My dad is at the hospital and we are struggling with money please pray for us these times are very stressful and I’m only 13. God bless you ❤ I love your videos
I can't wait for the part where he goes "it's time to presbyterian...this was predestined to happen" and then uses the power of John Calvin to slap Nestorians
Thank you Redeemed Zoomer, you have became so influential in my live. Through you God has helped me grow. May god be with you, and may he help us retake the mainline church. God bless.
I'm a Presbyterian. So is my mother, so is my grandmother, and so was my great-grandmother. Goes back far. Anyways, a few months ago, I was at a Baptist Campus Ministry meeting for some reason, and myself and another Presbyterian who was also there were playing pool with a Baptist. The Baptist asks, "Have either of you heard of Redeemed Zoomer?" and neither of us had. After a short discussion, it came to light that both of us Presbyterians had no social media, except for my Facebook account, leading to neither of us viewing your other platforms. I was just bored, so I decided to learn about church history, finished the video, went to comments, saw someone say something with your name in it, then realized it was you. Guess I can't say I've never watched you anymore. Glad I did, though. Good job.
A fun historical fact about Brazilian Presbyterianism: Actually, there were a major split in the Mainline denomination over Massonari. The Manline were full of free-Masson and that was viewd as ok. Masson being Anti-Catholic help protected Protestantism in Brazil and a lot of free-Masson were Protestants. The Independent Presbyterian Church was found but it went more liberal and start ordeining womens. The IPB (manline) in a Council declared being a Masson a Sin, but could not reunites with the IPI cause of the woman's ordination controversy. A very sad split, but what happens was a kind of Reconquista in the Manline and the retritionist went liberal.
Im a faithful member of the Presbyterian Church Ireland. The mainline denomination is still conservative with a good theological seminary teaching our ministers how to preach God’s word. Thank God for preserving us!
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613 Liberals at their worst deny the fundamentals of the faith such as Jesus being God, the resurrection and the Bible being the word of God. Liberalism started as an effort to marry the ideas of the enlightenment and historic theology together although is has gone well beyond that and into literal heresy
As a busy med student who is just trying to pass, your videos are extremely helpful. With that being said, there is a certain level of trust I must have in your research. I pray you are blessed for your obedience and that you stay objective as possible with your presentation. Also, there’s no way I’m becoming presby, but honored to have you as a brother.
I’m Gen X but I credit him too with helping me along my journey from being unaffiliated Jewish to embracing Christianity and learning about the branches and doctrines of Christianity. I have now been baptized and officially a member of a Presbyterian church. I know Jews who in becoming Christian chose Catholicism or Messianic Judaism. With my Jewish background I have felt more at home in the Presbyterian church, and I like the emphasis on scripture.
As a brasilian presbyterian I can confirm that by the grace of God our church stayed faithful. Glorified be the name of the Lord for sending us faithful men and women to preach about Him almost 200 hundred years ago.
Awesome!! Love the Presbyterian church! Awesome that you have men and women of God that preach the gospel Not a calvanist. But I love the 1st christians that left catholic heresies. God bless u!
As a Scottish Presbyterian. I have so much more insight into church history in my own nation! I especially loved the Marrow controversy bit and had never heard of it before. Thank you redeemer Zoomer! God bless you. Please come to Scotland one day!
I am from Cameroon and the Presbyterian church there is huge .. I never knew they were considered intellectuals though. I am baptist and we always referred to ourselves as people of the BOOK. But now that i think about it i know many Professors who are Presbyterian.
I really appreciate all the work this channel does!! Its helped me understand my faith and i am currently learning more and more towards Presbytarianism! Keep up the hard work!
brazilian here! went to the link in the description and was surprised to see my city's presbyterian church where i go!!! your videos are amazing! God bless your work :)
The Korean Presbyterian Church is actually two denominations (split in the 50s/60s) that claim the same name, with both claiming it is the true historic mainline KPC.
Praise God. Most of our presidents and most of Americans have been evangelical. If the US becomes another religion such as Muslim or catholic. We are ruined. That might be the case with all the immigration. Bottom line, America has been great due to evangelical Christianity!😊❤❤
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613real christian value do not include praying to creepy dolls and statues and mary😂. Man made traditions such as those are not true christianity The US became awesome because nearly all presidents and most Americans were evangelical Christian. The country would be super different if it were mostlu catholic. So glad it's not!😊
@@roses993 and now it's the standard of both political and theological liberalism, meanwhile most catholic and orthodox countries aren't so your theory doesn't stand the test of time...
@@roses993 1) praying to which creepy dolls are you talking about??? 2) so all the 4 apostolic churches and early church fathers were wrong until roses939 the heretic came along and said it is, LOLOL because he defines what is Christianity and what is not because I said so. 3) The USA presidents where freemasons, not even evangelical Christian. 4) "The country would be super different if it were mostlu catholic. So glad it's not!" I know not to look like Bavaria, St. Augustine Florida and look so beautiful like the Katie Freeway in Houston Texas.
RZ, I don't think you realize just how great of an impact God is having through you. I'm a Baptist who was saved two years ago at 28 years. I see such a great future for you and love what you're doing for the reconnaissance. The wisdom you have at such a young age is profound. You're an immense impact on my faith journey, God bless you! Sincerely, Redeemed Millenial
The explanation: “Predestination doesn’t go against free will. Because we said so.” I like how the entire history of Presbyterianism since Calvin consists of people saying that the establishment is wrong and breaking off from it.
Your take on Presbyterianism oversimplifies a lot. Predestination in Reformed theology isn't just a dismissal of free will-it's about God's sovereignty and His grace saving people who, left to their own devices, wouldn't choose Him (Romans 9, Ephesians 1). It aligns God's will with human freedom, recognizing that while humans make real choices, God's purposes are ultimately accomplished.And as for Presbyterian history, it's not just a story of rebellion. It's about a commitment to the authority of Scripture over human traditions. The Reformation-and Presbyterianism’s growth from it-was driven by a desire to return to biblical Christianity, which they believed the church had strayed from. If you think it's just 'breaking off,' you might want to consider why so many were willing to face persecution and even death for these beliefs.But let’s talk specifics: How do you reconcile your view with the consistent scriptural emphasis on God’s sovereign election? Or the historical evidence of Reformed churches striving for doctrinal purity based on Scripture, even at great cost?
@@pedroguimaraes6094 1) The question begs who defines scripture? 2) There is no free will if you are a Presbyterian, quit lying. Reason why a lot Presbyterian theology will lead directly into secular liberalism or into atheists. 3) "Or the historical evidence of Reformed churches striving for doctrinal purity based on Scripture, even at great cost?" The problem is who defines scripture in the first place and second Protestants will kill each other because there is no council or elders who can finally say what is true and what is false, which leads to just question the Bible directly, which leads into Age of Darkness (liberals call it Age of "Enlightenment") 4) 'The Reformation-and Presbyterianism’s growth from it-was driven by a desire to return to biblical Christianity, which they believed the church had strayed from." LOLOLOLOL, get lost, Presbyterianism growth came out of greedy English aristocrats who wanted theological bases to steal church gold in the monasteries because they where "elected" to do whatever they wanted to do because their actions meant nothing. 5) "It's about a commitment to the authority of Scripture over human traditions." LOLOLOLOL, again, get lost, it human John Calvin making his own human tradition by interpreting the Bible how he will pleased.
Hello Zoomer, Northern Irish presbyterian here, loving the use of the Ulster Banner (red hand of Ulster) for the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. You should check out the Free Presbyterian Church of Ulster. Great bunch of lads.
As a native Reformed Baptist Pennsylvanian I must kindly correct you: the Tennent Log College was founded in Warminster, Bucks County, PA. Otherwise great video and love your channel.
@@redeemedzoomer6053you know there's a stereotype where every time a Lutheran is integrated into Calvinist circles, he becomes Calvinist. To the point where the joke is that Lutherans segregate from Calvinists so that they don't become reform. It's funny because I'd like to see how rabid the reform faith would go if every Lutheran majority city received one reform minister preaching. Lol.
@@noahtylerpritchett2682 tbh, i am not even luthern, i used to be. But im kinda against titles so im just a normal christian. Im literally a 0 on the conservative/progressive spectrum. But ik luthuran and prebyterian beef and it can be a lil funny.
@@MrMcEggz Be sure to read the Institutes of the Christian Religion. I think most Calvinists don't know the contents of that book. If they did, I don't think they would be Calvinists.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforged i agree with calvinism, God is omnipresent. He exists in multiple places and places of time at once. It would make sense that he knows if your gonna go to hell bc he exists everywhere. Not js that, but the Bible says to deny yourself, calvinism is like that, saying: i dont desserve heavan but through Gods grace i do. I dont think calvinism goes against the Bible but i js dont call it calvinism cuz there js titles.
@@professorhaystacks6606 It’s important to know that neither Martin Luther nor John Calvin had anything to do with England’s embracing of Protestantism. Henry VIII broke away from the Vatican for personal reasons despite being a lifelong defender of Catholic dogma. He (and Elizabeth I) kept all the hierarchy and iconography whereas the continental reformers and Scotland abolished them.
I really appreciate your videos. I was heavily influenced by word of faith teaching due to my grandfather pastoring a WOF church. It left me disenfranchised with the faith for a long time, and more of a progressive Christian. God pulled me out of that life, and into a Calvinistic Baptist church. I ended up marrying my husband who was saved in college while going to R.C. Sproul’s church. We both are still learning, but lean heavily Presbyterian and would attend a Presbyterian church if we weren’t so heavily involved in our little Baptist one. Your videos have helped greatly in understanding the beliefs of the Presbyterian denomination, thank you and God bless.
Like the channel, my smooth brain was able to follow along alright. I am Opc in maryland but was previously Bpc (Bible Presbyterian Church) in Washington state. I hear rumors both might become one denomination again. Pray more of the Church unifies in and for the trying times ahead.
He had his problems with Henry VIII and did asked God to open Henry's eye before he died, but he was executed in Belgium, which was ruled by the Habsburgs. The inquisitor of his case also let him write some books putting foward his points, and wrote his own books in refutation to during the process.
It's funny that Queen Mary I executed less number of Protestants than the number of Catholics executed by King Henry VIII and is still being called "Bloody Mary". 😅
@@jdotoz After RedeemedZoomer said reformers were at risk of being executed by the Catholic Church I started going through Wikipedia's list of reformers. I'm through the Lutherans so far and not one was killed by the Catholic Church. Zwingli was killed in battle against a monarch who happened to be Catholic, but it was a war against civil authorities, not the Church. I still have to get through the list of Reformed, Anglican, and Radical Reformers.
You know what' s funny ? how false this comment is... Henry Killed around 300 Protestants and 300 Catholics during his reign. Mary Tudor killed 600 Protestants, so that's double the amount of her father. Also Henry the VIII is not remembered fondly by the Anglican Church of England or by English people as a whole. But the thing is Mary persecuting Protestants instituted by law as part of the Catholic Counter Reformation. Henry was a lot less bothered by the religious aspect and was more concerned about authority... that's why during the times of his reign before he endorsed the Reformation, he executed both Catholics and Protestants. And after is hierarchical separation from Rome and the acceptance of Reformation Church ideals and a different structure of church polity..., he still executed both Catholics and Protestants that he felt challenged his authority or in some other way failed him.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforged Idk about any other reformers, but Jan Hus was burned at the stake and potentially prophesied in a sense that a swan, who turned out to be Martin Luther, would succeed 100 years later (though it was slightly more than 100 years, and I'm a cessationist but of course miracles can still happen). Outside of reformers there was also William Tyndale around the time of the start of Anglicanism, he was strangled and then his body was burned.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforgedThe reformers were in danger, luckily they were heavily protected because they gained the support of many monarchs and governments. They were in danger of persecution because of the long history of catholic persecution against proto protestant groups. Look up the Waldensians and the brutal persecution they faced. Look at medieval catholic theology-an essential doctrine during this time was “exterminating heretics” that dared to disagree with the pope and the terrible practice of papal indulgences
There would be too much stuff to cover compared to the presbyterians video, that I don't think his format of videos would do justice to a lot of subjects.
@@diogomelo7897yes. Took hundreds of years for catholic heresies to evolve the way that they did😂 From a church simple and with pure gospel. To one with creepy dolls and statues. And praying to mary and people in heaven. And penance and indulgences. And useless rosaries. The 1st century church and the catholic church are two different entities🤡🤡
@@prins_af_danmark the fourth crusade arguably wasn't even a real crusade since all of the crusaders were excommunicated after they helped besiege Zara for the venetians to pay off their debts.
I’m a non-denominational YWAMer…this and other videos challenge me to go deeper into theology and church history. Thank you. I have great respect for what you do. I’d love to see a video you have on the Christian Missionary Alliance Denomination. I grew up in one. Sadly my local one has gone woke so I attend a Calvary Chapel instead.
@redeemedzoomer6053 Thanks for the encouragement? I’m not looking to leave my current church. For CMA I recognize it doesn’t have a history of tradition, but has been impactful for many believers including myself. It certainly was influential in giving me a heart for the nations.
14:38 interesting thing that, even though it was the Americans who brought Presbyterianism to the Philippines, it's now the Korean Presbyterians leading most churches here.
@@fatphobicandproud9003Brazilianism catholic is the most carnal heretical sexuality in the world. Search the carnival in Rio, a catholic party, 100% of the "dancers" say "im catholic".
I came from Presbyterian Church of Brazil (IPB in Portuguese). We have been blessed by the faithful preaching of God's Word in the past 165 years. Nowadays I moved to the US and became a member of PCA. By the way, the "Average PCA" picture you show in 19:42 is a picture of the church I've been attending (Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Raleigh, NC).
Scripture, Genesis to Revelation? We preach because the Bible tells us to do it. We congregate because the Bible tells us to do it. Those who are predestined to salvation will do that, and those not predestined don’t even care about it.
@@rochalima28 it does not even matter because your doctrine is satanic and second you are predestination to heaven or hell independent of you hear the false word of God that Calvinist preach
@@rochalima28 Still not answering the question, if you are predestined to hell or heaven independent if you preaching the satanic doctrine of Calvinist, why even bother to do so because your actions do not mean anything.
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613 That’s the point. Our actions are not a requirement but fruits of our salvation. The ones who God predestined will hear His Word and be saved. Specifically His Word. God predestined them to specifically go through this path, know Him and love Him.
Hey Redeemed Zoomer, you should visit Geneva College in Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania sometime. Small RPCNA college. At 13:21 you included a picture of my brother’s church!
I like how you showed Mr. Rogers as an example of a Presbyterian, from I recalled he was a priest from a Presbyterian church (possibly in Pennsylvania). I could be be wrong.
I'm from Brazilian Presbiterian Church (IPB), but here in Brazil we're kinda suffering a wave of modernism and liberalism in some federal states and presbitery. May God leed us to a diferente way and keep us faithfull to our confesions and sacraments.
The picture used at 7:57 for Cornelius Burges is actually a portrait of William laud who was promoted Archbishop of Canterbury and enforced Arminianism ideas in the Church of England during Charles 1st rule
I loved this. I’m a part of the CRCNA, which has deep roots from the French Huguenots. In this vid I keep seeing gaps in the story with a Huguenot shaped hole 😅 (like Calvin in Geneva, or the Dutch Reformed church in the US)
Great video. Good job.comically done. 😊 Now when the King of England goes to Scotland he is no longer King but an elder. Christ is King Amen’Presbyterian (PCA) here!✋
The main line presby church in Korea is less more like PCA care less sacrament and the split off one is more like PCUSA but with more conservative belief.
Putting Gottschalk of Orabis on the list of people who believed Predestination is not a good look. He was condemned for his view of the Atonement. A much better source would have been the Church of Lyon during that time, who basically just said the Lombardian formula to correct one of Gottschalk's opponents who said Christ died for all equally. John Davenant's "On the Death of Christ," has a whole chapter talking about this controversy, which is related to Predestination, and gives a list of various theologians who are way more orthodox than Gottschalk. Great video though!
14:30 "anyone who's pro slavery is utterly condemned by owning another man that which no man is appointed to rule but God and the God ordained government, but not as chattel to the slaver and his abominable treatment on his fellow man" Noah T. Pritchett 2024
My dad is at the hospital and we are struggling with money please pray for us these times are very stressful and I’m only 13. God bless you ❤ I love your videos
My dad came back and he’s okay thank you to everyone who prayed
MAY GOD BE WITH YOU THROUGH EVERYTHING AMEN AND HALLELUJAH 🔥🙏✝️❤️🔥
🙏
Praise God, and I pray that such young, strong faith will be awarded and your father will be abundant in health.
Thank you everyone for the kind words God bless you all ✝️
I can't wait for the part where he goes "it's time to presbyterian...this was predestined to happen" and then uses the power of John Calvin to slap Nestorians
My favorite part of church history
Absolute cinema
"We're Knox done yet..."
😢 Poor nestorianism
My favorite part of this video is when RZ said it's "Reforming Time" and then Presbyterianed everywhere
Thank you Redeemed Zoomer, you have became so influential in my live. Through you God has helped me grow. May god be with you, and may he help us retake the mainline church.
God bless.
Im Orthodox and I have much respect for the faithful Presbyterians reclaiming their church from theological liberalism, GLORY TO GOD!
@@serbiaballshomebase presbyterianism is demonic
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613how?
I'm a Presbyterian. So is my mother, so is my grandmother, and so was my great-grandmother. Goes back far.
Anyways, a few months ago, I was at a Baptist Campus Ministry meeting for some reason, and myself and another Presbyterian who was also there were playing pool with a Baptist.
The Baptist asks, "Have either of you heard of Redeemed Zoomer?" and neither of us had. After a short discussion, it came to light that both of us Presbyterians had no social media, except for my Facebook account, leading to neither of us viewing your other platforms.
I was just bored, so I decided to learn about church history, finished the video, went to comments, saw someone say something with your name in it, then realized it was you.
Guess I can't say I've never watched you anymore. Glad I did, though. Good job.
A fun historical fact about Brazilian Presbyterianism:
Actually, there were a major split in the Mainline denomination over Massonari. The Manline were full of free-Masson and that was viewd as ok. Masson being Anti-Catholic help protected Protestantism in Brazil and a lot of free-Masson were Protestants.
The Independent Presbyterian Church was found but it went more liberal and start ordeining womens. The IPB (manline) in a Council declared being a Masson a Sin, but could not reunites with the IPI cause of the woman's ordination controversy. A very sad split, but what happens was a kind of Reconquista in the Manline and the retritionist went liberal.
This video was PREDESTINED to be amazing.
Im a faithful member of the Presbyterian Church Ireland. The mainline denomination is still conservative with a good theological seminary teaching our ministers how to preach God’s word.
Thank God for preserving us!
Why is there even a liberal form of Presbyterian Church? Second, what is wrong with the liberal section of the Presbyterian Church.
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613 Liberals at their worst deny the fundamentals of the faith such as Jesus being God, the resurrection and the Bible being the word of God.
Liberalism started as an effort to marry the ideas of the enlightenment and historic theology together although is has gone well beyond that and into literal heresy
@MarkStein-b5b if you are protestant (heretic), why is abortion wrong???
And each Irish man
With feeling strong
Will answer to the call
And loud and high
We'll raise the cry
Revenge for Skibereen
Don't start your car tomorrow
As a busy med student who is just trying to pass, your videos are extremely helpful. With that being said, there is a certain level of trust I must have in your research. I pray you are blessed for your obedience and that you stay objective as possible with your presentation. Also, there’s no way I’m becoming presby, but honored to have you as a brother.
Redeemed zoomer you became so influential for me to embrace presbyterianism. I've been attending a PCA Church few months now and am doing membership!
God bless! Hope this video helps you understand your new religious heritage better
@@redeemedzoomer6053 sure do!
/\ Nephilim above me /\
I’m Gen X but I credit him too with helping me along my journey from being unaffiliated Jewish to embracing Christianity and learning about the branches and doctrines of Christianity. I have now been baptized and officially a member of a Presbyterian church.
I know Jews who in becoming Christian chose Catholicism or Messianic Judaism. With my Jewish background I have felt more at home in the Presbyterian church, and I like the emphasis on scripture.
@@aobrainstem9208 amén God bless you in your Journey of the christian life.
As a brasilian presbyterian I can confirm that by the grace of God our church stayed faithful. Glorified be the name of the Lord for sending us faithful men and women to preach about Him almost 200 hundred years ago.
Brazilian presbyterians assemble
Presbyterianism is satanic
Awesome!! Love the Presbyterian church! Awesome that you have men and women of God that preach the gospel
Not a calvanist. But I love the 1st christians that left catholic heresies. God bless u!
@@roses993 What Catholic heresies are you talking about? 2nd, who made roses993 that decider what is heretical and what is not heretical.
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613The Scriptures decide what is orthodox and what is heretic
As a Scottish Presbyterian. I have so much more insight into church history in my own nation! I especially loved the Marrow controversy bit and had never heard of it before. Thank you redeemer Zoomer! God bless you. Please come to Scotland one day!
I would argue that this is your best video yet.
When you got banished 3 times by Catholic queens named “Mary” and decided to confess your sexism in Twitter:
I am from Cameroon and the Presbyterian church there is huge .. I never knew they were considered intellectuals though. I am baptist and we always referred to ourselves as people of the BOOK. But now that i think about it i know many Professors who are Presbyterian.
This video is going to be fire! God bless you Redeemed Zoomer ❤️
these are easily your best videos and i love your expositions on the Reformed tradition, i hope you put out more stuff encouraging Presbyterianism!
I really appreciate all the work this channel does!! Its helped me understand my faith and i am currently learning more and more towards Presbytarianism! Keep up the hard work!
brazilian here! went to the link in the description and was surprised to see my city's presbyterian church where i go!!! your videos are amazing! God bless your work :)
The Korean Presbyterian Church is actually two denominations (split in the 50s/60s) that claim the same name, with both claiming it is the true historic mainline KPC.
What a wonderful birthday present!
Maryland was explicitly founded as a Catholic colony
Praise God. Most of our presidents and most of Americans have been evangelical. If the US becomes another religion such as Muslim or catholic. We are ruined. That might be the case with all the immigration. Bottom line, America has been great due to evangelical Christianity!😊❤❤
Amen, based on real Christian values.
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613real christian value do not include praying to creepy dolls and statues and mary😂. Man made traditions such as those are not true christianity
The US became awesome because nearly all presidents and most Americans were evangelical Christian. The country would be super different if it were mostlu catholic. So glad it's not!😊
@@roses993 and now it's the standard of both political and theological liberalism, meanwhile most catholic and orthodox countries aren't so your theory doesn't stand the test of time...
@@roses993 1) praying to which creepy dolls are you talking about???
2) so all the 4 apostolic churches and early church fathers were wrong until roses939 the heretic came along and said it is, LOLOL because he defines what is Christianity and what is not because I said so.
3) The USA presidents where freemasons, not even evangelical Christian.
4) "The country would be super different if it were mostlu catholic. So glad it's not!"
I know not to look like Bavaria, St. Augustine Florida and look so beautiful like the Katie Freeway in Houston Texas.
RZ,
I don't think you realize just how great of an impact God is having through you. I'm a Baptist who was saved two years ago at 28 years. I see such a great future for you and love what you're doing for the reconnaissance. The wisdom you have at such a young age is profound. You're an immense impact on my faith journey, God bless you!
Sincerely,
Redeemed Millenial
I love the simplicity, yet the depth and funny style of the video. Great job!!!
This is the only channel I'll be nostalgic for when I'm older. It's like a home.
I appreciate your videos. They have really helped to fill in some of the larger gaps in my knowledge of Church history: the Reformed tradition.
Peace
The explanation: “Predestination doesn’t go against free will. Because we said so.”
I like how the entire history of Presbyterianism since Calvin consists of people saying that the establishment is wrong and breaking off from it.
Presbyterianism is Satanic
Almost as if they are fighting against destiny
Your take on Presbyterianism oversimplifies a lot. Predestination in Reformed theology isn't just a dismissal of free will-it's about God's sovereignty and His grace saving people who, left to their own devices, wouldn't choose Him (Romans 9, Ephesians 1). It aligns God's will with human freedom, recognizing that while humans make real choices, God's purposes are ultimately accomplished.And as for Presbyterian history, it's not just a story of rebellion. It's about a commitment to the authority of Scripture over human traditions. The Reformation-and Presbyterianism’s growth from it-was driven by a desire to return to biblical Christianity, which they believed the church had strayed from. If you think it's just 'breaking off,' you might want to consider why so many were willing to face persecution and even death for these beliefs.But let’s talk specifics: How do you reconcile your view with the consistent scriptural emphasis on God’s sovereign election? Or the historical evidence of Reformed churches striving for doctrinal purity based on Scripture, even at great cost?
@@pedroguimaraes6094 How can God not be the author of all sin in your view?
@@pedroguimaraes6094 1) The question begs who defines scripture?
2) There is no free will if you are a Presbyterian, quit lying. Reason why a lot Presbyterian theology will lead directly into secular liberalism or into atheists.
3) "Or the historical evidence of Reformed churches striving for doctrinal purity based on Scripture, even at great cost?"
The problem is who defines scripture in the first place and second Protestants will kill each other because there is no council or elders who can finally say what is true and what is false, which leads to just question the Bible directly, which leads into Age of Darkness (liberals call it Age of "Enlightenment")
4) 'The Reformation-and Presbyterianism’s growth from it-was driven by a desire to return to biblical Christianity, which they believed the church had strayed from."
LOLOLOLOL, get lost, Presbyterianism growth came out of greedy English aristocrats who wanted theological bases to steal church gold in the monasteries because they where "elected" to do whatever they wanted to do because their actions meant nothing.
5) "It's about a commitment to the authority of Scripture over human traditions."
LOLOLOLOL, again, get lost, it human John Calvin making his own human tradition by interpreting the Bible how he will pleased.
I'd love to see this but for Orthodox and Catholic!
Agreed
thank you for the video it was very informative to me , God Bless You
Should do all the Reformers explained in 10 min (like your every church Father video).
Hello Zoomer, Northern Irish presbyterian here, loving the use of the Ulster Banner (red hand of Ulster) for the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. You should check out the Free Presbyterian Church of Ulster. Great bunch of lads.
Why even be Presbyterian heretic as you are already predestined to heaven or hell???
Up the union!!!!
Shamelessly stolen from the real, yellow and red flag of Irish Ulster.
“The conservatives STAND STR- I’m just kidding they give up.” 💀
As a native Reformed Baptist Pennsylvanian I must kindly correct you: the Tennent Log College was founded in Warminster, Bucks County, PA. Otherwise great video and love your channel.
As a Lutheran, i think bro just made me belive in calvinism and now i am questioning to become a presbyterian
Find a Presbyterian church in the map below!
@@redeemedzoomer6053you know there's a stereotype where every time a Lutheran is integrated into Calvinist circles, he becomes Calvinist. To the point where the joke is that Lutherans segregate from Calvinists so that they don't become reform.
It's funny because I'd like to see how rabid the reform faith would go if every Lutheran majority city received one reform minister preaching. Lol.
@@noahtylerpritchett2682 tbh, i am not even luthern, i used to be. But im kinda against titles so im just a normal christian. Im literally a 0 on the conservative/progressive spectrum. But ik luthuran and prebyterian beef and it can be a lil funny.
@@MrMcEggz Be sure to read the Institutes of the Christian Religion. I think most Calvinists don't know the contents of that book. If they did, I don't think they would be Calvinists.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforged i agree with calvinism, God is omnipresent. He exists in multiple places and places of time at once. It would make sense that he knows if your gonna go to hell bc he exists everywhere. Not js that, but the Bible says to deny yourself, calvinism is like that, saying: i dont desserve heavan but through Gods grace i do. I dont think calvinism goes against the Bible but i js dont call it calvinism cuz there js titles.
You know when Redeemed Zoomer copies Bill Wurtz you are in for a great video.
@@DruckerYTA thanks haha
fr
I identified Cornerstone OPC (0:08) in Houston in a split second. I have visited this wonderful congregation a few times. A lovely church!
This is an amazingly well done video
Wasn’t expecting the RPCNA shoutout. Thanks for the mention!
3:12 As a Star Wars fan, I love how you put Calvin and Knox as Vader and Starkiller respectively.
Meanwhile in England:
Henry VIII: Look at me. Look. At. Me. I’m the head of the Church of England now.
Ok I laughed at this.
@@professorhaystacks6606 It’s important to know that neither Martin Luther nor John Calvin had anything to do with England’s embracing of Protestantism. Henry VIII broke away from the Vatican for personal reasons despite being a lifelong defender of Catholic dogma. He (and Elizabeth I) kept all the hierarchy and iconography whereas the continental reformers and Scotland abolished them.
@@CliffCardi The Anglican church had a background before Henry VIII. It was not just the personal issues of him.
I really appreciate your videos. I was heavily influenced by word of faith teaching due to my grandfather pastoring a WOF church. It left me disenfranchised with the faith for a long time, and more of a progressive Christian. God pulled me out of that life, and into a Calvinistic Baptist church. I ended up marrying my husband who was saved in college while going to R.C. Sproul’s church. We both are still learning, but lean heavily Presbyterian and would attend a Presbyterian church if we weren’t so heavily involved in our little Baptist one. Your videos have helped greatly in understanding the beliefs of the Presbyterian denomination, thank you and God bless.
An entertaining showcase of Presbyterian history. Thank you.
Fantastic video. I learned a lot. I'm Anglican. Maybe you can give us this same treatment, if you haven't already.
Like the channel, my smooth brain was able to follow along alright. I am Opc in maryland but was previously Bpc (Bible Presbyterian Church) in Washington state. I hear rumors both might become one denomination again. Pray more of the Church unifies in and for the trying times ahead.
The mainline Presbyterian church in Cameroon stayed faithfully.
Do more of this, crazy history lesson thanks.
1:09 William Tyndale was killed by Henry VIII after he had already broken away from the Catholic Church
He had his problems with Henry VIII and did asked God to open Henry's eye before he died, but he was executed in Belgium, which was ruled by the Habsburgs. The inquisitor of his case also let him write some books putting foward his points, and wrote his own books in refutation to during the process.
William Tyndale was banished by Henry VIII.
He was killed by Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor.
@@IamGrimalkin It was a joint effort. He was apprehended by agents of Henry VIII and turned over to Charles V.
I‘m excited for this can’t watch it live tho I have physics 😢
It's funny that Queen Mary I executed less number of Protestants than the number of Catholics executed by King Henry VIII and is still being called "Bloody Mary". 😅
@@anycyclopedia Propaganda is a heck of a drug.
@@jdotoz After RedeemedZoomer said reformers were at risk of being executed by the Catholic Church I started going through Wikipedia's list of reformers. I'm through the Lutherans so far and not one was killed by the Catholic Church. Zwingli was killed in battle against a monarch who happened to be Catholic, but it was a war against civil authorities, not the Church. I still have to get through the list of Reformed, Anglican, and Radical Reformers.
You know what' s funny ? how false this comment is... Henry Killed around 300 Protestants and 300 Catholics during his reign. Mary Tudor killed 600 Protestants, so that's double the amount of her father. Also Henry the VIII is not remembered fondly by the Anglican Church of England or by English people as a whole. But the thing is Mary persecuting Protestants instituted by law as part of the Catholic Counter Reformation. Henry was a lot less bothered by the religious aspect and was more concerned about authority... that's why during the times of his reign before he endorsed the Reformation, he executed both Catholics and Protestants. And after is hierarchical separation from Rome and the acceptance of Reformation Church ideals and a different structure of church polity..., he still executed both Catholics and Protestants that he felt challenged his authority or in some other way failed him.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforged Idk about any other reformers, but Jan Hus was burned at the stake and potentially prophesied in a sense that a swan, who turned out to be Martin Luther, would succeed 100 years later (though it was slightly more than 100 years, and I'm a cessationist but of course miracles can still happen). Outside of reformers there was also William Tyndale around the time of the start of Anglicanism, he was strangled and then his body was burned.
@@WC3isBetterThanReforgedThe reformers were in danger, luckily they were heavily protected because they gained the support of many monarchs and governments. They were in danger of persecution because of the long history of catholic persecution against proto protestant groups. Look up the Waldensians and the brutal persecution they faced. Look at medieval catholic theology-an essential doctrine during this time was “exterminating heretics” that dared to disagree with the pope and the terrible practice of papal indulgences
That was awesome can’t wait for him to do the other denominations next
This is phenomenal. I'm Presbyterian and I didn't even know this - UPCUSA - but in South Africa - so UPCSA
This is so entertaining 🤪
Best video I've watched from your channel 👍
Please do a video of the history of all denominations. Can’t wait to see how long the Catholic one is.
About 2000 years long 😉
There would be too much stuff to cover compared to the presbyterians video, that I don't think his format of videos would do justice to a lot of subjects.
@@diogomelo7897yes. Took hundreds of years for catholic heresies to evolve the way that they did😂
From a church simple and with pure gospel. To one with creepy dolls and statues. And praying to mary and people in heaven. And penance and indulgences. And useless rosaries.
The 1st century church and the catholic church are two different entities🤡🤡
@MarkStein-b5b Zoomer ain’t gonna be happy about that lol
Thanks for all of your videos, Zoomer. I think I have found a new home church in the Associate Reformed Presbyterian church.
This is very interesting and also helpful to understand American history better.
Great video!
Starkiller John Knox is crazy. Great vid as always
Hey reedemed zoomer can you make a video on the crusades please?
FOURTH CRUSADE?
@@prins_af_danmark why the forth crusade
@@prins_af_danmark the fourth crusade arguably wasn't even a real crusade since all of the crusaders were excommunicated after they helped besiege Zara for the venetians to pay off their debts.
I’m a non-denominational YWAMer…this and other videos challenge me to go deeper into theology and church history. Thank you. I have great respect for what you do.
I’d love to see a video you have on the Christian Missionary Alliance Denomination. I grew up in one. Sadly my local one has gone woke so I attend a Calvary Chapel instead.
That’s what happens when women get put in ministry.
*hucks hand grenade. Leaves.
both of those denominations lack any sort of rootedness in tradition. If you want church history, you gotta leave
@redeemedzoomer6053 Thanks for the encouragement? I’m not looking to leave my current church. For CMA I recognize it doesn’t have a history of tradition, but has been impactful for many believers including myself. It certainly was influential in giving me a heart for the nations.
Redeemed Zoomer, are you going to make more Ecclesial History videos like this one and the other ones? (The ones about the Church and the Bible)
Depends on how well this video does
Alright
@@redeemedzoomer6053make a story of the Bible I guess MOVIE, just like your video except a 3 hour long FULL version!
@@MythicGivesthat is actually a great idea!
14:38 interesting thing that, even though it was the Americans who brought Presbyterianism to the Philippines, it's now the Korean Presbyterians leading most churches here.
Catholics: we’re not looking so bad now are we?
not at all
More please. This is sooo good
The Church did not kill John Wycliffe, they only dug up his bones and burned them. :)
An honor formerly only bestowed on Pope Formosus ...
Jan Hus anybody?
Only.....
Scholasticism far-predates the reformation. Thomas Aquinas was a scholastic.
I'm aware. I was referring to the period of Protestant scholasticism because this video is about Presbyterians
Not Presbyterian but love all of these videos keep them coming
A brazilian presbiteryan here. Thanks bro.
Why would want to be a heretical Presbyterian?
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613ikr Brazilianism is such an enduring heresy
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613 Bro wtf? , respect peoples choice, not everybody wants to be a pagan like you. Get lost you idol worshiper
@@fatphobicandproud9003 amen
@@fatphobicandproud9003Brazilianism catholic is the most carnal heretical sexuality in the world. Search the carnival in Rio, a catholic party, 100% of the "dancers" say "im catholic".
I’m a member of Dr. Sproul’s church. It’s incredible. Should add to your reconquista map!
No, why would he support a church that doesn't baptize babies
I appreciate you pointing out the lack of an ontological difference between Bishops and Presbyters right out of the gate
cuz there isn't one
Correct!
@@redeemedzoomer6053thus sayith redeemed zoomer
The Presbyterian church in Egypt is still faithful also and we are fighting very hard to stay like that
God bless
I came from Presbyterian Church of Brazil (IPB in Portuguese). We have been blessed by the faithful preaching of God's Word in the past 165 years. Nowadays I moved to the US and became a member of PCA. By the way, the "Average PCA" picture you show in 19:42 is a picture of the church I've been attending (Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Raleigh, NC).
Preaching what word of God??? That you are predestined to heaven or hell, so even bother going to church???
Scripture, Genesis to Revelation? We preach because the Bible tells us to do it. We congregate because the Bible tells us to do it. Those who are predestined to salvation will do that, and those not predestined don’t even care about it.
@@rochalima28 it does not even matter because your doctrine is satanic and second you are predestination to heaven or hell independent of you hear the false word of God that Calvinist preach
@@rochalima28 Still not answering the question, if you are predestined to hell or heaven independent if you preaching the satanic doctrine of Calvinist, why even bother to do so because your actions do not mean anything.
@@jeffreyrodrigoecheverria2613 That’s the point. Our actions are not a requirement but fruits of our salvation. The ones who God predestined will hear His Word and be saved. Specifically His Word. God predestined them to specifically go through this path, know Him and love Him.
Going through OCIA starting next week and I’m so excited to the join the United Church that convened at the Council of Nicaea
Hey Redeemed Zoomer, you should visit Geneva College in Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania sometime. Small RPCNA college. At 13:21 you included a picture of my brother’s church!
I like how you showed Mr. Rogers as an example of a Presbyterian, from I recalled he was a priest from a Presbyterian church (possibly in Pennsylvania). I could be be wrong.
I'm from Brazilian Presbiterian Church (IPB), but here in Brazil we're kinda suffering a wave of modernism and liberalism in some federal states and presbitery. May God leed us to a diferente way and keep us faithfull to our confesions and sacraments.
The picture used at 7:57 for Cornelius Burges is actually a portrait of William laud who was promoted Archbishop of Canterbury and enforced Arminianism ideas in the Church of England during Charles 1st rule
I'm a Brazil Presbyterian member
I loved this. I’m a part of the CRCNA, which has deep roots from the French Huguenots. In this vid I keep seeing gaps in the story with a Huguenot shaped hole 😅 (like Calvin in Geneva, or the Dutch Reformed church in the US)
Great video, it would have been better maybe if you included dates and years in which the actions took place.
2:30
"He cares a lot about equality because we're all terrible"
I love that line and I agree
Great video. Good job.comically done. 😊
Now when the King of England goes to Scotland he is no longer King but an elder. Christ is King Amen’Presbyterian (PCA) here!✋
HE MENTIONED US!!! Cumberlands for the win
This video better blow up. Do one on Orthodoxy next. 🙏
The main line presby church in Korea is less more like PCA care less sacrament and the split off one is more like PCUSA but with more conservative belief.
Great video
As a Lutheran I have nothing but respect for our Presbyterian cousins.
It really is just 500 years of splits
Thank you for this
I thought there was no way 20 minutes could contain enough information... but this is dense!
Was not expecting the Albion’s Seed interlude
I watch these videos on 2x speed and it’s wonderful. Like downloading knowledge in Matrix.
Not even Presby but this sounds very interesting
Do an Anglican one !
Putting Gottschalk of Orabis on the list of people who believed Predestination is not a good look. He was condemned for his view of the Atonement. A much better source would have been the Church of Lyon during that time, who basically just said the Lombardian formula to correct one of Gottschalk's opponents who said Christ died for all equally. John Davenant's "On the Death of Christ," has a whole chapter talking about this controversy, which is related to Predestination, and gives a list of various theologians who are way more orthodox than Gottschalk. Great video though!
His entire channel be like
I sure could’ve used this on my pca history ordination exam.
I am Presbyterian and I approve this message.
I love learning Christian history !!!!
14:30 "anyone who's pro slavery is utterly condemned by owning another man that which no man is appointed to rule but God and the God ordained government, but not as chattel to the slaver and his abominable treatment on his fellow man" Noah T. Pritchett 2024