ჰაი, რა ხდება თქვენთან? მოგილიზაციას როგორ უმკლავდებით? 🥴 -eti- in Oss-eti-an is Georgien ending and means -an (Osseti-an). Shouldn't you correct your nationality name?
As a firsi speaker it's really intresting that i can understand the logic behind the structure of those dialects that sound different from us. It really shows how geography and interactions with different people can create distinct cultures within one nation. Nice work 👍🏼
There isn't any difference between Persian and Dari, the tajiki is also understandable totally for Persian and Dari speaking people. Actually the three languages are the same
I'm Iranian and favorite Iranian languages are Baluchi and Kurdish I like baluchi because it's the descendant of the Parthian language and i like kurdish because it's closely related to Ancient Persian from Achamenid era.
They seem to have used the Eastern accent for Pashto, which is not the original accent. I wish videos like this would use the Western accent. The Eastern accent completely removes two original sounds and doubles up two others instead. I think it came from slang, to be honest. People who were too lazy to say "zh" and soft "sh" (they double up and use "g" and "kh" for those two sounds, respectively).
@@erfan3857 persian calls gilaki and tabari languages dialect and try to assimilate them and their ethnicities a lot of people don't know their own language , calender and history because of systemic xenophobia
@@user-ek1bm2jo3p Im Iranian bro what you are saying is nonsense we all know that mazani and gilaki are completely different languages. its fun you want to show some kind of pan-tabari ideallogy in social media, but Mazani people and gilaki people are so good with Persians, maybe they have some kinda issues with people of Tehran because of the tourists 😂 but they are so friendly with Persians of kourasan pars isfahan kerman or Yazd... its not for today, during history people of north were so influential for Iran in any teams ... so stop your bullshit please... Also brother you talk about ethnics in Iran, like Persians themselves consider Parsi as a nation but others as ethnicits......its also nonsense, Persians consider themselves as ethnic not a nation.... They proud to be ''part'' of Iran not Iran ''itself'' There are lots of sources from Gilan and Mazandaran like GhabusNamee ...go read them kid and see what was their idea about Iran Oh also don't forget Reza Shah the first king of Pahlavi dynasty was from Mazandaran he was not even Persian but people of Iran love him like other people of north
@@erfan3857 first of all the language and ethnic name is tabari or tapuri ( mazani is an arab ethnic group and shahname mazandaran was a different place) and oh yes the classic if you want equality and calling out oppression you're a pan ?! :/ bruh im not a separatist " They proud to be ''part'' of Iran not Iran ''itself'' " that's not true and you know it both Islamic regime and fascist palanis treated ethnic minorities like a second class citizens and try to assimilate them you can deny your privilege all you want but but you can't gaslight me to think were being treated equally all these years
They also used the more colloquial accent (eastern accent) for Pashto instead of the more formal western one. The western one shares more sounds with the other Iranian languages (notably the "zh" and soft "sh").
@@ZeeZee9 the sound (ts) and (dz) which are available in pashto and ossetian are also available in central kurdish . but people aren't aware of their existence and they think these two sounds are same as (tʃ) (dʒ) in english and arabic and other languages
Persian is a common tongue and literary language, not necessarily just another ethnic vernacular as your map is showing. As such it covers a far greater area.
Thanks for featuring my language. Love from an Azeri 💜 , BTW why you mentioned us as Tat instead of Azeri cause we have low numbers now , Still we are stuck to our actual language and Azeri is our Original and rightful name.
Hi Andy. Thank you for this wonderful video. I am Kurdish, from Kurdistan. The Kurdish language has many dialects (Kurmanji, Zazaki, Sorani, Lurian, Hormani and Lak I think). You spoke the Kurmanji dialect from North Kurdistan (Turkey). I also speak Kurmanji and I am from West Kurdistan (Rojava) (Syria) .The regimes of the countries that occupy Kurdistan have separated the Kurdish people, especially in Iran, so every geographical region of Kurdistan has become an independent people from the Kurds. Greetings to you from Kurdistan 🌺🌸🌺🌸 ❤🌞💚
They arenot dialects and they are seperate languages . they donot understand each other between lets say sorani,zaza and kirmanchi. All are seperate ethnic groups. All these people named kirmanchi and sorani are not natives of syria,iraq and Türkiye, they are nomads of Zagros mountains. and migrated during times. We will deter anyone naming our soil with another name. This is only social media sickness.
It's funny considering all Iranic languages sounding and having a alot of cognates with each other except Ossetian and Baluchi being way different than other Iranic languages
@@erfan3857 I know that they speak their own languages that's why I asked why it's marked as Persian on the map when Pamiri languages are Eastern Iranian
1:04 incorrect map. Kurdish Feyli/Laki speaking territories are highlighted as Luri. What is highlighted here as "Kurdish" is almost completely Kurmanji and Sorani. Completely ingoring the other dialects. Zazaki is not a unified language name also. It is only one branch of the wider Zazaki-Kirmancki branch. I for example speak the Dimli accent of the Zazaki-Kirmancki branch. And we are also Kurds. Whoever made that map has a chauvinistic bias.
Brother’s iran don’t mean only the people of iran and only Iranian people Iran mean land of aryan so when you are one of Iranian like me Kurd this you’re country too like Turkish country turkey Anatolian Turks Uzbekistan Uzbek turk Turkmenistan turkman turk Iran is a free country, it does not mean that all the residents of Iran are of Iranian descent, or if someone is not Iranian, he is not from Iran and is an immigrant no we have Iranian Turk iranian Arabs Iranian African Iranian Nativ Armans and Georgians so they are all Iranian and in the history of Iran, we had Turkish dynasties that are related to the Turks of Iran like Seljuk are Iranian Turk not turkey Turks
Я цыган, и эти языки так похоже на мой родной язык, числа почти как у нас все ек 1 дуй 2 трин 3 штар 4 панщь 5 шов 6 эвта 7 ухто 8 инья 9 дешь 10 , Привет всем, индия 🇮🇳, Иран 🇮🇷 Таджикистан 🇭🇺, Курдистан ❤🤍💚, осетия 🤍❤💛 , Gypsy 💙❤💚 I love you , brothers🦁, 🤝🙏...
@@rafayadnanhamid8795 the safest thing to do is to follow the afghan heroes steps till we meet allah We are being killed since over 100 years and no one even cares about what is happening to us, we only have one path, fight until victory or die with dignity, just like Afghanies did, they are our idol and they will always be
When we talk about kurdish , we are talking about lurish too . Two brothers that were oneday a part of each other but now they are a little far from each other . Bji Kurd o Lur .
@@abubakr-lur i don't wanna make you feel bad about your Kurdistan but when we are talking about Kurdish, Kurdish is bunch of Iranian dialects they are completely different Gorani is different language Kurmamji is a different language and Zazaki is also different Caspian language.... If you think with this kinda nonsense you will have access to the Persian gulf you are dreaming... Kurdistan is a landlock state Lurs have nothing to do with kurds if you gunna call them kurds i also consider all of Kurdish people as Persian... You are so rude You don't understand mutual respect i think Turkey put too much pressure on you guys So do your own business dreaming about Kurdistan in social media because its all you can do 😂
Persian, Dari and Tajik are all the same language : The Persian language. Dari and Tajik are different dialects than the Iranian Persian. Like American, Australian English......
@@uurrcann Zazaki is a Kurdish language , Kurdish itself is not a single language but 6 Closely related Languages including 1)Zaza , 2)Gorani and Kurdish proper 3)Kurmanji, 4)Sorani, 5)Xwarin and 6)Laki.
@@uurrcann Zazaki is a Kurdish dialect like Kurmanji or Sorani,there is Zazas who think they're language is not Kurdish but the ones who says that don't even know their own language,they are assimilated! Those ones after some generations would even forget that they are Kurds or Zazas but they would call themselves Turks! I met some Zazas who knows Zazaki and they say that they are Kurds! Zazaki is not a different language,the Kurds who talk Kurmanji can understan 80% of it.
@@persianguy1524 Persian is the language. Dari and Tajik are both dialects. The original post states that Dari and Tajik are the same even though there is a linguistic distinction
@@Abe-my9wb a dialect is the same as that language, just a different variation, not a different language. Tajik and Dari are Persian and in fact probably closer to original Persian than Iranian Persian.
@@persianguy1524 I know what a dialect is, thank you for the lesson. Dari and Tajik are dialects but are very different than Iranian Persian to the point where speakers sometimes don't understand each other. You're correct though since Dari has preserved more archaicisms than Iranian Persian.
Ossythians existed thousands of years before Russian and ukrainian Aryan speakers, ossythians speak much closer to the original Aryan language like iranic people. Also English speakers don't understand the attributes of the world they use, like mother: in Persian madar: ma: us/ dar: door or us coming out of. Balcony= Persian balakon=bala=up / kon= house= house that's up like balcony of apartments or the Balkan region of Europe.. Paradise=Persian pardis/ ferdoos in arabic but Persian orgin. Devil= dev Persian orgin. God= persian khoda= khod=self which have spiritual meaning of spirit in us coming from god. There are many many iranic and English similar Word's that's iranic people would understand it attributes and meaning and English speakers wouldn't.
@@Kamekasee Old Persian and old Median language were so close to each other even some experts consider them as Arya language during Achaemenid empire to early expansions of Sasanian empire Persian was a gendered language then they gradually became different from each other
@@abubakr-lur yes, Kurds are descendants of the ancient Zagro-Torosian people. They were speak an isolate language. But after the iranic migrations Kurds started speak an Zagro-Iranic language. Even the modern Kurdish is different from other Iranic languages really. Iranians want asimilate us Kurds. WE - ARE - NOT - IRANIC
Can someone please explain why Ossetian sounds so distinct? Is it because they were Christians and, thus, stayed out of Persian-Muslim cultural sphere which was the dominant socio-cultural paradigm in most of the Western and Central Asia? Thanks in advance!
Pashto also sounds distinct. That is due to influence from its indic neighbors. I imagine the same happened to Ossetian. The influence of its neighbors languages affected it in certain ways. Religion doesn't affect phonology though.
Osetçenin diğer dillerden farklı olmasının sebebi Peştunca ve Osetçenin doğu İrani dillerden kalanların ise batı İrani dillerden olması.Doğu İrani dillerle batı İrani diller çok erken tarihlerde birbirlerinden ayrışmaya başladılar.Bu dillerin Doğu ve Batı olarak sınıflandırılmasının kökeninde hem coğrafya hem de fonetik farklılık kıstas alınmış. Osetçe diğer İrani dillerin aksine etrafında İrani dil konuşulmuyor yani Osetçe konuşulan coğrafya Kafkas halklarının ortası dolayısıyla diğer İrani dillerle bir etkileşimi uzun zamandır yok ve daima Kafkas dilleriyle bir etkileşimi söz konusu bunun sonucunda da kelime dağarcığında ciddi bir Kafkas dilleri borç kelimeleri var. Farklılığın diğer sebebi de doğu İrani diller ile Batı irani diller arasındaki ses denklikleri. Videoyu detaylı incelemedim ama ilk 1 dakikasında 2 tane ses denkliğine rastladım. Bu ses denkliği ise h-s ses denkliği,p-f ses denkliği ve Peştuncada görülen "d-l" ses denkliği. Toparlayacaksak S=H P=F D=L Bu ses denklikleri sözcüklerde şöyle bir değişime sebep olmuş. Proto iranca : Dasa (on/10) sayısı Osetçede : Dæs kalmış ancak D-H ses denkliğinden batı İrani dillerinin çoğunda "Deh" şekline dönüşmüş. Proto iranca Dasa sayısı ise d-l ses denkliğinden Peştuncada "Les" olmuş. Osetçedeki diğer bir fonetik farklılık ise P seslerinin F ye dönüşmüş olması. Örneğin Partça : Pīt "baba" Beluçça : Pet "baba" Osetçede P-F ses denkliğinden "Fyd(fîd) : Baba Aynı şekilde 5 sayısında da bu ses denkliği var. Farsça : Panc "5" Kürtçe : Pênc "5" Osetçe : Fondz "5"
actually Persian is the official language of Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan. Kurdish language has a lot of similarities with Persian and other Iranic languages, im myself Kurd from Iran and i know both kurdish and Persian and i can realize this relationship very well...
@@Образованиесила Pashto is an iranic language, with an iranian grammer flex, vocabulary and origin. stop with your lies and media propaganda. Pashto is the largest language in Afghanistan. Persian is the largest SECOND-ethno-lingual language in Afghanistan. Everyone can speak Persian in afghanistan as it is a lingua franca (afghan-international language). Pashto is STILL however and will ALWAYS be the largest language in Afghanistan. it is an IRANIAN language.
@@thelegendaryboy4939 You are mistaken that everyone speaks Persian in Afghanistan, majority of people of the Eastern and Southern Provinces of Afghanistan border with Pakistan only speak Pashto they don't even know Persian.
Very fascinating. The Balochi that was in the video must’ve been a Pakistani Baloch. You can hear the Indo-Aryan influence in her pronounciation if I’m not mistaken.
@ꫝarry K Of course they do because they all belong to the Indo-Iranian branch. Hindi-Urdu of course being Indo-Aryan. Balochi and Pashto being both Eastern-Iranic languages that all go back to a Proto-Indo-Iranian language.
@ꫝarry K I believe Nuristani and Dardic languages are both isolates in the Indo-Iranian branch. They don’t seem to be connected to Indo-Aryan languages at all if I’m not mistaken. They do have Indo-Aryan influences seeing that they’re surrounded by Indo-Aryan languages like Hindko and Urdu-Hindi etc.
@ꫝarry K Pashto has nothing to do with hindi punjabi urdu or anything dardic at all. The words they share are persian loan words that india got during mughal rule.
If people like to know... Iranic languages classified as Caspian languages: Talyshi Gilaki Mazani Zazaki Eastern Iranian languages: Pashto (Shoghdi) (Khowarazmi) western Iranian languages: Kurdish and all of its accents , Lurish and all of its accents , Persian, Balochi, (Azari Pahlavi)
Greetings from Erbil, the capital of the Kurdistan Region، There are several different dialects in Kurdish such as Sorani, krmanji, zazaki, Hawrami and Gorani, hat video it is the term Krmanji,
Because they used the eastern accent, listen to the western accent (spoken in Kandahar or Quetta). It sounds much closer to the other Iranian languages.
Part of it is because they used the eastern/northern accent, which is not the original Pashto accent! The western accent (spoken in places like Kandahar) sound much more similar to the other Iranian languages. I think Eastern Pashto came from slang, to be honest. Too lazy to pronounce "sh" and "zh." I really don't like the accent. Super confusing to understand, too, because they removed two distinct sounds.
Persian and Dari is almost same language. Peace to the beautiful Iranian people
Yeah but Dari and Tajik people's original language was Sogdian of East Iranic origin before Islamic Invasion to the land.
No
they are same languages with different accents
Tajik Dari Farsi Parsi : Persian
maybe its not very obvious for a foreigner but tajik is also the same. kurdish and baluchi are the next 2 most similar
yes but Betty passed away recently made another name for the same language
Dari is a dialect of Persian...
Greetings from the South Ossetia.
Salam from Ossetia!
Ай тынг хæдзæр у ЙоуТуб-йы Осетийы комментарæй куыд хъæуы.
ሠላም
ჰაი, რა ხდება თქვენთან? მოგილიზაციას როგორ უმკლავდებით? 🥴 -eti- in Oss-eti-an is Georgien ending and means -an (Osseti-an). Shouldn't you correct your nationality name?
Darood from an Azeri ( Iranian one not turkified)
@@enta2 I’m from North Ossetia…
Similarities between ossentian language and Pashtu is amazing.
I absolutely LOVE the sound of the Ossetian language. So harsh, but at the same time so melodic. 😍
As a firsi speaker it's really intresting that i can understand the logic behind the structure of those dialects that sound different from us.
It really shows how geography and interactions with different people can create distinct cultures within one nation. Nice work 👍🏼
this channel really increased my love in languages!
Of course Ossetian has to be different.
This channel deserves way more views. Keep up the great videos.🙏🙏
Iran language 🇮🇷🇦🇫🇹🇯 👍
Iran language World 🌎🌍 language!!!👍
I man tajik nations 🇹🇯 Tajikistan!!! 👍
I ❤️ Iran language!!! 👍
Kurdish is a beautiful language
Im kurdish + Hi to all my INDO-IRANIAN BROTHERS ❤
Love from your Azeri Brother. Biji Kurdistan , Zendabad Iran.
@@h2eroskoryosaryakaraaryani777 kurd Are not iranic
Kurd =/= iran
@@abubakr-lur ahl e kojaa hasti berader?
@@Ferhat21.. Sena dej
There isn't any difference between Persian and Dari, the tajiki is also understandable totally for Persian and Dari speaking people.
Actually the three languages are the same
not really
When you said my name is Andy in Kurdish, you pronounced Kurdish very well.
Silav ji te ra 👋
Ossetian sounds badass
The same only one European Iranian language. Plus, one of a few East Iranian.
I can hear strong Circassian influence in Ossetian.
@@alpachino7659 And I can hear strong Azeri influence in Tat.
Long live Iranian people❤️
I'm Iranian and favorite Iranian languages are Baluchi and Kurdish
I like baluchi because it's the descendant of the Parthian language and i like kurdish because it's closely related to Ancient Persian from Achamenid era.
exactly
Beluci people and kurdis people is brother and same .your scholars say beluci people is kurd because we have same tribes
@@muratsariboga8745 Balochi people are kurds??
Nonsense
It just so rude
i don't know what the deal with you kurds outside Iran
100% 👍👍👍 and subscription. Greetings from Tajikistan to all Iranian people !!!
English: “The Iranian Languages are beautiful. I’m looking forward to learning them.”
Persian: “.زبان های اير انی زيباست من مشتاقانه منتظر يادگيری آنها هستم.”
Dari: “.زبان ەای ايرانی زيبا هستند. من مشتاقنه منتظر يادگيری آنها.”
Tajik: “Забонҳои эронӣ зебост. Ман бесаброна интизори омӯхтани онҳо ҳастам.”
Kurdish (Kurmanji): “Zimanên îranî xweş in. Ez li benda fêrbûna wam im.”
Kurdish (Sorani): “.زمانەکانی ئێران جوانن. من بەوپەڕی خۆشحاڵييەوە چاوەڕێی.”
Pashto: “.ايراني ژبې ښکاې دي. زه د دوی زده کواو ته سير ګې په لار يم”
Balochi: “.نه کايک کنيت تا ای تنظيماتا اجباری مکنيت”
Tat:
Ossetian: “Иранцы æвзæгтæ хорзæгтæ. Айраг мæ фæлмæ цæуы базонын.”
thank you for this, this is beautiful!! I’m curious, do you have the translation for Tat?
@@Образованиесила Pashto is definetly Iranian , Punjabi Pakistanis can't even understand it.
@@dankmemewannabe i sadly don’t
@@h2eroskoryosaryakaraaryani777 genetically they are indic, i think that's what he means
大佬！膜
Balochi and all other languages are beautiful 🌹🌹❤️❤️🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
جالب بود! ❤️
Ossetian and Pashto are the only ones that stand out, and they happen to be from the same Iranian branch, makes sense I guess.
They seem to have used the Eastern accent for Pashto, which is not the original accent. I wish videos like this would use the Western accent. The Eastern accent completely removes two original sounds and doubles up two others instead. I think it came from slang, to be honest. People who were too lazy to say "zh" and soft "sh" (they double up and use "g" and "kh" for those two sounds, respectively).
Gilki and Tati are a Caspian language branch. You should also introduce the Gilaki language, which has a population of 4 million in Iran
+talysh, tabari(tapuri) and zazaki
Caspian languages are really underrated
@@user-ek1bm2jo3p well
because they have less speakers than Kurdish or Persian
but they are well known in Iran
@@erfan3857 persian calls gilaki and tabari languages dialect and try to assimilate them and their ethnicities
a lot of people don't know their own language , calender and history because of systemic xenophobia
@@user-ek1bm2jo3p Im Iranian bro
what you are saying is nonsense
we all know that mazani and gilaki are completely different languages.
its fun you want to show some kind of pan-tabari ideallogy in social media, but Mazani people and gilaki people are so good with Persians, maybe they have some kinda issues with people of Tehran because of the tourists 😂 but they are so friendly with Persians of kourasan pars isfahan kerman or Yazd...
its not for today, during history people of north were so influential for Iran in any teams ...
so stop your bullshit please...
Also brother you talk about ethnics in Iran, like Persians themselves consider Parsi as a nation but others as ethnicits......its also nonsense, Persians consider themselves as ethnic not a nation....
They proud to be ''part'' of Iran not Iran ''itself''
There are lots of sources from Gilan and Mazandaran like GhabusNamee ...go read them kid and see what was their idea about Iran
Oh also don't forget Reza Shah the first king of Pahlavi dynasty was from Mazandaran he was not even Persian but people of Iran love him like other people of north
@@erfan3857 first of all the language and ethnic name is tabari or tapuri ( mazani is an arab ethnic group and shahname mazandaran was a different place)
and oh yes the classic if you want equality and calling out oppression you're a pan ?! :/ bruh im not a separatist
" They proud to be ''part'' of Iran not Iran ''itself'' " that's not true and you know it both Islamic regime and fascist palanis treated ethnic minorities like a second class citizens and try to assimilate them
you can deny your privilege all you want but but you can't gaslight me to think were being treated equally all these years
万岁伊朗语族，Salom az qin ba mardumi iran zabon，great persian empire🇮🇷 🇮🇷
Tashakor from a Christian who is learning Dari! 💖💖💖
Please use Western/Southern Pashto for these types of videos. It is much closer to the original Pashto and closer to its Iranian sister languages.
I'm a pashtun salam brothers
It seems that Pashto and Ossetian are most divergent.
They're the only two presented from the Eastern branch of Iranian languages.
They also used the more colloquial accent (eastern accent) for Pashto instead of the more formal western one. The western one shares more sounds with the other Iranian languages (notably the "zh" and soft "sh").
@@ZeeZee9 the sound (ts) and (dz) which are available in pashto and ossetian are also available in central kurdish . but people aren't aware of their existence and they think these two sounds are same as (tʃ) (dʒ) in english and arabic and other languages
@@7mad211 nice. What sounds are the second two that you wrote? I never saw that before.
Persian is a common tongue and literary language, not necessarily just another ethnic vernacular as your map is showing. As such it covers a far greater area.
Thanks for featuring my language. Love from an Azeri 💜 , BTW why you mentioned us as Tat instead of Azeri cause we have low numbers now , Still we are stuck to our actual language and Azeri is our Original and rightful name.
Azəri ilk dəfə şərh bölməsində görürəm
Yep
the Pahlavi Azari language would be something close to Tati and Kurdish
although there are a few sources from this language
Persians should all unite like the good old days
درود و سپاس فراوان 🙏🌹تاتی چه نوع زبان و یا گویشی است و در کجا صحبت می‌شود؟ با سپاس فراوان از شما🙏🌹
Hi Andy. Thank you for this wonderful video. I am Kurdish, from Kurdistan. The Kurdish language has many dialects (Kurmanji, Zazaki, Sorani, Lurian, Hormani and Lak I think). You spoke the Kurmanji dialect from North Kurdistan (Turkey). I also speak Kurmanji and I am from West Kurdistan (Rojava) (Syria) .The regimes of the countries that occupy Kurdistan have separated the Kurdish people, especially in Iran, so every geographical region of Kurdistan has become an independent people from the Kurds. Greetings to you from Kurdistan 🌺🌸🌺🌸 ❤🌞💚
They arenot dialects and they are seperate languages . they donot understand each other between lets say sorani,zaza and kirmanchi. All are seperate ethnic groups. All these people named kirmanchi and sorani are not natives of syria,iraq and Türkiye, they are nomads of Zagros mountains. and migrated during times. We will deter anyone naming our soil with another name. This is only social media sickness.
@@ayhankaracaoglu6845 you migrated from central Asia
My Grandfather in my mother's side is also Kurmanji Kurd in North Khorasan Iran
Very intresting
@Angel Gomez simp alert???????
@Angel Gomez thank u and y
Salom az Tojikiston 🇹🇯❤️
Slaw ez li kurdistanême 🟥☀️🟩
It's funny considering all Iranic languages sounding and having a alot of cognates with each other except Ossetian and Baluchi being way different than other Iranic languages
Pashto sounds different from the others
Love to all Iranian speakers from a Persian speaker. Salam va dorood be hame shoma❤❤❤
Why didn't you include Pamiri languages and marked the areas in Tajikistan where these languages are spoken as Persian?
No
they speak their own languages
which are Easter Iranic languages
this map doesn't include many details
@@erfan3857 I know that they speak their own languages that's why I asked why it's marked as Persian on the map when Pamiri languages are Eastern Iranian
Pamiri is marked. Have a closer look
@@shamm1053 They're not? 00:36 marked as Persian. In the beginning it has a different color yes but she didn't mention them in the list
Masham yst Pomeriyen .✊🌄
1:04 incorrect map. Kurdish Feyli/Laki speaking territories are highlighted as Luri. What is highlighted here as "Kurdish" is almost completely Kurmanji and Sorani. Completely ingoring the other dialects. Zazaki is not a unified language name also. It is only one branch of the wider Zazaki-Kirmancki branch. I for example speak the Dimli accent of the Zazaki-Kirmancki branch. And we are also Kurds. Whoever made that map has a chauvinistic bias.
Farsi,Dari,Tajiki are same language
Brother’s iran don’t mean only the people of iran and only Iranian people
Iran mean land of aryan so when you are one of Iranian like me Kurd this you’re country too like Turkish country turkey Anatolian Turks Uzbekistan Uzbek turk Turkmenistan turkman turk
Iran is a free country, it does not mean that all the residents of Iran are of Iranian descent, or if someone is not Iranian, he is not from Iran and is an immigrant no we have Iranian Turk iranian Arabs Iranian African Iranian Nativ Armans and Georgians so they are all Iranian and in the history of Iran, we had Turkish dynasties that are related to the Turks of Iran like Seljuk are Iranian Turk not turkey Turks
LONG LİVE KURDİSH LANGUAGE ❤☀💚
Persian and Dari are the same 100 💯 percent . Dari and tajiki are dialects of Persian language like Isfahani and yazdi dialect .
Ossetian, the least Iranian member, and moreover, due to "æ" letter, it approaches more to Danish/Norwegian.
the krudish you use is the kurmanji dialect. There is also sorani dialect which more similar to Iranian (farsi).
im half tabari half gilak and sorani Kurdish is way closer to our languages than persian !
Я цыган, и эти языки так похоже на мой родной язык, числа почти как у нас все ек 1 дуй 2 трин 3 штар 4 панщь 5 шов 6 эвта 7 ухто 8 инья 9 дешь 10 , Привет всем, индия 🇮🇳, Иран 🇮🇷 Таджикистан 🇭🇺, Курдистан ❤🤍💚, осетия 🤍❤💛 , Gypsy 💙❤💚 I love you , brothers🦁, 🤝🙏...
🎉 🌹❤️ I’m Kurdish hi
@@Kurdnetew Hello 🖐. 🤝
Gypsy from where?
цыганы не народы персии,. они народы индии. Возможно ваши языеи похожи потому что индией многие века правили персидские завреватели.
@@lambert801 I'm from Russia 🇷🇺
Selam from Palestine to the freedom fighters of Afghanistan
Based comment
@@rafayadnanhamid8795 the safest thing to do is to follow the afghan heroes steps till we meet allah
We are being killed since over 100 years and no one even cares about what is happening to us, we only have one path, fight until victory or die with dignity, just like Afghanies did, they are our idol and they will always be
@@odayb.y4457 ❤
Be the voices of us Iranians!
Don't forget that there are some other Iranian languages like Lurish Mazandarani Gilaki
Those are all varieties of Persian. Luri for example is the closest living language to Middle Persian Pahlavi along with basseri and bakhtiari.
When we talk about kurdish , we are talking about lurish too .
Two brothers that were oneday a part of each other but now they are a little far from each other .
Bji Kurd o Lur .
@@abubakr-lur lurs are Persian and speak a Persian dialect, not Kurdish. Kurds cannot understand us.
@@abubakr-lur i don't wanna make you feel bad about your Kurdistan but when we are talking about Kurdish, Kurdish is bunch of Iranian dialects they are completely different Gorani is different language Kurmamji is a different language and Zazaki is also different Caspian language....
If you think with this kinda nonsense you will have access to the Persian gulf you are dreaming...
Kurdistan is a landlock state
Lurs have nothing to do with kurds
if you gunna call them kurds
i also consider all of Kurdish people as Persian...
You are so rude
You don't understand mutual respect
i think Turkey put too much pressure on you guys
So do your own business dreaming about Kurdistan in social media
because its all you can do 😂
@@abubakr-lur Also Abu baker i don't even like your stupid Arabic name
be more respectful
فارسی تاجیکی بسیار بسیار زیبا و دلنشینه❤
ZAZAKİ is my language. ❤❤😊😊
Persian, Dari and Tajik are all the same language : The Persian language.
Dari and Tajik are different dialects than the Iranian Persian. Like American, Australian English......
Love Persian💖
(Excluding the Arabic words)
Only pure aryan words are love🧡
yeah Zendabad Iran , Zendabad Aryani Zib
@@h2eroskoryosaryakaraaryani777
Definitely, Let's revive our badass Old Persian again.
The Language much more older, richer and cooler than Arabic.
Why disrespect the arabs?
@@amulya_asmi It can't go back. people just speak the Persian language with Arabic words. Afghanistan is more traditional in their language.
Fellas, let’s not start up World War 500 Googol here
What a beautiful map
HER BİJİ ZİMANE KURDİ ❤☀💚
Can somebody Refer me good sites for Dari Farsi Or books? Wanna learn it badly
Zazaki is also Kurdish! (The map shows it as a different language)
Love to all Iranian people's from a Kurd!
I understood most of Persian.
they call themself Dimili (deylami) tho
Zazaki is a different language. not Kurdish.
@@uurrcann Zazaki is a Kurdish language , Kurdish itself is not a single language but 6 Closely related Languages including 1)Zaza , 2)Gorani and Kurdish proper 3)Kurmanji, 4)Sorani, 5)Xwarin and 6)Laki.
@@user-ek1bm2jo3p some of them do, not all of them. and if the term "dimli" derived from "deylami" is also another topic
@@uurrcann Zazaki is a Kurdish dialect like Kurmanji or Sorani,there is Zazas who think they're language is not Kurdish but the ones who says that don't even know their own language,they are assimilated! Those ones after some generations would even forget that they are Kurds or Zazas but they would call themselves Turks! I met some Zazas who knows Zazaki and they say that they are Kurds! Zazaki is not a different language,the Kurds who talk Kurmanji can understan 80% of it.
Where's Luri at?
My language Pashto ❤❤❤❤❤
I really would like to know who is the person behind Andy.
Her voice is adorable!
Parsian=Tajik=Dari
Not exactly but you're close
@@Abe-my9wb nope, they’re the exact same language just different accents and dialects
@@persianguy1524 Persian is the language. Dari and Tajik are both dialects. The original post states that Dari and Tajik are the same even though there is a linguistic distinction
@@Abe-my9wb a dialect is the same as that language, just a different variation, not a different language. Tajik and Dari are Persian and in fact probably closer to original Persian than Iranian Persian.
@@persianguy1524 I know what a dialect is, thank you for the lesson. Dari and Tajik are dialects but are very different than Iranian Persian to the point where speakers sometimes don't understand each other. You're correct though since Dari has preserved more archaicisms than Iranian Persian.
Didn't I just learn the lords prayer in farsi?
Thank you i shall practice praying
I thought Ossetian was Slavic based, not an Iranian language. Interesting.
we descends from ancient Alans Scythians
@@igorjee Jaszes along with their delegation even visited Ossetia a few times,nice people with interesting mix of cultures.Hail to Hungary!
As Russian I don't understand anything in Ossetian
yes, more similarity with Pashto, Yaghnobi, Pamir languages
Ossythians existed thousands of years before Russian and ukrainian Aryan speakers, ossythians speak much closer to the original Aryan language like iranic people.
Also English speakers don't understand the attributes of the world they use, like mother: in Persian madar: ma: us/ dar: door or us coming out of.
Balcony= Persian balakon=bala=up / kon= house= house that's up like balcony of apartments or the Balkan region of Europe..
Paradise=Persian pardis/ ferdoos in arabic but Persian orgin.
Devil= dev Persian orgin.
God= persian khoda= khod=self which have spiritual meaning of spirit in us coming from god.
There are many many iranic and English similar Word's that's iranic people would understand it attributes and meaning and English speakers wouldn't.
Persian is a beautiful language 😍
.Where Is the Hazara Part !!??
Where is larestani?
0:10 you forgot to add the (ye) at the end of the name . it is just like (is) in english without it the sentence would have no meaning
For some reason numbers in Pashto are way more similar to Croatian than the others.
Croatian people is aryeni people.i mean İran'ı and croatian language is same
.Where Is the Hazara Part ???
Most of these dialects are descended of middle Persian
Wow, Ossetian is so different from the rest of them...
which one was ossetian she just skiped that part to english i think
@@cheber5690 No, the Ossetian is the text in blue
@@nostalgiakarlk.f.7386 yes ik but she don't spell it
Salomolekum uzum Pomere mash mis ikme mardum darunand boyd viyam marineset az Pomir num mis hobo .💪🌄✊
We also use numbers in dari like tot language for example we use to 10 (dah and dahta)
TAJIK🇹🇯👑 FARS👑🇹🇯🦅🦁
Good video 👍
Kurdish is a gendered and ergative language, it is different from other iranic languages
All Iranian languages were gendered and ergative in past
@@erfan3857 lie
@@Kamekasee Old Persian and old Median language were so close to each other even some experts consider them as Arya language
during Achaemenid empire to
early expansions of Sasanian empire Persian was a gendered language then they gradually became different from each other
Kurdish is absolutely different made language , it isnt iranic .
Your sentence is false .
@@abubakr-lur yes, Kurds are descendants of the ancient Zagro-Torosian people. They were speak an isolate language. But after the iranic migrations Kurds started speak an Zagro-Iranic language. Even the modern Kurdish is different from other Iranic languages really. Iranians want asimilate us Kurds.
WE - ARE - NOT - IRANIC
Talışca da qoyardımız da? Why there not talishi?. They also irani
Can someone please explain why Ossetian sounds so distinct? Is it because they were Christians and, thus, stayed out of Persian-Muslim cultural sphere which was the dominant socio-cultural paradigm in most of the Western and Central Asia? Thanks in advance!
Being part of Russia/USSR means they speak with a Russian accent maybe.
Pashto also sounds distinct. That is due to influence from its indic neighbors. I imagine the same happened to Ossetian. The influence of its neighbors languages affected it in certain ways. Religion doesn't affect phonology though.
Osetçenin diğer dillerden farklı olmasının sebebi Peştunca ve Osetçenin doğu İrani dillerden kalanların ise batı İrani dillerden olması.Doğu İrani dillerle batı İrani diller çok erken tarihlerde birbirlerinden ayrışmaya başladılar.Bu dillerin Doğu ve Batı olarak sınıflandırılmasının kökeninde hem coğrafya hem de fonetik farklılık kıstas alınmış. Osetçe diğer İrani dillerin aksine etrafında İrani dil konuşulmuyor yani Osetçe konuşulan coğrafya Kafkas halklarının ortası dolayısıyla diğer İrani dillerle bir etkileşimi uzun zamandır yok ve daima Kafkas dilleriyle bir etkileşimi söz konusu bunun sonucunda da kelime dağarcığında ciddi bir Kafkas dilleri borç kelimeleri var. Farklılığın diğer sebebi de doğu İrani diller ile Batı irani diller arasındaki ses denklikleri.
Videoyu detaylı incelemedim ama ilk 1 dakikasında 2 tane ses denkliğine rastladım.
Bu ses denkliği ise h-s ses denkliği,p-f ses denkliği ve Peştuncada görülen "d-l" ses denkliği.
Toparlayacaksak
S=H
P=F
D=L
Bu ses denklikleri sözcüklerde şöyle bir değişime sebep olmuş.
Proto iranca : Dasa (on/10) sayısı
Osetçede : Dæs kalmış ancak
D-H ses denkliğinden batı İrani dillerinin çoğunda "Deh" şekline dönüşmüş.
Proto iranca Dasa sayısı ise d-l ses denkliğinden Peştuncada "Les" olmuş.
Osetçedeki diğer bir fonetik farklılık ise P seslerinin F ye dönüşmüş olması.
Örneğin
Partça : Pīt "baba"
Beluçça : Pet "baba"
Osetçede P-F ses denkliğinden "Fyd(fîd) : Baba
Aynı şekilde 5 sayısında da bu ses denkliği var.
Farsça : Panc "5"
Kürtçe : Pênc "5"
Osetçe : Fondz "5"
Just different cultures around through the whole history,from Goths to Caucasians and others
@@ansnshshbsbsh9113 Çok teşekkürler!
This is kurdish kurmanji and kurdish sorani is more similar to Persian language..
Didn’t know Afghans speak Persian & Kurdish being part the Iranian languages. Cool
actually Persian is the official language of Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan. Kurdish language has a lot of similarities with Persian and other Iranic languages, im myself Kurd from Iran and i know both kurdish and Persian and i can realize this relationship very well...
@@Образованиесила what? pashtu is not an Iranic language? u saw it in the video😂 linguistics put pashtu in Iranian languages family
@@Образованиесила Pashto is an iranic language, with an iranian grammer flex, vocabulary and origin. stop with your lies and media propaganda. Pashto is the largest language in Afghanistan. Persian is the largest SECOND-ethno-lingual language in Afghanistan. Everyone can speak Persian in afghanistan as it is a lingua franca (afghan-international language). Pashto is STILL however and will ALWAYS be the largest language in Afghanistan. it is an IRANIAN language.
@@thelegendaryboy4939 You are mistaken that everyone speaks Persian in Afghanistan, majority of people of the Eastern and Southern Provinces of Afghanistan border with Pakistan only speak Pashto they don't even know Persian.
Persian is one of the two official languages of Afghanistan
Very fascinating. The Balochi that was in the video must’ve been a Pakistani Baloch. You can hear the Indo-Aryan influence in her pronounciation if I’m not mistaken.
@ꫝarry K Of course they do because they all belong to the Indo-Iranian branch. Hindi-Urdu of course being Indo-Aryan. Balochi and Pashto being both Eastern-Iranic languages that all go back to a Proto-Indo-Iranian language.
@ꫝarry K I believe Nuristani and Dardic languages are both isolates in the Indo-Iranian branch. They don’t seem to be connected to Indo-Aryan languages at all if I’m not mistaken. They do have Indo-Aryan influences seeing that they’re surrounded by Indo-Aryan languages like Hindko and Urdu-Hindi etc.
@ꫝarry K Pashto has nothing to do with hindi punjabi urdu or anything dardic at all. The words they share are persian loan words that india got during mughal rule.
Love from gwader balochistan
Ossetian is the most beautiful ❤️
Salam to all great iranian sisters and brothers ❤
Why is Not zaza here ?
Her biji Kurdistan ✌️
Where is Wakhani and Sarykoli dialect?
What about pamiri languages
Dari and Tajiki are not languages, they are a dialect of Persian☝🏻☝🏻
Balochi almost sounds like Hindi!
If people like to know...
Iranic languages classified as
Caspian languages: Talyshi Gilaki Mazani Zazaki
Eastern Iranian languages: Pashto (Shoghdi) (Khowarazmi)
western Iranian languages: Kurdish and all of its accents , Lurish and all of its accents , Persian, Balochi, (Azari Pahlavi)
@ꫝarry K like I said......it only SOUNDS like hindi. I didn't say it is understandable by hindi speakers like myself.
Greetings from Erbil, the capital of the Kurdistan Region، There are several different dialects in Kurdish such as Sorani, krmanji, zazaki, Hawrami and Gorani, hat video it is the term Krmanji,
Yes that was kurmanci.i am kurmanc
@@muratsariboga8745 and i am sorani ,silav ji te re silav Li hemû Kurdên Bakur❤️💛💚
KURDİ ✌🏿🟥☀️🟩☝🏿
kurdi=pers
Pashto in its family photo:
🟧🟧🟧🟧🟧🔶🟧
😂
Because they used the eastern accent, listen to the western accent (spoken in Kandahar or Quetta). It sounds much closer to the other Iranian languages.
Also I never noticed how divergent Pashto is with the others
@@sharjeel.k126 Pashtuns are genetically indic
@@sharjeel.k126 Pashtuns have nothing to do with iranic people, they are genetically Punjabi.
@@sharjeel.k126 tajiks didn't wipe out any languages, all Languages are still spoken there
@@shamm1053 New profile for racist comments?
Part of it is because they used the eastern/northern accent, which is not the original Pashto accent! The western accent (spoken in places like Kandahar) sound much more similar to the other Iranian languages. I think Eastern Pashto came from slang, to be honest. Too lazy to pronounce "sh" and "zh." I really don't like the accent. Super confusing to understand, too, because they removed two distinct sounds.
Where Is the Hazara Part ????
the language of hazara is Persian we proud of them 👏 ❤
Gilaki, Sangsari, and many more languages in Iran.
Was ist mit luri?
Persian and Dari is the same languages
در خراسان خیلی از روستاها و شهرهای تات زبان داریم . من خودم هم تات هستم . یا ما تات نیستیم یا این زبون تاتی شما خارجیه
there's 2 type of tat i heard ! one closer to Persian another closer to north iranic languages
Zazakî is a part of the Kurdish language.