【Apple】 A woman rejected me because she thought I didn't earn enough but... [Compilation]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @maryh-w8647
    @maryh-w8647 Рік тому +44

    Sounds like she’s trying to camouflage POISON to me🤣😂

    • @sandrasausville9103
      @sandrasausville9103 Рік тому +5

      She's thinking that if he starts the divorce process then she'll be getting paid lmao 🤣😂

    • @lorifiedler13
      @lorifiedler13 Рік тому +3

      Not much of a disguise, imo.

  • @manxkin
    @manxkin Рік тому +24

    Death by blue cheese. 9 minutes in and I can't take any more blue cheese.

  • @ritafryer8134
    @ritafryer8134 Рік тому +4

    To chill out at a cafe with a bacon butty and a coffee makes my day.

    • @rhio-ohki6107
      @rhio-ohki6107 8 місяців тому +1

      🤔 burger vans soo much better imo anyways 😂mm bacon butty 😋

    • @met999000
      @met999000 6 місяців тому +1

      Don't know what a bacon butty is but Bacon makes everything taste better and I understand where you're coming from

    • @rhio-ohki6107
      @rhio-ohki6107 6 місяців тому +1

      @met999000 a bacon "butty" is basically a slang for bacon sandwich, either with bread or a roll/ bap depending where you are 🤷‍♀️ hope that helped 😁

  • @bcgrote
    @bcgrote Рік тому +20

    A guy who can cook and is frugal? Take me to the pub!

  • @ImaginaryCyborg
    @ImaginaryCyborg Рік тому +60

    I mean Blue Cheese is nice and all, but on every meal? C'mon Nat.

    • @susanhansen1290
      @susanhansen1290 Рік тому

      Maybe she has a blue cheese fetish?

    • @susanhansen1290
      @susanhansen1290 Рік тому +3

      Maybe the boyfriend is a blue cheese salesman?

    • @crazycatladym3027
      @crazycatladym3027 11 місяців тому +2

      And its not that healthy

    • @pollypockets508
      @pollypockets508 11 місяців тому

      😂​@@susanhansen1290

    • @wilmahunt
      @wilmahunt 8 місяців тому +1

      Has she not heard of personal taste preferences? She is just trying to drive him away so it won't be her fault.

  • @karenperras3814
    @karenperras3814 Рік тому +52

    I find the Blue cheese so damn funny every time he says it, I cant stop laughing LOL

    • @therealmaizing5328
      @therealmaizing5328 Рік тому +5

      It's hilarious! 🤣

    • @sandrasausville9103
      @sandrasausville9103 Рік тому +9

      I swear he sounds like a 50's greaser. I have to laugh, he's awesome

    • @autodogdact3313
      @autodogdact3313 Рік тому +5

      Exactly, I was going to say that too.

    • @lorifiedler13
      @lorifiedler13 Рік тому +5

      Curry with blue cheese. Eeew.

    • @WennekeMama
      @WennekeMama Рік тому +1

      I was watching this at night, while my husband was sleeping next to me. Couldn't stop laughing either 😅😂

  • @tricorvus2673
    @tricorvus2673 Рік тому +19

    In the corner of Hell where Natalie will end up, there’s nothing but bleu cheese.

  • @hoptoit5910
    @hoptoit5910 Рік тому +11

    Geez, how many times can one person say ‘blue cheese’ in a single conversation?

  • @sandykauffman8856
    @sandykauffman8856 Рік тому +3

    Blue Cheese In STEW ?!?!?!? That should be a War Crime!!!!!!!

  • @angellucas-ranck9594
    @angellucas-ranck9594 Рік тому +26

    ive never understood why cheaters always blow up about "Their privacy" whenever they get caught especially by their partner seeing stuff on their phone. of course ive never understood cheaters in anyway. why dont people just end the relationship rather then cheat.

    • @randysmith9636
      @randysmith9636 Рік тому +6

      Very well said, I agree 100%.

    • @jenevans7664
      @jenevans7664 4 місяці тому +1

      Because cheaters want to have their cake and eat it too!!! The morons.

  • @randysmith9636
    @randysmith9636 Рік тому +21

    I dated a woman that was always wanting to go to high end restaurants every weekend. I didn't mind going but every week was a little much. The food is fantastic, i honestly do enjoy going especially the sweet tea, it is the best around. Plus you get to look around at all the wears they have to offer. They do carry the best selection of old fashioned candy. As a bonus you can play checkers or the peg game while you are waiting for your food.
    But constantly wanting to go to high end restaurants will break a fellow.

    • @ellenosceola5707
      @ellenosceola5707 Рік тому +5

      Lol Cracker Barrel is not bad 😂

    • @lorifiedler13
      @lorifiedler13 Рік тому +3

      We bring Uno when the family goes out for pizza.

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +2

      Wait, you said "high end restaurants" then described the experience of going to Cracker Barrel. Did I miss something?

    • @randysmith9636
      @randysmith9636 Рік тому +2

      @@KamiNoBaka1
      Lol, high end is a relative term. It all depends on where you are starting from. If splurging on your anniversary dinner is super sizing your meal then CB is probably high end.
      It's all about perspective brother.

    • @dorothytucker9305
      @dorothytucker9305 Рік тому +3

      Take me to a greasy spoon any day of the week! Fru fru places have less food for way more money. I.e. 2 peas that they put cupped smoke on 1 leaf of lettuce and a drop of pudding for $200. Gimme a cheese burger and some curly fries dang it!😂

  • @BelleDede01
    @BelleDede01 Рік тому +15

    Good stories, good voices for each character's, and good editing.

  • @Lisa_The_Norwegian
    @Lisa_The_Norwegian Рік тому +43

    Okey, I am just going on a limb here and say, Natalie has a plan. Everyone who loves blue cheese knows it’s not for everyone, and would never put it in food if it weren’t agreed upon. She is starting a fight!
    And there it is..

    • @Lisa_The_Norwegian
      @Lisa_The_Norwegian Рік тому +5

      Isabel should know if you are inviting or suggesting the place for a date, you are the one who has to pay.

    • @nilajakamau7854
      @nilajakamau7854 Рік тому +6

      he even pointed out how she avoided consuming the cheese when put into a stew. my imagination conjured up an image of her meals including blue cheese and "my stomach is bubbling" 🤢🤮 in my world, blue cheese is dipping sauce for buffalo wings, fancy roasted meat sandwiches(w/even fancier toothpicks) and fruit/veggie salads.

    • @Lisa_The_Norwegian
      @Lisa_The_Norwegian Рік тому +6

      @@nilajakamau7854 I haven’t gotten to a stage in my life where I like Blue Cheese, but from what I know about it, and my limitid knowledge of cooking, it has a strong taste and will overpower a lot of other ingredients, so it doesn’t seem like a «for every meal» type of ingredient. I also didn’t think it was a particular cheap ingredient, so it seems like a poor plan all around. But now I find that honesty is usually easier in relationships than a huge scheme 😂

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому

      @@nilajakamau7854 So you've never encountered blue cheese outside of a sauce or dressing? It's good stuff as long as you like strong flavors. I'm especially partial to having small slices of blue stilton on crackers with green olives. Not that I have it often, good blue cheese is expensive.

    • @randykincy7954
      @randykincy7954 Рік тому +3

      @@Lisa_The_Norwegianblue cheese on a steak or a burger isn’t bad, particularly if you add bacon to the burger. No way you can add it to every meal though. That’s insane

  • @susanhansen1290
    @susanhansen1290 Рік тому +2

    Last one) jack picks up his sisters abandoned 3yr old son from his parents for his wife to take care of even tho she has a sick daughter and the boy has a temper and bullies his younger cousin.

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt 8 місяців тому +1

    Sounds like an honest sensible man.

  • @smhaceofspades2813
    @smhaceofspades2813 Рік тому +3

    Thanks a lot Natalie NOW I hate blue cheese even more how could you hurt my HOMIE with such poison!!!!

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt Рік тому +11

    If she is relying on him for groceries, cut her allowance

  • @ahtamclovin
    @ahtamclovin 3 місяці тому +1

    I like ones I don’t need to fast forward through it’s too stressful listening to the abuses

  • @Lupinemancer87
    @Lupinemancer87 Рік тому +3

    A lot of times, women can be extremely prideful, and have very fragile egos. Just ask my sister-in-law.

  • @StoopidMonkeysMomma
    @StoopidMonkeysMomma Рік тому +7

    Take a shot every time they say blue cheese lol

  • @susanhansen1290
    @susanhansen1290 Рік тому +2

    If you want someone to leave work and take care if your 2 kids and clean your house, pay what she would earn on the job. Even family.

  • @shawngilbert4306
    @shawngilbert4306 Рік тому +2

    Flash forward, Isabel moved town 3.8 decades later and went deep into debt to go under the knife before she tried her luck at another speed dating event, back to her flashy clothes with revealing. She got extremely flirty with one of attendees and had one drink after another, and soon began interacting and touching all of the male guests socially inappropriately, using all the techniques and cringey dialogues that she used when she was 19 years old, making loud scandalous announcements after touching their junk without consent, sometimes taking selfies with them without asking while they were uncomfortably pressed against her. It all went downhill when Isabel groaned and barfed all over one unfortunate member whose first time impression at such a speed dating event was ruined. Unfortunately all of this was caught and livestreamed through Ray-Ban glasses onto social media, by one of the younger looking attendees that Isabel got too personal with. Isabel made such a drunken hysterical mess of herself when she was arrested by the police and dragged away by the cops kicking and screaming away from the event, while everyone clapped and cheered as they looked her while uploading the whole scene onto Twitter. Ignoring her distressing [crocodile] tears the judge told Isabel that wae banned from both dating sites, parties as well as having any attachment to any member of the opposite gender whatsoever at any state, thanks to a tracked record of complaints by many men who had enough of her pretentious nature and lack of socially appropriate interpersonal skills. Currently Isabel is 90 years old and lives in a retirement home in and out of dementia. She smiles and sobs at her sorry state as the judge only allows the female medical staff to attend to her wellbeing, albeit detachedly after finding out about her history and completely ignoring her attempts for attention and idle chit chat regarding her desire to marry and have lots and lots of children with a young man one day.

  • @katcapuano1601
    @katcapuano1601 Рік тому +2

    I think alot of people might disagree with not taking the child in. However, I've been in that exact situation. My heart wanted to take him in, my heart would like to home all the children in need of one; but his behavioral issues posed a risk to my children, and when discussing it with them, my children expressed discomfort with living with him due to that. That was pretty much the end of the discussion. While I would like to home and care for all the children, I have to consider my own first, they are my primary responsibility and priority. He needed more help than I had to give

  • @jenniferbeyer6412
    @jenniferbeyer6412 Рік тому +8

    Dudes voice is annoying. Blue Cheese is ok, but not in all the food.
    The way he says purpose was hysterical.
    There is the reason she is trying to drive him crazy.
    Hate cheaters, if you want to see someone else, then break up or divorce. It hurts to break up but that's better than cheating, might as well to literally stab a knife in the back.

  • @BrettHarvey-u6c
    @BrettHarvey-u6c Рік тому +2

    2nd story, I've heard this before. But I like the voice actors in this version.

  • @gailwarnock2764
    @gailwarnock2764 Рік тому +3

    OMG he sounds like Elmer Fudd 😂😂😂😂

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt 8 місяців тому +1

    Poor Natalie, she should know cheating is just as bad AND the same as lying. If Thomas' wife is gullible, Natalie will be thrown under the bus.😢

  • @susanhansen1290
    @susanhansen1290 Рік тому +2

    I'd take the tavern food over the duck thing.

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt 8 місяців тому +1

    Isobel, if you tell him the restaurant and the menu you want, and YOU ask himt to go, it means you are the hostess and YOU PAY.
    If HE asks you out, HE pays. Or you could go dutch.

  • @femininevibes2213
    @femininevibes2213 Рік тому +2

    A few hundred dollars!? Lady you are crazy

  • @jenniferbeyer6412
    @jenniferbeyer6412 Рік тому +9

    This mom leaving the kids with grandparents, is rude. She needs to take care of her kids herself. And find daycare for them on herself.
    I was going to say they should call CPS and the police.

    • @Mew_Mokuba_Akari
      @Mew_Mokuba_Akari Рік тому +2

      Her office had daycare. But she'd rather spend the money on expensive stuff than on the daycare. Which begs the question why did she agree to go through with fertility treatments if she didn't want to pay for daycare and hubby seems out of the picture for long stretches of time

  • @lynnedunne6190
    @lynnedunne6190 Рік тому +8

    I'd be on the first plane, train or automobile to get out of there.

  • @donnalynch6845
    @donnalynch6845 Рік тому +2

    Yeah right Jack

  • @iriscurbelo4144
    @iriscurbelo4144 Рік тому +10

    I love to eat at Diners.
    Good meals.
    It's much cheaper.

    • @Jerseybytes2
      @Jerseybytes2 Рік тому +2

      hubby and I were lost once and didn't know what part of the state we were in. I was also hungry, so I told him to stop at the next diner so we could have food. when we got there I read the menu and knew where we were. they had pork roll on the menu.

  • @gdangeldth
    @gdangeldth Рік тому +6

    Dear creators. Please add transitions if the day/time/situation changes. It’s helpful that way.

  • @donyamcashburn5440
    @donyamcashburn5440 Рік тому +2

    Isabel should have kept her mouth shut. Don't like where a guy takes you, don't go again. But to dis a guy for not spending a bundle. Sad.
    When I'm ask where I want to eat, I say cheap.

  • @Justme-so2bo
    @Justme-so2bo Рік тому +4

    A woman like her that always wants to like high off someone else hogs she gives someone like us woman that doesn't care about a man's static just as long as he is working and we are helping to support each other I am satisfied with that.

  • @lynngrant533
    @lynngrant533 Рік тому +4

    These compilations are OK, but a pain in the ass without timestamps. PLEASE put timestamps in the comments or description or somewhere!

  • @nayatoneko
    @nayatoneko Рік тому +3

    I still dont ged why she tought she had any right to any money.
    She the cheater so no money😂

  • @annagilstrap4995
    @annagilstrap4995 Рік тому +7

    Oh so pathetic! I actually feel sorry for people like her because they will never know the joy of being loved for themselves nstead of superficial things.

  • @twiceshy9773
    @twiceshy9773 Рік тому +3

    Its the Gossip City voice actors?? Jeez, how many channels do they have??!

  • @denisebatts3414
    @denisebatts3414 Рік тому +5

    He has a Brooklyn accent sound like John Travolta or any other man from Brooklyn, bensonhurst

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +2

      He sounds more like someone who's not American and has only heard a Brooklyn accent on TV trying to emulate a Brooklyn accent.

  • @sandrasausville9103
    @sandrasausville9103 Рік тому +12

    I don't know about the rest of the women out there but I find a man who can cook kinda 🔥🔥 and he can cook well uh, I'll take that.😊

    • @therealmaizing5328
      @therealmaizing5328 Рік тому +4

      Yeah! If I were dating a guy who cooks, I'd ask him to cook the meal for our date. I'd even offer to buy the ingredients.

    • @sandrasausville9103
      @sandrasausville9103 Рік тому +1

      ​@@therealmaizing5328I married mine ❤. He's a amazing guy and a great cook

    • @annanderson7
      @annanderson7 Рік тому +4

      Yep, it is 🔥!

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +4

      Maybe I should lead with the fact that I'm a guy who loves to cook in my dating profile...

    • @annanderson7
      @annanderson7 Рік тому +3

      @@KamiNoBaka1 🤣🤣🤣

  • @jboardman34
    @jboardman34 Рік тому

    I would call my brother as soon as my sister in law dropped her kids with my elderly father. Ask him what he wants me to do

  • @helenedeniger5545
    @helenedeniger5545 Рік тому +2

    The accent...new york italian meets boston meets texas. For real?!?

  • @ajt62
    @ajt62 Рік тому +6

    A Kiwi trying a Brooklyn accent?

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +3

      Is THAT what that was? I couldn't tell if it was supposed to be NY or NJ, and had no idea what the VA's base accent was, but NZ would make sense with the specific odd pronunciations lol

  • @deborahsavrnoch7055
    @deborahsavrnoch7055 Рік тому +3

    Someone send Jeeves back to the mansion LoL

  • @sitarilyra9637
    @sitarilyra9637 2 місяці тому

    I LOVE blue cheese. I would not, however, want it for every meal. That's just too much

  • @mb1656
    @mb1656 Рік тому +4

    Omg, why do these women marry these horrible men & then start whining & complaining so just leave already instead of dealing w their crap , stand up for yourself & quit being a doormat already especially if your husband wont help in any way but instead forces you to do everything 🤦‍♀️🤬

  • @elainepeterson475
    @elainepeterson475 Рік тому +3

    The foundation and new floor came out very good. The woukd you get from your Fathers mill is fine qaukity. The whole House remodel is coming along well Abby🙏👍

  • @Ally.81
    @Ally.81 Рік тому +9

    Sometimes taverns have the best food and in my opinion the duck at a French restaurant is not so good, my bf got it once and it was dry and to pay 50 euro for a piece of dry duck is a waste. Don't get me wrong he said he loved it, but I had duck growing up (my grand parents had a farm) and it never was so dry.

    • @KamiNoBaka1
      @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +3

      That's going to depend on the restaurant. I mean, I live in the US, and here a lot of French restaurants charge an arm and a leg regardless of the actual quality of food just on the reputation of French cuisine. Most people who frequently go to expensive restaurants are also the type who think price equals quality, so they can get away with it.
      It's kind of like liquor; the most expensive brands are the most expensive not because they're the best, but because they're the biggest brand names.

  • @lynngrant533
    @lynngrant533 Рік тому +8

    In the second story, the gap between conversations is way too long. I can't speed it up because then the voices sound like chipmunks. Please listen to what you record and realize that real conversations don't have such a long response time.

  • @BelleDede01
    @BelleDede01 Рік тому +3

    The language that this Jack uses to talk to his wife 'ruthless asshole' ... Really? Plus of course he'll be expecting his wife to take care of his nephew Dan, right? He didn't even want to pick up his own daughter but cares that much for his nephew. Really? Run woman run!

  • @kristenhogansassy1
    @kristenhogansassy1 Рік тому +2

    The guys accent on the first story is killing me

  • @mrsdinosaur1009
    @mrsdinosaur1009 Рік тому +5

    Why does the female voice actor seem to rush through the scripts?

  • @KamiNoBaka1
    @KamiNoBaka1 Рік тому +7

    Look, I love blue cheese, but I really can't think of ANY stew that should have ANY cheese in it.
    Unless you count things like chili topped with cheese or saag paneer as stews. And even then, you don't use blue cheese for that.
    Do have to say that while I appreciate when these videos use an actual dude to voice act dudes instead of a woman making her voice as deep as possible, but maybe lay off the really bad fake NY/NJ accent. You know it's bad because you can't tell if it's supposed to be NY or NJ. And weirdly occasionally sounds Southern lol

  • @stevenmcglinn5954
    @stevenmcglinn5954 Рік тому +4

    I would not any meal with cheese in it apart from sandwiches and never anything with blue cheese. I would rather starve. I have gibe 28 days without any food in hospital as they insistent on including pepper on everything including cereals.

  • @kdeville87
    @kdeville87 Рік тому +3

    I knew she was cheating

  • @gailwarnock2764
    @gailwarnock2764 Рік тому +3

    She's snotty and entitled just horrible . He is luck y he found out what she's really like .

  • @everymoviehero9248
    @everymoviehero9248 11 місяців тому

    Know what else is a good source of calcium, chocolate milk

  • @aldecursoe7173
    @aldecursoe7173 Рік тому +1

    I know he's the nice guy and she's the problem, but who could put up with that voice/accent for more than 5 minutes? 🤷‍♂️

  • @oldwoman5942
    @oldwoman5942 Рік тому +2

    I HATE Blue Cheese though my husband loves it but he has never even tried to get me to eat it because I am an adult!

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt 8 місяців тому

    Reduce the household budget and her allowance by the amount it takes to eat out three meals a day seven days a week. Sounds like Natalue is NOT a working woman, just a cheater.

  • @ellenhage3611
    @ellenhage3611 8 місяців тому

    I'd go to a tavern. I hate fancy food. Also please cook for me. How can you be a princess with no princess money.

  • @MARTEY-t2i
    @MARTEY-t2i Місяць тому

    I know how to cook so that would not be a threat.It’s his money to spend as he wishes.If you want to eat there then go and buy your own.NOT EVERY GUY WOULD LOVE TO SPEND THAT MUCH ON A DATE

  • @TennesseeMelanie
    @TennesseeMelanie Рік тому +3

    These have to be the WORST accents!

  • @gailwarnock2764
    @gailwarnock2764 Рік тому +1

    That fake accent is so ridiculous please don't do that again .

  • @vickywilliams8320
    @vickywilliams8320 6 місяців тому

    Blue cheese is like Marmite. You love it or hate it.

  • @cherylcourtney1960
    @cherylcourtney1960 Рік тому +5

    Blue 🥵

  • @franciskadescamps5728
    @franciskadescamps5728 11 місяців тому

    Natalie talks like she is being chased by a dinosaur...

  • @brendahere
    @brendahere Рік тому

    Cut half the music volume

  • @Ventura574
    @Ventura574 Рік тому

    What accent is that dude using? Keeps wavering between old school, over the top Brooklyn and British. Ridiculous.

  • @wilmahunt
    @wilmahunt Рік тому +4

    Lydia cos doesnt like your parenting

  • @angelacoates9559
    @angelacoates9559 Рік тому +3

    For God's sake drop the accent

  • @carolinamixi987
    @carolinamixi987 Рік тому

    Why does the first guy speak like that? Does he have something in his mouth? He sounds like he was trying to talk like a kid

  • @lsmith992
    @lsmith992 Рік тому

    What the hell is that accent supposed to be?
    It sounds like a collection of little bits of various English accents but not enough to id for certain . Im English, speak one of them and know the rest.
    There's also something in there that sounds like
    New York Brooklyn. Really weird.

  • @mayhaynes2638
    @mayhaynes2638 Рік тому

    I am hard off hearing so got to have it up please stop the background music 😊

  • @ellenosceola5707
    @ellenosceola5707 Рік тому +3

    This is awful

  • @joeydemitro8976
    @joeydemitro8976 Рік тому +4

    NATALIE LISTEN UP AND LISTEN GOOD THERE TOO CUPCAKE AND STOP SWEARING AND CUSSING AND KNOW YOUR PLACE TOO NATALIE THE CUPCAKE

  • @marycordova9347
    @marycordova9347 Рік тому +3

    Another silly voice on the male 😮

  • @BrettHarvey-u6c
    @BrettHarvey-u6c Рік тому

    Does anybody else HATE the background music/noise? This is towards all videos

  • @oldwoman5942
    @oldwoman5942 6 місяців тому

    I absolutely hate blue cheese!

  • @rhio-ohki6107
    @rhio-ohki6107 8 місяців тому

    😱 PLEASE STOP THE BACKGROUND SOUND. ITS SERIOUSLY BAD ON EARS

  • @susanhansen1290
    @susanhansen1290 Рік тому

    I don't like any variety of blue cheese.

  • @femininevibes2213
    @femininevibes2213 Рік тому

    Blue cheese not even good for you its one of the most fattning dressings

  • @Mehp2
    @Mehp2 Рік тому +2

    Stop it with the bad accents

  • @femininevibes2213
    @femininevibes2213 Рік тому

    I hate blue cheese ugh

  • @patkovalic6380
    @patkovalic6380 11 місяців тому

    WTF was that

  • @tiaa668
    @tiaa668 Рік тому +5

    I'm not going to listen to repeats. I'm out

    • @nutty77
      @nutty77 Рік тому +3

      Everything is repeats nowaday 😮

    • @lynnedunne6190
      @lynnedunne6190 Рік тому +3

      Not everyone likes Blue Cheese

    • @lynnedunne6190
      @lynnedunne6190 Рік тому +3

      I LOVE blue cheese.

    • @l.p3861
      @l.p3861 Рік тому +3

      And the originals they didn't have those god awful accents

  • @ellejagerman6105
    @ellejagerman6105 Рік тому

    Tone down the music. I, personally really prefer these stories without background annoyance. 🤷‍♀️

  • @tommybell4850
    @tommybell4850 Рік тому +3

    Thank god he left her.