Excellent! No it's not Peking opera style, if you know what real Peking opera sounds like. It is a form of the traditional Western classical style which evolved in China to take on certain Eastern characteristics, which may give one the impression of being thin if you are used to hearing someone like Tebaldi or whatever. But it is extremely beautiful, and not thin at all, very fine singing. My grandmother was trained in this technique and it is instantly recognizable. Beautiful.
thank you for this BEAUTIFUL rendition. You are both two fine musicians who have captured the beauty for us. You, dear singer, you touch me profoundly. I appreciate your technique and your artistry. You, dear pianist, support the singer to perfection. You both work wonderfully together, like my dear partner Michel Prezman and I work together. The public must be very happy when you share your art. I hope you continue and I wish you both great success. The beauty of Chinese culture must be shared.
she purposely used peking opera technique to convey this song in this way. she is more than capable of delivering traditional operatic songs in a very beautiful way. if you've heard her other renditions of other songs, you'll know what i mean. particularly nightinggale song. very beautiful. s
@GermanOperaSinger I've always loved this song when I heard it on the radio as a child. I can appreciate the lyrics as a grown-up. Thank you for your explanation. I can appreciate it more after reading your comment. I'm not a critic, but I think this lady sings it really well, too. :-)
@GermanOperaSinger I actually prefer this to the "thicker" traditional Western classical style - I feel this singing technique suits the style, period and character of the song better.
She is the most fantastic singer who sang this song. 太棒了,吴碧霞.你是前无古人,后无来者,唯一能唱出红豆词精髓的女歌唱家.
好一個當代藝術歌曲博士，不同凡響。👍👍👍👏👏👏
大家可曾聽過童麗唱的嗎？
吳小姐唱的恢弘大氣，高貴華麗；童麗唱的幽幽魂繞，淒美動人。兩位都是此曲的最佳演繹者，只是風格不同，各有千秋。
听了一圈儿，民歌还是吴碧霞最登峰造极。太精致了，每一个细节都好完美。这才称得上学院派啊。
william Mian Wei 嘗試閉眼
同意，這是我最愛聽的 版本
中詞西唱是20年代各著名音家為中國歌曲，用西洋歌曲的唱法，注入原素，開拓新的领域，例如有踏雪尋梅，花非花，红豆詞，教我如何不想她...還有更多...吳小姐唱得很動聽，和范宇文教授唱這首歌，同樣帶有西洋唱法韻味，簡單的一首美好的詞句，一個歌手，配上一個鋼琴，這個三結合，給我們带來悦耳動聽，韻味無窮的享受，謝謝上載分享!
你都戇居嘅，劉雪庵作曲，曹雪芹作詞呀，你當佢地係鬼佬牙。烏下烏下
你看清楚，我沒有當人家戇居。我也沒說紅豆詞不是劉雪庵譜曲，曹雪芹作詞。
我說中詞西曲。用中國詩詞，譜西曲唱法。更多的還有陽關三叠，用唐朝王維詞。岳飛的滿江紅....
紅荳詞乃出自紅樓夢。
譜曲劉雪庵先生是現代人吧，作詞曹雪芹是近古人，大概是明未清初吧。
這首歌是典型中詞西曲，有何不對?
吳碧霞音色純淨很美,聽了再聽,好享受.
吳碧霞女士不愧為女高音歌唱家可以說是名不虛傳的！
這是值得我們尊敬的！
吳老師：我是澳門居民郭家棟請多多指教！
紅豆詞我很喜爱听，吳碧雫的唱腔太好听了，谢谢。
太棒太棒 感動我的心 改天我也自彈自唱看看 謝謝這麼棒的聲音分享 愛彈琴愛唱歌的台灣姑娘祝福您永遠這麼棒的美聲 在台灣祝福您
妙音旋律💖👍
Excellent! No it's not Peking opera style, if you know what real Peking opera sounds like. It is a form of the traditional Western classical style which evolved in China to take on certain Eastern characteristics, which may give one the impression of being thin if you are used to hearing someone like Tebaldi or whatever. But it is extremely beautiful, and not thin at all, very fine singing. My grandmother was trained in this technique and it is instantly recognizable. Beautiful.
M
Heard this song in a pub in Oslo for the first time couple of months ago. So glad I finally found it! It's so beautiful
It’s a gorgeous Chinese song!!
❤
聽過後有如餘音繞樑三日般.......!
thank you for this BEAUTIFUL rendition. You are both two fine musicians who have captured the beauty for us. You, dear singer, you touch me profoundly. I appreciate your technique and your artistry. You, dear pianist, support the singer to perfection. You both work wonderfully together, like my dear partner Michel Prezman and I work together. The public must be very happy when you share your art. I hope you continue and I wish you both great success. The beauty of Chinese culture must be shared.
第一夫人唱好聽呀，我從冇聽過話紅豆詞係西曲噃，真係敝鄉。
動聽極了，不下周小燕大師
一副好嗓子 ！
仍然是周小燕小姐唱得最好。
Wu Bixia 吴碧霞 เพลงลูกคอเสียง โอเปร่า นักร้องจีน ที่มีชื่อเสียง และ ร้องเพลงพื้นบ้านคนแรก
she purposely used peking opera technique to convey this song in this way. she is more than capable of delivering traditional operatic songs in a very beautiful way. if you've heard her other renditions of other songs, you'll know what i mean. particularly nightinggale song. very beautiful.
s
天籟聲音
好聽的歌聲 CCTV 好棒的製作
Her voice and signing are just exemplary!
What a wonderful performance!
就是这个味儿，能看见大家闺秀在帘边皱眉。
真的好美....把中國韻味都唱盡了..
雞皮疙瘩。。。。太棒了感情太到位了
liew fang 嘗試閉眼
絕唱！
ชอบคนนี้ที่สุด เสียงแบบนักร้องยุคโน้นแท้ๆ ไม่ชอบเสียงถงลี่ ชอบร้องแอ๊บแบ๊ว
金铁霖大加赞赏的高徒，吴碧霞
金铁霖高徒满座 彭丽媛也是。
@GermanOperaSinger
I've always loved this song when I heard it on the radio as a child. I can appreciate the lyrics as a grown-up. Thank you for your explanation. I can appreciate it more after reading your comment. I'm not a critic, but I think this lady sings it really well, too.
:-)
词作得太妙了。
紅樓夢作者曹雪芹作詞。
Chills....what a voice!
@GermanOperaSinger I actually prefer this to the "thicker" traditional Western classical style - I feel this singing technique suits the style, period and character of the song better.
very good
She is perfect!
2022年全世界华人美声唱法声乐大赛 金獎：一萬美金。告訴您的親朋好友，大賽章程詳見新唐人官網。
大赛宗旨
本届“全世界华人美声唱法声乐大赛”是由新唐人电视台主办的国际文化艺术比赛系列赛事之一。
比赛宗旨是为了弘扬纯真、纯善、纯美的正统声乐艺术，帮助全世界有才华的华人声乐家走上世界舞台。
...................................................................................................................................................................................................
那有這樣。睡不穩？
紅目魚。又不是我害他們的。
還是喜歡聽 童麗 唱的 低音板..
吳小姐唱的恢弘大氣，高貴華麗；童麗唱的幽幽魂繞，淒美動人。兩位都是此曲的最佳演繹者，只是風格不同，各有千秋。
好象童丽唱的更好听。😜
吳小姐唱的恢弘大氣，高貴華麗；童麗唱的幽幽魂繞，淒美動人。兩位都是此曲的最佳演繹者，只是風格不同，各有千秋。
鸡皮疙瘩都起来了…………
她唱法有民歌还有美声唱法 不是纯粹民歌
感觉这个版本跟唱歌剧似的，还是喜欢王洁实版本的
Beautiful Wu Bixia!!
Do you know where would be possible to find the scores for this version of the music?
Thank you very much.
介绍你们听范宇文唱的，可以比较这两位唱得怎样。其他的就不怎么样了。
我比較喜歡范宇文的版本，范宇文的聲音比較豐富，吳的比較沒那麼多變化，范的演唱方式比較婉轉，吳的演唱比較直白，范的感情也比較有變化。
這一位不知道是誰，唱得也不錯，但從展不開眉頭開始就比較弱....總之，我最喜歡范宇文詮釋的。
韓藝璇唱的也有一定水準。
好像音與影像不同步
@catshaw56
ur name just fit her voice,haha.
have fun cat fan club
石秋玉阿姨，是海星幼稚園，電視星海羅盤，搞亂了。戰地鐘聲，兩座平行橋平行線，我們的橋炸掉了。
喪鐘。林喪鐘。李進昌李進興，阿松。阿松昰不昰陳茂松？
拍拍手
擴音器開得過大,失去原味.
Ming Wah Leung 什麼是原味？
確實有點"西化"了,可能也是先入為主的結果吧~
鋼琴編曲比不上國樂版好聽⋯我覺得啦
呀！！！！！野猫叫！！！！！
还有那些奇怪得划音，把古人得优雅唱得荡然无存！
呀～～～～～閣下是評論還是在叫罵？？？？？
那樣優雅的古人之曲，可惜啊可惜！竟被旁聽者破壞了...
古人？谁是古人？
现代的
Beautiful Wu Bixia!!
Do you know where would be possible to find the scores for this version of the music?
Thank you very much.
Hi! If you haven't found it and still need it, I can send it to you :)