Can Jedi Have Red Lightsabers? 😳

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 тра 2024
  • We are very used to seeing Jedi have blue and green lightsabers but are they allowed to have red ones?
    Cuz even though the line is drawn very clearly that Sith have red and Jedi have blue and green, what’s stopping a Jedi from owning a red lightsaber?
    Well there are actually 2 very interesting explanations to this question.
    The first is that a Jedi is allowed to “USE” a red lightsaber especially if they are in trouble!
    We see this many times with Obi Wan using one of Ventress' sabers and Anakin taking Count Dooku’s.
    But just like what Obi Wan said after using one, “Red’s not my color.”
    Now of course a lightside user could take a red crystal and purify it which turns the lightsaber blade white like we see Ahsoka Tano do with an inquisitor.
    But if we take a look at what happens in the legends EU, things get spicy!
    Cuz we actually see Jedi like Adi Gallia, Depa Billaba, and even Luke Skywalker owning and using a red lightsaber!
    Yeah! Luke Skywalker built a Shoto saber just like the one we see Ahsoka use but he just decided to be different and have the color be red to compliment his green lightsaber!
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,1 тис.

  • @d.rodrickeamon6133
    @d.rodrickeamon6133 2 місяці тому +5553

    Luke made the red and green set because he hoped for another "Star Wars Christmas Special."

    • @chonflis3834
      @chonflis3834 2 місяці тому +57

      That isnt a thing what are you talking about

    • @ROLO31
      @ROLO31 2 місяці тому +123

      @@chonflis3834he’s very obviously joking

    • @IrysZero
      @IrysZero 2 місяці тому

      r/woosh ​@@chonflis3834

    • @videoplayback_
      @videoplayback_ 2 місяці тому +66

      ​@@chonflis3834you didn't get the joke 💀

    • @visionary011
      @visionary011 2 місяці тому +36

      ​@@chonflis3834 you must not know what a joke is

  • @drextube3841
    @drextube3841 2 місяці тому +3502

    Sith: Bleeding crystals is a right of passage.
    Jedi: Bleeding crystals is evil sith practice!
    Luke: man I just thought it’d look cool. It matches my other one so well.

    • @TheStealthyOne6
      @TheStealthyOne6 2 місяці тому +62

      Me fr

    • @anton.chigrinetc.96
      @anton.chigrinetc.96 2 місяці тому +126

      Luke had a shoto in the old canon. "Bleeding" bullshit did not exist those days, it's Disney invention.

    • @NameHere2856
      @NameHere2856 2 місяці тому +92

      ​@@anton.chigrinetc.96stop acting like it's a retcon. Synthetic and natural red crystaks still exist

    • @Bobert2314
      @Bobert2314 2 місяці тому +19

      Based Luke

    • @anton.chigrinetc.96
      @anton.chigrinetc.96 2 місяці тому +46

      @@NameHere2856 Yes, it is a retcon. 1. I have yet to see a natural red crystal in DisCanon. 2. As well as synthetic. 3. Vader's crystal was specifically introduced as "bled". None others were mentioned. In the Old Canon, it was synth.

  • @lightningrodstudios2441
    @lightningrodstudios2441 2 місяці тому +1559

    “Good guys are blue and green, bad guys are red”
    - George Lucas

    • @giacomomoschiano2761
      @giacomomoschiano2761 2 місяці тому +160

      *Samuel L. Jackson joined the chat*

    • @Jamseth_Ingramious
      @Jamseth_Ingramious 2 місяці тому +33

      Bastilla is typing a message...

    • @dirtylittledoe
      @dirtylittledoe 2 місяці тому

      ​@@Jamseth_Ingramiousbastilla still to this day Bae ❤

    • @baki484
      @baki484 2 місяці тому +25

      Adi gallia jedi with a red lightsaber
      Evan piell jedi with a red lightsaber
      Exar Khun sith with a blue lightsaber
      Ullic quel droma sith with a green lightsaber.
      Luke's shoto was a red

    • @kb-verse
      @kb-verse 2 місяці тому +30

      @@baki484 yes but those weren’t created by george lucas they were written by others

  • @ronly_driver
    @ronly_driver Місяць тому +846

    Mace Windu: fuckit, make it both

    • @philipvonbahr
      @philipvonbahr Місяць тому +78

      Ironically, he requested a different colored lightsaber for the movie cus he wanted to stand out, and George Lucas allowed it and wrote it into the lore.
      Purple is also the color that is more closely in tune with Light And Dark, and the style Mace Windu uses, actually 'dances' on the edge towards the dark side, and takes a lot of Focus and control not to lose oneself 😁

    • @itsjohn7848
      @itsjohn7848 Місяць тому +37

      I just love that there was a whole new major addition to the lore because sam jackson just wanted a different color lightsaber

    • @JamesGo2806
      @JamesGo2806 15 днів тому +1

      It’s a Jedi lightsaber. Purple is just rarer than the other two

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 15 днів тому +2

      ​@@philipvonbahr 1st pp.
      2nd 🫳⬛⬛⬛⬛🟪🟪🟪🟪🟪🟪🟪

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 15 днів тому

      ​@@JamesGo2806dats wha she said

  • @DarthArachnious
    @DarthArachnious 2 місяці тому +1326

    Red isn't inherently evil. The crystals themselves are tuned to the dark side. Ancient Sith used red Lignan crystals, which burned hotter and increased their dark side powers. When these crystals went extinct. The Sith found a way to make synthetic ones. This is why every Sith makes their own crystals as a right of passage. The Dark Side just turns them red. But a natural red crystal would just be red.

    • @remainprofane7732
      @remainprofane7732 2 місяці тому +88

      This lore is so overly edgy but it at least gives a solid reason why a Jedi wouldn’t be able to normally create one

    • @DarthArachnious
      @DarthArachnious 2 місяці тому +61

      @remainprofane7732 they eventually did. Luke cooked his green crystal using instructions Obi-Wan left him. But they weren't as powerful and they weren't attuned to the Dark Side.
      In Legends, Lightsabers and all their advancements were created by the Sith.

    • @itstime6974
      @itstime6974 2 місяці тому +37

      The synthetic and I think the lignan crystals thing is legends now, the sith bleeding them comes from modern canon.

    • @DarthArachnious
      @DarthArachnious 2 місяці тому +34

      @itstime6974 Yes, but the idea is the same. The Sith has to pour his will and the Dark Side into the crystal. So Maul, meditating and seething for a week, while his crystals cooked. Is similar to Vader corrupting a Jedi crystal through sheer will.

    • @itstime6974
      @itstime6974 2 місяці тому +8

      @@DarthArachnious thematically? Sure I can see that, physically? Nope.

  • @ondank
    @ondank Місяць тому +80

    Jedi: red is an evil colour, Jedi can't use it
    Luke: but it do be dope though

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 15 днів тому

      🫳⬛️⬛️⬛️⬛️🟥🟥🟥🟥🟥🟥🟥🟥

    • @JonO387
      @JonO387 3 дні тому

      I missed that movie.

    • @spankie7728
      @spankie7728 День тому

      Jedi can have red ... but then they jump over to Dark jedi Aka sith

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 19 годин тому

      @@spankie7728 cool

  • @mreggs3731
    @mreggs3731 Місяць тому +5

    I think Luke just wanted Christmas coloured lightsabers, nothing about what side he's on.

  • @superslothstudios2231
    @superslothstudios2231 Місяць тому +180

    The fact that Luke chose to have a second lightsaber that was red because it would look nice with his other one is hilarious to me

    • @cortsilver2564
      @cortsilver2564 Місяць тому +5

      To my knowledge it was taken from an inquisitor and he later purified it to white, but I'm not 100% on that

    • @joshrodriguez6726
      @joshrodriguez6726 28 днів тому +3

      ​@@cortsilver2564
      Luke's Shoto Red Lightsaber is from Legends and the inquisitor's are from Disney Canon.

    • @cortsilver2564
      @cortsilver2564 28 днів тому

      @@joshrodriguez6726 ah thank you. Was not aware :)

  • @birdquest8695
    @birdquest8695 Місяць тому +23

    Old Jedi: bleeding crystal red is evil
    Luke: my fuckin Jedi order, my fuckin rules

  • @GhettoJohnWick
    @GhettoJohnWick Місяць тому +97

    Luke Skywalker: Christmas Jedi

  • @Kurayamiblack
    @Kurayamiblack 2 місяці тому +441

    "But he just decided to be different"
    And that's why I love Luke Skywalker 😊

    • @Percival-kl9yy
      @Percival-kl9yy 2 місяці тому +10

      *Jedi Master Evan Piel had a red lightsaber in **_The Phantom Menace._*

    • @thomasross3890
      @thomasross3890 Місяць тому +1

      Its cause mace windu tracked and entraped one of the last sith factions and several jedi killed the last known sith....the other apprentice of darth grievous...sidius's master...the council granted him that colour as a right of passage...remember jedi are only allowed to kill in the name of peace order and good government...and are not allowed any wealth or personal posessions...thats why they condone the killing and dessimination of the dark jedi arts...the ones that sneak into positions of power and become become greasy murderous bastards on there way up

    • @Percival-kl9yy
      @Percival-kl9yy Місяць тому +1

      @@thomasross3890 *There is no such thing as the "Dark Jedi Arts" - there is only the Jedi Arts and the Sith Arts.*
      *Also if your information comes from any Disney material then it's Non-Canon.*

    • @brandiwilson7790
      @brandiwilson7790 6 днів тому

      🧑🏼☄️

  • @starfleet.command
    @starfleet.command 2 місяці тому +276

    Mofo had the Christmas sabers

    • @Ashera5469
      @Ashera5469 2 місяці тому +8

      Fr he wanted that Christmas miracle

  • @MaxyGamer10
    @MaxyGamer10 2 місяці тому +104

    The yellow lightasabers are underrated

    • @Rogue-element101
      @Rogue-element101 2 місяці тому +13

      Facts. As well as the ghostsaber

    • @darkrhino1138
      @darkrhino1138 2 місяці тому +10

      Nah, yellow is cool and unique but magenta just steals the show...Sadly I think it's a legends only color now lol haven't kept up with new lore tbh

    • @Cornelius9013
      @Cornelius9013 2 місяці тому +4

      ​@@darkrhino1138 No yellow is still a thing, in fact Ray at the end of the last movie wields a yellow saber now. It's for sentinels and temple guards, that hasn't changed. I remember Leia in Legends had a yellow one, But after Disney now it's blue. But I am now interested to see how rayville utilize it hopefully in a new Jedi Academy 🙏📲📺💯

    • @Cornelius9013
      @Cornelius9013 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@darkrhino1138But you are correct there, I think magenta is now Legends, as I think Adi galia was the only one to hold a crimson / magenta blade. And that was only in a few comics and the PS1 game "Jedi power battles" 🤷🎮🕹️💯

    • @saltbombcreations8336
      @saltbombcreations8336 Місяць тому +6

      Orange is also underrated

  • @DeadSoulRising97
    @DeadSoulRising97 Місяць тому +36

    That's why master I believe it's windu has a purple lightsaber ONLY CAUSE SAM L. JACKSON WANTED IT TO BE PURPLE LOL

  • @CrimsonKnight79
    @CrimsonKnight79 Місяць тому +92

    So in summery it doesn't matter what lightsaber you use, it's how you use it.

  • @cameronverwey2825
    @cameronverwey2825 Місяць тому +62

    Luke must really like space Christmas 😂

  • @brucewayne1269
    @brucewayne1269 Місяць тому +16

    Luke is all about playing red light green light! 😂😂😂

  • @mattdp5554
    @mattdp5554 2 місяці тому +18

    Anakin with red and blue is obviously a simbolism

  • @WD64
    @WD64 2 місяці тому +6

    Mace windu: Nah, I'mma do my own thing

  • @thanos1335
    @thanos1335 2 місяці тому +27

    Obi Wan: Luke, why do you have a RED Lightsaber?
    Luke: Cuz I thought it looked cool

    • @mistylover7398
      @mistylover7398 15 днів тому +1

      Obi won : only a sith deals an absolute I will do wha I must.
      🟦
      🟦
      🟦
      🟦
      🟦
      ⬛️
      ⬛️
      ⬛️
      ⬛️

  • @wingman-1977
    @wingman-1977 2 місяці тому +70

    In the novels, Luke build a lightsaber for Leia and the blade was red.

    • @valthenvega2434
      @valthenvega2434 2 місяці тому +12

      To be fair, back in the day Luke’s lightsaber was red in plenty of old marvel comics, and McQuarrie Darth Vader used a blue one, so it wasn’t inherently evil

    • @Fegyo98
      @Fegyo98 2 місяці тому +1

      because she is a woman 😂 blue is for boys red for girls😛 im joking.. this information was new for me.. i never read about Leia 's story

    • @trentonveselka2018
      @trentonveselka2018 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@valthenvega2434 Luke was in marvel comics?

    • @valthenvega2434
      @valthenvega2434 Місяць тому +4

      @@trentonveselka2018 Marvel in the sense of publishing, that is. They made plenty of sketchy comics before they went to Dark Horse Comic books.
      Actually, when Lucasfilm was purchased in 2012, the comic rights went back to marvel, and their artists made a realistic tribute cover art to the original A New Hope comic cover.
      Regarding to if Marvel ever did a canon crossover between Star Wars and the Marvel Universe in written media, that I do not know, though unlikely.

    • @g.masterlordoftheg-force4770
      @g.masterlordoftheg-force4770 Місяць тому +1

      @@Fegyo98I thought it was supposed to be pink, not red?

  • @justbigpig
    @justbigpig 2 місяці тому +25

    Honestly Luke was starting his own Jedi order at this point so he can just do whatever he wants

  • @Sus-hashbrown
    @Sus-hashbrown 2 місяці тому +6

    Mace Windu in the corner: 👁👄👁

  • @Xwzuv
    @Xwzuv Місяць тому +18

    The only thing is, Siths like Vader managed to forge their Kyber Krystal's color with his Rage etc... Which obviously the Jedi wouldn't do causing them to not have Red.

  • @insertfunnyhandlehere
    @insertfunnyhandlehere Місяць тому +34

    They can use one, they just can't create one. From what I understand the red are created by torturing and corrupting a regular lightsaber crystal.

    • @Kiable7
      @Kiable7 Місяць тому +5

      They need to channel their rage to create the light saber, turning it red.

    • @notproductiveproductions3504
      @notproductiveproductions3504 Місяць тому +2

      Kylo even cracked his during that process resulting in his signature crooked blade

  • @brandynpennington
    @brandynpennington 2 місяці тому +31

    Luke only had it because the empire used a lot of the kyber crystals and they even made them illegal so he had to use a synthetic one

    • @debthe2nd444
      @debthe2nd444 2 місяці тому +5

      If I remember correctly his green light saber Krystal is synthetic in legends

    • @brandynpennington
      @brandynpennington 2 місяці тому +2

      @@debthe2nd444 oh ok

    • @bruvathroatpuncher500
      @bruvathroatpuncher500 2 місяці тому

      Synthetic Kyber Crystals are more powerful and more unstable than natural kyber crystals as well.

    • @notproductiveproductions3504
      @notproductiveproductions3504 Місяць тому +3

      Imagine making Kyber crystals illegal but still mining them for the Death Star

    • @brandynpennington
      @brandynpennington Місяць тому

      @@notproductiveproductions3504 bro it’s a fictional organization that rules the galaxy where it’s only job is to be evil

  • @Kip450
    @Kip450 2 місяці тому +10

    Out-of-universe reason: it was not until _Attack of the Clones_ that it was firmly established that the Jedi, except Mace Windu, used blue and green lightsabers and the Sith used only red. Before that everyone, be they Jedi or Sith, used any of a wide variety of colors with no particular meaning ascribed to any of them. Except for, ironically, Mace Windu, who used a blue lightsaber before _Attack of the Clones._

    • @tommalatesta6313
      @tommalatesta6313 5 днів тому

      You are new to Star Wars aren't you?
      Even before Episode II Sith ALWAYS had red sabers... And to the part with blue and green...
      Dark Forces II: Jedi Knight and Jedi Knight: Mystery of the Sith.
      blue, green, yellow, cyan, orange and purple...
      The Games were release 1998.
      And the colors HAD meaning.

    • @Kip450
      @Kip450 5 днів тому

      @@tommalatesta6313 In the comic series _Tales of the Jedi,_ the main villains during the _Dark Lords of the Sith_ and _The Sith War_ arcs are the Sith Lords Exar Kun and Ulic Qel-Droma. Kun wields a double-bladed blue lightsaber and Qel-Droma has a green lightsaber (or blue or yellow, depending on the artist). Likewise, the villains of _Dark Forces II_ wield different colors, with only Jerec and Maw using red. Be careful with absolute statements.

  • @asura665
    @asura665 Місяць тому +7

    It's team colors obv

  • @AppalachianCascadian
    @AppalachianCascadian 2 місяці тому +10

    Ever since it became canon that red crystals are bled and not synthetic, I can't see how a jedi COULD have their own lightsaber be red. Bleeding a crystal is a dark side act.

    • @citronyman
      @citronyman 6 днів тому

      You absolutely can tap into the dark side and stay a Jedi, many of them do it from time to time when necessary. Anakin, for example, does it many times during the clone wars.

  • @benjilee329
    @benjilee329 2 місяці тому +156

    You forgot purple like Master Windu. According to Legends he was the most powerful Jedi next to Yoda. And theres the yellow saber from Disney's SW.

    • @Clonestudios501
      @Clonestudios501 2 місяці тому +54

      actually the first yellow light saber to appear in canon was the Jedi temple guards light sabers

    • @WTM3655
      @WTM3655 2 місяці тому +35

      Don't forget old republic sentinels like bastilla who made it reality for us..
      Back before the dark times..
      Before the Disney took over..

    • @oryxthetakenking8275
      @oryxthetakenking8275 2 місяці тому +16

      Mace Windu using a purple lightsabre: *Influence Gained: Kreia*

    • @dudewithbones5012
      @dudewithbones5012 2 місяці тому +26

      Yellow Saber's have been in star wars way before Disney.

    • @major_t_bagging
      @major_t_bagging 2 місяці тому +11

      Plo koon?

  • @striderjason9863
    @striderjason9863 2 місяці тому +3

    I remember being confused when I saw Adi Gallia wielding a red saber in Jedi Power Battles.

  • @IAmRevan66
    @IAmRevan66 2 місяці тому +5

    “My lightsabers should be festive for life day” Luke probably

  • @KratosAurionPlays
    @KratosAurionPlays Місяць тому +3

    Luke really was feeling the Christmas spirit.

  • @JeremiahWickles-in4sr
    @JeremiahWickles-in4sr Місяць тому +4

    Anakin didnt exactly "in trouble" when he used count dookus light saber

  • @swampygaming2975
    @swampygaming2975 Місяць тому +3

    Looks like Disney’s not the first to break conventions.

  • @itstheiceman11
    @itstheiceman11 Місяць тому +8

    I always thought the color of crystal changes based on what type of force user you are.
    That the only way to create a red saber is by bleeding it by committing horrible crimes (killing innocents).

    • @notproductiveproductions3504
      @notproductiveproductions3504 Місяць тому

      Actually you bleed a Kyber crystal by torturing it with the Force. That’s why Kylo accidentally cracked his

  • @Blaze4ification
    @Blaze4ification 2 місяці тому +7

    Not to mention purple. Also red, blue, and green makes sense being the primary colors (of light, in art it's red, blue, yellow, making even more sense for a LIGHTsaber), along with in art, certain colors are complimentary.
    Complete opposites, blue with orange, purple and yellow, and yes red with green probably why red and green are christmas colors for commercializing, and while the 1st lightsaber we do see is blue from Obi Wan and Luke's saber in A New Hope, making it green while fighting red makes them stand out more.
    These also are colors that when mixed make brown, because they're polar opposites. However, when used together not mixed obviously lol, makes them stick out a lot more. Certain video games utilize this too, 1st coming to mind is Castlevania, to make characters or enemies pop out, they made the backgrounds complementary colors.
    I'm guessing again that is why they gave Luke a green one, especially during the dark scenes of Return of the Jedi. If blue had been used, it'd blend too much with the dark backgrounds even if clashing with Vader's red saber.

    • @xheralt
      @xheralt Місяць тому

      _Pigments_ generate brown when mixed (subtractive color value). IBM PC's faked it as dim orange. The "purple" generated by mixing red & blue light (additive process) isn't really purple, it's magenta (think T-Mobile). "Spectral" purple (as in "on the visible spectrum", like Windu's sabre) is generated by different frequency of light, wavelength low 400 nanometers. Less than that is ultraviolet. Blue is low 500's. Green, mid-500's. Yellow high 500's. Orange a narrow band at low 600's, Red mid 600's.

    • @wolfman210
      @wolfman210 Місяць тому

      Actually, in art Red's complimentary is Cyan, Green's is Magenta and Blue's is Yellow.
      That's because the "real" subtractive primaries are Cyan, Magenta and Yellow which are the colors you get from mixing RGB light.
      Red+Green: makes Yellow
      Red+Blue: makes Magenta
      and
      Green+Blue: makes Cyan

    • @Blaze4ification
      @Blaze4ification Місяць тому

      @@wolfman210
      N... no?... but also yes, you're not entirely wrong, just mixed up.
      I mean it depends on the shade I suppose, but base colors, red is complimentary to green, yellow to purple (or violet I suppose if we want to get technical), and orange to blue. Even if we throw in sub colors like cyan, base red is still opposite to base green, while red orange is to cyan (or other blue green shades), red violet (magenta) is to yellow green, and yellow orange is to blue violet.
      Red+green does not make yellow under any circumstances lol.
      Not entirely wrong on red+blue but again depends on the shades, like a lighter shade of red, pink makes a more magenta color over base violet.
      Also not wrong on green+blue equaling cyan... but they're next to each other on the color wheel, they're not opposites.
      I even looked up on google images to double check, and seems like most of the color wheels that do make some of these happen like red vs cyan is because they're missing a color like orange. All this is because this utilizes a different color wheel from other art forms.
      It also depends on your artistic field, which is why you aren't wrong
      In digital design yes utilizing a RGB wheel works, but in painting the RBY wheel is utilized. This is because RGB is based on light, as I say in the 1st paragraph, LIGHTsabers using the light spectrum pallets. In science, astronomy, chemistry, biology, etc they too utilize the light RGB wheel. That is why by extension it is used in digital design.
      However when it comes to art um... can't find the right words and don't want to offend, basic art, original art? historical art, your painting, drawing, markers, crayons, portraits, landscapes etc the RBY color wheel is utilized. To which I am right, red being opposite to green etc, and the mixing of said colors producing browns as I mentioned prior.
      It's a difference of science colors vs... uggh trying not to denote or sound snobby, because that too is an art form, it's just different. It's science colors vs artsy colors. I even recall in biology class testing which shade of color a plant may grow under... dear god that was a long time ago. Then in college learning about astronomy while also taking art classes. It's different mediums, but neither are inherently wrong. Heck maybe that is why they made Obi Wan's lightsaber blue, because cyan in the light spectrum color wheel is opposite to red, and while called blue, blue lightsabers have always been a brighter shade of blue. Then they go and introduce Mace Windu with a purple lightsaber so they switched gears, now there's yellow, orange, light sabers of every color across the rainbow.
      Hopefully that helps and doesn't confuse you more lol. Admittedly I was a bit confused at 1st because it's been a while since I thought about the light spectrum despite mentioning it in my base comment.

    • @wolfman210
      @wolfman210 Місяць тому

      @@Blaze4ification RYB is the incorrect color model for art/subtractive color mixing and was created at a time when we had a very limited understanding of color. the only reason it hasn't been tossed out is because RYB has been taught for centuries and humanity is stubborn and resistant to being challenged. See also the still ongoing debate about if T-Rex had feathers or not.
      And mixing Red and Green LIGHT makes Yellow which is why it's a subtractive primary. Likewise mixing Red and Blue light creates Magenta * in other words Magenta is the "real" purple * and Green and Blue makes Cyan the additive secondaries.
      And since subtractive/pigment mixing is based on reflecting colored light off a surface rather than adding more colored light like in additive mixing the primaries are reversed with Cyan, Magenta and Yellow becoming the primaries while Red, Green and Blue become the secondaries.
      Mixing Magenta and Yellow pigments will make Red hence why Red isn't a subtractive primary while it is an additive(light) one. Likewise mixing Cyan with Magenta will yield Blue and mixing Cyan and Yellow will create a much more vivid Green than you get from mixing Blue * a secondary * with Yellow * a primary *.
      On that same note mixing Magenta with Blue will create a much truer Violet than the muddy "Purple" you get from the "traditional" mix of Red and Blue.
      In summary What the RYB model gets wrong is that Red and Blue are also secondaries with Green while "Purple" is a primary and Orange and Violet are tertiaries and the Tealish color you get from mixing Blue and Yellow is actually just an impure Green much like the "Purple" you get from Red and Blue.
      So to answer your question about Orange it's complementary/opposite color is a mixture of Cyan and Blue that I've both seen called simply Cyan Blue or Sky Blue.
      That said pigment primaries can be messy due to several pigments all being called the same color in paint.

    • @Blaze4ification
      @Blaze4ification Місяць тому

      @@wolfman210
      Oh don't even get me started on dinosaurs lol, especially the T-Rex. To which it has been proven untrue that it had feathers, not to say Tyrannosaurs genus itself weren't capable, the Yutyrannus 100% had feathers, especially given its climate that it lived in, colder environments, vs a Tyrannosaurus Rex had no need for feathers being in humid climates. Then some scientists say only their young had feathers, but then they lost them by adulthood which I mean is possible too, again given the climate, they may have evolved to lose their feathers so they wouldn't over heat.
      That is a whole other thing aside, let's ignore that this is about art. However no that isn't an archaic belief that humans are too stubborn to throw out. Go grab some markers or paint, mix them, if you mix red with green what do you get? If you mix purple and yellow what do you get? Blue orange? all= brown. They're complimentary because they are complete opposites, but when combined don't make another color. Red+Yellow=orange, blue+yellow=green, etc. Then mentioning other shades, tints, and pallets they come from mixing other colors together. Cyan is blue mixed with green, magenta is violet with red, pink is a tint of red mixed with while. Is this wrong?
      It's not that either of us are incorrect per say, again it's just different fields. Art is its own medium while science is its own medium. Pink isn't on the color wheel, would you include that? Like you said there are more colors that we know of that exist now, but if you just kept adding colors then it is well endless.
      Then again you mention LIGHT, again to which I agreed and is a different field, it's science vs art. I already know all that in your 3rd paragraph, you're preaching to the choire, but seriously go and buy paint and mix it and compare to a digital one. You're not wrong, yellow and blue, makes a gross asparagus green, while yellow and cyan is a pastel green, that's again though working under different fields. You mix a base blue paint it makes a vivid green too.
      ... no, that's not what the RBY model does, Red, blue, and yellow are primaries, while green, purple, and orange are secondaries, because they require 2 colors to make, just like in the RGB model. That's like preschool levels of art. No offense meant, it's just we're both not wrong. You say in summary too but that just seemed more confusing, missing punctuations?
      It's not that neither of us are wrong necessarily, it's just different fields of professions. Like I believe you, and as I stated in my own comment I too know of the RGB models, and what they do, but that's also different. It's not wrong that when you mix a red paint with a blue paint you get purple, or mixing a red and green gives you brown, red with yellow orange, red with white pink, etc. I don't think it's stubbornness that's just how it works with a physical thing like painting or drawing pallets vs light based stuff, digital, printing pallets.
      I won't deny the stubborness of the dinosaur and T-Rex debacle, scientists themselves, all of them wrong or right are stubborn lol. It's different for art though, artists aren't necessarily stubborn (not that they can't be lol), it truly is just a difference of fields. I can't think of words to describe it other than that, because again neither of us are wrong. You go on the internet to a paint thing mix stuff and it's the RGB format, mix blue and yellow it's a gross green vs cyan yellow a good green. you go into your closet, pull out some paints, mix blue and yellow you get a good green.
      Hell on a digital format the RGB WATER IS A COLOR, that shouldn't count, water isn't a color, it's colorless, it reflects colors, reflection isn't a color unto itself otherwise mirrors would be a color. Both do things improper, and both do some things proper, neither is inherently wrong, it's just... difference of profession and fields. There's a reason people say art and science are polar opposites.

  • @ronaldcarr5686
    @ronaldcarr5686 Місяць тому +9

    A Jedi wouldn't want to be mistaken as a Sith?

    • @citronyman
      @citronyman 6 днів тому

      The Jedi order was somewhat boomer in this question, but if you paid attention and watched/read other SW bits than the main movies, then you know, it's not that big of a difference, and the real thing that matters it how you use the Force, but the order thought it best to just never even go to the dark side because of it's tempting.

  • @Meravokas
    @Meravokas 2 місяці тому +35

    Red became a forbidden color because it was nearly exclusively the color created when producing synthetic kyber with Sith Alchemy. Also a number of the examples you gave weren't truly red, but orange.

    • @Walt_Xander94
      @Walt_Xander94 2 місяці тому +1

      Luke's 2nd saber certainly isnt orange.

    • @Meravokas
      @Meravokas 2 місяці тому +2

      @@Walt_Xander94 Wasn't talking about Luke's. More the likes of Adi Galia. I couldn't write the best response because when trying to type comments directly on a short, I can't scroll down on my own reply and have to write something very clipped to be able to hit reply.

    • @Phillisophical
      @Phillisophical 2 місяці тому +2

      Synthetic crystals are Legends and not canon content.

    • @Meravokas
      @Meravokas 2 місяці тому

      @@Phillisophical They haven't been actively removed from either.

    • @Xeta_
      @Xeta_ 2 місяці тому

      @@Meravokasyes they have

  • @WTM3655
    @WTM3655 2 місяці тому +162

    Grandmaster Luke only used a red short saber because he was just not trying to get his ass whipped *BUDUM TSST*
    Edit: I didn't think many would get that joke maybe 10 tops...
    Over 150...
    May the force be with you
    Always

  • @LSSJTHOR
    @LSSJTHOR 2 місяці тому +2

    "Jedi Power Battles" had a jedi with em.

  • @Spectre-0117
    @Spectre-0117 2 місяці тому +26

    Luke's red shoto came out before the establishment of sabre color meaning. It wasn't until later on in Legends material that it was explained that the red color manifested only due to the use of a synthetic crystal coupled with an extremely rushed construction job. He didn't "decide" to do it just to be different and compliment his green sabre lmao
    Long story short Jedi don't *construct* red blades for their personal sabres because the process requires torturing the kyber with the power of the dark side causing it to "bleed", which would be against the Jedi Code for obvious reasons. Purple or orange may manifest if the wielder has struck a balance with the ability to tap into the dark side without falling to it. Those colors aren't achieved though a bleeding process making them acceptable for Jedi use.

    • @zadakielfrostaxt1825
      @zadakielfrostaxt1825 2 місяці тому +2

      No they are Red because it’s Synthetic and the others are Colorful because their natural and that’s why Eth Koth has a 2Color blade which has a 50% Chance that ist Green or blue on Activation

    • @Spectre-0117
      @Spectre-0117 2 місяці тому

      @@zadakielfrostaxt1825 In Legends, yes you are correct. I literally included that in the first paragraph which it seems you didn't read. However, according to modern SW lore, red is now achieved through bleeding which is even shown in the new Jedi Survivor game.

    • @zadakielfrostaxt1825
      @zadakielfrostaxt1825 2 місяці тому

      @@Spectre-0117 the Game its Crap öike Disney SW its looks good but if you show on the story its Trash

    • @Spectre-0117
      @Spectre-0117 2 місяці тому

      @@zadakielfrostaxt1825 With respect, your feelings about it don't really matter nor change the fact that these story beats are now canon as set by their proprietary owner(s). Like it or hate it, doesn't change a single thing. Sorry lil buddy.

    • @loustancu3480
      @loustancu3480 2 місяці тому

      ​@@Spectre-0117wow I'm a pretty big nerd myself but I can hear the tape on your glasses

  • @maikebaier8004
    @maikebaier8004 2 місяці тому +7

    Darth Revan would be another interesting example

    • @gw1939
      @gw1939 2 місяці тому +2

      Revan is my favorite Star Wars character by far

    • @maikebaier8004
      @maikebaier8004 2 місяці тому +1

      @@gw1939 that dude is on another level

  • @John_Marstonm
    @John_Marstonm Місяць тому +7

    What about purple one?

    • @molybdaen11
      @molybdaen11 Місяць тому +1

      That's only for Master windu - because he dared to ask his god.

  • @dominicmitchell4014
    @dominicmitchell4014 2 місяці тому +8

    The alignment doesnt come from the color it comes from the way you weild and use your saber

  • @philipvonbahr
    @philipvonbahr Місяць тому +11

    The fact is that Jedi had used red kyber crystals Before Disney changed the lore regarding them..
    Previously, naturally occurring kyber crystals didn't have the red colour and was only present in artificially manufactured kyber crystals, giving it the red colour.
    Luke was unable to get a natural kyber crystal for his Shoto saber and used a manufactured one instead.
    After Disney got involved and changed the lore, a Red lightsaber is basically Torturing a natural kyber crystal (they are living organisms that are in tune with the force) until they "Bleed" and become red with the agressive emotions forced into them.
    A white kyber crystal is a Tortured kyber crystal that has gotten purified from the aggressive emotions forced into it.

  • @user-ch5ep3yp9s
    @user-ch5ep3yp9s 2 місяці тому +5

    The light sabre colours that I would pick would be the first yellow or orange and then purple

  • @user-he3il8kn6j
    @user-he3il8kn6j 2 місяці тому +39

    Red means corrupt that’s why the dark side only has red light sabers. That’s what happens with the crystal

    • @yuhmadda
      @yuhmadda 2 місяці тому +9

      That’s only in the current canon

    • @dominicmitchell4014
      @dominicmitchell4014 2 місяці тому +3

      That is not true it just means your kyber crystal is cracked thus the light saber is unstable so the technique for the light side will not work and breaking this technique is what makes you a sith

    • @zadakielfrostaxt1825
      @zadakielfrostaxt1825 2 місяці тому +5

      False Red means it’s an Artificial Crystal the Sith used them because it’s easier

    • @dominicmitchell4014
      @dominicmitchell4014 2 місяці тому +2

      @@zadakielfrostaxt1825 it'd not artificial its a real Kyber Crystal that has been corrupted by the dark force

    • @user-he3il8kn6j
      @user-he3il8kn6j 2 місяці тому

      @@dominicmitchell4014 exactly. Corrupt. Red means evil

  • @boqndimitrov8693
    @boqndimitrov8693 22 дні тому +1

    after all these explanations, suddenly the jedi looked like traffic lights to me.

  • @tatsumakivee4201
    @tatsumakivee4201 14 днів тому +1

    "I dunno, I was feeling festive when I made it." -Luke Skywalker

  • @EpicEditz359
    @EpicEditz359 2 місяці тому +4

    They weren’t because of the sith using red but after the disappearance of the sith for all those years they allowed Jedi to use the color red but once the sith returned they were all forced to change the color from red

    • @bruvathroatpuncher500
      @bruvathroatpuncher500 2 місяці тому

      Ex Ar Kun, was a Sith and he used a BLUE light double sided light saber. And there cases where Sith used blue and green light sabers as well.

  • @randyduff4758
    @randyduff4758 Місяць тому +8

    If a Jedi accepts a huge amount of money, then they can use whatever they want. Right Disney? Now answer the question real fans want to know, what gender do Jedi identify with? What about their sexuality? My kids need to know!!🙄🙄🙄

  • @StarwarsDray
    @StarwarsDray 2 місяці тому +1

    Luke’s Christmas sabers only for Christmas though

  • @Sloth-pw8ke
    @Sloth-pw8ke 2 місяці тому +2

    He never mentioned that there are 2 ancient spots for the Kyber crystals. One only Jedi are allowed and the other only the sith are allowed. This is because in the universe there is a good force and a bad force along with the one in the middle that keeps both sides at bay, but he died. Then the dark forces killed the light force. This is why the Jedi are loosing the war. The ancient spots for the Kyber Cristal’s are protected by magic.
    Btw I’m subbing🙂

    • @MrLuckyMuffin
      @MrLuckyMuffin Місяць тому

      There are multiple planets with liner crystals. Dantooine, tatooine, mygeeto and Ilum are the most common.

  • @Nightflasher
    @Nightflasher Місяць тому +3

    Omg... The Thumbnail says that: It's Zombie-Obi Wan with the high-ground - the world is lost!

  • @BenjaminSelmanoski
    @BenjaminSelmanoski Місяць тому +3

    They also have purple

    • @cursedhawkins1305
      @cursedhawkins1305 Місяць тому +1

      Purple sabers are because the user can use BOTH sides of the force, which Mace Windu was someone who could use both.

  • @willadslewandowski4977
    @willadslewandowski4977 14 днів тому +1

    Cal Kestis: if I can so can you

  • @NewRetroLetsPlays
    @NewRetroLetsPlays 2 місяці тому +1

    The crystal in Lukes red saber was the one from Vader's I believe.

  • @GulYasar-jo4mz
    @GulYasar-jo4mz Місяць тому +4

    Lightning yellow pink black gun

  • @aaditchaudhary5067
    @aaditchaudhary5067 Місяць тому +3

    RGB for max effective force output.

  • @bumbum5714
    @bumbum5714 3 дні тому

    Luke's red and green lightsabers be looking a lot like Christmas.

  • @informationnotfound
    @informationnotfound Місяць тому +1

    "No purple lightsaber?" - Samuel L. Jackson 2000

  • @ShalomMZia
    @ShalomMZia Місяць тому +3

    Light? Dark?,i pick both

  • @kylebates2860
    @kylebates2860 Місяць тому +3

    They can have green,blue,purple,orange, white,black, and red

    • @mjd.-
      @mjd.- Місяць тому

      What about yellow or is that for the Jedi guards

  • @tyrannotitan5547
    @tyrannotitan5547 17 днів тому +1

    Jedi: We're playing checkers.
    Sith: We're playing chess.
    Legends Luke: I'm playing Beat Saber.

  • @Theslightlysadisticone2
    @Theslightlysadisticone2 Місяць тому +2

    Luke is now the Christmas Jedi

  • @ChristopherWalters-vc1nm
    @ChristopherWalters-vc1nm 2 місяці тому +27

    Another reason is that you would be giving the crystal of the light saber pain when you bleed a light saber to turn it red.
    I know it sounds weird that the crystals can feel pain but it just does.

    • @Eclipse-mf6hc
      @Eclipse-mf6hc 2 місяці тому +13

      And in legends, the red crystal is a synthetic lightsaber crystal. But tbh, I prefer Disney sw’s explanation, I just think it adds weight to turning to the dark side, like you’re bleeding a crystal

    • @zadakielfrostaxt1825
      @zadakielfrostaxt1825 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Eclipse-mf6hcno it’s shit it’s a Crystal point not less not more Disney ruined it with their explanation

    • @Eclipse-mf6hc
      @Eclipse-mf6hc 2 місяці тому +3

      @@zadakielfrostaxt1825 that’s cool. What do u prefer about the legends explanation?

    • @rooknado
      @rooknado 2 місяці тому +4

      @@zadakielfrostaxt1825” Not less not more “ Have you not heard of THE FORCE?!? It quite literally is more than you say it is. There’s a reason it’s a Kyber crystal and not a random ass rock.

    • @nicholasheath6585
      @nicholasheath6585 2 місяці тому

      ​@@zadakielfrostaxt1825that's not disney... it was in books long before disney!

  • @chosen-wan2188
    @chosen-wan2188 2 місяці тому +11

    Short answer No

    • @dominicmitchell4014
      @dominicmitchell4014 2 місяці тому +3

      Long answer: the unsableness of the red one may make it hard to weild and use for the light sides technique, breaking this technique makes you a sith therfore no jedi can't have one

  • @MJHdesproj
    @MJHdesproj Місяць тому +1

    He wanted red with green so he could signal what direction he was going to other boats…

  • @chrismayer3919
    @chrismayer3919 Місяць тому +1

    Suddenly, my having an orange-bladed lightsabre doesn’t appear so bad…

  • @arminbaron839
    @arminbaron839 Місяць тому +4

    Is this a serious question bro?

  • @BabysitterSky
    @BabysitterSky Місяць тому +6

    If the writer wants them to sure. It's not real, you can just make up the rules as you go.

  • @marianapereyra8185
    @marianapereyra8185 Місяць тому +1

    I remember that in clone wars 2003 there was a jedi using a red lightsaber

  • @TheKingJeff
    @TheKingJeff Місяць тому +3

    Hello there

  • @ElemennoP
    @ElemennoP Місяць тому +5

    I doubt Ashoka wud be able sweep the floor with a broom let alone wield a saber..🙄😂

    • @AxtonTheObstagoon
      @AxtonTheObstagoon Місяць тому +1

      i can't tell if this is you shitting on Disney's version of Ahsoka or you being Misogynistic. i hope that it's not the latter

    • @ElemennoP
      @ElemennoP Місяць тому

      @AxtonTheObstagoon Disneys version, it was awful

    • @AxtonTheObstagoon
      @AxtonTheObstagoon Місяць тому +1

      @@ElemennoP alright, because the version in The Clone Wars and Rebels is great if you ask me

  • @jorgep19651
    @jorgep19651 2 місяці тому +1

    Luke; I want Neverending Christmas in combat

  • @Thehiddenmoran
    @Thehiddenmoran 8 днів тому

    I always found it funny how the jedi games reveal how whenever someone turns to the dark side, they just randomly like to use the force to make their kyber crystal red.

  • @joseduran7104
    @joseduran7104 2 місяці тому +1

    Luke: you know I love my green saber but imma make a red one cause it goes with green and Christmas "all I want for christmas intensifies"

  • @sanin805
    @sanin805 Місяць тому +1

    shoutout to Mace Windu and the in between purple lightsaber

  • @eljaminlatour6633
    @eljaminlatour6633 Місяць тому +2

    Also, because of psychology with colors. Red is a warm color and represents strong emotions like anger, hatred, and can cause aggression and hunger. While blue is a cold color which makes one person calm. Green is the color of nature, which could represent Jedis fighting for the greater good being the planets with nature. White represents hygiene and sanitation, it could also represent purity, which makes sense why a Sith's red lightsaber turns white.
    It's not 100% true, but it's good symbolism.

  • @nR00R
    @nR00R Місяць тому

    Man using that fight scene from TOR as your first clip was a good move. Probably my favorite fight out of any, animated or otherwise

  • @EeveelutionLover22
    @EeveelutionLover22 Місяць тому

    I always viewed it as the council wanted the galaxy to view green and blue lightsabers as colors of the Jedi council representing peace and prosperity

  • @thewhitewolf7241
    @thewhitewolf7241 24 дні тому

    And here I thought a sabers color was determined by the user’s relationship with The Force

  • @aaronammann4236
    @aaronammann4236 Місяць тому +2

    Technically yes in the older era as well.

  • @brendangibson8200
    @brendangibson8200 23 дні тому

    The longest version of "Yes, but no" I've ever seen 😂

  • @justsoicanfingcomment5814
    @justsoicanfingcomment5814 2 місяці тому +1

    Don't forget about the brown light sabers... Has a little heft to it.

  • @nvadams7344
    @nvadams7344 Місяць тому

    When Anakin had the red and blue sabers crossed it was symbolic, the moment he started to turn to the dark side

  • @solidfkingsnake
    @solidfkingsnake Місяць тому

    I remember seeing Adi Gallia with a red lightsaber in Jedi Power Battles when I was a kid thinking they made a mistake at first.

  • @TheGoodGuy85
    @TheGoodGuy85 2 місяці тому

    Luke matching his green jedi saber with a red sith saber was a metaphor about how thin the line ks between the light and dark side.

  • @scottishdog8195
    @scottishdog8195 Місяць тому +1

    Jedi just have fashion lightsabers

  • @TheMoneyBoy
    @TheMoneyBoy 2 місяці тому +1

    Did we forget that general grievous has green and blue light sabers, I understand that those were the ones that he killed, but no way the sith lords took him seriously

  • @WilliamDefoe69
    @WilliamDefoe69 15 днів тому

    Luke:Im not like the other Jedi I have a red lightsaber in fights

  • @patrickginn7931
    @patrickginn7931 Місяць тому

    Luke straight up Accessorizing

  • @violentsyn6710
    @violentsyn6710 Місяць тому

    Dang. Purple just got jumped over like it didn't even matter.

  • @wanderlustwarrior
    @wanderlustwarrior 4 дні тому

    Luke really likes Christmas.

  • @user-bv5uc4sh9f
    @user-bv5uc4sh9f Місяць тому

    A Jedi who walks a fine line between light and dark but gives in neither truly one with the force

  • @aurorialgaming1935
    @aurorialgaming1935 2 місяці тому

    You can probably hear the crystal screaming in pain...

  • @gunziro169
    @gunziro169 Місяць тому

    I like to think he turned a lightsaber red just to remind him of his father

  • @spartans122ouellette3
    @spartans122ouellette3 Місяць тому +1

    Are you sure just wasn't Luke using a red and green lightsaber like the Christmas colors because you want to do a Christmas thing

  • @rjwallace7477
    @rjwallace7477 2 дні тому

    Also I don’t think bleeding crystals used to be a thing from my knowledge but personally I like that addition and it makes sith getting their sabers cooler