The audience participation at the Garden could not have been a greater demonstration that there is much love for the Roses on this side of the pond. Angels wept.
I love the Roses since ‘89. Was with them ever since. What held them back from a unified supremacy was the fact they really couldn’t pull off that amazing sound live. Well, Ian couldn’t. The studio helped him stay in key and find the notes. Can’t hide live. While Reni, Mani and John did their thing, Ian just couldn’t keep up. Wow....this is a surprise. I saw them live and their Telly appearances and this is by far the best I’ve heard him. Well, done Ian.
don't stop is one of the most amazing pieces of music ever, to reverse a song in that way and turn it into what it is... and then they way they perform it live, it's mind blowing how good it is. and how special it was at heaton park in 2012
Oh man. 28 years I waited for Ian to get it together. Thank-you brother. A great, great performance. Reni is sublime. We always wanted greatness, and you gave it. Not that we ever doubted it. The beautiful echo of our generation.
Fantastic job the sound engineer has done for this,ian's voice sounds so loud,clear and in perfect tune,the music speaks for itself,the stone roses ♥️ xx
I'm honestly impressed too... not that I'd care if it had been his usual performance, The Stone Roses would be worth seeing live if there were no singer at all.. but this is AWESOME!
Belting performance. What a legend Brown is. The way he prowls the stage. Liam could only dream of being him. I last saw them in Leeds at 02 arena and they were fucking mint. Tight band. Mani a legend too. Kept looking like he was gonna pass out , his breathing was fucked! Think he’s got asthma or COPD. Reni on drums is outstanding and what more can be said of Squires guitar playing? Legends the lot of them.
This song hit another dimension. I have been going to concerts for 35 years (U2, The Police, Midnight Oil, Rolling Stones, Pearl Jam, etc.) and this was one of the best shows I have ever seen. Hope they come back to the States soon.
This is how they should sound, ive seen them 5 times and only once have I been on cloud 9 at the Etihad on the last night, that was last time I saw them and probably will be the last. They should have finished that third album they said they were half way through or was that the press talking. Now ive found what I'm looking for musically Which happens to be a front person in a band from 89 now solo who has given me back my mojo, were there is more to life than the roses who i l oved so much and still do.WJ she's were it's at now!
Mani's bass is so melodic , i know Squires guitaring is often the driving sound , but I honestly think Mani's bass gets overlooked. Renis drumming is a masterclass as well , arguably one of the best ever. As a band they really are overlooked in terms of their individual playing , they really were three great musicians in their own right.
Thanks for uploading these...I've been into the Roses since I was an 18 year old kid in 1989, and this is really the best I have ever heard the band. Back in the day Ian was never that friendly live, so it's good to see him giving you guys across the Pond some love....Cheers.
Thanks for uploading these Steve they are class, best I've seen uploaded from any of their gigs. Travelled all the way from the UK for this, what a night 🤘🤘Cheers
Damn, Reni needs to go on tour solo, just playin' the drums to all these songs. Nobody, and I mean NOBODY hits the skins like he does. His skillz are literally on the level of the magical and the majestic.
Nice vid. Really enjoyed watching. Been a fan since the debut album but never seen them. I had a friend who traveled cross the US to be there last night, though. So cool.
Had their first album in my first car, still play it now all these years later - was there last night and it was the first time I ever saw them live. The totally nailed it, the atmosphere was crazy, even after in the elevators and out into the streets. Amazing.
What makes them special is they disappeared as quick as they arrived giving them mythical status but there influence still ripples. That is an effect that cant be replicated. They arent about being the best band in the world, but the best band your world. Music is about feeling and the roses make you feel everything
Don't Stop really reminds me of Draft Morning by The Byrd's. Brilliant performance. Got to say Reni really holds it together. His bass playing is flawless and fluid. From the top.
I think they did it bcs it was probably a long standing ambition of theirs' to play MSG together....bcs other than that one show it doesn't fit in with any tour ....I really doubt they'd sell MSG out over a few nights, they're not so well known over there, seriously, there's only one city they can play night after night in a big venue and its their hometown... but good on 'um - they should rightly be proud of this gig
They were the hottest UK band `89-90.I didnt get their debut album then for my sins.I saw them in 1989 on a Boxpops tv show and thought thank f**k a proper guitar band are here again.But unfortunately they were fucked by a record company they were stuck with
The audience participation at the Garden could not have been a greater demonstration that there is much love for the Roses on this side of the pond. Angels wept.
When you get it you proper get it
Topman James
Love this one people ❤
I love the Roses since ‘89. Was with them ever since. What held them back from a unified supremacy was the fact they really couldn’t pull off that amazing sound live. Well, Ian couldn’t. The studio helped him stay in key and find the notes. Can’t hide live. While Reni, Mani and John did their thing, Ian just couldn’t keep up. Wow....this is a surprise. I saw them live and their Telly appearances and this is by far the best I’ve heard him. Well, done Ian.
Plus they more or less broke up before showing the world what they really had to offer what a shame amazing band
Listen to this gem waterfall. like it? now we'll play it backwards LOL
7 year old comment just made me laugh my head off in "sunny" Manchester.
Waterfall is probably my favorite song of all time. It was very nice of the band to play it backwards
Me too an amazing tune
Same, from the first time I listened to it to the last time I listened it amazes me with its beautiful simplicity.
don't stop is one of the most amazing pieces of music ever, to reverse a song in that way and turn it into what it is... and then they way they perform it live, it's mind blowing how good it is. and how special it was at heaton park in 2012
Absolutely agree 100% it blew me away at Heaton park,the whole thing did to be honest...one of the best days/nights of my life..
@@davemcshee3366 I’m surprised anyone can remember 🤩
Brilliant! All four are musical geniuses in my mind
Oh man. 28 years I waited for Ian to get it together. Thank-you brother. A great, great performance. Reni is sublime. We always wanted greatness, and you gave it. Not that we ever doubted it. The beautiful echo of our generation.
Well put mate😉
Autotune
That note was officially hit at 0:57
The Stone Roses in top shape, just great 💯
May 21, 2024
I think I've watched this at least once a month for the last year
Fantastic job the sound engineer has done for this,ian's voice sounds so loud,clear and in perfect tune,the music speaks for itself,the stone roses ♥️ xx
I would be an empty soul without the Roses. Life changing.
How did i not hear about this even happening, they were my favorite band around this time in my teens
Wait, this IS the best I've ever heard Ian! Tremendous!!!
I agree mate, he sounds unreal! seen so many live performances of them and never heard him sing so good
You can tell this show was so important to him... just spectacular. It was even better from the front row. I'm still buzzing off it...
I need a stewards inquiry...Sounds to good to be true....lol
I'm honestly impressed too... not that I'd care if it had been his usual performance, The Stone Roses would be worth seeing live if there were no singer at all.. but this is AWESOME!
was there... roof blown off, it was quite an experience
Belting performance. What a legend Brown is. The way he prowls the stage. Liam could only dream of being him. I last saw them in Leeds at 02 arena and they were fucking mint. Tight band. Mani a legend too. Kept looking like he was gonna pass out , his breathing was fucked! Think he’s got asthma or COPD. Reni on drums is outstanding and what more can be said of Squires guitar playing? Legends the lot of them.
Incredible tight and groovy - god bless Reni!
One day, one day I hope for more.
Mani's bass sounds awesome in your videos - thanks for sharing!
I hope sometime down the road the Roses has a legit US tour.
Ian sounds amazing here! Hope they tour the rest of the world soon
Mani comes into his own here.
The Bass is magical. Go back and listen again, just joy.
This song hit another dimension. I have been going to concerts for 35 years (U2, The Police, Midnight Oil, Rolling Stones, Pearl Jam, etc.) and this was one of the best shows I have ever seen. Hope they come back to the States soon.
you obviously missed Nirvana at Reading, too bad kid that gig was no.1 ;)
Good lord, with the exception of EARLY Rolling Stones, those bands suck compared to The Stone Roses. I agree, it was one of the best shows ever.
@Dale Cooper so was Pearl Jam
@@thestrongprevail3039 Pearl jam are and have sold out. it is now all about the money
This is how they should sound, ive seen them 5 times and only once have I been on cloud 9 at the Etihad on the last night, that was last time I saw them and probably will be the last. They should have finished that third album they said they were half way through or was that the press talking. Now ive found what I'm looking for musically
Which happens to be a front person in a band from 89 now solo who has given me back my mojo, were there is more to life than the roses who i l oved so much and still do.WJ she's were it's at now!
I wish I could have been there, I only discovered the roses in 2019. Unfortunately I’ll never get a chance again :/
They were amazing. Reni, original genius!!
Brilliant. We need the film 🎥 of this whole show for roses fans. I was supposed to be at this show but in life stuff happens at the wrong times
This show was EPIC! One of the best concerts I have ever seen!
Waterfall outstanding!!!!
Seeing this and hearing it just brightens up your day anytime, enough said.
thanx lads good to see you all together
Stone Roses ❗️
Sound just as good as when I saw them at the Hollywood Palladium in 1994 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Wow. Welcome back, Ian's voice. This really whets my appetite for the new album.
Mani's bass is so melodic , i know Squires guitaring is often the driving sound , but I honestly think Mani's bass gets overlooked.
Renis drumming is a masterclass as well , arguably one of the best ever.
As a band they really are overlooked in terms of their individual playing , they really were three great musicians in their own right.
Nothing short of bloody brilliant!
Best rhythm section in the business bar none! Take a bow.
Great performance from the Best band in the world.
I wanted to be there. I couldn't afford it. Thanks for the video!
Thanks for upload great sound
Thanks for uploading these...I've been into the Roses since I was an 18 year old kid in 1989, and this is really the best I have ever heard the band. Back in the day Ian was never that friendly live, so it's good to see him giving you guys across the Pond some love....Cheers.
Mani at 5:00 fucking top notch he's like no we are not ending this song
Ian pulling out all the best dance moves!
Ian nailed this one. So he should! But we all know how he can be
great show. i was there. thanks for posting
Thank you!!!!! Amazing video!!!! I was there and am loving begin able to relive it today!
I don't believe this. Reni's playing his drums backwards. Disgustingly brilliant. Absolutely fucking disgusting, brilliant.
Fantastic!!
thanks mate very good recording...they look like there looking after themselves too...
Remi man, how good is that guy? Blows my mind every time I see him.. I am not even a drummer lol
Don't get me wrong they are all class .
He could do it blindfolded he's that good
great sound recording - can't believe its so clear - way to go Steve-O!
Thanks for uploading these Steve they are class, best I've seen uploaded from any of their gigs. Travelled all the way from the UK for this, what a night 🤘🤘Cheers
This is brilliant my favs ..
excellent recordings. top fella thanks for sharing
Damn, Reni needs to go on tour solo, just playin' the drums to all these songs. Nobody, and I mean NOBODY hits the skins like he does. His skillz are literally on the level of the magical and the majestic.
And the mystical...
i was there last night. SO EFFIN GREAT
Incredible performance 🍋
Alan Wren: divine incarnation of the god of rhythm in human form.
Listen to that bass! Sweet!
Best they've ever sounded live... fact
Nice vid. Really enjoyed watching. Been a fan since the debut album but never seen them. I had a friend who traveled cross the US to be there last night, though. So cool.
@steveeaston nice one for putting this on..great footage
They might have "George Bested" it back in the day, but they came back like the ray of sunshine they always were, just even more beautiful.......
was at heaton park and etihad.... this is class
Brilliant !!!!
Had their first album in my first car, still play it now all these years later - was there last night and it was the first time I ever saw them live. The totally nailed it, the atmosphere was crazy, even after in the elevators and out into the streets. Amazing.
20GOTO10 The Stone Roses experience!! Hope the vibes are still with you, man..
How many people were there roughly? I didn't realise they were that big over there
Matt Gosling it was sold out mate. And mostly brits - great atmosphere even afterwards outside.
Waterfall is my favourite of all!!
Excellent, Cheers amigo
Wreni makes drumming look easy.
Awesome.
Well, it is easy for him. He's a natural musician.
Absolute Genius Remarkable 👏 🇬🇧💓🇬🇧
Amazing song!
Damn who else can play a song backwards . Damn that's awesome.
Amazing
Legends
Best IV heard Ian sing,was at Heaton park and Finsbury park and this sounds on a different level, sublime!!
No words the music speaks for itself 🤟🤟🤟😖😎😎😎😎
Took long enough to cross the pond, been in love with them since day 1... amazing job Ian and band..
Ian, John, Mani and Reni
Fucking epic. Hope they tour the US
Could of been the greatest band ever wow
What makes them special is they disappeared as quick as they arrived giving them mythical status but there influence still ripples. That is an effect that cant be replicated. They arent about being the best band in the world, but the best band your world. Music is about feeling and the roses make you feel everything
Immense roses
Best part of my mid-late teens, this album, snogging hot guys with floppy hair, wearing flarey cords and smoking Gold Seal or Nepalese bifters
love your commens dude roses 4eavxxxxxx
STONE ROSES EUROPE ✊❤️💥
Thank you.
I never realised.
Play it forwards. Play it backwards.
Smile.
Ian looks more engaged, appreciates the crowd more.
Reni is always the beast!
Top form there the boys
Don't Stop really reminds me of Draft Morning by The Byrd's. Brilliant performance. Got to say Reni really holds it together. His bass playing is flawless and fluid. From the top.
Reni the drummer lol, not the bass player!!!!!
Props for the Mani close ups!
what fantastic sound MSQ has - Brown in tune
Next time they are playing New York msg I think they might need to do a few nights!!!
I think they did it bcs it was probably a long standing ambition of theirs' to play MSG together....bcs other than that one show it doesn't fit in with any tour ....I really doubt they'd sell MSG out over a few nights, they're not so well known over there, seriously, there's only one city they can play night after night in a big venue and its their hometown... but good on 'um - they should rightly be proud of this gig
The mental capacity to play something backwards effortlessly 👍
Mani effortlessly slipping into don't stop was excellent
That's the best I've heard Ian sing
As a man who has tried to defend Ian Brown’s vocals before, I’ve given up. There’s no point, you go to watch four men, equally important.
They were the hottest UK band `89-90.I didnt get their debut album then for my sins.I saw them in 1989 on a Boxpops tv show and thought thank f**k a proper guitar band are here again.But unfortunately they were fucked by a record company they were stuck with
Mani is just incredible
All about Reni..
It clearly was all about Reni for Reni at least, since he can't resist overplaying the fuck out of it, to the point of completely ruining the rhythm
@@captainfeedback1 no, the drumming is completely enthralling and hypnotic
@@peterthirdandthebridges Each to their own. Do you play?
@@captainfeedback1 yes, but not as well as him
@@peterthirdandthebridges Not many people play as well as Reni used to. Including Reni ;-)
6.08 to 6.18 beautiful
Peter from Germany: Memorys coming back😢😢😢
Yanks lovin’ it 🙌🏼
This is different gravy but one question who the muppet that disliked this, wobble your head bert
With total respect to you, do you think there will be a "professional" dvd of this entire gig? He, varying angles etc?
would that there were ...
reni at 2:26 to 2:43 😍
Haha can do it blindfolded
Such a natural drummer it seems effortless
I love it, altgough I miss Squire playing arch-top type of guitat, more jazzy tone. Still played better than ever
Waterfall is for Reni 💪