I know I could tell he wanted to CRY 😢😭 when ALEC broke his HEART Magnus's goodbye seemed permanent like if you go thought with this you'll never see me again kind of GOODBYE and the look Alec had as Magnus walked away was like I"M AN IDIOT but does Alec go after him NO of course NOT he just stands there and lets his HAPPINESS slip through his fingers
my favorite bits: 1:07 Magnus caught himself smiling fondly at Alec so he cleared his throat and looked down 1:30 Alec being his confused innocent self 1:36 Magnus being okay with their relationship being hidden from the Lightwoods and everyone just so he could be with Alec 1:52 Ughhh you just can hear Magnus's heart breaking I swear 2:00 Alec's voice breaking 2:21 "not that I would know" ouch :'((((
The guy who plays Magnus does a really good job. He has to play a dramatic guy getting hurt but not showing any real emotion, while at the same time trying to que the audience in to what he's really feeling, but also trying to seem aloof and unbothered. Its a hard gig, but I think (from what I see in the comments) he does it well.
Yes, Harry Shum Jr really is a fantastic actor. He’s really good at showing his emotions even without words and he’s also good at making us believe the magical parts as well.
We all know Malec is the end result, but getting these two to that point is heartbreaking. But I wouldn't have it any other way. Great scene. Kudos to both Matthew and Harry.
1:12 Well obviously his advice didn't work did it Alec! Dishonor on you! Dishonor on your family! Dishonor on your cow! Down with the scriptwriters we are starting a revolution!
yeah its weird how I have absolutely zero idea about whats going to happen but in the same time, I'm really curious about all this and some new stuff that they've added are quite cool- like the (spoilers) alternate universe bit in Ep 10 :)
He realy cried not just inside. You can see tha tears in him eyes. Anyway, I want to kick Alec ass here, and in the books when he broke up Magnus heart, just not like that.
I know right! Sure he had girlfriends and boyfriends, but he never married any of them. None of those relationships ever got to serious. I think Magnus thought that Alec could’ve been different for him.
@@madelinestraumanis219 Magnus had had serious relationships before, but as he told Jem/Brother Zachariah later, "Alec is different." 😭💔 What Magnus feels for him is on a whole other level.
1:38 "I get it your part of a 'Don't ask, Don't tell' culture I'm fine with that. Your a traditional guy" Aww Magnus trying to stay as positive as he can is so cute.
Magnus looked very torn and regretful about betraying Alec. And Alec has yet to find out that the cup and Clary's necklace are gone. I wonder if he'll realise Magnus helped them with that. Ouch.
stop being so heartbroken guys! Endgame never gets together in the beginning! I mean it's only episode 9, and there's a malec episode! I actually appreciate all of this to happen, such a nice twist!
Look! You can actually pinpoint the moment his heart breaks! I could actually feel Magnus's pain in my soul I swear I love how good of an actor he is :(
When Alec voice wavers when he says partner ship. And when Magnus sounded like he was gonna cry while laughing and when he said "Goodbye Alexander". I judt died inside
the hurt in magnus's eyes is so painful to watch,and when he said marriage is a wonderful institution,not that..i would know" it killed my heart,magnus got his heart broken again after it was closed for a 100 years,that must be painful..
What hurts is while Magnus's words are understanding, he is clearly disgusted with Alec's choice of "following your heart is". The first Shadowhunters episode where every Malec scene broke my heart!!
Harry Shum and Matthew Daddario are geniuses! Their acting is on point! This scene break my heart every time I watch it.😭💔 #Shadowhuntersseason2needsmoreMalec
You know what hurts the most here?? Magnus KNEW that he was talking about his marriage to a WOMAN before he even clarified that it is with Lydia. After all, just a few minutes ago Izzy told him that their mother was looking for a bride for Alec. But Magnus still played the flirty coy act of his even though he felt that sharp hurt and disappointment. It almost feels like he was desperate for Alec to joke with him and say “no I’m not getting married”. And Harry is such an amazing actor that you can see the hope in his eyes the first few seconds when they’re talking and then that pain after Alec says that he’s getting married.
I'm not even in this fandom yet, don't even watch this show and I'm so emotional, not wanting malec be another gay ship who drags me in a fandom but LOOK AT MAGNUS I AM DEAD
the moment magnus says "goodbye alexander" there's a music playing at the background. the same music that plays in episode 12 at the scene where alec tells magnus that it's all just a game for him. what's this music? it's beautiful!
Alec really doesn’t have to explain himself, after all Magnus could be counted as “someone he knows” let alone further than an acquaintance, but he try to make Magnus understand the partnership as if he knows it would hurt Magnus, it’s cute how he stumbled through that.
...I want to cry...I am but like I'm not even on this episode yet...;-; Magnus's expression when Alec told him he was getting married broke my heart and I'm just so fucking devastated...
"Marriage is a wonderful _institution"_ That's a very specific choice of words but it got me thinking... institution, Institute, sounds similar, yes? Magnus definitely know that Alec's engagement is all for the Institute and his family's reputation and he's trying to tell Alec that he knows what this wedding is really about.
ok just to make clear alec on tells about the engagement to magnus like lydia started to tell his siblings his parents got to know themselves magnus couldve found out from anyone but he told him himself and i dont know what to make out of this
i notice that after this exchange alec goes to talk to lydia and his feelings waver there. he starts questioning because of the conflict in his head and heart about the situation and magnus. its almost as if magnus saying what he said planted the conflict and created the push alec needed.
Lets please talk about the fact that Magnus was more than ready to marry Alec even then.. He was even "fine" with his "traditional family culture "... All he wanted was, look at him saying we should atleast go for a dinner.... 🥺🦋💙
Magnus looked SO broken... I wanted to hug him
They both do
Me too
I know I could tell he wanted to CRY 😢😭 when ALEC broke his HEART Magnus's goodbye seemed permanent like if you go thought with this you'll never see me again kind of GOODBYE and the look Alec had as Magnus walked away was like I"M AN IDIOT but does Alec go after him NO of course NOT he just stands there and lets his HAPPINESS slip through his fingers
Magnus was crying in the inside
And I was too
I was crying on the outside, too ya know. 😭😭😭
No but you could ACTUALLY see the tears in his eyes??????
Yeah I can feel tat
@@nicoleschweitzer9653 I know!! I saw! It was heartbreaking...
"Goodbye Alexander..." I am dead.
I dead too.
I dead whenever they reunite and fall apart
The guy who plays Magnus is a great actor
His name is Harry shum. Jr and he was in glee!!
@@Jordan-jc3mw Yeahhhhhh..............he looked go innocent there......I am a huge fan of him
Totally agree
Yesss, Harry is the best!!
@@user-lz3vt4dy8v i love your username 🥺
But did you hear Alec's voice crack when he said "partnership" because I did and 💔
i heard it i wanna go hug them so hard
you're right, i noticed it the first time i watched them. god, my heart is in pain 😭😔
my favorite bits:
1:07 Magnus caught himself smiling fondly at Alec so he cleared his throat and looked down
1:30 Alec being his confused innocent self
1:36 Magnus being okay with their relationship being hidden from the Lightwoods and everyone just so he could be with Alec
1:52 Ughhh you just can hear Magnus's heart breaking I swear
2:00 Alec's voice breaking
2:21 "not that I would know" ouch :'((((
So true. This is my fav scene far. I need that 'Magnus' episode, bc I'm still crying bc of this.(':'(
forever living for malec analysis comments like these
ARE YOU TRYING TO MAKE ME CRYYYY😭😭😭
Jace: “It smells like heartbreak in here,”
Magnus: “That’s the Chinese food.”
- Mortal Instruments: City of Heavenly Fire
😂😂
😂😂😂😂omg YES😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂 Yassss 😂😂
I love that part
Yessss
The guy who plays Magnus does a really good job. He has to play a dramatic guy getting hurt but not showing any real emotion, while at the same time trying to que the audience in to what he's really feeling, but also trying to seem aloof and unbothered. Its a hard gig, but I think (from what I see in the comments) he does it well.
Yes, Harry Shum Jr really is a fantastic actor. He’s really good at showing his emotions even without words and he’s also good at making us believe the magical parts as well.
oh Magnus broke my heart into a million pieces :'(
Katy Kats ,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, .
WE SHOULD AT LEAST GO TO DINNER FIRST
That distraught face of Magnus when Alec told him. He was engaged. I just wanted to hug him and beat Alec ass. Magnus was crying in the inside.
Oof low blow
@@thetruth830 Am so late but I see what you did there
YOU CAN SEE THE TEARS IN MAGNUS'S EYES
My soul died more than thousand times during this scene 😭💔💔
Magnus's face killed me, we could see that he was dying inside 😭😭😭😭
same
Well, at least we know how he feels
I know right?! 😢😭😔
2:34 I think he knew he basically broke Magnus' heart
Heis a brilliant actor..
We all know Malec is the end result, but getting these two to that point is heartbreaking. But I wouldn't have it any other way. Great scene. Kudos to both Matthew and Harry.
Harry's face absolutely shatters my heart every time. He looks so broken and hurt and I just can't. He's one of the best actors ever.
1:12 Well obviously his advice didn't work did it Alec! Dishonor on you! Dishonor on your family! Dishonor on your cow! Down with the scriptwriters we are starting a revolution!
on his cow?😁
Seriously!!! (Btw love the Mulan reference lol).
jaja 😂😂
+Sienna Taylor the guy who plays Alec loves cows
Nice Mulan reference
“Maybe Alexander Lightwood would not break his heart.”
-Magnus Bane, The Course of True Love [and First Dates]
I just read that!!
kailey deverraux That was literally the only thing I was thinking during that scene when I was watching it and it broke me T^T
+Veronique Montalba Ikr!! It bothers me that the producers are straying so far from the book😬
yeah its weird how I have absolutely zero idea about whats going to happen but in the same time, I'm really curious about all this and some new stuff that they've added are quite cool- like the (spoilers) alternate universe bit in Ep 10 :)
+Veronique Montalba true, it's getting better as the show goes on at least😄 btw I love your profile pic, Tokyo ghoul is my life😂
I think Magnus was going to Cry. He Said: "not that i would know." He never Got married. I feel sorry for Magnus 😕
I dislike this. Not because i hate Magnus and Alec. I hate it when Alec broke magnus's heart
He realy cried not just inside. You can see tha tears in him eyes. Anyway, I want to kick Alec ass here, and in the books when he broke up Magnus heart, just not like that.
I know right! Sure he had girlfriends and boyfriends, but he never married any of them. None of those relationships ever got to serious. I think Magnus thought that Alec could’ve been different for him.
@@madelinestraumanis219 Magnus had had serious relationships before, but as he told Jem/Brother Zachariah later, "Alec is different." 😭💔 What Magnus feels for him is on a whole other level.
2:31 You can see Magnus looking back at Alec.
Harry is such a wonderful actor. Why have we not seen him in loads of things??? He plays Magnus to perfection.😊
1:38 "I get it your part of a 'Don't ask, Don't tell' culture I'm fine with that. Your a traditional guy" Aww Magnus trying to stay as positive as he can is so cute.
alec stupid, magnus loves you :(
Magnus looked very torn and regretful about betraying Alec. And Alec has yet to find out that the cup and Clary's necklace are gone. I wonder if he'll realise Magnus helped them with that. Ouch.
This is what I'm waiting for.
I feel so bad for Magnus 😭 He's dying inside 😭💔 My Poor baby ):💔
remember he breaks Alec's heart too pretty bad..in the book.
The way he said goodbye Alexander
stop being so heartbroken guys! Endgame never gets together in the beginning! I mean it's only episode 9, and there's a malec episode! I actually appreciate all of this to happen, such a nice twist!
That “not that I would know” BREAKS my heart! 300 years and 17,000 relationships and not one of them loved him enough to propose to him......
He needed THE ONE! He found him. ❤
I think later on Alec tells Underhill that Magnus is 800 years old.
1:34 broke my heart 😭
Trying to figure out who could possibly dislike this. Came to the conclusion that it must be Magnus.
and izzy
Magnus looked so broken here! Harry did a really good job here! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
NO
MAGNUS SAD LITTLE LAUGH
NO
I feel sorry for Magnus...
Look! You can actually pinpoint the moment his heart breaks! I could actually feel Magnus's pain in my soul I swear I love how good of an actor he is :(
When Alec voice wavers when he says partner ship. And when Magnus sounded like he was gonna cry while laughing and when he said "Goodbye Alexander". I judt died inside
"partnership for both of us" alec voice... so sad.
You can feel the pain of Magnus in this scene. Harry is superb!
the hurt in magnus's eyes is so painful to watch,and when he said marriage is a wonderful institution,not that..i would know" it killed my heart,magnus got his heart broken again after it was closed for a 100 years,that must be painful..
What hurts is while Magnus's words are understanding, he is clearly disgusted with Alec's choice of "following your heart is". The first Shadowhunters episode where every Malec scene broke my heart!!
Harry Shum and Matthew Daddario are geniuses! Their acting is on point! This scene break my heart every time I watch it.😭💔 #Shadowhuntersseason2needsmoreMalec
You know what hurts the most here?? Magnus KNEW that he was talking about his marriage to a WOMAN before he even clarified that it is with Lydia. After all, just a few minutes ago Izzy told him that their mother was looking for a bride for Alec. But Magnus still played the flirty coy act of his even though he felt that sharp hurt and disappointment. It almost feels like he was desperate for Alec to joke with him and say “no I’m not getting married”. And Harry is such an amazing actor that you can see the hope in his eyes the first few seconds when they’re talking and then that pain after Alec says that he’s getting married.
I literally could heard Magnus' heart breaking.
From the whole episode...this scene was heartbreaking....I REALLY CRIED...I understand Magnus my baby...YOU ARE HURT😥😥😥😥🙌
"family is everything to me"
WELL, WHEN MAGNUS BECAME PART OF IT WE ALL SAW IT AND I'M STILL CRYING
Is it just me, or Magnus wanted to cry? LOOK AT HIS EYES!!! BABY DON'T CRY. ;.;
Magnus looks great in this scene!
The way Magnus said: that's hot killed me
It was like he wanted to slap Alec for not seeing that he loves him
2:32 Magnus stopping and turning to look back at Alec
'You gotta help me,I'm losing my mind,I'm having this feeling you wanna leave this all behind..'
Magnus’ face when Alec told him he was engaged 😭. Poor Magnus. Harry Shum Jr is an incredible actor.
We will never see another pair on TV as great as this two. There's only one #Malec and Harry Shum Jr. and Matthew Daddario.
I just want to jump into the screen and hug him!
tears and hearts broken 😭😭
the way Magnus thought he was gonna marry him, was so cute and heartbreaking at the same time😭💔 [ik they're married now on the show]
I'm not even in this fandom yet, don't even watch this show and I'm so emotional, not wanting malec be another gay ship who drags me in a fandom but LOOK AT MAGNUS I AM DEAD
shit I already fell
Poor Magnus was so sad inside but still he congrats Alec for wedding 🙁
the moment magnus says "goodbye alexander" there's a music playing at the background. the same music that plays in episode 12 at the scene where alec tells magnus that it's all just a game for him. what's this music? it's beautiful!
Alec really doesn’t have to explain himself, after all Magnus could be counted as “someone he knows” let alone further than an acquaintance, but he try to make Magnus understand the partnership as if he knows it would hurt Magnus, it’s cute how he stumbled through that.
it still gets me every time with magnus.
“That’s why I proposed to Lydia”
Omg his face the heartbreak 😫😭💔
...I want to cry...I am but like I'm not even on this episode yet...;-; Magnus's expression when Alec told him he was getting married broke my heart and I'm just so fucking devastated...
that "good bye alexander" hit me hard kind of
Harry Shum Jr is an incredible actor..
breaks my heart to see magnus dying inside
slow down the video to 0.5 and you could literally see how hurt magnus is
A "solid partnership" that almost broke Magnus heart!!!
1:54 is the moment when Magnus's face tells something like: what's wrong with my gay-radar
That goodbye Alexander hit so hard 😢
I find it good that he sounded like he was joking with the whole date thing. Less embarrassment.
OHH HOW IT HURTS TO SEE MAGNUS LIKE THAT 😭 fuckkk this scene will forever kill me 💔
harry is incredible...
"not that I would know" well you do now
OMG "don't ask, don't tell" BRUH HOW DID I NOT RECOGNISE THIS. He's literally talking about being closeted and shit in the army ima die now
when magnus said "it hurts" i'm crying like a hell,still crying ........
Magnus' laugh could really show that he's broken😭😭😭😭
"What do you want me to give up my life for you?"
Yes honey thats what everybody wants.
2:18 magnus: marriage is a wonderful institution, not that i would know
now you know how it feels and look where you are now baby🤧😭😭😭😭
"Marriage is a wonderful _institution"_ That's a very specific choice of words but it got me thinking... institution, Institute, sounds similar, yes? Magnus definitely know that Alec's engagement is all for the Institute and his family's reputation and he's trying to tell Alec that he knows what this wedding is really about.
Magnus “it’s a solid partnership” chuckles* “that’s HOT” it was sad but kinda funny at the same time
ok just to make clear alec on tells about the engagement to magnus
like lydia started to tell his siblings his parents got to know themselves magnus couldve found out from anyone but he told him himself and i dont know what to make out of this
1:31 I loved that part so much he flirted with him *so* much he was like "You might not be *mine* yet but I am letting everyone know you are MINE."
i notice that after this exchange alec goes to talk to lydia and his feelings waver there. he starts questioning because of the conflict in his head and heart about the situation and magnus. its almost as if magnus saying what he said planted the conflict and created the push alec needed.
The most heartbreaking scene ever
Magnus’s sad laugh :((
I can’t
THIS PAIRING HAS RUINED MY LIFE
Magnus was so broken but so was I
That look on Magnus face wanted me to beat Alex up. And also give Magnus a huggg
It’s like alec wanted to say something after magnus left
Marriage is a wonderful institution....not that I would know
*BABY NOW U KNOW*
Oh my god I could see Magnus hurting inside for a second after Alec said he proposed to Lydia :'( is that just me??
His voice crack in partnership 😫😫
*Sniffs* Goodbye Alexander.....
Omg, you can tell he was about to cry!!! MAGNUS DONT CRY HONEY!!!! ;.;
he broke me heart when He cried,Magnus
Poor magnus 🥺
I honestly cant handle seeing these two heartbroken, and tbh I'm pretty sure were gonna get more of these kinda moments in the future seasons..
2:18 You will know after the final episode of Shadowhunters😏😏
it was so sad, im gonna cry. Alec wake up ! you said it for your family but you make cry everyone :'(
YOU CAN SEE THE PAIN IN HIS EYES
I remember the first time I saw this and I cried all night
It looked like alec wanted to say something as magnus walked away
Lets please talk about the fact that Magnus was more than ready to marry Alec even then.. He was even "fine" with his "traditional family culture "... All he wanted was, look at him saying we should atleast go for a dinner.... 🥺🦋💙