Ah, was going to ask how people frpm a sunny desert world ended up pale white and if they were underground dwellers, why they spend all thier time aboveground.
@@thalmoragent9344BLACK SUN? ‼️‼️HOLY FUCKING SHIT‼️‼️‼️‼️ IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING TNO REFERENCE??????!!!!!!!!!!11!1!1!1!1!1!1! 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱 TNO IS THE BEST FUCKING MOD 🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯 SABLIN IS SO BLESSEDDD 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎👊👊 BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN 😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩 😩😩😩😩KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPU ‼️‼️HOLY FUCKING SHIT‼️‼️‼️‼️ IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING TNO REFERENCE??????!!!!!!!!!!11!1!1!1!1!1!1! 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱 TNO IS THE BEST FUCKING MOD 🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯 SABLIN IS SO BLESSEDDD 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎👊👊 BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN 😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩 😩😩😩😩KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE🤬😡🤬😡🤬😡🤬🤬😡🤬🤬😡LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY NIXON IS NOT A CROOK! RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Alexei is still alive?!? TICK TOCK FUNNI MAN HAS A MENTAL BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN ❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓SHRIMP BOAT SHRIMP BOAT SHRIMP BOAT So Long...‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂SANE DSR PATH WHEN?
@@thalmoragent9344 it’s implied that everything they consume they buy from off world or produce at great expense in controlled environments. The Harkonnes are essentially slavers rather than producers of industry.
The Harkonnens absolutely reminded me of the Engineers. Not just the production design being reminiscent of H.R. Giger, but the way the people speak AND look.
@@rizzo-filmsfun Fact: Giger worked on the unfinished adaptation in the 70s... He was assigned Geidi Prime and the Harkonens. When the project fell through he took his work elsewhere, and thus, the Xenomorph design came to be.
@@angelusdemorte3 that is pretty cool. I knew about that. I wonder how much Jodorowsky inlfuenced Villeneuve if at all, though Giger's designs have influenced countless films and other mediums since he was popularized in Alien. I wouldn't be suprrised if at least the production design team had some Giger influence on Dune.
I'm not the only one! I feel like sci fi films are going to be heavily influenced by the aesthetics of these films. And that's a good thing. The Engineer home world looked so boring and terrestrial. Star Wars films/shows these days look so plain and uninspired, like a bunch of cosplayers running around on a soundstage. Meanwhile, cosmic MCU films look like cgi rainbow vomit. Anyway, rant over.
@@butterstotch3233Also the first scene of aperture was an surprisingly amazing begin, the scene when that Harkonnen big man goes with his army to where is Paul and the hole final sequence of fight with worms killing Sardhaukar, finishing in Paul's grandpa killing that general Harkonnen.
@@carlosandleon Subtle in that it looks like it could simply be black and white. But there's little details that make it a bit weird. Like how a character's eyes are a little grey or their skin can be slightly translucent and almost look like porcelain.
The gladiator scene with the weird puppet things is *exactly* how imagined a drukhari world from 40k. Just so off and unsettling, something I’ve not experienced in cinema in a long time, if ever
Herbert used Giedi Prime as an allegory warning against the potential costs and dangers of running a military industrial complex driven by fear and greed.
Not necessarily. Dark coloured objects absorb visible light, black the best of all. Vantablack absorbs nearly 100% of light that falls on it hence why a 3D object painted in Vantablack looks like a void with no features.
To say the star absorbed light would be incorrect; instead the correct statement would be, the star only emits lights in the ultraviolet spectrum, or at the ultraviolet end of the spectrum. The star wouldn't be absorbing light in the other spectrums; it simply wouldn't be emitting light in those spectrums. We already know of stars like brown dwarf stars that don't emit much light in the visible spectrum, which is simply a limit of human vision. Other animals are able to see within the ultraviolet spectrum.
If a star emits mostly invisible frequencies of light, with only a little in the visible part of the spectrum, would the light be white? It would be red, right? If it were on the infrared side, or violet, if it were on the ultraviolet end?
@@EzraSolomonecolors are entirely a construct of human perception. Colored light doesn’t exist as like an objective thing, there is just electromagnetic radiation with a spectrum of frequencies and humans happen to be able to perceive of some of them and differentiate between them by perceiving them as colors
@@Jm-wt1fs Yes. Sound, also, is only our perception of compression waves through matter. If I were asking a question about what would be perceived as a result of a mechanical source oscillating at lower frequencies compared to an stylized portrayal of that, I don't know how that fact helps to answer my question.
@@EzraSolomone if the star only emitted a little light, then it would just be dim. If it emitted red light it would be red, like the most common stars in the galaxy red dwarves. So what is the question even bc there is no realistic scenario where a star makes a planet black and white to human eyes lol
@@Jm-wt1fs Having achromatopsia is a realistic scenario where the world would appear monochromatic to human eyes, but my question had nothing to do with that. I'm aware that a "light absorbing star" bleaching the color from a planet makes no sense, and that color only exists through human perception, but thanks. I was only asking how actual stars might appear in certain cases, and I already got my answer.
@@DaDaDo661 black holes absorb EVERYTHING. That’s why light “can’t escape” . I cringe when I see people say incorrect things with confidence like they never bothered to first check…
I think they just worded it wrong. Maybe it just emits certain frequencies of light, although the light is white which means it contains all frequencies of the visible light spectrum. The only way a planet could be black at white like this is if the stuff on the planet only reflects white light, aka, is colorless.
@@chimera916 No, this was an artistic choice by the director. If he had just left it at that without trying to explain it, no one would be talking about it. The book never mentions a "light absorbing star"
@@chimera916You think people couldn't live in terraformed habitats on an otherwise inhospitable world and get everything they need shipped from elsewhere?
@@d-_-b8558your talking about massive infrastructure that would need constant power money and support to keep habitable. What do you think plagues us real life humans in space travel. Needing massive infrastructure to support us for long periods of time. It would be extremely costly.
On a practical level from the audience perspective, what was the difference between shooting in infrared compared to just black and white? It seems like they went through a hell of a lot of trouble just to film in infrared, but to the uninformed viewer, it really just looks black and white. So why go through the trouble of it?
black and white wouldn't look the same at all. I know that sounds silly because this looks black and white, but the infrared gives effects and details that a regular film with black and white filter wouldn't give
The infrared gave milkier highlights, and created a very translucent look on the skin tones, especiallt for feyd and barron. Theire eyes also have a tranlucency to it. The subtelty of the infrared photography allowed for smoother highlight falloff and textures.
It doesn’t look anything like black and white film, I assumed it had gone through a bizarre color correction process that the cinematographer dreamed up. This is way more nuts.
Alia was in the film and had dialogue from inside the womb which I thought was a more interesting way to show what she was like in the books. Peter Jackson showed us that you don’t have to follow every letter of every chapter to create a brilliant while still mostly faithful adaptation of a classic. With a series like Dune that already had a huge following you weren’t going to please everyone. But as a fan of the books I think this and the first film brought Arrakis to life vividly in the ways I personally imagined the scenes when reading them. Changing Kynes to a female and adding more discord to the romance doesn’t ruin Dune.
@@dylanmorgan2752 Right, changing Kynes to a female, making it so Chani isn’t their daughter, making it so Chani is at complete odds with Stilgar who was her UNCLE, completely ixnaying the child Paul and Chani had at seitch Tab’r, which was killed, which was the entire reason Paul drank the waters of life, who WAS NOT EGGED ON BY THEIR MOTHER TO DO SO! Who had not been told anything about the Kwisatz Haderach until he told his mother that he knew about it. Also the Bene Gesserit had no current ties to the planet, the mysteries and lore having been passed down by the reverend mother who had crash landed with the original people who eventually became the fremen, who most certainly did not have a “fundamentalist” group living in the south. Yeah it’s one thing to take out a few plot points or gloss over certain things, but they completely destroyed the Vaunted warrior poet Gurney Halleck and removed everything that made him an amazing character. Honestly they were so far off the plot that at the end I was surprised they actually finished the first book. They cut out so much, and yet somehow padded it out into a bloated 3 hour monstrosity. I think they could have cut the last hour out and made a 3rd 2 hour movie that could have been a lot better. So many main characters were just glossed over it isn’t even funny.
@@juangonzalez9848 I feel our definitions of 'main characters' are vastly different. Gurney's poetry and balliset playing are referenced several times across the 2 films. You believe the film was too long but want every minute detail including alongside the entire Chani childbirth. Both films make multiple mentions to the Bene Gesserit having spread propaganda for centuries. As well as the Kwisatz Haderach being mentioned. Saying there was no fundamentalist movement in the book is also a major stretch, it being a prime way to show why Paul's Fedaykin are assembled so quickly during a period that even the writer glossed over when he jumps straight from learning their ways to 2 years in the future. Fundamentalist groups are an easier way to convey the radicalism of the Fremen leading up to the jihad. If you have this many problems with how the story was told is a sign of going into something looking for every minor fault. My main focus was does the overall greatness of the Dune plot get ruined by omission? not really. You could ultimately count a thousand things they dropped from the book that weren't worth mentioning in the medium of film where you have worry more about pacing. Tom Bombadil was cut from LOTR because they were already 3 hours long and removing him didn't impact the overall story of LOTR. Same way them spending an extra ten minutes talking about the polar ice caps and the water smugglers doesn't really need to happen. Ultimately did Villeneuve create an amazing piece of cinema? Yes. Did he pay homage to plot and include most of the main strokes of the story? Yes.
@@dylanmorgan2752 No, I don’t want every minute detail from the books included, what I want is for it to not be completely and utterly ignored. Chani and Paul had a child, whose death was a pivotal point in Paul deciding to take the waters of life. His mother at no point in time prior to that egged him into that in the book. Chani was also not anti reverend mother in the book, which she is in the movie. Shit, she was training to be the next reverend mother in the book. Why did they do a complete 180 in this movie with her? She was completely loyal to Paul in the book and understood that he had to have a political marriage, now she’s running away in frustration and anger. That’s not a minor difference in plot man, that is a major direction shift. Also, the Fedaykin in the movie were a thing, and guess what, they weren’t part of the bloody fundamentalist movement. I’m just saying that they did not come even close to following the plot at the end of part 2. It’s one thing to not have Alia be the one to kill Baron Harkonen, it’s another thing entirely to completely change the relationship dynamic of the actual main characters.
@@juangonzalez9848 I think the changes are meant for "a modern audience" and are ultimately rooted in ideological motivation. Cinematography was great, though.
There were many things I liked in Dune 2. But this small segment alone was enough to tell me that it was best Movie I saw in Cinema for a very long tine.
Astrophysically, a sun that emits mostly infra-red would be the size of a brown dwarf, so about 300 times bigger than Jupiter but 20,000 smaller than a main sequence star (emits regular light) . To explain the night/day phenomenon on Geidi Prime, an atmospheric filter ( a gaseous troposphere on GP) would be excited by the infra-red emissions thereby causing more visible light in the atmosphere to generate daylight, the gas would then cool off by night as it is no longer exposed to the star. Sounds like this effect has been manufactured on Geidi Prime or they would just live in relative darkness ( akin to the book and the 1984 movie).
I thought the color choice is interesting as well. The greyscale, almost monochromatic. The Harkonnen built a civilization that's so binary. Black & White. The rulers are painted in bright white. Despite how dark their practice is. The contrast is so freaking great. Just love it.
It's black and white, like our first pictures and films, but it's not the lowest level of technology, it's the highest we have. That we've advanced so much but essentially wound back up in the beginning, is a huge theme in the Dune universe.
The inkblot fireworks were my favorite
That was so creative! This movie was just amazing.
Made me wonder if such looking fireworks are possible
Exactly 💯 that was the illest shot and scene of the year.
@@flashgordon6510this movie was ass
@@zyourzgrandzmaz100% chance you are under the age of 16. If not, you have the equivalent critical thinking skills of that age range
To be clear their sun doesn't absorb light. It simply emits very little visible light but mostly infrared frequencies.
I love your profile picture :D
Thank you for the clarification, I just couldn’t get past the physics of a light absorbing sun.
@@ethio6308 SPACESHIP!
My SAD wouldn't survive 2 seconds being on that planet LMFAO
Ah, was going to ask how people frpm a sunny desert world ended up pale white and if they were underground dwellers, why they spend all thier time aboveground.
In the book, the planet is described as having a "low photosynthetic potential," which it loks like it does
Wonder what plants would look like with a Black Sun 🤔
@@thalmoragent9344BLACK SUN? ‼️‼️HOLY FUCKING SHIT‼️‼️‼️‼️ IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING TNO REFERENCE??????!!!!!!!!!!11!1!1!1!1!1!1! 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱 TNO IS THE BEST FUCKING MOD 🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯 SABLIN IS SO BLESSEDDD 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎👊👊 BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN 😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩 😩😩😩😩KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPU
‼️‼️HOLY FUCKING SHIT‼️‼️‼️‼️ IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING TNO REFERENCE??????!!!!!!!!!!11!1!1!1!1!1!1! 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱 TNO IS THE BEST FUCKING MOD 🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯 SABLIN IS SO BLESSEDDD 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎👊👊 BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN BLACKSUN 😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩 😩😩😩😩KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE KISHIPURGE🤬😡🤬😡🤬😡🤬🤬😡🤬🤬😡LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY LBJALLTHEWAY NIXON IS NOT A CROOK! RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED RFK BLESSED Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Yo Speer! 🇩🇪 Alexei is still alive?!? TICK TOCK FUNNI MAN HAS A MENTAL BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN ❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓❓SHRIMP BOAT SHRIMP BOAT SHRIMP BOAT So Long...‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂SANE DSR PATH WHEN?
@@thalmoragent9344 it’s implied that everything they consume they buy from off world or produce at great expense in controlled environments. The Harkonnes are essentially slavers rather than producers of industry.
Personally, I'm under the impression that there is no foliage or plant-life on Geidi Prime, just from what I've seen of/read about it.
It was polluted by careless implementation of heavy industry. That was corrected over time post-Harkonnen rule.
Feyds birthday scene was actually a Taylor Swift concert in greyscale
😂😂😂😂😂 yassss
😂
less evil
Taylor: "In my Prime (Giedi) era..."
...takes shaver to hair...
@@jonathantan2469 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The entire Geidi Prime sequence was jaw dropping.
Right? I couldn't get enough of it
I literally couldn't put it back in😮
@@xenadonau8356...'what' in 'where'?!
@@Rosskles the "jaw" in "place"
@@xenadonau8356 oh god right 🤣🤣
Austin butler, everything jared leto wanted to be
Ouch. 🫣 So true though. 😅
you just casually delt Jared Leto +10 psychic damage
jared leto is literally an oscar winning actor lol
@@vabp8985 Super undeserving. He was insanely stereotypical in that movie - he's a terrible actor.
@@vabp8985 and Barbie's an oscar winning movie
This scene was other-worldly... Reminiscent of Alien's Engineer starkness.
It’s not a coincidence it’s the same guy who designed these things
The Harkonnens absolutely reminded me of the Engineers. Not just the production design being reminiscent of H.R. Giger, but the way the people speak AND look.
@@rizzo-filmsfun Fact: Giger worked on the unfinished adaptation in the 70s... He was assigned Geidi Prime and the Harkonens. When the project fell through he took his work elsewhere, and thus, the Xenomorph design came to be.
^
@@angelusdemorte3 that is pretty cool. I knew about that. I wonder how much Jodorowsky inlfuenced Villeneuve if at all, though Giger's designs have influenced countless films and other mediums since he was popularized in Alien. I wouldn't be suprrised if at least the production design team had some Giger influence on Dune.
It looks like a planet that the engineers from Prometheus should be from.
It does! I was thinking about them when I first saw it.
David?
I'm not the only one! I feel like sci fi films are going to be heavily influenced by the aesthetics of these films. And that's a good thing. The Engineer home world looked so boring and terrestrial. Star Wars films/shows these days look so plain and uninspired, like a bunch of cosplayers running around on a soundstage. Meanwhile, cosmic MCU films look like cgi rainbow vomit. Anyway, rant over.
Same art from jodorowskys dune book from the 70s . All giger original art
@@Bvggerffplsthey all are from Jodorowskys Dune art book thats been the template for every sci fi/ fantasy film since its release
My favorite sequence in the entire film
Dude same 😮
Not like there're many as good as it.
This one is the best in the movie hands down
@@WestLegend03Idk the entire knife fight was pretty great and Paul riding the grandfather sand worm
@@butterstotch3233Also the first scene of aperture was an surprisingly amazing begin, the scene when that Harkonnen big man goes with his army to where is Paul and the hole final sequence of fight with worms killing Sardhaukar, finishing in Paul's grandpa killing that general Harkonnen.
Every damn shot was a masterpiece
I love this look. It’s so subtle, yet overpowering at the same time.
Subtle??????!
@@carlosandleon Subtle in that it looks like it could simply be black and white. But there's little details that make it a bit weird. Like how a character's eyes are a little grey or their skin can be slightly translucent and almost look like porcelain.
@@danielterrell2191 Like what the average baby camera does
Subtle my ass
@@carlosandleon An infrared camera was used to get that effect. How is that an average baby camera?
The fireworks were trippy
Fr
That effect made that sequence so memorable. It added to the feeling of it all. Such a great movie!
Sad Austin Butler left too early, his character was so good
Omg that IS him!! I kept trying to place his face. 😂😂😂🤦🏽♀️
Fr I wanted to see more of him
You fought well, Atredies
Really? I thought he was cheesy as hell. Sounds like it’s just me though.
@@itypewithmykneecaps1 he was cringe to me. Gave me “the ick”. But maybe that’s how he was supposed to be?
I will never forget the scene when suddenly dune became a rave colosseum
It reminds me while trying to see things in darkness only greyscale could be seen instead of colours.
That is how night vision works. The. Colour cones of the eye need more like than the black and white rods
First time an english speaker is pronouncing correctly Denis Villeneuve's name
First time in the history of pronouncing names🙏
😂😂😂
I can pronounce it correctly
With respect I have seen mispronunciation by a few American English UA-cam critics but not (so far) from ‘British’ English ones.
Ahhh French.
an obnoxious amount of letters added to words to just not pronounce them, then ridicule those who do.
The euro equivalent to AAVE 😂😂
@@ArtOfRuin981 You nailed it!! Why have letters there that are silent and won’t be pronounced, it’s ridiculous and unnecessary 😭
"I love that scene"
"Which one?"
"The one scene that's a montage of the entire movie"
What is the name of the movie
@@ghadeersyriac Darude - Sandstorm
Oh boy did they succeed! That scene is incredible and gave me goosebumps!!
"May thy knife... chip and shatter."
"May THY knife chip and chatter."
Giedi Prime gave me such visceral reactions
The imagery in this film was on another level. I would have never imagined coming up with something even close to their depiction of Giedi Prime
When it transitioned to b/w I knew this is gonna be the best film I've watched from the theatres.
Watching fireworks go off in that scene really messed with my head; I loved it!
That was weird as hell
I literally went to pee right at that moment in the theatre and missed it lol
I was today years old when I learned that the DP for Dune also did Zero Dark 30. Yeah that makes a lot of sense
He also did The Batman.
greg fraiser is insane, his resume is flawless
His other work includes The Batman and Rogue One
@@sxham04His resume definitely has flaws. Unless you consider Snow White & The Huntsman and The Gambler with Mark Wahlberg good movies.
@@Largentina.Those movies look pretty good he probably just did what the director asked of him which is his job
The gladiator scene with the weird puppet things is *exactly* how imagined a drukhari world from 40k. Just so off and unsettling, something I’ve not experienced in cinema in a long time, if ever
Giedi Prime gave me nazi germany vibes
Herbert used Giedi Prime as an allegory warning against the potential costs and dangers of running a military industrial complex driven by fear and greed.
Which is on purpose, the director said he wanted it to look like a WW2 fascist movie
Yup.
Do the LGBT army give you the same vibes?
@@DartFrog815 rent-free
"a star that doesn't emit light, it absorbed it."
So a black hole?
Not exactly, because it ain't attract more things than light. I never think that as possible but not sounds as very uncapable of exist.
Not necessarily. Dark coloured objects absorb visible light, black the best of all. Vantablack absorbs nearly 100% of light that falls on it hence why a 3D object painted in Vantablack looks like a void with no features.
Probably a neutron star. Doesn't absorb light as such but emits very little
Ya, idk what they're talking about. I don't think they do either
@@alanmountain5804 You cannot live near a neutron star, the radiatiin would destroy every life on the planet
People with brown eyes have glowing eyes in infrared light
And people with blue eyes just get dark eyes right?
The entire harkonnen part of the movie in the second half was darkly magical 🖤
I'm glad I watched this movie in the theater. I missed the first movie and only saw it at home.
Same and same. So I had to see Dune Part 2 twice!
Same here. Imax Dune 2 was amazing
The visuals in this adaptation were PERFECT
It had real "Triumph of the Will" vibes
That ash white cube ball reminds me of the Engineer from Promethius. 👽👾👽
Cue ball
well... "COME GET YOOOOOOOOOO DINNER"
5 more minutes mom
Those black & white fireworks were the cherry on the top.
So that’s why Shane Gillis says the movie looks like a cologne commercial 😂
The books explain the planet as bleak, massive regions that are inhospitable, industrial, and gray. I think the movie makers did a great job here.
Yes, I did know. Did You know, Hoyte van Hoytema used the Same technique for the moon chase scene in Ad Astra?
This movie was a spectacle, both in appearance and substance
The scene on Giedi Prime was a badass nuar 🔥
It's beautiful. I kept watching it because the scenes, the score, the people, are just so pretty.
To say the star absorbed light would be incorrect; instead the correct statement would be, the star only emits lights in the ultraviolet spectrum, or at the ultraviolet end of the spectrum. The star wouldn't be absorbing light in the other spectrums; it simply wouldn't be emitting light in those spectrums. We already know of stars like brown dwarf stars that don't emit much light in the visible spectrum, which is simply a limit of human vision. Other animals are able to see within the ultraviolet spectrum.
If a star emits mostly invisible frequencies of light, with only a little in the visible part of the spectrum, would the light be white? It would be red, right? If it were on the infrared side, or violet, if it were on the ultraviolet end?
@@EzraSolomonecolors are entirely a construct of human perception. Colored light doesn’t exist as like an objective thing, there is just electromagnetic radiation with a spectrum of frequencies and humans happen to be able to perceive of some of them and differentiate between them by perceiving them as colors
@@Jm-wt1fs Yes. Sound, also, is only our perception of compression waves through matter. If I were asking a question about what would be perceived as a result of a mechanical source oscillating at lower frequencies compared to an stylized portrayal of that, I don't know how that fact helps to answer my question.
@@EzraSolomone if the star only emitted a little light, then it would just be dim. If it emitted red light it would be red, like the most common stars in the galaxy red dwarves. So what is the question even bc there is no realistic scenario where a star makes a planet black and white to human eyes lol
@@Jm-wt1fs Having achromatopsia is a realistic scenario where the world would appear monochromatic to human eyes, but my question had nothing to do with that. I'm aware that a "light absorbing star" bleaching the color from a planet makes no sense, and that color only exists through human perception, but thanks. I was only asking how actual stars might appear in certain cases, and I already got my answer.
When I first saw this I was in complete awe.
The star that absorbs light usually called a Black Hole
Yep, and I do see light after all.
Back holes don't absorb light, it just can't escape
@@DaDaDo661 black holes absorb EVERYTHING. That’s why light “can’t escape” .
I cringe when I see people say incorrect things with confidence like they never bothered to first check…
no
Damn that's awesome. I thought they just put a black and white filter over it lol
If the sun absorbs light then hows everyone see when they go outside, and whats making the light so they can see to fight
I think it ain't absorb ALL THE WHOLE LIGHT, just much of it or instead would be just dark as hell.
It's didn't obsorb the infared light
I think they just worded it wrong. Maybe it just emits certain frequencies of light, although the light is white which means it contains all frequencies of the visible light spectrum. The only way a planet could be black at white like this is if the stuff on the planet only reflects white light, aka, is colorless.
@@EzraSolomone So, in less words: Dune is stupid.
No complex life could survive in such a world, and there are no stars like this.
@@chimera916 No, this was an artistic choice by the director. If he had just left it at that without trying to explain it, no one would be talking about it. The book never mentions a "light absorbing star"
One of my favorite parts of the movie for sure
i thought it was censorship from the cinema because of the bloody fight and age restrictions. either way, the dark vibe in this movie is insanely good
If so, then the creative team absolutely turned a weakness into a strength.
When the sisters walked into the black sunlight with their dresses was amazing.
As far as science knows… no life could exist around a star like this…
It's true, but Dune is stupid.
Good thing this is science fiction then eh 😂
@@chimera916You think people couldn't live in terraformed habitats on an otherwise inhospitable world and get everything they need shipped from elsewhere?
@@d-_-b8558your talking about massive infrastructure that would need constant power money and support to keep habitable. What do you think plagues us real life humans in space travel. Needing massive infrastructure to support us for long periods of time. It would be extremely costly.
Do you think science fiction is real? Please, this is a story that include giant sandworms, don't expect the 'science' to be real
the fireworks imploding like " contained joy " was awesome too
On a practical level from the audience perspective, what was the difference between shooting in infrared compared to just black and white? It seems like they went through a hell of a lot of trouble just to film in infrared, but to the uninformed viewer, it really just looks black and white. So why go through the trouble of it?
black and white wouldn't look the same at all. I know that sounds silly because this looks black and white, but the infrared gives effects and details that a regular film with black and white filter wouldn't give
The infrared gave milkier highlights, and created a very translucent look on the skin tones, especiallt for feyd and barron. Theire eyes also have a tranlucency to it. The subtelty of the infrared photography allowed for smoother highlight falloff and textures.
Lighting was infrared not the camera
@@jimboh.2654 the camera was also modified to only see infrared
It doesn’t look anything like black and white film, I assumed it had gone through a bizarre color correction process that the cinematographer dreamed up. This is way more nuts.
All of those scenes are perfect and preeminent in the film history
Isn’t it like that in the books?
Nope, it's a movie only thing.
Also the Harkonnens are gingers in the books and not Bald like in these movies.
@@dhyaankotian4672 An understandable change 😂
I like this z makes them more menacing
@@TheGlassMonty I like zis , make zit more manacing
@dhyaankotian4672 the gingers would have been scarier. Lol
Watch this in theaters if you haven't already. Incredible visuals and sound.
A star that absorbs light instead of emitting it is impossible. Unless it’s a black hole, which you wouldn’t be able to orbit anyway.
I'm pretty sure it absords certain wavelengths of its own light. Meaning that it does emit light, just not like a normal star.
Black holes can be orbited easy tho
Giant sand worms are impossible too
Damn it's almost like it's a fictional story
What? You can easily orbit a black hole without any issues... what are you talking about?
i love that the reason why is also a metaphor💀
No Alia, a grumpy and weirdly twisted Chani who has no chemistry with Muad' Dib. . . This was cinematic awesome but a mangled, disappointing story.
Alia was in the film and had dialogue from inside the womb which I thought was a more interesting way to show what she was like in the books. Peter Jackson showed us that you don’t have to follow every letter of every chapter to create a brilliant while still mostly faithful adaptation of a classic. With a series like Dune that already had a huge following you weren’t going to please everyone. But as a fan of the books I think this and the first film brought Arrakis to life vividly in the ways I personally imagined the scenes when reading them. Changing Kynes to a female and adding more discord to the romance doesn’t ruin Dune.
@@dylanmorgan2752
Right, changing Kynes to a female, making it so Chani isn’t their daughter, making it so Chani is at complete odds with Stilgar who was her UNCLE, completely ixnaying the child Paul and Chani had at seitch Tab’r, which was killed, which was the entire reason Paul drank the waters of life, who WAS NOT EGGED ON BY THEIR MOTHER TO DO SO! Who had not been told anything about the Kwisatz Haderach until he told his mother that he knew about it. Also the Bene Gesserit had no current ties to the planet, the mysteries and lore having been passed down by the reverend mother who had crash landed with the original people who eventually became the fremen, who most certainly did not have a “fundamentalist” group living in the south.
Yeah it’s one thing to take out a few plot points or gloss over certain things, but they completely destroyed the Vaunted warrior poet Gurney Halleck and removed everything that made him an amazing character.
Honestly they were so far off the plot that at the end I was surprised they actually finished the first book. They cut out so much, and yet somehow padded it out into a bloated 3 hour monstrosity. I think they could have cut the last hour out and made a 3rd 2 hour movie that could have been a lot better. So many main characters were just glossed over it isn’t even funny.
@@juangonzalez9848 I feel our definitions of 'main characters' are vastly different. Gurney's poetry and balliset playing are referenced several times across the 2 films. You believe the film was too long but want every minute detail including alongside the entire Chani childbirth. Both films make multiple mentions to the Bene Gesserit having spread propaganda for centuries. As well as the Kwisatz Haderach being mentioned. Saying there was no fundamentalist movement in the book is also a major stretch, it being a prime way to show why Paul's Fedaykin are assembled so quickly during a period that even the writer glossed over when he jumps straight from learning their ways to 2 years in the future. Fundamentalist groups are an easier way to convey the radicalism of the Fremen leading up to the jihad. If you have this many problems with how the story was told is a sign of going into something looking for every minor fault. My main focus was does the overall greatness of the Dune plot get ruined by omission? not really. You could ultimately count a thousand things they dropped from the book that weren't worth mentioning in the medium of film where you have worry more about pacing. Tom Bombadil was cut from LOTR because they were already 3 hours long and removing him didn't impact the overall story of LOTR. Same way them spending an extra ten minutes talking about the polar ice caps and the water smugglers doesn't really need to happen. Ultimately did Villeneuve create an amazing piece of cinema? Yes. Did he pay homage to plot and include most of the main strokes of the story? Yes.
@@dylanmorgan2752
No, I don’t want every minute detail from the books included, what I want is for it to not be completely and utterly ignored. Chani and Paul had a child, whose death was a pivotal point in Paul deciding to take the waters of life. His mother at no point in time prior to that egged him into that in the book. Chani was also not anti reverend mother in the book, which she is in the movie. Shit, she was training to be the next reverend mother in the book. Why did they do a complete 180 in this movie with her? She was completely loyal to Paul in the book and understood that he had to have a political marriage, now she’s running away in frustration and anger. That’s not a minor difference in plot man, that is a major direction shift. Also, the Fedaykin in the movie were a thing, and guess what, they weren’t part of the bloody fundamentalist movement.
I’m just saying that they did not come even close to following the plot at the end of part 2. It’s one thing to not have Alia be the one to kill Baron Harkonen, it’s another thing entirely to completely change the relationship dynamic of the actual main characters.
@@juangonzalez9848 I think the changes are meant for "a modern audience" and are ultimately rooted in ideological motivation. Cinematography was great, though.
The entire 2 movies feel like a few desert scenes but that one gladiator fight one.
Ugh, but that bald-cap on what’s his name was janky AF.
The world-building and creation from the cinematography, SFX to the costumes and acting were next level, everyone brought their A-game to this :)
Bro I guess zendaya has to kiss on every guy she’s in a movie with now, rip Tom
How is that different from every other actor whose movie has a romance arc?
Duh she's an actress she has to kiss while acting or she'd probably lose her job
There were many things I liked in Dune 2. But this small segment alone was enough to tell me that it was best Movie I saw in Cinema for a very long tine.
Don’t worry if you watch the trailer, you watch the three hour movie😂
So that’s why is looks well lit and dark at the same time.
I was so impressed with how they presented Geidi Prime and the Harkonnens. Surpassed my highest expectations.
This and the sandworms' knockout entrance into battle were my favorite scenes
I was surprised at how jacked and chiseled Austin Butler was💀
Geidi Prime is such a badass name
this kind of effect is thousand more cool in The Zone of Interest, maybe even millions
Best movie of the last 20 years! 😍
Best picture 2024. Hands down.
I’m going to have to rewatch the whole thing now
Giedi Prime sequence was insane, and Austin Butler’s presence is what made it work.
Amazing cinematic work. Always dreamed of creating something close. Next lifetime ❤
The transition from colour to monochrome was orgasmic
Astrophysically, a sun that emits mostly infra-red would be the size of a brown dwarf, so about 300 times bigger than Jupiter but 20,000 smaller than a main sequence star (emits regular light) . To explain the night/day phenomenon on Geidi Prime, an atmospheric filter ( a gaseous troposphere on GP) would be excited by the infra-red emissions thereby causing more visible light in the atmosphere to generate daylight, the gas would then cool off by night as it is no longer exposed to the star. Sounds like this effect has been manufactured on Geidi Prime or they would just live in relative darkness ( akin to the book and the 1984 movie).
New look? More like expanded on the descriptions and tones of Herbert, awesome.
The Apex of the Dune2.
I thought the color choice is interesting as well. The greyscale, almost monochromatic. The Harkonnen built a civilization that's so binary. Black & White. The rulers are painted in bright white. Despite how dark their practice is. The contrast is so freaking great. Just love it.
idubbbz character in suns 2 was my favorite
Basically, “did you guys know that Denis Villanueve literally invented black and white filming”
It's black and white, like our first pictures and films, but it's not the lowest level of technology, it's the highest we have. That we've advanced so much but essentially wound back up in the beginning, is a huge theme in the Dune universe.
This was the greatest movie of all time.
Amazing how they made a human society look and feel so alien
You’re the first reviewer I hear pronounce the name Villeneuve correctly 👏🏾
The dark vibes in this scene is something really different.
This movie is legendary.
It's not a "sun"... there's only one Sun, this is a star.
The Harkonnens in the new Dune movie look like the Guild from the 1984 Dune movie
Absolutely love the bleakness of the harkonnens i was completely enthralled with this scene and the whole planet, really
Feyd made the movie for me. All the scenes on Giedi Prime were the best.
def go watch this in the theaters! Was a good one
Who would settle around such a star?
Beautiful film my favourite of 24
harkanen arena scene was a blast!!!!!11
Bro looks like judge Holden
I definitely assumed it was a black and white flashback as they rushed through the plot 😂
bro you're so underrated
I still haven't fully absorbed Part Two, but I just feel like watching it over and over again.