I went down this rabbit hole deep…It started in 1987 when I bought a Jubilee 4x12 with the Vintage speakers as an upgrade….These were the very first “V30’s”….they were built exclusively for Marshall,and still are to this day…Marshall first put these in the Studio 15 in about 1986,but they really rolled them out with the Jubilee series in 87….Celestion came out with the “off the shelf”version,but the Marshall one was and is THE original design of the V30…Celestion has changed the design many times over the years to make them easier to produce,but the Marshall design is proprietary to them….Mesa got a production run for themselves in the 90’s when Celestion changed the design again,and Mesa wanted to keep the same version as before……I went on a binge,and ended up with sets of 1987’s..1993’s…1998’s…2000’s…2003’s and finally 2019’s…..They are my favorite speakers ever,and I much prefer the original Marshall version to all the others….and they do sound different…so when someone says,I hate V30’s,I always say,which ones?..
I have a 2554 SJ combo from 1987. Love that little massive amp. I also have a comparatively new cab from Thomann with 'V30' in.I use it for my Helix and for my SV20. I love both.
The speakers are all the same spec, same thing. The differences we all hear are really simple to explain. 1) older speakers that have been broken in sound better 2) ALL speakers off the assembly line do not come out exactly the same. You can have two speakers sequentially right off the assembly line sounding audibly different. I know how tempting it is to believe in this myth that there is ONE perfect V30 and all the rest are bad or not as good. It isn't that simple. There is no actual way of determining X so called version of the V30 is better than all the rest, I can find you a cabinet right now with the Marshall labeled V30, hell it can be one from 87 that hasn't been played, and it CAN I PROMISE you. sound like total shit. There is no magical guarantee because it says marshall on it that it will be better. The marshall versions were made to 16 ohms. Most other V30 cabs are fitted with 8 ohm versions. That is an ACTUAL difference, but I have a feeling no one wants to hear that. Anyway good luck everyone lol
Make this as clear as I possibly can. The ACTUAL reason for anyone curious about why even are there these V30's with different labels/names put on them? It's really simple. Amplifier brands buy huge stocks of speakers, For example with the marshall version, they wanted all of them to 16 ohms. Mesa, wanted them all in 8 ohm. Thats it guys. Thats literally are there is to it. The amp brands buy their stock of speakers, if the speakers WERE actually different, THEY WOULD TELL YOU. Hughes and kettner had bought V30's to their spec for their cabs many moons ago, where there was an actual difference, they used the celestion lead cones instead of bass cones.
@@colelewis9940 the Marshall and Mesa V30’s are made in the UK,the regular versions are made in China…Marshall has their own “T”number for the production line….In 1987 ALL of the G12 Vintage’s were 8ohm speakers in the Jubilee 4x12 cabs…..The V30 was exclusive to Marshall in the beginning….they still are….I have many sets from many different era’s….The Marshall G1230 sounds very,very different from a standard Celestion V30..,it’s not just a the same speaker with a different sticker slapped on it…
I vastly prefer the Marshall G12 Vintage, here and in person. I’ve played Chinese V30s, the Mesa V30s, and the Marshall versions, and every time, the Marshall comes out on top. The Marshall G12 Vintage has plenty of the V30 high-end chirp and high-mid grind and is plenty aggressive, but without the honk and harsh mess of the other two. Full disclaimer: I’ve played a bunch of amps through these speakers, but only played my Bogner Ecstasy 3534 through all three speakers, and generally go for a high-gain sound that has snarl but a fuller bottom end. Euge captured the differences really well and confirmed again why I prefer the Marshall version.
Thank you (and your comparison) I put Marshall Vintage + V30EN 90's in my 2x12 cab, now it sounds amazing. Thank you so much for your reviews and comparisons.
The Rabbit hole of V30's is there are different variations like the Mesa OEM V30 which I use exclusively ;) Short story: my 2nd cab I purchased new in the late 90's is a Marsh Vintage 4x12 with the marsh v30's and a friend had a Trace Elliot 4x12 cab with UK V30's and we compared them and I like the Trace cab speakers better for some reason and so we decided to swap all four speaks and I still have the UK V30's from that cab dated 1995 and they sound great still all these years and sound really close if not the same as the Mesa OEM V30's (16ohm variant btw). I wish I kept the Marsh V30's still only because it's so hard to find them for sale without having to have to buy a used or new cab to get them!!! Great video like always and interesting to hear the differences between V30's. Rock on! \m/
＞The height of each speaker from the floor will influence the sound. The speaker closer to the floor should have more low mids and more lows. That's not accurate. The lower the speaker, the closer to the wall, the lower the bass
The Celestion V30 has such nice mids. They are my favourite speaker. I will never get rid of my old Mesa oversized 4 X 12 cabinet. I noticed the greenbacks in that cabinet, those are my 2nd favourite speaker. The greenbacks are the best speaker for a Marshall head IMO. Just like the V30 works perfectly with a Mesa head the Greenback I think is the perfect speaker for a Marshall head.
I like both a lot but mainly I use Vs with my JCM800s and GBs with my Plexi 👌. But both work really well in almost any given situation with all my amps.
Both sounded really good. My 4x12 cab has Celestion G12k-85's. Which sound darker to me, but I like them. They are not harsh on the highs. Easy to EQ a good chunky tone. We get used to whatever speakers we have. Our ears adjust to them over time. We start to accept their tone as being "normal", because it is familiar. But like you always say...... if it sounds good, then it's good.
Excellent comparison. Mostly preferred the v30 over the Marshall. Used the Marshalls in a 1960AV for years. Once I started using Orange amps, The 1960AV really fell out of favor. Too spikey and no richness. Made the amps sound cheap. It's all about finding the right speakers and cab to compliment the amp.
Thanks for the video. I had a 1936 Vintage cab with marshall vintage speakers in it. The clerks at guitar store told me the cab had V30s in it, but it never sounded right to me. Sounded dead (I like bright crunch). Opened it up, found the vintage marshalls, not vintage 30s, removed them, put them in the attic and put in the V30s I am used to. Like night and day. These two types of speakers don't really sound alike to me in person or on this video. I much prefer the V30 regardless of where it is made.
V30s are perfect in a blend with more darker and rounded sounding speakers. I run a V30 with a Hesu Demon together in a 212 and they complement each other very well. Tight and punchy with that distinct top end a V30 is known for. Yet V30s are a bit "boring" and harsh sounding to many, the sound they produce miced up with a SM57 is still some kind of the gold standard in modern metal productions
Love that Marshall G12 ! I was always curious about those . This is the first time I heard it isolated. Has a nice growl in the mids . I’ll keep an eye out for one ☝🏼 Thanks for the demonstration 🤘🏼🤘🏼
Great video and playing, Euge! Amazing differences between the speakers especially with different amps. I think a combo of greenbacks and vintage 30s (whatever your preference) is a great mix in a 4x12.
I really enjoy both here. The Marshall vintage sounds more relaxed, balanced, but all over slightly duller. It sounds like the kind of speaker that would be nice to hear by itself for a longer period of time. The V30 sounds so aggressive and in your face that I can get how some people would get fatigued over time. But it’s so brutal. And I think you would stand out way more in a live setting, and it also has more of that famous angry wall of chainsaws sound. These speakers would sound great mixed together in the same cab.
I'm surprised how much of a difference there really is. The Marshall was warmer without being dull. The Vintage 30 sounds harsh and fizzy by comparison.
Hi Euge! Thanks for all yours videos , I think i saw all of these . I'm a big fan of the jmp/jmc 800 too (and Sykes and Lynch too!) . Unfortunately I wasn't able to read all the questions you were asked and your possible answers on this subject, but have you ever tried and compared the celestions G12M65...? 🤔🙂
I almost feel as if the speakers had been broken in differently, or for different periods of time. In all, I would have loved to hear them blended together, especially with those first riffs.
My two go to cabs are my Mesa 4x12 OS with V30s, and a Marshall 4x12 with two Marshall Vintage and two DV77s. So, I've also compared the crap out of the two. The Marshall Vintage speakers don't get nearly as much love as they should. You can get some really pissed off tones out of them.
I enjoyed the Marshall vintage speakers more than the Chinese 30's. But that could be my setup and youtube compression. Maybe if I was sitting with you it would be different story
Thanks!! The biggest problem with this comparison is that I loved them both too. I don't want 1 sound, I want both. I feel like a good test would be to try and adjust tone an EQ and see which one you can get to sound more like the other one. I feel like the V30 could pull off the Marshall V by dropping the highs?
That's nice. I was just looking for a comparison vid of these.😉 Best Vintage 30 i ever played is the Vintage 30MF from the Mode Four Cabs. Vintage 30 for the not so mid-heavy Peavey. And Marshall Vintage for the Boogie and the Marshall. For me: Still my G12K-100s.
I felt that although the Chinese V 30 was more mid range focused and tight , it sounds more harsh. I'm guessing that it's probably better to have that and EQ out some of the harsh high end? As opposed to with the Marshall speaker one would have to do more EQ corrections to bring up the mids and tighten the low end? Have you tried the eminence dv 77? Amazing speaker for metal
In another video you said you X'ed the marshall vintage and the greenbacks for the JCM800. It sounds like the celestion vintage is already a mix of both of these
Hi Euge :) Any chance that you know if these Marshall G12’s UK made are what they put in newer 1936V cabinets? I’m looking for a 2x12 cab to compliment my Engl Fireball 25, and I’m torn between Engl Pro 2x12 and Marshall 1936v. However, I really like the sound of the Marshall G12’s Thanks mate 🙌
The Celestions definitely sounded better to me but this is using the exact amp settings to compare... maybe you can make the Marshall vintage sound closer by turning up the treble and mids just a touch? Thanks for the video!
Hey Euge, got a question for you. Have you ever noticed a difference in tone between a wired 16 Ohms cab vs. a 8 Ohms cab? I read some people find a 16 Ohms speaker brighter than it's 8 Ohms version... Can't say I noticed that difference though, or at least can't remember one since I've been using the EVH for over 5 years after selling the VHT FB.
Naah. I mean it would take lots of effort to compare ’cos I’d need to put the same (but) 8 ohm speakers to my cab (’cos cab makes a big difference too - some are brighter, some this and some that) and record with the same mic in the same position etc. And I definitely don’t have time or interest to do that. My motto has always been that ”If it sounds good it’s good and if it ain’t broken don’t fix it”.
@@EugeValovirta230V Euge, I looked around a little because I remembered reading or watching something related to the question, same speaker/different Ohms sounding different. If you're curious, you can hear it here... at 1m50 the 8 ohms and 4m27 the 16 ohms. ua-cam.com/video/NYxpg6s-XfQ/v-deo.htmlsi=PnTbGWB69_1rTPNq 🤘😎🤘
They sound so similar that I don’t think it’d make much difference, but I would never put Chinese speakers in my British amps, or Russian tubes or anything made by communists. I was born in Czechoslovakia. Perhaps you’ve heard of it?
The Marshall sounds like it has a little t75 blood in it, it has a slightly distant character. The regular V30 sounded best with the Marshall and the 5150, but the Mesa was killer with the Marshall vintage
I like your playing thanks for the Videos! First I would have to say The Marshall Vintage sounds best for Lead! Its not such a good comparison with the use of the Audio Aux 5 thats a much brighter Mic than the Sm57...for all the tracks...its a tuff comparison its heavy but Im not sold that its better than the Celestion V30! You might like to also get the new Celestion Vintage 30 2022 you won't see much of a difference but the Cap on the Speaker is see Through! Keep it going Euge!
@@EugeValovirta230V I hope your correct I bought both even though my V30 is Amazing I want to pair it with that new clear mesh one...That Marshall Vintage does sound thick tuned down and it sounds great for solo's so I got it also. Try pairing your V30 with the G12H 30 70th Anniversary model they sound Amazing together! Thanks Man! n/
Will u try 2022 made V30 ? Glen from SMG compare that speaker with 2014 V30 and he likes the newest V30. From what I hear, newest V30 doesn't have the treble harshness that plague V30. Maybe it's even similar to what Marshall vintage.
Do you know what these cab's are made of? Like plywood, pressboard, Birch etc? Nothing to do with the vid, but just curious. Also what are your thoughts on this cab? You really diggin it? Thanks man!
@@EugeValovirta230V Oh nice man! Ya, I've got an 80's JCM800 with G12-65's, but theres no grill or back panel lol. I'm gunna restore it. And I'm on the hunt for a newer Marshall cab, maybe one of these or a TV Cab. Cheers brother!
Yo Euge. Love this video as all the others. Only channel I follow religiously on UA-cam. Mesa Boogie special orders 60w Celestion V30 speakers, made in Suffolk, UK. Puts them in their rectifier cabinets. They also special order a 90w Celestion named Black Shadow, made in UK as well. I have a 1x12 Rectifier cabinet with the V30 and my Mark V 35 combo came with the Black Shadow. Maybe a few for you to try. Maybe one of them works out for you.
They’re very different speakers. Mesa’s V30s are different from the Chinese V30s everyone else uses, which are different from the “Marshall Vintage by Celestion”. From what I’ve been able to gather, the closest thing Celestion sells to “Marshall Vintage” are the V-Types, the difference being Marshall ones are made in the UK, while V-Types are made in China. But they sound pretty damn close. Also: Mesa heads sound their best with British V30s. They’re literally made for those speakers. Marshall heads sound their best with Marshall cabs. Swapping those usually makes the midrange sound “off”.
I heard this too. I think our monitors and listening environment really influences what we hear from these samples. The Marshall Vintage sounded like a "finished" guitar sound that has been low and high cut to fit into the mix. The V30 sounded big and nasty...in a great way, but I would imagine that with drums and bass it would need to be eq'd to fit better and be heard in a track.
When you look at the slave labor aspect of the Chinese made Celestion you have to honor the person who made it under unbearable brutal demands of being sleep deprived or skipping meals and many like businesses workers having to camp at their work stations to fill demands from their Corporate slave drivers. I have a Chinese made Ibanez electric guitar not perfect for 5 yrs.but I thank the hard work this person put into his or her life or death situation to get a meager pay. That said the Chinese brand is what Michael Sweet (Stryper) switched to a few years ago and I love that bite and heavy sound these speakers seem to be consistent everytime considering China's disparage of all involved in putting them out! Nice video...Peace.
The Marshall’s definitely sound much warmer. The V30’s are definitely harder, more aggressive. I like and use both. Excellent info as always Euge. 🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽
I went down this rabbit hole deep…It started in 1987 when I bought a Jubilee 4x12 with the Vintage speakers as an upgrade….These were the very first “V30’s”….they were built exclusively for Marshall,and still are to this day…Marshall first put these in the Studio 15 in about 1986,but they really rolled them out with the Jubilee series in 87….Celestion came out with the “off the shelf”version,but the Marshall one was and is THE original design of the V30…Celestion has changed the design many times over the years to make them easier to produce,but the Marshall design is proprietary to them….Mesa got a production run for themselves in the 90’s when Celestion changed the design again,and Mesa wanted to keep the same version as before……I went on a binge,and ended up with sets of 1987’s..1993’s…1998’s…2000’s…2003’s and finally 2019’s…..They are my favorite speakers ever,and I much prefer the original Marshall version to all the others….and they do sound different…so when someone says,I hate V30’s,I always say,which ones?..
😎🤟
I have a 2554 SJ combo from 1987.
Love that little massive amp.
I also have a comparatively new cab from Thomann with 'V30' in.I use it for my Helix and for my SV20.
I love both.
The speakers are all the same spec, same thing. The differences we all hear are really simple to explain. 1) older speakers that have been broken in sound better 2) ALL speakers off the assembly line do not come out exactly the same. You can have two speakers sequentially right off the assembly line sounding audibly different.
I know how tempting it is to believe in this myth that there is ONE perfect V30 and all the rest are bad or not as good. It isn't that simple.
There is no actual way of determining X so called version of the V30 is better than all the rest, I can find you a cabinet right now with the Marshall labeled V30, hell it can be one from 87 that hasn't been played, and it CAN I PROMISE you. sound like total shit. There is no magical guarantee because it says marshall on it that it will be better.
The marshall versions were made to 16 ohms. Most other V30 cabs are fitted with 8 ohm versions. That is an ACTUAL difference, but I have a feeling no one wants to hear that.
Anyway good luck everyone lol
Make this as clear as I possibly can. The ACTUAL reason for anyone curious about why even are there these V30's with different labels/names put on them?
It's really simple. Amplifier brands buy huge stocks of speakers, For example with the marshall version, they wanted all of them to 16 ohms. Mesa, wanted them all in 8 ohm. Thats it guys. Thats literally are there is to it. The amp brands buy their stock of speakers, if the speakers WERE actually different, THEY WOULD TELL YOU. Hughes and kettner had bought V30's to their spec for their cabs many moons ago, where there was an actual difference, they used the celestion lead cones instead of bass cones.
@@colelewis9940 the Marshall and Mesa V30’s are made in the UK,the regular versions are made in China…Marshall has their own “T”number for the production line….In 1987 ALL of the G12 Vintage’s were 8ohm speakers in the Jubilee 4x12 cabs…..The V30 was exclusive to Marshall in the beginning….they still are….I have many sets from many different era’s….The Marshall G1230 sounds very,very different from a standard Celestion V30..,it’s not just a the same speaker with a different sticker slapped on it…
I vastly prefer the Marshall G12 Vintage, here and in person. I’ve played Chinese V30s, the Mesa V30s, and the Marshall versions, and every time, the Marshall comes out on top. The Marshall G12 Vintage has plenty of the V30 high-end chirp and high-mid grind and is plenty aggressive, but without the honk and harsh mess of the other two. Full disclaimer: I’ve played a bunch of amps through these speakers, but only played my Bogner Ecstasy 3534 through all three speakers, and generally go for a high-gain sound that has snarl but a fuller bottom end. Euge captured the differences really well and confirmed again why I prefer the Marshall version.
🙏🤟💪
I got some vintage 30 style speakers in a Crate Vintage Club 50 and it really does sound somewhere in between these two
Thank you (and your comparison) I put Marshall Vintage + V30EN 90's in my 2x12 cab, now it sounds amazing. Thank you so much for your reviews and comparisons.
Thanks!
Very helpful. Thank you Euge!
Glad to hear! Thanks!
The Rabbit hole of V30's is there are different variations like the Mesa OEM V30 which I use exclusively ;) Short story: my 2nd cab I purchased new in the late 90's is a Marsh Vintage 4x12 with the marsh v30's and a friend had a Trace Elliot 4x12 cab with UK V30's and we compared them and I like the Trace cab speakers better for some reason and so we decided to swap all four speaks and I still have the UK V30's from that cab dated 1995 and they sound great still all these years and sound really close if not the same as the Mesa OEM V30's (16ohm variant btw). I wish I kept the Marsh V30's still only because it's so hard to find them for sale without having to have to buy a used or new cab to get them!!! Great video like always and interesting to hear the differences between V30's. Rock on! \m/
The height of each speaker from the floor will influence the sound. The speaker closer to the floor should have more low mids and more lows.
👌
Interesting to compare this next time..?
＞The height of each speaker from the floor will influence the sound. The speaker closer to the floor should have more low mids and more lows.
That's not accurate. The lower the speaker, the closer to the wall, the lower the bass
The Celestion V30 has such nice mids. They are my favourite speaker. I will never get rid of my old Mesa oversized 4 X 12 cabinet. I noticed the greenbacks in that cabinet, those are my 2nd favourite speaker. The greenbacks are the best speaker for a Marshall head IMO. Just like the V30 works perfectly with a Mesa head the Greenback I think is the perfect speaker for a Marshall head.
I like both a lot but mainly I use Vs with my JCM800s and GBs with my Plexi 👌. But both work really well in almost any given situation with all my amps.
Both sounded really good. My 4x12 cab has Celestion G12k-85's. Which sound darker to me, but I like them. They are not harsh on the highs. Easy to EQ a good chunky tone. We get used to whatever speakers we have. Our ears adjust to them over time. We start to accept their tone as being "normal", because it is familiar. But like you always say...... if it sounds good, then it's good.
Indeed.
Excellent comparison. Mostly preferred the v30 over the Marshall. Used the Marshalls in a 1960AV for years. Once I started using Orange amps, The 1960AV really fell out of favor. Too spikey and no richness. Made the amps sound cheap. It's all about finding the right speakers and cab to compliment the amp.
Thanks for the video. I had a 1936 Vintage cab with marshall vintage speakers in it. The clerks at guitar store told me the cab had V30s in it, but it never sounded right to me. Sounded dead (I like bright crunch). Opened it up, found the vintage marshalls, not vintage 30s, removed them, put them in the attic and put in the V30s I am used to. Like night and day. These two types of speakers don't really sound alike to me in person or on this video. I much prefer the V30 regardless of where it is made.
Thanks! I prefer the Marshalls. Just my personal preference.
I put these two speakers in 1936 cab, they sound amazing with les paul and 2203x boosted, very agressive. Cheers 🤟
🤟💪
V30s are perfect in a blend with more darker and rounded sounding speakers. I run a V30 with a Hesu Demon together in a 212 and they complement each other very well. Tight and punchy with that distinct top end a V30 is known for. Yet V30s are a bit "boring" and harsh sounding to many, the sound they produce miced up with a SM57 is still some kind of the gold standard in modern metal productions
Indeed.
Great video. Very helpful. Thanks again.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks!
I have the 1960 AV cab with these. Swapped 2 out for the Creamback H and really like it. Running a Diezel VH2 pretty ballsy rig
I'll buy the two Marshall Vintages you swapped out. If you've still got them, let me know.
I preffer the Celestion V30 sound, but The best of all would be to mix the 2 speakers in one cabinet.
Love that Marshall G12 ! I was always curious about those . This is the first time I heard it isolated. Has a nice growl in the mids . I’ll keep an eye out for one ☝🏼
Thanks for the demonstration 🤘🏼🤘🏼
Cool! Thanks!
Great video and playing, Euge! Amazing differences between the speakers especially with different amps. I think a combo of greenbacks and vintage 30s (whatever your preference) is a great mix in a 4x12.
Thanks! Indeed.
I really enjoy both here. The Marshall vintage sounds more relaxed, balanced, but all over slightly duller. It sounds like the kind of speaker that would be nice to hear by itself for a longer period of time.
The V30 sounds so aggressive and in your face that I can get how some people would get fatigued over time. But it’s so brutal. And I think you would stand out way more in a live setting, and it also has more of that famous angry wall of chainsaws sound.
These speakers would sound great mixed together in the same cab.
You explain, play and sound GREAT
Thanks!
Awesome as always, mate 👍 Comparing within a full mix would be very interesting, including the EQ moves across all tracks.
Thanks!
I'm surprised how much of a difference there really is. The Marshall was warmer without being dull. The Vintage 30 sounds harsh and fizzy by comparison.
Hi Euge! Thanks for all yours videos , I think i saw all of these . I'm a big fan of the jmp/jmc 800 too (and Sykes and Lynch too!) . Unfortunately I wasn't able to read all the questions you were asked and your possible answers on this subject, but have you ever tried and compared the celestions G12M65...? 🤔🙂
Marshall quite scooped sounding compared to the Chinese but not in a bad scoop way.. I preferred it myself.
I almost feel as if the speakers had been broken in differently, or for different periods of time. In all, I would have loved to hear them blended together, especially with those first riffs.
My two go to cabs are my Mesa 4x12 OS with V30s, and a Marshall 4x12 with two Marshall Vintage and two DV77s. So, I've also compared the crap out of the two. The Marshall Vintage speakers don't get nearly as much love as they should. You can get some really pissed off tones out of them.
💪🤟
very cool vídeo! I think a combination of the two would be nice
Thanks! Indeed.
Thanks for the review. My preference is the V30s. 🤘🎸🎸🤘
You’re welcome!
@EugeValovirta230V for what it's worth, your review of the ENGL Artist Edition was excellent! And I have my heart set on the 50-watt model. 🤘🎸🎸🤘
That v30 is killer !
It's crazy how the Marshalls always sounded brighter to me but here they definitely sound darker
I enjoyed the Marshall vintage speakers more than the Chinese 30's. But that could be my setup and youtube compression. Maybe if I was sitting with you it would be different story
Thanks!! The biggest problem with this comparison is that I loved them both too. I don't want 1 sound, I want both. I feel like a good test would be to try and adjust tone an EQ and see which one you can get to sound more like the other one. I feel like the V30 could pull off the Marshall V by dropping the highs?
That's nice. I was just looking for a comparison vid of these.😉 Best Vintage 30 i ever played is the Vintage 30MF from the Mode Four Cabs. Vintage 30 for the not so mid-heavy Peavey. And Marshall Vintage for the Boogie and the Marshall. For me: Still my G12K-100s.
Cool 😎🤟.
Both sound great!
Very different sound . Great video , thank you ! 🤘
Thanks!
Great comparison. Next time do the Mesa V30 :)
I felt that although the Chinese V 30 was more mid range focused and tight , it sounds more harsh. I'm guessing that it's probably better to have that and EQ out some of the harsh high end? As opposed to with the Marshall speaker one would have to do more EQ corrections to bring up the mids and tighten the low end?
Have you tried the eminence dv 77? Amazing speaker for metal
About like that. No I haven’t.
@@EugeValovirta230V check Kristian Kohelers channel for review on it. I think you'll like it
The Marshall Vintage 30 sounds a bit like the G12T-75 with that hollow, vocal midrange, and a more subdued harmonic content.
Which T75 version? The ‘84 vented version sounds totally different than the current ones.
In another video you said you X'ed the marshall vintage and the greenbacks for the JCM800. It sounds like the celestion vintage is already a mix of both of these
Would love to see an in style of Mick Mars!
Hi Euge :)
Any chance that you know if these Marshall G12’s UK made are what they put in newer 1936V cabinets?
I’m looking for a 2x12 cab to compliment my Engl Fireball 25, and I’m torn between Engl Pro 2x12 and Marshall 1936v.
However, I really like the sound of the Marshall G12’s
Thanks mate 🙌
To my understanding the Marshall Vintage’s are still made only in UK.
@@EugeValovirta230V thanks for the insight man :) I thought so too 😁
🤘🤘🤘
The Celestions definitely sounded better to me but this is using the exact amp settings to compare... maybe you can make the Marshall vintage sound closer by turning up the treble and mids just a touch? Thanks for the video!
Yeah one can do a lot with the amp’s eq, mics, mic placement etc.
Euge - Do you recall what the impedance rating was on the Chinese-made Vintage 30 for this shootout? Thank you.
Yeah! 16 ohm 👌.
@@EugeValovirta230V ❤ Thanks! 🎸
Hey Euge, got a question for you. Have you ever noticed a difference in tone between a wired 16 Ohms cab vs. a 8 Ohms cab? I read some people find a 16 Ohms speaker brighter than it's 8 Ohms version... Can't say I noticed that difference though, or at least can't remember one since I've been using the EVH for over 5 years after selling the VHT FB.
Naah. I mean it would take lots of effort to compare ’cos I’d need to put the same (but) 8 ohm speakers to my cab (’cos cab makes a big difference too - some are brighter, some this and some that) and record with the same mic in the same position etc. And I definitely don’t have time or interest to do that. My motto has always been that ”If it sounds good it’s good and if it ain’t broken don’t fix it”.
@@EugeValovirta230V Euge, I looked around a little because I remembered reading or watching something related to the question, same speaker/different Ohms sounding different. If you're curious, you can hear it here... at 1m50 the 8 ohms and 4m27 the 16 ohms. ua-cam.com/video/NYxpg6s-XfQ/v-deo.htmlsi=PnTbGWB69_1rTPNq 🤘😎🤘
They sound so similar that I don’t think it’d make much difference, but I would never put Chinese speakers in my British amps, or Russian tubes or anything made by communists. I was born in Czechoslovakia. Perhaps you’ve heard of it?
The Marshall sounds like it has a little t75 blood in it, it has a slightly distant character. The regular V30 sounded best with the Marshall and the 5150, but the Mesa was killer with the Marshall vintage
I've got a cab with an original V30 made in England, and a Marshall Vintage. I much prefer the Marshall vintage
The Marshall V is my favourite too 👌.
Thanks! Cool video. ~Fabian
Glad to hear! 🙏
I like your playing thanks for the Videos! First I would have to say The Marshall Vintage sounds best for Lead! Its not such a good comparison with the use of the Audio Aux 5 thats a much brighter Mic than the Sm57...for all the tracks...its a tuff comparison its heavy but Im not sold that its better than the Celestion V30! You might like to also get the new Celestion Vintage 30 2022 you won't see much of a difference but the Cap on the Speaker is see Through! Keep it going Euge!
Thanks!
My Celestion V30 is the new see through cap which they released in 2020 if I remember correct.
@@EugeValovirta230V I hope your correct I bought both even though my V30 is Amazing I want to pair it with that new clear mesh one...That Marshall Vintage does sound thick tuned down and it sounds great for solo's so I got it also. Try pairing your V30 with the G12H 30 70th Anniversary model they sound Amazing together! Thanks Man!
n/
🤟
Will u try 2022 made V30 ?
Glen from SMG compare that speaker with 2014 V30 and he likes the newest V30. From what I hear, newest V30 doesn't have the treble harshness that plague V30. Maybe it's even similar to what Marshall vintage.
This is the new 2022 version 😎🤟.
Nice video what celestion speakers u think to get the zack wylde sound the best outta the line of celetion speakers ...
HI Euge, do you thing 4 v30 on a 1960AX will be to bright? great playing by the way!!
Both sound good but for me I'll go with marshall because it is an iconic sound.... Btw is the celestion v30 16ohm or 8ohm?
Both great sounding .. the Chinese v30s might contribute to hearing loss faster being more aggressive in the in the upper range .. lol
👌😎
Preference Hippie! Preference. Nice Video!!
Hippie? 😂😂😂
Thanks! 😎
Great video❤
Thanks!
For my ears V30 is the best speakers ever.
I got a Harley Benton 212 vintage cab.
About how long does it take to break in a pair of v30's? The bottom end seems lacking
I guess it depends how much you play but in my experience after a few days of intense & loud playing they start to ”open up”.
Are both 16 ohm? I know impedance can affect tone pretty big!
Yes.
Marshall Vintage - Winner 🎉
Thanks Euge. Big difference, liked the Marshall version a lot better. Which one did you prefer, especially with your Marshalls?
The Marshall Vintage but I’ve used the Celestion quite a bit too especially with some downtuned metal stuff.
Marshall Vintage alllllllllllllllll day!
😎🤟
Not worth blending or unify the two?
I like booth, but i think i prefer the Celestion. Does all Vintage Marshalls are made um UK?
Cheers from Portugal 🤘🍺🇵🇹
Yeah they’re all made in UK. Cheers!
Check out Hesu Demon speaker from Poland, it´s a modern take on a V30
Nice job! :) v30 for me
Do you know what these cab's are made of? Like plywood, pressboard, Birch etc? Nothing to do with the vid, but just curious. Also what are your thoughts on this cab? You really diggin it? Thanks man!
marshall.com/amps/products/cabinets
My favourite cabs 🤟
@@EugeValovirta230V Oh nice man! Ya, I've got an 80's JCM800 with G12-65's, but theres no grill or back panel lol. I'm gunna restore it. And I'm on the hunt for a newer Marshall cab, maybe one of these or a TV Cab. Cheers brother!
Cool man!
What is marshall.model v30? T?. Do not understand why my speakers do not have mids...
Yo Euge. Love this video as all the others. Only channel I follow religiously on UA-cam. Mesa Boogie special orders 60w Celestion V30 speakers, made in Suffolk, UK. Puts them in their rectifier cabinets. They also special order a 90w Celestion named Black Shadow, made in UK as well. I have a 1x12 Rectifier cabinet with the V30 and my Mark V 35 combo came with the Black Shadow. Maybe a few for you to try. Maybe one of them works out for you.
Thanks! Glad to hear! 👌🤟
Celestions were broken in and Marshalls are not? Does it make hearable difference?
V30 is the king! 🤘
I like that you played Shortest Straw. It is alleged that Metallica used the Marshall Vintage for AJFA.
🤟. Yeah and on Black Album as well.
Great video 🎉 actually for me mesa v30 is best.but I also like Marshall vintage too,different feeling,great video thank you so much
Thanks!
the Celestion is made in China, Marshall UK..for me..the Marshall original V30 sounds bigger and fuller, smoother and nicer overall.
👌💪
The V30 has a higher sensitivity rating at 100 DB while the greenback is 97 DB sp the V30 will seem a little louder .
Marshall is tighter and more scooped rather the mid heavier v30
I like th dound og thr Wintage
Vintage 30’s all
Day.
I use both a lot depending what I’m looking for 👌.
They’re very different speakers. Mesa’s V30s are different from the Chinese V30s everyone else uses, which are different from the “Marshall Vintage by Celestion”. From what I’ve been able to gather, the closest thing Celestion sells to “Marshall Vintage” are the V-Types, the difference being Marshall ones are made in the UK, while V-Types are made in China. But they sound pretty damn close.
Also: Mesa heads sound their best with British V30s. They’re literally made for those speakers. Marshall heads sound their best with Marshall cabs. Swapping those usually makes the midrange sound “off”.
Yes indeed.
To me the midrange is always 'off' with any boogie amp.
Marshall is more clearer defined and punchier. It all really depends on your setup, style and sound you are after.
Exactly.
I heard this too. I think our monitors and listening environment really influences what we hear from these samples. The Marshall Vintage sounded like a "finished" guitar sound that has been low and high cut to fit into the mix. The V30 sounded big and nasty...in a great way, but I would imagine that with drums and bass it would need to be eq'd to fit better and be heard in a track.
I hate the Vintage 30 on a Plexi-style circuit… even a broken down V30 sounds too mid spikey…. Im a greenback guy for life.
😎🤟
When you look at the slave labor aspect of the Chinese made Celestion you have to honor the person who made it under unbearable brutal demands of being sleep deprived or skipping meals and many like businesses workers having to camp at their work stations to fill demands from their Corporate slave drivers. I have a Chinese made Ibanez electric guitar not perfect for 5 yrs.but I thank the hard work this person put into his or her life or death situation to get a meager pay. That said the Chinese brand is what Michael Sweet (Stryper) switched to a few years ago and I love that bite and heavy sound these speakers seem to be consistent everytime considering China's disparage of all involved in putting them out! Nice video...Peace.
🙏
Awesome...Happy Holidays!
The Marshall’s definitely sound much warmer. The V30’s are definitely harder, more aggressive. I like and use both.
Excellent info as always Euge.
🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽
Indeed. Thanks!
Marshall’s win
Marshall vintage is more the on your face compare to Celestine vintage 30
I find it to be the other way around but I guess it’s in the ear of the beholder 👌😎.
Eminence CV 75 speakers.....
Marshall is more aggressive
I watched this whole video hoping to hear the two mixed together. As easy as that would have been… nope.
Whats wintage?😂