I'm of course, very impressed by the pianist. But I'm also impressed with whoever tuned the piano to make it out-of-tune just enough to sound like it'd been not tuned for a while, but still basically musically sound. I doubt that's easy.
Good point, Jim! As a former piano tuner, I think it's mostly Hollywood magic. The temperament on the piano from the audio is good, and purposefully so. You have a good ear, and you're right! The unisons are slightly de-tuned to make it realistic. That wouldn't be hard for a tuner. But, had the tuner made the temperament out of tune even slightly, it would've been a challenge to not fight what they hear, and I think it would've made the piano sound worse than they would've liked. I'm sure they wanted it to sound beautiful enough to capture the humanity without wrecking the scene. To be realistic, the piano wouldn't have been tuned in months. The freezing room would've caused the wood on the piano to contract causing the wires to contract and deviate from its standard tuning so far that even a monotone would hear it. The character's performance would have been played imperfectly because no one of any caliber can play that without warming up, and with freezing fingers. Hollywood magic. We just have to consider the essence of what's being presented in the scene without the need to be too realistic. :)
With a large enough movie budget you could just purchase a piano, put it in an apartment/house like this one, start a world war and genocide and allow time to take its toll on the piano ever so slightly.
I both agree and disagree with this comment. The piano may be out of tune on purpose, but I think they did it to make it sound like a piano made in the early 20th century. You know, the piano didn't always sound as smooth as it does today.
To me, this is by far the best scene in the whole film. To see the German officer being so moved by Szpilman's out-of-this-world piano skills gives me goosebumps. Everything that lies behind is so meaningful: not only do you get the obvious sympathy for Szpilman and his horrible situation, being under circumstances that are so strange for an accomplished musician that used to live a comfortable life; you also feel unexpectedly sympathetic towards a Nazi officer (yes! A Nazi officer indeed!) because you get to see that, after all, he's also human. You get a little hope, despite everything that was going on during those very dark times, that in the end, there is something good inside all of us that can be sparked by, in this case, music, which is, as this scene shows, a universal language that can transcend every conceivable boundary. A true masterpiece.
Wilm Hosenfeld saved many jews during WWII and recieved the "Righteous among nations"(Award by Yad Vashem, an institute that preserves the jewish memorial) award after his death, so i dont think its really right to call him a "Nazi officer"
@@filouteries But terminology dont really matter to be honest, idk why i am making such a big deal of it. It is very nice that you acknowledge him as a hero
The fact that Adrien Brody learnt how to play piano for this movie. Hats off to him. (But he didn't play the ballad by himself though, it's CGI and was played by pianist Janusz)
In his real life when he was in front of the situation, he didn't play this piece and instead played Chopin's Nocturne in C# Minor No 20. He was able to show his musical prowess and that the beauty of music is unbounded. This same phenomenon also happened during wars where two opposing sides were temporarily united through the touch of music.
The desolation in knowing that this one wonderful human being only survived because of this unique skill. So many others perished, "we will remember them".
The german soldier didn't have intention to kill him. It wasn't because of the pianist skill neither because he played like that. They were losing the war already but the german could have been one of the few good ones.
@@SimonZimmermann82 You are correct that we cannot know and name the "untold" millions who were willfully murdered. We only know the few. I have no right to offer an opinion, I will do my best to honour and respect them.
It's eerie seeing how he goes from being a frozen and half starved to death man to looking like the true pianist he was before the war. Just compare 0:05 to 1:36
This scene made me know and remember forever a human being, his sweet soul and his name: Wilhelm Adalbert Hosenfeld. May your memory last forever in our hearts 💛 and inspire us.
Gods angels come in many ways and forms. This Officer saved his life and he in turn inspired many others including me with his courage and talented musical gift . Keep Aiming High Always
How to keep the music playing when all but life is dead… a testimony to the resilience of the human soul despite the genocidal torture of the human body. An enactment of that kind of courage.
Graças a Deus ele sobreviveu!! Se casou, teve filhos e netos! Faleceu bem velho no ano 2000. O oficial alemão que o ajudou, foi preso e morreu na prisão nos anos 50. Mais tarde ele foi condecorado com a medalha Justo entre as nações...na presença dos filhos e netos do pianista.
Война нужна Вове-Обнулёнышу, чтобы отвлечь россиян от внутрироссийских проблем. Но война не скрыла проблемы России, а показала всю гниль, накопившуюся за 22 года.
Spillman was playing Chopin when Germans bombed Warsaw, during Polish Radio broadcast of Spillman, and interrupted his broadcast. When the War ended, he resumed playing Nocturne in C-Sharp Major, where he left off. Sad. tragic part of Wilm Hosenfeld, the Geman Officer, never retuned to see his wife and kids; died in a Soviet prison concentration camp.
@@riograul2043 ure right, but i think other nazis did worse things and werent persecuted at all. Its not right. Some have been expatriated, and with new names started new lives... i feel nauseated
@@riograul2043 he was just a soldier like the French, the English, the Americans, fighting for his country. He was a Wehrmacht officer, not a nazi. Big difference ! I feel sorry for him, he should have been saved for what he did, instead he died in a Russian prisoner camp.
Это самая сильная сцена из фильма - финал: Жизнь- и Смертьнесущие начала встретились в момент, когда Жизнь победила, а Смерть, принесшая столько бед и разрушений, бежит, НО, потрясённая силой, скрытой в пианисте и этой музыке, останавливается и заставляет офицера задуматься "как я, Живой, Разумный человек, мог служить Смерти, как я мог забыть о прекрасном шансе, который дала Жизнь Всем людям?! "... Слава Украине и её Героям, пробуждающим зов Жизни и Разума в каждом человеке на Планете!💗🇺🇦💕 Господи 🙏 ЗАЩИТИ УКРАИНУ💗🙏
Un moment unique, un génie, un soldat d une armée monstrueuse. Une époque terrifiante. La beauté de la vie, la musique, chopin. Une larme , qu elle gâchis.
Escena de Antología el pianista mostrando su virtuosismo en un momento donde el frío , el hambre y la soledad lo acosaban pero aún así su amor a la música fue más importante. Estremecedora película en uno de los periodos más oscuro de la historia.
C'est une belle illusion , car il joue - très mal d'ailleurs et sans phrasé - les premières notes de ce magnifique opus 23 en sol mineur de CHOPIN.Comme il n'a pas vraiment le sens du rythme , il bouscule le triolet de croche si expressif après avoir écorché la montée à l'unisson de la phrase introductive.C'est intéressant de voir qu'il ne possède aucun sens technique , les mains n'ayant que très peu abordé cet aspect essentiel du piano.Je crois néanmoins qu'il pianote dans la vie... mais sans approfondir. La suite de la Ballade est un enregistrement de qualité.Pour les besoins du film , toute une partie du développement est sauté pour arriver à la Coda qui est le passage le plus périlleux de cette oeuvre.Dans l'ensemble l'acteur - qui est excellent dans ce rôle difficile - fait assez bien illusion au piano...si ce n'est qu'il eût été impossible au pianiste , dont le film retrace la vie , de pouvoir jouer cette Ballade de CHOPIN après autant de temps passé sans travailler sa technique et dans l'état d'affaiblissement physique où il s'était réellement trouvé.Ce n'est pas l'oeuvre qu'il joua devint l'officier allemand , mais le Rondo en ré Majeur de MOZART. Il eut été merveilleux qu'il retrouvât cet officier une fois les hostilités passées.Hélas , il apprit que celui-ci mourut quelques années plus tard en Sibérie et il regretta de n'avoir pu l'aider à son tour. Une histoire profondément bouleversante et vraie que le film de POLANSKY retrace avec fidélité. Lionel VIGNERESSE.
Il a certes appris mais ce n'est pas lui joue la ballade en totalité^^ (hormis le début). Cette pièce est musicalement compliqué et certains y passent des années avant de rendre une belle on copie
Фильм потрясающий и очень тяжёлый ! Это так страшно - война !!! Сейчас слушать без слёз не могла (( The movie is amazing and very heavy! It's so scary - war!!! Now I couldn't listen without crying ((
He had no choice his life depended on it.......even though scared, cold, hungry, and tired music was his passion he missed playing so much that he did a phenomenal job.....again his life was on the line and he chose to survive.
Acho que na vida real ele deve ter tocado bem. Apesar da fome, frio, dor e medo ao ver a morte, ali diante dele, nesse momento, ele reuniu todas as forças e transferiu para o piano, que mesmo meio desafinado, tocou o coração do algoz e foi salvo pela música!
Отличный фильм.И молодец Полански, что показал, правду-кто на самом деле освободил поляков и евреев от зверства нацистской Германии.Европу от фашистов освободил СССР! Советский солдат! А у нас пленные немцы построили целый район города!
Whaat, I thought someone else played that part instead of him. He surely practiced a lot of months to reach that level and he probably had knowledge how to play piano because it would take 2-3 (even a lot more) years of piano experiencie to play Ballade N.1 like that unlees he is a prodigy
@@beshepman7963 he played the intro no doubt but then his face and hands are never shown together which is understandable because this piece is hard. Very very hard to play that well
I'm wondering why @Thomas Kretschmann didn't get any Oscar, Palm, or Globe until now. Starring all notable german officer roles, unbeatable acting even when he's just listening to the music...
A most moving juxtaposition. The starving Jewish concert pianist and the Nazi officer reflecting on the monstrous insanity of what his allegiance has destroyed.
@@AlexanderGrodskij Maybe, but to serve as a Nazi officer was to promote the Holocaust. One has to wonder, if that Jewish pianist had been a Jewish car mechanic would the Nazi officer had shot him? Clearly the pianist spoke to a higher aspect of the Nazi officer, but respect for innocent human life should not be filtered through a person's aesthetic values.
@@GnomicMaster We know the answer because we know who that Nazi officer was. He saved more people, not only Szpilman. May be what you say was the interpretation in the film but the reality was different.
One of my favorite movie. He is such a beautyfull man, the sincerety through his eyes. So fragile and strong. In the Light rises hope in humanity when fly the notes breaking the cold and make explode the precious of life facing death in the emptiness of the mad powers. As Angel kills In a peacefull fights the Evil
Meiner Meinung nach nimmt das Hören dieser ausgeschnittenen Melodie leise Positionen ein, durchbricht allmählich die Belagerung des Feindes, verwaltet das Leben der Menschen im Inneren und zerstört schließlich die Burg und stellt sie wieder in ein ruhiges Land dar. Es fühlte sich wie eine Bühne an, zu der man zurückkehren kann. Ich denke, es spiegelt die moderne Welt wider, dass die schöne und schöne Melodie weggeworfen und die Geschichte gesponnen wird. Pianisten haben eine große Sensibilität und Technik.☺️
Qué gran película , Éste soldado alemán aprecio la buena música del polaco judío y lo ayudo ... Luego se tornaron las cosas y el soldado alemán fue a un campo de concentración y el pianista intento ayudarlo , pero ya no pudo o un traslado o la muerte . Lo qué más asco me da que entre seres humanos pudiera pasar esa miserable injusticia , cuándo muchos eran judíos ... Y cómo aún hoy muchos no reconocen el holocausto y los miles y miles de crímenes y experimentos que hacían con mujeres , niños , hombres , ancianos , no tenían corazón , estaban locos , locos de poder y gloria ... Qué no se vuelva a repetir otro loco anda suelto
I so dislike my German country. For the part they played in the Human History of the World. Shalom Shalachem Brothers and Sisters. And those who deny this history including our 45th. Have no idea what they are talking off. I miss my friend Ellie Wiesel.
Please do not dislike your country. Yes, what happened was horrible. It’s important to remember you can’t be held accountable for Germany’s past history. But you can learn from it and make sure it does not happen again. My ancestors owned slaves and I am absolutely ashamed of that part of my family’s history. So I make sure I do not judge people by the color of their skin. I hope in my small way that I can make up for the sins of my ancestors.
Oh and the propaganda taught to you your cultural marxist schools has made you a history expert? Likely not given the very stupid first statement you wrote. Ask yourself this: who does it service to hold Germany done by making it''s people guilty for eternity? Why is it that basic facts can't be disputed about that time? Who doesn't let you questions them? If those questions gave answers different than what you've been told, what happens next? Don't be stupid your whole life Angelika. Those German soldiers were trying to save you from the barbarians at the gate and all you can do is live off of government benefits and complain.
@@mocuishle1028 Exactly. All this generational blaming has gone way too far. A person living now is not responsible for what their ancestors did/did not do. God does not judge people like this so neither should we.
@Angelika Bertrand I lived in your country for 10 years. I have never expected Germans to learn from history to that extent as I saw... People were absolutely embarrassed to speak about history. Felt responsible. I found little reminders of Jewish history on the streets, galleries, pathwalks, buildings. Schools visit c.camps. Exemplary! I was actually proud of you, well done! I like germans a lot, literally loove your language and certailny loove your mentality! You have every right to be a proud German! (in a good way,of course😉)
I remember that scene from 20 years ago. For some reason I didn't remember which piece was played, which I should have. The improbable thing is that the piano was not years out of tune and the sound is well engineered.
Check this out: ua-cam.com/video/tlkzmcVy15s/v-deo.html
imagine playing that well with cold hands
For real
That’s what I was thinking bruh
Its unreal)
Ahaha i was thrilling the same
Imagine the piano sounding that good after having sat for any length of time in a cold, damp warehouse.
I'm of course, very impressed by the pianist. But I'm also impressed with whoever tuned the piano to make it out-of-tune just enough to sound like it'd been not tuned for a while, but still basically musically sound. I doubt that's easy.
That's a very good point!
One way is to tighten/loosen strings by 1/8th of an interval randomly
Good point, Jim! As a former piano tuner, I think it's mostly Hollywood magic. The temperament on the piano from the audio is good, and purposefully so. You have a good ear, and you're right! The unisons are slightly de-tuned to make it realistic. That wouldn't be hard for a tuner. But, had the tuner made the temperament out of tune even slightly, it would've been a challenge to not fight what they hear, and I think it would've made the piano sound worse than they would've liked. I'm sure they wanted it to sound beautiful enough to capture the humanity without wrecking the scene. To be realistic, the piano wouldn't have been tuned in months. The freezing room would've caused the wood on the piano to contract causing the wires to contract and deviate from its standard tuning so far that even a monotone would hear it. The character's performance would have been played imperfectly because no one of any caliber can play that without warming up, and with freezing fingers. Hollywood magic. We just have to consider the essence of what's being presented in the scene without the need to be too realistic. :)
With a large enough movie budget you could just purchase a piano, put it in an apartment/house like this one, start a world war and genocide and allow time to take its toll on the piano ever so slightly.
I both agree and disagree with this comment. The piano may be out of tune on purpose, but I think they did it to make it sound like a piano made in the early 20th century. You know, the piano didn't always sound as smooth as it does today.
To me, this is by far the best scene in the whole film. To see the German officer being so moved by Szpilman's out-of-this-world piano skills gives me goosebumps. Everything that lies behind is so meaningful: not only do you get the obvious sympathy for Szpilman and his horrible situation, being under circumstances that are so strange for an accomplished musician that used to live a comfortable life; you also feel unexpectedly sympathetic towards a Nazi officer (yes! A Nazi officer indeed!) because you get to see that, after all, he's also human. You get a little hope, despite everything that was going on during those very dark times, that in the end, there is something good inside all of us that can be sparked by, in this case, music, which is, as this scene shows, a universal language that can transcend every conceivable boundary. A true masterpiece.
Wilm Hosenfeld saved many jews during WWII and recieved the "Righteous among nations"(Award by Yad Vashem, an institute that preserves the jewish memorial) award after his death, so i dont think its really right to call him a "Nazi officer"
@@DomFileoreum well, that’s what he was. A nazi officer, and a hero that saved jews.
@@filouteries Nazi is an ideology, while german is a nationality. They are completly different.
@@filouteries But terminology dont really matter to be honest, idk why i am making such a big deal of it. It is very nice that you acknowledge him as a hero
The fact that Adrien Brody learnt how to play piano for this movie. Hats off to him.
(But he didn't play the ballad by himself though, it's CGI and was played by pianist Janusz)
Not sure I understand what you mean. His hands are computer-generated?
@@hetmanjz Not exactly. They swapped his hands out with a pianist.
@@MrNigeltree Of course that makes more sense than saying "it's CGI," which was probably just awkward phrasing on the OP's part.
In his real life when he was in front of the situation, he didn't play this piece and instead played Chopin's Nocturne in C# Minor No 20.
He was able to show his musical prowess and that the beauty of music is unbounded.
This same phenomenon also happened during wars where two opposing sides were temporarily united through the touch of music.
Война- чудовище, пожирающее всех без разбора. Я плакала по пианисту и по спасшему его офицеру. Господи, пошли мир на землю!
Amen
Amen.
Пока Вова-Обнулёныш отдаёт приказы - добра не будет. Агония Обнулёныша слишком дорого обойдётся всему Миру
Ámen
Оба -человеки , с большой буквы.
The desolation in knowing that this one wonderful human being only survived because of this unique skill. So many others perished, "we will remember them".
The german soldier didn't have intention to kill him. It wasn't because of the pianist skill neither because he played like that. They were losing the war already but the german could have been one of the few good ones.
Indeed, as a Gentile, I urge all other Gentiles to never forget
@@caezarlapuc8627 thanks for correcting him.
No, we won't. We only remember those who make it into a story, stored in zeros and ones in a cloud of Amazon Netflix and Microsoft
@@SimonZimmermann82 You are correct that we cannot know and name the "untold" millions who were willfully murdered. We only know the few. I have no right to offer an opinion, I will do my best to honour and respect them.
It's eerie seeing how he goes from being a frozen and half starved to death man to looking like the true pianist he was before the war. Just compare 0:05 to 1:36
Thomas Kretschmann’s moving expression enhances this superb scene. Excellent actor.
Он плачет. Этот немец. Плачет без слез. Слушая это исполнение..❤
This scene made me know and remember forever a human being, his sweet soul and his name: Wilhelm Adalbert Hosenfeld. May your memory last forever in our hearts 💛 and inspire us.
Gods angels come in many ways and forms. This Officer saved his life and he in turn inspired many others including me with his courage and talented musical gift . Keep Aiming High Always
❤ The officer himself died in the Soviet camp. His name was Wilm Hosenfeld.
Какой благородный человек офицер! Видно высокообразованный, воспитанный и богобоязненный! Прекрасный фильм, прекрасные люди, прекрасный Шопен!
Доброе утро.. Не могу вспомнить название фильма.. Подскажите пожалуйста.. Пианист?
@@МаринаКоновалова-г7в фильм называется «Пианист»
Everybody gangsta until chopin starts being played
Adrian Brody has an amazingly translucent nose.
How to keep the music playing when all but life is dead… a testimony to the resilience of the human soul despite the genocidal torture of the human body. An enactment of that kind of courage.
Graças a Deus ele sobreviveu!! Se casou, teve filhos e netos! Faleceu bem velho no ano 2000. O oficial alemão que o ajudou, foi preso e morreu na prisão nos anos 50.
Mais tarde ele foi condecorado com a medalha Justo entre as nações...na presença dos filhos e netos do pianista.
I had no knowledge about this. Thank you for providing such bittersweet closure.
Боже зачем война, жизнь так хрупка и так прекрасна. Священна. Любая жизнь. Как мы это допустили?!!!!
Не мы, а американские олигархи, которые зарабатывают на войне. Как тогда, так и сейчас
Война нужна Вове-Обнулёнышу, чтобы отвлечь россиян от внутрироссийских проблем. Но война не скрыла проблемы России, а показала всю гниль, накопившуюся за 22 года.
Spillman was playing Chopin when Germans bombed Warsaw, during Polish Radio broadcast of Spillman, and interrupted his broadcast. When the War ended, he resumed playing Nocturne in C-Sharp Major, where he left off. Sad. tragic part of Wilm Hosenfeld, the Geman Officer, never retuned to see his wife and kids; died in a Soviet prison concentration camp.
You reap what you sow
@@riograul2043 ure right, but i think other nazis did worse things and werent persecuted at all. Its not right. Some have been expatriated, and with new names started new lives... i feel nauseated
Is it known what happened to him? Clearly he was someone with humanity left in him, war is ugly and brutal.
@@riograul2043 he was just a soldier like the French, the English, the Americans, fighting for his country. He was a Wehrmacht officer, not a nazi. Big difference ! I feel sorry for him, he should have been saved for what he did, instead he died in a Russian prisoner camp.
@@micheladerry5681 he was not a nazi, just a Wehrmacht officer fighting for his country. The nazis wore black uniforms.
I actually like his phrasing for the beginning part. You can notice good acting and music art are related
his phrasing wasn’t good, but it is impressive that he learned it.
@@jonathanDstrandhis phrasing was good but it was not the actor playing it
Это самая сильная сцена из фильма - финал: Жизнь- и Смертьнесущие начала встретились в момент, когда Жизнь победила, а Смерть, принесшая столько бед и разрушений, бежит, НО, потрясённая силой, скрытой в пианисте и этой музыке, останавливается и заставляет офицера задуматься "как я, Живой, Разумный человек, мог служить Смерти, как я мог забыть о прекрасном шансе, который дала Жизнь Всем людям?! "... Слава Украине и её Героям, пробуждающим зов Жизни и Разума в каждом человеке на Планете!💗🇺🇦💕 Господи 🙏 ЗАЩИТИ УКРАИНУ💗🙏
Un moment unique, un génie, un soldat d une armée monstrueuse. Une époque terrifiante. La beauté de la vie, la musique, chopin. Une larme , qu elle gâchis.
ШЕДЕВР -ФИЛЬМ , ШЕДЕВР -ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ ! НАСТОЯЩЕЕ ИСКУССТВО , ВСЕГДА ПОБЕЖДАЕТ!
Music saved his life. 🌹
True
That german officer used to rescue jews, i don't remember his name but their story is real.
I just remember, Wilm Hosenfeld.
Died without any regonision for his deed
It's incorrect. The general would have saved him regardless. As he did with so many Jewish men at the time.
Escena de Antología el pianista mostrando su virtuosismo en un momento donde el frío , el hambre y la soledad lo acosaban pero aún así su amor a la música fue más importante. Estremecedora película en uno de los periodos más oscuro de la historia.
Humanidade sem Deus 🙏🇧🇷
The two extremes of the human condition, sublime creativity and heartless destruction.
La mejor escena del pianista. Memorable los dos ,algo inolvidable
Один из самых пронзительных моментов. Спасибо❤️
Una de las escenas más épicas del cine mundial....emocionante sin dudas ... La adoro
Il regista,oltre a farmi conoscere questa opera ci ha trascinati in una emozione miracolosa
А для меня, самая большая боль, - это боль немецкого офицера!!!! Взгляните на его лицо и руки!! И вы поймёте, что такое настоящее страдание!!!
La bella música le salvó la vida. Gracias por compartirla.
I only wish they had played the entire ballade. ❤
Music is the tongue of God...out of this tragedy and atrocity will blossom the tunes of life and compassion..music heals
The tongue? Not sure of that.
@@maxdominate2481 a figure of speech dear..it s ages long by Confucius
C'est une belle illusion , car il joue - très mal d'ailleurs et sans phrasé - les premières notes de ce magnifique opus 23 en sol mineur de CHOPIN.Comme il n'a pas vraiment le sens du rythme , il bouscule le triolet de croche si expressif après avoir écorché la montée à l'unisson de la phrase introductive.C'est intéressant de voir qu'il ne possède aucun sens technique , les mains n'ayant que très peu abordé cet aspect essentiel du piano.Je crois néanmoins qu'il pianote dans la vie... mais sans approfondir.
La suite de la Ballade est un enregistrement de qualité.Pour les besoins du film , toute une partie du développement est sauté pour arriver à la Coda qui est le passage le plus périlleux de cette oeuvre.Dans l'ensemble l'acteur - qui est excellent dans ce rôle difficile - fait assez bien illusion au piano...si ce n'est qu'il eût été impossible au pianiste , dont le film retrace la vie , de pouvoir jouer cette Ballade de CHOPIN après autant de temps passé sans travailler sa technique et dans l'état d'affaiblissement physique où il s'était réellement trouvé.Ce n'est pas l'oeuvre qu'il joua devint l'officier allemand , mais le Rondo en ré Majeur de MOZART.
Il eut été merveilleux qu'il retrouvât cet officier une fois les hostilités passées.Hélas , il apprit que celui-ci mourut quelques années plus tard en Sibérie et il regretta de n'avoir pu l'aider à son tour.
Une histoire profondément bouleversante et vraie que le film de POLANSKY retrace avec fidélité.
Lionel VIGNERESSE.
one of the best scene. just beautiful. that out of tune piano makes it so real. like he is in the room. and this german oficer is handsome.
Inolvidable escena, , la música sanadora del alma
Difficile de ne pas être émue par ce passage bravo à cet acteur qui a appris à jouer du piano pour tenir ce rôle
Il a certes appris mais ce n'est pas lui joue la ballade en totalité^^ (hormis le début). Cette pièce est musicalement compliqué et certains y passent des années avant de rendre une belle on copie
Cada vez que la veo me sigue impresionando igual que la primera
Спасибо большое! Беларусь.
Артист ,играющий немца великолепен
Он немец и есть. Томас Кретчман.
A melhor parte do filme. Chego a arrepiar.
This movie is wonderful. Such great acting and direction.
Фильм потрясающий и очень тяжёлый ! Это так страшно - война !!! Сейчас слушать без слёз не могла (( The movie is amazing and very heavy! It's so scary - war!!! Now I couldn't listen without crying ((
Потрясающий фильм и актёры.Всегда смотрю и плачу
He had no choice his life depended on it.......even though scared, cold, hungry, and tired music was his passion he missed playing so much that he did a phenomenal job.....again his life was on the line and he chose to survive.
Ci saranno sempre 'persone buone' e la musica è il 'catalizzatore' che unisce gli esseri umani...
Heart wrenching...powerful
Geniusz Chopina.......
Heh.......
Polska🇵🇱
Замечательный фильм.
Актеры-супер.
🎶музыка вечна-Шопен.
Фильм потрясающий!!!!
Браво!!!
The look in the German's face reflects the thought "How many more Szpilman's have we destroyed amongst the Jews ?".
So beautiful music is universal the language of love touches the heart….
One of the greatest movies ever...
Acho que na vida real ele deve ter tocado bem. Apesar da fome, frio, dor e medo ao ver a morte, ali diante dele, nesse momento, ele reuniu todas as forças e transferiu para o piano, que mesmo meio desafinado, tocou o coração do algoz e foi salvo pela música!
He truly was an elite among people of his time
Отличный фильм.И молодец Полански, что показал, правду-кто на самом деле освободил поляков и евреев от зверства нацистской Германии.Европу от фашистов освободил СССР! Советский солдат! А у нас пленные немцы построили целый район города!
Fun fact : the actor of Szpilman took piano lessons with a piano teacher for playing this scene himself !
That's really interesting!
Well unless he took piano lessons for at least 8 years he wouldn't be able to play any Chopin ballade that well
Whaat, I thought someone else played that part instead of him.
He surely practiced a lot of months to reach that level and he probably had knowledge how to play piano because it would take 2-3 (even a lot more) years of piano experiencie to play Ballade N.1 like that unlees he is a prodigy
@@beshepman79638 years ??? Nah bro you are tripping you can learn piano in less than a year and to a very high lvl
@@beshepman7963 he played the intro no doubt but then his face and hands are never shown together which is understandable because this piece is hard. Very very hard to play that well
Эпизод с балладой-фантастика.
Esta cena do filme é muito emocionante. O filme é muito bom. Já o assisti várias vezes.
Thật cảm động. Âm nhạc đã kết nối trái tim của hai con người. Mặc dù vị trí của họ khác nhau. Tuyệt vời
Such a great movie...very sad of what he went through irl and survived
Um dos melhores filmes que já assisti!
UA-cam reminding me that I had a crush on Thomas Kretschmann.
Национальность -милосердие !
I'm wondering why @Thomas Kretschmann didn't get any Oscar, Palm, or Globe until now. Starring all notable german officer roles, unbeatable acting even when he's just listening to the music...
Was für ein beeindruckender Film..... Mein Herz schmerzt.
Тяжёлое, великое кино о замечательном человеке, пианисте.
Играет, как последний раз.Он не знал, что можно ожидать от нацистского офицера
My heart is aching.🙏🙏🙏
Cudna scena z humanistycznym przesłaniem...
Poza tym muzyka Wojciecha Kilara (nie tylko do tego filmu) genialna...
A most moving juxtaposition. The starving Jewish concert pianist and the Nazi officer reflecting on the monstrous insanity of what his allegiance has destroyed.
This was not an ordinary nazi officer. He wrote in his diary: I save everybody I only can.
@@AlexanderGrodskij Maybe, but to serve as a Nazi officer was to promote the Holocaust. One has to wonder, if that Jewish pianist had been a Jewish car mechanic would the Nazi officer had shot him? Clearly the pianist spoke to a higher aspect of the Nazi officer, but respect for innocent human life should not be filtered through a person's aesthetic values.
@@GnomicMaster We know the answer because we know who that Nazi officer was. He saved more people, not only Szpilman. May be what you say was the interpretation in the film but the reality was different.
@@AlexanderGrodskij Again, maybe so, but what did the swastika represent?
@@GnomicMaster we know that too. In general you right, but that particular man was a good man.
최고의 명장면!!!!
One of my favorite movie. He is such a beautyfull man, the sincerety through his eyes. So fragile and strong. In the Light rises hope in humanity when fly the notes breaking the cold and make explode the precious of life facing death in the emptiness of the mad powers. As Angel kills In a peacefull fights the Evil
Essa parte foi linda!
Tout est beau et aussi l'officier allemand
"I am...
... I was a pianist."
Highly recommend this movie. Adrien Brody is brilliant!
if you saw the movie and know the story about Wladyslaw Szpilman during the WW2 this will be very touching
Великолепный фильм!
Кто исполняет в фильме Шопена? Мощно и очень талантливо сыграно🔥🔥🔥
Януш Олейничак-талантливо!!!
@@user-iy6zj8uq4n Януш прекрасно сыграл, очень глубоко ❤️
@@Nmarfa а главное по-шопеновски-романтично.
Gerçek bir hikayeden alınmış muhteşem bir filmleri muzik dinlediğim en iyi ork 😊
Fantastic! I put part of this in a short I did.
Meiner Meinung nach nimmt das Hören dieser ausgeschnittenen Melodie leise Positionen ein, durchbricht allmählich die Belagerung des Feindes, verwaltet das Leben der Menschen im Inneren und zerstört schließlich die Burg und stellt sie wieder in ein ruhiges Land dar. Es fühlte sich wie eine Bühne an, zu der man zurückkehren kann.
Ich denke, es spiegelt die moderne Welt wider, dass die schöne und schöne Melodie weggeworfen und die Geschichte gesponnen wird.
Pianisten haben eine große Sensibilität und Technik.☺️
This clip would’ve been better if it included the pianist getting discovered and the German officer telling him to play it. Thanks for the upload!
This reminds me of the Japanese proverb, “芸は身を助く”, which means “Art brings bread.”
Favourite scene
Uno dei più toccanti e precisi film sull'ascesa del Nazismo. La sua follia che pian piano prende il posto della realtà consueta. Brody eccezionale.
Qué gran película , Éste soldado alemán aprecio la buena música del polaco judío y lo ayudo ... Luego se tornaron las cosas y el soldado alemán fue a un campo de concentración y el pianista intento ayudarlo , pero ya no pudo o un traslado o la muerte . Lo qué más asco me da que entre seres humanos pudiera pasar esa miserable injusticia , cuándo muchos eran judíos ... Y cómo aún hoy muchos no reconocen el holocausto y los miles y miles de crímenes y experimentos que hacían con mujeres , niños , hombres , ancianos , no tenían corazón , estaban locos , locos de poder y gloria ... Qué no se vuelva a repetir otro loco anda suelto
I so dislike my German country. For the part they played in the Human History of the World. Shalom Shalachem Brothers and Sisters. And those who deny this history including our 45th. Have no idea what they are talking off. I miss my friend Ellie Wiesel.
Please do not dislike your country. Yes, what happened was horrible. It’s important to remember you can’t be held accountable for Germany’s past history. But you can learn from it and make sure it does not happen again. My ancestors owned slaves and I am absolutely ashamed of that part of my family’s history. So I make sure I do not judge people by the color of their skin. I hope in my small way that I can make up for the sins of my ancestors.
Oh and the propaganda taught to you your cultural marxist schools has made you a history expert? Likely not given the very stupid first statement you wrote. Ask yourself this: who does it service to hold Germany done by making it''s people guilty for eternity? Why is it that basic facts can't be disputed about that time? Who doesn't let you questions them? If those questions gave answers different than what you've been told, what happens next? Don't be stupid your whole life Angelika. Those German soldiers were trying to save you from the barbarians at the gate and all you can do is live off of government benefits and complain.
@@mocuishle1028 Exactly. All this generational blaming has gone way too far. A person living now is not responsible for what their ancestors did/did not do. God does not judge people like this so neither should we.
@Angelika Bertrand I lived in your country for 10 years. I have never expected Germans to learn from history to that extent as I saw... People were absolutely embarrassed to speak about history. Felt responsible. I found little reminders of Jewish history on the streets, galleries, pathwalks, buildings. Schools visit c.camps. Exemplary! I was actually proud of you, well done! I like germans a lot, literally loove your language and certailny loove your mentality! You have every right to be a proud German! (in a good way,of course😉)
I remember that scene from 20 years ago. For some reason I didn't remember which piece was played, which I should have. The improbable thing is that the piano was not years out of tune and the sound is well engineered.
There are cut and paste on score obviously for film timing
It is strange that even in artistworld many became dying sick,or adodoty like Chopin, when Rubinstein, he lived
❤Chopin❤
That Coda 😮
Браво!
Actor very good in this. And in Peaky Blinders…🍻🎶
Conmovedora secuencia de esta película, sublime música, gananando la batalla de la estupidez y rivalidad humana
感動 我❤心深處；touched my heart
Wielki film Polańskiego.