Supreme Court has Succumbed to Executive Control after Modi became PM: Justice Shah | Karan Thapar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 жов 2022
- #karanthapar #thewirenews #cheifjusticeofindia #cji
Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-interview-with-karan-thapar
In an interview where he is sharply critical of the functioning of the Supreme Court since 2014, when Narendra Modi became Prime Minister, and particularly of former Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, the former Chief Justice of the Madras and Delhi High Courts has said that since 2014 the Supreme Court “practically succumbed to the executive’s control”. Justice Ajit Prakash Shah said: “All floodgates opened after CJI Thakur’s retirement”. Justice Shah said of the Supreme Court: “Over the last 8 years the judiciary is completely demoralized and under siege”.
Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. ua-cam.com/channels/hWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQ.htmljoin
Thank you Justice Ajit Prakash Shah, for your insight and your sincerity in revealing malpractices in the judiciary. Hope this brings about correction for the sake of all citizens.
he himself was biased coward capitalist judge who bribed hij way up during congress govt
Chief Justice Ramana only talked but never walked the talk. Unfortunate.
True. He offered lip service only.
True. He as any other judges deal with jihadis and conversion mafia who want to islamise and christianize country. SC judges releasing even Zubair, Rana Ayyubs,Teesta and Azan Khan etc are proofs. Set 2 men bench to solve Hijab issue, how and why!? During CAA agitation they allowed seizure of capital in the name of dissent on a law that was any way adjudicated by them and which is final. Why!?. Should order to clear roads and await their decision, isn't it!? They did when the interlocutors were ridiculed, why!? Their complacesy resulted in mayhem. Blood in their hands actually.
He his a corrupt guy,got lot of property in Hyderabad,read sriram panchu article on him
Andhra C M facing accumulation of assets disproportionate to his declared wealth alleged RTD justice ramanna is corrupt. Politicians are exempt from provisions of IPC and enjoy more privileges is the court gives
Ranjan Gogoi as CJI was meant to set a good example of what a judge should be. He turned out to be a grim warning to the country as to how low the supreme court can fall. It is doubtful any of his successors will stoop so low. The bar is too low.
Appreciate your comments n concerns there in.
History will spit on Ranjsn Gogoi, he is a good example of what a good judge should not be.
Very disturbing.judiciary in most populous democracy.
cowards, collaborators and agents were revealed. many more are hidden.
What stopped Supreme Court from delivering ram mandir judgement until 2019 only when Modi came? Supreme Court was controlled by congress before ?
Cannot imagine living in a Country without a functional 'Justice System'. God have MERCY on the good people of INDIA.🇮🇳 Justice Shah & Karan Sir - thank you both.🍃
😂😂😂😂
Please get out
As you rightly said sir, it's an eye opener on our pathetic judicial system. I feel so insecure.
You can always move to Pakistan
But you seem to be rich and educated
@@ddb0831 what a terribly stupid comment. One day, God forbid , you might get into trouble and the judiciary will not be there to give you some / any/ protection
@@ddb0831 Why Pakistan, wish him well, wish him for places like US, Norwegian country or Canada.
@@ddb0831 you nagpur half knickers,you did not move a inch for India independence except boot 🥾 licking of British,. Tell me one half knicker who fought for India independence
Manmohan Singh said just before demitting office in his exact words : "I do believe that having Mr. Modi, whatever his merit, as the Prime Minister, will be a disaster for India."
Dr Manmohan Singh is an outstanding person, a rare gem👍🙏
He was a good man
The first prophet of 21st century. He was absolutely right about Modi in 2014 and about demonstration in 2016. The country has still not come out of its ill effects on both prophesies.
@arwind sawant, even Adolf Hitler was an undisputed leader in Germany for a long time but the world dreads him even now. Only time will tell what kind of a leader Modi was.
Do you know Dr. Singh's educational qualification? Do you know why he wears a particular shade of blue turban? Modi is a chronic liar. He sold tea at a railway station that did nit exist at that time. He send Advani's picture by e.mail even when the technology was not invented. Needless to talk about Ache din, vikas, fuel price, joblessness, global hunger index ranking, demonitisation et al. What the nation build over six and a half decades was destroyed in less than five years by Modi.
Modi's election twice is good for the nation. After some time electorate will understand the mistake and never ever will it repeat.
Can you please post one poll promise he kept?
Manmohan Singh was right except for his wordings it's disastrous of herculean proportions 🇮🇳👍💐🙏😂
Excellent interview, and superlative research by Mr Thapar. Nicely done.
That interview cam happen only after 2024 in jail.
@@rajmohandutta1814 you are wearing half knicker made in nagpur correct
@@rajmohandutta1814 Hopefully.
@@sureshharinathbabu9717 You are wearing skull cap.
@@sureshharinathbabu9717 and your comment is inspired by librandu lutyens media
Very unfortunate to hear as democratic institutions like judicial system is in danger.
😂😂😂😂
It has been for the last 8 years. When that innocent helpless girl was denied justice, we could see the design. Even her phone was put under pegasus.
@arwind sawant right, it is an international conspiracy- that is why the government is so silent.
We are not under maharaja or badshah
@@LitLotus it is not தமிழ் translation it is written in Tamil version of hindi writing. No use.
Karan another wonderful interview, enjoyed every second of it. Justice Shah is spot on. His views concur the views of many people of this country. If judges of Supreme Courts behave in manners unbecoming, it's a sad day for democracy. Like Justice Shah said , justice must be done and seem to be done too. This perception of fairness of our judges has taken a big hit in the recent times. Hope and pray that our next CJI, Chandrachud will restore the faith of every citizen in our judicial system and that our constitution is in safe hands. Thank you both for this interview.
100% true
Highly rated programme. The Justice speaks honestly and frankly. And so does Karan Thapar ask questions bluntly. The problem is WHO WILL BELL THE CAT? Who will stop the downside?
The judges were entrusted to do it as their job. Their greed and lack of guts is solely responsible for this sorry state today.
@@LitLotus : calling others names is a poor reflection on oneself.
@@LitLotus : I prefer not to reply to comments like this.
@@LitLotus mind your language when communicating with ladies. And yes, truth is very very difficult to digest.
DYC Rockstar - Umeed Hai !
Mr:Karan, why don't you try once again and bring PM to your show? Would be a treat to watch the show..
😂😂👌👌
😂😂😂😂👌👌😜😜
Maunmohan Singh to a show is silent audio less show
Are you crazy sir, if Karan brings the PM for an interview again this time he will pee in his pants an run away within a minute 😂, can you imagine a guy would be able to say a thing when he hasn't given a press conference throughout his 8 years as PM,, no other leader in the world has this dubious distinction 😜😂👌🙏
@@loneranger1265 very well said bro...add one more distinction, changing costumes in a day..😂👍
People were perplexed, demoralised and frightened the way SC and some HC justices were delivering justice.
Judiciary is not under siege, it has been made impotent
Like 56?
Indian Judiciary is itself responsible for any such so called siege. For long Judiciary seems to remain silent on cases pending. Influenced by the top Lawyers, or, Government, or, some influential journalists etc... They allowed themselves to be in the captive of 10 jonpath for their own interest... Now , if any changes happen, it looks like influenced by the Modi Govt as becz people are not accustomed with changes....
Martin Luther King "The ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence over that by the good people."
Salute to Justice A.P. Shah.
If you don't sit silent.... CBI, ED, IT all will come to you....
In a similar manner, good citizens of India maintained total silence during the Sikh Genocide in November 1984.
Why justice j.s.kehar mocked the petition related to Kashmir genocide filed by sushil Pandit?
Lost complete faith in this country'
One of the best interviews ever watched. Thanks to both of you
Thank you so much for your bold journalism I appreciate it very much.
We shall support everything that supports democracy in India.
Most enjoyable interview ever watched on your show Mr Thapar. Keep it up. If judiciary is interfered by the executive, where can a common citizen find Justice? God save our nation.
😂😂😂😂
@@johndoejohnnydoe1477
Country's laughing stock💩💩💩
@@togetservi4342 😂😂😂😂
HATS OFF TO ALL BRAVE HONEST REPORTING!
Excellent, keep it up
Honest my arse. Propaganda, fearmongering, troublemaker, instigator is what Thapar is.
Loved the judge he spoke courageously.few men like him left.🙏
The great journalist Mr. Karan Thapar sir, is excellent interviewer by raising reasonable question s.
excellent and open views of Justice AP Shah who seems to be a thorough gentleman, honest to the core and bold in expressing. Karan brings in-depth analysis by asking right questions. It makes us understand how the judicial system is manipulated by Modi to his advantage to remain in power.
Without doubt judiciary is crushed by the political leaders of Centre and State to carry out their nefarious and corrupted activities, with a paltry allocation of funds. The main reasons for an incompetent judicial system is it's lifeline channel is choked, which is Money/ funds to carry out comprehensive Judicial Reforms. Even NJAC is not Comprehensive. Further additions are required like Manpower Planning on an all india scale is required (Judicial staff, judges and support staff) then we come down to infrastructures/ Court buildings etc, then to Supervision, / inspection Mechanism, watchdog for any deficiency. Better Centre studies world judicial systems and adopts which is best for india, where there is low crime rate and high development Rate.
Mr. Thapar, very nice interview, most required, but can be understood by very limited percentage of citizens as in ENGLISH. IT is most important to have such interviews in HINDI which will make a very big percentage of Indian Citizens understand the facts and accordingly make their minds.
Yes, it would be great if this interview is translated or dubbed in Hindi.
We must congratulate to respected justice Shah for his bold opnion.
He Is commandable and deserves full respect of intellectuals and professional.
An important and interesting interview after a long time. Justice Shah was bold and blunt in his observations and analysis, which are in public interest. We need more such justices to come out in public and expose the misdeeds of the judiciary.
Best intellectual journalism.
i m very sad why he couldn't became CJI.. I have seen very few judges of his quality
Thank you Karan Thapar and Justice Shah. Now I understand many legal aspects as Rafael deal still haunts me till date, the sealed cover, CAG reports Escrow account etc now clarified.
And CAA, Rajya Sabha nominated 2 months after retirement!
BEST OF ALL INTERVIEWER ACCROSS THE GLOBE IE KARAN THAPER--ITS HISTORY
Great interview, Karan! I hope CJI Chandrachud does a lot of good things for the judiciary and I wish him all the best.
Justice should be removed from the name of Mr. Gogoi now for scumming to the power
Thank u Thapar sir for this interview.
The properties of all the judges of all times should be checked!
I don’t think they are any better than corrupt politicians!
If they succumb to any pressure and do like the judge taking rajyasabha as reward then why do we need them!
Just a waste of public exchequer on their luxury without any output!
Aadhar was made voluntary by the Supreme Court but the Executive has made it mandatory ,more recently in the requirement of linkage of Voter's ID to Aadhar. If one raises this point with a government official , it is totally disregarded. Courts and judges's have become inconsequential .
An accused or the accuser can not be also judge and jury. It's against the tenets of justice.
Thanks to Karan Thapar for this great interview of national importance. He was also not interjecting and repeating himself in this interview. Great exercise, hats off to you.
i have a full hope from honourable CJI Dy chandrchude that he will try to change the things which are on old track to preserve the real soul of indian democracy
Absolutely. Hope keeps one going. That there will always be some good people at right time and place and do right things.
this interview is an eye opener sir 👍
What he says it is True and when Naru Mod introduced this change, Wise people like him Warned our Nation..🙏
People are losing faith in our judiciary.
Excellent 👍. Truth and constitution are very vital for the country
Great truth.
Not only law but even order (police, cbi, Ed, etc) is now ruled by an executive. Whether modi or any indian cannot rule this particular administration or council.
A real eye opener.... so sad for this country
Just.Shah stands lone but seems to have done this to save the system . hats off
He has pointed out most of the shortfalls brilliantly
well done justice loving sir Shah and sir Thapar. thank you
Mr. Shah has quoted that during Late Indira Gandhi rule judiciary was weakened. He tends to forget that the judgement went against her, setting aside her election.
Mr. Shah owes a reply...
The Supreme Court was like a mother to the people of India.
Manmohan Singh was right " Modi will be disaster for India" and indeed all educated people who love this country more than BJP, feel the same thing today. He was spot on 🙏
Kareem Khan? Your name says all!! Manmohan Singh has a voice?? Modi is a thinker and doer. India thrives because of him.
Think , speak and act not from a place of fear ... but from a sense of pride , real pride about who you are and where your ancestors come from. IT. DOESN'T Matter if you are a Hindu, Muslim or Christian..
The Bristish and western left have been waging a war to castrate India starting with McCauley.
We have to break the mental shackles imposed on us, and that continues to be impose on us.
Make sure you don't become an unwitting soldier for the Global Left ..else you will get it is wokeism and walking on eggshells where you are afraid to freely speak your mind.
Find out the real meaning of Allah or Krishna or Jesus and work toward the welfare of all.
There are plenty of thugs in BJP as there are in Congress .. but I have come to believe that Modi has the right intentions.
Manmohan is a dummy puppet and the whole world knows it. Just for the sake of clinging to the post of PM.
He sacrificed self respect.
See the people of India have faith in Modi and have given mandate the second time.Respect people's will.These kinds of talks helpnoneexcept Modi bashesrs
@@ddb0831 Thriving under unemployment and high inflation.
David DB. And you are a Modi bhakt.
Mr.Karan I enjoy viewing your episodes . Keep going with the good work.
This is Kalyug Raj and not Ramarajya. Firing someone for taking half day leave
Very able judge. Practised for many years in High Court of Bombay before taking office as judge. Put in a lot of effort to reduce pendency.
It's refreshing to watch such interviews with such daring,fearless interviewers like Karan Thapar,Ravish kumar, punya prasun Bajpayee and such like who are rare species to come across these days.I salute them from my heart.
Justice must not be only done but also be SEEN to be done. Then why sealed covers?
Highly commendable interaction.
Instead of solving quarrels at the initial level, present justice system only encourages endless disputes.
Thank you Karan for the discussion. Hearing Justice Shah has always been a delight 🙏
most daring job done by you dear Mr Thapar. We need to pay more attention in this area of justice. Blatant blundars are committed by these custodians of Jusitce under MODIji. Pathetic and deplorable. Thank you for this courageous interview
Beyond imagination. You certainly deserve appreciation u for asking very bold open and deep acting, investing questions from the person concerned. LIKE IT.
The Parliament of India, Judiciary, especially media, academic institution (JNU), democratic virtues like secularism, unity in diversity, inclusivity, human rights org. non alignment & independent foreign policy were all pivots to the great status and reputation of India in the world & amity of nations uptill 2014. China, pakistan or else, were simply no comparison to india. Unfortunately given the state of affairs today, every international organisation is promptef to downgrade indias standing and indices.
Both participants are ethical in expression making the contents true and one deserving to be emulated 👌🌿🌺👍☘️💐🙏
Very unfortunate
It is heartening to know that every action of judiciary be analysed later and if necessary point out the deficiencies if any.This is needed as a guarantee for constitutional rights.
Courts should all be wound up.it will save huge amount of taxpayers money. People should take law into their hands that is perhaps to settle their differences themselves. And wind up parliaments etc .let people rule themselves directly.
Before 2014 it was said " CBI becomes caged bird " Now which of the institutions are coming under the situation of caged bird plight .......
All institutions
@@ananiyer Now they are using the term collegium to bring.... no swagaa the Judiciary under their control . " A cat goes on pilgrimage after devouring a hundred mice "
Karan --- Can you do a piece on the UK's next PM... I'd love to hear it from you!!
👍🏼❤️🙏🏼 Very unfortunate the pathetic situation of our judiciary☹️
One feels pride in hearing such brilliant and fair judges,
Justice AP Shah, one of the best upright and great judges and also a wonderful person
Thank you Karan ji for a great interview with one of the humble and nicest judges I have seen, Justice AP Shah
There was ray of hope in CJI Ramana tenure, but sadly it was too short..
Shocking State of Affairs! Wonderful, honest and illuminating exposition by Justice A.P. Shah! Where are we headed?
Hope, wish and pray, Hon'ble Justice D Y Chandrachud would usher an era for Court's of Justice's to again pursuing vigorously to upkeep the sanctity and primacy of Constitution of India. The people's dwindling faith in justice would be restored and Judiciary would strongly fight off any move to weaken their credentials and stature. His tenure as next CJI would be very important for strengthening Judicial System in country. 🙏🙏
Agree and wish for the same.
Just scrutinize the American judicial system and there's a way to ensure impartial judges.
The Nation lost precious years to confusion , Lack of priorities , Sale of gods , justice thrown to winds ; wholesale madness , undermining the State and rule of law. All the national institutions are under pressure , which weakened the state. Mother India is hurt very badly.
Your discussion is Excellent but one sided, let other side be given a chance ,to defend his position, then only the discussion will be Completed 🙏
Shame on our Judiciary,.... to whom common man trust ? they r the Big Big Sinners,
Jail is the rule. Bail is the exception ?........Bhima Koregaon and Delhi (engineered) Riots accused are rotting in Jail for so many years without hope of trial at least commencing...let alone concluding.
Mr Thapper, it was a good eye opening interview, it seems such interviews must be continued of the same subject,to open the eyes of the executive or otherwise such shabby situations will keep continuing. NICE👍...... ✍️
on
Fantastic... Thank you very much Respected honourable Justice Shah & Karan Thapar .
With due respect to revered justice Shah ji and anchor Thapar ji ,even for recruitment for govt services from peon to most elite IAS,IPS and alike central and state govt services mandatory minimum ,maximum age,minimum educational ,minimum maximum age,written exam,interview lastly police verification with good character is must.Shockingly nothing such for becoming HEAD of NATION.Most sadly ,root cause is here,unaddressed even by judiciary.Very said.Jai Hind.Bharat Mata Ki Jai.
thanks for sharing The Wire ...
Great interview Mr K Thappar , you are legend, is only you and Ravish Ji who speak very true, it’s good for our country go ahead Sir .
We support yr very credible inquisitive illustrious channel
Karan Thapar is not only a Generalist but in my opinion he is above all & having knowledge more than SC Judges. Karan is most impartial in his generalism.
Nowadays, it has become a fashion that the Hon'ble Judges, makes sensational statements after retirement. Failed to understand that why the same were not expressed when in office? Probably, they were doubtful whether there, other fellow members would support. Whether this is a shortcut? For the sake of argument, it's OK, but it doesn't have really fruitful impact because whatever is said outside courts needs to be substantiated through proper procedures. In other words, Nowadays, it has become a practice, to attempt pressurizing sitting benches.
He has put into words our thoughts!
People like Justice Shah are hopes for common people.
Karan bless you for coming to point in Last for saibaba 😂
Nice interview & thanks to Justice A P Shah for clearly view on unfair practice in judiciary.
Law must be amended urgently and everyone however high he may be including president must be made liable to prosecution and punished as per law if found guilty. PM must be subject to qualifications and other limitations in the light of Modi’s style of governance. Judiciary must be strengthened with right kind of men and not like Gogoi.
Quite an enlightened interview. More people should listen to it. Judiciary's image is high when judicial decisions are taken with fairness and utmost impartiality. Now people are aware of what is happening in the country. People look up to judiciary for justice.
100 guilty may be set free but not one innocent be punished. Well quite a few judges followed it to the last word and set free a lot of rich criminals . Judges are nre not Gods so these should also be under scrutiny .
India flows with Rahul. Time has come for the finals.. 👍👍👍Great people participation. Save Nation rally 👍👍👍Counting the Cause of saving the Nation. What is spending is nothing.. 🙏🙏🙏👍👍👌Manmohanji a best PM for India. Reason for India's economic development. 👍👍.
Now everything in disarray.... 🙄🙄🙄
Looking forward to an interview by you with Indian PM once again
I agree you , I will request Mr K Thappar to interview Modi and Amit Saha
Excellent
Thanku Mr Karan and
Justice A P Shah
Very informative. Thank you
Classic example is judge who made PC go to jail , after retirement made the appellate tribunal chief , the list goes on
God help us .. judiciary is compromised where do normal citizens get justice ..
Mr Dave is extraordinary bold lawyer honest very human kind approachable I wish him good healthy life
Most interesting interview I have ever witnessed on any channel...really an EYE OPENER facts of past eight years...thanks