Outlander 4x11 Reaction | If Not for Hope | Review & Breakdown

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 22

  • @MeyaRoseGirl
    @MeyaRoseGirl Рік тому +7

    Minor book changes:
    -Claire, Jamie, and Ian were not that far behind Roger. More on that in later episodes.
    -Much like Jamie's offer back at Helwater, John was slightly tempted by Brianna's proposal because she offered to also bear HIM a child, which would mean he'd have child that mingles his and Jamie's blood. But he didn't seriously consider it because he knew Jamie would absolutely kill him for turning his daughter into the "consort and broodmare to a degenerate sodomite." (I love thinking about the what-if, though, of Bree becoming her brother's stepmother and her children being Willie's nieces/nephews AND step-siblings.)
    -Brianna never considered marrying Forbes, but that was more for his sake than hers because she didn't feel it would be fair to marry someone under false pretenses, but a marriage to John would be entirely honest.
    -Brianna didn't tell them Roger was her husband to give him an out if he didn't want to be father to Bonnet's child. But I do agree, if Jocasta is so convinced that he's dead, then there's no harm in telling everyone Brianna's husband is dead. If he comes back alive, great, they can just say it's a miracle. If not, the baby is no longer considered a bastard, and she doesn't have to marry any of those fools that are obviously after Jocasta's fortune and just think it's a bonus that this beautiful fertile young woman comes with it.
    I mean, ugh, these are the same people that thought Jamie and Claire were so ridiculous for being anti-slavery. It doesn't occur to them that Brianna would have the same "sentiments" even after she told them about her portrait of Phaedre? Or maybe it did, but they figured that once she was married, they could shut her up because legally a wife is not a distinct person but rather an appendage to her husband. *Shudder* Thank Heavens for John giving Brianna the space to carry her child in peace without having to deal with Jocasta's "MacKenzie" machinations.

  • @TerryYelmene
    @TerryYelmene Рік тому +4

    "Briana is more like her mother..." -no truer words, Anna, no truer words!
    I believe once the travel party returned to the village, Roger was being prompted to "run the gauntlet" to become one of the Mohawk.

  • @karingriffin8727
    @karingriffin8727 Рік тому +1

    "No GPS...No Map." 😆

  • @heidibrown3854
    @heidibrown3854 Рік тому +7

    The trial is to see if Roger is a Mohawk or will be a slave

    • @qbasicmichael
      @qbasicmichael Рік тому +1

      Running the gauntlet.

    • @kmuk6276
      @kmuk6276 Рік тому +2

      Yes if He would have made Till the end without ending on the floor, He would have been free.

  • @reneeg9406
    @reneeg9406 21 день тому

    There are few characters, in any story, that equal the champion that is Lord John❤
    He may not be a "main hero"... But he is a champion like no other 🥰

  • @susanstein6604
    @susanstein6604 Рік тому +4

    It wasn’t a fair trial. Roger was hungry and thirsty and exhausted.

  • @Ami_E_Bowen
    @Ami_E_Bowen Рік тому +1

    I'm here to say Jamie Fraser isn't the wonderful man we all think he is. On chapter 5, page 66 of book 3 "Voyager" Jamie drop kicks a little dog! (Well, to be fair he kicked him in the ribs and sent him flying for chasing the chickens and the dog ran off so he was okay)

  • @jacksonlinda5919
    @jacksonlinda5919 Рік тому +1

    I hated Claire's cuddling of 20-year-old Brianna after she had kept a secret from Jamie.

  • @elenadehaan6549
    @elenadehaan6549 Рік тому +5

    she isn't planning on actually marying lord john and he her, it's just to buy time ! :)

  • @dammit_janet
    @dammit_janet Рік тому +1

    Woo! Catching your reaction whilst it's red hot!! Can't wait to see this reaction, quite a few classic moments!

  • @gopherlyn
    @gopherlyn Рік тому +1

    If Roger can succeed in running the gauntlet, then he will become a Mohawk, if he fails then he will remain a captive.

    • @dahlizz99
      @dahlizz99 Рік тому +1

      And it makes sense to have a gauntlet. You don't want to invite weak or cowardly men into the tribe.

  • @deannajones3849
    @deannajones3849 Рік тому +1

    Love watching your reactions!

  • @susanstein6604
    @susanstein6604 Рік тому +1

    Diana Gabaldon can be tough ion her characters kind of like George RR Martin.

  • @conniesandlin6712
    @conniesandlin6712 Рік тому +1

    A really bad Soul Train line 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @susanstein6604
    @susanstein6604 Рік тому

    Psychology didn't in in the 18th century and the word psychology didn't exist.

  • @Siwushwiw
    @Siwushwiw Рік тому

    Your rrr reaction video got blocked

    • @AnnaAlexanderAuthor
      @AnnaAlexanderAuthor  Рік тому

      I woke up and saw it was just blocked. For 5 seconds of the movie. Makes it very difficult to react to foreign films when companies try to claim copyright.