i agree , today the best singers around can't hold a candle to her esp.Barbra in her prime ....just GORGEOUS VOICE , SO BEAUTIFUL TO listen ✨to ❤️🔥💞❣️💜💥🙏✨🎶🎶🎶🎵🎶🎤🎶🎶🎵🎶🎶her voice is a gift 🎀🎶🎶
Great analysis. I think what hits me about Barbra is the way she emotes. As you say, she acts the song like a scene in a play. Beautiful clarity and purity in her voice too ❤
John, I never mind it when you pause because your analyses are always both relevant and illuminating, and I especially appreciate that you give special attention to rhythm, it's such a crucial part of what makes a performance land. And Barbra is a legend of course, truly unmatched
I have been a Barbra fan since the mid-60's, and she still astounds. I have two Streisand playlists saved, one is 20-odd performances (the list changes occasionally as youtube removes some videos from the site), in chronological order, ranging from her as a nineteen-year-old making her network tv debut on 'The Tonight Show' to her last tour (The Music, The Mem'ries, The Magic). All astounding performances, all LIVE, and the vast majority performed way before any kind of autotuning or 'sweetening' of the vocal line ever considered, and usually not even possible. The other playlist I love to listen to is her 'My Man' playlist, consisting of live performances of this song ranging from this one, to her performance of the song in the film 'Funny Girl', to a tv special promoting "Funny Lady" in the 70's, performing it during her first live concert in twenty-some years at the MGM Grand in 1993, and then two other concerts from 2006 and 2019. Has she had to alter keys and gained some hoarseness and lost some of her ability to hold those notes so wonderfully long as she aged? Absolutely. Did she EVER sing it the same way twice? Absolultely NOT!!! Her musical conductor and arranger for the 2006 tour said something along the lines of: "I know where My Man starts and where we will basically end, but I never know exactly how she is going to get there". Some singers are honestly mediocre vocalists when looked at strictly for the quality of their singing, but are still great singers because of how they can interpret and perform the song. And then there are some fantastically talented singers who have uncanny precision and unique vocal talents, but while they are performing 'perfectly' they may please your ears without warming your heart. Barbra's voice touches my soul and I will always be glad that I was alive to be able to hear this glorious singer.
I’d be interested in seeing your reaction to “He Touched Me” from A Happening in Central Park (1967). The whole concert is spectacular, but that particular performance gives me chills and I’ve easily listened to it over 100xs
Everything you said is soooo true and it is vexxing to see so few views on these reaction videos of some of the greatest singers because they are somehow forgotten by present generation. Especially since these are artists from a pre autotune/pitchcorrection days. From the era when to become a singer you had to be able to actually sing. And to become one of the greats you had to be an actually Great singer. btw if you want to hear another excellent singer more to date..check out Zhou Shen from China! You will enjoy for sure
Streisand's vocal performance of 'If I Didn't Love You' is exceptional. Her breath control and phrasing are unmatched. I fail to even consider anyone doing a better job. Barbra truly is a galaxy of talent among lesser stars.
"Perfection" is the perfect word to describe Barbra Streisand. And to think, she never had any vocal training... that's all innate natural talent and instinct. And another remarkable thing about Barbra, you never hear her perform a song the same way, no matter how many times she's sung it. She sings in the moment. Some things just can't be taught. Enjoyed your professional take on inarguably (to me anyway), the greatest vocalist ever.
@Spo-Dee-O-Dee Exactly! She would say...'I don't care about the money, I want control over my work.' And "The Broadway Album" is a perfect testament to that.
Babs is absolutely amazing! It is mind blowing that some artists have the body awareness to develop this high of a level of technique on their own. I am still teaching, but hearing someone this great really inspires me to start singing ore myself. Thank you for this great analysis.
This performance continues to enthrall me. And I was fortunate enough to see My Name Is Barbra on the night it was broadcast [I was 14]. Your reactions were thrilling to watch also. Thank you, John!
When I was little and my mother played her early recordings, I called Barbra, "The lady who sings." Like there were no others. There still aren't. She was a gift go humanity.
I've loved her voice for decades! I had the pleasure of seeing her live in concert. One of the greatest singers ever, by any metric. It's a shame that younger people only know her as an actress. My teenage nephew had no idea that she started as a singer. My favorite live performances from her TV specials: C'est Si Bon, How Does the Wine Taste and Starting Here/Starting Now.
There’s actually a better version to break down. She actually sounds like a trumpet when she hits the higher “what’s the difference if I say …. “ and she also goes into a higher note on the second “he’ll never know “ so there is more variation to both verses… one thing is…. She IS perfection
Not sure how to request one of your excellent reactions/breakdowns but listening to you break down the incredible Dan Vasc's performances would be an education. His range is phenomenal . His list of covers is huge. A metal singer with 10 years classical training and the control of a seasoned opera singer, who can sing anything [almost literally] . "Metal singer sings Amazing Grace" should tell you something. And he's done Nessun Dorma too . And to stay on topic, love Barbra. Old enough to have watched her films in the cinema : ) Thanks for the reaction.
This is the best vocal analysis I’ve heard about Barbra and this song. You are incredibly good at this! I rarely hear such Intelligent discussion of vocal production. Thank you! I’m a vocal instructor and you and I would have a lot of fun talking about singing!! And this particular performance by this legendary vocalist is as you say PERFECTION. It is the moment she became a superstar.
I wish you would react to the other perfect singer of the 20th century - Judy Garland. Her duet with Barbra Streisand is a classic. Happy Days are here again. Her finale in the Get Happy finale of the movie Summerstock is also outstanding. She has the best version imo of Old Man River.
Barbra She has so much technique, I repeat, so much technique that it is ABSURD to think that she didn't even study for this, 99% of the existing techniques that fit into the human voice, she reproduces with greater naturalness.
It is StreiSand. Not Streisand. As a singer she has no equal. The voice and musicianship is almost too much to believe it has come from a human being. She is breathing!
She's been performing for over 60 years. You might want to learn how to pronounce her last name. There is no Z in iy. It is simply two syllables Strei and Sand. Maybe you could use this to remember how to pronounce her name. When you go to the beach You will see wet sand and dry sand, but you probably will not see Streisand.
Fifty years ago, Barbra had me under her spell. Think I drove my family crazy listening to her vinyls. Still love her.
know what you'r talking about!
i agree , today the best singers around can't hold a candle to her esp.Barbra in her prime ....just GORGEOUS VOICE , SO BEAUTIFUL TO listen ✨to ❤️🔥💞❣️💜💥🙏✨🎶🎶🎶🎵🎶🎤🎶🎶🎵🎶🎶her voice is a gift 🎀🎶🎶
Streisand is the best singer of my lifetime. Her abilities are heaven sent
No, they are not..they are a happy genetic fluke in where she has the talent AND the interest AND the opportunity
I appreciate you reacting to Barbra because not alot of people are. I hope you do more of her ❤
Great analysis. I think what hits me about Barbra is the way she emotes. As you say, she acts the song like a scene in a play. Beautiful clarity and purity in her voice too ❤
John, I never mind it when you pause because your analyses are always both relevant and illuminating, and I especially appreciate that you give special attention to rhythm, it's such a crucial part of what makes a performance land. And Barbra is a legend of course, truly unmatched
Mama o man never ever will be a voice like this again God blessed her throat and gave us the best
I have been a Barbra fan since the mid-60's, and she still astounds. I have two Streisand playlists saved, one is 20-odd performances (the list changes occasionally as youtube removes some videos from the site), in chronological order, ranging from her as a nineteen-year-old making her network tv debut on 'The Tonight Show' to her last tour (The Music, The Mem'ries, The Magic). All astounding performances, all LIVE, and the vast majority performed way before any kind of autotuning or 'sweetening' of the vocal line ever considered, and usually not even possible. The other playlist I love to listen to is her 'My Man' playlist, consisting of live performances of this song ranging from this one, to her performance of the song in the film 'Funny Girl', to a tv special promoting "Funny Lady" in the 70's, performing it during her first live concert in twenty-some years at the MGM Grand in 1993, and then two other concerts from 2006 and 2019. Has she had to alter keys and gained some hoarseness and lost some of her ability to hold those notes so wonderfully long as she aged? Absolutely. Did she EVER sing it the same way twice? Absolultely NOT!!! Her musical conductor and arranger for the 2006 tour said something along the lines of: "I know where My Man starts and where we will basically end, but I never know exactly how she is going to get there". Some singers are honestly mediocre vocalists when looked at strictly for the quality of their singing, but are still great singers because of how they can interpret and perform the song. And then there are some fantastically talented singers who have uncanny precision and unique vocal talents, but while they are performing 'perfectly' they may please your ears without warming your heart. Barbra's voice touches my soul and I will always be glad that I was alive to be able to hear this glorious singer.
I’d be interested in seeing your reaction to “He Touched Me” from A Happening in Central Park (1967). The whole concert is spectacular, but that particular performance gives me chills and I’ve easily listened to it over 100xs
Everything you said is soooo true and it is vexxing to see so few views on these reaction videos of some of the greatest singers because they are somehow forgotten by present generation. Especially since these are artists from a pre autotune/pitchcorrection days. From the era when to become a singer you had to be able to actually sing. And to become one of the greats you had to be an actually Great singer.
btw if you want to hear another excellent singer more to date..check out Zhou Shen from China! You will enjoy for sure
Streisand's vocal performance of 'If I Didn't Love You' is exceptional. Her breath control and phrasing are unmatched. I fail to even consider anyone doing a better job. Barbra truly is a galaxy of talent among lesser stars.
"Perfection" is the perfect word to describe Barbra Streisand. And to think, she never had any vocal training... that's all innate natural talent and instinct. And another remarkable thing about Barbra, you never hear her perform a song the same way, no matter how many times she's sung it. She sings in the moment. Some things just can't be taught. Enjoyed your professional take on inarguably (to me anyway), the greatest vocalist ever.
@Spo-Dee-O-Dee Exactly! She would say...'I don't care about the money, I want control over my work.' And "The Broadway Album" is a perfect testament to that.
@Spo-Dee-O-Dee She's one of a kind!"
Fabuleuse, talentueuse, une magicienne ❤❤❤
Babs is absolutely amazing! It is mind blowing that some artists have the body awareness to develop this high of a level of technique on their own. I am still teaching, but hearing someone this great really inspires me to start singing ore myself. Thank you for this great analysis.
I love how excited you are listening to her because I feel the exact same way! Thanks for the analysis.
She is amazing.
Thank you for such a beautiful reaction and analysis. Barbara is one and only. My favourite female vocal. Warm greetings from Serbia.
Breathtaking!!!!!!!!!
Barbra’s a legend. An amazing singer & story teller! A fellow NYer like me.❤❤❤❤
This performance continues to enthrall me. And I was fortunate enough to see My Name Is Barbra on the night it was broadcast [I was 14]. Your reactions were thrilling to watch also. Thank you, John!
Thank you for watching.
When I was little and my mother played her early recordings, I called Barbra, "The lady who sings." Like there were no others. There still aren't. She was a gift go humanity.
I've loved her voice for decades! I had the pleasure of seeing her live in concert. One of the greatest singers ever, by any metric. It's a shame that younger people only know her as an actress. My teenage nephew had no idea that she started as a singer. My favorite live performances from her TV specials: C'est Si Bon, How Does the Wine Taste and Starting Here/Starting Now.
I grew up listening to her records in the 60s. Phenomenal!
On that last note, I'm hearing a tone that's an octave above what she is singing.
Good ears! She is boosting the higher harmonic by adjusting her vocal tract resonance.
Brilliant technical breakdown. Thank you.
Thank you!
Was obsessed with her as a kid (and a former Brooklynite like her) to me …she’s one of the greatest vocalists ..if not the best 💕
There’s actually a better version to break down. She actually sounds like a trumpet when she hits the higher “what’s the difference if I say …. “ and she also goes into a higher note on the second “he’ll never know “ so there is more variation to both verses… one thing is…. She IS perfection
Not sure how to request one of your excellent reactions/breakdowns but listening to you break down the incredible Dan Vasc's performances would be an education. His range is phenomenal . His list of covers is huge. A metal singer with 10 years classical training and the control of a seasoned opera singer, who can sing anything [almost literally] . "Metal singer sings Amazing Grace" should tell you something. And he's done Nessun Dorma too . And to stay on topic, love Barbra. Old enough to have watched her films in the cinema : ) Thanks for the reaction.
Great stuff John. Fun to hear it from a virtuoso and to see you so exuberant over it make it a pleasure to watch.
My all time favorite singer, actor, director…..and person. The only singer that has similar dynamics in her songs is Lara Fabian .
@SamuelM.-iz1unOh hell to the NO Sam. Lara is NOT a Celine wannabe. Her idol is Streisand.
@SamuelM.-iz1unOh hell to the No. Lara idolizes Streisand (as do I.) A Celine wannabe she is not.
Please react to Gabriel Henrique, from Brazil. I'd be interested on your take.
This is the best vocal analysis I’ve heard about Barbra and this song. You are incredibly good at this! I rarely hear such Intelligent discussion of vocal production. Thank you! I’m a vocal instructor and you and I would have a lot of fun talking about singing!! And this particular performance by this legendary vocalist is as you say PERFECTION. It is the moment she became a superstar.
Hi Doug, thank you for the kind feedback! It’s always nice to meet fellow voice teachers.
@@JohnHennyVocalStudio thanks for the reply! Hope we can meet sometime!!
I wish you would react to the other perfect singer of the 20th century - Judy Garland.
Her duet with Barbra Streisand is a classic. Happy Days are here again.
Her finale in the Get Happy finale of the movie Summerstock is also outstanding.
She has the best version imo of Old Man River.
The greatest singer ever period
The greatest singer of all time!
❤Perfection
Barbra She has so much technique, I repeat, so much technique that it is ABSURD to think that she didn't even study for this, 99% of the existing techniques that fit into the human voice, she reproduces with greater naturalness.
Great analysis. Most of these " coach " reactions are alot of guff. Not this one.
She is just perfect... not amazing, not incredible, she´s perfect.
No one has the vocal dynamics of Streisand
NO ONE!
👍👍👍
I heartily suggest you listen to this song by Kathy Kirby..... A. M. A. Z. I. N. G.!
It is StreiSand. Not Streisand. As a singer she has no equal. The voice and musicianship is almost too much to believe it has come from a human being. She is breathing!
She's been performing for over 60 years. You might want to learn how to pronounce her last name. There is no Z in iy. It is simply two syllables Strei and Sand.
Maybe you could use this to remember how to pronounce her name.
When you go to the beach
You will see wet sand and dry sand, but you probably will not see Streisand.
Say it like this: STRY - SAND😊
You should have used the movie clip from funny girl. She shot the ending scene live with full Orchestra. It's a lot better than this.
Her last name is pronounced StreiSand like sand on the beach.
You need to pronounce her name correctly. StreiSand not StreiZand.
Not Streizand!
Not a musician at all but I do know it's the phrasing that makes her special to me anyway.