:45, agreed. that white balance...can REALLY vary. I think lighting is the key factor for these specific settings. F/2.8 got me thinking they are doing this when the sun just BARELY hanging on. lol
3:53 This made me burst out in laughter so hard😂😂😂
Ha ha that was my natural knee jerk reaction!
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Yeah I mean his work is good and I don’t want to make fun of him but I just think car photography is running 2 different roads. The business road where it really is about „professional“ photography and the enthusiast road where they know more about the cars than their camera. I don’t want to hurt anybody here, but these people tend to say a lot of wrong things in photography and those are always the loudest.
I really appreciate your YT channel! Even though I‘m more of a studio photographer it’s very interesting and definitely helps a lot for everyone interested in photography.
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal I also wanted to ask if you could show how you‘d go for an interior detailed shot.
Do you do HDR or do you also include flashes?
@@kjdh3823 yes. Almost always light an interior but don’t use hdr - looks too fake.
Could you make a video where you go over “faking” rolling shots and adding in blur in post?
Uploading tonight!!
We need more of you on this platform, loved Lambo shoot, and all guide videos like pricing one which is relatively old now.
Nice commentary. I'd like to see videos of your pan & blur techniques.
I watched this video a few weeks ago and had many of the same thoughts as you.
1:45 electronic shutter artifact, usually seen in video. Easy fix for that is just to use mechanical shutter of the camera...
Could you make a video about northborders, I'm interested in your opinion, what do you think about him.
Thanks for your question. I want to be clear that I have no opinions about the character of other UA-camrs. My opinions are only on what they say in their content. That being said, I could make 1 about one of his videos. Do you have one in mind?
"The Landscape Shot" Then shows a Starbucks or Gas Station... The location is just as important in my car photography as the car itself. I don't think of it as one specific shot to get... This is definitely aimed at the hype IG photographers.
As a motorcycle and car photographer, I was very disappointed by how much confidence combined with totally untrue quotes the guy made. Thanks for making it right. You know, there are those who do things and those who take a couple shots and immediately brag about it. By the way cool shots that you’ve done!
The things people do for views, but it actually works for him. He got a lot of views.
Wait, I wanted to see you rip into his last "tip" of combining them all!
Love this video, but I think the main difference is I consider these 2 different routes. There’s speed and quality or there’s taking your time and quality. Although some of his tips and terminology is definitely wrong, not everyone wants to spend 30-1 hour on one photo on the location. They want to be done within an hour or 2, edit the next day.
The Lightroom photographer I like to call it or editorial in some cases.
You and I are definitely more quality over quantity and most of your viewers are too, his viewers are not.
But I love this video because it does showcase the differences between the 2! Obviously you’re wayy more technical and specific than him and other UA-cam car photographers.
More, please 🙏
Reactions?
Yes, Michael!
@@IvoIvanov-imagefactorystudio ok!!
Question could he use polarized lens to get rid the “flare” hehe had to, but yah or could he use nd filter to reduce light coming in? Btw when my mom was buying rav4 I saw that group shot of Lexus Rx really love it “my nick name for that style is ballroom shot and group when they are in row” the artist in me chicken skin just looking at it because the way you highlight each car each window with different color tones with each car that what made my chicken skin..
a polariser doesn't remove flares, only reflections.
As a Pro photogpraher shooting cars for over 30 years I hop I can guess the '10 shots' ..... I'll watch it now and come back
It’s not what you think 😜 looking forward to your reply though
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Just watched. You are right; it wasn't what I thought - great channel - love it - good luck
@@nelsonclub7722 that’s why I made rhis reaction video. Thanks for watching tho.
Great comments in a well done vid, and as a car tog (for car magazines) must agree with all you said. Oh as for the Porsche vid then yes.
Make the motion blur video!
Done and uploaded!
You are too kind on this youtuber😂 i saw that video😅 I’ve got emotional damage
ha ha too funny! Good memes last forever!
remind me someone commented you need to learn how to shoot car photos from north borders😂
oh yes! shall I react to one of his videos next?
It's a tricky one, because Joseph is just creating youtube content for an audience of probably non-car shooters or hobbiest crowd.
Those of us who have been working in the commercial ad sector for long enough have a very different view on how car photography needs to be done because of industry experience.
It's maybe comparing apples and pears a bit. But then again, we're all just making youtube content too.
Thanks Seagram. My main criticism was him coming across as a pro and expert, potentially misleading the YT audience. Also trying to full a void and offer my perspective with "industry experience". People, as always, will believe whatever they want to believe.
Why you said “No” sounded important. Let’s have a video on just this.
Oh it is important - so important that it will be the most important video I will ever make. Saving it until I get a larger audience.
What camera do you use to shoot your professional car shoots?
Great reaction video, you are very kind! Also, I think Joseph meant 'copy space' for this bit... 8:32
Copy space correct
I dont think you were too harsh at all. The difference between a pro and a You Tuber. The one teaches the other hypes to get more followers and likes, Personally I like longer FL in the 85-200 range but I am not shooting the environmental shots you do
I think the main issue is that the other guy is way too clickbaity in the title, whilst actually being average AF in his work.
His method may not be to everyone's liking, but he does get a lot of views. Maybe that's the way to succeed on UA-cam.
Portraying yourself 'real professional' and superior to the fellow youtuber but yet don't know the difference between flickering issues in electronic shutter cameras and the flaring. Guess who's still living with old gen cameras and making a mockery of himself?
Thanks for your comment. Electronic shutter banding are uniform lines across the entire frame - this isn't. We have no idea if he's using electronic shutter at all (even though his Sony has this feature), so you're presuming. The lens flare shapes are directly aligned to the headlight shape/size. This is just basic logic, not software engineering logic.
I'm late to the party. Maybe the video didn't deserve to be dissected like that; the guy never claimed to be a professional photographer though he uses the 'pro' moniker as clickbait in the title. He's trying to make a buck off social media and puts out videos that he thinks would go viral among a certain audience. Shooting cars is a subniche on instagram and there are people out there teaching how to edit those videos. Flashy colors, speed ramps, stupid gimbal moves, plethora of effects slapped on in AE. A different world from yours, albeit both are focused on cars. Apples to oranges.
I don't see a problem expressing my opinion about someone else's opinion. Just like you are expressing your opinion to me. My only problem is when people telling me I cannot or should not share mine.
Excellent video, but please don't show how to fail.
But how will we learn if we don't fail?
You know it's gonna be bad info when they edit photos in a LED lit room. Worst editing workspace ever.
Too harsh? Not at all. More like showing the difference between a pro and a wanna be influencer…
You went in on someone who's clearly trying to click bait people into watching his video. It's really not that deep for you to make this whole video.
I have no idea what. you just said.
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Nothing I said was hard to understand. In short, you took his video too seriously.
So you don't think I should have made my video? Anything else I can do or not do for you?
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal Ay man look, if you wanna be condescending fine. This isn't an attack but it seems that's your style of choice when it comes to critique so you can't be critiqued or told anything. I used to be like that. You want your ego stroked and you want validation. I suggest therapy and getting the f*ck over yourself. You're incredibly talented but you're also very immature.
I don't think you were critical enough... that dudes video was terrible.
Oh ha ha. Let’s see about the next reaction
Garcia is full of bull💩. I’m no expert I only shoot motorsports from behind the fences but I’ve been behind a camera for Film video and stills for over 30 years and I would never give this stupid advice that he’s given. And I just became a follower of yours because you do great work.
Thank you for subscribing! Means a lot!
Points taken, but this cat's got five TIMES the subscribers you have. Nit picking him makes you look petty and envious. I agree with a lot of your critique, but the tone doesn't reflect well on you. (I was expecting you to criticize his haircut next.) Rather than picking on others, show us the RIGHT way to do it. Be positive and it will serve you better.
Number of subscribers is a number gen Z means it's important, nobody else in the right mind.
Uh yeah I really wanna see that video 5:16
Done. Just posted.
@@ThePhotographyRebuttal thank you good sir 🤝