Dunkirk from the German Perspective | Animated History
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 гру 2019
- Support my channel by downloading Rise of Kingdoms: patron.me/armchair, Use the code q2c73mvtnh and claim the below prizes: GEM x 200, Silverkey x 2, 50000 Food x 2, 50000 Wood x 2
Sign up for The Armchair Historian website today:
www.thearmchairhistorian.com/
Discord: / discord
Ironside Computers - Click here to customize your own PC: ironsidecomputers.com/ USE DISCOUNT CODE "History" FOR 5% OFF!
Sources:
www.thedailybeast.com/the-mys...
markcallagher.com/history/ww2r...
dunkirk1940.org/index.php?&p=1...
hushkit.net/2018/04/17/spitfi...
Great Battles of World War II by Dr. Chris Mann
www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/5...
www.wearethemighty.com/articl...
defenceindepth.co/2016/07/11/...
skeptoid.com/blog/2013/04/15/...
The Private War Journal of Generaloberst Franz Halder - Volume IV (link)
HyperWar: The War in France and Flanders by Major L.F Ellis (link)
Report of Comparative Trials of Hurricane Versus Messerschmitt 109 (link)
Strategy For Defeat - The Luftwaffe 1933-1945 by Williamson Murry (link)
Music:
Lining Up - Experia
Live, Fight, Survive - Anthony Earls
Corner Cube - Christian Andersen
In Front of the Fort - Experia
Behind the Dusk - Trailer Worx
Thunder from the West - Zach Heyde
No Going Back - Wendel Scherer
Armchair Historian Theme - Zach Heyde
SFX by SoundRav
soundrav.com/ - Game Audio - Sound Design - Post Production
EDUCATIONAL CONTENT, ADVERTISER FRIENDLY
Support my channel by downloading Rise of Kingdoms: patron.me/armchair, Use the code q2c73mvtnh and claim the below prizes: GEM x 200, Silverkey x 2, 50000 Food x 2, 50000 Wood x 2
Pls do soviet invasion of manchuria 1945 the underrated reason why japan surrender
Speaking of East Asian Combat, if you Armchair takes requests, why not do a small one on the siege of Qingdao in ww1?
The Armchair Historian Hay mate. I just have to say taht your content suprises every time.
I especialy adored the animated conversation between Hitler and his generals.
Just keep at it. You shoud have a TV channel if I was asked.
The sacrifice of the 21th, 32th, 60th and 68th french Infantry Division and 12th Motorised infantry division
Please the battle of alps
Let's be real. In WW2, Britain had some SERIOUS plot armour
Simon Norris this made me chuckle 😁 too bad it seems that we’re even more hated than the Germans, judging by a lot of comments.
Joel Whitworth Agreed. I know it’s just the troglodytes that tend to scream the loudest about that sort of stuff, and that any person who judges someone else just because of the country they’re from isn’t the kind of person worth having around, but they act like we’re the only country that ever waged wars for profit and colonised land, even though most of Western Europe was on that very same party bus.
well more like Channel Armour actually, the Royal navy and the German lack of proper amphibious invasion equipment or ships helped quite a lot.
Island + navy = +20 resistance to invasion
@Ricardo Milos we are hated by lots of people just like you, i think the craziest part is how close britain was to joining you germans and how little the germans actually wanted to attack britain, it was literally hanging on the balance, sir oswald mosley a british fascist who supported hitler was going to sieze power but was arrested mere days before he did, with him in power we wouldve joined the germans, wouldve split france and the entire world wouldve likely fell with the german/british army beating anyone who comes at it, the combined air forces and then britains navy.
sun tzu said it: "deprive a man of escape, and he will fight like a demon."
SUN TZU SAID THAT, AND I THINK HE KNOWS A LITTLE MORE ABOUT FIGHTING THAN YOU DO PAL BECAUSE HE INVENTED IT!
@@k_aesar ok mate
@@k_aesar And then he perfected it so that no living man could best him in the ring of honor!
@@k_aesar WHY ARE WE YELLING?!?!?!
Not Sure Sun Tzu told him to.
The french soldiers trapped in Lille sacrified themselves to buy some time for their british and french friends. We must never forget the ones who were left behind to act as heroes.
Facts bro facts
ሚኪያስ Éthiopien That’s what he said man
I read that as french fries.
Nah. Their were in the beach for TWO weeks. No one bought them time! 🤣
You have fought for your EMPIRES. After WW2 finish, you continue the war against the vietnamese people.
My granddad brother died at this battle to save English soldiers. Everybody laughed at the French surrendered but many people joined the French resistance like my Grandfather. They never gave up the country like the government did...
it was wise for france to surrender because hitler would have grounded paris and much more cities if they hadnt
My grandad was one of the last officers to leave dunkirk, i appreciate what the French did, Never saw my grandad as he died from the affects of mustard gas from WWI that finally got to him.
@@un3xxy343 yes if they didn't surrender the culture of their cities would die.
Now France is a Islamic colony, Ironic
@@jonny2911 do you think I will leave my country?
European Union is a fucking mess and hope many french will vote next year Marine Lepen. Unfortunately every party made a alliance when we are favourite...
If you are English is not better when you go to London or Birmingham!!! You have already Sharia law for the muslims people.
UK is also an Islamic country
*Armchair Historian:* Shows the German side.
*UA-cam:* Demonitized
Charles Anthony but it isn’t coz it still has ads for me...
Anything historical is demonitized
Armchair Historian: ...
UA-cam: Demonetized
UA-cam is so terrible even ingsoc has feared them
I just wrote something similar. Another historical channel showed figurines of historical people and some showed swastikas for Nazi Germany. They were forced to remove the swastikas.
As a German speaking person myself I loved that the hypothetical conversation of the high command was actually in German
Ja, genau!
That's good
Ich bin Amerikan, oder das ist geil!
@@weldin shut up
I only speak German a little, but I loved it. I wondered how good the German accents were. I'd imagine there might be accent differences between those speaking hoch German and the Austrian Hitler.
'The british won't come back in this war.'
Well that didn't age well.
Hitler never wanted war with Britain, the commies were always the enemy. He offered peace and he thought theyd accept. Nope.
@@Triple5live In their defence, would you really trust someome who broke treaties? I’m not saying the Versallies treaty is ever good. I’m no real Historian but It seems you are leaning to one side based on political ideological belief instead of learning on all sides like a real historian.
@@firemangan2731 he did not want to fight the British but by 1939 he knew he was going to and was not doing any favours
Just like the younglings
They wouldn’t have alone
Cudos for getting proper German speakers to do the High Command scene, when it came up, I was so afraid it would be Holywood Germans.
It's quiet telling that "Hollywood Germans" is a sufficient description so that most people know what you're talking about.
I think that is why the film Downfall had so much impact. Hitler being played by Anthony Hopkins in a shires accent just doesn't cut it.
I spoke to a ww2 veteran a few months before he passed away. He said the french were amazing. They fought until the last bullet to allow the brits the chance to escape. They understood the importance of allowing the brits a chance to escape to regroup and fight again another day, so the french died fighting for that cause and hope.
The veteran said he was one of the last men to escape, he escaped on a small paddle boat, he said he can’t describe how petrifying it was to know you were going to get killed if you did not escape.
I had so many more questions I wished I had asked him. Unfortunately that time has passed now.
The facts are very stubborn and they tell totally different story than your veteran.
Mark Filkerson what’s your story?
McBizz 9 but they only surrendered after the last Brit left the beach. So, I believe the story of the french were brave and helped the brits escape. Why are you guys so desperate to pull down the french?
65,000 French or more were saved by the Brits plus the British rear guard and German indecision to follow up played the main roles in the expeditionary force escaping.
@@belsayshootingground cause they are frech :P sry german Humor xD
Logan Paul: *films dead bodies*
UA-cam: give em the money!
History channel:
UA-cam: *DEMONETIZED!*
@Jimmy James people can have any names they want so suck it up
@Jimmy James ObViOuSlY for the memes
@Jimmy James I know, you deleted your comment lol
Logan paul's video was fucking deleted.
also please stop with these like-hungry comments.
@@baldoggie Yeah that's because he disabled it himself, UA-cam didn't care
Despite our overwhelming numerical superiority, the French counterattack in several points. I cannot understand how these soldiers, sometimes fighting 1 to 20, still find the strength to assault. It’s amazing.
I find in them the same passion as those of Verdun.
We do not pierce anywhere and suffer terrifying losses, some battalions have lost more than 60% of their troops sometimes even more. "
"Dunkirk provides me with proof that the Frenchman is one of the best fighters in the world."
General Georg Von Kuchler.
sam sam yee
Shame how the French has their reputation tarnished by spineless politicians
@@Malos_ spinless politicians or spinless ally ?
If UK did not betray Poland then France the war could have ended before 1945...
@Slava Svoboda The British still won the war right? I don’t think anyone here was spineless.
“There’s no such thing as bad soldiers, only bad offficers.”
"Keep land, lose men. Lose land, keep men. Land can be retaken, men cannot." Mao Zedong
"Man who walk through swinging door is going to Bangkok." - Mao Zedong.
he also starved like 50 million people to death but yes men are valuable.
@@historicalsnek1927 Indeed
“Keep food, lose men. Lose food, lose men.” -Also Mao
That’s fucking rich, coming from the greatest mass murderer in human history.
wow, that conversation was actually in German. Respect, makes the whole thing much more authentic.
Vinnie-Kush sounded like fluent German too I wonder who did the voice acting🤔
The speakers were actually native germans, you could hear it, they didn't have even the slightest accent.
Nice
Also worth noting; The guy who voiced Hitler didn't go for any sort of evocation of the way Hitler sounded in his speeches.
Which many do and turn it into a caricature.
Good choice on their part.
@dopey "his normal voice" as opposed to "the way Hitler sounded in his speeches".
If only UA-cam appreciated history
"Those who controls the present controls the past"
Vlare could be a good place for it since you can actually reach out to the staff there
Media outlets want history to be told by those who can rewrite it for their agenda. Look at the history channel for a prime example, now its all about reality shows and aliens.
UA-cam appreciates history...
... As long as it is approved by our overlords of course
YOU MEAN NAZINPROPOGANDA
“Besides, the British won’t come back in this war” a phrase that didnt age so well for hitler
I think Hitler expected the British to negotiate with Germany as feelings among most of the British aristocracy and Establishment were sympathetic ( and quite well connected ) to the Nazis war against Bolshevism. This is one theory for Hitler holding back for a few days during the Dunkirk campaign.
Hitler felt like what his army had just accomplished excluded the possibility of continued war against Britain... what happened at Dunkirk wasn't really a miracle as much as a matter of the trapped Allied armies being spared as a gesture of goodwill to Britain, who Hitler was convinced would then come to terms and cooperate against Stalin. It's very well documented that Hitler never wished to fight the Brits or even challenge their naval supremacy. The lesson I suppose is to never make such assumptions, never squander a golden opportunity to destroy the enemy.
@@jeremybunn8473 It's pretty obvious that is what happened. When I was in school Dunkirk was characterized as a miracle but in the years since I've come to realize it was largely a moment of weakness/overconfidence/wishful thinking by Hitler. He never dreamed Britain would refuse to come to terms after what amounts to a serious gesture of goodwill on his part. For somewhat obvious reasons (mostly political), this reality is obscured in Western history texts.
@@bobshenix
Hitler didn't order the halt, Von Rundstedt did. His Panzer Divisions had been fighting for 3 days without rest, had outrun their Infantry and Artillery support and were suffering 50% attrition rates for their Tanks.
On the side of the Allies in Dunkirk they had good defensive positions, AT Guns, Tanks and, with no way out, would fight ferociously. Von Rundstedt ordered the halt because, well, wasting his Panzers at a worthless attack on Dunkirk could have cost the Invasion of France dearly. Tanks, without Infantry, will get butchered in Urban Combat. Just look at Turkey wasting it's Leopard 2s by sending them into cities alone, only for some teenager with an RPG-7 to put a rocket in the side of it.
Invading Dunkirk would have been a waste of time and material for a 50% chance of grabbing a few extra kills/POWs, or losing multiple Panzers and having to retreat while the Allies get away, thus making the rest of the invasion potentially fail or have much higher casualties. Hell, the Armies at Dunkirk could have even counterattacked if they repealed the Germans, which would have been disastrous for Germany and their logistics.
Me: decides to listen to history doc on Bluetooth speaker as I shower. 5 minutes; Germans begin screaming about battle plans.
Roomate: "What the hellis going on in there!?"
LMAO I'm German and I cannot hear any screaming. Why does it always come off as screaming?
I don't even understand why people these days bother to watch TV channels like History channel when you can find way better content online, like these UA-cam videos that clearly has a lot of time and passion invested into them. Truly great documentary videos. Keep it up!
People older then around 50 simply don’t understand/get it
I don't even know why they call it history channel anymore.
I cancelled my cable service. Internet only. I do have a roku for free stuff but I get what I want online.
Pawn stars pal. Pawn stars
But where else will I learn about Ancient Aliens and hunters who hunt ghosts!?!!?
Are we really at the point where historical documentaries cannot display historically accurate flags?
Not on youtube
Welcome to UA-cam’s dumb algorithm
Could you explain yourself please?
not if the flag has a particular kind of cross on it because the cross is satan incarnite and will ressurect the 4th reich just by people seeing it regardless of context
Take it or leave it, UA-cam is dumb sometimes
“Be careful with him, eh?”
“He’s bloody dead mate.”
“Yeah, is be bloody careful with him!”
Rip George 😭
That was an awesome movie
I just watched it,
“Despite our overwhelming numerical and material superiority, the French are counterattacking in many places. I cannot understand how these soldiers, often fighting one-on-twenty, still find the strength to repel every attack. It’s amazing. I find in these French soldiers the same flame as in those of Verdun in 1916. "
“Dunkirk is for us [the Germans] a setback. Almost all of the British Expeditionary Force and part of the French 1st Army escaped us, because a few thousand brave Frenchmen blocked our access to the sea. "
Général Von Küchler
I swear my country is always forgotten in this part of ww2, it makes me so mad
Armchair Historian: "We want to teach World War II history."
UA-cam: "Okay."
Armchair Historian: "We want to teach history about German experiences in WWII."
UA-cam: "......... *REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE* "
You'd think teaching the experiences of the "bad guys" would make sense.
Take history from all sides
That’s a lot EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
@@zjenthusiast3037 It's proportionate to UA-cam's overreaction.
The Official Sikris pretty much, they need to chill cuz my boi Armchair be solid asf
Shouldn't that be: "Nein, Schweinhund! Nicht on Nazis! Ze Battle of France ist verboten! Too much violence for kiddies!"
Goring: The Luftwaffle will take them out
Fails
Goring: We can air supply Stalingrad with the Luftwaffle
Fails
Dang, was Goring an allied spy?
toooo much morphines in blood :D
"No bomber can reach the Rhur, if one of them reach the Rhur, my name isn't Goring, my name is Meyer..."
Hermann Meyer...
No, the guy was a fat slob. He believed his Luftwaffe was infallible. Fellow Germans called him 'The Fat One' behind his back.
And he had a big back. And a butt to go with it. :)
There were more Luftwaffe planes under the English Channel than there were U-Boats. And there were more U-Boats providing air support at Stalingrad than there were Luftwaffe. Dick Dastardly and Muttley would have commanded the Luftwaffe with more success than Goering. But they were too busy trying to catch that Pigeon *NOW!*
You jest. But there was an SOE plan to assassinate Goering. It was decided that his removal would hinder the Allies rather than help them so the plan was shelved.
It’s so sad that the French are known for the cowardice of their government in ww2
NOT for the bravery and heroism of the soldiers on the front
They are represented by the cowardly politicians who gave up to stay in power
Not by the men determined to stay in the fight
They didn't gave up to stay in power, if France didn't surrendered it would have been a massacre and the country would have been utterly destroyed
It's always been that way in every war, in every country.
@@Cynane27 Examples?
@@LuxMortis_ the world
@@dolantho Hi Dylan, might give me some examples please? I can't find one myself that match what's happening with the French coward stuff.
Dunkirk : Let's withhold our Panzers.
Normandy : Let's withhold our Panzers.
lol
The commanders having a conversation was a great touch keep up the awesome work.
I agree this part of the video was great please consider using them more often.
The conversations where good, but it still came down to Hitler's War of the Generals. Hitler wanted to take credit for everything that went right and blame others when things went wrong. And letting 300,000 British troops slip through his fingers, was well worth it to Hitler to have a handful of Generals in his grasp. There is much of Hitler's motives that we can never definitely know, but one thing we can know for sure, after Dunkirk the Sitzkrieg was definitely over.
i disagree , i don't think putting words in historical figures moths is a good thing for a documentary to do unless they actually said them
@@pavivier I figure as long as we acknowledge that it's a hypothetical conversation then that's fine. If we purposefully misled our viewers then that would be a problem. We also did extensive research to really understand each general's perspective about the battle and tried to model the conversation after something we think could have actually occurred. Just like how in documentaries they use footage from reenactments to show a hypothetical of how combat would have looked, we used animations to show a hypothetical of how a conversation would have looked.
@@behindthearmchair8727 Oh definitely, the statement at the start was more than enough, my dislike for it is purely personal and it isn't misleading at all. I'm really glad to hear that you researched each general's perspective as i was left wondering if this was the case after watching. might i suggest mentioning this if/when you do something like this again?
I have to say Griffin, the animation and voice acting made this video beautiful. I cannot imagine how much time you've must have spent on making this. Super great done and keep going but don't exhaust yourself!
too bad youtube is going to demonetize it, meaning he will make no money for all of his hard work
Unpopular opinion; Animations are rather stiff and unexpressive, almost like paper dolls .But yeah, the voice acting is pretty good.
true! do not exhaust yourself griffin!
otherwise Hitler won't let you attack those defenseless divions on dunkirk...
eh i mean post another video.
yeah, otherwise Hitler won't let you post another video!
...
that doesn't sound right...............
@@joaoostroski4778 lol I like your sense of humor
it's like downfall but dunkirk
Incredible presentation. I always wanted to know the full story after watching the movie with Tom hardy. I'm glad to have access to such valuable information that is delivered so well, especially in times like we are experiencing today. Knowledge of this kind of history is becoming increasingly valuable! Please keep creating!
That conversation at German HQ would have been more believable if Göring was eating.
It's actually really interesting seeing from this side as no one else actually tells the German side. Very interesting.
ThatKindaGuy Travel isn’t that something actually? Not 1 time ever has anyone ever heard their side?
Yes apparently if you even say the word German, you are a pro nazi homophobic scumbag because murica is a winpy offended society now. Dumbasses
@A Scam Involving Corndogs imagine saying boomer unironically.
Europa the Last Battle also has some interesting German accounts of the whole time period. Greatest Story Never Told which was mentioned up above is also a good account.
@A Scam Involving Corndogs ok weeb
British soldier in North Africa: "Aye bloke, isn't that your tank?"
This is, by far and large, the single worst impression a yank has ever done of a Brit.
@@spoonovic Absolutely
@@su-hoonc3073 That's better, mine was a Canadian exchange student living in England
@@su-hoonc3073 Wasn't talking about you Jackie Chan, don't worry.
Soar Alba sounds a bit racist if you ask me but ok
Massive thumbs up for having the germans speak german! I can tell a lot of work goes into your vids. Huge thanks to you and your animation team!
Sooo awesome to show different perspectives like that! Truly great work!
Why not replace swastikas with the UA-cam logo?
Alternate History Hub did it to avoid demonetization.
Michael Kevin Millet
Why
Maui Dp he is right youtube is really going agains thwart it once stood for
Dank Sanchez
Yes
But it’s still entertaining
If UA-cam died
You couldn’t watch any videos about Nazis
Nor gaming
Nor music
Nor anything
UA-cam might suck
But its creators and videos are pretty good
Maui Dp I know but youtube is trying everything to drive said creators away, it’s a good platform just run by idiots
Michael Kevin Millet
If UA-cam died
Any other website would never be able to get hundreds of millions of viewers to switch over just like that.
Liking those dunkirk Stuka sound effects 👌
The British soldiers on the beach didn't though
@Mr. Gerry ehm no, they didn't
@@bs2202 lmao just seeing you as an enemy is scary
Iv noticed the animation quality has got significantly better, good job!
I just watched Dunkirk the movie this weekend, great info in this video - thank you!
The battle against UA-cam rages on. Great video guys! Thanks for the Awesome content of last year.
15:24
Belgian batalion: *Change the world, my final message, goodbye!*
yeah I think they were disbanded due to too many casualties
@@AS-dr1cp no it was because the belgians didnt want to lose manpower and equipment in the encirclement
@@kingfaz07 no because this area was led by king leopald 3 himself the king had surrendered his nation that is why the rest of the belgians went back with the king although that belgian area of units also went to england
@@deepyamandas1192 i think it's a hoi4 reference, in other words he's joking about a videogame that plays similar to this video
It will never cease to amaze me how much respect soldiers have for each other regardless of who they’re fighting for.
The Germans had no respect for Polish or Russian soldiers, only intense hatred. And vice-versa I suppose.
@@tonywells6990 Mm no. The Germans did have respect for Slavs and Jews. Most did.
They fought because of nationalism and patriotism. Because of family and friends.
Most were threatened, forced, and conscripted to fight. Most didn't agree with Hitler's supremacist ideals, but they thought it would rebuild Germany, so they had to go with it.
They were national socialists, not zealous crusaders.
They were a fascist-forced people, not racist torturers.
@@Ares-rx4zz Exactly yeah.
pure fantasy. many US soldiers treated asian and middle eastern soldiers with nothing but disgust and contempt, not to mention cruelty. and that was the official policy, btw. look at the propaganda posters distributed.
@@demuattius1112 this is just pure nazi apology and revisionism. bullshit.
Your arguments, presented in the conversation, were excellent.
Fun fact, Charles DeGaulle actually counterattacked to the south
At the Battle of Montcornet ! De Gaulle had even written a book well before the Second World War to alert the French high command on the importance of war of movement with mechanized means where he had perfectly predicted all the German strategy and in particular the breakthrough through Sedan. He had acquired military command experience during the Soviet-Polish war where he had obtained a quote and especially during the battle of Verdun and throughout the ww1 but he was mocked and demeaned by the politicians of the time ... He put his plans into action with the Offensive of Montcornet which was a success while the Allied armies were breaking up. Unfortunately his strategy would have had to be applied on a larger scale to be effective.
Zericoyo _ feel bad for him the more I learn. He saw how the next war would be fought and knew better then most how easily peace in France could be flipped on its head. He has the solutions but a bunch of assholes won't let him fix the problem.
There was several counter attacks. One British counter attack caused the SS 'Totenkopf' to break and run in panic. It lead some Germans to conclude they required more time to prepare their final offensive. They had very little intelligence about British and French strength in the pocket and they certainly did not anticipate a vast naval rescue.
@@DeafLord18 Yep for info his mentor was Philippe Pétain in Person. He had so much respect for him for the 1st World War that he called his son "Philippe" in homage to "Philippe Pétain". During Pétain's judgment at the liberation of France, a lot of French wanted the death penalty for high treason but De Gaulle pushed the judgment towards a life imprisonment while under the Vichy regime, the least free French (therefore of his own son (Soldier) and Women who had joined the Free French Forces at the start of the armistice in 1940) was stripped of his nationality and intended for the death penalty for high treason. De Gaulle was one of the rare French presidents despite criticism to flourish and pay homage to the tomb of Marshal Pétain for the armistice of the 1st World War!
@@navarro4238
The marshal is a great man who died in 1925. Trouble is, he didn’t know it.
-Charles de Gaulle
The defense of Lille by those 35 000 French soldiers was a decisive point.
I will never forget the stories about brave French soldiers. Their leadership was weak, but the men were strong.
That's how my grandpa told his son, and his son told me.
My grandpa's grave is in Marigny, Basse Normandy.
Don't let brother's wars happen again.
Thanks UA-cam, had I seen Germany's real historic flag, I'd probably start shouting in german while donning an SS uniform again...
@@robertcrawshaw9978 You too? I hate it when that happens. Good to know someone can relate!
Happens every time
I think anyone can realet
Again?
@@chose_this_on_the_toilet Nien! Shhhh
Dammit nearly invaded the uk man who else gets this? All of you?
Great channel. Very well done. I will be watching more.
Thank you
What did the Germans learn from Dunkirk? The British saved their professional soldiers British eventually won the war.
The Germans lost their most experienced army, 6th army and all the equipment at Stalingrad for nothing. This gave 'the USSR impetus to win the war.
A temporary retreat is a good thing.
By the time of the battle of Stalingrad, their oil situarion was so desperate, that they could never win the war.
But they fought on for two more years, so Stalingrad was truly meaningless.
Ben Laskowski Lol
@@mikeappleget482 Thanks, but why the lol?
@David Kuijl "Now they say that the allies never helped us, but it can't be denied that the Americans gave us so many goods without which we wouldn't have been able to form our reserves and continue the war... We didn’t have explosives, gunpowder. We didn’t have anything to charge our rifle cartridges with. The Americans really saved us with their gunpowder and explosives. And how much sheet steel they gave us! How could we have produced our tanks without American steel? But now they make it seem as if we had an abundance of all that. Without American trucks we wouldn’t have had anything to pull our artillery with."
-Marshall Georgy Zhukov
They were called the "Allies" for a reason. The Soviets needed the UK and USA, and vice-versa. A man like Stalin wouldn't ask for help unless he needed it, and he was constantly demanding the opening of a Western Front to relieve his troops.
I really love that you didnt forget belgian defiance in this battle. Most of the times the belgian and sometimes french defenders are forgotten so i love that you guys didnt forget them. Aparently a few belgian divisions held out for much longer because they didnt know of the surrender of the country because communication lines with them were dead. And after the war king leopold the third had to abducate because of the outrage of the people because he had surrenderd and had helped the germans during their ocuppation of belgium. Also would love to see a video about the battle of verdun of world war 1. Love the video's and keep up the amazing work.
Yea, be outraged that someone tried to take the Satanists that destroyed Belgium in the past decades out of there and move them to Madagascar. Or are you saying Brussels is the place to be nowadays? Compare Belgium 1930-1945 to Belgium now and tell me you "won".
As far as i know: YOU ARE FUCKED, SAME AS EVERYONE ELSE IN THE WORLD BY NOW!
Because why? Who has control over your Country? The People? Or the true Winners? Yes, those that paid Dutroix to grab the Children and have them ready for Rape & Murder.
Why is there no follow up on the Case? Yea totaly not because Politicians, globalist Banksters, Judges & Police are in on it.
/rant end
On ne passe pas.
Good film and some good points made here that I’ve not heard before
Well done, thanks
Fantastic video. Yours is the best historical content on UA-cam
When the armchair historian isn’t even in an arm chair
@J Thorsson That's why it's called lie-f.
When the armchair isn’t even a historian
Liam Redmond *The armchair historian was an Impostor*
Time for a GoFundMe
*SCAM*
13:20
“In any war, Belgians always make a good shield.” - anonymous
Not for the german fist
That's messed up
Belgians do not exist.
@@sovietagent9303 yep
@@antoniescargo1529 Sure about that?
Amazing work, superb as always.
Göring: Promises something
History: He was wrong. very wrong.
2020 is looking great if we're gonna get more content like this.
Demonitized content.
@@JesusProtects That's why I support him on his website, uncensored and more content :P
dont worry we're going to get a live action one soon
Oops
Griffen is Killin it. This is one the best episodes yet. The dialogue and animation is on another level. So cool. Keep making more please!
I had no idea most of these were animated -- I always thought based on some thumbnails it was just The Armchair Historian talking on camera.
These videos are truly well done, keep it up!
The bravery of the civilian men that sailed across the channel to help their fellow countryman is a characteristic and a strength that lies deep within us all. We don’t often find ourselves in situations or circumstances that cause and require us to summon that kind of selfless heroism. When the stakes are as high as having to protect your homeland from the threat of tyranny, suffering, and subjugation of your fellow countrymen I think most people would sail that proverbial boat straight into a war zone in order to keep that from happening. That kind of power is in the hearts of all good men and women and it’s that strength that evil men fear and wish to stomp out. We are constantly divided in this country and I find myself falling victim to the tribalism in our media all the time. Feeling forced to pick a side and trying to push my opinion onto other almost in a dogmatic way. For that I am guilty and I know many others are as well. We all must remember that as Americans we have to stand up to that same kind of evil that was exhibited at dinkirk by the German leaders. There is nothing more that the most powerful evil selfish egomaniac men want in the world than to divide us and make us easy to control. We must stand together and we must all be willing to sail into war for our brothers and sisters no matter what political or religious values we each hold individually.
I love the EDUCATIONAL CONTENT in the title! :)
It's pretty sad that he has to point that out..
@Jeffrey Epstein wtf
@@hardcorehardo It's pretty sad that he has to point that out...
@@hardcorehardo It's pretty sad that he has to point that out..
@@hardcorehardo It's pretty sad that he has to point that out...
my grandfather was at Dunkirk, while on his retreat to dunkirk they slept in a barn before making it to dunkirk while they were held out in the barn the lines had changed over night putting them behind enemy lines and ended up slipping back over to the British Lines during the next night and then getting hit by a piece of shrapnel on the beach and then going on to recover to serve in North Africa Being Present at the Battle El Alamein and also fighting with the french where he got awarded legion d honneur by the french not sure where he fought with them but i have his medals and etc.
That's fascinating, my great grand father also fought in north africa on the french side, maybe they bumped into each other
@@haaxeu6501 Nice, Thats quite a Possibility His Name was Gordon Reeves
copy link, paste, delete spaces, watch video, copy link, add spaces, and share this truth
- Wake our ppl up ! htt ps: //w ww. bit chu te. com /vi deo /rl Otx bRP UZB H/
@@notplebbes9108 whats the point of faking being white. It's ok to not be European. There are plenty of other interesting things in other regions.
@@sabus1265 how does one fake being white?
My great grandad was at Dunkirk, he got shrapnel trapped in his leg and needed to get it removed, after the injury he was not allowed to continue fighting for the rest of the war he was in his 40s at the time and thus he was already nearly over the age limit to be in listed, so he was kept stationed down in London during the Blits and the Battle of Britain and shot down German/Nazi plains.
I’m very glad to have heard about him and see his medals, Dogtags, and pictures of him, he is definitely a role model and someone I look up to and admire.
P.S. me and my Family are Scottish lol
Let's Travel well my great grandad died when my dad was only 10 in 1985 so........IDK
Let's Travel how do you mean?
Let's Travel how do you mean by “the West”?
Let's Travel well at the end of the the War in Europe, I believe he was glad to have fought and be recognised for his actions. However he never received any medals for his actions when he was alive, he got posted one from London to here (in Scotland) after the war but it was Stolen in the post, (we believe it was the Defence Medal) then after his death, my grandad (my great grandads son) was called down to London to come and collect 2 medals in his honour, the War Medal 1939-1945, and the 1939-1945 Star, my grandad kept the Defence medal wile he gave the 1939-1945 star to his brother (my great uncle). So yeah, I know that my great Grandad and my Grandad hate/hated Nazis, wile my Grandad Children all hate Communists, my Dad and Uncles also hate the Nazis.
I remember a story from my Dad telling me that my Great grandad once said he would do anything just to see the Berlin Wall get taken down. So yeah, with everything that’s been going on as of late it’s pretty scary stuff with China you know there Cyber attacks on Australia, there threats to go to war with Taiwan, and there Border dispute with India it’s pretty scary stuff.
Absolute quality of visuals, story telling and research. Better then most documentaries with gigantic budgets. Where is your patreon ?
18:00 And that's where the movie Dunkirk starts.
This movie is historically inaccurate.
Ilans 789 but it’s pretty good
@@ilanselaphiel2557 It's not that inaccurate stuff like the German planes being painted yellow was so the audience could tell who was British and who was German
This was the same with most mistake being made to help the audience
@@willkp50 Well that depend if you liked the movie or not. I, personally don't like it.
Ilans 789 not liking it doesn’t make it historically inaccurate.
There were some quirks, to be sure, and they made some decisions in favor of drama (e.g. an actual civilian crew on the small boat, which was not typical though apparently did happen, as well as the stripes as discussed) but what, specifically, was inaccurate?
"Their victory could have been more decisive if their superiors had taken greater risks." They also could have lost. We'll never know.
Great job again with this video !
Your videos are captivating thank you
It was a great German victory.
And a good British retreat, covered by the french and belgians.
DevilAshes we should never of gone back, should of left you to the Germans.
DevilAshes if you lived in London you never lived in Britain or England.
@epoh333 Based on your revisionist view of history, that is being increasingly discredited? The world is beginning to realise that, Germany was in a noble fight, against the international bankers.
Excusez mon compatriote, il ne sait pas ce qu'il dit.
@epoh333 Absolute nonenese. France started the war with the outrageous treaty of Versailes, in which they stole German territory from Germany. WW2 had *nothing* to do with "racial supremacy", so like I said, cut the bullshit revisionist view of history.
My father and 2 of my uncles were at Dunkirk, and being a 22 year vet myself i can only imagine what they went through
Your father ??? You mean grandfather...
Its interesting seeing the battle of my hometown from a different perspective. We learn more about the Victory of operation Dynamo than the fails of the Germans. Also Dunkirk used to be a beautiful city before the war but it got all destroyed and rebuilt quickly to accommodate the thousand of homeless.
single best history channel, thank you
Your production quality is amazing.
I love your editing, Its Top notch especially when the german high command starts discussing. 👌🏼
That reeenactment of the OKW convo was excellent. That hitler voice was spot on. Goerings voice was good too
Wow this channel is mindblowingly amazing!
I’ve been subscribed since you guys only had a few hundred followers and I am continually amazed by how much improvement you implement from video to video, keep it up
Armchair Historian: posts a video
UA-cam: Demonitized
Terrific video! Loved the detail and the obvious homework done behind the talk. I would like to add two small suggestions, which I believe will help your delivery:
1. Pronounce the word "a" as "uh" Nobody pronounces it "ay".
2. Pronounce the word "the" as "thuh" when it precedes a consonant sound, such as "the plane" or "the tank" but pronounce it "thee" when it precedes a vowel sound, such as "the apple" or "the honest man" or "the X-ray".
I love the hypothetical conversations that happen in this video series
"Said every naive strategist ever"
Bruh
In b4 UA-cam de-monetised the video!
Too late
It's a real shame. Contents like this are true gems, and yet UA-cam seems to be too ignorant to realize it.
@@venn2001ad Oh they realize it. They just don't want the opposing side to be treated in anything but a demonized light.
Marco Sandoval It’s spelt both ways.
Why does UA-cam demonetize these kind of videos?
Maaaaan their hypothetical conversation had me feeling like i was there lol
And Fegelein in the background with all his antics
The French and Belgian role in the evacuation of Dunkirk is massively understated. If it wasn’t for them, Britain would have had to surrender.
Why would Britain have had to surrender?
no they wouldnt. there were 340k soldiers.thats more than enough to defend the germans and it was Britains best and most well equipped army.
@@redeese9268 Subsequently, the Royal & Merchant Navies lifted a further 191,870 men, together with 310 artillery pieces, 2292 vehicles, and 1800 tons of stores, from ports in Western France, during Operations Aerial & Cycle.
No, they wouldn’t have surrendered. This Germanic obsession of winning one battle = win the war is so preposterous it has to be countered at every turn.
Britain, safe behind the channel, would build up its army again while fighting on every other front and wait for the “New World” aka the Dominions (and not the USA like everyone believes) to build up their own strength and help liberate France/defeat Germany. To put it bluntly, no general in their right mind would fold with the hand Britain was dealt.
This was always the plan. The British have been doing this strategy since the War of the Spanish Succession because it works. What difference if France is captured when Germany can’t even grow enough food to feed their own people, much less oil for their machinery.
@@Chewable396 With operation dynamo Churchill thought it would be possible to save a maximum of 50 000 soldiers. Please tell me how could UK win or even continue the war with only 50 000 soldiers and a majoritary pro-peace opinion in the UK? Churchill said it: "The battle of France was a disaster we lost the majority of our army".
almost nothing said about Belgians who were also there!
Belgium surrendered on 28th May
@@angloirishcad and it was the smartest thing to do, they got otherwise butchered with them patatoguns
is just a speed bump
Belgians? Maybe they were Waffling? Hitler advanced through many countries because he blackmailed the leaders of that country. Hitler knew about their wrongdoings more than their people knew; so to stay in power as Hitler promised, they did not put up a fight.? Seems like there was a lot of screwing the public was happening in many Countries. Hitler took advantage of that.
they were there thats all you can say
"Malgré notre écrasante supériorité numérique, les Français contre-attaquent en plusieurs points. Je ne parviens pas à comprendre comment ces soldats, luttant parfois à 1 contre 20, trouvent encore la force de donner l'assaut. C'est stupéfiant.
Je retrouve en eux la même fougue que ceux de Verdun.
Nous ne perçons nulle part et subissons des pertes terrifiantes, certains bataillons ont perdu plus de 60% de leur effectif parfois même plus."
"Dunkerque m'apporte la preuve que le Français est l'un des meilleurs combattants au monde."
Général Georg Von Kuchler.
Sorry, I don’t speak croissant.
@@thecommonfool2110 this is what he mean't
Despite our overwhelming numerical superiority, the French counterattack in several points. I cannot understand how these soldiers, sometimes fighting 1 to 20, still find the strength to assault. It’s amazing.
I find in them the same passion as those of Verdun.
We do not pierce anywhere and suffer terrifying losses, some battalions have lost more than 60% of their troops sometimes even more. "
"Dunkirk provides me with proof that the Frenchman is one of the best fighters in the world."
General Georg Von Kuchler.
D'autres citations:
"Despite our overwhelming numerical and material superiority, French troops counter-attacked in several places. I can't understand how such brave soldiers, fighting in various places at one against ten (sometimes even one against thirty), still manage to find enough strength to go on the assault:
it's simply amazing ! I find among the French soldiers of Dunkirk the same ardour as that of the poilus of Verdun in 1916. For several days hundreds of bombers and guns have been pounding the French defences. However, it is still the same thing, our infantry and tanks cannot break through, despite some ephemeral local successes."
" "Dunkirk proves to me that the French soldier is one of the best in the world. The French artillery, so feared in 14-18, once again demonstrated its dreaded effectiveness. Our losses are terrifying: many battalions have lost 60% of their strength, sometimes even more! “
"By resisting about ten days to our forces, which were significantly superior in terms of numbers and resources, the French army achieved a superb feat in Dunkirk that is to be commended. It certainly saved Britain from defeat, by allowing its professional army to reach the English coast."
General Von Küchler commandant of the XVIII
army during the last stand of the french army to cover the british at Dunkirk.
"May 18th 1940: the Führer still worries a lot about the southern flank. he's furious and claims that we take the best path to make the whole campaign fail !
The french troops never stops counter-attacking. May 21st 1940: that day starts in an extremely tense atmosphere: reports indicates a serious pressure on the northern flank of the IVth army. The VIth army faces a solid front. May 22nd 1940: our tanks, that are currently fighting in the south, have met a powerful enemy. Our panzerdivisionen suffer too many losses and attack without being required to. Stress is growing. May 23rd 1940: the losses for the tanks of our ten panzerdivisionen reach 50% !
The french resistance is fierce."
General Franz Halder's diary, one of the chief of staff of the Wehrmacht
"Those frenchs, under the brave command of general Molinié, have during four critical days contained not less than seven german divisions that, otherwise,would have participated to the attacks of the Dunkirk perimeter. Thoses troops thus brought a splendid contribution to the safety of their luckier comrades and of the BEC."
Winston Churchill in his War Speeches,
talking about the french resistance at Lille
Adolf Hitler respond to the journalist Lutz Koch, coming back from Bir Hakim:
“You heard what Koch just said. Bir Hakeim is new evidence of the thesis I always defended: the French are, after us, the best soldiers in Europe. After the war, we will absolutely have to build a coalition which may contain a country capable of military exploits such as Bir Hakeim wich stun the world”.
Any historian: posts a video
UA-cam: do we even have to take a look
Great video, learned alot
Always feels good to see more of them videos coming... Keep it up!
Are you Greek ?
stay strong griffin. this content is great
Excelente video , me suscribí. Saludos de Argentina
I love your German translation in the comic! Great job!
I loved the conversation between the generals. Even if it wasn’t said, I could imagine them bickering and talking like that
Can you do the battle of France from the french perspective
Knight
GERMANY INVADES!!!
France: O sacré bleu, I lost again. 😩
NAZISM INTESIFIES!!
@@polishherowitoldpilecki5521 unfunny
🏳️🏳️🏳️
@@meceffeukada3767 since when are colonized nations allowed to speak? 🙃
@@aquiladoro8535
Since when uncolonized nations exist ?
"The soothing waters of the English Channel"? lol
Thumps up for that absolutely flawless German! Nice to see someone putting that much effort in it!
Usually I'll throw on these videos and listen as i do math homework or something, the sudden German threw me off lol
What's 12x14 = 168
What's 29x17 = SCHLIEFFEN
Same lol
Just like the French when German forces push through the Ardennes
1:13 bis 2:11: Alles ist in dichten Nebel gehüllt!
Durin der Unsterbliche thanks Kaiser
Durin der Unsterbliche Endlich ein Deutscher hahahahhaha
Ich kann nicht aufhören zu lachen
The Battle of France was a stunning victory for Germany. I can’t imagine how good it would’ve felt for those men after they fought so bravely and achieved what the previous generation couldn’t. That being said the British and French also fought with much courage and stubbornness and even had the Germans panicking at times. But all in all they gave the Allies a good lesson in modern combined arms warfare and a reminder that war had evolved way beyond the conservative trench tactics of The Great War.
I love the content!!! Amazing knowledge
Alex the Rambler: OOOOOH THAT'S A TASTY ENCIRCLEMENT! TASTY!
"Oh. My. Giddy. AUNT"
ISorrowProductions: OH THATS JUICY
@@r3strt Nice
Paint brush
*hoi4 gang intensifies*
I would love another dunkirk movie from the german perspective with they were fighting the French holding the line protecting the British retreat.
A. british soldiers also stayed behind to cover the retreat. B. french soldiers were evacuated alongside the british.
Wont get made, anything that's from Germany or Japanese perspective is pretty much impossible to make in this era especially if said movie/tv show shows that those side are also humans
@@blankblank1949 not necessarily. Check out Letters from Iwo Jima.
@@r.s.334 Letters from Iwo jima wasnt from this generation of cry babies. It was helmed by Clint Eastwood.
@@blankblank1949I figured it was still this era. Good movie either way.
Great vid. Great studio.