Stronghold WW2 Field Battle 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @ClamChowder_FireBuff69
    @ClamChowder_FireBuff69 5 років тому +44

    If you look very closely you can see the GI’s deciding not to take their hits.

  • @carlruf9037
    @carlruf9037 5 років тому +22

    Its good to see the ladies take an interest and partake. The nursing squad was impressive.

  • @kaidenrigg3683
    @kaidenrigg3683 5 років тому +44

    World War 2 reenacting is a cool idea, but the Allies always ruin it by thinking they're invincible. Walking around without cover behind the vehicles like nothing's going on? Seems like an easy target.

    • @TheMadVulpen
      @TheMadVulpen 5 років тому +1

      *yes*

    • @w3dnesd4y57
      @w3dnesd4y57 5 років тому +3

      Since after WW2 the Heer apparently enlisted fat people and seems to be terribly out of shape, it seems easy enough to lose the war for the Germans. you American reenactors are so bad.

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 10 місяців тому +2

      I know, it’s particularly bad with the Marine reenactors, it’s all Allies, but Marines especially. Some are ok about calling their hits but yeesh. At least the Axis forces call our hits n shit

  • @callsignsparty6503
    @callsignsparty6503 4 роки тому +15

    Dang those Americans sure seem to like slowly walking through open fields while under heavy small arms fire

  • @stitchem7
    @stitchem7 3 роки тому +9

    300 German troops, anti-tank guns and tanks are like,..."Run, an allied squad is advancing".

  • @professormanhattan7254
    @professormanhattan7254 4 роки тому +24

    Unfortunate tbh. The uniforms look great, the scene is perfect, but watching the G.I.'s casually walk towards the front was just awful. Not to mention assaulting a ground in position with jeeps whilst the Germans have machine-guns, anti-tank/vehicle gun and a Jagdpanzer. Unfortunate and disappointing.

    • @vladmirputin9694
      @vladmirputin9694 4 роки тому

      In World War 2 Allies and Axis did their best to gain ground. Charge enemies launch artillery strikes anything but since u know that the wehrmacht isn't a NAZI division it's pretty ironic u don't know tactics

    • @frefels2628
      @frefels2628 3 роки тому +1

      @@vladmirputin9694 what is that awnser even? What do you mean? Both sides obviously tried thier best during the war. Artilery was used aswell. Its pretty obvious that an entire branch within the german defense force is not one singular division. Whats ironic? And in what way does he not know military tactics? I mean i dont know about you but last time i heard slow mo walking is not in the manual for what to do in a combat situation. Especially under machine gun fire of any kind.

  • @plaguedynasty836
    @plaguedynasty836 2 роки тому +13

    after being a reenactor for some time i see reacuring problem... allies (mostly american) having a sence of invincibility and boosted ego.

    • @BritishMilitaria
      @BritishMilitaria 8 місяців тому

      I see your point how does 20 allied soldiers a weapons carrier and 2 jeeps take onv2 armoured cars an anti tank gun and a hetzer dank destroyer aswell as 50 soldiers and win its weird.

    • @LiamMounts
      @LiamMounts 7 місяців тому

      Are you a Nazi

    • @LiamMounts
      @LiamMounts 7 місяців тому

      Nazi

    • @LiamMounts
      @LiamMounts 7 місяців тому

      He or She is a Nazi

  • @mushroomcloud1
    @mushroomcloud1 6 років тому +12

    Nicely done and great kit, weapons , vehicles and period clothing.
    The only thing I would improve to add to the realism is the tactics of the attackers.
    I know that the spectators want to see the attackers vehicles, but the tactics in the battle
    are hard for a military historian to watch.
    I doubt most people watching will notice the flaws, but the nitpick crowd like myself will.
    Thanks for a great overall video and props to all the reenactors for such a good presentation.
    I wish I could take a ride in the Hetzer.

  • @kevinlutz2679
    @kevinlutz2679 5 років тому +13

    Hey! It's only a reenactment! For entertainment purposes. The battle field would cover hundreds of square miles. Here it's been compressed into the size of a medieval battle field.

    • @noahmations8211
      @noahmations8211 5 років тому

      Kevin Lutz everything you said was wrong

    • @noahmations8211
      @noahmations8211 5 років тому

      I’ve come back 4 weeks later and I still don’t get what you mean

  • @youdontneedtoknowbro
    @youdontneedtoknowbro 7 років тому +19

    I am a part of the one of the German units (I am the mg42 gunner) but I would love if we were able to accurately portray a battle. A German company dug in with anti tank guns and a hetzer would wipe the allies and their keeps

    • @jer574
      @jer574 7 років тому +2

      Exactly what I was thinking.

    • @Mr__Sauce
      @Mr__Sauce 7 років тому +1

      youdontneedtoknowbro yeah I was in the SS unit that was on the front lines to the left of you and we just kept firing and retreating. It was lots of fun but not really accurately portrayed especially since the allies in this had little cover, no tanks, and like always take very few hits

    • @Mr__Sauce
      @Mr__Sauce 7 років тому

      Al G actually the Allies had 1 AT gun but that was about it

    • @Mr__Sauce
      @Mr__Sauce 7 років тому

      Al G yeah it was one of the Polish ones I think. It was on the right side of the battle from the German viewpoint

  • @jackp.richardson6415
    @jackp.richardson6415 Рік тому +3

    WW2 Reenacting looks like so much fun. I know everything isn't 100% accurate as depicted but honestly I'd look over it considering these kinds of events are just a show for audiences. As someone who's loved history since I could read, I only wish a reenactment group was near me :(

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 10 місяців тому

      Holy shit you’re the only one that has actually realized that the public events aren’t always accurate 100%. The private tactical events usually are most accurate and in many cases would be considered the most accurate representation of the war

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 10 місяців тому

      Where are you based? I’m sure there’s a group in your state

  • @tuannguyen-cuocsongmytexas6048
    @tuannguyen-cuocsongmytexas6048 2 роки тому +4

    May I know location of this place in Oregon please ?

  • @Delray58
    @Delray58 7 років тому +17

    Very nice and I know it is just a reenactment but...that was a large force of Germans supported by two armored recon units (some kind of Sdkfz. in a 6 rad and an 8 rad), a Hetzer and a anti-tank gun position facing a smaller mixed force of British/American troops with two jeeps (one looks like it might be towing an anti-tank gun) and a truck. I know the Germans are the bad guys and maybe the airplane noise is supposed to be allied air support but...just seems like a cop-out that the allies win.

    • @kentuckyreenactor9132
      @kentuckyreenactor9132 7 років тому +6

      Delray58 trying being a german reenactor and having to put put up with these stupid situations, it happens all the time when we outnumber them with infantry and armor they don't have any tanks capable of destroying ours and our tanks magically die.

    • @kraigotto1380
      @kraigotto1380 7 років тому +10

      The public get upset if the Germans win and say that is not how it was. You have to understand most see history with Hollywood eyes.

  • @starwarsuniverse5359
    @starwarsuniverse5359 6 років тому +12

    Enemy has god Mode?

  • @gbipit1
    @gbipit1 3 роки тому +7

    Glad Baldwin wasn’t producer

  • @Groovy_Bruce
    @Groovy_Bruce 3 роки тому +9

    Not sure what makes me happier, the hetzer or the horse.

    • @pbp-uw5tj
      @pbp-uw5tj 2 роки тому

      the german on the bike

  • @General.Longstreet
    @General.Longstreet 6 років тому +19

    There's no way soft skinned vehicles wouid enter the tactical area . They wouid loiter in the rear .

    •  5 років тому +2

      Everything is about sex for you people, isn't it?

    •  5 років тому +1

      Never try to understand jokes. It's Chinatown, Zombie. It's Chinatown.

  • @reverence791
    @reverence791 6 років тому +11

    5:54 Lol that dude in the tank is questioning his retreat from Americans with little to no cover and nothing really anti-tank or even bulletproof cars

    • @Eshayzbra96
      @Eshayzbra96 6 років тому +1

      At least they aren't all fat

  • @Max-lk6yi
    @Max-lk6yi 6 років тому +16

    now that is exactly NOT how a battle would've played out like srsly who's the idiot that would drive a jeep head first into a german infantry formation WITH tank support

    • @tylerthegrimm
      @tylerthegrimm 6 років тому

      Lolz Mmilh tourettes guy

    • @Max-lk6yi
      @Max-lk6yi 6 років тому +1

      @@tylerthegrimm yea cuz a 30 cal would make a lot of difference lol

    • @mistakoruto
      @mistakoruto 6 років тому

      Go somwhere else tittled " real war " you able to find it in middle east or ukrain war.. If you want the real deal tho.. This just "ACT of WAR" they're obviously acting.. There's no SOP for this or whatever.. Tq.

    • @Kodaiva
      @Kodaiva 6 років тому

      Daily Kapox acting is still supposed to be as realistic as possible

  • @reginaldmcnab3265
    @reginaldmcnab3265 4 роки тому

    Good job man! If it wasn’t for color and the clarity of the video I could have thought it was the real deal, the constant gunfire and the intermitting aircraft above helped to make it so powerful.
    In every world war 2 movies that I’ve seen, it is the Germans that looses, it is true that they lost the war, however, the Germans won many battles even though they, the soldiers, were outgunned and outnumbered from the very outset of the war, in spite of that, the performance and achievement of the German soldier on the battlefield was extraordinary, some of the victories they won are unparalleled, history and the enemy can attest to that.

  • @Mr__Sauce
    @Mr__Sauce 7 років тому +14

    I'm in one of the German units in this and thanks for the great footage

    • @Mr__Sauce
      @Mr__Sauce 7 років тому +1

      kwanwow852 are you asking if I am German?

    • @TheVirzo4
      @TheVirzo4 Рік тому

      are you the obese boy?

    • @Mr__Sauce
      @Mr__Sauce Рік тому

      @@TheVirzo4 no haha

  • @sentinel531
    @sentinel531 7 років тому +5

    That propelled gun wouldn't miss at that range

  • @shig357
    @shig357 4 роки тому +1

    Anyone know which group this is and who's on horseback? I'm looking at putting together a cavalry kit and need some advice.

  • @StukaSteven
    @StukaSteven 7 років тому +3

    what are some good German units based in Missouri?

  • @nickbarman4145
    @nickbarman4145 7 років тому +7

    great video like always

  • @mattybrewster8523
    @mattybrewster8523 5 років тому +16

    why are the brits running around with black tank berrets on and the one random dude in british desert uniform with what looks to be an m1 rifle xD

  • @Deutche_Reenactment
    @Deutche_Reenactment 10 місяців тому +3

    Hey my unit was in this one! It’s the tank w/the trident! 2. Panzer! This was long before I joined the unit but still! Good to see them!

    • @dboone8279
      @dboone8279 7 місяців тому +1

      Hey!!! A fellow 2. Panzer member good to see ya!

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 7 місяців тому +1

      @@dboone8279 Hey man! Good to see you too! I was late on my Dues I’m still waiting for John to get back to me again lol

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 7 місяців тому

      @@dboone8279 I think you popped up for me on Facebook, I sent you a request lol

    • @dboone8279
      @dboone8279 7 місяців тому

      @@Deutche_Reenactment did you send him a facebook dm he responds pretty fast that way

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 7 місяців тому +1

      @@dboone8279 Yea I did. He got back to me recently I should be good to go! Will you be at Rockford this year?

  • @tobiswk2125
    @tobiswk2125 5 років тому +3

    Hallo,
    in welcher Stadt oder Land spielt sich das ab?

    • @Gslor
      @Gslor 5 років тому +2

      Steht in der Videobeschreibung. 😉

    • @heinzrudiger287
      @heinzrudiger287 4 роки тому +2

      Oregon Illinois, U.S.A

  • @wilhelmkurtz3891
    @wilhelmkurtz3891 Рік тому +5

    how in the world did the Germans lose this battle.

    • @Deutche_Reenactment
      @Deutche_Reenactment 10 місяців тому +3

      It’s because, my friend, the Axis forces tend to be the only people calling their hits when they know they’ve been shot. And I’m not bashing on EVERY Ally, but the Allies are typically the only ones that don’t call their hits. The Army is bad about it but the Marines are also pretty bad with it too. Not every Ally is like that, but I’m saying, I’ve been on both ends of it. German’s more fun imo

    • @carlosgallegos7946
      @carlosgallegos7946 9 місяців тому +1

      IMO, international banks and family dynasties (such as the Rothschilds) ensured an allied victory through seemingly limitless resources while Germany faced a rapidly dwindling supply of pretty much every necessity of war.

  • @Damo3445
    @Damo3445 6 років тому +3

    THis is simply awesome

  • @TrampConnoisseur
    @TrampConnoisseur 3 роки тому +9

    Americans have plot armor

  • @munyaradzichikwanha9350
    @munyaradzichikwanha9350 7 років тому +3

    great

  • @mattkilroy13
    @mattkilroy13 7 років тому +6

    That one random Cossack volunteer...

  • @6thcromium
    @6thcromium 7 років тому +8

    i really love Germany from South Korea

  • @fangedorchidgames2187
    @fangedorchidgames2187 6 років тому +4

    Amazing. One of the best I have seen. Also is that the Grossdeutschland fighting?

  • @upendarkumar3533
    @upendarkumar3533 7 років тому +1

    thanku

  • @matt99908
    @matt99908 Рік тому +1

    One of the best

  • @octaviobruzzone3298
    @octaviobruzzone3298 6 років тому +5

    How do you know When you are been hit ??

    • @SonTran-lo3yd
      @SonTran-lo3yd 6 років тому +1

      Octavio Bruzzone they used real bullets but they shoot like the trees or something.

    • @octaviobruzzone3298
      @octaviobruzzone3298 6 років тому +1

      Son Tran Are you sure because if it is then dont you think that would already been many people dead .

    • @NotCondorTheBird
      @NotCondorTheBird 6 років тому +7

      lmao no we fucking don't, we use blanks, and you know your hit because the pop is distinct and u can see the flash pointed at u

    • @octaviobruzzone3298
      @octaviobruzzone3298 6 років тому +1

      Thomas Giblin understood 😌

    • @mistakoruto
      @mistakoruto 6 років тому

      @@NotCondorTheBird or they'll be dead when they're tired tho

  • @13bravo72
    @13bravo72 6 років тому +8

    People moving too slowly, and what's with officer standing up during a fire fight? The Hetzer is pretty cool as well as the PAk. I know it's only a reenactment, but they can at least try and 'act' like its real.🙄🤔😏 I did like how the landser used the back of the Hetzer, though.

    • @jerikromero1746
      @jerikromero1746 6 років тому

      This is why I got into my local chapter of Jomsborg Vikings.

  • @rangergerald1095
    @rangergerald1095 7 років тому +13

    2:04 Heroes and Generals in real life. XD

  • @MeowReapZ
    @MeowReapZ 7 років тому +3

    DAT SOUND!!!!!!!

  • @JavaIsAwesome
    @JavaIsAwesome 2 роки тому +4

    Who won........
    a Hetzer VS 2 Doge & 2 willy Jeep
    or
    a section of allied troop VS A platoon of German Soldier
    Clearly the allies need add moar tanks XD

  • @godwrote01
    @godwrote01 7 років тому +3

    That Pak shoots really fast

    • @norcoparent6189
      @norcoparent6189 7 років тому +2

      They are fairly easy to reload and can fire really fast with an experienced crew.

  • @pappabear4977
    @pappabear4977 7 років тому +6

    The horse going back and forth detracted from the realism.

  • @РАшенСлавянов
    @РАшенСлавянов 7 років тому +3

    normal reconstruction part of ww2

  • @이저코
    @이저코 7 років тому +6

    Warthunder solider edition

  • @frefels2628
    @frefels2628 3 роки тому +14

    This is just sad. This is probaly the worst re-enactment video i've seen. Lets adress the issues one by one. The first thing i noticed was the absurd start positioning of the allied troops. They where in good range to get completly gunned down instantly from the start. The allies as if that wasnt enough realise quickly the advantages of being completly immune to all sorts of gunfire and begin a holywood style slowmarch onto the field. By the camer angels it doesnt seem like they even have AT. The germans on the other hand outnumber them by far, have defensive positions and they have one Jagdpanzer and an AT gun. The allies even if they actully decided that taking cover was smart would have no way of winning.

    • @jamesreallylongusernametha1228
      @jamesreallylongusernametha1228 3 роки тому +1

      just enjoy it
      it wouldn't be interesting if the allies where all killed that's it battle over

    • @justod1117
      @justod1117 3 роки тому +1

      People tend to have fun, it's not usually made so you history geeks feel satisfaction.

    • @frefels2628
      @frefels2628 3 роки тому +5

      @@justod1117 I get that it's made for fun but a lot of people that take part in it are history geeks so i expect a slightly better preformance. And also i don't see the fun in it if one of the sides is not even acting like their in a combat situation.

    • @colem_h
      @colem_h 3 роки тому +1

      “But the allies won!” Yeah. Barely. In the early to mid parts of the war the Germans tore up everything in their path. Even in 44’ and 45’ they still inflicted heavy casualties on their enemy. It’s not like it was an easy fight against them.

  • @norms3913
    @norms3913 2 роки тому +3

    Not 1 German soldier even carrying a panzerfaust smdh

  • @jeejettai5804
    @jeejettai5804 6 років тому +8

    I was the medic

    • @Kodaiva
      @Kodaiva 6 років тому +1

      Jee Jettai which one

  • @ごくろうさん-k8m
    @ごくろうさん-k8m 5 місяців тому +1

    参加したい😮

  • @monyoutube8788
    @monyoutube8788 7 років тому +1

    very good video

  • @daveJDB
    @daveJDB 2 роки тому

    Damn.

  • @Groovy_Bruce
    @Groovy_Bruce 3 роки тому +5

    Nice gear. Not the fittest group ever tho lol. Ye old party might take issue with this representation.

  • @herman30678
    @herman30678 7 років тому +3

    TIGER-1 + KING TIGER

    • @herman30678
      @herman30678 7 років тому

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @herman30678
      @herman30678 7 років тому

      oh oh!!+BF-109😂

    • @getawayfromme1320
      @getawayfromme1320 7 років тому

      少芸 _ you forgot the FW 190s, ma'am

  • @ВадимКирсанов-я5в
    @ВадимКирсанов-я5в 2 роки тому +2

    Америка у тебя и мозги и голова на месте все у вас хорошо получается не тошто у некоторых

  • @hanamizu-taisa2424
    @hanamizu-taisa2424 7 років тому +2

    like a war movie! wonderful!

  • @SonTran-lo3yd
    @SonTran-lo3yd 6 років тому +5

    They used real bullets.

    • @melchiorlg6646
      @melchiorlg6646 6 років тому +1

      Son Tran plot twist

    • @jogondrino5163
      @jogondrino5163 5 років тому

      😂

    • @JohnsonTheSecond
      @JohnsonTheSecond 4 роки тому

      Yeah, that's why they were all out in the open. Average lifespan of a reenactor is 0.5 events, except tank crew.

  • @yoyohighness
    @yoyohighness 6 років тому +2

    as real as it gets

  • @jackwatson543
    @jackwatson543 6 років тому +5

    All way too bunched up

  • @dalemacio1055
    @dalemacio1055 7 років тому +1

    That guy in 2:06

  • @ДядькоСашко-у7й
    @ДядькоСашко-у7й 4 роки тому

    Имея Hetzer и PAK-35 немцы уничтожили бы разведку союзников за 2 минуты. А реконструкция очень интересная. Показаны DRK, потери и работа санитаров с двух сторон. Well done!

  • @masrekulalam8203
    @masrekulalam8203 7 років тому

    masrekul

  • @RuhulAmin-hp6wo
    @RuhulAmin-hp6wo 7 років тому

    OK

  • @emdenny10
    @emdenny10 6 років тому +3

    Way too bunched up. But at this point in the war most of these germans had no effective nco's or officers left. Most were starving and low on ammunition and food. Most were inexperienced conscripts. Aside from the pak 40 and stug they mostly gave ground.

  • @rajjakansari614
    @rajjakansari614 7 років тому

    just

  • @marianovaliente2103
    @marianovaliente2103 Рік тому +1

    Muy real la whermacht 😂😂😂 enfermeras lindas eh? Para que os cuiden despues😊😊😊 impresionante parece de verdad todo.todo armas vehiculos tanques blindados armas todos son de verdad.que realismo.muy bien felicidades.

  • @ທ້າວຄໍາກຽ້ວຊັນຍາລາດ

    ຍິງຫຍັງບໍ່ເຫັນຫຍັງ ຊ້ອຕີ

  • @bolle8140
    @bolle8140 6 років тому +4

    Zieht die deutschen Uniformen aus ihr bescheuerten Amerikaner.

  • @joehill4094
    @joehill4094 7 років тому +3

    that german is an nco and a medic lol

  • @ВадимКирсанов-я5в
    @ВадимКирсанов-я5в 2 роки тому +1

    Американцы вы во всем мастера Виват Америка 🤩

  • @ashokalawe2460
    @ashokalawe2460 6 років тому

    Ashok Alaew

  • @carlosteran5617
    @carlosteran5617 4 роки тому

    Sublime España, sublime Alemania, sublime Norte América ...

  • @ឳភ្នំពេញអើយ
    @ឳភ្នំពេញអើយ 7 років тому +1

    ហាមវេ៖

  • @bijoybichitra4647
    @bijoybichitra4647 7 років тому +1

    dokala

  • @subashchander7240
    @subashchander7240 6 років тому

    supnachodrivideo

  • @pekonimies8288
    @pekonimies8288 7 років тому +3

    Lol hetzer is comming

  • @mycricketworld148
    @mycricketworld148 7 років тому +1

    Pujan

  • @rahulkumarraaj7138
    @rahulkumarraaj7138 6 років тому +1

    RAHUL kumar

  • @ผีปอบบ่พอบาท
    @ผีปอบบ่พอบาท 6 років тому +1

    คิดว่าเรื่องจริงห่าขั้วกรุว่าแล้วเห็นขี่ม้าวิ่งไปวิ่งมามันคือบ่โดนยิงจักเถื่อที่แท้ถ่ายหนัง😀😁😂😛

  • @grgygantz6760
    @grgygantz6760 Рік тому +1

    I have seen monkey fights at the zoo. With more action than this.

  • @levigaming9008
    @levigaming9008 5 років тому

    Well comrades WE have to fight those germans how in youtube?

  • @mandomendez9736
    @mandomendez9736 7 років тому +1

    USA! USA! USA!

  • @TheVirzo4
    @TheVirzo4 Рік тому +2

    12:11 the shame of the German army

  • @George-pp2hr
    @George-pp2hr 7 місяців тому +2

    This is all fantastic to be in reanacment. Love all the vehicles. What are nurses doing in the field? Not knocking just curious. It looks like a lot of fun wish I was there.👍🇭🇲🦘🐨✌️