Realistic Dinosaurs or Fake Ones? | Comparing Accuracy | The Isle Evrima Part 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 50

  • @unapeppina4824
    @unapeppina4824 2 місяці тому +13

    Troodon is loosely based off known troodontids although much of it's design is fictionalized and is much closer to that of a dromaeosaur than a troodontid.

  • @StelloTyrannus
    @StelloTyrannus 2 місяці тому +7

    Worth noting that O. C. Marsh didn’t “discover” most of the species that he named. That was usually done by the many people he employed, rich dude

  • @M00cat
    @M00cat 2 місяці тому +5

    I like most of the isles fictional spins on the dinosaurs

  • @JorgePerez-yg4so
    @JorgePerez-yg4so 2 місяці тому +7

    It would be cool if we had the ability to make them look accurate now I’m not gonna say it’s bad bc this is essentially a game based off jp and you gotta give each Dino a mechanic to make them unique otherwise then no one will really play them

    • @Mood_Be_Smooth4903
      @Mood_Be_Smooth4903 2 місяці тому

      When that one Dondi stream showed off the Rex roar and it sounds a lot like the inaccurate Jurassic park Rex roar: 😢
      But Rex is fun and cool

    • @JorgePerez-yg4so
      @JorgePerez-yg4so 2 місяці тому

      @@Mood_Be_Smooth4903 they said it’s gonna have another more accurate roar but if I remember irl Rex didn’t roar it and I know this sounds weird but it essentially very creepily laughed and spino also made like siren noises there’s vids online on how they may have sounded

  • @JorgePerez-yg4so
    @JorgePerez-yg4so 2 місяці тому +2

    I just got the isle today I’ve played around 3 hours of it I keep on dying but it’s fun my only problem so far is the ping and lag and bad performance and how annoying is to get into a server

  • @dojo45789
    @dojo45789 2 місяці тому

    It always confused me that they didnt let ptera take off from the water, not only since it could irl but itd make for a much more entertaining and less one sided interraction between crocs and ptera in the water. Would also let pteras be more interactive besides just flyby pecking things if it could quickly go into and out of the water. Its part of what makes thal fun in path even tho thal I think probably couldnt take off from water or dive? I would love that aspect but with the isles flying mechanics

  • @MastaBaitaAmbatukam
    @MastaBaitaAmbatukam 2 місяці тому +1

    They should've made their own name to use for beipiaosaurus. Since it isn't accurate anyway. Like how they made the name of omniraptor

    • @thetinyrexy4798
      @thetinyrexy4798 2 місяці тому

      Omni got named omni cause they want to make actual utah but people dont want they to remove omni so that's why it got renamed, what the problem getting a genetic modified dinosaur looking different then the original one?

    • @MastaBaitaAmbatukam
      @MastaBaitaAmbatukam 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thetinyrexy4798 It doesn't need to have the same name. Especially if the name isn't even a good one. Like beipiaosaurus

    • @thetinyrexy4798
      @thetinyrexy4798 2 місяці тому

      @@MastaBaitaAmbatukam why shouldn't it? They make beipi be a semi aquatic so it actually playable and can survive is the island, minmi gonna be a semi aquatic so it can actually survive the island, why can't it be called beipi and minmi? you mad cause devs didn't make em like the original dinosaur in order to make those dinosaur survive in the island? If they didn't plan to make a new whole utah, omni would still be called utah by now

    • @MastaBaitaAmbatukam
      @MastaBaitaAmbatukam 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thetinyrexy4798 I didn't say it shouldn't have the same name, I'm saying it doesn't need to. And the name beipiaosaurus isn't even a good name anyways

    • @thetinyrexy4798
      @thetinyrexy4798 2 місяці тому

      @@MastaBaitaAmbatukam it NEED to, like dude they literally just make a better version of beipi to survive in the island nothing else, what should they called it? Duckosaurus? why would even make another pointless name when you can just use beipi as their name that not make anyone confused "what the heck is this dinosaur"?

  • @TheDarkPanther0
    @TheDarkPanther0 2 місяці тому +2

    Troodon is a waste taxon meaning it doesn't exist

  • @oOPawsOo
    @oOPawsOo 2 місяці тому

    Since the isle is in our timeline, and all the dinos are constructed in a lab, I'd say that having non accurate dinos walking around is very plausible, and being placed on the island makes million of years of evolution obsolete. Much like JP. 😀

  • @patrox2529
    @patrox2529 2 місяці тому

    Actually some small ornithopods had feathers, for example kulindadromeus or leallynasaura

  • @NicolasFadrny
    @NicolasFadrny 2 місяці тому +1

    Love ya!

    • @mrbeardmTV
      @mrbeardmTV  2 місяці тому +1

      @@NicolasFadrny Appreciate it

  • @saitama_9279
    @saitama_9279 2 місяці тому +2

    realistic is way cooler imo. i think they are scarier

    • @rexmexzilla
      @rexmexzilla 2 місяці тому +1

      Depends a lot the context, its not a dino simulator its a game.

    • @rexmexzilla
      @rexmexzilla 2 місяці тому +1

      Depends a lot the context, its not a dino simulator its a game.

  • @Tuesdayz
    @Tuesdayz 2 місяці тому +6

    they're all genetically modified animals same as in Jurassic Park, i never really understood why ppl endlessly debate the paleo accuracy of stuff like this 😂

    • @mrbeardmTV
      @mrbeardmTV  2 місяці тому +7

      @@Tuesdayz didn’t make the video to debate them, just made the video to compare the isle’s dinos with their real life ones, just for fun :)

    • @TheDinoNerd
      @TheDinoNerd 2 місяці тому +4

      Because it matters. If they were all fictional species it wouldn't. Omniraptor doesn't matter, because it's made up. But by calling the playables a certain genus or species, it assigns expectations. Look at Troodon. It's invalid, but due to it bearing the name of "Troodon" it is expected to resemble a troodontid. For it to be Troodon, it needs to BE Troodon, not a random creature the devs decided to call Troodon. A plucked chicken is not a red-tailed hawk. Creative liberties are fine, but to call it something it barely resembles invites criticism.

    • @shaxo5364
      @shaxo5364 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@TheDinoNerd sorry to say this, but the majority of people who play these type of games don't really care about it
      It's not like this is the first time something like this has happened, I mean we literally have jurassic park as an example
      Few people can stay butt hurt about it if they want, but the game was never meant to be a documentary or educational, this isn't Saurian
      Anybody can use anything and call it anything if they want
      If a game was made about dinosaurs killing each other, and they used real names and made them look fictional, than they can do it
      You can hate it all you want, nothing would change and that's that.

    • @MastaBaitaAmbatukam
      @MastaBaitaAmbatukam 2 місяці тому +1

      because the animals have the same names as real animals, instead of their own name

    • @Tuesdayz
      @Tuesdayz 2 місяці тому

      ​@@TheDinoNerd I mean, it looks about the same as any other depiction of Troodon without feathers. In terms of them behaving and feeling like real animals, The Isle is far ahead of comparible games, something I don't think they get enough credit for, deino is a perfect example and has beautiful attention to detail in all of it's animations.

  • @dev4159
    @dev4159 2 місяці тому +1

    the dinosaurs that are supposed to have feathers don't, but the ones that aren't do lmao

    • @TheLegendaryOutdoors
      @TheLegendaryOutdoors 2 місяці тому

      not many dinos that are in evrima had feathers.

    • @dev4159
      @dev4159 2 місяці тому

      @@TheLegendaryOutdoors and ? there still are some that do, and i know the exceptions exist too.

    • @TheLegendaryOutdoors
      @TheLegendaryOutdoors 2 місяці тому

      @@dev4159 wait, do you play on islander semi realism? And did you have a calico looking dibble a couple days ago?

  • @granddooku
    @granddooku 2 місяці тому

    pteranodon is 50 kg irl. it has a wing span of 6 meters

  • @stephanwagner6189
    @stephanwagner6189 2 місяці тому +1

    I hate Omni players, no matter how many corpses are around, they still kill my fresh spawn Cera just because they can. It should not be able to spawn in South plains imo

    • @BlapwardKrunkle
      @BlapwardKrunkle 2 місяці тому

      Skill issue. My rec is stay out of high pop areas as a cera until ur big enough to fight off a pack, then it’s fun when they fight u cuz u actually have a chance!

  • @drterraminator2651
    @drterraminator2651 2 місяці тому +1

    You forgot to mention that the real baip is not an adult specimen..

  • @OrcaIslands
    @OrcaIslands 2 місяці тому +1

    Height: Very Small

  • @PasqualeBilancia
    @PasqualeBilancia 2 місяці тому

    Tbh if the isle evrima had accurate animals it will be like legacy, one animal is OP one is weak.

  • @vitvidstreamer2702
    @vitvidstreamer2702 2 місяці тому

    Nice

  • @jonathanchan63
    @jonathanchan63 2 місяці тому

    The isle has a quite few that are very close to their real life counterparts but then some just compete works of fiction or just jp clones
    , personally for me this creates a disconnect when it comes to the artstyle.

  • @SelfproclaimedLizardWizard
    @SelfproclaimedLizardWizard 2 місяці тому

    We found a bunch of bones in the dirt. That’s pretty much all we know about them

  • @elpanamonstruo4757
    @elpanamonstruo4757 2 місяці тому

    a

    • @mrbeardmTV
      @mrbeardmTV  2 місяці тому +2

      @@elpanamonstruo4757 b