Why I Used to Kill Bonsai Trees | Q&A
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2024
- Before today's Q&A, I want to show you an update on my 26-year-old Trident Maple bonsai, which you all have seen before. It's growing nice foliage now that it is springtime. Thanks for sending in your questions. I hope you find this week's Q&A helpful!
0:00 Introduction
0:16 Update on my Trident Maple
1:30 How to remove Irish moss
2:33 How often should I water bonsai
3:58 How to keep trees alive
5:41 When to cut back a tree
7:23 What to do with dead trees
7:49 Why I developed bonsai shortcuts
8:52 About jins, pruning, and repotting
11:17 How to germinate seeds for bonsai
To stay up to date on my bonsai, which will be available for purchase later this year, please sign up for my emails at bonsaiheirloom.com.
Be a part of my bonsai community! You can also find me here:
- / bonsaiheirloom
- / bonsaiheirloom
- / bonsaiheirloom
Questions about your bonsai? Leave a comment below or you can reach out to me at hello@bonsaiheirloom.com. I'll do my best to help!
#bonsai #plants #gardening #bonsaitree #bonsaitreesforbeginners #plantcare #gardeningtips #questions #howtobonsai #tutorial #howto #tipsforbeginners #bonsaitechniques #mapletree #nurserytrees #tree #seedlings #bonsaiforbeginners #bonsaitreecare #bonsaitreemaking #bonsaigarden #bonsaiheirloom #bonsaiplant #bonsaicollection #miltonchang #entrepreneur #bonsaimaster - Навчання та стиль
I genuinely love your videos. I appreciate the "no bullshit" approach you have to bonsai, combining patience with brutal edits on your trees.
thank you!
Often information is passed on without questioning. The problem is it is like the game of whispering in the next persons ears. After several iterations, You'll have a different messafe!
I love your choice of "Edit"...instead of drstic cut! 🙂
Thank you Dr.Chang.
Please clip like!
I really enjoy your videos. Im 72 years old and just beginning my journey with Bonsais. I have many years growing Neofinetia Orchid Japanese Wind Orchids I’ve purchase a couple of 10 to 15 year Bonsais to use as examples to develop my own and to sharpen my skills. I will concentrate on outdoor trees able to thrive in Central Florida. My last comment is to personally Thank you for sharing your knowledge and experience to the World.
Thanks for all the answers! We learn with every video!
I'm so glad!
I love the patience question. Yes if I only had 1 tree I would go out of my mind but I have so many trees and bushes that I always have something to do. Like always I love your videos.
Thank you Mr.Milton
Fantastic video!
Gladyou like it!
Thank you! Plese click like.
Always a great Q&A.
Thx!😊
I know I'm repeating myself, but I really like your philosophy and it confirms my own approach.
Your approach of not slavishly adhering to tradition and instead going your own way that suits your nature is exactly what I prefer. Because Bonsai is an art that everyone has to discover for themselves. Just as not every painter or sculptor follows the same strict rules, but instead develops their own style and thus becomes unique.
Well said!
And influencer on UA-cam 😊
Agree I would not propagate juniper from seed, but then I had to smile remembering that impatience is antithetical to the essence of bonsai. A few years ago I bought a palm-of-the-hand black pine that had been propagated 35 years earlier from a seed in Japan. Its backstory was important to me. I remember seeing a picture of a crabapple styled by Peter Chan propagated from a seed picked up in a public garden in England. I have noticed that sometimes the older we get we are drawn to collecting seeds from botanic gardens. Enjoyed the Q&A . . . thanks! I too like the chicken litter pellets, except the smell.
And thanks for keeping it simple.. what do you think about the new bonsai Master like Ryan Neil, and the Brad Pitt of Bonsai Bjorn Bjorholm?
spot on to the point. great video
Thanks for your response. I watched your video on watering, it was helpful. Nice trident maple, might look nice in a colored glazed pot
Yeh
Japanese convention!
I have several maple seedling that sprouted😊 I can't wait till real spring.
Thanks for the reply and advice. I've done this many times before too, but my lawn is full of this moss. It looks like it's spreading seed all over the place from there. But I will be much more careful now that I know I have to act quickly.
With all due respect, thank you again.
Thank you for sharing your bonsai philosophy. I’m adopting your techniques especially the soil mixture. As a long time gardener I think the mix you use makes so much sense. I watched your videos all winter, purchased a nursery juniper at half price after Christmas and now trying my best not to kill it.
😊!
Thx!
I appreciate your approach to growing bonsai in a dry climate. Please keep giving us these tips since very little of the US is tropical jungle. As you have mentioned, I also seem to need a potting soil that will retain moisture and fertilizer. I still water at least every other day. I also prefer plastic pots when a tree is developing a heathy mat of roots because more moisture is retained. Keep up the good work.
Thx for the input
Thanks for you videos...keep em up >I learn a lot
May I ask a few question possibly for your next QA? 1) For your outdoor trees, how do you keep the soil from being displaced during rain storms? 2) if you use the moss powder to establish ground cover, will that hold the soil in place during rain storms? Sincerely Bruce
Bonsai pots are usually above the soil line.
If your tree is not on a slope, soil is not washed away but compacted.
Moss can hold soil somewhat if your garden is not on a steep slope. Usually people use grass instead of moss or even juniper on a steep slope.
Love that you always ask for critical feedback. Eternal student :).
Yes, I'm learning from you guys too!
@@bonsaiheirloom I haven't taught anyone anything about bonsai yet! Very new myself, but learning a little every month. My tree is a good teacher!
Thank you very much! Okay! Sounds like cuttings are the way to go! I appreciate the video and perhaps I'll jump on making Gin next some time!😆
Variety of juniper not sure
One viewer says some junipers are poisonous
I can’t verify
@@MiltonChang Oh, Thank you! I'll keep that in-mind for sure! 😁
Thank you
You're welcome!
Please don’t throw away those beautiful pieces of wood, although they didn’t live as a bonsai there’s a huge community of people with aquariums and vivariums who pay good money for pretty pieces of wood to grow plants and moss on in their tanks!! I would love a bonsai tree “growing” out of my fish tank. Beautiful
Good point
Only some trees won’t rot in water
The trees in my yard don't have root ball. It's all taproot, oaks and cedar elms. Oaks are harder to keep alive as a matter of fact I don't have oak yamadori 😅. Thanks for the tip and cutting around slowly.
OOO! thank you! I have asked several times what to do with the moss that wants to cover everything. Now you have shown what needs to be pulled out - Irish moss. And this one is growing in my pots. It is very difficult to exterminate and it blooms and multiplies very quickly. Maybe you have some advice how to destroy this nuisance.
Thanks for the wonderful videos and tips.
What I do is to remove the entire top layer of soil. Over it with new soil...adn be VERY vigilant in ulling out the seedling as I have show in this vcideo. In fact, I have NO more irsh moss problem!
Goodluck!
Can you do more close up on how you prune? I’m doing more quick growing tree so I can bend and shape them rather than through pruning. Thank you for all the useful information 🎉
Sure! If you watch some of my other videos, you can also see me do some up close pruning.
Great love it
Thx!
Thx!
Hi, Milton thank you for all your advices, could you please give an advice on how to make the leaves smaller on maple tree?
Time...leaf size reduces with raminfication...also choose maple trees with small leaves to start. For example Ozakazuki has the most beautiful red fall color, but leaves are huge...so you have to make those into huge bonsai for scale.
Hello my friend, I do enjoy your channel. My question for Q&A is: did you ever get nervous to start trees in the beginning, as in, did you ever have trouble starting to style thinking you would mess up a tree? How do you overcome that hesitation?
Chris
Thanks for this great question. I answered it in my recent Q&A :)
When is a good time for repotting a migo pine and what I need to have in their soil for the mycorrhizae for be able the roots be healthy. Thank you sir
Hey Milton, I love your videos and appreciate you sharing your knowledge. Any experience with pomegranate trees? I plan to grow this sapling in a big pot and air layer until it gets to the thickness I want.
Good idea. Yes, I know a lot about pomegranate. Please view the garden tour last week fore my 100 year old tree. I will do a thorough discussion on pomegranate trees. For now, let the branch grow long, because the tree flowers art the end,..,.Hopefully you get some female flowers, then you cut off the rest and let the fruit form. Have fun!
My idea now is to work a group of trees of the same kind, but of different age, and give a thorough discussion of that sp.
Thank you for another amazing video Mr. Chang!
Have you ever had any success with juniper cuttings in winter? I tried making cuttings with some trimmings from winter pruning but had no luck.
I am sure it is not wise to do so in freezing seasons
Try spring till fall
Thanks for your honesty especially the PATIENCE bit 😂
No one is perfect!😊
Thank you so much for your videos! I've been fascinated with this form of art for decades, and decided to start doing something about it instead of just admire it.
I have a weeping birch I planted almost 30 years ago. It is only about 5 feet tall and maybe 7 inches around at the base (the moose have done a great job pruning it!).
I'd like to turn it into a bonsai, but have no idea how to start doing that. Any (and all) education and tips would be muchly appreciated!
Spring is a great time to transplant. Just do not et roots dry out. Birch loves water. When in doubt, plant it in an over size pot to start...have fun!
Haha great story about the moose! And wonderful question. I will address this in my upcoming Q&A so please stay tuned!
Hi Milton,
Thanks a lot for your videos ! I have a question : do you always care about bonsaï styles ? Cascade, informal upright, broom ... What is your opinion ? Thank you.
Guillaume
I can't force fit! I tend to go with the flow. Take advantage of the exiting flow to make into any of the above styles. :)
Hello, thank you for the valuable information and advices. I have not very common question. I am growing 4 trees from seeds. When can I separate them into different pots? And what pots can I use?
Se[arate when the tree can be handled...Not urgency so long as the roots got so big that it jams the pot.
@@MiltonChang-ee6rq my pot is as small as my palm
I will answer this in my Q&A!
What do you think of adding mineral grit to the bonsai mix? From my research it is suppose to add the micronutrients that sometimes our mixes miss. I make my own mixes also. Bonsai soils to expensive for me. Just a thought.
Sure...you must mean micronutrients like what is in commercial fertilizer.
I will answer this in my Q&A.
@@bonsaiheirloom It is a rock dust that adds trace minerals to the soil. Azomite is one of them and Andesite Mineral Complex. Not a fertilizer, so to say. Just a thought.
Hi Milton when is the best time to take cutting from juniper to plant
Any time!
Slower to root in winter
Of course I mean cs winter
I will wait till spring on in freezing winters
@@MiltonChang thank you
I'm sure you have gone over your soil mixes. But I can't find it. Here in central valley california it's difficult to keep moisture with non organic bonsai soil. I noticed the trees in the potting soil grow more vigorously. But my trees in traditional mix struggle. Is there a happy medium.
Hi there, please check out my video about soil: ua-cam.com/video/aOeeXAGb6T0/v-deo.html Let me know if you have any other questions!
👍👌🙂
Thanks...do you need to click lick for UA-cam to know you like? I am not sure.
Wow it's always so beautiful at your property.. and I can't find the link to your website. I would love to buy some starter material or even some Mature tree's if possible.. I'll take your ugly ducklings 😅
My website is bonsaiheirloom.com. Pre-orders will begin later this year. For now, you can sign up for our email list so you get updates and announcements! Thank you for your interest!
Отсутствие забора - может, и эстетично, но крайне неудобно. Дети и домашние питомцы тогда отправляются в свободный полет. Забор нужен фкнкционально, это не декорация ))
Twenty five years, I'm just happy if I don't kill mine after 5 year's.
Can happen
All in a day’s work!