John, would you please, please, please begin each of your programs saying "Today is [date]"? I find podcasts that you made months or years ago continuing to pop up in my YouTude algorithms. I have to make an effort to figure out what is going on NOW!
23:12 I think it’s more about the laity being able to express their concerns about where failures occurred and the clergy, after devastating the church, being humble enough to listen - Pope Francis delivered a wonderful example
100% Agree. I have totally tuned off what comes from Rome, other than pray for the Pope. I stay focused on my local parish, very solid parish that very reverently celebrates the 1970 Roman Missal. I have voiced my displeasure with Pope Francis Papacy by not donating one penny to the annual Peters Pence collection sent to the Pope. The last time I donated, Pope Benedict XVI was Pope. And before the mods get upset, I do not hold to any sedevacantist position, Pope Francis is 100% the Pope, but I don't have to agree it is a good Papacy. Cheers and God Bless
@@nathandg0924 No, I have my views that are not yours. And that is Ok. In fact, Theologically, Pope Francis papacy to me Has in fact only shown that Christ promise in MT 16:18 still is true and He (Christ) is guiding the Catholic Church the same way He did during the time of Pope Honorious, Pope John XXII and the Great Western Schism before the Council of Constance (1414-1418) when there were 3 Papal Claimants.
I was educated by the Dominicans. The two Dominicans Francis has elevated are theologically heterodox to be kind. I don't know the rest but if they are as bad as those two........ Francis has never elevated an Ugandan. Apparently Uganda, one of the biggest Catholic populated countries, isn't peripheral enough for Francis. Pope Francis' 'peripheral' isn't particularly geographical apparently.
@@briandelaney9710The penalty is not as broad as it has been made out in western corporate media. It is not like they are hunting down male interior decorators and ballet dancers. The death penalty is for “aggravated homosexuality” and the text of the law on the Ugandan Parliament website defines this an act against a minor, a disabled person, an unconcious person, a person under the influence, against the mentally ill, infecting another with HIV, acts with genetically related persons, etc. The death penalty for any or most of these offenses were on the books in many western countries earlier in the 20th century.
@@briandelaney9710 The Anti-homosexuality Act of 2023 calls for the death penalty for “aggravated homosexuality” which involves cases of same-sex relations involving people who are HIV positive, children and other vulnerable people. We need more of the same across the western world.
A candidate must me a intellectual heavy weight, holy and capable before chosen to be cardinal. Maybe not this period. Maybe in the next consistory. There is already an African Bishop elevated, just wait for the go signal of the Holy Spirit.
Is the role of cardinal still relevant? It seems to encourage unhealthy ambition within the clergy-climbing the greasy pole. And let’s not forget, red or purple robes were banned in the early Church! As for saying no to women deacons, it’s curious how the examples given of prominent women in the Church all appear after Constantine. What about before then? Political labels like liberal or conservative feel out of place in a spiritual community. On St John Henry Newman’s feast day, it's worth remembering how he was seen as too conservative by some Anglicans, yet too liberal by some Catholics later on. Let's follow his example of wisdom and courage!
You use the type of tone with the pope you might with a president of a nation or an earthly king. The pope holds the keys to the kingdom of God. You don't want to be a gnat in God's eye but an obedient and fruitful servant. Synnods have always been one way the Church has had its conversations. As for female deacons, the infallible Bible has already spoken on that.
The pope should have the guts to recreate lay-cardinals based on ordination in the minor orders. He already allowed women to be ordinated in minor orders so he could create female cardinals.
I am surprised that he did not mention soon-to-be Cardinal Pablo Virgilio David, well known for his pro-poor advocacies and even visiting shanty towns.
17:20 the key word here is "ordained." I think the question is whether deaconesses would be established/restored as an Installed ministry à la Lectors, Acolytes (cf. Spiritus Domini), and Catechists (cf. Antiquum Mysterium).
@@TheGariego Well, I'm not clear on what you are arguing. I'm talking about Installed Ministries, not mere "appointment." Seminarians, since the suppression of the Minor Orders, have been required to be admitted to the Installed Ministries of Lector and Acolyte (canon 1035). What Pope Francis changed in 2011 in Spiritus Domini is that one does not need to a) be in seminary formation or even b) be a man to be eligible for those ministries. And, indeed, some dioceses have started admitting women to those Installed Ministries.
@fr.billfox2961 I was simply saying I don't know of any parish that installs lectors or acolyte. Your average parish just gives some training, and sometimes not, and that's it.
@@TheGariego well, the types of Installed Ministers I am writing about are not typically installed by priests but by bishops. Since it's a sacramental, not a Sacrament, I imagine that it would be easy to delegate a priest to install those ministries. In Spiritus Domini, the Holy Father expanded the Installed Ministries of Lector and Acolyte, but did not give much guidance about implementation. I reckon it'll take 10 years or so to work that out.
Someday that Belgian prime minister will discover that Christ is King over this whole world, even little Belgium, and that he (the PM) had been working for the Usurper who, along, with other unrepentant rebels, will be sentenced to hell. Pope Francis should be gentle but firm with such fools because he’d be doing them a favor to open their eyes to reality.
@@briandelaney9710 I made no final judgement, only the valid warning on which God will at least in part base His final judgment in the absence of repentance. The PM still has time to repent but his public arrogance will be an obstacle to humble recognition of his grievous error.
The Pope made a big mistake by going to a Kings tomb in Belgium thus entering into politics. He opened a door that created decent in a secular society.
Private citizen initiate abortions and private citizens carry them out, not the State. Jesus asked to teach and to turn away if the teaching is not accepted. He did not say to legislate/penalize. Inquisition was efficient vat that.
On the question of Israel, that is my wheelhouse. That is my area of expertise. I want to make the comment, that everything you said, and the perspective you took to arrive at those conclusions are all wrong. You in fact have the Israeli perspective. That is a no no. Please pay attention to the military perspective. In regards to a two state solution; that is literally an impossibility; and that is the reason it was promoted by the US. The US is Israel and Israel is the US, there is no daylight between them. What should have occurred, is a hearing at the International Court. That is the reason it was created to settle these disputes. The reason why it wasn't used, is because Israel would have lost. So they advertise "peace" talks, when what is needed is "justice" talks. Now that opportunity is past. It will be settled militarily.
Yours is an insane take. And on the first anniversary of sheer unadulterated savagery never witnessed on video ever before. 1200 mostly innocents including babies and 250 kidnapped. Ur a very sick puppy.
Synod waste of time just like the last one - the resources of the church could have been better used to serve the poor rather flying these yahoos to Vatican
Does Jesus Christ, the Eternal High Priest, approve all these appointments? Lord Jesus Christ have mercy on Your Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church 🙏🏼✝️⛪️
He was probably referring to the context of a homily at mass, not as a general rule. Even today, no one, man or woman, is supposed to give the homily unless ordained priest or deacon.
Better to have married priests as in the examples of the various eastern catholic rites than be heretical with ordained females. Female Catholics who insist of the impossible should be shown the door. They do nothing but erode the Church.
That was 2000 years ago. Since then many things have changed. The church is a living organization. By its own understanding the catholic church evolves by the influence of god. So, it is up to us, living now to manage helpimg people to find their way to god. That may well include actions that would not have been appropriate 2000 years ago, but are necessary now.
1) As a Ukrainian-Rite Catholic, I am thrilled that Pope Francis will elevate Bishop Mykola Bychock of the Ukrainian Rite Diocese in Melbourne as a cardinal. The elevation is interesting in a couple of different ways. The bishop will be Australia's only cardinal, so technically he will outrank his fellow his bishops in Australia, His diocese is suffragan to the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne. Also, by naming Bishop Bychock a cardinal, the pope bypassed Sviatoslav Shevchuk, the major archbishop of Kyiv (Kiev) and primate of the Ukrainian Catholic Church. From what I have gathered, Francis and the archbishop have a rather frosty relationship. Their falling out concerns the pope's efforts to broker a peace between Ukraine and Russia. 2) As an unabashed progressive Catholic, Pope Francis is more liberal than his predecessors. However., a lot of liberal Catholics, such as myself, would like to see Francis move the church further to the left
@@ConanTheLibrarian-n5qYou cannot in the full sense of the word be liberal and at the same time catholic😢. Read Pascendi and the Syllabus Errorum. Liberalism is not catholic.
I remember Sister Concetta. The principal, the principal of the parochial school I went to over 60 years ago. Talk about power in the Church.
Ruler and Commander
@@AnthonySejda when the nuns were involved you better not get out of line.
Catholic schools before they became Marxist were the highest quality
God help the Church
John, would you please, please, please begin each of your programs saying "Today is [date]"? I find podcasts that you made months or years ago continuing to pop up in my YouTude algorithms. I have to make an effort to figure out what is going on NOW!
Belgium used to be a strong Catholic country
until it became ultraliberal
Good for the Pope in this instance
Enjoyed it very much.
23:12 I think it’s more about the laity being able to express their concerns about where failures occurred and the clergy, after devastating the church, being humble enough to listen - Pope Francis delivered a wonderful example
1 Corinthians 2:2 "For I determined not to know any thing among you, except JESUS CHRIST, and HIM crucified."
The Synod is a flop
100% Agree. I have totally tuned off what comes from Rome, other than pray for the Pope. I stay focused on my local parish, very solid parish that very reverently celebrates the 1970 Roman Missal. I have voiced my displeasure with Pope Francis Papacy by not donating one penny to the annual Peters Pence collection sent to the Pope. The last time I donated, Pope Benedict XVI was Pope. And before the mods get upset, I do not hold to any sedevacantist position, Pope Francis is 100% the Pope, but I don't have to agree it is a good Papacy.
Cheers and God Bless
You are just bitter and jealous of the Pope because you know he's attracting millions to the faith but you can't.
Don't justify your views. Reflect on them instead.
@@nathandg0924 No, I have my views that are not yours. And that is Ok. In fact, Theologically, Pope Francis papacy to me Has in fact only shown that Christ promise in MT 16:18 still is true and He (Christ) is guiding the Catholic Church the same way He did during the time of Pope Honorious, Pope John XXII and the Great Western Schism before the Council of Constance (1414-1418) when there were 3 Papal Claimants.
I was educated by the Dominicans.
The two Dominicans Francis has elevated are theologically heterodox to be kind.
I don't know the rest but if they are as bad as those two........
Francis has never elevated an Ugandan.
Apparently Uganda, one of the biggest Catholic populated countries, isn't peripheral enough for Francis.
Pope Francis' 'peripheral' isn't particularly geographical apparently.
Maybe there's no one liberal enough in Uganda.
Have the Ugandan bishops ever spoken out about the Death Penalty law for gays ?
@@briandelaney9710The penalty is not as broad as it has been made out in western corporate
media. It is not like they are hunting down male interior decorators and ballet dancers. The death penalty is for “aggravated homosexuality” and the text of the law on the Ugandan Parliament website defines this an act against a minor, a disabled person, an unconcious person, a person under the influence, against the mentally ill, infecting another with HIV, acts with genetically related persons, etc. The death penalty for any or most of these offenses were on the books in many western countries earlier in the 20th century.
@@briandelaney9710 The Anti-homosexuality Act of 2023 calls for the death penalty for “aggravated homosexuality” which involves cases of same-sex relations involving people who are HIV positive, children and other vulnerable people.
We need more of the same across the western world.
A candidate must me a intellectual heavy weight, holy and capable before chosen to be cardinal. Maybe not this period. Maybe in the next consistory. There is already an African Bishop elevated, just wait for the go signal of the Holy Spirit.
Notice how the laicization of Argentina's Principi doesn't get a mention
I'm Indonesian, born and raised. And it looks like that you're wearing a batik shirt?
Hello neighbour! 🇮🇩✝️🇦🇺👋
@@rahawa774 halo rekan sebangsa
Is the role of cardinal still relevant? It seems to encourage unhealthy ambition within the clergy-climbing the greasy pole. And let’s not forget, red or purple robes were banned in the early Church!
As for saying no to women deacons, it’s curious how the examples given of prominent women in the Church all appear after Constantine. What about before then?
Political labels like liberal or conservative feel out of place in a spiritual community. On St John Henry Newman’s feast day, it's worth remembering how he was seen as too conservative by some Anglicans, yet too liberal by some Catholics later on. Let's follow his example of wisdom and courage!
You use the type of tone with the pope you might with a president of a nation or an earthly king. The pope holds the keys to the kingdom of God. You don't want to be a gnat in God's eye but an obedient and fruitful servant. Synnods have always been one way the Church has had its conversations. As for female deacons, the infallible Bible has already spoken on that.
CCR Man!!! LOLOLOL 😂
no comment about Timothy Radcliffe op? No thought about this could indicate conclave soon?
What, Radcliffe gets to vote for 6 months and then ages out.
@@masterspinITthat is the point😮
And once again the well deserving archbishops of major archdioceses around the world such as Sydney and Melbourne have been overlooked. 😓
The people on the Neo-modernist Titanic think the future is looking good for them. Proverbs 19:21.
I or you missed the point. Please clarify your last sentence of the explanation.
I appreciated most of your analysis. Balanced
Peru and Japan are not peripheries. They have always had cardinals.
The pope should have the guts to recreate lay-cardinals based on ordination in the minor orders. He already allowed women to be ordinated in minor orders so he could create female cardinals.
If they were all checked on "the Pontiff's Chair" then it's all good. I know they can't be dumb, nobody's dumb :)
You are horrendously naive or I hope being sarcastic.
Francis is an enemy of the Catholic Faith.
I am surprised that he did not mention soon-to-be Cardinal Pablo Virgilio David, well known for his pro-poor advocacies and even visiting shanty towns.
17:20 the key word here is "ordained." I think the question is whether deaconesses would be established/restored as an Installed ministry à la Lectors, Acolytes (cf. Spiritus Domini), and Catechists (cf. Antiquum Mysterium).
Since they no longer officially appoint lector and readers, etc., that doesn't seem likely.
@@TheGariego Well, I'm not clear on what you are arguing. I'm talking about Installed Ministries, not mere "appointment." Seminarians, since the suppression of the Minor Orders, have been required to be admitted to the Installed Ministries of Lector and Acolyte (canon 1035). What Pope Francis changed in 2011 in Spiritus Domini is that one does not need to a) be in seminary formation or even b) be a man to be eligible for those ministries. And, indeed, some dioceses have started admitting women to those Installed Ministries.
@fr.billfox2961 I was simply saying I don't know of any parish that installs lectors or acolyte. Your average parish just gives some training, and sometimes not, and that's it.
@@TheGariego well, the types of Installed Ministers I am writing about are not typically installed by priests but by bishops. Since it's a sacramental, not a Sacrament, I imagine that it would be easy to delegate a priest to install those ministries. In Spiritus Domini, the Holy Father expanded the Installed Ministries of Lector and Acolyte, but did not give much guidance about implementation. I reckon it'll take 10 years or so to work that out.
Someday that Belgian prime minister will discover that Christ is King over this whole world, even little Belgium, and that he (the PM) had been working for the Usurper who, along, with other unrepentant rebels, will be sentenced to hell. Pope Francis should be gentle but firm with such fools because he’d be doing them a favor to open their eyes to reality.
@@K-Hsueh only God can condemn to Hell. Humans should be very wary of assigning places there lest we end up there
@@briandelaney9710 I made no final judgement, only the valid warning on which God will at least in part base His final judgment in the absence of repentance. The PM still has time to repent but his public arrogance will be an obstacle to humble recognition of his grievous error.
The Pope made a big mistake by going to a Kings tomb in Belgium thus entering into politics. He opened a door that created decent in a secular society.
He did not visit that tomb for political reasons. +
@@wendyfield7708 You obviously do not think that abortion is a political consideration however I beg to disagree.
Still smiling over Cardinal-elect Mikola Bychok...
You blithely describe the assassination of a leader of a sovereign state a victory?
What about the Ukrainian Catholic candidate? No comment?
Why is Archbishop Paul Gallagher not a Cardinal?
Who the hell is Gallagher?
@@fredphilippi8388 I believe he's a British born Vatican diplomat.
Vatican Secretary of State….google him, no need to swear
How is the bishop has the right to promote someone to cardinal ? For example the bishop of Rome.
Friends in the sense that they are gay or at least gay friendly
Private citizen initiate abortions and private citizens carry them out, not the State. Jesus asked to teach and to turn away if the teaching is not accepted. He did not say to legislate/penalize. Inquisition was efficient vat that.
Isn’t exactly that that evry Pope does ?
Twenty-one new "Cardinals" from a renegade "Pope." It's inane.
The question : Is pope F. Catholic?
Deeply
On the question of Israel, that is my wheelhouse. That is my area of expertise. I want to make the comment, that everything you said, and the perspective you took to arrive at those conclusions are all wrong. You in fact have the Israeli perspective. That is a no no. Please pay attention to the military perspective. In regards to a two state solution; that is literally an impossibility; and that is the reason it was promoted by the US. The US is Israel and Israel is the US, there is no daylight between them. What should have occurred, is a hearing at the International Court. That is the reason it was created to settle these disputes. The reason why it wasn't used, is because Israel would have lost. So they advertise "peace" talks, when what is needed is "justice" talks. Now that opportunity is past. It will be settled militarily.
Yours is an insane take.
And on the first anniversary of sheer unadulterated savagery never witnessed on video ever before.
1200 mostly innocents including babies and 250 kidnapped.
Ur a very sick puppy.
@@Jimboken1this conflict did not start 1 year ago😢. A sick ethnonationalist country
@@karlheven8328 Maybe it started when Jesus walked this land?
But he was a Jooo tooooo
@@Jimboken1 Jesus was a jew, the Ashkenazi are "those who say they are jews but are not." Revelation 2:9 and Revelation 3:9.
Synod waste of time just like the last one - the resources of the church could have been better used to serve the poor rather flying these yahoos to Vatican
Does Jesus Christ, the Eternal High Priest, approve all these appointments? Lord Jesus Christ have mercy on Your Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church 🙏🏼✝️⛪️
Antipope
Women should not be heard in the Church--St. Paul
Au contraire -- Minneapolis
He was probably referring to the context of a homily at mass, not as a general rule. Even today, no one, man or woman, is supposed to give the homily unless ordained priest or deacon.
@@TheGariegoBut being ordained and a woman is not even a possibility according to the Scriptures, so why even mention the word woman?
Better to have married priests as in the examples of the various eastern catholic rites than be heretical with ordained females. Female Catholics who insist of the impossible should be shown the door. They do nothing but erode the Church.
That was 2000 years ago. Since then many things have changed. The church is a living organization. By its own understanding the catholic church evolves by the influence of god. So, it is up to us, living now to manage helpimg people to find their way to god. That may well include actions that would not have been appropriate 2000 years ago, but are necessary now.
Modernism is new god in novus ordo
1) As a Ukrainian-Rite Catholic, I am thrilled that Pope Francis will elevate Bishop Mykola Bychock of the Ukrainian Rite Diocese in Melbourne as a cardinal. The elevation is interesting in a couple of different ways. The bishop will be Australia's only cardinal, so technically he will outrank his fellow his bishops in Australia, His diocese is suffragan to the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne. Also, by naming Bishop Bychock a cardinal, the pope bypassed Sviatoslav Shevchuk, the major archbishop of Kyiv (Kiev) and primate of the Ukrainian Catholic Church. From what I have gathered, Francis and the archbishop have a rather frosty relationship. Their falling out concerns the pope's efforts to broker a peace between Ukraine and Russia.
2) As an unabashed progressive Catholic, Pope Francis is more liberal than his predecessors. However., a lot of liberal Catholics, such as myself, would like to see Francis move the church further to the left
Well , Cardinal is a pretty Latin title for a Ukrainian bishop. Maybe Metropolitan would have been better
@@briandelaney9710 touche!
@@ConanTheLibrarian-n5qYou cannot in the full sense of the word be liberal and at the same time catholic😢. Read Pascendi and the Syllabus Errorum. Liberalism is not catholic.