Operation Searchlight, Mukti Bahini & the Involvement of India | Ep 2 | A Twisted Tale of Betrayal

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 147

  • @alitaimoor1482
    @alitaimoor1482 2 роки тому +14

    Well, Eastern Pakistanis deserved better when Awami League won the election. Ayub had already treated them harshly and then Mr. Bhutto and Yahya ganged up on them. What did they expect?
    Funny that they never teach us about atrocities committed in East Pakistan.

  • @saifuddin7187
    @saifuddin7187 2 роки тому +22

    Attacking Indian airfields by the pak air force on the order of army cheif was a blunder and pak army chief was not sincere to resolve east Pakistan political issue

    • @usmang5542
      @usmang5542 2 роки тому

      Don't you think war was already certain by that time? Afterall, the PM of India asked her chef if he was ready to go to war in April. He said he'd prepare and wait for winter.

    • @anshuraj4277
      @anshuraj4277 2 роки тому

      @@usmang5542
      Pakistan was illegitimate state anyway

  • @premkumar-tt2ix
    @premkumar-tt2ix 6 місяців тому +2

    There is no way Bangladesh would have gained independence without direct interference of Indian armed forces because Pakistan had America giving them weapons and aid .

  • @khalidhasan7581
    @khalidhasan7581 2 роки тому +41

    93k is a world record

    • @usmang5542
      @usmang5542 2 роки тому +3

      WW2 Germany vs Russia. 200,000 surrendered in Ukraine.

    • @amitbfl
      @amitbfl Рік тому

      Haa hahaha ....
      So it's not world record.. sad pakis fail... Next time

    • @MediaMangers
      @MediaMangers Рік тому +5

      No, and only 25000 to 28000 were Army active personals and rest were civil infrastructure and semi government intellectuals etc. There is complete prove of it in official documents, all you need to do some effort and work.

    • @Kashif0473
      @Kashif0473 Рік тому +4

      35,000 army, navy and airforce employees in total. 93K included all the west Pakistanis including civilians.

    • @MediaMangers
      @MediaMangers Рік тому

      @@Kashif0473 Well explained.

  • @manuchoudhary852
    @manuchoudhary852 2 роки тому +27

    India had to intervene to correct the situation as Bangladeshi people are our brothers who faced tremendous hardship. It was our duty.
    Ayesha jalal is a corrupt historian who present the facts selectively to promote the army's agenda. She is part of the problem by not sharing the truth. Lately the research by scholars like Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed has brought out lot of facts which was known only to select quarters.

    • @manuchoudhary852
      @manuchoudhary852 2 роки тому +2

      @@AbdulSamad-jw6xq u r right. specially the work done by Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed has brought lot of clarity to the freedom struggle.
      BTW do you know who Ayesha Jalal is married to ? very interesting Indian connection....Sugata Bose who is related to Subhah Chandra Bose.

    • @danishbhat3377
      @danishbhat3377 2 роки тому

      Since when Bengalis became your brothers as per that logic even Pakistanis are your brothers .kya kya chutiye h internet p

    • @usmang5542
      @usmang5542 2 роки тому +2

      Are Kashmiri's anybody brothers? If Indians are such brotherly and humanitarian, why is it so hard for them to fathom a referendum in Kashmir and end the misery?
      I think while there west side did a lot of injustice, it didn't amount to secession. There was unwarranted Indian intrusion as well as ego for power in the party leadership just as much as the west side.

    • @manuchoudhary852
      @manuchoudhary852 2 роки тому +6

      @@usmang5542 instead of wondering about kashmir why u people dont focus on what u already have. just look at the state of balochistan and rest of pakistan. there is so much of gaps and things to improve instead of keeping masses wondering about the impossible and thereby diverting them from.
      anyway more and more i think about pakistan and more and more i thank british and jinna for creating pakistan for the "peace loving" people. just look at the gap...where India is headed and where ur "paradise" is headed. biggest achievement of 75 years is international terrorist hub and international beggars .... while India is focusing on health/education/science & Tech......we have reached Moon and Mars ....something u cannot do even in 1000 years....

    • @usmang5542
      @usmang5542 2 роки тому +6

      @@manuchoudhary852 Congratulations on reaching the moon and mars. Great to hear your newfound focus on health/education/science and technology. What are all these for? The betterment of the people? If yes, then give Kashmiri people their rightful referendum for freedom. If you are such better and peace loving people, why is that much harder than going to the moon or mars?
      It sounds like to you have not caught wind of how polluted the indian media has become and is absurdly misconstruing events and grossly misinterpreting the facts.
      There are certainly countless things that require improvement and are being worked. There is no reason why Kashmiri should not get their freedom to choose after as you mentioned you have been enjoying for 75 years. Why couldn't you wait and focus on all the things you talk about?

  • @lopezalehandro1666
    @lopezalehandro1666 2 роки тому +3

    03:01 Rajarbagh Police Line, 04:51 politicians found it..., 05:17 made the declaration, 05:25 East Pakistan Rifles, 09:24 Swaran Singh, 09:28 Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed

  • @zhsana4611
    @zhsana4611 Рік тому +4

    Read "Dead Reckoning memories of the 1971 Bangladesh war" By Sarmilla Bose.

  • @khalidhasan7581
    @khalidhasan7581 2 роки тому +10

    love bangladesh
    long live bangladesh

  • @wanderlustavi2171
    @wanderlustavi2171 2 роки тому +13

    Good to see Pakistani UA-cam channel posting this .. it would be good if u attach that iconic photo of surrender..

    • @nassermj7671
      @nassermj7671 Рік тому +1

      Of how easily you let a fellow High Schooler have Aksai Chin? Not a bullet fired, scared like sht! Yeah that was something. you are right. How 'brave' you are with Primary Schoolers. Shame on you. Doob Maro!

  • @rifatulislamrishad9809
    @rifatulislamrishad9809 Рік тому +3

    Love India from Bangladesh

  • @faizan_ukk
    @faizan_ukk 2 роки тому +10

    Make episodes on PTM and their demands. Make episodes on Gwadar protests. Show the people their valid and fair demands. We need to prevent another Bangladesh War!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @shihabuddin4007
      @shihabuddin4007 2 роки тому +1

      Ptm is nothing but stooges. They won one seat that also at the mercy of pti who let them win by not nominating candidate

    • @liaquatali1278
      @liaquatali1278 2 роки тому +1

      میرے بھائی فیضان خٹک آپ کا کوئی قصور,نہیں ھے,,پاکستان کے قادیانی نے سب مسلمانوں کو آپس میں لڑوایا ھے,,تو آج آپ پشتون مسلمان ,,بنگالی مسلمان ,,بروھی مسلمان ,بلوچ مسلمان ,,پنجابی مسلمان ,,سندھی مسلمان ,,سرائیکی مسلمان مہاجر مسلمان یو آپس میں لڑ رھے,,یاد رکھنا اگر,آج ھم باز نہ آئے تو پھر ھم سب کا حال بھی فلسطین ,لبنان , مصر ,عراق ,,لیبیا شام ,سوڈان یمن اور,دوسرے مسلمانوں جیسا ھی ھوگا,,,کافر,ھندو ,,عیسائی اور یہودی ,بدھ مار,مار,کر تمھارا,بھرکس نکال دیں گے,, آج بنگلہ دیش صرف نام نہاد آزاد,ھے,,کیوں کہ بنگالی مسلمان آج بھی غربت میں مر رہا ھے,,,بنگالی مسلمان خواتین صرف 2 ھزار,روپیہ میں فروخت کر دی جاتی ھے,,لعنت ھے ایسی آزادی پر ,,,پھر سے خلافت قائم کرو,,مرد مسلمان بنو,,,

    • @nassermj7671
      @nassermj7671 Рік тому +1

      You an Indiot incognito? Nice try!!

  • @Emmy-wv1jy
    @Emmy-wv1jy 2 роки тому +9

    Jinnah said Pakistan is a two nations theory ,, Bangle never want to be a part of Pakistan, because they welcomed British in 17th century,, at partition time , British are not willing to give bangle as country,, So bangle fallowing Jinnah and able to transit liberation with Pakistan,

    • @zaryankhan8977
      @zaryankhan8977 2 роки тому

      Now we wish ,pakistan would not have accepted east bangale ,n india would have captured it n thy would also hav been suffering like other muslims in india.

    • @sarvathavicharsheel7487
      @sarvathavicharsheel7487 2 роки тому +2

      @@zaryankhan8977 why would India take East Bengal?
      And if you were so much concerned for Indian Muslims why didnt you take them all

    • @thebestevertherewas
      @thebestevertherewas Рік тому

      @@zaryankhan8977 🤣

    • @everythingerina9379
      @everythingerina9379 11 місяців тому

      @@zaryankhan8977 You idiot! Don't you know Bengal gave the biggest vote to create Pakistan? The All India Muslim League was founded in Dhaka in 1906, did you know? Pakistan betrayed the Bengalis the Bengalis were treated unfairly.

    • @zaffhussain2314
      @zaffhussain2314 7 місяців тому

      Well Bangal betrayed the whole sub continent in 17th century and helped Britain to take over, all leaders of Muslim league was from Bangal from 1948 to 1958 there were 7 prime ministers from Bangal they have done nothing. Ayub wanted to reform East Pakistan but Hussain Shaheed Sawerdi, mujib rehman played their own game. And Later on he was involved in agartala case thatswhy Pakistani Army could not trust him and he was a security risk. Well 25 march operation was to fined the Mukti bahini's Hindu bangalis whom mascared the West Pakistan civilians. Later on they killed Mujib, Osman, and Zia-ur- Rehman. Also to get everyone's facts right there were 30k regular and 13k reserves soldiers of Pakistan and rest were Civil servants of West Pakistan whom where working at Airport banks and other departments. Both Pakistan and Bangladesh are better off separated from each other.

  • @kumar7586
    @kumar7586 2 роки тому +8

    It looks like Captain Oli Ahmad got carried away telling his story.
    He says that the Mukti Bahini fought its own war and would have liberated Bangladesh on its own!
    Is he crazy? Bangladesh would never ever have come into existence without Indian armed intervention.
    It was an India-Pakistan war. India lost nearly eight thousand soldiers in that war. The Mukti Bahini was India's creation. Bangladesh is India's baby.
    I used to think that Pakistan was the only country in the subcontinent which teaches its school students false history.
    I was wrong. Bangladesh does the same.

    • @rohitkashyap7476
      @rohitkashyap7476 2 роки тому +2

      Kya farak padta hai.....
      Let them think whatever

    • @miahmdmostafajamal3009
      @miahmdmostafajamal3009 2 роки тому +1

      Stop your mouth brother. Muktibahini free bangladesh not Indian army.

    • @rohitkashyap7476
      @rohitkashyap7476 2 роки тому +2

      @@miahmdmostafajamal3009 yea yea sure....

    • @kumar7586
      @kumar7586 2 роки тому

      @@miahmdmostafajamal3009 Are you a child? It was an INDIA-Pakistan war.
      Your pathetic Mukti Bahini could never have made Bangladesh.
      At the surrender, not ONE of your great Mukti Bahini leaders was seen. General Niazi surrendered to General Jagjit Singh Aurora, NOT to MAG Osmani, Ziaur Rahman or Khaled Musharraf. These people were all under OUR command.
      If your Mukti Bahini was SO powerful, then your present army must be a thousand times stronger. You should have helped the Afghans defeat Americans!
      Why don't you help us in defeating Pakistan NOW? Please send your MIGHTY Bangladesh army to the line of control in Kashmir and crush the Pakistan army. Take revenge for 1971!
      Help us please! 😄🤣😜😄😄

    • @rahatzaman8120
      @rahatzaman8120 2 роки тому

      VIETNAM .

  • @tahirhassan5720
    @tahirhassan5720 Рік тому

    N Pakistani nation listening patriotic songs 😢😢💔

  • @himelsamuelharney5992
    @himelsamuelharney5992 2 роки тому +5

    It's hilarious that people with insanely stupid grammatical mistakes in English are claiming to know the truth. English toh likhne meh Jan nikal ja raha hai orr Chale critical arguments present karne.

    • @zay4110
      @zay4110 2 роки тому +1

      English ka truth jannay se kya lena dena hai bhai?

    • @AbhayPeshin
      @AbhayPeshin 2 роки тому +2

      Colonial mindset se bahar niklo, English is not the marker of a good argument. Maybe in Pakistan?

    • @rahatzaman8120
      @rahatzaman8120 2 роки тому +1

      What English has anything to do with it ?
      And Truth ? Everyone has thier own version of "truth" .

  • @belalhossain6969
    @belalhossain6969 2 роки тому +4

    Noblest of Prophets Muhammad saws said..if you are behaya..shameless, u can do anything...your are pure examples of deceit, most murderous nation ?? Genocide on unarmed, rickshawwalas and innocent women..how will you stand with such crimes against humanity on Laylat al Qadr...

    • @kumar7586
      @kumar7586 2 роки тому +3

      You are right.
      But the Bangladesh army has done the same to the Chakmas in the Chittagong Hill tracts.
      The atrocities committed by the Bangladesh army in the CHT are as horrendous as those of the Pakistan army against Bengali Muslims in 1971.
      In fact, Bangladesh has gone one step further. It has settled hundreds of thousands of Bengali Muslims in the CHT thereby reducing the Chakmas into a minority in their own land!
      Isn't Bangladesh a "pure example of deceit and murderous nation" as you described?

    • @MeUltraNoobsDeath
      @MeUltraNoobsDeath Місяць тому

      @@kumar7586 "Bangladesh Army done the same" I have many Chakma friends they dont want independence only around 20% of Hill tract people want independence and those are the really poor ones

    • @kumar7586
      @kumar7586 Місяць тому

      @@MeUltraNoobsDeath That is not the point. The Bangladesh army too committed horrendous war crimes while crushing the Chakma insurgency in the late 1970s and 1980s. People who live in glass houses should not throw stones.

    • @MeUltraNoobsDeath
      @MeUltraNoobsDeath Місяць тому

      @@kumar7586 "Glass houses" lmao the average Bangladesh is x2 richer than the average Pakistani. And what source do u have that says stuff like that?

    • @kumar7586
      @kumar7586 Місяць тому

      @@MeUltraNoobsDeathMillions of Bangladeshi Muslims work as cleaners and drivers in the Gulf.
      Your national profession is: cycle rickshaw driver!
      Until recently, most of your Bangladeshi "Muslim" women used to not even wear blouses. That is not uncommon in rural Bangladesh even today.
      What kind of Islam is that?

  • @filmyprofessor_99
    @filmyprofessor_99 2 роки тому +5

    What done mistakes they didn't let the journalist in for telling people of West and the workd about after the Bhola Flood and give much and much humanitarian for people of Bengal and sideline the politics and think about Pakistan first

  • @Unknown93unkown
    @Unknown93unkown 2 роки тому +8

    Make episodes on layari Karachi please

  • @rupeshchoudhary6497
    @rupeshchoudhary6497 2 роки тому +9

    Bangldesh live long

  • @arsalanmirza3411
    @arsalanmirza3411 Рік тому +2

    Is history repeating 🔁 again in Imran Khan’s Pakistan 🇵🇰

    • @nassermj7671
      @nassermj7671 Рік тому +1

      Not really Indiot, you can stop dreaming 'Akash Malhotra'.

  • @Fitness4Freshies
    @Fitness4Freshies Рік тому

    My earlier comment was removed which is such a shame. The Bengalis were killing non Bengalis and Biharis and west Pakistanis (you can read books published by Bengalis where they boastfully say such things) .
    Was the army supposed to sit idly and watch or protect its citizens? The army operation was justified and in my opinion a bit too late, the operation should have happened much earlier to nip the problem in the bud.

    • @ansazeem1234
      @ansazeem1234 11 місяців тому

      So you agree that the Bengalis were not our own citizens? lol such hypocrisy. You don't respond to civilian violence with further civilian violence

    • @Fitness4Freshies
      @Fitness4Freshies 11 місяців тому

      @@ansazeem1234 hahahaha Bengalis were Pakistanis until 1971 but they were killing Biharis and other West Pakistanis. Later the Bengalis killed sheikh Mujib

    • @ansazeem1234
      @ansazeem1234 11 місяців тому

      @@Fitness4Freshies hmm i wonder why please learn history

    • @Fitness4Freshies
      @Fitness4Freshies 11 місяців тому

      @@ansazeem1234 hahaha yes please learn history …

    • @MeUltraNoobsDeath
      @MeUltraNoobsDeath Місяць тому

      And so were the biharis killing bengalis its literally vise versa. You Pakistanis claim that Bhutto and Yahya Khan and Ayub khan and jinnah were angles and mujib and bengalis were murderous villians

  • @muhammadnuman8557
    @muhammadnuman8557 Рік тому +1

    Lots of love for Pakistan from Oman
    (Mascat)

    • @nassermj7671
      @nassermj7671 Рік тому +1

      Lots of love to the great nation our family from Oman

  • @saadshahzad6104
    @saadshahzad6104 2 роки тому +4

    No visuals

  • @sumi9546
    @sumi9546 Рік тому

    Joy bangla 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩

  • @faheemsardar
    @faheemsardar 2 роки тому +7

    Russia and India among other countries interfered. Pakistan warned Russia of revenge and got it. After East Pakistan India has had a lot of problems. In this strange time my father defeated the Indians on the west and captured Chhamb.
    India got lucky. Go through their interviews of Gen Jacob. How many separation movements are there in India at the moment?
    It was a logistical miscalculation it appears.
    India is still at it and failing this time. TTP and others are all supported by India.

    • @AbhishekTiwari-qt7fr
      @AbhishekTiwari-qt7fr 2 роки тому +2

      Lol still trying to defend your coward army.

    • @sarvathavicharsheel7487
      @sarvathavicharsheel7487 2 роки тому +20

      India had captured 1300 kms in West Pakistan
      Those portions were returned to Pakistan by India in a good will gesture

    • @faheemsardar
      @faheemsardar 2 роки тому +1

      @@AbhishekTiwari-qt7fr read history. Remember 1948? 1965? 2019? India is nothing without its partners.

    • @faheemsardar
      @faheemsardar 2 роки тому

      @@sarvathavicharsheel7487 how sweet. Where did you get the 13000 figure? Recheck it. It is a customary thing.

    • @AbhishekTiwari-qt7fr
      @AbhishekTiwari-qt7fr 2 роки тому +1

      @@faheemsardar looser always give excuses. Please focus on paying next EMI to IMF.

  • @rizwankhan-lk2og
    @rizwankhan-lk2og 2 роки тому +6

    pakistan should help the kashmiri freedom fighters militarily to end attrocitites being done by india...

    • @pradeepra
      @pradeepra 2 роки тому +16

      Lol we are going to capture karachi and lahore in coming decades.

    • @rizwankhan-lk2og
      @rizwankhan-lk2og 2 роки тому +3

      @@pradeepra haha..send abhinandan tea is getting cold..

    • @pradeepra
      @pradeepra 2 роки тому +9

      @@rizwankhan-lk2og poor chap eager to see you on other side of border when we dissolve pakistan to federally adminstered indian provinces.

    • @knightofgodserventofholymo7500
      @knightofgodserventofholymo7500 2 роки тому

      Kashmiri doesn't want to be part of Pakistan....even the separatist in Kashmir want an independent state

    • @TheEngrAsad
      @TheEngrAsad 2 роки тому

      @@AbdulSamad-jw6xq
      China got its land back from India and killed many indian soldiers with iron rods. We shot down indian planes and captured abhinandan while india shot down its own helicopter and sacked its own air chief and than killed its own chief...

  • @wkhan5
    @wkhan5 2 роки тому +5

    The video should begin with the numerous killings on non-Bengalis that the Awami League supporters started well over a month before operation searchlight. The country was lawless, where the Awami league gangs could kill with impunity. Even Mascarenhas article writes about the atrocities that the Bengalis had been carrying out BEFORE operation searchlight

    • @rahatzaman8120
      @rahatzaman8120 2 роки тому +4

      And you are totally ignoring how the Biharis were killing the Bengalis too .
      We wouldn't just sit back and let the Biharis behead us .
      ( No hard feeling towards the Biharis now btw .. the current generation of Biharis are doing well with thier small business now .. they are part of our country .
      Some are doing better like my family doctor is from the Bihari community .
      Sh---it happens during war and conflict . I am not denying that )

    • @wkhan5
      @wkhan5 2 роки тому +2

      @@rahatzaman8120 Biharis had no reason to first start killing Bengalis in a state where they were in a minority. The killings were started by Awami League goons. This is not to take away from subsequent atrocities that Biharis would have been involved in. I am setting the record straight

    • @rahatzaman8120
      @rahatzaman8120 2 роки тому

      @@wkhan5 possible .. both parties blame each other . So at this point I just leave that bloody history behind .
      The 1971 war was not just about Biharis either . They just became a chess piece in a bigger political game .
      As if the PAK elite of that time really cared that much about this poor little bihari community here . They had bigger plans .

    • @rahatzaman8120
      @rahatzaman8120 2 роки тому +1

      If there was no "operation searchlight" .. I have a feeling that Pakistan may remain untied .
      But at the same time .. the union of west and Pakistan was unrealistic . We are too far away from each other . And this is Bengal with its own historical background .
      The idea that muslims should remain together also doesn't really apply here considering that Afghanistan arabia or Turkey is not part of Pakistan either .

    • @sharifraihan5192
      @sharifraihan5192 2 роки тому

      Napakistan killed 3 million people, raped 2-4 lac women, killed 1000 intellectuals, 1 crore people fleed to India to save their life. At last on 16th December, 1971 napakistan cowards, bustard, genocider, rapiats shamefully surrendered. Napakistan murdabad, 93000 surrender murdabad, suor e azam jinnnah murdabad

  • @khanmohed3236
    @khanmohed3236 2 роки тому +2

    اب اس ملک میں حضور کا دین تخت پر آ کے رہے گا انشاءاللہ
    اور ملک لبرل ازم کی بجائے اسلام ازم کی طرف جائے گا انشاءاللہ
    لبیک لبیک لبیک یا رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم
    تحریک لبیک پاکستان

    • @fatimasohail224
      @fatimasohail224 2 роки тому

      Tragic loss for pak

    • @knightofgodserventofholymo7500
      @knightofgodserventofholymo7500 2 роки тому

      But sahih Bukhari hadiths says that Muhammad was a rapist.... burglar and a cruel war lord cum slave trader.....exmuslims in my land spreading those verses and many muslim youth left religion according to a maulawi...