With the amount of times Fir accidentally says "forgetful" in place of "forgettable", it makes me think a lot of these moons have difficulties remembering their keys and wallets rather than making no impression.
I know this is small but I really appreciate how Fir repeatedly says “the MOST intended way”. It really highlights how creative you can get with these moons which is what makes this game so special.
Which is actually fairly important for whichever seed ends up on the northwest pot, as that one will end up taking a full hour to grow, I believe, rather than the usual 20 minutes.
I’ve always wanted to know what Fir’s favorite, least favorite, 69th favorite, and 373rd favorite moons are! Thanks for the documentary, it’s for real super well done, and I loved it all
I cannot accurately describe how much of a towering achievement this video is for your channel, Fir. I don’t even want to know how much planning and editing and revising and this took. I mean, Odyssey Central’s crack at this idea was already really impressive, but you managed to provide even more detail to most moons, an introspection on every kingdom as a whole, a tier list alongside a ranking at the end, and solid editing throughout all 4 hours. This has to be one of the most impressive projects on this platform.
My biggest issue with the 500 coin moon in Deep Woods is the fact that this concept isn’t repeated anywhere else. It *feels* like a recurring moon, but it’s the only place in the entire game where that capture actually has a use. I saw that area and knew something had to be done there, but couldn’t figure it out until I saw an all moons speedrun.
i figured it out immediately but after throwing like 200 coins in i decided it clearly wasn't anything important, maybe just a cute little easter egg. i later googled what it was all about and found out i had to throw a bunch more money in. fun times
I really like how you mentioned that even the filler moons can all come together to create a fun and rewarding exploration system, because I totally agree. The worlds feel so much more fun to run around in when you have moons just sitting around to find and collect, even if they are super lame in a vacuum.
All human understanding is based on comparison. We can't understand good without seeing bad. An experience cannot be full-throttle start to finish; that would be exhausting. The middling, waste of time moons create lows that accentuate the highs. We love the good moons more because we see what bad moons can be. If Mario Odyssey had deleted all of the bad moons, it would have been a worse experience.
55:30 fun fact, until i watched a play through i never realized you were supposed to take a cheep-cheep down the hole and simply ground-pounded and made it on the brink of death
I've been saying that 15/50 would make so much more sense that the 15/100 for hero of the beach for so long. Hearing you say it makes me feel so validated. Really enjoyed the video, wish I could sub to you a second time!
I feel like with cascade, not enough credit was given to "This is a tutorial. There WILL be some easy, just sitting there moons, to help teach people the game."
I would argue moons that don't require any effort to get to don't teach players anything other than the fact that there are moons that take no effort to get to
@@Lovely_Bean_ odyssey was my first mario game and guess what? """free""" moons helped, its the exact same as lots of achievements at the start of a game, it gets you going. i wouldnt of played it if it wasnt the only game we started out with and it was already on the system which is easier to forget as there's no card. now you might think that's stupid and when you have a game you should play it anyway, i was a young child and seeing mario and cappy's happy animation when i got those moon lying around was nice, i didnt really know who mario was that well and i loved that odyssey was my intro to 3d mario games. btw odyssey is a CHILDREN'S GAME, the turtorial is Meant to be easy, let children have fun dumb@ss
@Lovely_Bean_ It teaches them that moons exist, what they look like, that they're spread around the map in varying locations, that you need them to progress, and what you should be looking out for in general when seeking them out. It's a tutorial level. It's not supposed to be teaching you trick jumps, variable platforming, or unique puzzles yet. Cap Kingdom taught you the basic mechanics of movement and world interaction, Cascade Kingdom teaches you the basic mechanics of goal-based progression. That's practically essential for a video game this complex aimed at young kids. Cascade treats Moons like other kingdoms treat Moon Shards. Because, in that kingdom, they serve the same effective function as a Moon Shard. It's only in Sand Kingdom where they put up the curtain and say "Okay, now you get what you're doing and why you're doing it. Here's where it comes together. Good luck."
Hey Fir, thanks for the video. You missed to mention something when ranking "Top of a Dune" (Sand Kingdom #17): There is a cute way to discover this moon (and I found it this way originally): When you capture a Moe-Eye and put on the shades, you see a glow in the distance where the moon is. I love this so much.
I found this for another ground pound moon in Moon cave but never noticed it for on Top of the Dune. It's a neat addition but I still generally dislike the invisible ground pound moons
@@breaddatisbreadIt's not a stupid idea, it's just a poorly executed idea. Could've definitely designed moons where it's interesting to use Moeyes to see them. But they didn't.
For real, genuinely a great way to express the overall poor design and execution of the Toadette moons. 1 at a time, pointless filler, and none are even really unique. Toadette is possibly my least favorite part of the game.
Fantastic video, kept me entertained for an entire glove (crocheting), my only wish is that the list at the end had the letter/rank displayed as well. Great stuff!
I just want you to know how good I sleep listening to this. I keep coming back to it whenever I’m restless. Your voice, the listing off stuff, all perfect for a good nights sleep.
Often times it's the contrast that makes the good things great, its why you find serious and scary moments in comedies while finding comedic moments in dramas and horror. Having some obviously crappy/easy moons makes the challenging/great moons shine even more.
This video made me so happy I love it tysm for making this Super Mario Odyssey is one of my hyperfixations and I love hearing people talk about it for hours so you just made my day
Going through these like this helps me to see that the point of Cap Kingdom is to be a tutorial for SMO's unique movement, while Cascade Kingdom is a tutorial for how collecting stars works. That would explain why the moons from those two kingdoms are both very easy, even superficially so, but in different ways. Each moon in Cap Kingdom helps you learn to move, each moon in Cascade Kingdom teaches you about the kinds of puzzles you'll experience to get moons.
Technically you're not really meant to get any moons in cap kingdom until you beat the game bc you'll have no reason to go back and there aren't any moons until you go back so it's not really a tutorial for moving
I’ve been really looking forward to this video!!! Thank you for doing it! I can’t imagine how long it took to plan out and record all the video. It’s a great video to listen to while painting. So thank you again!
I loved the video, the time and dedication is appreciated and worth it, it represents and shows your quality as a youtuber, endure and answer even the most ridiculous questions from your subs IN THE BEST WAY POSSIBLE, I loved the video, GOD tier
1:42:33 If you were too enraptured by the awe of the festival for your secret-hunting brain to be active, i'm sorry but that's a skill issue. Got this moon first try because of *course* I'm going to check on top of the coin blocks I can jump onto.
Holy shit. Was expecting a livestream montage of you doing a 100% run and saying the tiers but to actually narrate every single moons with explanations? Insane.
This is a great, well-edited video! I like that you found some things to say for even the most unremarkable moons. It shows that you put lots of effort into this!
16:10 The thing is, that moon was made for you to triple jump, as those steps appear as one set a bit earlier in the kingdom, with a sign telling you about triple jumping.
Finally had time to finish watching! Insane work, Fir! I don't even want to imagine how much work it actually took. The hatred for a treasure made from coins was to be expected but ngl the intensity for Chargin' Chuck sub-area took me by surprise lmao The conspiracy theory definitely sounds valid tho!
Was not prepared to enjoy this video as much as I did. Watched it over the course of three days lol. It was great to hear such an in depth commentary from someone who knows the game so well
Big fan of LS Mark style formatting. Ranking each moon with where it places within its kingdom was a great way to help us visualize your final list before it happened. Can’t wait til this video gets 5 million views
The moon in Lake Kingdom on the Little Pillar is pretty great imo. An unremarkable spot, that still sticks out. You won't find it, if you don't search in such places. And since you don't need every moon to beat the game, it's a nice reward for players trying to find as much secrets as possible.
1:49:06 iirc, the map is a brochure that tells you stuff about the world. It has some if not all the answers to the questions. If it's just some, I think some npcs talk about her
2:18:59 okay, I think you should at the very least bump this up to B+ purely for the reference it is. For those who don’t know, this is the exact chest layout as the one in Mario 64 in dire dire docks. And considering the beach cave area, it’s more than def a reference to that original star.
As a wannabe game designer I actually really like On Top of the Rubble because it shows that the devs understand their intended audience: children with limited patience. Your initial Cascade visit isn’t meant to be an open-world tour like most Kingdoms that come after-it’s given a sense of urgency. You’re given a task by a frantic NPC, and children are more likely to help NPCs when they ask for it. You need 5 Moons to fix the ship. You get Our First Power Moon to introduce yourself to the concept, you fight Ma Broodal to introduce Multi-Moons, and you need a fifth Moon so you can fix the ship and go to the next kingdom right away, where you spend a significantly longer time. The Moon on Top of the Rubble is placed in an obvious location on purpose so kids don’t feel stressed out when they’re so close to their goal. From there, they can work their way up to the more complex puzzles.
I agree, it serves a really important purpose. But this ranking is mostly about how enjoyable or interesting Fir finds it, rather than how good it is from a game design perspective or the millions of other possible perspectives
holy shit thank you for putting a list of all the songs in the video in the description 11:39 fun fact, there's a bunch of note sets in 3D Land that play some retro tune, usually the SMW athletic theme 30:05 i think you meant "cascade" here 1:24:43 fir can't count confirmed 2:27:42 wait is it "tall rock shell" or "tall rock shelf" 2:30:00 i think you forgot to put what song this is in the list 2:50:18 i mean the mummy only spawns if you grab the hidden coins if that's worth anything 3:04:26 you forgot this song too 3:19:14 oh hey, 3D Land reference 3:29:05 missed this song too 3:30:50 and this one 3:43:19 and this one (i get the feeling that you were starting to wear down) 3:51:05 oh hey, just noticed moon's "hidden on the side of the cliff" and one of the sister moons, cascade's "next to the stone arch" share moon numbers (#29) 3:51:50 mood another note on the massive list, it's funny to see the long lists of moons with similar names or premises, like the peach moons and the occasional string of timer challenges 4:10:47 um, acktchually that *clearly* says "iceburn circuit class s" 4:13:36 my pleasure ;) 100/10, would binge-watch again
I just thought of a video idea For you You may actually like this one. Super Mario Odyssey, but Koopa free free-running is always Active That's basically Where You're trying to beat the game. Before the Koopas do. So you're racing against the Koopas. To the end of the game. Maybe you could add some other twist. Cause seems kind of easy but still.
bro forgets not everyone is a god gamer like him with the "too easy" moons. odyssey is for everyone, but still glad to know some of the moons I struggle with are also hated by speed runners
7:05 I remember at one point me and my sister were trying to collect all the moons, she would play and I would read her descriptions on how to find the moons. She was better at the game than me except for the Koopa races. I always felt so cool doing the Koopa races for her
Volleyball 100 is literally the only moon i am missing. My high score was 70-something and i have refused to go abck and try again ever since failing that run
You missed that in order for Peach to appear in a kingdom you must get world peace in that kingdom, making it another reward for world peace. I always liked that aspect of Peach’s moons. edit: everything here on is an edit added while watching the video 11:36 “I wish they played a small theme like that one star in Mario Galaxy” ah yes, the one time the notes in Mario Galaxy played a small theme So far Fir has yet to talk about the importance of teaching new players using early moons, or the subtle storytelling from moons (like lost in the luggage) (or thanks for the charge. I always loved the story telling of that one)
as someone with very scattered mario odyssey knowledge who mostly followed the low% captures category (all about using cappy as little as possible and only getting the moons needed to progress the run), i was entirely unaware of a majority of these moons before this video. and im having the time of my life watching it and learning about all of them, so :3 great work, just, really engaging
While I don’t disagree with your rankings, I am a little surprised that some of the common “Any %” moons got ranked lower for being boring. Ones that might be boring to find from a player’s perspective, but are on your path in a speedrun, are always nice to get if you want to leave the kingdom earlier, and I was expecting some moons to get bumped up to slightly higher rankings for that.
I can't be the only one who thought it said 80 and 90 at 2:15:10 Also I have to say, I think it would have been nice to always show the current tier in the final ranking. Besides that, I really appreciate the effort that went into this video, congrats on finally getting it out!
good video, lost kingdom was my favorite ever since I first picked up this game. The smaller size and verticality allows for skips like in the koopa freerunning and reminds me of something like whomps
With the amount of times Fir accidentally says "forgetful" in place of "forgettable", it makes me think a lot of these moons have difficulties remembering their keys and wallets rather than making no impression.
Also, isn't Fir a native English speaker? Because for me, English is my second language and even I noticed Fir mixed up forgettable and forgetful.
Well he’s from United States and he doesn’t have any accent really so like he has to be
@@Reaktron88 his first language is Marioese, which just consists of “wahoo” and its various derivations and tenses
@@nedcurfman3486 Oh my god I actually thought it was a real language and I had gotten it wrong! I think CJ is the most fluent Marioese speaker.
*number of times (seeing as we're being picky about wording :P)
I know this is small but I really appreciate how Fir repeatedly says “the MOST intended way”. It really highlights how creative you can get with these moons which is what makes this game so special.
Real, speedrunners never do that
How creative can you get with the thousand moons for planting seeds or doing a ground pound
Pure insanity, can't wait to watch this in the background all day
I’ve been watching it in bed with covid all day, it’s great
Got the flu, so chilling watching this and playing Splatoon 3 Side Order
Hi gem cat!!! How often you make mods? And also, HOW do you play them on switch when you get mods on PC?
Exactly what I’ve been doing all day XD
Bold of you to assume it's background material. I will view every second.
I love the jump from the rage during “a treasure made from coins” to “I like this moon cause you get to be a tree :)”
lol
1:09:39
@JuliaGearheartwhat are you talking about
@@chrislawson3536
What did they say? Their account was TERMINATED
that was such a silly moment lol
2:19:35 one neat little thing I would add here, not really to improve their score, is that you can use a gushin to speed up the plants’ growth
Which is actually fairly important for whichever seed ends up on the northwest pot, as that one will end up taking a full hour to grow, I believe, rather than the usual 20 minutes.
I’ve always wanted to know what Fir’s favorite, least favorite, 69th favorite, and 373rd favorite moons are! Thanks for the documentary, it’s for real super well done, and I loved it all
Why 373
Either channel inside joke or random number for the sake of comedy
@@JoshyYoshi4that’s our first power moon
@@JK17-1at 373?!?!?!?!?!
Yeah I always wondered his 634 favorite moon
I definitely didn’t make a typo in any of the kingdoms I helped edit 👍
…
You want us to pretend that there aren't any typos in this video?
gommba
Jesus loves you and may God bless you
it's okay im lowkey illiterate i wouldn't even notice
"cheating problem" with smallant at the top lmao love that
When?
@@amberstargames Cap kingdom koopa freerunning
@@amberstargames @7:04
7:00
I’m pretty sure it’s just someone who changed their name
I cannot accurately describe how much of a towering achievement this video is for your channel, Fir. I don’t even want to know how much planning and editing and revising and this took. I mean, Odyssey Central’s crack at this idea was already really impressive, but you managed to provide even more detail to most moons, an introspection on every kingdom as a whole, a tier list alongside a ranking at the end, and solid editing throughout all 4 hours.
This has to be one of the most impressive projects on this platform.
ODYSSEY CENTRAL FANS ASSEMBALL
@@michaelsminecraftknowledge oh dear, what have I invoked?
Odyssey central isn’t even good at the game
He did the bare minimum on his video
@mr.lantern1111 is right
31:28 Its a short jump away.
31:29 Proceeds to do a long jump...
Dang you got me
Oh the irony
@@Firhands up, you’re being arrested for doing a long jump when you said short jump!
FBI, OPEN UP!
Yeah! For 836 years! @@Lolbit3cl1pse
My biggest issue with the 500 coin moon in Deep Woods is the fact that this concept isn’t repeated anywhere else. It *feels* like a recurring moon, but it’s the only place in the entire game where that capture actually has a use. I saw that area and knew something had to be done there, but couldn’t figure it out until I saw an all moons speedrun.
Imagine if instead of shop moons every kingdom had one of these and they only took 100 coins to complete
I’m glad its not repeated anywhere else
i figured it out immediately but after throwing like 200 coins in i decided it clearly wasn't anything important, maybe just a cute little easter egg. i later googled what it was all about and found out i had to throw a bunch more money in. fun times
I really like how you mentioned that even the filler moons can all come together to create a fun and rewarding exploration system, because I totally agree. The worlds feel so much more fun to run around in when you have moons just sitting around to find and collect, even if they are super lame in a vacuum.
All human understanding is based on comparison. We can't understand good without seeing bad. An experience cannot be full-throttle start to finish; that would be exhausting. The middling, waste of time moons create lows that accentuate the highs. We love the good moons more because we see what bad moons can be. If Mario Odyssey had deleted all of the bad moons, it would have been a worse experience.
Noticed your finding these moons in 2025! Nice to see fellow time-travelers
ah yes, going into the past. im starting to miss 3098.
I’m in January 2023, what has happened so far?
@@1tz_Rav3nIm from 4269 matpat has quit and everyone started riots and never stopped, they are still going
I'm just glad the war is over.
It’s sad to hear the world ended in 3100
55:30 fun fact, until i watched a play through i never realized you were supposed to take a cheep-cheep down the hole and simply ground-pounded and made it on the brink of death
thats what literally everyone did
I've been saying that 15/50 would make so much more sense that the 15/100 for hero of the beach for so long. Hearing you say it makes me feel so validated. Really enjoyed the video, wish I could sub to you a second time!
3:51:49 the zoom in with the clown outfit had me genuinely laughing out loud!🤣🤣🤣
you know moons 836-727 are bad when they're ranked lower than the moons where your sole goal is to press A
Really more of half the moons you only need press A
My english is bad sorry 😅
when you see it
I feel like with cascade, not enough credit was given to "This is a tutorial. There WILL be some easy, just sitting there moons, to help teach people the game."
I would argue moons that don't require any effort to get to don't teach players anything other than the fact that there are moons that take no effort to get to
That’s acceptable for non moon rock moons.
@@Lovely_Bean_ odyssey was my first mario game and guess what? """free""" moons helped, its the exact same as lots of achievements at the start of a game, it gets you going. i wouldnt of played it if it wasnt the only game we started out with and it was already on the system which is easier to forget as there's no card. now you might think that's stupid and when you have a game you should play it anyway, i was a young child and seeing mario and cappy's happy animation when i got those moon lying around was nice, i didnt really know who mario was that well and i loved that odyssey was my intro to 3d mario games.
btw odyssey is a CHILDREN'S GAME, the turtorial is Meant to be easy, let children have fun dumb@ss
@Lovely_Bean_ It teaches them that moons exist, what they look like, that they're spread around the map in varying locations, that you need them to progress, and what you should be looking out for in general when seeking them out. It's a tutorial level. It's not supposed to be teaching you trick jumps, variable platforming, or unique puzzles yet. Cap Kingdom taught you the basic mechanics of movement and world interaction, Cascade Kingdom teaches you the basic mechanics of goal-based progression. That's practically essential for a video game this complex aimed at young kids.
Cascade treats Moons like other kingdoms treat Moon Shards. Because, in that kingdom, they serve the same effective function as a Moon Shard. It's only in Sand Kingdom where they put up the curtain and say "Okay, now you get what you're doing and why you're doing it. Here's where it comes together. Good luck."
Plus, it's a good hook
Hey Fir, thanks for the video. You missed to mention something when ranking "Top of a Dune" (Sand Kingdom #17): There is a cute way to discover this moon (and I found it this way originally): When you capture a Moe-Eye and put on the shades, you see a glow in the distance where the moon is. I love this so much.
I found this for another ground pound moon in Moon cave but never noticed it for on Top of the Dune. It's a neat addition but I still generally dislike the invisible ground pound moons
@@Fir same
using moeyes to see moons is a stupid idea they should just be used to see platforms
@@breaddatisbreadIt's not a stupid idea, it's just a poorly executed idea. Could've definitely designed moons where it's interesting to use Moeyes to see them. But they didn't.
If I’m not mistaken the Ninetendog will also dig at it if it follows you up the dune
Love the clown costume as he’s reading off each toadette moon one by one during his final ranking
For real, genuinely a great way to express the overall poor design and execution of the Toadette moons. 1 at a time, pointless filler, and none are even really unique. Toadette is possibly my least favorite part of the game.
and mario slowly taking a nap
I loved the running gag of how you showed every "edge of the cliff" moon at once and was just like "gee, I wonder where I've seen this one before"
Fantastic video, kept me entertained for an entire glove (crocheting), my only wish is that the list at the end had the letter/rank displayed as well. Great stuff!
Neat, now I can compare both yours and Odyssey Central’s rankings!
cool you also watch Odyssey Central!
@@TheCupcakeMan777 I do! With how many different genres and channels I watch and comment on, I often get compared to Christopher Moon lol.
@@TwilightChomperEnthusiastyour his brother pol
I just want you to know how good I sleep listening to this. I keep coming back to it whenever I’m restless. Your voice, the listing off stuff, all perfect for a good nights sleep.
Wow. Four hours. Fir, I know what I’m gonna do today!
Fir, I know what were gonna do today!
Suddenly Phineas and Ferb
Wow today I know exactly what I am gonna do for four hours straight
Ferb, I know what we're gonna do today!
You crazy 🤪
this was a VERY good video. thank you for your time, i love hearing your energy speaking about this game and your most passionately loved/hated moons!
Bench friends at 69 with that subtle tone change was peak
@thinkingfubukioh my… 😳
It was insane, 8 months has put in to make this 4 hours long vid that I spent a week to finish it, great job and I love the rankings!
836 pieces of cheese ranked ✨
Top 836 cheese
Often times it's the contrast that makes the good things great, its why you find serious and scary moments in comedies while finding comedic moments in dramas and horror. Having some obviously crappy/easy moons makes the challenging/great moons shine even more.
i just got done watching Odyssey Central’s all moon ranking video, just for you to upload this one. ironic timing, love it.
This video made me so happy I love it tysm for making this Super Mario Odyssey is one of my hyperfixations and I love hearing people talk about it for hours so you just made my day
Going through these like this helps me to see that the point of Cap Kingdom is to be a tutorial for SMO's unique movement, while Cascade Kingdom is a tutorial for how collecting stars works. That would explain why the moons from those two kingdoms are both very easy, even superficially so, but in different ways. Each moon in Cap Kingdom helps you learn to move, each moon in Cascade Kingdom teaches you about the kinds of puzzles you'll experience to get moons.
Technically you're not really meant to get any moons in cap kingdom until you beat the game bc you'll have no reason to go back and there aren't any moons until you go back so it's not really a tutorial for moving
Fun fact: spin throws can be archived without motion controls by spinning the stick twice to get Mario into a spinning state and then cap throwing
I’ve been really looking forward to this video!!!
Thank you for doing it!
I can’t imagine how long it took to plan out and record all the video.
It’s a great video to listen to while painting. So thank you again!
GREAT VIDEO FIR!!! LOVE YOUR CONTENT, KEEP UP THE AWESOME WORK!!!!!!!!
41:12 For Dancing with New friends, you can also access this moon by wearing the skeleton outfit
Really? That's going in my quiz. I use it on my brother each week so thank you
2:23:24 for a relaxing dance, you can wear the sunshine outfit they added to the game later to enter
I loved the video, the time and dedication is appreciated and worth it, it represents and shows your quality as a youtuber, endure and answer even the most ridiculous questions from your subs IN THE BEST WAY POSSIBLE, I loved the video, GOD tier
1:42:33 If you were too enraptured by the awe of the festival for your secret-hunting brain to be active, i'm sorry but that's a skill issue. Got this moon first try because of *course* I'm going to check on top of the coin blocks I can jump onto.
This is my favourite part of the whole video
Holy shit. Was expecting a livestream montage of you doing a 100% run and saying the tiers but to actually narrate every single moons with explanations? Insane.
So glad this project is FINALLY out, good job on all the hard work! :D
Starting watching this video in release and just finished it, was an absolutely amazing watch.
Only 10 minutes in and already I know this is going to end up in my long video essay rewatch rotation. Great job Fir!
Been mentioning it on stream for months, and you finally released it THANK YOU 😊
This is a great, well-edited video! I like that you found some things to say for even the most unremarkable moons. It shows that you put lots of effort into this!
3:51:50 the slow zoom while letting Mario idle and SLEEP is a great touch.
Happy to see people are still making Mario Oddessy content I love watching it :)
After watching it in chunks I'm finally done watching. No wonder this beast of video took this long to make. Kudos for taking on this wild challenge
16:10 The thing is, that moon was made for you to triple jump, as those steps appear as one set a bit earlier in the kingdom, with a sign telling you about triple jumping.
You put so much work and thought into this. Nice work!
the Glass Is Half Full is top 10 for me, love the fact that the boss arena is the whole kingdom
Finally had time to finish watching! Insane work, Fir! I don't even want to imagine how much work it actually took.
The hatred for a treasure made from coins was to be expected but ngl the intensity for Chargin' Chuck sub-area took me by surprise lmao The conspiracy theory definitely sounds valid tho!
Thank you Fir, this is one of the all time great UA-cam videos. I greatly enjoyed it, please never stop making videos!!!
your altaria stack never fails to make me smile
his NAME is HOPPING????
I guess, because the H is capitalised
@@demoman5864 but every word is capitalized in the moon names (apart from articles and conjunctions like "the", "a", "an", "or", "from", etc.)
@@IsaacHND nice
Yes
I don't think the rabbit has a name, just the fact that he was caught as he was hopping in the whatever
Was not prepared to enjoy this video as much as I did. Watched it over the course of three days lol. It was great to hear such an in depth commentary from someone who knows the game so well
Yo, I literally subscribed yesterday 😂 Great timing!
Amazingly engaging for what this video is. Proud to say I watched every second of it.
Wonder how different this will be from OdysseyCentrals
Same
same chain
Same
Dry bones for smash
@@Xachpro5475 How cute, you chain-breaking dumbass.
Big fan of LS Mark style formatting. Ranking each moon with where it places within its kingdom was a great way to help us visualize your final list before it happened. Can’t wait til this video gets 5 million views
3:53:56 *WWIIDDEE PPEEAACCHH* jumpscare lmao
3:56:40 is a bit closer to it, but whatever
The moon in Lake Kingdom on the Little Pillar is pretty great imo. An unremarkable spot, that still sticks out. You won't find it, if you don't search in such places. And since you don't need every moon to beat the game, it's a nice reward for players trying to find as much secrets as possible.
holy gosh darn heck 4 hours!? good job man
UA-camr Odyssey Central did it in only 2 hours and 36 minutes
@@micahheyward5342his vid was amazing
Odyssey central did the bare minimum, fir’s is way better in my opinion
1:49:06 iirc, the map is a brochure that tells you stuff about the world. It has some if not all the answers to the questions. If it's just some, I think some npcs talk about her
The clown outfit while slowly going to sleep for the Toadette moons lmao
9:43 Fir is officially a time traveler
IKR.💀
That "Found with Cap Kingdom Art"...
FOR MY ENTIRE ODYSSEY PLAYTIME
I THOUGHT THOSE WERE TOSTERENA BUILDINGS
*ARE YOU KIDDING ME*
Yeah, I had to look up most of the Hint Art, especially the Dark Side ones
You got to respect this man for making a 4 hour video just talking about super Mario odyssey moons
2:33:16
All I could think of while you were talking about this was SmallAnt saying "You gotta hit him in the junks!"
Love the effort Fir!!!!!!!!!! Your
patience is extremely impressive!!!!!!!!!! Proud of You!!!!!!!!!!
My spelling isn't the best. 😅
Congrats on your Mario Odyssey doctoral thesis lol. Will be saving this for this weekend for when I tackle cleaning my room
Bro really spent all his time on this video. What a legend. Love your vids btw
2:18:59 okay, I think you should at the very least bump this up to B+ purely for the reference it is. For those who don’t know, this is the exact chest layout as the one in Mario 64 in dire dire docks. And considering the beach cave area, it’s more than def a reference to that original star.
It took me a while to get through the whole thing, but great video! (:
As a wannabe game designer I actually really like On Top of the Rubble because it shows that the devs understand their intended audience: children with limited patience. Your initial Cascade visit isn’t meant to be an open-world tour like most Kingdoms that come after-it’s given a sense of urgency. You’re given a task by a frantic NPC, and children are more likely to help NPCs when they ask for it.
You need 5 Moons to fix the ship. You get Our First Power Moon to introduce yourself to the concept, you fight Ma Broodal to introduce Multi-Moons, and you need a fifth Moon so you can fix the ship and go to the next kingdom right away, where you spend a significantly longer time.
The Moon on Top of the Rubble is placed in an obvious location on purpose so kids don’t feel stressed out when they’re so close to their goal. From there, they can work their way up to the more complex puzzles.
I agree, it serves a really important purpose. But this ranking is mostly about how enjoyable or interesting Fir finds it, rather than how good it is from a game design perspective or the millions of other possible perspectives
his name is secretly fire@@archerelms
holy shit thank you for putting a list of all the songs in the video in the description
11:39 fun fact, there's a bunch of note sets in 3D Land that play some retro tune, usually the SMW athletic theme
30:05 i think you meant "cascade" here
1:24:43 fir can't count confirmed
2:27:42 wait is it "tall rock shell" or "tall rock shelf"
2:30:00 i think you forgot to put what song this is in the list
2:50:18 i mean the mummy only spawns if you grab the hidden coins if that's worth anything
3:04:26 you forgot this song too
3:19:14 oh hey, 3D Land reference
3:29:05 missed this song too
3:30:50 and this one
3:43:19 and this one (i get the feeling that you were starting to wear down)
3:51:05 oh hey, just noticed moon's "hidden on the side of the cliff" and one of the sister moons, cascade's "next to the stone arch" share moon numbers (#29)
3:51:50 mood
another note on the massive list, it's funny to see the long lists of moons with similar names or premises, like the peach moons and the occasional string of timer challenges
4:10:47 um, acktchually that *clearly* says "iceburn circuit class s"
4:13:36 my pleasure ;)
100/10, would binge-watch again
I remember the streams for this, so excited that it's out
THANK YOU FIR. My day has been rough but this brightens it up quite a lot. I love your content in general but 4hrs of it is a blessing. THANKS
I hope the rest of your day is as wonderful as you are, random stranger on the internet
@@BaalFridge wow thank you so much, that really means a lot to me random stranger c:
I just thought of a video idea For you
You may actually like this one.
Super Mario Odyssey, but Koopa free free-running is always Active
That's basically Where You're trying to beat the game. Before the Koopas do. So you're racing against the Koopas. To the end of the game. Maybe you could add some other twist. Cause seems kind of easy but still.
This has become a comfort video for me.
bro forgets not everyone is a god gamer like him with the "too easy" moons. odyssey is for everyone, but still glad to know some of the moons I struggle with are also hated by speed runners
this was a list of how much he enjoyed the moons not an objective tierlist of how good they are.
omg a 4 hour video, I'm gonna be watching this all through next week
Saying this took 8 months of time while posting 19 videos in that span is insane, major props
The fact that fir has the mental fortitude for this is absolutely insane.
7:05 I remember at one point me and my sister were trying to collect all the moons, she would play and I would read her descriptions on how to find the moons. She was better at the game than me except for the Koopa races. I always felt so cool doing the Koopa races for her
This is so interesting, no one would have every thought of this
I’ll call it. Worst is the Volleyball
100 and the best is darker side!
Coin cougher moon exists
I say the badest Mons are the flying sphynx and Taxi
Volleyball 100 is literally the only moon i am missing. My high score was 70-something and i have refused to go abck and try again ever since failing that run
@@TheCodysbiggestfan same here, I hate that moon
@@TheCodysbiggestfan try 2 player mode
@Fir both you and your editor deserve a GG the must have been a lot of work and I really enjoyed it :)
Oh boy this is gonna be fun 😃
Volleyball 100 better be last 😂
Never felt like a long video! Fir always deliver good dopamine fr
You missed that in order for Peach to appear in a kingdom you must get world peace in that kingdom, making it another reward for world peace. I always liked that aspect of Peach’s moons.
edit: everything here on is an edit added while watching the video
11:36 “I wish they played a small theme like that one star in Mario Galaxy” ah yes, the one time the notes in Mario Galaxy played a small theme
So far Fir has yet to talk about the importance of teaching new players using early moons, or the subtle storytelling from moons (like lost in the luggage) (or thanks for the charge. I always loved the story telling of that one)
Thank you so much for making this video. It helped me get all 880 moons in Mario Odyssey and helped me 100% it.🎮
I've got a certain amount of fondness for the taxi/sphinx in distance moons. They're like a shitpost romhack moon but in the actual game.
as someone with very scattered mario odyssey knowledge who mostly followed the low% captures category (all about using cappy as little as possible and only getting the moons needed to progress the run), i was entirely unaware of a majority of these moons before this video. and im having the time of my life watching it and learning about all of them, so :3 great work, just, really engaging
3:33:55 sorry gotta remember my spot 😅
1:10:25
I love how it goes from so much hate to just chill 😂
While I don’t disagree with your rankings, I am a little surprised that some of the common “Any %” moons got ranked lower for being boring. Ones that might be boring to find from a player’s perspective, but are on your path in a speedrun, are always nice to get if you want to leave the kingdom earlier, and I was expecting some moons to get bumped up to slightly higher rankings for that.
I can't be the only one who thought it said 80 and 90 at 2:15:10
Also I have to say, I think it would have been nice to always show the current tier in the final ranking. Besides that, I really appreciate the effort that went into this video, congrats on finally getting it out!
4:12:01 WHAT THERE IS A DRAGON IN DARKER SIDE?!?!
I wish
Oh my gosh, it's been so long since I last saw a brand new comment pop up 😭
good video, lost kingdom was my favorite ever since I first picked up this game. The smaller size and verticality allows for skips like in the koopa freerunning and reminds me of something like whomps