Can you solve the penniless pilgrim riddle? - Daniel Finkel
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 чер 2018
- If you enjoy our riddles, we highly recommend reading "The Number Devil": amzn.to/2kO7S8P
Check out our book rec page to learn more: bit.ly/2JqwgLE
View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/can-you-so...
After months of travel, you’ve arrived at Duonia, home to the famous temple that’s the destination of your pilgrimage. The walk from the welcome center to the temple isn't a long one ... but there’s a problem. Can you outsmart the city's imposed tax and make it to the temple without paying a fee? Daniel Finkel shows how.
Lesson by Daniel Finkel, animation by Artrake Studio.
Thank you so much to our patrons for your support! Without you this video would not be possible! Tan YH, Brittiny Elman, Mayra Urbano, Ruth Fang, Kostadin Mandulov, Alex Schenkman, Sdiep Sriram, Ivan Todorović, Antero Semi, Yanuar Ashari, Mrinalini, Anthony Kudolo, Scott Gass, Querida Owens, Hazel Lam, Manav parmar, Dwight Tevuk, Stephen A. Wilson, Siamak H, Dominik Kugelmann, Katie Winchester, Mary Sawyer, David Rosario, Samuel Doerle, Be Owusu, Susan Herder, Savannah Scheelings, Prasanth Mathialagan, Yanira Santamaria, Chad Harper, Dawn Jordan, Constantin Salagor, Activated Classroom Teaching, Kevin Wong, Umar Farooq, Goh Xiang Ting Diana, Dmitry Neverov, Tushar Sharma, Cristóbal Medina Moenne, MJ Tan Mingjie, Yansong Li, Jason A Saslow, Joanne Luce, Henry Li, Kyle Nguyen, Taylor Hunter, Noa Shore, Lex Azevedo, Merit Gamertsfelder, and Bev Millar.
If you enjoy our riddles, we think you'll enjoy the mind-boggling, brain-teasing book, "The Number Devil": amzn.to/2kO7S8P Snag an e-book version for $2.99 for a limited time, thanks to our partners at Picador! Use the link above. Happy reading (and mind-exploding)!
TED-Ed first like first comment ....now get me to 10 k subs atleast
So walk in a swastika shaped path
Thanks for a new sub 😲
TED-Ed Do you plan to do more historical videos on Rome?
is it over?
>wake up
>eat breakfast
>go outside
>walk counterclockwise around my house
>earn money by doing this
well, this is my life now
Lol
nice use of the reddit meme arrow
@@thatoneguy9582 "green" text
I liked.
It's 420 now.
Ur welcome.
It's for visitors...😂
"the city owes you 8 silvers"
this dude literally uno reverse card the city
Lol nice
I’m the 300th like
Bro is you're name jade?
I thought that was a nun...
“You dare use my own spells against me, Potter?”
"Not all those who wander are lost"
Yeah. Some of them just walk endless counter-clockwise circles to earn money.
I'm sure that's what Tolkien meant.
All that is gold does not glitter,
Not all those who wander are lost,
The old that is strong does not wither,
Deep roots are not reached by the frost.
From the ashes a fire shall be woken,
A light from the shadows shall spring,
Renewed shall be blade that was broken,
The crownless again shall be king.
Why did he leave us.
@@irishmanfromengland25 *becomes every 5-year-old since forever* YEAH BUT *WHY*
@@irishmanfromengland25 Nice. I am reading LoTR rn
@@aadhyaivaturi495 same here!
This bug was fixed in Update v19.5
?
*patch notes*
fixed bug where cities owe you money
Temple now has entry fee
Mathematicians no longer allowed in city
Gabriela Martinez 🤦🏼♂️
@@gaby-rv8fl 😂😂 he means that they beat the system
omg
if a visitor came that wasn't a pilgrim, they could get infinite silver just for walking around.
That creepy clown next door true
That creepy clown next door
sadly the walking tax doesn't apply to those
Redstoneboi just theoretically if you just keep walking west
@@kytacoyigo3988 what?
@@raffimolero64 nope
This kingdom is gonna go bankrupt if they don’t do something about this.
Yes
They sure will
I doubt everyone is that smart
If a person is not on a pilgrimage they could walk in a circle to make infinite money.
@@sonicmastersword8080 they sure will I am trying that
"The rules of pilgrimage forbid you from walking over any stretch of ground more than once"
LoL imagine going inside your house
"Steven, I'm stuck in the kitchen again"
But if you have a kitchen then you aren’t a pilgrim
a pilgrimage literally means going away from your house to a religious place
@@atroll9996 Pretty sure churches don’t have kitchens.
@@atroll9996 fair enough
Then. How. Do. You. Leave. The. Gate
How 2 get rich:
1. Go 2 Duonia
2.Walk counterclockwise loops
3. Congrats
! WARNING ! Dont be a pilgrim
Nathan Weatherly Go to the welcome center, they’ll give you directions
Nick Romadez But how do you get to the welcome center?
*insert words here*
@@awhahoo by being in the town
Where the Duolingo bird lives.
This is why I prefer Tax Evasion.
please don't be like yoshi
*YOSHI TIME*
are u good there
Based
Yoshi has entered the chat
Jim: what's your job
John: I cook for a living what do you do for a living?
Jim: I walk counter clockwise and the government gives money.
Lol
No, John is the tax reformer.
@@stag5076 yea that's why... He made the reform and now he benefits from it
the tax applies to visitors, not citizens
@@mrmurpleqwerty4838 Visit everyday
"you have no money and no way of learning any" - basically me
TedEd: Can you figure out a way to reach the temple without owing any tax?
Me: No, the answer is no, I can't.
imagine walking around in circles for a paid job...
Doktor Fickle SIGN ME UP!!
That’s some good exercise too, stayin fit and makin bank
runners
Track runners have looked at you, what do you do?*
im a security guard and i have to do patrols around a building every 2 hours during my 8 hour shift...you just described my job
Now... how do you get out?
Yeah since you cant go on the same path twice or more your stuck i guess
_You’re._ You spelled it wrong.
RS Phoenyx even the thing is over the tax isn’t the over so just go left four times and go up four times they owe you lots of monies
@RS Phoenyx AND IF YOU GO EAST AT THE SOUTHERN MOST STREET AND GO UP THE EASTERN MOST STREET YOU WILL GET MONEY
You can cross your path again soo
If you go Down, Down, left, Down, right, right, right, up, up, up, left, Down, left, left, left, Down, Down, Down, right, right, right, right
You make 4 silver
exactly what i just checked, it goes -12 and then + 8 = -4, they own u 4 silver, i was actually looking for a comment saying this cuz i thought i would be the first thinking about profting XD
M Nagano you can’t cross the same street twice...
@MadOut2BCO Gameplay Oh, yea kind of missed that...
@@petrdymanus9073 it's okay, by the time the tax return comes in the mail your pilgrimage is over. Enjoy the 4 bones
@@iBeStrong1038 today I posted a way to make 2 silver. Your way is legit and better. :-) Noice
I found a route that makes Duonia owe me money: I'll go 1 Down (8 silver), 2 Left (4), 2 Down (16), 4 Right (24), 3 Up (3), 1 Left (1), 1 Down (2), 1 Left (0), 1 Down (0), 1 Left (-2), 2 Down (-8), 3 Right, and you're at the destination with a net tax of -2 silver.
wrong, at the third step, the government considers that your destination
@@Graham226 How exactly? After 3rd step, I'm at the intersection of the leftmost vertical street and second from bottom horizontal street. I checked my route multiple times when I came up with it, there are no mistakes.
@@wombat4191 i used a spreadsheet to calculate, where are you starting from? at third it is already at temple
@@Graham226 I don't know what kind of spreadsheet you used but that is just overcomplicating things, this is a simple "draw a line on the grid" task that is best done with a pen and grid paper if you really want to confirm how my route goes. I start where the pilgrim is at the start of the problem, at the middle of the top street.
You must have misunderstood my instructions in the original comment, because after the third step the pilgrim isn't even near the destination. She hasn't even gone to right once, which would be required to get there. After the fourth step she in turn is very close to the destination, just one street above it.
If you still disagree, I can draw you a demonstration of how my route is supposed to look.
@@wombat4191 i tried that an hour ago, no matter what i do, i end up on the temple by the third step, i reach the corner and that is considered the destination
Yeah ill watch the riddle but won't even try to solve it
Nolan Chojnacki basically me everytime
I tried very briefly and gave up lol
Heck yes
Me to
same
Good luck trying to go back cause of your pilgrimage rule
please stop telling me the actual way I get it now haha
Once you reach your destination the pilgrimage is over and you can do whatever you want
just destroy the temple to get out cuz ur pilgrimage rule doesn't say you can't
Lê Nguyễn Thị just because you can does not mean you should
You 421 fools. Once you reach the temple the pilgrimage is over.
@@jaketheboss9092
Eh. Destroy the temple it is.
We're going to need a full John the Tax Reformer documentary.
The pilgrim can even save 4 silver for a big meal after visiting the temple. Simply instead of going three blocks south, go two block south (16), one west (14), one south (28), three east (34 instead of 36). Then as in the official solution: to the northern wall (4.25 instead of 4.5), one west (2.25), one south (4.5). Then to the eastern wall (-1.5 instead of -1), south (-12) and to the temple (-4).
These riddles always wake up the inner child in me.
Used to love them and now am starting to love them again.
Mustafa Ahmed I am a child
In the video, you say it is 5x5, though it shows a 4x4.
Sarika Rathi if you do the exact path but backwards then that might solve that problem
Mustafa Ahmed if only they didn't sound so unbelievable
Mustafa Ahmed You should check the Professor Layton video games. They are full with riddles like this one. They are for DS, 3DS, and mobile. It's as if they were made for the riddler in me haha.
4:20 What I’ve LEARNED from this pilgrimage is tax evasion
420 nice
Technicaly correct
My friend: So what is your job? Mine is a Doctor
Me: uhhh it's complicated
How to make money: hey mom I’m going to my summer job
Mom: I’m so proud
Him: *walks in counterclockwise circles around his house like a boss*
So inefficient. 1 loop of that is 4 walking units and earns you 1 silver.
Instead bring enough silver to declare the northeast corner as your destination (which is at most 8 silver, assuming you live in the gate), then walk in a gigantic loop passing the gate, then the temple in that order over and over again. It takes 16 walking units, but earns you 127 silver, for a net of 16.9375 silver per walking unit, as opposed to 0.25.
A 6675% increase in profit margins.
Even if walking from 1 walking unit is 1 hour, it is still more efficient to go 2 blocks each, than 1 block. 8 walking units, assuming the space to fit it in, 16 gained on the downswing, and then a cost of 1 on the upswing, for a net of 15, or 1.875 per hour, a 650% increase, and I am not convinced it is 1 hour to walk that distance. Assuming that the pilgrim cannot sleep outside, and that she walked the entire day from the moment she walked up, 22 walking units were covered.
At worst, that is a rate of 1.375 walking units per hour assuming a 16 hour walking day, but assuming an 8 hour walking day, that is 2.75, or 2 full loops, and a maximum of 3 walking units away from the northeast corner. Given a distance further than that, you might have to resort to a smaller loop on your second pass, but anything is more efficient than walking around a single block.
@@gingerinajacket8519 how could i miss that
@@TheDoerOfRandomStuff jaiden?
@@yoursleepparalysisdemon1828 sorry my UA-cam lagged
And I accidentally posted it here because of it. That comment was meant for a Jaiden Animations video
If I lived in a city which had walking tax
I'd damn straight move out, I don't care if that's where the Fiction section of the library is
It’s only for visitors though
you would owe money moving out tho
On your way do a large counter clockwise loop
thanks democrats
It’s only for visitors
"Man i just love all of these pennies i have."
"DO I SMELL PENNIES?"
*"SCREECH OF TERROR"*
Me: Walks counterclockwise around the city from start
City: Here’s 8.5 Silver
7.5
Welcome to Duonia you must pay your tax
*Walks around* NO U
Thank you for posting a riddle that actually keeps it within the rules given rather than being a "Technically you can" solution such as the wizard duel.
I found a better way to beat this. Up, up, down, down, left, right, left, right, B, A, Start.
Problem solved.
/\ /\ \/ \/ )) (( B A +
@@gdmoonlight454 left right left right you uncultured swine!
dont get it..
@@pauldominiqueschal6769 veteran gamer meme
It can't fail lol
“No all those who wander are lost...”
I really felt that, thank you for putting that quote there.
How does the Pilgrim leave if they can't go over any path they've walked on already?
The Pilgrimage ends once they arrive at the Temple, meaning they are no longer bound by the rules of said pilgrimage and are free to exit the city over previously walked ground. Or at least, I would assume so.
@@NocturneKitsune Hey, that means they can exploit the counterclockwise loophole afterwards.
don’t leave
"Not all those who wander are lost..."
imagine if they go in again to get silver, easy money
Tolkien
Who
Not all that glitters is gold
+Jay All that is gold does not glitter…
Real solution: sue the city for unfair taxation and discrimintaion
Rick and morty fan not a crazy one how is that discrimination?
Tyler Stivers it only applies to visitors
YAAAASSSSS
Extortion is the word you seek. Not discrimination.
Yeah but,suing needs a lawyer, and lawyer cost money, your penny less
Me: throws away pilgrim rules
When I get to the temple after walking the same stretch of ground:
"Yeah, PAY ME."
TED-Ed: "As a pilgrim, you carry no money, and have no way of earning any."
Also TED-Ed: "Each counterclockwise loop actually *earns* you 1 silver."
Wait does that mean you can get rich by walking around the city over and over again
yep
that's well known phenomenon on graphs: sometimes, if you consider edges with negative weight and there are loops in your graph, you might end up with a path that gives you arbitrarily large negative final values
an algorithm that can be used to detect these loops is the Bellman-Ford algorithm, which can be implemented to profit on top of arbitrage
Cee Revolt yeah so you can run around the whole city to get some easy cash lmao
No, as you cannot walk around the same block twice ;)
once the pilgrimage is done, actually yes, since that rule only applies during the pilgrimage - hit the temple, be done with it and get them riches
and I guess Cee was meaning "you" in general, why hasn't someone showed up and broken the city yet?
+Serdar MAMYEV
there's probably more to the town than just a temple. visitors can come for that and they can walk around the same block.
Always love when a new riddle comes out! Keep it up Ted-ed
Pilgrim walks counter clockwise and reaches temple and does not have to pay tax
Temple : Wait,that's illegal
Seems easy enough, though I must say, a city containing a major pilgrimage site putting this much strain on not just everyday travelers but also _the pilgrims,_ many of whom have apparently sworn vows of poverty or otherwise pack very light to avoid tempting bandits, would seem to be risking some serious international outrage.
1:18 and all of a sudden, it gets so complicated 😅
This is actually one of the simplest riddles from ted ed :P The other ones are mind blowing
more math
"Can you find the way to the temple without owing any tax?"
Me: pssh, no biggie, I just have to...
5 hours later
nvmd, I give up
The secret ingredient is crime
@@razvanefros411 yeet
Leave the grid
After watching till the end I still had troble to stop thinking about it, so I figured another way that even earns you money. You just go south two block insted of three, then west, south, east, than the same route as the other way you come to the temple with the city owing you 4 silver.
The solution is tax evasion
Ted: Can you solve the riddle
Me: takes an aeroplane
The way that final moral derived was superb!
My answer got me a debt of -2 lol. Earned money on the pilgrimage XD
Mine got -6
Shatrunjay What directions did you go in?
show
look at the 4th rule 1:51 XD
Edit: I got my math wrong but I think the best way to make some money is DDLDRRRUUULDLLLDDDRRR.
Love your animation!!! It must take more time to make riddle than solving then😊😊😊 Anyway love from Nepal
🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
Nepali Dudes love for nepal form Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
go left all the way then up because you already made it to the temple so you can just leave like that
"Not all those who wander are lost"-J.R.R.Tolkien. Love it .
Comes into gate: Your balance is 0.
Goes North.
The apocalypse ensues.
You can divide zero by something, you can't do the opposite though.
I love that Ted-Ed is making more riddles! Especially when they're well thought out and well made! Keep up the great work.
Since I'm not a pilgrim, I would not have that weird rule. So my job would be to walk in counterclockwise loops.
My solution : just don’t go!
Step 1: confirm you have green eyes
Step 2: owe no tax
Lesson 5: The shortest route was a detour.
“The shortest route was a detour”
When *I* got to the temple the *city* was owing me 4 silver
How?
yes, in fact, me too!! You just have to make a little detour: in the beginning, don't walk south-south-south but south-south-east-south-west.
pls show your entire working cuz i can’t get it
PotatoTornado we are? we ain’t solving the riddle we’re outsmarting it
Yess yess. Instead of going south-south-south, you go south-south-west-south-east and then continue on as normal. Extra 4 silver lmao
This riddle is so smart. I really enjoy these riddles they always help me think!
Interesting. I found a more complicated alternative solution in which you go a bit more West before doing looping around. Still was able to cut enough corners that it ended with 0. I could’ve even ended with a profit at the temple if it wasn’t against the rules.
Does anyone else just watch these and never solve them?
"Not all who wander are lost"
- Velen, The Profet
Prophet*
It was originally Tolkien's quote tho
*alex roeggla* Good one...
Westworld
Lee G it’s just a reference
I love these quizzes!!! Please do more!!! :)
We love your riddles,so please try making more.
For real, the Number Devil's a good book.
Yeah, we enjoyed it too, Lumos! Any other favorite math books?
I read the dutch version, a good book indeed.
That was my childhood.
John Meo Same here!!
Who here also watched Cyberchase when they were a kid? Lol
I'd love to live there, I have them owe me 8 silver by doing the path he said, then I'd walk back to the entrance and owe an ASTOUNDING 0 silver, then I'd repeat over and over and I'd be rich in no time!
But, since I ain't no Pilgrim, I'd just walk around the block bottom right of the welcoming center six times, walk to the left (to where I'd have my house) and have the city owe me 20 silver, walk up, and repeat!
I would like to have the house with the lake, one block above where I'd have my house, but I'd owe 10 silver instead
Game-o-Tron Super
you’d have to have moved out for that to work
REQUIREMENTS FOR TAX:you have to be a visitor, not a citizen with a residence in the city of Duonia
0:06 She's spreading cutiness and good vibes while she's walking
There is a way to end at 0 without owing decimal numbers (etc 2.5) on the way.
Down - down - down
Right - right
Up - up
Left - left - left - left
Down
Right
Down
Right
Down
Right - Right
So if you aren’t a pilgrim...
(Walks hundreds of times round block)
...then the city owes me 4287 silver
coming back from the temple be like:
STONKS
"Non-pilgrims can literally abuse the system by just walking counter-clockwise multiple times." -Sun Tzu, The Art Of War
It must be really hard to make riddles, who ever made it, I really appreciate it.
Yi Xin Wang I think riddles are side products of mathematical and other thinkings. Still they are great
This one is so contrived, I kind of feel like it took more work to come up with the question than to figure out the solution.
I would reckon that most of these riddles were made where the question was already known as well as the answer, and then it was wrapped up into a "scenario" as shown here so it could be nicely animated.
So in that sense they could all be considered "contrived", unless they found a riddle and took it as is.
Usually it's harder to make these than solve these.
You need to solve it to make it :D
Actually, most if not all of those are based on ancient riddles and enigmas, this one, for example, is based on the ant perimeter thought experiment.
1: Confirm you have green eyes.
2: Tell the taxes to leave.
3: Job done.
All that is gold does not glitter,
Not all those who wander are lost,
The old that is strong does not wither,
Deep roots are not reached by the frost.
From the ashes a fire shall be woken,
A light from the shadows shall spring,
Renewed shall be blade that was broken,
The crownless again shall be king.
I like how going on counter clockwise walks around the city earns you silver
Switch religions, then proceed to change it back once you arrive at the temple
*INFINITE IQ*
So Christians when you point out that all the self-centered rules they make aren't actually supported by the bible?
The pilgrim: *manages to get to the temple without paying any tax*
Me, an ordinary tourist visiting the city: *runs counterclockwise around the city and gets free bucks every time*
I just want to know how weird this pilgrim looked walking around, saying she was going to the temple and then going the opposite direction
You know what? I'll just go back home.
Capitalism did this to her
*C O M M U N I S T M A N I F E S T O*
Capitalism gave her taxes huh?
She has no money because of her religion and the taxes were imposed by a monarchy, so how is the problem caused by capitalism
It's spelled socialism*
?
This riddles always make me say *oh------ that's the way!!*
me jogging counter clockwise around a block: its called a hustle, sweetie
"Not all who wander are lost"
-Velen
"All who do this are useless"
-Everyone except the commenter
Seriously,hats off to your animation,can't wait for the next riddle!
Imagine if some person walked in a loop and got stuck. It could happen, because they can’t walk the same ground twice, they would just be stuck. Unless... what if they crawled?
1. confirm you have green eyes
2. ask the pilgrimage to leave
3. start walking
This is my first of your riddles to actually solve without looking at the answer. Keep up the good work, love your riddles.
The Number Devil's such a great book! I read it last year and it managed to explain cool maths concepts in a really fun and unique way!
You made it! Now get back to the only door in the city without taxet
Sometimes, the hard way is the best way
You can actually gain some silver by the time you reach the temple if instead of continuing downwards from the centermost intersection, you took a detour left 1 block, down 1 block, and continued along the path to the right 1 block.
Your money would change over this path to these numbers: 4, 8, 16, 14, 28, 30, 32, 34, 17, 8.5, 4.25, 2.25, 4.5, 2.5, 0.5, -1.5, -3, -6, -12, -10, -8, -6, -4, leaving you with 4 silver owed to you by the end of the trip.
Well, I guess part of this guy's pilgrimage code is to never earn or spend any money. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@danielmaher1654 Yeah. Look at the 4th rule (1:51).
yinghung man DANG IT
And I thought calculus was hard
Why do I see you everywhere?
Help me get 10'000 subs for ad revenue Pls Cus he wants fame and attention duh
Justin Y. Oh god we met again
Help me get 10'000 subs for ad revenue Pls because we all see hallucinations. He can't be that much everywhere
Conspiracy theory: Justin Y. is a group tasked to conquer every UA-cam comment section before UA-cam's impending apocalypse.
It's so fulfilling to have solved it yourself. One reservation though, it took me 2,5 hours.
Check :
Start with 0 silver
Option 1 - 2 Left + 2 Down + 2 Right + 2 Down + 2 Right = - 4 Silver.
Option 2 - 2 Left + 4 Down + 4 Right = - 8 Silver.
Isn't this better options? You can get 4 or 8 silver with free visit too.
You can’t start by going left, you can only go down or right
Well what I I break the rules of the pilgrimage.
*scenery*
Me: phew I’ve walked around the city 36 times and the city owes me a couple hundred dollars.
simply say you don't owe silver
i am genius
madhavi nowduru i am smarter. Just say THEY owe YOU $999,999,999,999,999,999,999. 🤯
Gabriela Martinez i am smartest. Look at the fourth rule.
CubicMinecraft BUT ALSAS, I AM NOT A PILGRIM, AND CAN CROSS MY OWN PATH!!!
CubicMinecraft The Log
I do these before a big test and I swear my brain works 10 times better
OMG! I really LOVE this Ted-ed riddles!🥰
Thanks to your videos, reciting and doing patterns in the class I'm in so super easy! It kind of actually gives me a high grade. Keep up the good work!
After almost three years of watching these riddles this is the first one that I full solved. feels good :D
1)you dont walk, you run
2) you walk zigzag
3) you walk diagonally
4) you teleport
What kind of pilgrimage makes it illegal to walk in the same path you traveled in?