@@xPrincessGarnetXVI i appreciate your efforts dude for creating such a masterpiece from a lost anime the message I felt it to my heart it is just so beautiful yet so sad at the same time thank you dude
No matter how many times i watch this edit, I just cant get enough of it. Johan is the only serial killer who i can forgive. This Anime is a message to mankind, it shows the the impact of "nurture" on kids.
People who are monsters themselves always can create even bigger monsters with their bad and negative influence (An example is the same Bonaparta and the mother of twins), that's what is sad in all of this story about Johan, because I believe if everything was fine with him and his sister, their childhood, he would have grown up as an ordinary and maybe even a very kind person like Tenma or better. And indeed, the idea that everything could have been completely different and good, if not all the bad things that happened, that turned Johan into a monster, makes me feel sad and sorry for him.
I have always felt such an anguish for Johann. I felt disturbed by him, but not because he was a monster. Which he was. But I saw all the chain of events in his life as this inevitable slope to the pitch black darkness he would be inevitably forced to live in. I just wish that after he's woken up for the second time, he stays away from humanity. I want him to stay within sunlight, flowers, trees and have something akin to peace.
This is not an edit. It is a video that makes me calm. Humanity has not experienced this, Thank you for revealing this to humanity. The treasure has been uncovered. The treasure is this video. It is here with its beauty.
Truly a beautiful comment. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with me. I think out of all my Monster amvs, this one is my favorite. It holds a special place in my heart.
I don't consider this an edit. I consider it an ultra-beautiful pompous retrospective tribute through which the author tried to convey to humanity a message.
That shot of his face haunts me so much. Like the only time we get to truly see JOHAN. Not just hear about him from other people. Naoki ALWAYS stated to the animators to NEVER deviate from the way he expressed Johan's eyes and due to this, I paid special attention to his eyes in every single scene. I feel that despite Johan's nameless smile and mechanical expression, his eyes could not lie from what he was feeling. And this definitely shines when Johan finally reunites with Nina...his eyes were so incredibly expressive. I'M STILL CRYING TOO. HAHA
This is one of a kind edit, that shows Johan and Anna's relationship in a way that, justify all his actions however emotionless they were but as you said, they were all in a way, for his sister. Really this made me see them differently than when I read it. They're were just stuck in tragedy and it was destiny that Johan was being made that way. Emotionless but for his sister. You portrayed them beautifully as siblings than what I have ever seen between them. Thank you for the experience.
Thank you for the very touching comment. Really means a lot that I have touched you with my edit! These two are always on my mind. I HAVE PLENTY MORE AMVS PLANNED.
I thought the first part of Running had broken me but I think I was wrong because no matter how many times I watch this I'm on the verge of tears, this is an amazing edit, I love it
This amv hit the emotions so hard, almost on the verge of crying...The song and sequence of scenes and the message is beautiful, Johan truly loved Anna more than anything. In a way he also saved Anna from becoming a monster like him, all along made her believe that it was him in the rose mansion that day, only if she still had memories of her past, she also would have turned out as that empty merciless monster. This amv is by far one of best i have seen.
Ah I am so glad to hear this hit your heart! I cried making it LOL. Thank you for your beautiful and wonderful comment. It's comments like yours that truly makes editing worthwhile.
Really means a lot to hear you say this because, out of all of my monster amvs I made and the ones I have planned, this amv will always be my most treasured. I cried editing it ha. So I am sorry! *gives you tissues*
i dont know who u are but i bet u have the most beautiful soul making this masterpiece. whatever u went through, i respect ur emphathy. Now i know that somewhere on this planet we still love this nameless character at some level.
Aw. 🥺 Gonna make me tear up over here. Such a wonderful comment. This is what editing means to me. I want to touch the hearts of others while displaying mine. Thank you for appreciating my work and for acknowledging the soul that went into it.
THANK YOU! I am so, so glad I found this edit. I legit started tearing up lol. It's hard to find edits where ppl can actually see how immature and childish Johan is and how tragic the whole story is. The amount of people doing "gigachad" edits to Johan is pretty annoying so I'm happy to see something with emotion behind it. Absolutely loved this.
You're very welcome. I share the very same sentiments about the Johan edits. I don't think Johan was childish. But he's stupid and tragic. If only he used his masterful speaking skills to communicate with Anna none of this would've happened haha
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI For me personally, I feel like his identity/self kind of ended after her mother made the choice. Then when he told Tenma about that day, I feel like it represents how his sense of self came back to him and he's starting his life again where it once ended (which is when he was a child). Grimmer also said that their humanity was still there, just buried very, very deep; and we see glimpses of that through Johans projection. Like that time when he was manipulating that one child who lost his mother, I feel like the hatred unique to his own self was shown. I have a lot of thoughts abt the series but ik you read/watched it a long time ago so ya prolly don't care as much as you did when ya finished lol, but thank you again for the edit and also the response
@komikall3104 I wrote essays! You should read if you still feel so strongly about monster. I still love talking about it. You should also watch my twin brothers 2 hour analysis video!!
4-5 years ago I watched this anime and it left every lasting impact on my brain i am still trying to find a character Better than Johan Liebert, If i was as smart as him I'd be unstoppable and I'd have achieved everything I want
I know what you mean...I am still fixated on him after 4-5 months of finishing monster. I truly wished Johan could have had a happier life after all was said and done...even though by righteous eyes, he doesn't deserve it. Also, love your name!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI So..Do you both understand me....if I say..that am just on verge of falling in love with him...Or have I gone stupid... He terrifies me...but
Johan's story is such a understandable tragedy but some of his actions like manipulating that orphan boy were so irredeemably evil idk if I should sympathize with him or not, anyways you did a incredibly amazing job at this amv it will get people more interested in reading/watching Monster.
Naoki never portrays a character, whether it be a serial killer or even that rapist, as someone who acts evil because evil. But because of how they were groomed, abused and broken by the world. So with Johan and Milos, after my 4th watch and after reading the manga and sequel novel, I realized Johan was speaking about himself, asking Milos questions he asked himself every single day. Their mother abandoned them, their mother chose between two kids, favoring one over the other. As cruel as it was, Johan always feels the need to reaffirm his ideals by using others. If no one reaches out to Milos and he finds the same darkness as Johan, then Johan is not wrong. He specifically does this with Dr Tenma but he was proven wrong in the end by Tenma and by Nina and this was the final nail in the coffin. He thinks he has humans all figured out, because from the day he was born he lived in hell every day. Doesn't make his actions any less wrong. But I understand why Naoki had Johan do this. Anyways, thank you so much for the thoughtful comment! I will end up rambling about Monster and its powerful themes all day so let me stop!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Very well said. Johan is still a monstrosity to society but still has humanity deep down for his admirable high intellect, empathy, complex goal and love for his sister. And again, you do a great job at getting people into Monster in a mature and respectful way.
This masterful edit puts so much into perspective. It shows their hell and mostly Johan's and his feelings for his sister and his wish to protect her. It is tragic but absolutely beautiful. And your choice for what to colour is absolutely on point. Cinematic masterpiece.
I keep coming back here and watching this masterpiece. Thank you very much for understanding Monster with all your being and conveying it to us so beautifully.
Hello, thank you so much. I'd give Monster a 2nd watch, welcome the entirely new experience now that you know everything. It was intriguing to see how differently scenes appeared to me my 2nd and even 5th watch of Monster.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI yess! thank you for making this :’) and i am reminded of the scene where the first lieberts said they only wanted johan but johan said anna had to come along too, he really didn’t want them to separate :(
@user-lc1sb1qf2w Yep. Stated in Another Monster, "The one that boy loved more than ALL was his sister. " And that's really telling. Idk how most people think Johan didn't care about his sister and thinks that he wanted to torture and kill her. They missed everything about Monster. The fact that Johan never forgot Anna despite Kinderheim 511 SPEAKS VOLUMES about how much he treasured his sister. And when she got back from the Red Rose mansion, he apologized for what happened to her that day their mother threw her, showing the weight of his guilt. But sure, I guess Johan didn't love her at all. 🫠
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I agree completely! It’s in the details, he never says that everything done was for both of them/for her, but we can see that it was
@user-lc1sb1qf2w while I truly believe everything he did was for Anna, there are obviously SOME things what obviously wasn't. But that doesn't mean he didn't love her. You should watch my twin brothers Analysis essay on Johan.
That edit is the most epic and emotional one i have ever watched. And probably i will never forget about this video. It made me feel so weird that i can't even think about something else. You are so god damn talent on edits. You should make more so we can watch more :D
Your comment really touched my heart. I have tons of Monster amvs planned! I just struggle with the time to edit currently, but don't worry! I will get them out of my heart&soul! Thank you for taking the time to leave such a wonderful comment!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I trust you about the planned videos! And i believe that you will make them with your all. I already can't wait to see them. I watched your other videos and i lije them so much. Thank you for replying to my comment. You absolutely deserve much more subsecribers. And i hope that you will. See you in another video 👋
@@Patli-CAN 🥲your comment made my day. Thank you so much. I am just finishing up a new one but I cannot upload it until my twin brother finishes his analysis video! I will start on the next project asap!
So amazing this literally reminded me of how perfect Monster is I legit can't express how much I Love this anime and it bothers me when people haven't seen it lol 😂 it's just one of those shows you have to watch
Thank you for your insight and thanks for responding to all questions of mine. I would like to ask you this last question. What is Johan to Tenma and Tenma to Johan and what effect do you think Tenma's death will have on Johan? I have read your essays and it has helped in understanding a lot of parts I myself did not understand and I thank you for that.
LINK TO MY ANALYSIS ESSAY ON JOHAN LIEBERT: Everything he did was for Anna - A Monster Capable of Love www.reddit.com/r/MonsterAnime/comments/ttihlh/everything_johan_did_was_for_anna_a_monster/
Was absorbed in your interpretation of 'Monster', thoroughly enjoyed it. I wasn't sure what the author was trying to tell or connect the dots throughout the anime cause I had a lot of breaks in-between watching. Your explanations really shed some light onto the whole story, and I'm very glad that I was able to find them. Again, really appreciate what you did and I would to thank on behalf of everyone who has read your analysis. It was really simply and very understandably written, it was a pleasant read. You really are a very good writer. Sincerely, hope you're having a nice day ;D
Ah. I apologize it's taken me a bit to respond, I was completely left in awe at your wonderful comment I did not know what to say! First of all, thank you so soooo much for your wonderful and thoughtful comment. I LIVE for comments like this. They make my day and to be honest, I smiled ear to ear after reading this. I want to further thank you for taking the time to read my essays! Goodness I know they were quite a read!!! So I truly appreciate it. I am glad I was able to help you understand. When I finished monster there was this pit in my heart because I felt like all of the information was thrown at me in a mess of puzzle pieces - and I needed to connect each to complete the puzzle that was of Naoki's story. I knew deep in my heart that there was absolutely NO WAY Naoki presented Johan as an absolute evil only to keep that notion of him up until the end. No, Naoki spent the rest of the series destroying that very concept of Johan and focused on humanizing him...but its so sad to me that A LOT of the viewers fail to realize this. Instead, they cling to this superficial concept of Johan as this edgy villain who had no purpose other than being a murderous evil man without actual intent. But if you paid close attention, you'll see that the overwhelming outer layer around the entire story of Monster - is the variable / concept of Love that served as the driving force to every single character in the story: Boneparte and his passion for human discovery and following his father's footsteps, Viera and her love for her husband, Grimmer and the love for his child, Eva and her twisted love for Tenma, Lunge and his passion for his work, Mikail and his love for science, Tenma and his love for life and Johan, the love he had for his sister. Mikail's quote to Grimmer displays this clearly, "the missing element in his past experiences that kept the children from becoming monsters was LOVE." Anyways, I am sorry for rambling. Thank you so much for taking time out of your day to leave me such a wonderful comment. I could cry. I WILL FOREVER TREASURE YOUR WORDS. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI oooh man, I'm dumbfounded by your reply. Was not expecting this at all. Now I know how much you care about what you do. Like woow man you astonish me. It's really nice to get such a passionate response!! Nah, I should be the one thankful for you and your honest wonderful work and for taking your precious time to give such a wholesome reply. Man, like I have no words. Can't appreciate you enough, your words have made my day. With all your insight and knowledge, I'll just call you senpai, senpaiii :DD
@@tenn4splayer Haha oh nooo you're so adorable lol. Thank you so much. It is I who cannot appreciate YOU enough. Your comments make my day. I truly edit from my heart. Every amv I make is a piece of myself; so I am glad you noticed! I hope you're having a good day my friend!
Oh, I was thinking, I know this might not match but i think the song "Another life motionless in white" can work for the twins, but in the alternative universe where Johan actually dies at the end, Tenma couldn't save him. I saw nobody talking about this alternate ending, but I think it would be REALLY REALLY sad... Just listening to the song while thinking about it crushes my heart
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Never saw anything about this ending, just me imagining how sad it would be while listening to "another life" that strangely for me match as Nina's point of view 😔
no what the fuck. i just read your theory before coming across your wonderful edit and i found it fascinating how it depicted the theory so well (which i loved) only to find out it was you who made it. how are you so good both a writing and making an edit?
Haha that's funny you came full circle back to me. Such a small world isn't it? Thank you, I think it's the only two things I am somewhat decent at LOOOOL
@@obitocoamvs1690 really?! That means a lot. Thank you so much. Your first comment had me laughing this morning. I talk like that too and I just heard the way it was said looool. Hope you've been well?!
@@obitocoamvs1690 I've been alright. Just got over catching covid T-T AND OH. I downloaded, ripped them and converted them from a torrent. I have ALL OF IT, including the creditless opening if you want it? I have it uploaded for download as a zip file. LET ME KNOW.
I dont know why I love Johan despite how evil he is...I don't know why I wanted to hug him despite how cold his aura is it feels like I wanted to be like him but I know that no one can ever replace and portray this character, only Johan Liebert is... Who are you? What is your real name, Johan?
Human emotion is trivial. We sympathized with Johan only because he has a story and a sad past, even though he killed many. At the end of this video, we liked the picture of Johan playing with his sister and forgot that he had killed the two old people who were raising him. Human emotion is a trap
This is not an edit it's a message to mankind 😭
This is possibly the best comment and honor, I could ever receive thank you so much.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI i appreciate your efforts dude for creating such a masterpiece from a lost anime the message I felt it to my heart it is just so beautiful yet so sad at the same time thank you dude
No matter how many times i watch this edit, I just cant get enough of it. Johan is the only serial killer who i can forgive. This Anime is a message to mankind, it shows the the impact of "nurture" on kids.
People who are monsters themselves always can create even bigger monsters with their bad and negative influence (An example is the same Bonaparta and the mother of twins), that's what is sad in all of this story about Johan, because I believe if everything was fine with him and his sister, their childhood, he would have grown up as an ordinary and maybe even a very kind person like Tenma or better. And indeed, the idea that everything could have been completely different and good, if not all the bad things that happened, that turned Johan into a monster, makes me feel sad and sorry for him.
I have always felt such an anguish for Johann. I felt disturbed by him, but not because he was a monster. Which he was.
But I saw all the chain of events in his life as this inevitable slope to the pitch black darkness he would be inevitably forced to live in.
I just wish that after he's woken up for the second time, he stays away from humanity. I want him to stay within sunlight, flowers, trees and have something akin to peace.
'Please..... don't make me forget Anna.....' I am literally crying right now
*hands tissues *
YOU DOING OK MY FRIEND??
Yeah yeah 😅😅😅. Thanks for asking though
he loves his sister so much but he dont know how to express his feelings
The only anime dub I really love!! Johan's voice made me cry, you made the emotions out in this asmv. Thank you very much.
thank you so much for the wonderful comment. I love kid johan and adult Johan's voice so much T-T
Death note dub dbz dub real good too
the dubs to Berserk and a couple of Ghibli movies are also great
How much I cried with this video is not written. WHY?? THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN SO HAPPY IF THEY HAD HAD A NORMAL CHILDHOOD😭😭😭😭😭😭
It’s so surreal finding a good Monster edit in 2022, I love it!!
Glad to hear it! They'll be more. MY LOVE IS ONLY GROWING.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Oh my god I love you 💕😭
@@porcelaincats667 hehe yaaay. Check out my other AMVS if you haven't!!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I’ll have to now!!
@@porcelaincats667 👉👈🥺
This is not an edit. It is a video that makes me calm. Humanity has not experienced this, Thank you for revealing this to humanity. The treasure has been uncovered. The treasure is this video. It is here with its beauty.
Truly a beautiful comment. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with me. I think out of all my Monster amvs, this one is my favorite. It holds a special place in my heart.
@xPrincessGarnetXVI Yeah, idk how I wrote this comment. This video just made me happy.
I don't consider this an edit. I consider it an ultra-beautiful pompous retrospective tribute through which the author tried to convey to humanity a message.
Thank you. This really means a lot to me!
Hands down he is the greatest psychological character in anime history 💯
"Are you going to shoot me....?" His face expression makes me cry 😭😭😭
It's been a week and am still here crying over this edit 😭😭
That shot of his face haunts me so much. Like the only time we get to truly see JOHAN. Not just hear about him from other people.
Naoki ALWAYS stated to the animators to NEVER deviate from the way he expressed Johan's eyes and due to this, I paid special attention to his eyes in every single scene. I feel that despite Johan's nameless smile and mechanical expression, his eyes could not lie from what he was feeling. And this definitely shines when Johan finally reunites with Nina...his eyes were so incredibly expressive.
I'M STILL CRYING TOO. HAHA
This is one of a kind edit, that shows Johan and Anna's relationship in a way that, justify all his actions however emotionless they were but as you said, they were all in a way, for his sister. Really this made me see them differently than when I read it. They're were just stuck in tragedy and it was destiny that Johan was being made that way. Emotionless but for his sister. You portrayed them beautifully as siblings than what I have ever seen between them. Thank you for the experience.
Thank you for the very touching comment. Really means a lot that I have touched you with my edit! These two are always on my mind. I HAVE PLENTY MORE AMVS PLANNED.
Dude I got goosebumps. Absolutely amazing.
Thanks! I'm actually glad to hear it. Your amv always makes me so emotional.
Even a Monster loves his sibling
I thought the first part of Running had broken me but I think I was wrong because no matter how many times I watch this I'm on the verge of tears, this is an amazing edit, I love it
This amv hit the emotions so hard, almost on the verge of crying...The song and sequence of scenes and the message is beautiful, Johan truly loved Anna more than anything. In a way he also saved Anna from becoming a monster like him, all along made her believe that it was him in the rose mansion that day, only if she still had memories of her past, she also would have turned out as that empty merciless monster. This amv is by far one of best i have seen.
Ah I am so glad to hear this hit your heart! I cried making it LOL.
Thank you for your beautiful and wonderful comment.
It's comments like yours that truly makes editing worthwhile.
I love it You described the whole anime and Johan's feeling to ''IT CANNOT BE UNDONE''
I am crying right now. This edit is spectacular and I can confidently say it's the best.
Really means a lot to hear you say this because, out of all of my monster amvs I made and the ones I have planned, this amv will always be my most treasured.
I cried editing it ha.
So I am sorry! *gives you tissues*
I'm not crying :,( absolutely loved it!!
i dont know who u are but i bet u have the most beautiful soul making this masterpiece. whatever u went through, i respect ur emphathy. Now i know that somewhere on this planet we still love this nameless character at some level.
Aw. 🥺 Gonna make me tear up over here. Such a wonderful comment. This is what editing means to me. I want to touch the hearts of others while displaying mine.
Thank you for appreciating my work and for acknowledging the soul that went into it.
Wow thank you for this
@@AdityaBhavesh-d5x awww. Thank you for watching! 💗
THANK YOU! I am so, so glad I found this edit. I legit started tearing up lol. It's hard to find edits where ppl can actually see how immature and childish Johan is and how tragic the whole story is. The amount of people doing "gigachad" edits to Johan is pretty annoying so I'm happy to see something with emotion behind it. Absolutely loved this.
You're very welcome. I share the very same sentiments about the Johan edits. I don't think Johan was childish. But he's stupid and tragic. If only he used his masterful speaking skills to communicate with Anna none of this would've happened haha
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI For me personally, I feel like his identity/self kind of ended after her mother made the choice. Then when he told Tenma about that day, I feel like it represents how his sense of self came back to him and he's starting his life again where it once ended (which is when he was a child). Grimmer also said that their humanity was still there, just buried very, very deep; and we see glimpses of that through Johans projection. Like that time when he was manipulating that one child who lost his mother, I feel like the hatred unique to his own self was shown. I have a lot of thoughts abt the series but ik you read/watched it a long time ago so ya prolly don't care as much as you did when ya finished lol, but thank you again for the edit and also the response
@komikall3104 I wrote essays! You should read if you still feel so strongly about monster. I still love talking about it. You should also watch my twin brothers 2 hour analysis video!!
Everything you make always had such depth and emotion. Beautiful as per usual sis.
thank you so much brother T-T really means a lot!
4-5 years ago I watched this anime and it left every lasting impact on my brain i am still trying to find a character Better than Johan Liebert, If i was as smart as him I'd be unstoppable and I'd have achieved everything I want
I know what you mean...I am still fixated on him after 4-5 months of finishing monster. I truly wished Johan could have had a happier life after all was said and done...even though by righteous eyes, he doesn't deserve it. Also, love your name!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI in the novel another monster sequel of monster johan lived a happylife
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI So..Do you both understand me....if I say..that am just on verge of falling in love with him...Or have I gone stupid... He terrifies me...but
Johan's story is such a understandable tragedy but some of his actions like manipulating that orphan boy were so irredeemably evil idk if I should sympathize with him or not, anyways you did a incredibly amazing job at this amv it will get people more interested in reading/watching Monster.
Naoki never portrays a character, whether it be a serial killer or even that rapist, as someone who acts evil because evil. But because of how they were groomed, abused and broken by the world.
So with Johan and Milos, after my 4th watch and after reading the manga and sequel novel, I realized Johan was speaking about himself, asking Milos questions he asked himself every single day.
Their mother abandoned them, their mother chose between two kids, favoring one over the other.
As cruel as it was, Johan always feels the need to reaffirm his ideals by using others. If no one reaches out to Milos and he finds the same darkness as Johan, then Johan is not wrong. He specifically does this with Dr Tenma but he was proven wrong in the end by Tenma and by Nina and this was the final nail in the coffin.
He thinks he has humans all figured out, because from the day he was born he lived in hell every day.
Doesn't make his actions any less wrong. But I understand why Naoki had Johan do this.
Anyways, thank you so much for the thoughtful comment! I will end up rambling about Monster and its powerful themes all day so let me stop!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Very well said. Johan is still a monstrosity to society but still has humanity deep down for his admirable high intellect, empathy, complex goal and love for his sister. And again, you do a great job at getting people into Monster in a mature and respectful way.
I can never forget about this anime definitely one of the best ones out there
absolutely masterpiece
he is first killer who I can forgive and obsessed ❤
OMG THIS IS A MASTERPIECE!😭💫 YOU MUST HAVE A MILLION LIKES!!!💖💗💓💞💘💝💖
I wish!!!! T-T but thank you
This masterful edit puts so much into perspective.
It shows their hell and mostly Johan's and his feelings for his sister and his wish to protect her.
It is tragic but absolutely beautiful.
And your choice for what to colour is absolutely on point.
Cinematic masterpiece.
@@kurokatze1107 thank you so much. Really means a lot.
I keep coming back here and watching this masterpiece. Thank you very much for understanding Monster with all your being and conveying it to us so beautifully.
Thank YOU for always coming back and appreciating my work
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI You're welcome :)
This is beautiful. I end the anime just a couple days ago. It's very good, I already miss it. The song choice was perfect too for this clip.
Hello, thank you so much. I'd give Monster a 2nd watch, welcome the entirely new experience now that you know everything. It was intriguing to see how differently scenes appeared to me my 2nd and even 5th watch of Monster.
Amazing pulled the emotions effortlessly. Music plus the scenes pulled were 10/10.
This asmv Is criminally underated!
but i do like to say i went back to this and it saved me somehow i never understood it thank you
This means a lot to me. Thank you for sharing this with me
Absolute masterpiece, which helps me to find inspiration for my book. Thank you for this great edit!
Hope all is well with your book!
Best Monster amv I’ve seen so far
Really means a lot. Thank you so much. ^_^
The acorn scene is so perfect :(
thank you. That part of the amv as well as the last part is my favorite. I think it fell so nicely.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI yess! thank you for making this :’) and i am reminded of the scene where the first lieberts said they only wanted johan but johan said anna had to come along too, he really didn’t want them to separate :(
@user-lc1sb1qf2w Yep. Stated in Another Monster, "The one that boy loved more than ALL was his sister. "
And that's really telling. Idk how most people think Johan didn't care about his sister and thinks that he wanted to torture and kill her.
They missed everything about Monster.
The fact that Johan never forgot Anna despite Kinderheim 511 SPEAKS VOLUMES about how much he treasured his sister.
And when she got back from the Red Rose mansion, he apologized for what happened to her that day their mother threw her, showing the weight of his guilt.
But sure, I guess Johan didn't love her at all. 🫠
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I agree completely! It’s in the details, he never says that everything done was for both of them/for her, but we can see that it was
@user-lc1sb1qf2w while I truly believe everything he did was for Anna, there are obviously SOME things what obviously wasn't.
But that doesn't mean he didn't love her.
You should watch my twin brothers Analysis essay on Johan.
I just read your reddit essay and now I got to know how tragic this character is
T-T thank you so much for reading my essay!!!
That edit is the most epic and emotional one i have ever watched. And probably i will never forget about this video. It made me feel so weird that i can't even think about something else. You are so god damn talent on edits. You should make more so we can watch more :D
Your comment really touched my heart. I have tons of Monster amvs planned! I just struggle with the time to edit currently, but don't worry! I will get them out of my heart&soul! Thank you for taking the time to leave such a wonderful comment!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I trust you about the planned videos! And i believe that you will make them with your all. I already can't wait to see them. I watched your other videos and i lije them so much. Thank you for replying to my comment. You absolutely deserve much more subsecribers. And i hope that you will. See you in another video 👋
@@Patli-CAN 🥲your comment made my day. Thank you so much. I am just finishing up a new one but I cannot upload it until my twin brother finishes his analysis video! I will start on the next project asap!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI I can't wait for it! :)
So amazing this literally reminded me of how perfect Monster is I legit can't express how much I Love this anime and it bothers me when people haven't seen it lol 😂 it's just one of those shows you have to watch
This edit is a masterpiece
Thank you for your insight and thanks for responding to all questions of mine. I would like to ask you this last question. What is Johan to Tenma and Tenma to Johan and what effect do you think Tenma's death will have on Johan? I have read your essays and it has helped in understanding a lot of parts I myself did not understand and I thank you for that.
This is so beautiful!!!! I love these twins so much, I'm crying so hard omg!! 😭❤️😭❤️😭
Congrats this is amazing!! 💖
LINK TO MY ANALYSIS ESSAY ON JOHAN LIEBERT: Everything he did was for Anna - A Monster Capable of Love
www.reddit.com/r/MonsterAnime/comments/ttihlh/everything_johan_did_was_for_anna_a_monster/
PART 2
www.reddit.com/r/MonsterAnime/comments/ubmza5/was_johan_aware_from_the_beginning_that_anna_was/?
This give me shivers...
A big compliment to me. Thank you so much.
I'm in love with your essays and videos
That really really means a lot thank you so soo much T-T
Second part is even better! Really great AMV, made me emotional!
Yaay I'm glad. This Monster amv happens to be my favorite haha
Oh! I've never seen one this beautiful. Such depth and emotion. I'm touched 🥺❤️ ty
thank you so much!! Glad I was able to move you with my work!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI You did and I'm grateful for that ❤️
Holy shit..i got goosebumps
what a edit bro I am really saying this is the best edit ever i have seen on the internet on monster........................❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hey, thank you. ❤️
Really means a lot.
This is MY favorite edit too.
Check out my other Monster amvs!
Each time I watch this, I sob.
Good job, ig.
Great work 💐
Thank you ^_^ ❤️❤️
Your edit always inspire me. I love them, they are so well done.
This video put tears in my eyes.😢
It's okay friend! I cried while editing it haha. Glad it moved you so
The masterpiece gets a masterpiece edit...... Never thought someone can edit it so well.. ❤️❤️
You honor me too much! Ahh thank you so much.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI You just earned it
thats amazing, you make me cry
Awww. Thank you. *hands tissues*
Don't worry I cried making it too haha
Omg this is so beautiful and amazing😭😭❤️ you did an awesome job!!! And I loved your writings too! Very insightful!!!
I CRY THANK YOU SO MUCH
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Of course! You deserve it!!
Was absorbed in your interpretation of 'Monster', thoroughly enjoyed it. I wasn't sure what the author was trying to tell or connect the dots throughout the anime cause I had a lot of breaks in-between watching. Your explanations really shed some light onto the whole story, and I'm very glad that I was able to find them. Again, really appreciate what you did and I would to thank on behalf of everyone who has read your analysis. It was really simply and very understandably written, it was a pleasant read. You really are a very good writer. Sincerely, hope you're having a nice day ;D
Ah. I apologize it's taken me a bit to respond, I was completely left in awe at your wonderful comment I did not know what to say!
First of all, thank you so soooo much for your wonderful and thoughtful comment. I LIVE for comments like this. They make my day and to be honest, I smiled ear to ear after reading this.
I want to further thank you for taking the time to read my essays! Goodness I know they were quite a read!!! So I truly appreciate it.
I am glad I was able to help you understand. When I finished monster there was this pit in my heart because I felt like all of the information was thrown at me in a mess of puzzle pieces - and I needed to connect each to complete the puzzle that was of Naoki's story.
I knew deep in my heart that there was absolutely NO WAY Naoki presented Johan as an absolute evil only to keep that notion of him up until the end.
No, Naoki spent the rest of the series destroying that very concept of Johan and focused on humanizing him...but its so sad to me that A LOT of the viewers fail to realize this. Instead, they cling to this superficial concept of Johan as this edgy villain who had no purpose other than being a murderous evil man without actual intent.
But if you paid close attention, you'll see that the overwhelming outer layer around the entire story of Monster - is the variable / concept of Love that served as the driving force to every single character in the story: Boneparte and his passion for human discovery and following his father's footsteps, Viera and her love for her husband, Grimmer and the love for his child, Eva and her twisted love for Tenma, Lunge and his passion for his work, Mikail and his love for science, Tenma and his love for life and Johan, the love he had for his sister.
Mikail's quote to Grimmer displays this clearly, "the missing element in his past experiences that kept the children from becoming monsters was LOVE."
Anyways, I am sorry for rambling.
Thank you so much for taking time out of your day to leave me such a wonderful comment. I could cry. I WILL FOREVER TREASURE YOUR WORDS.
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI oooh man, I'm dumbfounded by your reply. Was not expecting this at all. Now I know how much you care about what you do. Like woow man you astonish me. It's really nice to get such a passionate response!! Nah, I should be the one thankful for you and your honest wonderful work and for taking your precious time to give such a wholesome reply. Man, like I have no words. Can't appreciate you enough, your words have made my day. With all your insight and knowledge, I'll just call you senpai, senpaiii :DD
@@tenn4splayer Haha oh nooo you're so adorable lol. Thank you so much. It is I who cannot appreciate YOU enough. Your comments make my day. I truly edit from my heart. Every amv I make is a piece of myself; so I am glad you noticed! I hope you're having a good day my friend!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Sending a heart cause I can't 'love' comments ❤
Third time commenting😅, and this edit still never fails to make me cry.
OMG you're so sweet ;__;
GOOSEBUMPS OMG
This One Almost made me cry 😫
W edit 🔥🔥
Very good edit appreciate the hard work!
Thank you Obluda!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Obluda?
@@Muhammad17372 that's the name of the Nameless Monster book lol.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI ok I read the manga didn't know lol the book of the monster with big mouth and big eyes had that name alr
@@Muhammad17372 it's the front cover name of the nameless Monster. Obluda means monster in Czech.
You should watch the anime too. Its pretty good!
OMG THIS IS BEAUTIFUL
Best monster edit.
Я плачу ...
I'm crying too it's okay
Perfection
I love this so much I just started watching monster! Good vid.
OMG!! This is full of spoilers though!!! 😳
This is beautifully made .
Thank you so much
i watch this like once a week , so good
What a beautiful edit... It left me sad and charmed, i appreciated it. 🥺
Oh, I was thinking, I know this might not match but i think the song "Another life motionless in white" can work for the twins, but in the alternative universe where Johan actually dies at the end, Tenma couldn't save him. I saw nobody talking about this alternate ending, but I think it would be REALLY REALLY sad... Just listening to the song while thinking about it crushes my heart
damn is there fanfiction of this ending?!
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI Never saw anything about this ending, just me imagining how sad it would be while listening to "another life" that strangely for me match as Nina's point of view 😔
Why am i crying after watching this edit i mean it really broke my heart 😭💔
And this gives to rebirth of a monster
A masterpiece
i enjoy your works..omg amazing
that really makes me so happy. Thank you so much T-T
This man manipulate me to become succesor of him
Thanks man. Thanks a lot
You're welcome
3:11 I need this picture!!! Anyone know the source?
The link is actually in the description
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI oh Thank You... And you did great work.. Fabulous edit ❤️
Im really happy my YT recommended this edit 💖
@@unknown_Rishi that makes my day hearing this. Thank you so much.
Awesome!
Masterpiece
POV :When u watch this anime years ago
And found this
I should watch this anime
no what the fuck. i just read your theory before coming across your wonderful edit and i found it fascinating how it depicted the theory so well (which i loved) only to find out it was you who made it. how are you so good both a writing and making an edit?
Haha that's funny you came full circle back to me. Such a small world isn't it?
Thank you, I think it's the only two things I am somewhat decent at LOOOOL
Everything is perfect
U really are a good editor
👍
Truly makes my night to hear this T-T ahh thank you
so so good shietttttt
this is actually the best one i've ever seen edited for monster lmao
@@obitocoamvs1690 really?! That means a lot. Thank you so much. Your first comment had me laughing this morning. I talk like that too and I just heard the way it was said looool.
Hope you've been well?!
hahahah! ive been good how about you ? where did you get monster is such good quall aaaa :';(
@@obitocoamvs1690 I've been alright. Just got over catching covid T-T AND OH. I downloaded, ripped them and converted them from a torrent. I have ALL OF IT, including the creditless opening if you want it? I have it uploaded for download as a zip file. LET ME KNOW.
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI yessss please please i have it but in way lower quality than this :o thatd be much appreciated and i currently have covid :'(
Why is this edit just so beautiful.. It made me feel pained for these two siblings..they went through so much
most epic amv ever
Bravo!
my life was too similar to Johan's life...
I'm sorry to hear that
Was the video taken down? I wasn't able to find it for 2 days
I got hacked by bitcoin streamers and youtube deleted my account. But I got it back! Sorry about that
CUTE AAAAAAA
How many times did you rewatch this Anime?
I watched the anime series 3x and then I read the manga (perfect edition) and also read the sequel novel Another Monster. Why? lol
I dont know why I love Johan despite how evil he is...I don't know why I wanted to hug him despite how cold his aura is
it feels like I wanted to be like him but I know that no one can ever replace and portray this character, only Johan Liebert is...
Who are you? What is your real name, Johan?
Perfect 😢
again a beautiful edit, btw türk müsün, sadece türkçe altyazı var ondan merak ettim.
oh no I am Japanese / Italian! I put Turkish subs for someone who requested it in the comments! Thank you
@@xPrincessGarnetXVI oh ok! I was shocked when i saw a good turkish subs so i thought you were turkish, have a nice dayy
Its 2024 and I still love this anime! I still love Johan! My honeybunchh, sugarplum, daddeh Johan! 💋😈
Johan my love❤
Amoo😭😭😭🖤
Human emotion is trivial. We sympathized with Johan only because he has a story and a sad past, even though he killed many. At the end of this video, we liked the picture of Johan playing with his sister and forgot that he had killed the two old people who were raising him. Human emotion is a trap
It is what makes us human. Stripping us of such is clearly displayed in the series as a huge detriment