Does Judge Judy Think The MENENDEZ Brothers Should Be Freed?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 гру 2024
- Judge Judy Sheindlin is in her fourth year starring on the Amazon Freevee series “Judy Justice”! During a wide-ranging interview for her new season of the hit series, Judy shared her perspective on the case of the Menendez Brothers and their resentencing hearing set for Jan. 30. "Judy Justice" is streaming exclusively on Amazon Prime Video.
“I don’t think our justice system should have anything to do with entertainment “… says Judge Judy, who’s been making millions upon millions off of her TV court show!
GOOD POINT. lol
True
She supported Trump!!!!!!!!
@Acronym6197 that's unfortunate.
they must never trust to this judge judy with abuse victims' cases again because his level of ignorance is astonishing 🥴 fortunately that has several judges who supported the release of the menendez brothers. we are in 2025 the judicial system has evolved, mental illnesses such as battered woman syndrome are now used as a defense in the courts because it knows the heavy impact of trauma on the brain of the victim of abuse which does not allow him not finding a reasonable solution. and in this case we speak of "imperfect self-defense" then the maximum sentence is 3 to 11 years in prison like the case of arnel Salvatierra or gyspy rose.
6 expert psychologist world renowned who evaluated Menendez brothers they determined that they suffer from the Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder (C-PTSD) and Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) and that at the time of the crime they acted out of fear he was convinced that their abusive parents represented an eminent danger to their lives. and by conclusions in imperfect self-defense, the trial is unfair, they must not only release the Menendez brothers from prison but also compensate them for all these years of injustice
I think that theses poor guys have paid their debt and have suffered enough.. Let them go free..
Poor guys.. Whatever
they must never trust to this judge judy with abuse victims' cases again because his level of ignorance is astonishing 🥴 fortunately that has several judges who supported the release of the menendez brothers. we are in 2025 the judicial system has evolved, mental illnesses such as battered woman syndrome are now used as a defense in the courts because it knows the heavy impact of trauma on the brain of the victim of abuse which does not allow him not finding a reasonable solution. and in this case we speak of "imperfect self-defense" then the maximum sentence is 3 to 11 years in prison like the case of arnel Salvatierra or gyspy rose.
6 expert psychologist world renowned who evaluated Menendez brothers they determined that they suffer from the Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder (C-PTSD) and Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) and that at the time of the crime they acted out of fear he was convinced that their abusive parents represented an eminent danger to their lives. and by conclusions in imperfect self-defense, the trial is unfair, they must not only release the Menendez brothers from prison but also compensate them for all these years of injustice
"Poor guys"???
They killed their innocent mother. They were adults and not being abused anymore. They could've just left home... like most abuse victims
If they were Black, would you have the same leniency?
@TheRedScareIsAlive exactly I totally agree
Poor guys?.....that would be the sentiment if they were being attacked and defended themselves, which led to them killing 2 ppl and being sentenced for it......
This is not that case, they did this deliberately, and had were not in anyway in any harm or danger where they had to protect themselves, by which they killed someone.
But by your logic, everyone who's been in jail for murder and served lengthy sentences, should be let out.....cause after all they been in jail and suffered enough right?
But why did they MURDER their MOTHER so viciously???? They deserve to STAY IN JAIL. PERIOD.
Set them free
Facts naw
Did JJ really just say, "I don't think our Justice System should have anything to do with entertainment "?! 👀
...while making $50M a year filming her reality court show. Girl, bye.
It's not a movie her show they are real cases though friend. That is permitted. I'm in legal field it's not for entertainment it's for court cases that allow public viewing
I agree with judge Judy!!
It is not like they are seriel killers...
Exactly. Everyone here assumes they might do it again but what would the reason be? They killed two people who abuse them.
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
FREE THE Menendez Brothers ❤
They blew their mom’s face off then blasted both of her knees, 10 times they shot her. That is wicked. They both could’ve left home. Both were old enough to do that. They didn’t want to leave the money. I agree with judge Judy. Some say she contradicts herself about courts being swayed by entertainment but the difference is she is not swayed in her rulings by public opinion because she is ruling before it goes to air. It’s not the same
If your mom had ALLOWED your dad to s**lly abuse you for years, you might do the same thing.
Plus the other stuff she did to them.
Well They parents are pedophiles 💀 they must never trust to this judge judy with abuse victims' cases again because his level of ignorance is astonishing 🥴 fortunately that has several judges who supported the release of the menendez brothers. we are in 2025 the judicial system has evolved, mental illnesses such as battered woman syndrome are now used as a defense in the courts because it knows the heavy impact of trauma on the brain of the victim of abuse which does not allow him not finding a reasonable solution. and in this case we speak of "imperfect self-defense" then the maximum sentence is 3 to 11 years in prison like the case of arnel Salvatierra or gyspy rose.
6 expert psychologist world renowned who evaluated Menendez brothers they determined that they suffer from the Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder (C-PTSD) and Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) and that at the time of the crime they acted out of fear he was convinced that their abusive parents represented an eminent danger to their lives. and by conclusions in imperfect self-defense, the trial is unfair, they must not only release the Menendez brothers from prison but also compensate them for all these years of injustice
You could say the same thing about the Turpin family, who had near 30 year old children still home, being abused and are named as victims. Certainly, they could have left home without the parents being able to do much about it, but still, they were there being tortured. You might think they were free, but they sure didn't seem to think they were
Have you ever been abused from a young age?
Well the mom’s sister says to let them out
I think the brothers should be set free
Let them out! Kids shouldn't be SAed!!! 😢
Wasn't expecting her to say, "Yes".
Judge Judy is a judge with real televisied cases to educate masses not to entertain. Its to allow viewers to see what a case decision is like in public. Her choice she is not joking around nor she trying to gain fame by movies. She is just televising her cases as a right to do so. Im in legal field if she feels that glorifying cases so horrific are wrong i agree.
If she were in the business of education, she’d be teaching law somewhere, not on TV presiding over small claims court. She has made multi millions as a celebrity judge whose brand is to berate and dress down her plaintiffs and defendants. Thats what people tune in for. To see her yell at people. Not to be educated. That’s why the show is filmed in HOLLYWOOD!
U know what’s gonna happen it’s gonna be Gypsy rose all over again if they get released the media will glorify them and make out like there some kind of brave superstar they will have tons of deals and interviews a documentary and more they will make millions off of this
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
I agree. Instant influencers if they are freed.
Judge Judy tells it as she sees it ❤
The Menendez brothers even if they were free from prison nobody wants to hire them 🤷
They have family to take care of them.
What does this have to do with anything. And yes as said above they have family money. And can do some non public facing roll in many lines of work.
But they can write books, give interviews, be part of documentaries etc, and get paid MILLIONS !!
They can also start their own businesses, anything ~ they're both pretty smart.
@@jojobee42 I agree. And Erik might become a professional artist and display his art work in galleries. And Lyle wishes to continue his therapy groups and help prisoners in jail.
@@jojobee42That’s what I was thinking. To be honest, they should have already been receiving money from all the way people gave profited off of their pain over the years.
Hardly a surprising take from Judgemental Judy.
I agree. Reloading isn't self-defense.
God blessings. Judge. Judy.
❤
Keep them locked up!
Not me thinking the title said “Mendes” as in “Shawn Mendes” 💀🤦♀️
Their mother knew what the dad was doing and didn’t ever intervene, she sa’d Lyle when he was a kid, she was also very physically abusive. Why don’t people do actual research before saying their opinion
I agree judge judy
I have to call BS. They could have walked away. The reason they didn’t was money. They could have left but they would have to leave the money. That is rhetorical reason these two spoiled parts shot their mother in the face. For the money.
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
You're incorrect
No they should not be set free these two kids premeditated the murder of their parents and should never be set free!!!
They would've never been considering release if they were black
Stop 🛑 that
JUDY BYE GIRL🙄
Thank god.
The abuse claim is a tactic. People should see through it.
Unfortunately people aren't very bright anymore. Thank God these monsters were locked up back in the day....fast forward 2024 they would be given the Keys to the city.
It’s not a tactic, 50 defence witnesses testified to Jose being abusive and kitty enabling it. 2 cousins testified to hearing about SA when the brothers were young children. There were literally photos taken by the parents of the brothers “body parts” which are evidence of abuse. Erik also has an unexplained throat injury from when he was 7 years old which corroborates when the SA first started happening, normally if the injury happens because of a fall the parents would specify it and it would be in the medical record, but it was labelled ‘unexplained injury’. So it’s not a tactic there is alot of evidence proving SA and physical abuse you have watched the whole trial.
@Swasgg13 Total tactic.
They need to be freed!
Gracious.
I don’t think they should be released. Just like other cases similar to this they still killed two people and they should serve there time in prison. They don’t relook at other people’s cases so why are they doing it with this one. I’m not saying what they went through with there parents wasn’t bad but they could have gone and gotten help from someone instead of murdering there parents. Keep them in prison till there full sentence is over.
you clearly don’t understand, so i’m just gonna say to you to never tell someone how to tie their laces if you’ve never been in their shoes. they were scared out of their minds that leaving or getting help would get them killed, because that’s what their parents threatened to do to them.
And the 2 ppl were their parents
@@rondas7772 and the 2 people abused, one raped them, the other molested one of them, and threatened them with death.
they must never trust to this judge judy with abuse victims' cases again because his level of ignorance is astonishing 🥴 fortunately that has several judges who supported the release of the menendez brothers. we are in 2025 the judicial system has evolved, mental illnesses such as battered woman syndrome are now used as a defense in the courts because it knows the heavy impact of trauma on the brain of the victim of abuse which does not allow him not finding a reasonable solution. and in this case we speak of "imperfect self-defense" then the maximum sentence is 3 to 11 years in prison like the case of arnel Salvatierra or gyspy rose. 6 expert psychologist world renowned who evaluated Menendez brothers they determined that they suffer from the Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder (C-PTSD) and Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) and that at the time of the crime they acted out of fear he was convinced that their abusive parents represented an eminent danger to their lives. and by conclusions in imperfect self-defense, the trial is unfair, they must not only release the Menendez brothers from prison but also compensate them for all these years of injustice
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
Disagree Judy. Set them free. I wonder what Byrd thinks..
No, way! these guys are guilty! It was brutal. Abuse doesn't give you a license to unalive people, but this generation will have you believe otherwise.
So you would like child peds to roam free?! 🤨
They deserve to be free… but Gypsy Rose didn’t? I swear y’all people only like them cause of that dumb ass show.
What's the point of putting ppl in prison
😂is this a serious question?
Just think about what you've just asked.
they must never trust to this judge judy with abuse victims' cases again because his level of ignorance is astonishing 🥴 fortunately that has several judges who supported the release of the menendez brothers. we are in 2025 the judicial system has evolved, mental illnesses such as battered woman syndrome are now used as a defense in the courts because it knows the heavy impact of trauma on the brain of the victim of abuse which does not allow him not finding a reasonable solution. and in this case we speak of "imperfect self-defense" then the maximum sentence is 3 to 11 years in prison like the case of arnel Salvatierra or gyspy rose. 6 expert psychologist world renowned who evaluated Menendez brothers they determined that they suffer from the Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder (C-PTSD) and Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) and that at the time of the crime they acted out of fear he was convinced that their abusive parents represented an eminent danger to their lives. and by conclusions in imperfect self-defense, the trial is unfair, they must not only release the Menendez brothers from prison but also compensate them for all these years of injustice
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
They should stay in prison.
Life should be actually life 😡
They should NOT BE FREED
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately
Why did they kill their mother?
C💓urtney 💓🥀💓🥀💙💙💙💓🥀💓
Had to like this comment because my name is Courtney 😍😁❤️
@@CcC864_20 😍😁💓 💙🥀
Mom dad thanks for life?
They killed out of fear of imminent danger to their lives All 6 expert psychologist world renowned determined that because of years of abuse since the age of 6 that lyle and erik suffered from the "Battered Woman Syndrome" by conclusion then it was of imperfect self-defense. then in the eyes of the law they are victims but not murderers and what they committed is considered self-defense. People suffering from battered woman syndrome after yearsof sexual, physical and psychological violence have such a significant impact on their state of mind that they develop anxiety, a feeling of helplessness and a perception inability to escape the abusive relationship that they can preemptively attack their abusers even when resting, sleeping or to when resting, sleeping or to avoid a situation in which they cannot protect their lives adequately