2020 Mercedes E Class Vs BMW 5 Series Head To Head Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @Jack_S_
    @Jack_S_ 4 роки тому +28

    If you are going to compare cars head to head, they need to be comparably optioned. Picking the BMW with the 6 cylinder at a given price point over the 4 cylinder means that it is going to be thin on options, feeling less luxurious. Then you have the 4 cylinder Mercedes, which is going to feel leisurely compared to the 5'er, especially when the Merc has the optional air suspension. No one is going to cross shop these two as spec'd. If they had their budget limited to the $65k these cars are, they would either compare lightly optioned E400's and 540i's or solidly optioned 530i's and E300's. A lot of the differences you note between the cars is due to optioning them differently, not inherent differences between the cars. Having driven and played with the tech in both cars, they both are nearly equal, with their sense of style being the most defining difference, so picking one or the other becomes an exercise in taste rather than logic.

  • @nguyenquocbao3812
    @nguyenquocbao3812 4 роки тому +7

    Young channel but great effort ! Keep up your good work !

  • @williebender1895
    @williebender1895 5 років тому +34

    In conclusion I can be the driver of a bmw but the passenger of a benz

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому +4

      I feel that it's set up more like a mini s class

  • @cnxexpat1862
    @cnxexpat1862 4 роки тому +5

    I drive mostly in the city, slowly from red traffic light to the next traffic light or from traffic jam to traffic jam. Then I want to have it so comfortable as possible. Also the passengers want this.

  • @mbos7821
    @mbos7821 4 роки тому +11

    James, really good review of both cars. I would choose mercedes for interior and bmw for exterior.

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      Glad to help thank you for the feedback👌🏻

  • @sandeepjain4372
    @sandeepjain4372 4 роки тому +13

    It is not 2020 eclass or 2020 5 series.
    Both are 2019 models

    • @Megaman_123
      @Megaman_123 3 роки тому

      The Mercedes was still in production as of may 2020

  • @cloudniner4lifex
    @cloudniner4lifex 5 років тому +26

    You have an E350 compared to a 540i. The E350 is equivalent to the 530i. You should have done an E450 to have a fair comparison to that 540i. I have the E Class. True luxury vehicle in my opinion.

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому +5

      In the video I addressed that I understand that, I based this comparison off of MSRP these cars are only 1k in difference.

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому +8

      But the E class is my favorite of the two

    • @cloudniner4lifex
      @cloudniner4lifex 4 роки тому

      U N I E300 is the 2 liter engine. E450 replaced the E400 3 liter engine.

    • @TheRossa21
      @TheRossa21 4 роки тому +1

      cloudniner4lifex dude have you ever driven or owned a BMW?

  • @robertsobczak90
    @robertsobczak90 3 місяці тому

    Why in the world would you not put the e450 with the v6 twin turbo with 362 Hp?

  • @angellousutharsann
    @angellousutharsann 4 роки тому +12

    If it were the performance variants, I’d take the e63, but for the non performance variants I’d take the 5

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      That's fair I agree with you on that one

    • @qb_66
      @qb_66 3 роки тому +1

      M5>

  • @jamdias8449
    @jamdias8449 3 роки тому +1

    The merc is a 2.0?
    Why has it got a 350 badge?

  • @neel-uronchondi9339
    @neel-uronchondi9339 4 роки тому +21

    BMW exterior beat Mercedes benz, but Mercedes benz interior definitely beat BMW

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      Yeah that’s the thing if you combined elements of both cars it’s be perfect

    • @DiegoShock
      @DiegoShock 4 роки тому +1

      James Salvatore thats when Audi enters the game😂

    • @cnxexpat1862
      @cnxexpat1862 4 роки тому

      In the last years many people complained about the noisy cheap plastic at the Mercedes interior.

    • @adeel9668
      @adeel9668 4 роки тому +1

      Diego Shock nah Audi exteriors look terrible compared to bmw or Mercedes

    • @MrPangulo007
      @MrPangulo007 4 роки тому

      @@cnxexpat1862 i just bought used 2013 e350. Lovely. No plastic. Wood+leather only. Sexy family car. Or sexy private car. Sexy.

  • @karahan246
    @karahan246 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the video. What about noise while driving? Which car in your opinion is more quite?

  • @nylens471
    @nylens471 8 місяців тому

    Good video, infotainment is important but you need to go into detail about the available options on infotainment systems

  • @Bswithjay
    @Bswithjay 5 років тому +11

    I had both bmw wins it hands down due to the drive and how precise the steering wheels is plus I got WiFi and wireless charging oh and less flashing lights everywhere on the dash board kinda annoying with all Mercedes

  • @SDBROOKS08
    @SDBROOKS08 4 роки тому +8

    I went with the 18 e class over the bmw. BMW is so dated with the things they are doing. You drive one you drive them all. The Mercedes is literally the best driving experience. Smooth yet aggressive when need be. Burmester systems sound beyond great! Go team Merc!!!!

  • @johnjtrischettijr6439
    @johnjtrischettijr6439 3 роки тому

    Excellent video very informative. Thank you

  • @maddcrz
    @maddcrz 5 років тому +11

    Benz wins in terms of styling because that BMW interior feels so outdated, not to take away from the craftsmanship because it's simple and understated....but it does feel old

  • @outsideboy23
    @outsideboy23 Рік тому

    WHICH ONE IS CHEAPER TO MAINTAIN!!!????

  • @Gemini_0815
    @Gemini_0815 2 роки тому

    So the Mercedes is best because I don’t need to take my hands of the wheel. Why would I need a touch screen then? Confused

  • @mahmoudlashin4372
    @mahmoudlashin4372 5 років тому +1

    Great work you are doing really. Keep up the good work. Just some tips I shoot some videos but not for cars but If you are getting into this industry you should watch alot of references and the best one is Top Gear UK great shots you will learn alot from them (framing, composition, timing and a couple of good ways of introduction)

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому

      Thank you for the feedback I appreciate it👌🏻

  • @jimmiesofsavinrock8887
    @jimmiesofsavinrock8887 5 років тому

    awesome review man

  • @TheRossa21
    @TheRossa21 4 роки тому +3

    1 thing about this video... don’t speak so loud when you’re outside... you mess up the mic and it sounds like you’re yelling

  • @manny6020
    @manny6020 4 роки тому

    Great content and delivery

  • @louis-tj2pq
    @louis-tj2pq 4 роки тому +1

    In the uk the screen in the merc is touchscreen

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      Interesting how they change little things between the us and the European markets

    • @louis-tj2pq
      @louis-tj2pq 4 роки тому

      Yep

  • @yousuffarid327
    @yousuffarid327 3 роки тому +1

    Bro the e300’s competitor would be the 530 not the 540, the competitor for the 540 would be the e400 get yr info right

  • @Kannada_First
    @Kannada_First 5 років тому +4

    This review is simple & very practical.

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому +1

      That's the goal keep it simple👌🏻

  • @michaelchavez5133
    @michaelchavez5133 4 роки тому

    Beautiful review brother still deciding. I can’t decide lol 😬

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому

      It's a tough call

    • @MrPangulo007
      @MrPangulo007 4 роки тому

      Older mercedes are reliable. I heard bmw is more electrical. And they have electrical problems. Electrical goes out ur car is generally toast especially if it's electric heavy. Mercedes is also electric heavy but more so accessories. More mechanical=more reliable. Idk. Ive never owned a bmw but i got friends who do they say small things break or go out electronically. Maybe easy if ur a daily electrician or know about stuff like that. Some people can hack their tesla and never need to know mechanical stuff.

  • @williamliu6855
    @williamliu6855 4 роки тому

    Your would pick A6 or 5 series?

  • @tommyolsen8224
    @tommyolsen8224 5 років тому +9

    🖤 Mercedes-Benz 🖤

  • @williebender1895
    @williebender1895 5 років тому +11

    Love them both but give me that Benz

  • @allenho2778
    @allenho2778 5 років тому +11

    Very biased opinion. Family car vs. sports car. BMW every time.

  • @almighty9662
    @almighty9662 3 роки тому +5

    Wow that mercedes e class i is way better looking car

  • @MrPangulo007
    @MrPangulo007 4 роки тому +1

    Mercedes seems to have bigger space in back and front. I got friends who are 200lbs+ at 6 foot+ and barely fit in mercedes. I got a e350. They prolly wont fit in the bmw. Like barely fit in my car... barely. Im the shortest guy :/

  • @dj_houdini7766
    @dj_houdini7766 9 місяців тому

    Nice deal sleds

  • @dilips7114
    @dilips7114 4 роки тому +1

    Two cars my favorite i like benz bmw audi brands

  • @kingcrumpet
    @kingcrumpet 4 роки тому +1

    Trying desperately to appear unbiased towards the merc but failing miserably.

  • @rishabhraj8497
    @rishabhraj8497 4 роки тому +8

    BMW is a car specially made for the young Entrepreneurs who can enjoy the experience of driving as well as made themselves relax in the back seat when needed. Whereas Mercedes is meant for a rich old person who can enjoy relaxing all day at the back seat.

    • @cnxexpat1862
      @cnxexpat1862 4 роки тому

      I drive mostly in the city, slowly from red traffic light to the next traffic light or from traffic jam to traffic jam. Then I want to have it so comfortable as possible. Also the passengers want this.

  • @daki3317
    @daki3317 3 роки тому

    More room by feet is bigger in BMW and back seet is higher for leegs more Comfort seets in back is BMW i have Them both

  • @erikandrehoglund55
    @erikandrehoglund55 5 років тому +4

    Benz lf course

  • @savijadesilva2528
    @savijadesilva2528 2 роки тому +2

    BENZ E300D IS THE BEST CAR IN THE WORLD

  • @Haricane61
    @Haricane61 7 місяців тому

    Merc is love❤

  • @dilips7114
    @dilips7114 4 роки тому

    What a beautiful cars whosm look

  • @vikrm1795
    @vikrm1795 5 років тому +6

    Brother where is the drive experience?? In which BMW destroys Mercedes
    Also Mercedes uses Artico(Artificial Manmade) Leather also not real wood only veneers(knock on it you'll see its hollow), BMW uses real Nappa leather and real wood , Mercedes might look more expensive BMW is much much higher quality
    And during night drive BMW Headlights are just amazing it's like turning on the Sun , mercedes has a range of only 120 meters.
    I think you are a bit too biased towards Mercedes

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому +5

      I appreciate the feedback the reason for not driving the BMW or the benz is simple since I'm just starting out my channel my access to these cars is very limited not everyone allows me to drive the cars. I try to make the best content with what I'm provided with. As I gain more of a following the content will only get better because as I become more relevant I will be able to drive more vehicles allowing for better content. I will take your feedback into consideration when making future content👌🏻

    • @vikrm1795
      @vikrm1795 5 років тому +1

      @@SteakSchmidt BMW has a torque converter and gearbox is way faster and responsive merc. Artico is green ?? Really ?? Then why do they use hide from 4 cattles for maybach, why not use artico in that. It's just a way to fool consumers 80% of consumers dont even know its artico. Because they never highlight it

    • @vikrm1795
      @vikrm1795 5 років тому +1

      @@SteakSchmidt not all models have eq😉

    • @jibroniuk3604
      @jibroniuk3604 5 років тому

      Vikram Rajan - have you ever driven an E-Class in Sports + mode? You may be pleasantly surprised by how sporty the ride can get.

    • @vikrm1795
      @vikrm1795 5 років тому +2

      @@jibroniuk3604
      Yupp for 3 months, the throttle response and the shifts might become 15-20% faster
      Still nowhere near as agile as BMW

  • @coolbema
    @coolbema 4 роки тому +5

    Mercedes always an old man car and Bmw for sport enthusiastic drivers

    • @ayushpatel994
      @ayushpatel994 4 роки тому +5

      lol not amg tho :))) amg actually leads in its class and although BMW is sporty but they need to change their interior with the 5 series like the e class has with its new screen and display... both r nice in my opinion but Mercedes is definitely popular with us teens just like BMW is.

    • @ayushpatel994
      @ayushpatel994 4 роки тому +1

      but dude the new 3 series from BMW looks fire... but 5 series and E class r more for older adults... the 3 series and the C class r fire.... especially the 3 series... 5 series looks old now tbh

    • @cnxexpat1862
      @cnxexpat1862 4 роки тому

      I am not old, but I am driving mostly in the city. How can I drive sporty? I want it comfortable.

  • @TheRossa21
    @TheRossa21 4 роки тому +2

    Mercedes is a puppy compared with bmw ... on bmw everything is accurate ,Mercedes is full of glitches and so on ... is a reason for what germans stated when they build up BMW ... they said “we made BMW to compete with Mercedes class but we didn’t expect it to be better “ keep that in mind ... on top from own experience i can tell BMW is better

  • @grapezking07
    @grapezking07 3 роки тому

    FEE AH TURES

  • @Bando4.20
    @Bando4.20 4 роки тому

    You should’ve got the 3liter mercedes and than compare them but anyways bmw outside is a beast but when you get inside of mercedes then it’s a different story

  • @j.drenthe2090
    @j.drenthe2090 3 роки тому

    Inline 6 rules!

  • @danjoe9588
    @danjoe9588 Рік тому

    just bit of advice.. when your talking, you should point the camera to the car interior. We want to see the car, not you're facial features. ;)

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  Рік тому

      That was an old vid new ones are very different

    • @danjoe9588
      @danjoe9588 Рік тому

      @@JamesSalvatore I must say. I viewed some of your more recent videos and I have actually been really enjoying them. Your videos are awesome.
      Great work!!

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  Рік тому

      @@danjoe9588 thank you

  • @faresah9307
    @faresah9307 3 роки тому +2

    Mercedes the best or nothing

  • @alexandercarter5034
    @alexandercarter5034 4 роки тому +1

    Mercedes all the way. I’ve been my decision.

  • @Justchill13548
    @Justchill13548 4 роки тому

    I don't think bmw has android auto?!🤔

  • @12pm59
    @12pm59 5 років тому +4

    BMW really needs to take more pride in there interiors like Benz and Audi do nice exterior thou

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому

      Yeah I agree I'm more of a Benz person myself

    • @12pm59
      @12pm59 5 років тому

      See if u could do a review on the 2020 Audi A6 also

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  5 років тому

      Definitely doable I recently just found a Audi dealer that will be working with me👌🏻

    • @12pm59
      @12pm59 5 років тому

      James Salvatore that’s great looking forward to seeing more videos

    • @allenho2778
      @allenho2778 5 років тому

      MB cannot do a good job on the outside.

  • @Шейх-МансурНахчо
    @Шейх-МансурНахчо 2 роки тому

    Benz💯

  • @MrPangulo007
    @MrPangulo007 4 роки тому

    I wish i was rich enough to compare a bmw and a mercedes. Idk what bmw is most reliable. Id like a easy diy 5 series. Something 3.5L and sedan.

  • @EchiMisa
    @EchiMisa 3 роки тому

    Ok

  • @ebusdk
    @ebusdk 4 роки тому

    IF you ask your viewers to like and subscribe in the beginning of the video, its because you dont trust your own content....

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      Thats not why at all

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +1

      People forget to so if you remind them it helps.

    • @JamesSalvatore
      @JamesSalvatore  4 роки тому +2

      I remind people both in the beginning and in the end

  • @egwuogusmarth.c4949
    @egwuogusmarth.c4949 Рік тому

    Bmw is the donkey while mercedes is the horse

  • @lizparks1662
    @lizparks1662 Рік тому +1

    Mercedes anyday out of the week, better inside and out

  • @scarrydude
    @scarrydude 2 роки тому

    Wrong cars compared. Everything you say therefore is nonesense