@@gryce9077 hate to break it to ya but just about everyone uses some sort of pitch correction on their vocals nowadays. yes, even dave grohl. a lot of live mixing engineers are also running vocal tuning in live performances as well. clearly, they aren’t here because the vocals are very rough from each singer
@@jamestemple8970 it’s not about selling out. it’s about making sure he’s singing on key so the song sounds good. you wouldn’t play your guitar out of tune on a track, why would you approach the vocals the same way? a lot of people associate the “auto-tune” sound with T-pain because it’s so dramatic. real life “auto-tune” AKA pitch correction is applied to everything, even the most accomplished singers
@@xs-xb4ih The joke about selling out did not really have anything to do with auto-tune which is an effect I associate with one thing: total cheesiness. Sure many singers, especially pop singers use it but many do not. This idea that just about everyone uses it is not really accurate.
I would pay an embarrassing amount of money for a Nirvana reunion tour with Joan Jett. This show wasn’t her best with them but the other two times I’ve seen her play with them she killed it.
@@marcomaracas-qq3kk you don’t understand how live mixing works. this is probably just the mix from the console that was then broadcasted to viewers. i 100% guarantee you that this is not what it sounded like in the room.
Best performance of the night! Blew my mind, could not believe I watched Nirvana 3/4 and all the women killed it! Joan Jett!! Violet Grohl was crazy, great set choice! Went back to 7th grade when we heard the tragic news 😢
science and physics stupid. It may not be his fault but the fault of where the sound source came from. If I don't know the exact setup I can't say for certain, but the reason is the difference in speed of light 186,000 MILES per second and Sound traveling at 1160 FEET per second. It depends on when the sound source is taken from.. don't blame someone because you don't understand physics. if the video is shot from close or far but the sound is captured from a distant mic then there is a perceived delay.
I work in retail and had to excuse myself from the cash register because I could not hold back my tears. Nirvana was my gateway into punk and I've been a punk since '93. I vote to have them take the "sublime" route and have Violet as frontwoman. JJ, Annie and Kim (especially Kim ❤) were great, but Violet is something else..😮 I'd like to see and hear much more of this. Even as I'm writing this I'm still crying, so many childhood memories...😭
Technical issues aside, this was a powerful and emotional event,Kim Gordon was mesmerizing and haunting,Joan can still shout and play guitar. Lotta emotions flowing…
@@gregariousmills she’s terrible and i don’t know why nirvana keeps bringing her out. i know kurt was a big fan of sonic youth, so it’s probably to honor him, but be honest with yourself and accept the fact that can’t even sing on key and is difficult to listen to
It might have been harder to tell what it was with the sound on.😂 No disrespect to Annie and the band but that was a bit messy. Who cares though? Still a huge surprise and the high point of the night.
What a nice surprise! The surviving members of Nirvana performed with Kim Gordon (SY), two of my favorite bands in high school playing School, literally made me feel like "you're in high school again" for a moment.
Sonic Youth sucks. Watch Narduar interview. They bully him, very mean, rude, and act like total jerk offs. Kurt called them idiots. I will never listen to that crap
"All apologies" en el contexto de una reunión de Nirvana, después de semejante catástrofe como los incendios, debe haber sido una emoción muy fuerte para los que estuvieron ahí, incluyendo a los mismos músicos. Kurt Cobain hubiera estado más que orgulloso.
I think Kurt would have loved hearing/seeing Kim Gordon sing his song. She is the female Kurt to me. I've loved Sonic Youth and Nirvana since back in the day when they came out. Kurt got me into tons of great music that I still love today. Shonen Knife is another fave of mine and The Meat Puppets also. Genius musicians/songwriters.
@chilenapromedioRU Must be joking....NXCRE will be awesome Lajon whitherspoon COREY GLOVER WILIAM DUVAL Chino Moreno Daniel Johns too but i guess is more that THEY will not be approved by Novoselic....i guess There is so many male singers with a very authentic and powerful voice that will fit very well with the band .... But Chris and Dave only chosen woman til now at Kurt place....with all my respect a woman can not get any closer to the power and intensity of Kurt voice...it's just always sound dull and make the song irrelevant and not worst listening next to the original
The list can be longuer of male singers dont even Corey Taylor and ciee I dont know why this obsession ? Is like if only men will sing Aretha Franklin songs ? Or Sade songs ? Or Tyna Turner songs ?Or any legendary female voice ? Sorry but Kurt even if he loved Women artists WAS A Man not a Woman What iswrong with that in 2020 ?
I'd love to see Buzz and Dale with Pat, Dave and Krist, Dave swapping from Guitar, Backing Vocals and doubled drums. Neither needs a 2nd drummer but Dale has shown how cool it is and Dave is heavy and sparse on drums and they could kill it. Buzz and Dave swapping vocals would be awesome. This was enjoyable. It's live so go easy on them. They're raising money for fire relief and at least one had setup issues with in ears.
Dave did a few shows with Melvins as a drummer in the 90’s after the end of Nirvana. Too bad there’s no video. It helped inspire the addition of big business duo as opposed to just adding a bass player.
Does the mix sound like shit or they did not rehearse or something lol. They sound like they just learned that the festival's sponsor is a cigarette brand.
hate to say it but kim gordon is just not the right fit. i know kurt was a sonic youth fan and im sure it’s done to honor him (and the fact that he was a woman rights advocate) but let’s be honest, it’s terrible.
I don't know who the first girl is but she was great. Kim wonderful. Kurt would love to hear Joan Jett. And Violet Grohl rocked. Hope she can find her own way and make us proud - her dad certainly is and Kurt would be :) Listening to Kurt, Dave, Krist and Pat everyday for the last 30 something years. Thank you so much :)
What the F happened with Joan Jett? She even forgot the lyrics! Come on, you really forgets "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't after you"? Catch-22 Joan!
This made me tear up. Damn. 31 years on since Kurt's passing and we all miss him still. Nirvana forever. ❤
Same here mate . ❤
I’m old. I lived through the 27 Club… Janis Joplin, Jim Morrison, Jimi Hendrix etc.😢😢😢
Pat Smear was in a freezer? He looks like the same age at the last Nirvana´s album
He wasn't.Some of his victims probably are.Kinda kidding.He is punk.
Real, imperfect human voices are so much better than auto-tune.
@@gryce9077 hate to break it to ya but just about everyone uses some sort of pitch correction on their vocals nowadays. yes, even dave grohl. a lot of live mixing engineers are also running vocal tuning in live performances as well. clearly, they aren’t here because the vocals are very rough from each singer
@@xs-xb4ih Not surprised Grohl does. He soldout decades ago.
@@jamestemple8970 it’s not about selling out. it’s about making sure he’s singing on key so the song sounds good. you wouldn’t play your guitar out of tune on a track, why would you approach the vocals the same way? a lot of people associate the “auto-tune” sound with T-pain because it’s so dramatic. real life “auto-tune” AKA pitch correction is applied to everything, even the most accomplished singers
@@jamestemple8970 yah,yah.you"re so punk.we get it.
@@xs-xb4ih The joke about selling out did not really have anything to do with auto-tune which is an effect I associate with one thing: total cheesiness. Sure many singers, especially pop singers use it but many do not. This idea that just about everyone uses it is not really accurate.
I would pay an embarrassing amount of money for a Nirvana reunion tour with Joan Jett. This show wasn’t her best with them but the other two times I’ve seen her play with them she killed it.
Uhhh oasis 10x better .., nivarana was trash
@@Phislammajamma4ever 🤣
@@Phislammajamma4ever the only person who believes this is Liam Gallagher. Liam! Is this you?! HI!!!
@@Trevcreative1 Actually, if you take away the "trash" part, that could have been said by a teenage Frances Bean Cobain.
Not sure I am with you there for some reason
Seeing Dave on the drums helps me sleep at night
Lol
This version of All Apologies is great, thank you !
Pat playing lead on these tracks is great. he is so animated, like the old days.
The sound engineer needs to be fired.
@@marcomaracas-qq3kk you don’t understand how live mixing works. this is probably just the mix from the console that was then broadcasted to viewers. i 100% guarantee you that this is not what it sounded like in the room.
Girlvana is such a vibe
Next will be transvana
Lol
Hervana
@@l17___321 ugh
Meh
Best performance of the night! Blew my mind, could not believe I watched Nirvana 3/4 and all the women killed it! Joan Jett!! Violet Grohl was crazy, great set choice! Went back to 7th grade when we heard the tragic news 😢
Violet did good. The others were terrible. Kim is amazing I sonic youth but not so much here
@@DeadVegaInSpainviolet was beautiful and made me sob !! My inner 9 year old is just soaring !
@@DeadVegaInSpainthe mix was poor. If you isolate the vocals, they were pretty good.
That "Blew my mind" was intentional?
Doesn't say much then because this is fucking horrid. Even his bass sound is off.
This was one for the the old school fans! Thank you.
Lol fart
Thanks for this!!! I got to see them live a couple of times when I was 18. Still as powerful and amazing as ever. Kurt would have fucking loved it.
Violet Grohl is so good. I would love to hear her do more Nirvana songs.
if her name wasn't violet grohl you wouldn't have even commented.
@ such a pointless comment.
I'd love too! She's great!!
We miss you Kurt 😢
Indeed. Definitely not Nirvana without him
@@questionblock8949 Why?What happened?Did they break up?
@@gman007-d5x nuh all still there. Kurt went to the bathroom during their set. Missed the whole set. Stomach bug. Terrible.
This made my day at 542 AM on NYC. PAT SMEAR = life
Kim Gordon is so fucking cool.
And old and talentless.
@@Arturo-p1g4y Opinions vary widely on this subject. 💀🎧
Yessss and she's a powerfull on vocals
@@Entendasletras lol fart
Very emotional version of All Apologies.
Lol fart
Creí que estas emociones las había dejado atrás pero la escucharlos y verlos se que siempre estarán en mi, gracias, te extrañamos Kurt.
This made me cry, miss u Kurt
Wow! The band sounded amazing like 30yrs haven’t gone by! And all the singers were fantastic. Would ❤to see any of them if they did a tour 🤘🙏🔥
All in all is all we are.
My whole 2025 is made with this. Thrilled !! The end with Violet !! I sobbed !!
In switzerland at work. 07:30 a.m & had 1 headphone in my ear. It was the fucking best friday morning ever at work. Fuck, that was so cool!!
The guy who was in charge of synchronizing the sound and the image is unemployed now!
science and physics stupid. It may not be his fault but the fault of where the sound source came from. If I don't know the exact setup I can't say for certain, but the reason is the difference in speed of light 186,000 MILES per second and Sound traveling at 1160 FEET per second. It depends on when the sound source is taken from.. don't blame someone because you don't understand physics. if the video is shot from close or far but the sound is captured from a distant mic then there is a perceived delay.
@@spankeywankeyyes but this is not a new phenomenon
@@spankeywankey Not if the camera has a feed from the desk. But the sound is so awful I suspect not!
I work in retail and had to excuse myself from the cash register because I could not hold back my tears.
Nirvana was my gateway into punk and I've been a punk since '93.
I vote to have them take the "sublime" route and have Violet as frontwoman. JJ, Annie and Kim (especially Kim ❤) were great, but Violet is something else..😮
I'd like to see and hear much more of this.
Even as I'm writing this I'm still crying, so many childhood memories...😭
LOL for real
Aww ❤ love to see Dave back on stage . And Pat ❤️
Chris looks good!!! They all look like they're having fun too!!! Thank you Nirvana!!!
Kim Gordon is female Kurt Cobain
Lol
Kurt would approve. Or maybe not. Nevermind.
How lovely to see everyone together again ♥️ We miss you so much Kurt
They couldn’t have thought of a better song for Joan Jett to sing. Amazing.
I got a big smile when I saw it was t.p. Almost as big as Pat Smear’s smile.
Brought me back to my college days....great to see Krist, Pat and Dave on the drums....man...this made my day!!!!
There's a lot going on in that version of All Apologies
😂😂Grohl confessing his sins
Technical issues aside, this was a powerful and emotional event,Kim Gordon was mesmerizing and haunting,Joan can still shout and play guitar. Lotta emotions flowing…
Very moving performance of All Apologies with an amazing Violet Grohl….
I would love to hear Kim Gordon do more nirvana songs.
Ugh
@@gregariousmills she’s terrible and i don’t know why nirvana keeps bringing her out. i know kurt was a big fan of sonic youth, so it’s probably to honor him, but be honest with yourself and accept the fact that can’t even sing on key and is difficult to listen to
@@xs-xb4ih I can understand that, but in my opinion she has a fantastic voice, especially for the punk genre. I never get tired of listening to her
Sorry, they are from Nirvana and they are playing a Nirvana song but this is not Nirvana
Before even watching this without the the sound on, I could guess the first song by drums and guitar
It might have been harder to tell what it was with the sound on.😂 No disrespect to Annie and the band but that was a bit messy. Who cares though? Still a huge surprise and the high point of the night.
Look at Pat. That dude caught a break when Kurt grabbed him for the band.
You can tell he really loves playing these shows
@@Doyle-fq7we Pfft... Pat doesn't have anything else to do LOL
I’m not crying, you’re crying
Goes to show we are all unique. Nothing beats authenticity and being yourself.
Wow this is just what the world needs now, a Nirvana reunion with Kim Gordon, Joan Jett and Violet Grohl 🤘🏻🥳
What a nice surprise! The surviving members of Nirvana performed with Kim Gordon (SY), two of my favorite bands in high school playing School, literally made me feel like "you're in high school again" for a moment.
Nirvana w/ Sonic Youth!!! 90's come backkkkk!!!!
Sonic Youth sucks. Watch Narduar interview. They bully him, very mean, rude, and act like total jerk offs. Kurt called them idiots. I will never listen to that crap
"All apologies" en el contexto de una reunión de Nirvana, después de semejante catástrofe como los incendios, debe haber sido una emoción muy fuerte para los que estuvieron ahí, incluyendo a los mismos músicos.
Kurt Cobain hubiera estado más que orgulloso.
BREED WHAT A SONGGGGGG
Love them foreveeeeer!! ❤🔥
I think Kurt would have loved hearing/seeing Kim Gordon sing his song. She is the female Kurt to me. I've loved Sonic Youth and Nirvana since back in the day when they came out. Kurt got me into tons of great music that I still love today. Shonen Knife is another fave of mine and The Meat Puppets also. Genius musicians/songwriters.
Nobody knows how to fucking mix Nirvana live anymore.
Miss u kurt
I love when she comes out and does this type of stuff. She’s got a great performance of “gasoline” by Big Black on here, too.
Polite fix, "Kerosene" by Big Black
@ Thanks! Have you seen the performance? It’s really good.
@Lane-wf2er I have!! Such a great song to cover too!!!
Violet kinda looks like a younger Ann Wilson of Heart.
The looks not voice😢
MI TEMA FAVORITO DE NIRVANA CANTADO POR ST VINCENT....❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Nirvana's songs speak for themselves and they'll outlive us all
Quite pleased I guessed it was Breed from the hover-over of the video with no sound just watching the guitar frets and the drumming.
Violet was amazing such a beautiful performance for her uncle kurt
I watched all of foo last night. It was fantastic! 😃😃😃♥️♥️♥️
They could tour with Violet Grohl as the front woman and kill it.
that would be crazy
that's what I was thinking. sooo good.
I wish it was Frances
Agreed !!!!
@@gpfmusicocan you imagine !?
Wish I got tickets for this, Joan Jett and Nirvana? I love it
Great all! St Vincent too ❤
WOW WOW WOW! What a line up! Chills.
Kim Gordon crowd was like 'who' honestly, she was best singer in this line-up...
Territorial Pissing sounds darker af, love it
Kim Gordon rocked! Sang it just like Kurdt would’ve like it 🤘
If there’s anyone out there cooler than Kim Gordon, I’ve never heard of them.
Love the clip, but goddamn it drives me nuts when the audio and video aren't in sync...
Kim Gordon!!! Smashed it out of the park again!
Just, utterly fantastic!!!
Long live y'all ❤❤
This is 🔥 !!!!!!!
Why everytime there is a Nirvana reunion is a Woman who sing? I know Kurt will like it but ist weird is like no man can sing a kurtsong?😅
Post Malone
No man can fill those shoes mate.
@chilenapromedioRU
Must be joking....NXCRE will be awesome
Lajon whitherspoon
COREY GLOVER
WILIAM DUVAL
Chino Moreno
Daniel Johns too but i guess is more that THEY will not be approved by Novoselic....i guess
There is so many male singers with a very authentic and powerful voice that will fit very well with the band ....
But Chris and Dave only chosen woman til now at Kurt place....with all my respect a woman can not get any closer to the power and intensity of Kurt voice...it's just always sound dull and make the song irrelevant and not worst listening next to the original
The list can be longuer of male singers dont even Corey Taylor and ciee
I dont know why this obsession ?
Is like if only men will sing Aretha Franklin songs ? Or Sade songs ? Or Tyna Turner songs ?Or any legendary female voice ?
Sorry but Kurt even if he loved Women artists WAS A Man not a Woman
What iswrong with that in 2020 ?
There’s video of some guys doing songs from the r&r hall of fame after party. J Mascis from dinosaur jr is the only one I remember
The first one was my favorite 90s too bad we couldn't hear it that good
All I can say is that this was better than the rock and roll hall of fame presentation
Violet Grohl is absolutely amazing!!! ❤❤❤
I'd love to see Buzz and Dale with Pat, Dave and Krist, Dave swapping from Guitar, Backing Vocals and doubled drums. Neither needs a 2nd drummer but Dale has shown how cool it is and Dave is heavy and sparse on drums and they could kill it. Buzz and Dave swapping vocals would be awesome. This was enjoyable. It's live so go easy on them. They're raising money for fire relief and at least one had setup issues with in ears.
Dave did a few shows with Melvins as a drummer in the 90’s after the end of Nirvana. Too bad there’s no video. It helped inspire the addition of big business duo as opposed to just adding a bass player.
Violet did a perfect job!
Kurt!!!!!! Miss u❤
Nirvana forever, for Kurt❤
Holy shit. Sign Kim up and lets make a new band. We need this energy, bad.
GOD I MISSED THIS!?!
Does the mix sound like shit or they did not rehearse or something lol. They sound like they just learned that the festival's sponsor is a cigarette brand.
Nirvana forever ❤
Nirvana Tour soon?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Even with technical glitches annie sounded great
Pat, Kris, and Dave looked like kids again. Really cool to see
I just love Joan Jett and Kim Gordon... ❤
Hervana. I felt bad for Annie. Her mic was NOT cooperating at all. Best set of the night.
Violet is the best. She should have sang the whole time
Okay, who else started balling when Dave came in on the vocals?
The microphone ruined this, but Violet and Joan still rocked
hate to say it but kim gordon is just not the right fit. i know kurt was a sonic youth fan and im sure it’s done to honor him (and the fact that he was a woman rights advocate) but let’s be honest, it’s terrible.
So much for soundcheck
I would pay to see Violet Grohl on the vocals in a Nirvana tour
We love Nirvana !!!
They blew it…
I didn’t like the performances until all apologies and when violet kicked into the chorus the tears just started flowing. Goddamn it Kurt we miss you
dang, violet killed it.
I don't know who the first girl is but she was great. Kim wonderful. Kurt would love to hear Joan Jett. And Violet Grohl rocked. Hope she can find her own way and make us proud - her dad certainly is and Kurt would be :)
Listening to Kurt, Dave, Krist and Pat everyday for the last 30 something years. Thank you so much :)
First girl was St. Vincent. Check out her shit. She's good.
What the F happened with Joan Jett? She even forgot the lyrics! Come on, you really forgets "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't after you"? Catch-22 Joan!
Thank you Joan Jett ❤