You Never Give Me Your Money (Isolated Rhythm Guitar)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 січ 2022
- I put paul playing the guitar because I don't know if he is here (which is most likely), since many forums and famdom say that he plays here, but who knows, only mcca
read the description before making meaningless comments lol
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abbey Road 1969
Rhythm Guitar (1965 Epiphone ES230TD Casino): John Lennon
Lead Guitar or Rhythm Guitar (1962 Epiphone ES-230TD Casino): Paul McCartney
___________________________________________________________________________
Patreon: / dld2music
Instagram: /
Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/DLD2M... - Розваги
Abbey Road 1969
Rhythm Guitar (1965 Epiphone ES230TD Casino): John Lennon
Lead Guitar or Rhythm Guitar (1962 Epiphone ES-230TD Casino): Paul McCartney
___________________________________________________________________________
Patreon: www.patreon.com/dld2music
Instagram: instagram.com/dld2.music/
Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/DLD2Music
This is all George. The only guitar McCartney plays on this is bass (overdubbed). John played some rhythm guitar during the “out of college” portion. The rest is George.
The Beatles began recording ‘You Never Give Me Your Money’ on 6 May 1969. They laid down 36 takes of the song, which at this point ended abruptly immediately before the “One two three four five six seven” refrain.
Paul McCartney’s guide vocals were recorded on track one of the eight-track tape; his piano was on track two; Ringo Starr’s drums on three; John Lennon’s guitar on five; and George Harrison’s guitar on six. Lennon’s rhythm guitar is first heard as the “Out of college” section begins.
McCartney alone returned to it on 1 July, overdubbing his lead vocals onto take 30. It was left again until 11 July, when he added a bass guitar part, which was recorded onto track seven of the tape.
Four days later, on 15 July, he added more vocals to track five, joined by Starr on tambourine. McCartney also overdubbed tubular bells onto track eight, and manually double-tracked his second-verse lead vocals on track one.
Six rough stereo mixes were also made on 15 July, only three of which were complete. None were used on the album, and the song received further overdubs at a later date.
On 30 July six reduction mixes of the song were made. These were numbered 37-42, and take 40 was considered the best. Additional vocals and tambourine were added to it, although the mix and overdubs were later discarded.
Love this. Especially around the 1:00 mark. The guitar sounds very jazzy.
McCartney plays the piano on the backing track and overdubbed bass on this one. Lead guitar belongs to George as far as I know
Very TASTY guitar playing.
Actually, just about everything in this video is George.
This particular guitar part was played as part of a live take in the studio, recorded in May 1969 at Olympic in London. Paul was on piano and vocals, George and John were on guitars (possibly both Epiphone Casinos), and Ringo was on drums obviously. One of the outtakes from this session can be heard on the Abbey Road deluxe edition.
On the tape box for this session, it was apparently written that George was playing a "bassy" guitar, which certainly describes the lead tone on this song quite well. It's also clear that the same guitar that's playing this lead was doing the fills at the beginning and either turned up the volume or kicked on a fuzz pedal for the solos. The fills have been confirmed to be played by George, as session tapes reveal that he was going over what these parts would sound like with Paul prior to the taping - George's intention was that they would harmonize with Paul's vocal line, as they do on the released version.
All of which is to say that the guitar solos in this song were played by George. I'm guessing he was using his Casino because I think the humbuckers on a Les Paul would have handled the distortion a bit more smoothly; moreover there are images of George using his Casino during the sessions for the Billy Preston album That's The Way God Planned It, which occurred around the same time. George later double-tracked the lead part before the "one sweet dream" section, and the second guitar part can be heard in the other video on this channel. The arpeggios and the outro riff were played by John; ADT was applied after the fact so they sound a little like they were put through a Leslie but actually it was Paul's piano that was using the Leslie when the track was recorded (it was switched on during the "out of college" section, but it was later mixed out and replaced with the sped-up saloon piano). In fact Paul doesn't play any guitar on this song.
People think that the arpeggios were played by George because a) it sounds like the riff from "Badge" by Cream, b) George probably played the "reprise" version at the end of "Carry That Weight" and c) because people incorrectly associate the Leslie - which, again, wasn't even used here - with George exclusively during this period. While George did use the Leslie a lot, John did too: for instance there's his finger-picked rhythm guitar (arpeggios, no less) on "Octopus' Garden" and "Sun King."
EDIT: For good measure, I'll point out that this really doesn't sound much like John's guitar work anyway. Even John's most melodic lead playing, as heard on on "Get Back" or "The Ballad of John and Yoko," tends to be highly rhythmic in nature. He'll go for short and snappy phrases with little sustain, whereas this features a lot of fairly adventurous bends and longer held notes, which are typical of George in the later Beatles era, probably due to his being influenced by Indian music. The closest John ever got to something like this was on "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" and even then he was just mimicking his own vocal line.
Mark Lewisohn says the same. Lennon was in hospital in Scotland after a car accident when this was recorded.
@@bloeddorstigbeest Not true. John was absent for the July 1st vocal overdub session.
Thank you!!! Some one finally shares my view on who plays what. This has been one of my biggest mysteries regarding the Beatles songs. Who played which guitars on this track? It’s not an easy thing to figure out. Beatles Rock Band sure got it wrong in the Abbey Road DLC. But I digress, I think I have something to add to this. I think the “bassy guitar” George played was the Fender Bass VI. The nature of how much the intro parts sustain and how much bass frequencies there is always made me think that. Then this isolated audio was the final proof to my suspicion. During the “Out of college” part, the rhythmic strummed “jazzy” chords reveal the secret. There are chord voicings that are just not possible to reach on a standard tuned 6 string guitar…but they are possible on the Fender 6 string bass. It also was not unlikely for John/George to use the Bass VI to strum really low-voiced chords (Dig It, Back in the USSR). What is so cool about this revelation is that it’s the only occurrence of a beatle playing a guitar solo on this instrument. Thank you for properly and perfectly explaining George and John’s contributions to this song. It’s always been a pet-peeve of mine with the stories surrounding this song.
@@alexdiachok6597 are you saying the rhythmic fills and licks at the beginning of the song was the fender VI as well?
@@alexdiachok6597 sorry, no way is it the Fender IV. I can get those tones EXACTLY on my Casino. Absolutely not 6 string bass. An E7#9 (played the second time around “out of job” sequence) would sound awful on the IV)
This is George! I know this is controversial, but please refer to Dimitri Mitrovic’s comment on this video. He perfectly explains this phenomenon and I furthered his explanation to explain how this part played by George, was also controversially played on the Fender Bass VI. I love discussing this stuff! Such a great revelation that I’ve been searching the answer for, for a very long time.
George plays the Les Paul on its neck setting. He plays all the parts at the beginning and all the lead, including the end. John plays the Epiphone Casino and can first be heard on the ‘out of college section’. His playing in the ‘one sweet dream’ but is some of my favourite rhythm playing.
Ian MacDonald was wrong.
I don't care who played it - that last lilting riff at the end of this song is the bomb. It just added this nice twirl to the song around the bass and drum parts.
i was literally just learning the parts on this song on guitar lol. looked throughout your channel for the guitars cause you’ve always been my go to but man if only i had waited a little longer lol good video though!
hahahah, if you want I'll upload the lead guitar too
@@DLD2Music if you could that would be great! the tutorials on youtube aren’t that accurate so i was learning by ear most of it off of pietas isolation but it’s both guitars and i’m realizing after listening to this that i got some of the parts mixed up and also missed a couple of things haha
@@curtis11214 wait for it
@@curtis11214 ua-cam.com/video/iupWf8K_uNg/v-deo.html
According to Ian McDonald, this is John Lennon's part. McCartney didn't play guitar in this one. Harrison's guitar is clearly the one doing all the arpeggios. It 100% sounds like his Rosewood Telecaster though a leslie speaker.
In The Beatles Rock Band this is the part that Lennon appears playing too. And that game was made under the supervision of Beatle historians.
McDonald didn't have access to the original session tapes. He probably just assumed that based on the fact that it sounds sort of similar to the riff on the Cream song "Badge," which George co-wrote. If you listen to the alternate takes, which are available on UA-cam, you'll hear that the Leslie speaker was actually applied to Paul's piano, not the guitar. The reason the arpeggios sound the way that they do is because they were treated with ADT after the fact.
And RockBand animations aren't really infallible. For instance they show John singing the "aahs" in A Day in The Life (most people who've analyzed and dissected the tapes agree that it's Paul) and for some reason they give George Paul's high harmony part in the "She's So Heavy" sections of I Want You.
@@D.A.99740 And the irony is that Clapton played the Leslied guitar on the bridge.
@@marcusphelan57I dont doubt that one bit, but where did you hear that ?
@@ericwalter4771 Guitar Player Nov 87 interview with George.
Absolutely outstanding.
Great track!! Thanks!
Nice, never heard this part so clearly!
AMAZING, THAKS
Maravilloso. 😎
George Harrison's part. Maybe an Epiphone Casino. He played one at the beginning of the Abbey Road sessions.
George Harrison is playing this.
Could we get an isolated tracks video for the 1970 glyn johns mix from Across the Universe? With backing vocals and all ;-;
Great!
So its pretty easy to differentiate George playing and John, especially on this!
1:00 possibly john
Hi I think Paul plays guitar at least at 3:10 mark he plays the same style and licks than in MC Cartney (I) solo album IMHO.
Antin, el marginal
Hello L G ! I like your detailed comment. I Love Continuing Education, and THE Bass ( on this song)
Tempranito 🗿👍
this is complete George's style It's annoying to see everything played by George being credited to Paul for no reason ..even when the abbey road anniversary book says otherwise GET A HOLD MACCA FANBOYS
I dont know man
I heard many times that the distorted guitar part in this song was played by John.
I think George guitar part is the one with the Leslie speaker tone.
Yeah Paul didn’t play guitar on this
@@dimitrisilva6452 yes George played the Leslie guitar
George did the Leslie guitar tone, and about 99% of the lead work but you can hear on the break down where the guitar doubles and one does a higher octave.. This is Paul playing along on that part only. @2:10 and the next few bars
No lo digo yo, en definitiva es verdad. Por siempre, The Beatles!!!!
"Tengo un gran temor también tengo mis dudas".
This is great. Thanks for posting. Is there any accurate guitar tab available for this song?
I dont think so
Genius part
🥲GRACIAS; EXCELENTE TRABAJO👏👏👏
La betlemania es universal.
Sounds like John uses a Fuzz Face at the end.
Isn't this George's part
Sounds like George’s style at the end especially.
@@Vincentlpp08 ジョージです。
@@dachille1 ジョージです。
George used the fuzz face on the whole song but just had his volume knob very low on the start and gradually turned the volume up throughout the song and at the end, it sounds like the guitar is on full blast
I have the full version where this continues on for a few more minutes after the fade and eventually dissolves into a 12 bar jam, and Paul is on the piano so it's John or George going off on lead at the end.
And it sure doesn't sound like John.
I wnat hear at the full version
@@DLD2Music I could email it to you, but the quality is from a cassette taped from another cassette. But if you've never heard it before, you'll enjoy it.
@@SecretAgentPaul ok, send me a email, i wanna hear that
@@DLD2Music what's your email address?
@@SecretAgentPaul valentinosa2310@gmail.com
It's George!
Could be possible.
1:40
this part was played by George
Man, I've watched several videos, read several articles, and read arguments in the comment sections of atleast 4 different YT videos claiming this is John's part.
your comment actually reassures me that this is George's part. I also believe you coz I've been following you for a while and I'm pretty sure you know what you're talking about
This fuzzy one is John, same as Carry That Weight (The End)
The confusing thing is that John wasn't present during the Carry that weight recordings, he didn't have any guitar on it I believe, but he was present during this recording though, which again makes me think that this George's part
@@sarveshbane1718 During the "End" John plays the third part of the solos (using the fuzz pedal, the same sound he used here)
@@Solomongrundy68 That's Also what confuses me, John did use the fuzz pedal for the end solos but the style of playing is very different, I'm not really arguing for it to be Geoge it's just that I'm not able to be convinced about who it actually is.
Sounds mostly like Paul
Actually, it's John
I’m a huge fan of McCartney, but this has to be played bu George. This is played live while McCartney was sat at the piano. Lennon just played straight chords in the chorus like always.
It sound a lot more like George than Paul
I think only John played this guitar
Chupela
Xd
Awesome!!!
In my opinion John played the solo in the middle... and Paul played the solo in the end of the song!!!
That's a great song!!!
It's George.
I agree actually, Les Paul neck pickup is a special kind of bassy
Paul’s on guitar here? Always assumed it was George.
George is playing the lead guitar
ジョージの音です。
this is lead guitar BRUH
El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Morelia Michoacán México oh El Profesor Daniel Franco Jr Escutia para Presidente de Cuitzeo Del Porvenir Michoacán México el Pueblo Miajico because I am not a Pintor and i am not George Floyd he's an African American black man and now mi Madrina va echar afuera a todos mis Renteros por andar robando celulares y La Vivis Vicky Valencia y Guillermo they said they are La Nueva Generación and they are now America most wanted