Can Stagg Be BEATEN By Elijah Craig!? | Stagg Jr Batch 15 vs Elijah Craig Barrel Proof C920

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @CPGumby
    @CPGumby Рік тому +5

    "Your mom eats dry cupcakes." LOL!!! 🤣

  • @TripleCM239
    @TripleCM239 10 місяців тому +1

    Blended my Stagg 22A with my ECBP C923…. Absolutely phenomenal blend of two fantastic bottles

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  10 місяців тому +1

      Funnily enough we just did a similar blend on those exact two batches and it’s VERY good!

  • @davidg5308
    @davidg5308 Рік тому

    Damn just damn...the C920 is amazing...just had a few other pours and ended with the C922 and I am done for the night - happy Friday night and cheers!!!

  • @Russ_L
    @Russ_L Рік тому +3

    Love the ECBP, have yet to come across a Stagg but I’m still hunting. Cheers

  • @kathyhughey7350
    @kathyhughey7350 Рік тому

    Loved Batch 13, 14 and 15 of Stagg Jr. - got the 17 and it was just not enjoyable. Tried adding water to the 17 and putting it on ice, still just not my jam especially compared to previous batches. Great video.

  • @CPGumby
    @CPGumby Рік тому +1

    I have seen ONE BOTTLE of Stagg Jr. in person, and they wanted $299 for it... so I will keep looking and maybe some day I will get one. I have had a pour of Batch 14 at a bar last year and it was amazeballs! I have a single bottle of ECBP C922 and a Private Barrel store pick--paid MSRP for both and both are fantastic. Good to know that if I never find a Stagg Jr. I'm still good with what I have and can get. FIGHT THE FOMO!

  • @johncannon3593
    @johncannon3593 Рік тому +2

    C920 was my all-time favorite batch (though I only got into them in the 19's. Good thing I have a few bottles bunkered along with several B520s. I like Stagg jr (now just Stagg), but I'll only pay up to about $100 for it. No reason to pay $200-$300+ at all. ECBP are always available in my area for $70 any day of the week.

  • @michelerivera6183
    @michelerivera6183 Рік тому

    Nice! Sadly, I never got to try any ECBP from 2020 but am a big ECBP fan overall. Love Stagg Jr batch 15 but it is (like Jason says on the Mash and Drum) like "a candy shop."

  • @OldFashionedWays
    @OldFashionedWays Рік тому +1

    that is interesting. that is why i love blinds. thanks for sharing. cheers.

  • @nickp5511
    @nickp5511 Рік тому

    Nice job! Stagg Jr in my area is 300.00 to 500.00 and ECBP’s are usually 70.00 I found a ECBP B520 & C920 that were 90.00 each so I grabbed both!

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      Wow, you hit the jackpot. B520 and C920 are both two of the best batches in a long time.

  • @89sooner
    @89sooner Рік тому

    The best thing about the must-have ECBP is that since I discovered it with A121, I’ve been able to get at least one of each batch (through A123) and typically a backup (and the single barrels have been all over creation since late last summer…if way more variable)….then comes Stagg, Jr., which has only entered into my life with a single MSRP bottle of 16 and then 17 (18 could still happen). Dang it, Stagg, Jr!

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      We still have to get ECBP out of the back room through connections here. Hoping we’re trending toward finding it on the shelf again soon.

    • @89sooner
      @89sooner Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey Oh the joys of the 50 versions of the 3 tier system. It always (well for 7 times) shows eventually up in OKC (A122 showed up about 2 weeks before B522), but when you hear about it, you’ve maybe a few days to get on it. Obviously we have our blindspots as well, but I don’t necessarily care that we are paradise for Weller SR-lovers.

  • @stuartrollings602
    @stuartrollings602 Рік тому

    Great review of two wonderful pours! Thanks

  • @robertbugh1798
    @robertbugh1798 Рік тому

    Love the ending!!

  • @msutton01
    @msutton01 Рік тому

    Josh's reactions are the best. Loved your song at the end Erin! Great blind.

  • @jmonterojr
    @jmonterojr Рік тому

    Great video. I can't get any Stagg for less Than 300 bucks. Ecbp Continues to impress for the price. And you all need a channel of Erin drinking bourbon and doing Karaoke. Hit for sure

  • @chasecarter1170
    @chasecarter1170 Рік тому

    ECBP is my lifeblood. Scored two a117s today and I'm pumped lol finally got the current bottle shape vertical!

  • @jasonreinecke3569
    @jasonreinecke3569 Рік тому

    How much more did you like C920 compared to C922? C922 is my favorite that I've had. Never had C920 and just curious how much difference there is.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      We do like C920 a fair bit more than C922, but A123 is right there with C920 for us (if not better). ECBP has been delivering some gems (with the exception of the 2021 releases and A122 for our palates-none of which were bad, but they just weren’t as great to us as ECBP usually is).

    • @jasonreinecke3569
      @jasonreinecke3569 Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey Thank you!

  • @FakingANerve
    @FakingANerve Рік тому

    Is there a video of that blind of all the ECBP? I'm curious how a couple specific batches fared.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      Not publicly. It was on one of our monthly Patreon livestreams. What batches are you interested in?

    • @FakingANerve
      @FakingANerve Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey B522 and C922.

    • @FakingANerve
      @FakingANerve Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey Reason being, I had the B522 recently and loved it. I have a bottle of C922 and while I haven't opened it yet, I've heard it was one of the better ECBP.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +2

      @@FakingANerve both are two of our favorite batches since B520 and C920. A123 is also excellent. We particularly loved B522 ourselves, not as the prototypical ECBP, but a great balanced sweet sipper.

  • @jamesstreet1144
    @jamesstreet1144 Рік тому

    I found STAGG 18 in Clarksville for $200, found it in Evansville In. for 58.99. Found the A123 ECBP (also in Evansville) for 79.99

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      Way to go Evansville on proper pricing!

    • @ttiger9780
      @ttiger9780 Рік тому +1

      That makes me sick. Never seen one.

  • @lionelg4648
    @lionelg4648 Рік тому +1

    have you tried the first Stagg, thoughts?

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      Batch 18? If so, it’s solid. Darker and less fruit forward than a lot of Stagg Jr batches. Has a second gear of jalapeño-like heat on the finish that’s unique and may not be for everyone, but is interesting.

  • @zgermanrobot
    @zgermanrobot Рік тому

    C920 is my personal favorite 😍. I am lucky to have 3 of them. Never had Stagg Junior. Unable to find them, and I will not buy any whiskey over $160. Awesome review, like always. You, ADHD and Whiskey Row( or Beyond the Row), are my go to Bourbon tunes. Keep up the good work.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      Thanks so much man! That’s some exceptional company to be mentioned alongside. We appreciate the kind words!

  • @markcatron8996
    @markcatron8996 Рік тому

    The A123 is another great pour, such a great taste. A bit lower proof at 125.6

  • @imoffthegrid2158
    @imoffthegrid2158 Рік тому

    I just picked up the Stagg 22B for $52 and they also had Blanton's gold for $118 . This particular store has a no mark up policy. Problem is you have to get lucky and be there when they start selling them from behind the counter.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      Fantastic score! Gotta love stores who respect reasonable prices.

  • @chrisdunning5481
    @chrisdunning5481 Рік тому

    I do not always have both of your head to head bottles but I do have these. When C920 came out I liked it so much I bought quite a few. Still have two unopened. Also have several Stagg 15’s. I do think the C920 is overall better. But it’s hard not to love the Stagg. Love the video as usual. Enjoy those unfrosted cupcakes that you apparently know so well…..🤣

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      Congrats on having a couple of C920s bunkered. It's a batch we still look for ourselves just in case. Cheers Chris!

  • @troybucher6383
    @troybucher6383 Рік тому

    I haven't had a chance to grab a C920, but really like my Stagg 15. The 15 is so sweet!

  • @tsubakichan
    @tsubakichan Рік тому

    Lucked upon a bottle of C920 for $80, which I know is overpriced but considering its fame - happy to have it. Still waiting for a special occasion to pop it...

  • @byoregon1
    @byoregon1 Рік тому

    OK. FIrst we have the "dark and rich" line, followed by "this thing is quite large but doesn't always function as well as I would like". I think the thumbnail of this episode should have been "Stuff & Whiskey After Dark"!

  • @michaelackley1560
    @michaelackley1560 Рік тому

    Home with snow. Wish it was later in the day. I would have EC. Not pale Erin translucent. Pale is when you're sick.

  • @terrencemcdermott5840
    @terrencemcdermott5840 Рік тому

    I’m a big fan of ECBP, I know everyone always lauds it as the best value in whiskey, but that’s because it is! I have never owned a Stagg. It’s impossible to find in WI. I also typically gravitate towards ECBP’s flavor profile more than the sugary sweetness of BT products.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      We get why the sugary sweet fruit-forward profile is a crowd pleaser, but that darker candy bar profile is just such a winner in our books. Great minds? We think so. Cheers Terrence!

  • @roscoepcoltrane23
    @roscoepcoltrane23 Рік тому

    C920 is my favorite ECBP but I will say A123 is awfully good. Stagg Jr batch 13 for me was amazing. That’s the only one I’ve had. It’s to hard to find. So good though.

  • @davevogelsang6791
    @davevogelsang6791 Рік тому

    I finally found and bought a bottle of Stagg Junior TODAY! Paid a little too much, but have never seen it in the wild, and this was the last bottle on the shelf.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      Nice! Which batch?

    • @davevogelsang6791
      @davevogelsang6791 Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey looks like 18. 131 proof and no JR on label.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      @@davevogelsang6791 our bottle of 15 is gone so we used 18 for the b-roll. Same for the ECBP C920 being gone so we used a different batch for the b-roll there as well just so folks had a visual of the bottle. Note the text stating it's a different batch used in the lower left of the screen for each b-roll shot. Great eye and great callout in case others were wondering!

  • @Bill.K.
    @Bill.K. Рік тому

    This matchup would make my soul happy too. 😀

  • @otiskeithwatkins1679
    @otiskeithwatkins1679 Рік тому

    I got some stagg this morning. I won't say I overpaid because it was for charity.....and I'll probably never do it again.

  • @matthewlenehan3345
    @matthewlenehan3345 Рік тому

    What a great pairing to pull!

  • @zhanborukhov7026
    @zhanborukhov7026 Рік тому

    Stagg is pretty much unattainable where I live. ECBP rarely disappoints.

  • @JenkinsB
    @JenkinsB Рік тому

    Depends on batches...

  • @johnkostyak3481
    @johnkostyak3481 Рік тому

    Was it about 6:55 that Josh figured out what he was drinking?

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      I never try to think about what’s in the glass and on these two all I knew was that I loved the first glass but at 6:55 I realized I loved the second glass even more because of that deep, dark richness. Big C920 fan.

    • @johnkostyak3481
      @johnkostyak3481 Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey Ah, got it. I think you'll like A123 then.

  • @LeatherDaddy97
    @LeatherDaddy97 Рік тому

    In general i definitely prefer ecbp

  • @theswag5997
    @theswag5997 Рік тому

    Swimming in whiskey, Scrooge McDuck style...

  • @877-MASH-NOW
    @877-MASH-NOW Рік тому

    WHISKEY CHEERS 😎

  • @joeappleton6849
    @joeappleton6849 Рік тому

    Never try it because of fabulous price

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      They do get pretty inflated in most markets, which is a real shame.

  • @NattyGymBro
    @NattyGymBro Рік тому

    Dark and rich 😂😂

  • @jimmiegill3981
    @jimmiegill3981 Рік тому

    There is nothing wrong with being Irish ☘️

  • @mattburns6496
    @mattburns6496 Рік тому

    Wasn’t he just describing a muffin?

  • @DaveH8905
    @DaveH8905 Рік тому

    C920 was the GOAT. Not representative of any other of their releases that came after.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому +1

      You'll hear no arguement from us. That bottle was magic.

    • @ttiger9780
      @ttiger9780 Рік тому

      C920 was great. Loved B520, too

  • @davebenson8547
    @davebenson8547 Рік тому

    theres no way stagg jr is $60..if you can find it you wont get it for under$300......

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Рік тому

      It's supposed to be $60. For our batches (14, 15, 17, 18) we've paid $60, $60, $100, and $80 respectively. $100 is our hard cap on Stagg. The fact that bottles get marked up to $250-300+ is a testament to how messed up things have gotten.

    • @davebenson8547
      @davebenson8547 Рік тому

      @@stuffandwhiskey just saw 2 bottles yesterday in 2 different stores. they were both $300