Analysis matters, maulana sbi is confusing many Quranic ayats and ahkamat without context.. ghamidi sb is very clear an he knows how to analyse and draw a right conclusion in the light of context of Quramic surah and ayat
Issue arises when people start forcing their opinions and/or interpretation upon other people after believing that their opinion and/or interpretation is the right one and everyone else is wrong. Please live with your opinions and/or interpretation and let other people live with theirs in peace and stop being a laughing stock for the non-muslims. Another major issue is that we mix culture with religious matters. We present many cultural values as religious values which is mostly not the case as their is a huge difference of opinion amongst scholars. An example of such things is the issue of hijab how much and what parts should be covered varies by culture and even scholars don't agree with each other.
When Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) was asked about the aayah (interpretation of the meaning): “O Prophet! Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies” [al-Ahzaab 33:59] - he covered his face, leaving only one eye showing. This indicates that what was meant by the aayah was covering the face. This was the interpretation of Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) of this aayah, as narrated from him by ‘Ubaydah al-Salmaani when he asked him about it.
Surah Azhab Ayah 59 says it clearly. Ghamidi Sahab can say whatever he wants but the words are very clear even if you do not consider tafaseer or Ahadith.
quran 33:59 "O Prophet, tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to bring down over themselves [part] of their outer garments. That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused. And ever is Allah Forgiving and Merciful." tafsir ibn kathir Here Allah tells His Messenger to command the believing women -- especially his wives and daughters, because of their position of honor -- to draw their Jilbabs over their bodies, so that they will be distinct in their appearance from the women of the Jahiliyyah and from slave women. The Jilbab is a Rida', worn over the Khimar. This was the view of Ibn Mas`ud, `Ubaydah, Qatadah, Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Sa`id bin Jubayr, Ibrahim An-Nakha`i, `Ata' Al-Khurasani and others. It is like the Izar used today. Al-Jawhari said: "The Jilbab is the outer wrapper. `Ali bin Abi Talhah reported that Ibn `Abbas said that Allah commanded the believing women, when they went out of their houses for some need, to cover their faces from above their heads with the Jilbab, leaving only one eye showing. Muhammad bin Sirin said, "I asked `Ubaydah As-Salmani about the Ayah: ﴿يُدْنِينَ عَلَيْهِنَّ مِن جَلَـبِيبِهِنَّ﴾ (to draw their Jalabib over their bodies.) He covered his face and head, with just his left eye showing.''
Mr Ghamidi is defining this ayah with its context also,it is the ayah of temporary symbol in a situation for to recognize, not order of Hijab,for that it is in Surah Noor
Ghamdi point of view is most balanced..the other side of panel have a weak understanding of the matter and surface narrations.. May ALLAH give us best guidance.
"I THINK"..................Everybody tried his or her best. However, despite Mr. Ghamidi is always a great observer and presenter of facts with keen eye, this time, Ms. Taiyba Yousfi (Allah-e-Yahfazuk) responded, questioned, and answered (mostly) like a "purely faithful" Muslimah. MashaAllah. Her questions didn't receive satisfactory answers! Her answers didn't receive satisfactory appreciation or agreement. May Allah grant her even better in this world and the Next. And may Allah forgive us all in this world and the Next. And Allah Knows Best.
It's interesting that when this program aired, I was on the traditional side and didn't knew who Ghamidi Shab was, and though that who is this Fake Mullah without beard challenging our traditions. But now After 20 years I am watching again with Ghamidi Sahab Point of View and Cant help Smile how my concepts have change throughout these years.
Same here ... I have lived the example n teachings of Mullahs n realised how fake n men oriented it is n only when I started thinking rationally Ghamdi Saheb's points made sense to me n also what I love about his teachings is that he takes historical context n facts with n explains how we should take teachings n guidance from the Quran. Mullah hve rested all those years after the 4 Imam n never thought that time demands work n development. My question is why today after putting women in burqas men have started fulfilling their sexual desires from other men or kids? Isn't it true that we ourselves have put this idea of sex symboles about women in men's minds. This is ridiculous that West has found all the gems of the Quran n we kept covering n restricting our women more n more n achieved NOTHING!!!
Well you can contradict with any one of them. I think that we should appreciate that everyone is calm and at serene when debating an hot topic.. Any person who is listening to this can make up their own notion based on the rational argument by any of them. You can't imagine these days that kind of educational debate without lashing out to others...
Ghamidi sb on top as always.... MashAllah... In a nutshell... Dress modestly, be modest, keep your eyes clean...and dont dress for attention...if some women wear hijab, so be it... if some dont let them be as long as they dress modestly....
Surah Noor Me Ghar Ke satar ke bare Me Discussion kya gaya hai aur Surah Ahzab Me Bahar Ke Hijab Ke Bare Me Discus Kiya Gaya Hai... Lekin. yaha Par Gamdi sahab bhi aur Molvi sahab bhi dono commandment ko mix karne Ko koshis Kar rahe hai.... 🇮🇳
Bro,Pura padho,Surah Noor ki 3 ayat milaker dekho Waha doo alfaaz istimal kiye Gaye hain. "Bait ul Maskunah"."Bait ul Gair Maskunah)...na ki khaali. Gher. Surah Ahzab ki ayat puri padho,yeah waqti tor per ik shinakht ke liye na ki chere aankh band kerke girne ke liye. (Religion without science blind)
@@ahsanansari4679 Bro,Pura padho,Surah Noor ki 3 ayat milaker dekho Waha doo alfaaz istimal kiye Gaye hain. "Bait ul Maskunah"."Bait ul Gair Maskunah)...na ki khaali. Gher. Surah Ahzab ki ayat puri padho,yeah waqti tor per ik shinakht ke liye na ki chere aankh band kerke girne ke liye. (Religion without science blind)
Is anyone not raising eyebrows over the fact that all the ghamdism praising accounts have such similar comments? Ghamdi the visionary. Ghamdis knowledge is vast. Ghamdi this, ghamdi that.
I also admire Ghamidi Sahab. But these people are real fanatic. They don't think deeply what ghamidi sir conveying to us. Rather praise him immensely to show that he is superior than typical Mullahs. They are like those fanatic of every group. Good for nothing.
Ghamidi sahab saari baatein sahi karte karte end main gadbad kar baithe... Agar hijab ban hota hai west main to musalmano ko hijab tark karke taleem ko tarjee deni chahye ...ok 1- Agar musalman country asa hi kare ghair Musalmano ke sath aur force kare hijab, to ghamidi sahab yehi kahenge? 2- Agar western countries kal ko kahen aapko mini skirt pehen na compulsory hai education ke liye to bhi muslamano ko apni tehzeeb tark kardeni chahye aur mini skirt main apni maa betiyon ko allow kardena chahye. Right?
ghamidi doesnt know even the etiquettes of conversation. he keeps on intrupting both scholars in their turn and keep twisting his tongue. such a misguiding person.
ghamidi provides his (opinions) without evidences. he mis-interprets quran which clearly differs from the intrepretation told by muhammad pbuh and as interpreted by sahaba r.a and salaf. may allah deal with this fitna ghamidi. liberals love him because he say what they want to hear. what a shame that if our woman dont consider ummhatul momineen as their idols who else. quran is for whole humanity and it does not differ between muslims. no one is better in the eyes of allah except who has more taqwa. the quran is for all men and woman until qayamah. ghamidi is clearly misleading our youth. ghamidi is a liar. he has no evidence only his "opinions".
Moeen Ali hahahhaa ur a joke.. go and lsn to the moulvis who tell tales from hadeeth books. Thts wht narrown minded ppl like u deserve.. Ppl like u jst pick one ayat from a whole surrah bt nvr understand the whole comtext of tht surray I pity ppl like u
fozia wahab.. hasnt covered his head even and came to talk about hijab. hillarious. ghamidi only presents his (opinion) without evidence. and any opinion without evidence has no value. we understand quran the way prophet pbuh told us and not the way ghamidi interprets it. both are jahil.
![[1/2] Kiya Mazhab aur Science Mutasadum hain - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ca3eJZ3h7dc/mqdefault.jpg)
Ghamidi sab the miracle of this era...ocean of knowledge .never run short of words...
Yes❤
Ghamidi Sb. (ha) knowledge is on another level, MaşaAllah. ❤️
Analysis matters, maulana sbi is confusing many Quranic ayats and ahkamat without context.. ghamidi sb is very clear an he knows how to analyse and draw a right conclusion in the light of context of Quramic surah and ayat
Issue arises when people start forcing their opinions and/or interpretation upon other people after believing that their opinion and/or interpretation is the right one and everyone else is wrong. Please live with your opinions and/or interpretation and let other people live with theirs in peace and stop being a laughing stock for the non-muslims.
Another major issue is that we mix culture with religious matters. We present many cultural values as religious values which is mostly not the case as their is a huge difference of opinion amongst scholars. An example of such things is the issue of hijab how much and what parts should be covered varies by culture and even scholars don't agree with each other.
When Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) was asked about the aayah (interpretation of the meaning):
“O Prophet! Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies”
[al-Ahzaab 33:59] -
he covered his face, leaving only one eye showing. This indicates that what was meant by the aayah was covering the face. This was the interpretation of Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) of this aayah, as narrated from him by ‘Ubaydah al-Salmaani when he asked him about it.
but tafseer of ibn kathir shows different
He was explaining the Aayah only
Ghamdi is always to the point and a great scholar......behtareen aalim e deen
Surah Azhab Ayah 59 says it clearly. Ghamidi Sahab can say whatever he wants but the words are very clear even if you do not consider tafaseer or Ahadith.
quran 33:59
"O Prophet, tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to bring down over themselves [part] of their outer garments. That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused. And ever is Allah Forgiving and Merciful."
tafsir ibn kathir
Here Allah tells His Messenger to command the believing women -- especially his wives and daughters, because of their position of honor -- to draw their Jilbabs over their bodies, so that they will be distinct in their appearance from the women of the Jahiliyyah and from slave women. The Jilbab is a Rida', worn over the Khimar. This was the view of Ibn Mas`ud, `Ubaydah, Qatadah, Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Sa`id bin Jubayr, Ibrahim An-Nakha`i, `Ata' Al-Khurasani and others. It is like the Izar used today. Al-Jawhari said: "The Jilbab is the outer wrapper. `Ali bin Abi Talhah reported that Ibn `Abbas said that Allah commanded the believing women, when they went out of their houses for some need, to cover their faces from above their heads with the Jilbab, leaving only one eye showing. Muhammad bin Sirin said, "I asked `Ubaydah As-Salmani about the Ayah:
﴿يُدْنِينَ عَلَيْهِنَّ مِن جَلَـبِيبِهِنَّ﴾
(to draw their Jalabib over their bodies.) He covered his face and head, with just his left eye showing.''
Mr Ghamidi is defining this ayah with its context also,it is the ayah of temporary symbol in a situation for to recognize, not order of Hijab,for that it is in Surah Noor
Completely twisted meaning and context.
Ghamdi is simply awesome 🎉
Ghamdi point of view is most balanced..the other side of panel have a weak understanding of the matter and surface narrations.. May ALLAH give us best guidance.
"I THINK"..................Everybody tried his or her best. However, despite Mr. Ghamidi is always a great observer and presenter of facts with keen eye, this time, Ms. Taiyba Yousfi (Allah-e-Yahfazuk) responded, questioned, and answered (mostly) like a "purely faithful" Muslimah. MashaAllah. Her questions didn't receive satisfactory answers! Her answers didn't receive satisfactory appreciation or agreement.
May Allah grant her even better in this world and the Next. And may Allah forgive us all in this world and the Next.
And Allah Knows Best.
Please highlight one instance where she made a Solid point or asked a Question that wasn't answered?
Gambidi is so perfect and thorough in discussions ... no match for his intellect ...!!
Nadia Taha moulana and the scholar besides him were clueless
It's interesting that when this program aired, I was on the traditional side and didn't knew who Ghamidi Shab was, and though that who is this Fake Mullah without beard challenging our traditions. But now After 20 years I am watching again with Ghamidi Sahab Point of View and Cant help Smile how my concepts have change throughout these years.
Welcome to the enlightenment
Same here ... I have lived the example n teachings of Mullahs n realised how fake n men oriented it is n only when I started thinking rationally Ghamdi Saheb's points made sense to me n also what I love about his teachings is that he takes historical context n facts with n explains how we should take teachings n guidance from the Quran. Mullah hve rested all those years after the 4 Imam n never thought that time demands work n development. My question is why today after putting women in burqas men have started fulfilling their sexual desires from other men or kids? Isn't it true that we ourselves have put this idea of sex symboles about women in men's minds. This is ridiculous that West has found all the gems of the Quran n we kept covering n restricting our women more n more n achieved NOTHING!!!
Well you can contradict with any one of them. I think that we should appreciate that everyone is calm and at serene when debating an hot topic.. Any person who is listening to this can make up their own notion based on the rational argument by any of them.
You can't imagine these days that kind of educational debate without lashing out to others...
Yeh aurat apne aap ko jaahil kehti hai phir bhi ise itni himmat ke ulama je saamne baithi hai
Chi chi chi
Ghamidi sb on top as always.... MashAllah... In a nutshell... Dress modestly, be modest, keep your eyes clean...and dont dress for attention...if some women wear hijab, so be it... if some dont let them be as long as they dress modestly....
enlightenment assured with ghamadi sahab.
No doubt ❤
Surah Noor Me Ghar Ke satar ke bare Me Discussion kya gaya hai aur Surah Ahzab Me Bahar Ke Hijab Ke Bare Me Discus Kiya Gaya Hai... Lekin. yaha Par Gamdi sahab bhi aur Molvi sahab bhi dono commandment ko mix karne Ko koshis Kar rahe hai.... 🇮🇳
Wo es k bary Mai buhat clear Hain mix ap Kar rahy hain
@@umairhasan8671 aap bataye kya mix hua Hai?
Bro,Pura padho,Surah Noor ki 3 ayat milaker dekho Waha doo alfaaz istimal kiye Gaye hain.
"Bait ul Maskunah"."Bait ul Gair Maskunah)...na ki khaali. Gher.
Surah Ahzab ki ayat puri padho,yeah waqti tor per ik shinakht ke liye na ki chere aankh band kerke girne ke liye.
(Religion without science blind)
@@ahsanansari4679 Bro,Pura padho,Surah Noor ki 3 ayat milaker dekho Waha doo alfaaz istimal kiye Gaye hain.
"Bait ul Maskunah"."Bait ul Gair Maskunah)...na ki khaali. Gher.
Surah Ahzab ki ayat puri padho,yeah waqti tor per ik shinakht ke liye na ki chere aankh band kerke girne ke liye.
(Religion without science blind)
Ghamadi Sahab outclassed every other person here....
aaj k dour mai jab log porn daikhty hu unko yeh pta na ho k hatho or chehry ka parda hai ya nhe. Afsoos hai.
26:00 Ghamidi sahab jawab nahi dey sakey. Kia aaj fitna ka daur nahi hai ? Quran ek tadbeer bata raha hai or hum apni aqal lara rahey hain.
29:56
Apni aqal lga kar hi tum use tadbir keh rhe ho or gaamdi saahab use waqti tor par kia jaane walaa hikmati ahkaam kha 😂
Ghamdi Sab is great scholar.
Is anyone not raising eyebrows over the fact that all the ghamdism praising accounts have such similar comments? Ghamdi the visionary. Ghamdis knowledge is vast. Ghamdi this, ghamdi that.
I also admire Ghamidi Sahab. But these people are real fanatic. They don't think deeply what ghamidi sir conveying to us. Rather praise him immensely to show that he is superior than typical Mullahs. They are like those fanatic of every group. Good for nothing.
Because he is ❤
Ghamidi sahab saari baatein sahi karte karte end main gadbad kar baithe...
Agar hijab ban hota hai west main to musalmano ko hijab tark karke taleem ko tarjee deni chahye ...ok
1- Agar musalman country asa hi kare ghair Musalmano ke sath aur force kare hijab, to ghamidi sahab yehi kahenge?
2- Agar western countries kal ko kahen aapko mini skirt pehen na compulsory hai education ke liye to bhi muslamano ko apni tehzeeb tark kardeni chahye aur mini skirt main apni maa betiyon ko allow kardena chahye. Right?
simply, Ghamdi is the best.
ghamidi sb really ......awsome
Ghamidi shab as always balanced approach
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi 👌🏻👌🏻
Ghamidi sahab tak kon ponch sakta hai, ye kin loogu ko ein k samnay bitha daitay hain🤦🏻😂
Uh can't mess with ghamidi ⚡
Islamic scientist !
Aj gamdi sahb ukhde nazar aa rahe hi
Love you 💞💞💞😗 ghamidi sahib
ghamdi sab you are great sir👍
Ghamidi sb is logically and evidentially wrong.
All of them don't match for ghamidi sb intellect
Ghamdi is confused person he misguide people. May Allah give us true understanding of islam and give all of us hidaya.
Gamidhi sb is great!
ghamidi is great
Ghamdi is not perfect because he added its own opinion , which is not allowed in islam
M.IQBAL Anjum pls tell me wht did he added? Which is not allowed as per quran/sunnat pls..
give daleel
I found Ghamdi clear and to the point. Great explanation....
Asa.ghamdi sahab app azeem alim hy
Kya yeh ghandi sahib ki Biwi hai jo boys cut karke Ulma mey bethi hai
Alima is the best
ghamidi doesnt know even the etiquettes of conversation. he keeps on intrupting both scholars in their turn and keep twisting his tongue. such a misguiding person.
You are wrong
Mr Ali : Mr Ghamdi's etiquettes (akhlaq) cannot be challenged !
ghamidi provides his (opinions) without evidences.
he mis-interprets quran which clearly differs from the intrepretation told by muhammad pbuh and as interpreted by sahaba r.a and salaf.
may allah deal with this fitna ghamidi. liberals love him because he say what they want to hear. what a shame that if our woman dont consider ummhatul momineen as their idols who else.
quran is for whole humanity and it does not differ between muslims. no one is better in the eyes of allah except who has more taqwa. the quran is for all men and woman until qayamah. ghamidi is clearly misleading our youth.
ghamidi is a liar. he has no evidence only his "opinions".
His views are balanced u can not understand that, only highly intellectual understand him....
Moeen Ali hahahhaa ur a joke.. go and lsn to the moulvis who tell tales from hadeeth books. Thts wht narrown minded ppl like u deserve..
Ppl like u jst pick one ayat from a whole surrah bt nvr understand the whole comtext of tht surray
I pity ppl like u
Lesson mizan lecture fot more understanding ghamidi.
rabia Bibi rightly said sister!
And if anyone needs his book pls contact me! I can send u for free via email. Hve a soft copy
@@alimansoor6459 only Quran is the true guidance 👍
ye kin logon ko ghamidi sahb k saath betaya hua hai
fozia wahab.. hasnt covered his head even and came to talk about hijab. hillarious.
ghamidi only presents his (opinion) without evidence. and any opinion without evidence has no value.
we understand quran the way prophet pbuh told us and not the way ghamidi interprets it.
both are jahil.
Gambidi is so perfect and thorough in discussions ... no match for his intellect ...!!
Ghamidi sahab tak kon ponch sakta hai, ye kin loogu ko ein k samnay bitha daitay hain🤦🏻😂