As someone who's also 100% completed the event, I agree; Roblox cares more about the games that are popular than the games that want to put as much love in them as possible and the ACTUAL classic games; don't get me wrong, the developers for The Classic's games tried, but there are tons of other talented developers who could've made something a lot less tedious; I can imagine these spots were contested though
Agreed, however there is a low chance that Roblox will do something to make their players happy, as they most likely will do the things that other popular games have been successful with. And I don’t wonder why, it’s very profitable.
Games that should have been in the classic 1. Epic Minigames 2. Natural Disaster Survival 3. Murder Mystery 2 4. Work At A Pizza Place 5. Flood Escape 6. Theme Park Tycoon 2 edit: since everyone's been saying it: 7. Speed Run 4
Fun fact, I did manage to finish the bedwars mode solo easily. ..by letting the bed die and then making a platform over the void and waiting a solid 70mins for the penguins to essentially attempt to reach me each round, failing, and falling into the void. I tried even longer clearing it with other people, and figured this cheese method was the only way to get it over with. 0/10 for that trash fest
Bee swarm really did a good job with their event they took the game "Revenge of the slimes" a old popular game made by the same people who made build a boat and turned it into something really cool. The games that actually put a lot of effort in their game have my high respects Arsenal, A dusty trip, and bee swarm are all amazing
i literally ignored arsenal telling me to bring a friend with me and soloed it , but it was so painful and took me like an hour and a half (i was able to find a skip at the flood part by rocket jumping but using rpg after getting it made it much harder especially when i had the gatling gun , i picked up the rpg by accident)
Thing is: ROBLOX feels "worse" because it's becoming more and more corporate and synthetized. You cannot feel the intention, response, effort, or human input through the ROBLOX platform anymore. Ever wonder why "Catalog" is now "Marketplace" and "Games" are now "Experiences"? They're shortening their own bridges from games to reality for the novelty, and the money. Edit: People keep replying about the fact that "Marketplace" and "Experiences" are about ROBLOX's lawsuits regarding its site. As if I don't know? And? And what? It changes nothing about my statement. The message is that greed empowers wrath, and wrath empowers greed. The past is home-made, the future is synthetized.
Roblox needs the money for profits. If Roblox didn't make profits, they couldn't keep running. They need to maintain servers, pay staff, pay premium payouts and developers, and the list continues. Roblox is doing this for the better, otherwise there will be no more Roblox.
Welcome to late capitalism. Sooner or later, every business or company that was started with passion and integrity becomes a soulless, corporate machine with the sole intent of making money and pleasing shareholders. This same exact thing is happening in the movie industry, the AAA game industry, and so many others.
Whats funny is that BedWars penguin survival was literally also just completely reused code from their old gamemode from 2021 but they put studs on the blocks to make it "classic"
Well at least I am happy what they are now burning in the shadow realm and hopefully they will stay in it (getting 253 badges was a lot harder because of them)
Great video, I heavily agree with all the points you make about new events feeling rushed. Games are picked based on playtime and profitability rather than quality and theming. Also 1x1x1x1 being teased during rp2 nearly 4 years ago just for this event to end with a mediocre sword fight is awful You nailed the text to voice transition as well, great editing, and great content
Funny thing about the adopt me tix, I was so bored waiting for the teapot that I found them all without a guide, because I literally had the time to check anywhere. By the time I was done the teapot wasn't even a teen...
@@gamingdiamond168 well ı had fun doin it, ı understand why people love this game so much by playing this game, but if you didnt like it well thats your problem ı cant say anything
i completely agree with you. they hop on trends more than caring about what the really old members of the community want. which naturally makes sense bc at the end of the day they are trying to make the most money. you could obviously tell which selected games had actual effort put into them compared to others. for example doors was asked to particpate but they declined, not considered a classic game but being one of roblox's most popular games on its site it made sense. but if doors did accept im sure they would have made a fun and engaging classic event
Banger vid - the fact The Classic lobby still currently has 1k+ active players show how it easily is the best part of the event. Even after i 100%'d it, I stayed playing there for a bit, just having fun launching people into game portals, it's awesome. I hope there won't be that many of these events because don't really feel like doing one of these every 2-3 months; Egg Hunts being yearly made them a lot more special. Regarding the games, I'm surprised I did not find that many other people complaining about how most of them handled the Token / Tix system - to be honest the entire thing could've easily been about 50 badges total instead of 253/257 (the bling badges count torwards the number LOL). It's clear how there was no cohesion between the quests of the various games, with a lot of them just being tedious grinds. BTW, regarding 5:27; you AK collided with the killbot, making it turn so you ended up shooting yourself. Yeah, that can happen. It's stupid. (also the hiloh controversy was pretty much solved and i don't think that matters at all because the official roblox twitter account directly congratulated him for placing first in the other hunt)
These reasons are why I didn't buy the gold track for either of these. It just goes to show that there's no point in trying when the fight in "The Classic" is just a buffed up zombie AI boss. edit: also i managed to do the bed wars quest alone (played with randoms instead of my friends) and i feel like i only got really lucky here
The “new” Bedwars event is actually just a reuse of an event they had a few years ago, an exact copy with tix, it was also insanely hard back then. Me and my friend couldn’t to it, we basically had ptsd.
@@Thiago_GamesAnother thing about the older mode was that you weren’t just completely doomed if the bed broke. In the old mode, you could just run around the map getting emeralds and constantly buy speed pies to keep running. In this new mode, the penguins just become pretty much impossible to kill or even run away from as soon as your bed breaks.
Usually I play roblox events to 100% completion, but this one was different. The oldest event I can remember playing is Egg Hunt 2016 and ever since that I've at least attempted every major event. When this was announced, I was pretty excited since it looked promising and I was hoping it'd be better than The Hunt, so I came in with high expectations. Still with all the hype behind it, I waited for the first day to pass to read reviews and I was shocked at how disappointing it was. It was just an over glorified Hunt with less games. The items really weren't great, and the selection of games were strange for the genre of the event. I looked at the lobby a bit and was overwhelmed, so I went to go look at the games. First game I picked was Blade Ball since I figured it'd be easy, but it got really boring waiting for the boss to start so I went to driving empire and quit once I realized it was a massive grinding simulator. After that I just quit and honestly I'm happy I didn't go through with it. Disappointing event and I hope roblox learns a lesson from these past two events
You know it when Roblox picks "those popular games" for the event. Overall, gotta say this event is pretty rush (some excluded). Roblox didn't really took the criticism wholely. Same as this event which didn't completely resolve its foundback legacy and didn't reach our expectations. I really hope honestly, its better if its pushed off somewhere 5-7 months when The Hunt ended. They could really use some enough time with PASSION and CREATIVITY while organizing the event. Plus, this could render out the nostalgiabait that I HOPE they could just do it with passion like the past events that are not that hard to contemplate. And plus, we really dont have a problem being a 5-7 month of waiting the next edition. Like seriously 4 YEARS OF NO EVENT and still you survived, in some cases its affirmative! If it would be pushed off with more months, games that participated in the event will have the same output as A dusty trip and Arsenal (they start with A's so A for them!). And also Bee swarm simulator if considered. I think what we really expect is that we would be making LONG ADVENTURES and MADE FRIENDS ALONG THE WAY! The classic event said otherwise. We had small time for the event which we expect to live moments in the classic times LONGER. And they're in a great hustle with cheap and poor outputs and a tight deadline. This is why passion and creativity doesn't value here because nowadays, Roblox is hogging money, advert and make money as soon as possible. Clarifications are understood by mine and gotta say nonetheless, events are back, but they're not truly put out of creativity and putting tension into the event, its just "grind, repetitive tasks and collect tixes and tokens" thats it. I hope in the Third Edition (hope there is honestly), Roblox should read criticisms and expectations from people first before organizing and planning for an upcoming event. Although I nearly completed the event (248/257), I had some times of fun and the devs tried to put their game into the event as themeing and with high quality as possible (good for them), but really they should put some tension or set off some difficulties just for the event to be LIVELY again... And really for Roblox to be TRULY BACK LISTENING TO THE COMMUNITY, Just like the past egg hunts. And I hope Roblox sees the problem and learns a lesson.
I remember playing on a guest account in 2015, making my first account in 2016, losing that account and making another in 2018, forgetting the password and making the account i have today. I saw how the events roblox had has really changed.. i remember getting egg hats from games i didnt even know were part of it. and ngl i feel like the problems started to occur either after brick bronze's deletion or live-ops. most roblox games back then also had so much passion and effort put into them. now it feels like it's just super saturated and childish. it really pains to see how the platform changed for the worse.
hey someone with pretty much the same thing, my latest acc I think 2020 and I started at 2016. I remember playing a egg hunt as a guest, it was kind of cool, I liked it but then after a few cool games, it just died for me as either most games are infected with griefers or just banned like brick bronze. I just kinda wish roblox had actual care or a bit more than money wand more money
wtf same. like down to the exact year. i used to participate in events but more for fun and not to 100% them. i remember playing egg hunt 2018 and thinking it was really cool and i kinda regret not beating it, now i just 100% every event no matter how painful lol
@@TheGamer707. yeah everything pretty much went downhill after brick bronze's deletion. probably because roblox doesn't want their platform to be destroyed by copyright
20:46 This surprised me that Gary’s Theme was played here, it genuinely did. Also great video, solid analysis of the Classic Event too. Some I may have disgreed because I had a better/worse experience within that game, but overall it was a excellent video that went in depth of the Classic Event.
it's crazy that since the introduction of LiveOps in May 16th, 2019 (Roblox's first attempt at developer-based events) they still have faced the same issues as the Classic: Hunt did
My biggest problem with the classic was how long it went for. Not everyone on earth gets to use a computer for 5 hours a day, and i barely got one of the prizes 1 hour before the event finished
As a 2018-19 player when I first heard about the classic I thought they would have games like Natural disaster survival and work at a pizza place I was surprised by the games that were chosen on games I didn't expect.
In the 4 minute mark of the video, you basically just had the exact same opinion that I had about there being missed potential for the RoToken badges! Honestly, the idea of multiple objectives for each RoToken is very awesome, it's just that not every game did that route (which sucked). Even the games that had the best objectives in this event (like Arsenal for instance) still had this issue of a drawn out milestone completion award for the RoTokens. The most notable game for me is Bee Swarm Simulator, as I had a lot of fun playing that objective with my friends (so i didnt have to do it with randoms), and everything about the objective just felt nice. Except for the use of milestones for the RoToken stuff, i didnt like that cause it was used so much. You covered this event review video well by the way! Great editing and great ways of describing stuff about the event.
good video man, imo the tds one was the best game in the event (that I actually played) ofc I have a bit of bias bc i first tried everything except for map 3 which took 2 attempts
Eh tds was fine but it takes a lot of trial and error from new players as someone who has played tds for years, it was easy but for others I get it would be time taking
this has got to be one of the best videos I've ever seen.. the whole time i was legit shaking at how well i liked this and how much this correlated with this hunt on so many levels, the whole thing was chaos and everyone hated doing the event. everyone doing the event felt miserable except arsenal and bee swarm simulator.
love how 90% of the games in the *classic* event aren't even based on *classic* roblox seriously, toilet TDS? that's literally so recent it's insulting to the creators of actual content.
Sometimes I wonder if the tix and tokens mechanics ruined the event, I wonder that because some games got ruined like Blade Ball having a battle pass or Driving Empire needing 500 points for all tokens. Just because for you to get 15 things in one game.
ngl the hub was the best part of the event. I wish it was just the hub, but some games actually made fun challenges like bee swarm, arsenal and tds. Hopefully next time it is just a hub. (like egg hunt 2018)
Absolutely agree with everything. While i have not completed neither the hunt nor the classic, I didn't complete those because they were boring as HELL (at least i got the bucket hat) Roblox doesn't do quality checks and they only want big, successful games in their events so the outside of roblox thinks that they're very in touch with the community and doing a good job. I'm pretty sure some classic games even applied for the classic and were DENIED, which is honestly just insane. Some games were good (A Dusty Trip, Arsenal, BSS etc.), but most are just a shitfest meant to milk premium payouts out of the clueless premium players, that think these items would look good on them and that the completionist dream isn't masochism. also the lobby of the classic was genuinely the best part of the event, i had so much fun on that i can't lie all the quests were fun to do and even though i don't like games focused on minigames or general random doings meant to induce fun, this brought me back to the days when you could play stuff like epic minigames, murder mystery 2, flood escape 2 or flee the facility or etc. in 2018 and have fun for hours.
i really hope roblox makes another event like ready player 2. out of the few events i have played, (i only started participating in events during 2020 and by then events were already pretty bad) rp2 was my favorite one by far.
I know I'm lvl 300+ in TDS, but I found it too easy, the issue comes with the players who don't play TDS, they want it easy, but the people who do play it a lot, want it hard, so they went with some kind of medium between it.
I mean it's fair enough, i can see their points too. I'm a new player so playing this is extremely hard, map 3 took so long to beat and by the time i beat it i already have a sense of strategy to complete map 5. Overall it's reasonably hard (unlike bedwar, im still despise them so much), IF ONLY THEY ALLOW MULTIPLAYER IT WOULD BE SO GOOD. But anyway, good game, top 4 for me even tho i prefer the ttd quest bc its easier
Honestly, the classic event is an W event Toilet tower defense, was added which saved the event Toilet tower defense is the best tower defense game, the gameplay is so good, the graphics are as beautuful as sirius A's shine... playing toilet tower defense makes me cry of how much nostalgia from 2014 playing garrys mode, good old times... toilet tower defense is a place serene, beautiful as a galaxy andromeda... hope you get your deserved bloxy awards prize... Once i was with my dad on the top of a mountain, se was watching stars, seeing constellation. And one of the costellation was a toilet form! It was a signal! A signal of something gonna happen! And happened! Toilet tower defense got released and it was incriblely good! I started to play it everyday till now and i never stopped. Toilet tower defense is a masterpiece made my greek gods because of how majestic, beautiful and perfect. Playing it gives so much peace, makes me feel on a garden with birds singing and clean water... so much peace toilet tower defense give...
I just randomly found this guy and my opinion on him is his way of voicing in the video is classical and gives me interested vibes for some reason (i think its the editing) i love this man’s channel already. Im subbeddd
I don't see shockwave runners background footage in videos and seeing shockwave runners kind of shoked me. Anyways great video, and great background game footage choice.
thank you feo for sharing your opinion, however i find it strange that you included a 30 minute interlude where you just chanted "old roblox was better". odd choice but still a good video 👍
2:16 Oddly enough, that's the thing about larger platforms and games. I remember something I read that kind of fits with the current direction of things that said something along the lines of "games are not fun, they are engaging." And I say kind of, as not everyone is following this way of making things, but a majority are beginning to go this way.
on the same page as you in the earlier part of the video. joined on 8/11 2015, so my account will be 10 aswell soon. highschool gonna be crazy. i met so many friends in the period before the roblox logo changed from red and white. i can perfectly sing the xbox theme in my head, i remember playing innovation inc games on the xbox, i remember the egg hunts being a large part of the fun i got from roblox. so many large games from that period have changed their ways. roblox just doesnt have the fun it used to, so ive decided to try becoming a roblox game developer, maybe try to bring that nostalgia back in some way. roblox has been in my life for basically as long as i can remember. roblox just seems to be trying to get as realistic as possible, but back then they just wanted their players to have fun. i know i cant go back. i know itll just be memories. so if your reading it to this, dont be sad that you cant relive it, not only be happy that you experienced it, but also be happy that it may not be the end of the good times.
I’ve played adopt me before (yes sadly) and the teapot was literally just an adopt me pet with “CLASSIC” slapped onto it. Same aging system same everything.
the reason that the game selection is so bad is probably due to a lack of communication, you actually had to apply to get in so either nobody knew know or nobody applied
The dragon adventures quest is a HARD F because they basically force you to buy a radar by making the eggs take literal hours to find. Even if there's a way to find them, like rejoining, it's just... no... and same with driving empire or whatever...
tds' event was really good, but the big problem with it is that if you aren't aware of how to play it, so, i kind of went through it with ease (i'm level 286 :D )
this was one of the best roblox related videos ive seen after so long anyways you made me realize i am also with my account for over 10 years no wonder why im quitting
8:33 - Abstract Alex is amazing in my opinion, made SB1 and SB2 (sb2 was amazing but takes forever to farm later floors, but it should be that way), World Zero, and gave help to Defaltio, who made Lumber tycoon.
There was an official strat for the bedwars event that required everyone possible in the server to use specific kits (2 ice hammer guys 3 embers and a support) meaning that they knew it was overturned and even planned for it
I really expected FE2 to be in the event, im not gonna lie. Im playing that game from 2017, i really expected it to be there, Crazyblox would just cook it up. But we just got the same games as the hunt, but, atleast bss was there, im glad they gave chsnce to one of the classic games cook. However, i liked event. You can say its mid or bad, but, its wasnt bad or good, its was just like the hunt, pretty mid and awkward, but pretty fun and playable. Maybe Roblox will listen players in the next Event coming and give creators more time? We'll see.
I have never really completed both events which is sad but for a good reason since the hunt had to much games and it really overwhelmed me and i had school during that time and the classic despite it not having that much games unlike the hunt i never found it interesting i did complete one game though which is TDS since i was gaining intrest to that game again during that time and also these were the first event i participated in like EVER i think there were other events that had happened before those but i never participated in them at all really but im crossing my fingers and hoping the future events are gonna be really good ones since the classic felt less shittier than the hunt
As a 2008 player, I totally agree with everything said here. They stopped caring about their legacy and only care about games that make them popular and money. Tracing back to years ago, they would announce newly created games or just make events for fun on games that people didn't even know existed. I doubt that would ever happen now.
So to clear up some confusion on TDS the classic event. The maps are based off of very old maps from the beta state of the game and brought them back for nostalgia (the event was focused on the players that joined the game around 2019)
4:25 I agree with the message of the video. However, the key to start the car is in the top right in font size 36 or more. Idk how you missed that lol. Also, you can remove liquid from the gas tank by opening and tilting it down, causing it to spill out.
While I played the Classic Event I thought about some ACTUAL good games for the event. I think actual classic games would be way better to fit the theme and make it more fun than... toilet tower defense... Here's my list of potential additions (this is more than 15): - Bee Swarm (that was actually a good pick) - Doomspire Brickbattle - Epic Minigames - Super Bomb Survival - Treasure Hunt Simulator - Build a Boat For Treasure - Natural Disaster Survival - Fashion Famous - Adopt Me (also a decent pick) - Speedrun 4 - Jailbreak - Work At A Pizza Place - Find the Domos (the true original "Find the" game) - Be Crushed By a Speeding Wall - Weight Lifting Simulator - Flood Escape - Mining Simulator (the OG one, not the ripoffs) - Murder Mystery 2 If you have any other ideas let me know, I'll add them to the list
25:48 escape was one of my favorite games back in the day and honestly, the classic event might have been a little bit better if they added classic flood escape because it is an old game and a lot of people have played it since that time which I bet it would be able to make it into a pretty good part of the event.
The classic event was the most fun not because of the content but because during a dusty trip, the fuel broke and I spent a good hour going mach 2 abusing a bug
mic quality gets better later on btw i was still trying to figure it out while making this video
lol
your voice is nice
hi
i really like your voice. try to keep up the good work!
w video
As someone who's also 100% completed the event, I agree; Roblox cares more about the games that are popular than the games that want to put as much love in them as possible and the ACTUAL classic games; don't get me wrong, the developers for The Classic's games tried, but there are tons of other talented developers who could've made something a lot less tedious; I can imagine these spots were contested though
Yeah like toilet tower defense, his event was good
Agreed, however there is a low chance that Roblox will do something to make their players happy, as they most likely will do the things that other popular games have been successful with. And I don’t wonder why, it’s very profitable.
OMG IS THAT STARISM IN A FEODORIC VIDEO LETS GOO!!! However i must say that i agree with this opinion of yours.
Imagine if Michaels Zombies was in the event and did an Undead Coming game mode, that would be foret
It’s the ice man
Games that should have been in the classic
1. Epic Minigames
2. Natural Disaster Survival
3. Murder Mystery 2
4. Work At A Pizza Place
5. Flood Escape
6. Theme Park Tycoon 2
edit: since everyone's been saying it:
7. Speed Run 4
agree with everything but not mm2
mm2 to speed run 4
yeah
@@improbablyfur speed run 4 was created around the same time as mm2
6. Speed run 4.
Fun fact, I did manage to finish the bedwars mode solo easily.
..by letting the bed die and then making a platform over the void and waiting a solid 70mins for the penguins to essentially attempt to reach me each round, failing, and falling into the void.
I tried even longer clearing it with other people, and figured this cheese method was the only way to get it over with.
0/10 for that trash fest
*neuron activation*
That’s genius
Good thing that me and the 3 other apes are skilled enough to cheese this penguin wars of a game with our combined "hiveminds".
Bee swarm really did a good job with their event they took the game "Revenge of the slimes" a old popular game made by the same people who made build a boat and turned it into something really cool. The games that actually put a lot of effort in their game have my high respects Arsenal, A dusty trip, and bee swarm are all amazing
FINALLY someone who knows it's from RotS and it isn't just random slimes
arsenal made me kms and i didnt complete it because it was too impossible for me
@@D00MWatcher1 same. Big guy? Too much hp the conveyer? Too many enemies
NOW GET TO ROUND 20 hehahahahahahhehehahhahhehha
i literally ignored arsenal telling me to bring a friend with me and soloed it , but it was so painful and took me like an hour and a half (i was able to find a skip at the flood part by rocket jumping but using rpg after getting it made it much harder especially when i had the gatling gun , i picked up the rpg by accident)
Thing is: ROBLOX feels "worse" because it's becoming more and more corporate and synthetized.
You cannot feel the intention, response, effort, or human input through the ROBLOX platform anymore. Ever wonder why "Catalog" is now "Marketplace" and "Games" are now "Experiences"? They're shortening their own bridges from games to reality for the novelty, and the money.
Edit: People keep replying about the fact that "Marketplace" and "Experiences" are about ROBLOX's lawsuits regarding its site. As if I don't know?
And? And what? It changes nothing about my statement. The message is that greed empowers wrath, and wrath empowers greed.
The past is home-made, the future is synthetized.
Yea this is sadly true.
The world nowdays is like that, corps and the internet holding their hands together for the perfect dystopia. We are fucked dude.
Roblox needs the money for profits. If Roblox didn't make profits, they couldn't keep running. They need to maintain servers, pay staff, pay premium payouts and developers, and the list continues. Roblox is doing this for the better, otherwise there will be no more Roblox.
games are experiences for the apple scandal to not pay money by making games look like experiences
Welcome to late capitalism. Sooner or later, every business or company that was started with passion and integrity becomes a soulless, corporate machine with the sole intent of making money and pleasing shareholders. This same exact thing is happening in the movie industry, the AAA game industry, and so many others.
Whats funny is that BedWars penguin survival was literally also just completely reused code from their old gamemode from 2021 but they put studs on the blocks to make it "classic"
there is nothing classic about stupid penguins fr
Well at least I am happy what they are now burning in the shadow realm and hopefully they will stay in it (getting 253 badges was a lot harder because of them)
bedwars symbolizes the hell that roblox workers endure when they don't make bad decisions
Oh cmon bedwars wasnt that bad.
@@thebestnoobyt1270bro forgot to log out of his alt
Great video, I heavily agree with all the points you make about new events feeling rushed. Games are picked based on playtime and profitability rather than quality and theming. Also 1x1x1x1 being teased during rp2 nearly 4 years ago just for this event to end with a mediocre sword fight is awful
You nailed the text to voice transition as well, great editing, and great content
Roblox powering disappointment
@@azzamensor7687 fr lmfao
Funny thing about the adopt me tix, I was so bored waiting for the teapot that I found them all without a guide, because I literally had the time to check anywhere. By the time I was done the teapot wasn't even a teen...
disagree, adopt me was fun
@@NotKeremAlp doing the same stuff over and over just for it to grow up is not fun :/ its just too grindy
@@gamingdiamond168 well ı had fun doin it, ı understand why people love this game so much by playing this game, but if you didnt like it well thats your problem ı cant say anything
@@NotKeremAlp adopt me was garbage how do you get fun from watching a tea pot grow 😭😭🙏🙏
@@yeri970 idk i had the same feelings when i was starting
i completely agree with you. they hop on trends more than caring about what the really old members of the community want. which naturally makes sense bc at the end of the day they are trying to make the most money. you could obviously tell which selected games had actual effort put into them compared to others. for example doors was asked to particpate but they declined, not considered a classic game but being one of roblox's most popular games on its site it made sense. but if doors did accept im sure they would have made a fun and engaging classic event
@Medbear1987 their reason was that they are working on the floor 2 update so they wanted to focus on that instead of creating a whole new event
Banger vid - the fact The Classic lobby still currently has 1k+ active players show how it easily is the best part of the event. Even after i 100%'d it, I stayed playing there for a bit, just having fun launching people into game portals, it's awesome. I hope there won't be that many of these events because don't really feel like doing one of these every 2-3 months; Egg Hunts being yearly made them a lot more special.
Regarding the games, I'm surprised I did not find that many other people complaining about how most of them handled the Token / Tix system - to be honest the entire thing could've easily been about 50 badges total instead of 253/257 (the bling badges count torwards the number LOL). It's clear how there was no cohesion between the quests of the various games, with a lot of them just being tedious grinds.
BTW, regarding 5:27; you AK collided with the killbot, making it turn so you ended up shooting yourself. Yeah, that can happen. It's stupid.
(also the hiloh controversy was pretty much solved and i don't think that matters at all because the official roblox twitter account directly congratulated him for placing first in the other hunt)
Bro is a menace to roblox community by launching ppl into portal
@@findthelittleguyssits funni tho
what is mario doing here vro 😭😭🙏
These reasons are why I didn't buy the gold track for either of these.
It just goes to show that there's no point in trying when the fight in "The Classic" is just a buffed up zombie AI boss.
edit: also i managed to do the bed wars quest alone (played with randoms instead of my friends) and i feel like i only got really lucky here
How did you even solo the bedwars token quest
@@abahtani1371 i didn't solo it, i meant that i did it without friends, hence "alone"
should've specified that i played with randoms instead, ack
the bling track looked terrible besides for the helmet
Genuinely great video. Didn't know how much your videos needed a voiceover before this.
The “new” Bedwars event is actually just a reuse of an event they had a few years ago, an exact copy with tix, it was also insanely hard back then. Me and my friend couldn’t to it, we basically had ptsd.
It was much easier back then because you could just use pearls and balloons, and that was pretty much the meta
@@Thiago_GamesAnother thing about the older mode was that you weren’t just completely doomed if the bed broke. In the old mode, you could just run around the map getting emeralds and constantly buy speed pies to keep running. In this new mode, the penguins just become pretty much impossible to kill or even run away from as soon as your bed breaks.
@@Thiago_Gamesoh its the guy from the gci server also congrats for being top 2 for 100% the event
Penguin
Traumatic
Stress
Disorder
*war flashbacks*
“Who wants to sleep in a city that never wakes up, blinded by nostalgia?”
Possible people from after 2019
who wants to sleep in the city that never wakes up! (old yellow bricks-arctic monkeys)
i do like how you dont need to play all the games to get all the prizes. i managed to be able to skip a LOT of games. nice vid as always, feodoric!
NO WAY FEODORIC TALKS?!?!?!
O:
Somehow I predicted he would talk in this video without even clicking on it or anything
Im edging to his voice
😳🥵
@@3eeltf
9:54 THANK YOU FOR ACTUALLY MENTIONING TOWER HEROES AND HOW THEY WERE A HIGHLIGHT OF METAVERSE CHAMPIONS
Usually I play roblox events to 100% completion, but this one was different. The oldest event I can remember playing is Egg Hunt 2016 and ever since that I've at least attempted every major event. When this was announced, I was pretty excited since it looked promising and I was hoping it'd be better than The Hunt, so I came in with high expectations. Still with all the hype behind it, I waited for the first day to pass to read reviews and I was shocked at how disappointing it was. It was just an over glorified Hunt with less games. The items really weren't great, and the selection of games were strange for the genre of the event. I looked at the lobby a bit and was overwhelmed, so I went to go look at the games. First game I picked was Blade Ball since I figured it'd be easy, but it got really boring waiting for the boss to start so I went to driving empire and quit once I realized it was a massive grinding simulator. After that I just quit and honestly I'm happy I didn't go through with it. Disappointing event and I hope roblox learns a lesson from these past two events
You know it when Roblox picks "those popular games" for the event.
Overall, gotta say this event is pretty rush (some excluded). Roblox didn't really took the criticism wholely. Same as this event which didn't completely resolve its foundback legacy and didn't reach our expectations.
I really hope honestly, its better if its pushed off somewhere 5-7 months when The Hunt ended. They could really use some enough time with PASSION and CREATIVITY while organizing the event. Plus, this could render out the nostalgiabait that I HOPE they could just do it with passion like the past events that are not that hard to contemplate. And plus, we really dont have a problem being a 5-7 month of waiting the next edition. Like seriously 4 YEARS OF NO EVENT and still you survived, in some cases its affirmative!
If it would be pushed off with more months, games that participated in the event will have the same output as A dusty trip and Arsenal (they start with A's so A for them!). And also Bee swarm simulator if considered.
I think what we really expect is that we would be making LONG ADVENTURES and MADE FRIENDS ALONG THE WAY! The classic event said otherwise. We had small time for the event which we expect to live moments in the classic times LONGER. And they're in a great hustle with cheap and poor outputs and a tight deadline. This is why passion and creativity doesn't value here because nowadays, Roblox is hogging money, advert and make money as soon as possible.
Clarifications are understood by mine and gotta say nonetheless, events are back, but they're not truly put out of creativity and putting tension into the event, its just "grind, repetitive tasks and collect tixes and tokens" thats it. I hope in the Third Edition (hope there is honestly), Roblox should read criticisms and expectations from people first before organizing and planning for an upcoming event.
Although I nearly completed the event (248/257), I had some times of fun and the devs tried to put their game into the event as themeing and with high quality as possible (good for them), but really they should put some tension or set off some difficulties just for the event to be LIVELY again... And really for Roblox to be TRULY BACK LISTENING TO THE COMMUNITY, Just like the past egg hunts. And I hope Roblox sees the problem and learns a lesson.
I remember playing on a guest account in 2015, making my first account in 2016, losing that account and making another in 2018, forgetting the password and making the account i have today. I saw how the events roblox had has really changed.. i remember getting egg hats from games i didnt even know were part of it. and ngl i feel like the problems started to occur either after brick bronze's deletion or live-ops. most roblox games back then also had so much passion and effort put into them. now it feels like it's just super saturated and childish. it really pains to see how the platform changed for the worse.
hey someone with pretty much the same thing, my latest acc I think 2020 and I started at 2016.
I remember playing a egg hunt as a guest, it was kind of cool, I liked it but then after a few cool games, it just died for me as either most games are infected with griefers or just banned like brick bronze. I just kinda wish roblox had actual care or a bit more than money wand more money
Old roblox was just as bad as now there's a term for this called romanticizing the past (2015 isn't old lol)
wtf same. like down to the exact year. i used to participate in events but more for fun and not to 100% them. i remember playing egg hunt 2018 and thinking it was really cool and i kinda regret not beating it, now i just 100% every event no matter how painful lol
@@TheGamer707. yeah everything pretty much went downhill after brick bronze's deletion. probably because roblox doesn't want their platform to be destroyed by copyright
please compare the amount of effort put into egg hunt 2016 and the hunt
20:46 This surprised me that Gary’s Theme was played here, it genuinely did.
Also great video, solid analysis of the Classic Event too. Some I may have disgreed because I had a better/worse experience within that game, but overall it was a excellent video that went in depth of the Classic Event.
BSS note: it’s one of the only games to keep the event. You can still play and get rewards in the game.
it's crazy that since the introduction of LiveOps in May 16th, 2019 (Roblox's first attempt at developer-based events) they still have faced the same issues as the Classic: Hunt did
3:00 are you seriously in Shorts Wars
Don't forget Spongebob with Nickelodeon. They are the conductors of the nostalgia bait train.
My biggest problem with the classic was how long it went for. Not everyone on earth gets to use a computer for 5 hours a day, and i barely got one of the prizes 1 hour before the event finished
As a 2018-19 player when I first heard about the classic I thought they would have games like Natural disaster survival and work at a pizza place I was surprised by the games that were chosen on games I didn't expect.
In the 4 minute mark of the video, you basically just had the exact same opinion that I had about there being missed potential for the RoToken badges! Honestly, the idea of multiple objectives for each RoToken is very awesome, it's just that not every game did that route (which sucked). Even the games that had the best objectives in this event (like Arsenal for instance) still had this issue of a drawn out milestone completion award for the RoTokens. The most notable game for me is Bee Swarm Simulator, as I had a lot of fun playing that objective with my friends (so i didnt have to do it with randoms), and everything about the objective just felt nice. Except for the use of milestones for the RoToken stuff, i didnt like that cause it was used so much.
You covered this event review video well by the way! Great editing and great ways of describing stuff about the event.
good video man, imo the tds one was the best game in the event (that I actually played) ofc I have a bit of bias bc i first tried everything except for map 3 which took 2 attempts
Eh tds was fine but it takes a lot of trial and error from new players as someone who has played tds for years, it was easy but for others I get it would be time taking
for me it was bss, cuz glider exists and my team didn’t suck
is that the feodoric voice commentary
this has got to be one of the best videos I've ever seen.. the whole time i was legit shaking at how well i liked this and how much this correlated with this hunt on so many levels, the whole thing was chaos and everyone hated doing the event. everyone doing the event felt miserable except arsenal and bee swarm simulator.
love how 90% of the games in the *classic* event aren't even based on *classic* roblox
seriously, toilet TDS? that's literally so recent it's insulting to the creators of actual content.
Whats the song st 16:27?
Bruh he literally wrote the name of every song into the video, I didn’t see it lol 💀
Sometimes I wonder if the tix and tokens mechanics ruined the event, I wonder that because some games got ruined like Blade Ball having a battle pass or Driving Empire needing 500 points for all tokens. Just because for you to get 15 things in one game.
FEODORIC THANK YOU I GOT TO THE TOCR NET WHILE LISTENING TO THIS IN THE BACKGROUND
NETTINGTON RUN!!!!
did you beat it?
ngl the hub was the best part of the event. I wish it was just the hub, but some games actually made fun challenges like bee swarm, arsenal and tds. Hopefully next time it is just a hub. (like egg hunt 2018)
Absolutely agree with everything. While i have not completed neither the hunt nor the classic, I didn't complete those because they were boring as HELL (at least i got the bucket hat) Roblox doesn't do quality checks and they only want big, successful games in their events so the outside of roblox thinks that they're very in touch with the community and doing a good job. I'm pretty sure some classic games even applied for the classic and were DENIED, which is honestly just insane.
Some games were good (A Dusty Trip, Arsenal, BSS etc.), but most are just a shitfest meant to milk premium payouts out of the clueless premium players, that think these items would look good on them and that the completionist dream isn't masochism.
also the lobby of the classic was genuinely the best part of the event, i had so much fun on that i can't lie all the quests were fun to do and even though i don't like games focused on minigames or general random doings meant to induce fun, this brought me back to the days when you could play stuff like epic minigames, murder mystery 2, flood escape 2 or flee the facility or etc. in 2018 and have fun for hours.
7:47 where does this sound effect come from? it sounds really familiar
i was ready to read the second book from feodoric and i got jumpscared by a voice
i really hope roblox makes another event like ready player 2. out of the few events i have played, (i only started participating in events during 2020 and by then events were already pretty bad) rp2 was my favorite one by far.
I know I'm lvl 300+ in TDS, but I found it too easy, the issue comes with the players who don't play TDS, they want it easy, but the people who do play it a lot, want it hard, so they went with some kind of medium between it.
I mean it's fair enough, i can see their points too. I'm a new player so playing this is extremely hard, map 3 took so long to beat and by the time i beat it i already have a sense of strategy to complete map 5. Overall it's reasonably hard (unlike bedwar, im still despise them so much), IF ONLY THEY ALLOW MULTIPLAYER IT WOULD BE SO GOOD. But anyway, good game, top 4 for me even tho i prefer the ttd quest bc its easier
Simple answer- Spam. The. Towers. :)
as someone who doesn't play tds i am convinced the people who thought the tds event was too hard have a skill issue because it was pretty easy
@@CarolCanGame Ok but its supposed to be challenged + ttd worse than tds
I'm level 250 and even I struggled with map 3. It's not just the new player's
he upgraded to voice acting let's go
great vid man
Honestly, the classic event is an W event
Toilet tower defense, was added which saved the event
Toilet tower defense is the best tower defense game, the gameplay is so good, the graphics are as beautuful as sirius A's shine... playing toilet tower defense makes me cry of how much nostalgia from 2014 playing garrys mode, good old times... toilet tower defense is a place serene, beautiful as a galaxy andromeda... hope you get your deserved bloxy awards prize...
Once i was with my dad on the top of a mountain, se was watching stars, seeing constellation. And one of the costellation was a toilet form! It was a signal! A signal of something gonna happen! And happened! Toilet tower defense got released and it was incriblely good! I started to play it everyday till now and i never stopped. Toilet tower defense is a masterpiece made my greek gods because of how majestic, beautiful and perfect. Playing it gives so much peace, makes me feel on a garden with birds singing and clean water... so much peace toilet tower defense give...
Skill issues
i cannot tell if you're being sarcastic, or glazing
@@exeintt for sure hes sarcastic
I just randomly found this guy and my opinion on him is his way of voicing in the video is classical and gives me interested vibes for some reason (i think its the editing) i love this man’s channel already. Im subbeddd
skibidi toilet tower defense 💀
I don't see shockwave runners background footage in videos and seeing shockwave runners kind of shoked me.
Anyways great video, and great background game footage choice.
thank you feo for sharing your opinion, however i find it strange that you included a 30 minute interlude where you just chanted "old roblox was better". odd choice but still a good video 👍
Great quality videos as always 🔭
You restarted in dusty trip for mixing oil? Man just remove 2 wheels to tilt the jeep and the fluids comes out.
how the hell was he supposed to know that
2:16 Oddly enough, that's the thing about larger platforms and games. I remember something I read that kind of fits with the current direction of things that said something along the lines of "games are not fun, they are engaging."
And I say kind of, as not everyone is following this way of making things, but a majority are beginning to go this way.
adopt me was a better game, it was like brookhaven but better in terms of UI, before the damn pets update came ever to the game.
what was that at 10:30
why did it say abort me 💀💀💀💀
i saw it too lmao
The best part about this video was your music taste and AOT transitions
Hi
second
Hi
on the same page as you in the earlier part of the video. joined on 8/11 2015, so my account will be 10 aswell soon. highschool gonna be crazy. i met so many friends in the period before the roblox logo changed from red and white. i can perfectly sing the xbox theme in my head, i remember playing innovation inc games on the xbox, i remember the egg hunts being a large part of the fun i got from roblox. so many large games from that period have changed their ways. roblox just doesnt have the fun it used to, so ive decided to try becoming a roblox game developer, maybe try to bring that nostalgia back in some way. roblox has been in my life for basically as long as i can remember. roblox just seems to be trying to get as realistic as possible, but back then they just wanted their players to have fun. i know i cant go back. i know itll just be memories. so if your reading it to this, dont be sad that you cant relive it, not only be happy that you experienced it, but also be happy that it may not be the end of the good times.
Okay but you can’t say the “nostalgia bait train” when people like Kreekcraft were begging them to do this.
whats the name of the obby game u were playing?
hey chat 🔭
I’ve played adopt me before (yes sadly) and the teapot was literally just an adopt me pet with “CLASSIC” slapped onto it. Same aging system same everything.
the music used in 14:00 is from grand turismo, forgot the name tho
Whats the game in the background at 1:22
whats the game at 0:48?
i recognise it but i forgot the name
I like the dramatic music you use when we're going into another game
It's from attack on titan
It’s pretty crazy how the Hub of the classic event was genuinely the only fun I had in the event
It is cool how you went from making ToTS and ToIM to these higher quality videos lol.
me when one of my favorite small games is used for background footage:
shockwave racing btw
I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS FOR HOURS THANK YOU
what is the name of the music at 26:45 ?
Relaxed Scene
the reason that the game selection is so bad is probably due to a lack of communication, you actually had to apply to get in so either nobody knew know or nobody applied
what is the original theme of the transition sound at 6:35
The dragon adventures quest is a HARD F because they basically force you to buy a radar by making the eggs take literal hours to find. Even if there's a way to find them, like rejoining, it's just... no... and same with driving empire or whatever...
tds' event was really good, but the big problem with it is that if you aren't aware of how to play it, so, i kind of went through it with ease (i'm level 286 :D )
Pls tell how to get chomik of babel and when backrooms final update release??? 😮😮
this was one of the best roblox related videos ive seen after so long
anyways you made me realize i am also with my account for over 10 years no wonder why im quitting
2:23 bro i was on a vacation to texas and saw the hunt ad on some billboard thingy
Wait that’s wild. Did they actually advertise it irl?
what was the castle game at 25:33 you were playing?
8:33 - Abstract Alex is amazing in my opinion, made SB1 and SB2 (sb2 was amazing but takes forever to farm later floors, but it should be that way), World Zero, and gave help to Defaltio, who made Lumber tycoon.
whats the music at 16:26?
it says it at the top, srry im too lazy to type it lol
There was an official strat for the bedwars event that required everyone possible in the server to use specific kits (2 ice hammer guys 3 embers and a support) meaning that they knew it was overturned and even planned for it
I really expected FE2 to be in the event, im not gonna lie. Im playing that game from 2017, i really expected it to be there, Crazyblox would just cook it up. But we just got the same games as the hunt, but, atleast bss was there, im glad they gave chsnce to one of the classic games cook.
However, i liked event. You can say its mid or bad, but, its wasnt bad or good, its was just like the hunt, pretty mid and awkward, but pretty fun and playable. Maybe Roblox will listen players in the next Event coming and give creators more time? We'll see.
The arsenal quest actually got nerfed 2 times, it was originally 12 mins, but got nerfed to 15 mins, then 20 mins
You mean buffed?
what is the game at 0:48 ?
12:56:22 This has got to be a hint for chomik 999
Whats the game in the background called
I have never really completed both events which is sad but for a good reason since the hunt had to much games and it really overwhelmed me and i had school during that time and the classic despite it not having that much games unlike the hunt i never found it interesting i did complete one game though which is TDS since i was gaining intrest to that game again during that time and also these were the first event i participated in like EVER i think there were other events that had happened before those but i never participated in them at all really but im crossing my fingers and hoping the future events are gonna be really good ones since the classic felt less shittier than the hunt
As a 2008 player, I totally agree with everything said here. They stopped caring about their legacy and only care about games that make them popular and money. Tracing back to years ago, they would announce newly created games or just make events for fun on games that people didn't even know existed. I doubt that would ever happen now.
So to clear up some confusion on TDS the classic event. The maps are based off of very old maps from the beta state of the game and brought them back for nostalgia (the event was focused on the players that joined the game around 2019)
2009-2012 veteran here, I agree with all of your points, arguments, & opinions tbf.
the most unbelievable thing is that they forgit Erik Cassel in the "guess the famous old characters"
4:25 I agree with the message of the video. However, the key to start the car is in the top right in font size 36 or more. Idk how you missed that lol. Also, you can remove liquid from the gas tank by opening and tilting it down, causing it to spill out.
While I played the Classic Event I thought about some ACTUAL good games for the event. I think actual classic games would be way better to fit the theme and make it more fun than... toilet tower defense... Here's my list of potential additions (this is more than 15):
- Bee Swarm (that was actually a good pick)
- Doomspire Brickbattle
- Epic Minigames
- Super Bomb Survival
- Treasure Hunt Simulator
- Build a Boat For Treasure
- Natural Disaster Survival
- Fashion Famous
- Adopt Me (also a decent pick)
- Speedrun 4
- Jailbreak
- Work At A Pizza Place
- Find the Domos (the true original "Find the" game)
- Be Crushed By a Speeding Wall
- Weight Lifting Simulator
- Flood Escape
- Mining Simulator (the OG one, not the ripoffs)
- Murder Mystery 2
If you have any other ideas let me know, I'll add them to the list
25:48 escape was one of my favorite games back in the day and honestly, the classic event might have been a little bit better if they added classic flood escape because it is an old game and a lot of people have played it since that time which I bet it would be able to make it into a pretty good part of the event.
I was in both 2017 and 2018 egg hunts and god, I miss them so much
PIZZA TOWER MUSIC IN THE FIRST PART OF A VIDEO YEEEEEAH I LOVE IT
what is that parkour game in the background at the start, I used to play it and forgot the name
where did u find 25:28
The classic event was the most fun not because of the content but because during a dusty trip, the fuel broke and I spent a good hour going mach 2 abusing a bug
The video was so cool ! (Pls tell me the name of the parkour game in background at 0:47 )
i loved the hats in the classic but i couldnt be bothered to do these hugely mid quests for some hats that took up hours