In the whole movie they were silent but their love was screaming through their eyes. They didn't touch each other but they were feeling each other through the air i just lived this💜💛💗🕉️.
You could have written millions of books using all the worlds in every language of the world, but you couldn't be able to tell even the tiniest moment of this film... This is the one of the best love stories in entire film history. Very sad to know that there are countless silent and un-lived love stories, even maybe right in our circle of people. I will never forget the way your film made me feel and cry. Thank you for this masterpiece and please know that the persons who watched your work are definitely very lucky to share it. And Murakami! Ahh what an impresive and intense detail. Congratulations!
I am straight. But it made me cry. Its so overwhelming. I can feel how one of my closest friend and brother would feel. My respect for him has increased. Beautiful protrayal of pure love !
You know the pain, they had in their eyes when the other one was crying, was really heart wrenching. And the empty train seats where the book was kept, to touch the seat and feel the person who was there a few moments ago was the purest form of love, I would say. Sometimes bodily touch doesn't really mean satisfaction. What really gives satisfaction is that they are very close even with that distance, that barrier between them but their souls touched eachother. Finally they know that, like the parallel lines of railway tracks they will be together but always on the different sides. They just can see eachother in pain, from the other side and be happy with that pain in their hearts. What love is? To be happy even with pain. This is just awesome. I think I have already watched it twice and will watch it for more times. This pain is so soothing. This heartbreak is so pure. Thanks to the cast n crew to make something which really touched my soul. It showcased something that is not very real and contemporary. But this is how it should be. This is how love should be.
His name is N...... We met in our workplace. He was dashing, handsome, arrogant yet had haunting eyes. Our gaze met frequently during long hours in the office at first. Then we interacted, we became almost friends. Our "eye" affair got intense. Those longing haunting gazes during presentation, board meetings, during coffee break or office outings. We melted and mated with those engaging gazes. And his smile whenever we made small talk...was this the same arrogant man I first flinched at?! But I felt reserved after all we were two men in India; and he was married. He left the office and nothing came of it. Only fond memories remains. Those eyes... sometimes I think. The ring on the finger of Jitin, one of the protagonist, triggered the memory. This haunting movie is an ode to all those gay men who could never love each other to fruition.
The story, like the train has no beginning and no end ..it is the journey what matters and who you take it with. Faraz Ansari ..hats off for this masterpiece and you once again proved that words always falls short when trying to describe an emotion.
😊 itna sannata kyon hai bhai....itna khula invitation hai to break the ice when the guy in dark colored shirt made a move to come closer.....ek Hi bolne mein kya jaata hai...seriously ishara na samjhe to koi kya kare 😢
This is incredibly pure, I was feeling the anticipation, fear and butterflies for them both. The touching of the seat, purposeful leaving of the book, and tension in the tiny steps forward and with their hands so close to touching. So glad homosexuality was decriminalised in 2018 but this was way to late for the hidden voices, untold loves and broken hearts. Beautiful short movie, id love to have seen how their story developed over time. ❤
My heart is half broken half healed right now. It really touched my heart, the removal of article 377 is only a starting for providing human rights, we still have to walk a long journey. It's a very humble request to every straight person that please let everyone love , it doesn't cost you anything. #loveislove
I am straight and I am big supporter of lgbt community. But many people don't understand this I dont know why. Some people still have problem with transgender. It is going to be long journey for our lgbt community. I can only do is hope sooner or later they get what they deserve ❤❤
@@SarveshSawant Oh, that's so sweet. Even, I'm an ally. I lost my brother, and I just regret I couldn't do anything. But, surely will not let any of brother to die anymore. I will fight for LGBTQ till my last breath.
This was emotional.. Many stories are untold.. Even now section 377 has gone but people's mindset is still not changed... Hope.....one day we dont have to feel scared about anything..... ♥️🌈
This is, without any doubt, the most beautiful written and acted LOVE story ever seen. No need of dialogue here since these two speak with their heart and mind. GOD is pure love, and I saw it and sensed it the minute they met. The crying of happiness, the approval gestures from the lips, the breathing of their souls together, the patience to get closer . . . a masterpiece of filmmaking, a great job from everyone who collaborated on making this film a reality for 2 individuals, no matter what sex they are. I have seen it 15 times and I will never get tired doing this. Once again, THANK YOU ALL!
I don't know why but it made me extremely sad and heartbroken 💔 this movie is a gem and true representation of South Asian LGBTQ community. Love from Pakistan.
I've waited for this short film for 3 years to end up crying for 15 minutes straight. I mean no wonder this won 59 International awards. it deserves it. Amazing acting by Dhruv and Jitin. And the music!! it honestly gets me every single time. It's soooo beautiful. Faraz sir, I can't even put it into words how much I love this baby our yours. Soooo beautiful!!
What a beautiful and powerful film. The actors did an amazing job conveying their feelings without speaking a word. When he touched his wedding ring, you felt his pain. Having to marry a woman to appease family and society. Having to repress who he truly is. So well done! Thank you for posting! 🙂✌🏻🙂
So many arranged marriages in India. That’s what I understood it to mean. They drew specific attention to it so that’s how I interpreted it. Each of us may see it differently. ✌🏻
This is so heart wrenching and beautiful. Such little details told the story; the Jitin looking at his wedding ring in one scene and Dhruv crying in the other scene, Jitin expressing his desire for Dhruv to come back closer to him and Dhruv's initial hesitancy to act on his feelings and the final scene of both dropping at the same station but different platforms knowing that their worlds are apart and separated but there is a point where they'll eventually meet and finally be together. Kudos to Faraz , Jitin, Dhruv and the whole team who made this fine piece of cinema.
Don't be afraid to be gay, if you're happy then don't allow people's beliefs or opinions to get you down, because in the end it's your life and your rules.🌈🌈
@@pikaboo5501 I relate, around some of my friends and relatives I pretend to be just like them. In reality I'm just so scared. It's so heartbreaking to be in a conversation like that but I have no choice.
If I cannot love someone like they do, if will be my bad luck. It is hard to fall in love but what is more difficult is to never been able to be with the 'person' one loves. When they look at each another and the other avert the eyes, and when they try to hide in books and the wait for the other one to come, it all looks so adorable. I love every moment of this film. Thanks to the creators for giving us this beautiful piece.
@@dalerider3124 I really hope your comment does NOT mean you stand against the gay community. But if your comments does mean you are against us, this is what I have to say to you - Love, lust, infatuation, crush, or whatever it does not matter. People should be able to feel and act on those feelings if they choose without fear and or persecution. No one has the right to control another and tell him or her who they can and can't have those feelings towards and if you are trying to control others in that manner, may you never know what true love is and never find the happiness you're trying to keep from others. May you always be longing, lonely, and miserable.
Dale Rider Don’t try to take the high moral ground by spitting out a pious platitude. Since all of us are embodied beings the body is integral to our life-experience, so don’t denigrate the physical element in love. Is there no lust in heterosexual love ? Of course love is much more than a physical sensation - it’s a complete emotion, it involves responsibilities, it entails care and commitment. But from where did you get the idea that only individuals from the opposite gender are capable of this psychologically enriching and ethically ennobling experience in relation to each other ? Never forget this truth : love transcends the binary of gender.
@@dalerider3124 Are you gay to know if it's lust or love? cause lots a gays people are not just looking for sex but life parter. And if that's the case... lot's of heterosexuals have lust and only think about fucking so... what's your point?
I so wanted them to speak up and express, but I could sense the space as well. It is beautifully shown. It is emotional and heart wrenching to see the guy cry.
Daily passenger's on Railways do not talk even if they smile at each other even if they are in stress in actual life. Especially the ones with pure heart and simple loyal lust. That's a fact and last local has many such homeless stories. Hugs are more peaceful than kisses and those are truly what shows human nature in pain and joy. Don't know why I wrote it there. 😊🙂
It´s truly a masterpiece. So much deep emotions without saying just one word. Their eyes said everything. Now I´m sitting here...crying. For me it´s still unbelievable that there are countries in 2019 who are against same sex love. I live in a country where same-sex-marriage is possible. We even have openly gay politicians, artists, actors, teacher ... Ok, we also have still homophobic people. But to have the right to be with the person I love is important. Don´t give up. Please stay strong and I´m pretty sure if everybody around the world is a little more open someday the world will be a better place! 🌈
This is the first indian short i ever saw, and it made me cry. I now watch other indian movies too. They are miles better than american movies because they seem so real.
Nothing much happened. But a lot happened. This is how art is. The camera work and direction are spot on and the background score is heartfelt. The emotions are portrayed incredibly by the two actors. It's too deep. Not a single word is there, but the eyes speak everything!
Beautifully portrayed. The chemistry between the two is so intense, cannot explain through words. Touched my heart deep inside my heart. I was getting goosebumps all the time. Background music touched my soul. Thank you Faraz, Jitin and Dhruv for this wonderful movie. Hoping for it's second part.
Can't belive yaar. The movie proved, love can happen without talk. Their expressions just amazing, the eye contacts. So silent but said so much. Salute to the makers and the actors 🫡 Hadn't even imagined such a love story, which won't have any words. Wish they had confessed their love.🫠
The cinematography, the expressions of the actors, the background score was so powerful and intense. Everything was perfect. And the moments between the leads were so pureee. I could feel their emotions!
Hello from Australia. This is a beautiful film, very moving, touching and sad. Great acting and photography. Their interactions back and forth reminded me of a ballet. Congratulations to all involved.
Pretty commendable how quite a lot was said without a single word being even mouthed or muttered. The symbolism, metaphors, and visual cues were used intelligently, sensitively, and with a keen eye.... Great job guys (everyone associated with the project)!
This is the best short movie ever. I can feel every single emotion the cry, the feeling of someone being their, the love etc. There is no wonder this won so many awards
my god this is truly a very nice short movie...its so precisely acted as well as directed....without saying A SINGLE WORD THIS BL gave me goosebumps.....i truly truly loved this...thanks everyone for making this kind of heart touching video...i loved this
Woow wow just Woooow what a pure romance and said a lot of things even without saying a word. Hats of to actors and director they nailed it. Simply magical.
Silent but powerful. A beautiful story. I wish they would smile at each other. You could just feel the love between them. I loved this story. It did bring tears to my eyes.
The best LGBTQ movie ever i have seen. No words needed to express love or feelings, this movie has proven it and it lifts a hope for somebody. Great work by the team of sisak. Looks like they were known to each other before the guy in suits got married, and now the silent journey in the train rekindle their romance.
I have ridden the train to work almost every day for 19 years. I have seen a lot, heard a lot, and yes even did...a little. But this movie, the sound of the train, the visuals of passing views from the door and windows, the music that helps to lead you through the anticipation, the looks to each other, their lips and eyes tell so much. To experience the wonderful joy of love, true, love without a word is humbling and exhilarating all at the same time. My heart was pounding as I watched...wanting more for both. Simply beautiful............
First and foremost Kudos to the team who made this movie happen.There is so much free flow of emotions that i literally could feel all of it.In the end i felt a lot of pain when they stood far apart in 2 different platforms filled with emotions but unable to convey it.I hope things change for the better in every nation.Love is love , it has no differentiation no caste no creed no gender.The will to be free and to be loved is the right of everyone.After long i watched something so beautiful yet so painful.
I think this video represent all the silent voice who cannot express themselves in Asia except Taiwan. This is remarkable video that should be watched by anyone in this world!
Breathtaking and emotional. Yes it made me tear up and ripped at my soul. Thank God that I live in American where love is love is love. Thanks for making such a touching film.
So wonderfully expressed!! Loved to hear that screaming voice in Silence. Kudos to you for expressing so vociferously for a Cause. India isn't still that Modern and Open.
I started off thinking, oh no, it's silent and I'll switch off in a minute or two. But this masterpiece didn't need dialogue. It had everything else. Visuals, emotion and movement. Like a beautifully choreographed dance. I could watch this again and again. The movement of the two characters, the emotional connection without touching. Stunning. A fitting tribute to what was until recently, forbidden love. Absolutely brilliant.
Excellent!!! Easily one of the best short films I have ever seen. Mr. Ansari, I can't thank you enough for making and sharing this movie. Amazing how powerful the storyline was with zero words! Truly brilliant! Just curious, did you have to get special permission to shoot the movie on the train? Or did you have to coordinate with the train's schedule and regular daily passengers?
O my god despite of being a straight also my eyes got teary so heart touching story it is...the society doesn't let u live your way this is the modern world where one doesn't has the right to live his life his way until this society will not change these kinda sacrifices will be continuously happening...... but love is love #live your life and let others live
Speechless.....no words to express my feelings after watching this.....so intense so deep....so meaningful and yet so heart wrenching...bitter truth.....heart just aches looking at them separated by the train tracks....such purity in the emotions...well done to the crew....amazing job
OMG. This was happend to me in subway when i was a student. He stand behind me and touch my hand. We just looked each other about 15 minutes. Same emotions as here happened to us. But next station he is left and I never meet him againe. 30 years past and I am still remember that eyes. Real storyline and wondefull acting. Well Done guys. 👍
Oh....so touching! Congratulations to the whole team of this film. I wasn't expecting such perfection......but it's brilliant! Acting, direction, concept, almost everything.....I really loved it.
The music was so powerful...It was so overwhelming, heart wrenching and heart touching at the same time , as if not only the characters but the music itself is trying to portray, trying to speak the enormous mix-up of feelings that the characters were willing to show towards each other... As if there is no need of words, words will only become futile but to feel, the feelings of no end~ *And can we also talk about that how good looking our actors are...Jitin is so dashingly handsome and Dhruv has those cute innocent charming looks....Oh my God they got so damn Good looks and their chemistry was like water, so smooth and so natural...Did anyone notices that their appearances got to improved each passing day and they both started to carry themselves more attractively, It's just my thinking but they could make a good couple ☺️ I love their acting *soooo* much that I can't help but to want a full movie which will probably be the sequel of this short film and want a Happy Ending with these two end up together* Lots of love to ♥️Jitin and Dhruv♥️
Probably the very first indian short film on LGBTQ love made so beautifully and executed perfectly... No need of explicit content to express the love.... Loved it seriously... Do make more like this...❤️
It's been 6 years I travel in train to my college many mens see me but I wait for one at 5:45 wadala to Panvel to see my man coming from where I don't know but when ever I see him my heartbeat becomes faster than before 🤪#silentlove
within seconds the characters took our heart, within minutes we fell all into their silence, and at the end without even knowing we also cried silently in their pain. this is such a masterpiece , the creator of this is just so brilliant
I don't know how many times I have watched it. No words, no touch, still connected at much deeper core. Silence is definitely underrated. All the best Faraz for Sheer Qorma. Wishing success like Sisak 💙❤️💚
Beautiful! Wonderful script, direction, actors and locations! How to say everything, without using the word. The attitudes and actions of the actors/characters overflow with desires, with love. Desire and libido in full bloom. There is a lot of truth and honesty in their love. The soundtrack is beautiful. I loved! I loved! Congratulations! - Lindo! Roteiro, direção, atores e locações maravilhosos! Como dizer tudo, sem usar da palavra. As atitudes e ações dos atores/personagens transbordam de desejos, de amor. O desejo e a libido a flor da pele. Há muita verdade e honestidade no amor deles. Linda a trilha sonora. Amei! Amei! Parabéns!
Beautiful portrayal of an unsaid and silenced love story in the *loudest silence* possible. No wonder the repressed and caged emotions can never be put up in words. 🌈❤
9:38 he shows his hand. In his ring finger. Their is a ring. He is married. Younger person is upset now. 12:16 now he is choosing him. But decision is younger person’s hand. He likes him too but he doesn’t have courage.
That's the purest form of Love, isn't it? That's something, we sometimes suffer from, while travelling in trains, in metro or in bus. But, we can't do anything. Because our eyes are doing everything. Beautiful !!
OMG OMG Finally I am watching this film, from a long time I was waiting for it, This is one of the best LGBT films I have ever seen. Thank you so much to each and every cast and crew for this beautiful film.
This silent film showed so many raw emotions in just a few minutes, emotions that cannot be said out loud, emotions that are unheard, hated, misinterpreted, and feared by society. Many bigots should understand that it is much more than sex. It's about love and everyone deserves love.
This is absolutely beautiful- the music, the acting and the longing. It breaks my heart to think that so many love stories are left unsaid and incomplete... I really hope that someday all of us find in our hearts the love to accept people for who they are.
Glad that people are more accepting lgbtq+ people and is no more afraid to talk about it 😍 Wishing of a future where lgbtq+ people don't have to come out, as straight people don't come out and say" guys, I'm straight "😬😜
Even if the spectator is straight, he can't deny the fact that the every moment of this short caption is seriously profound......, profound with deep rooted inexplicable emotions. Background score is undeniably breathtaking.....
It was pleasant to see or have someone who understand u completely,who notices ur loneliness n the shedded tears in d serenity but still holding on to be strong n not let the world overcome u .....Indeed a strong determination to RULE N OVERCOME THE MATERIALISTIC THINGS.........
Worth the wait ❤️❤️❤️.sisak is the reflection of pain of silence. The pain the suffering we deal everyday of our life just because we love someone who happens to same sex as us. Really wanna thank #faraz sir for this amazing short film ❤️❤️. You truly deserved the appreciation you got❤️❤️
In the whole movie they were silent but their love was screaming through their eyes. They didn't touch each other but they were feeling each other through the air i just lived this💜💛💗🕉️.
I can't even imagine what is the mentality of those people who disliked this beautiful creation..!! love is the worst thing to be hated..!!
hamare desh me orthodox logo ki kami kam hai ke ??
@Sangeeta Sarmah na ati sharam.kyon abega?? Galt kya kaha maine.hum kisike pyar me dabao na dal sake.har kisiko apna pyar chun neke hak ho.
Right.
You could have written millions of books using all the worlds in every language of the world,
but you couldn't be able to tell even the tiniest moment of this film...
This is the one of the best love stories in entire film history.
Very sad to know that there are countless silent and un-lived love stories, even maybe right in our circle of people.
I will never forget the way your film made me feel and cry. Thank you for this masterpiece and please know that the persons who watched your work are definitely very lucky to share it.
And Murakami! Ahh what an impresive and intense detail.
Congratulations!
Kya hum dost ban sakte hai 🫂🤝
I am straight. But it made me cry. Its so overwhelming. I can feel how one of my closest friend and brother would feel. My respect for him has increased. Beautiful protrayal of pure love !
अपने भाई और मित्र का हमेशा साथ देणा 🙂
😊🤭
You know the pain, they had in their eyes when the other one was crying, was really heart wrenching. And the empty train seats where the book was kept, to touch the seat and feel the person who was there a few moments ago was the purest form of love, I would say. Sometimes bodily touch doesn't really mean satisfaction. What really gives satisfaction is that they are very close even with that distance, that barrier between them but their souls touched eachother.
Finally they know that, like the parallel lines of railway tracks they will be together but always on the different sides. They just can see eachother in pain, from the other side and be happy with that pain in their hearts. What love is? To be happy even with pain.
This is just awesome. I think I have already watched it twice and will watch it for more times. This pain is so soothing. This heartbreak is so pure.
Thanks to the cast n crew to make something which really touched my soul. It showcased something that is not very real and contemporary. But this is how it should be. This is how love should be.
❤️
💝❣️
Exactly the way i felt.....
i loved it so much i can't even express in words....pure love knows no boundaries 😍
I actually kinda felt the same way .......
His name is N......
We met in our workplace. He was dashing, handsome, arrogant yet had haunting eyes. Our gaze met frequently during long hours in the office at first. Then we interacted, we became almost friends. Our "eye" affair got intense. Those longing haunting gazes during presentation, board meetings, during coffee break or office outings. We melted and mated with those engaging gazes. And his smile whenever we made small talk...was this the same arrogant man I first flinched at?!
But I felt reserved after all we were two men in India; and he was married.
He left the office and nothing came of it.
Only fond memories remains. Those eyes... sometimes I think.
The ring on the finger of Jitin, one of the protagonist, triggered the memory.
This haunting movie is an ode to all those gay men who could never love each other to fruition.
Gave me chills:( if not in this world, maybe in another
It hurts sam
So many homosexual men and women, forced to get married to the opposite gender... It's just sad.
The story, like the train has no beginning and no end ..it is the journey what matters and who you take it with.
Faraz Ansari ..hats off for this masterpiece and you once again proved that words always falls short when trying to describe an emotion.
👍❤️
Ya right no end
👍❤
😊 itna sannata kyon hai bhai....itna khula invitation hai to break the ice when the guy in dark colored shirt made a move to come closer.....ek Hi bolne mein kya jaata hai...seriously ishara na samjhe to koi kya kare 😢
“If you can love someone with your whole heart, just one person, then there’s salvation in life.”
- Murakami
Beautiful and true.
Well said3
@@michaelhaldar6506 can u make me understand the plot of this movie?
I agree with you buddy 👍
Bilkul Sahi bro.
This is incredibly pure, I was feeling the anticipation, fear and butterflies for them both. The touching of the seat, purposeful leaving of the book, and tension in the tiny steps forward and with their hands so close to touching. So glad homosexuality was decriminalised in 2018 but this was way to late for the hidden voices, untold loves and broken hearts. Beautiful short movie, id love to have seen how their story developed over time. ❤
Faraz should do a sequel to this.
My heart is half broken half healed right now. It really touched my heart, the removal of article 377 is only a starting for providing human rights, we still have to walk a long journey. It's a very humble request to every straight person that please let everyone love , it doesn't cost you anything. #loveislove
U r not different at least for me.enjoy ur life.
I am straight and I am big supporter of lgbt community. But many people don't understand this I dont know why. Some people still have problem with transgender. It is going to be long journey for our lgbt community. I can only do is hope sooner or later they get what they deserve ❤❤
@@SarveshSawant Oh, that's so sweet. Even, I'm an ally. I lost my brother, and I just regret I couldn't do anything. But, surely will not let any of brother to die anymore. I will fight for LGBTQ till my last breath.
Great👍 ❤is❤
This was emotional.. Many stories are untold.. Even now section 377 has gone but people's mindset is still not changed... Hope.....one day we dont have to feel scared about anything..... ♥️🌈
Yes .
True
Hi vikrant
🌈❤️🌈❤️ Love is 💕
That one day will never come, our destiny is to fade in dark!!🥺🥺
This is, without any doubt, the most beautiful written and acted LOVE story ever seen. No need of dialogue here since these two speak with their heart and mind. GOD is pure love, and I saw it and sensed it the minute they met. The crying of happiness, the approval gestures from the lips, the breathing of their souls together, the patience to get closer . . . a masterpiece of filmmaking, a great job from everyone who collaborated on making this film a reality for 2 individuals, no matter what sex they are. I have seen it 15 times and I will never get tired doing this. Once again, THANK YOU ALL!
Proud to be part of this film as an Associate producer!!!! ♡..... Sisak..... ~
..
Darya Red both actor Naam Kya hai detail milegi kya
Actor name??
@@alokkarn5568 Dhruv Singhal and Jitin Gulati
Hello
@@alokkarn5568 r u Chutiya?? 🙄🙄
Under oppression even silence speaks the loudest words.
Beautifully captured emotions of wanting to be loved and respected as human beings.
Aapka naam kya Mujhse Dosti Karoge Kuttippuram please
Absolutely true
❤👍
4 years after . here I am in 2024 watching this again and again wishing I will have something similar
I don't know why but it made me extremely sad and heartbroken 💔 this movie is a gem and true representation of South Asian LGBTQ community. Love from Pakistan.
I love Pakistan 💖💖💖💖💖🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈 i'm from Indonesia🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
I've waited for this short film for 3 years to end up crying for 15 minutes straight. I mean no wonder this won 59 International awards. it deserves it. Amazing acting by Dhruv and Jitin. And the music!! it honestly gets me every single time. It's soooo beautiful. Faraz sir, I can't even put it into words how much I love this baby our yours. Soooo beautiful!!
It's so sweet.....even I was waiting for years......that track lines ....fani duniya see pare
@@vishwanathdubey902 bottom boy ka naam kya ha ..
U cried for 15 mins gay*
@@kumararoshis4550 Dhruv
@@greenbalcony3904 Daaamnn good one😂
What a beautiful and powerful film. The actors did an amazing job conveying their feelings without speaking a word. When he touched his wedding ring, you felt his pain. Having to marry a woman to appease family and society. Having to repress who he truly is. So well done! Thank you for posting!
🙂✌🏻🙂
Why do you feel it's a wedding ring? Even men wear rings. It is normal for us to meddle our ring when we are tensed about something.
So many arranged marriages in India. That’s what I understood it to mean. They drew specific attention to it so that’s how I interpreted it. Each of us may see it differently. ✌🏻
This is so heart wrenching and beautiful.
Such little details told the story; the Jitin looking at his wedding ring in one scene and Dhruv crying in the other scene, Jitin expressing his desire for Dhruv to come back closer to him and Dhruv's initial hesitancy to act on his feelings and the final scene of both dropping at the same station but different platforms knowing that their worlds are apart and separated but there is a point where they'll eventually meet and finally be together.
Kudos to Faraz , Jitin, Dhruv and the whole team who made this fine piece of cinema.
Brillinat
The music, the acting, the story- all of it was beautiful. Loved it so much 🧡🏳🌈
Don't be afraid to be gay, if you're happy then don't allow people's beliefs or opinions to get you down, because in the end it's your life and your rules.🌈🌈
❤
It’s not that much easy to rule own life. 🙂
In a perfect world
But right now, i have to make crude comments about gays despite being one, so people accept me
@@pikaboo5501 I relate, around some of my friends and relatives I pretend to be just like them. In reality I'm just so scared. It's so heartbreaking to be in a conversation like that but I have no choice.
@@sooya_sauce8618 we are so pathetic
If I cannot love someone like they do, if will be my bad luck. It is hard to fall in love but what is more difficult is to never been able to be with the 'person' one loves. When they look at each another and the other avert the eyes, and when they try to hide in books and the wait for the other one to come, it all looks so adorable. I love every moment of this film. Thanks to the creators for giving us this beautiful piece.
This video is exactly how LGBTQ love is being silenced in all African countries and India ... I just hope people realize that love is love
LUST is not LOVE
@@dalerider3124 I really hope your comment does NOT mean you stand against the gay community. But if your comments does mean you are against us, this is what I have to say to you - Love, lust, infatuation, crush, or whatever it does not matter. People should be able to feel and act on those feelings if they choose without fear and or persecution. No one has the right to control another and tell him or her who they can and can't have those feelings towards and if you are trying to control others in that manner, may you never know what true love is and never find the happiness you're trying to keep from others. May you always be longing, lonely, and miserable.
Dale Rider Don’t try to take the high moral ground by spitting out a pious platitude. Since all of us are embodied beings the body is integral to our life-experience, so don’t denigrate the physical element in love. Is there no lust in heterosexual love ? Of course love is much more than a physical sensation - it’s a complete emotion, it involves responsibilities, it entails care and commitment. But from where did you get the idea that only individuals from the opposite gender are capable of this psychologically enriching and ethically ennobling experience in relation to each other ? Never forget this truth : love transcends the binary of gender.
Yes 💗
@@dalerider3124 Are you gay to know if it's lust or love? cause lots a gays people are not just looking for sex but life parter. And if that's the case... lot's of heterosexuals have lust and only think about fucking so... what's your point?
This short film deserves a feature film. Wonderful story!
No. It's perfect as it is.
I so wanted them to speak up and express, but I could sense the space as well. It is beautifully shown. It is emotional and heart wrenching to see the guy cry.
Very beautiful story, this is how we do struggle everyday to find love in the society. No one can understand ❤
Right
Daily passenger's on Railways do not talk even if they smile at each other even if they are in stress in actual life.
Especially the ones with pure heart and simple loyal lust.
That's a fact and last local has many such homeless stories.
Hugs are more peaceful than kisses and those are truly what shows human nature in pain and joy.
Don't know why I wrote it there.
😊🙂
akhilkumargautam hii
Have patience gradually society also recognise lgbt changing their angle of vision
it's difficult to understand
Not a single word has been uttered, but the emotions drowned us viewers....This is such a gem
I can finally share this beautiful movie with everyone I know! 28 hours to go! 🌈
Beautiful
It´s truly a masterpiece.
So much deep emotions without saying just one word. Their eyes said everything.
Now I´m sitting here...crying. For me it´s still unbelievable that there are countries in 2019 who are against same sex love.
I live in a country where same-sex-marriage is possible. We even have openly gay politicians, artists, actors, teacher ...
Ok, we also have still homophobic people. But to have the right to be with the person I love is important.
Don´t give up. Please stay strong and I´m pretty sure if everybody around the world is a little more open someday the world will be a better place! 🌈
Excellent movie. Very touching.and emotional. Superb background music. Keep it up. Waiting for more bold presentation. Best wishes.
This is the first indian short i ever saw, and it made me cry. I now watch other indian movies too. They are miles better than american movies because they seem so real.
Nothing much happened. But a lot happened.
This is how art is. The camera work and direction are spot on and the background score is heartfelt.
The emotions are portrayed incredibly by the two actors.
It's too deep.
Not a single word is there, but the eyes speak everything!
Nipun I like true frndsip Plzzz tell me came my Wtsp 9670711795
Nine store 8017953885
Amen ❣️
Nipun purohlt hi💋
Hii
Beautifully portrayed. The chemistry between the two is so intense, cannot explain through words. Touched my heart deep inside my heart. I was getting goosebumps all the time. Background music touched my soul. Thank you Faraz, Jitin and Dhruv for this wonderful movie. Hoping for it's second part.
Can't belive yaar. The movie proved, love can happen without talk. Their expressions just amazing, the eye contacts. So silent but said so much.
Salute to the makers and the actors 🫡
Hadn't even imagined such a love story, which won't have any words. Wish they had confessed their love.🫠
The cinematography, the expressions of the actors, the background score was so powerful and intense. Everything was perfect. And the moments between the leads were so pureee. I could feel their emotions!
Hello from Australia. This is a beautiful film, very moving, touching and sad. Great acting and photography. Their interactions back and forth reminded me of a ballet. Congratulations to all involved.
Thanks so much, Craig. Truly appreciate the love.
@@farazlovesjazz1 Beautiful ❤🧡💛💚💙💜🤎
Pretty commendable how quite a lot was said without a single word being even mouthed or muttered. The symbolism, metaphors, and visual cues were used intelligently, sensitively, and with a keen eye.... Great job guys (everyone associated with the project)!
Whenz the second part ? 2 ?!
A decent matured gay movie portrayed in a positive masculine way with emotions.
Really very nice
This is the best short movie ever.
I can feel every single emotion the cry, the feeling of someone being their, the love etc.
There is no wonder this won so many awards
This is call a LOVE
Hy
my god this is truly a very nice short movie...its so precisely acted as well as directed....without saying A SINGLE WORD THIS BL gave me goosebumps.....i truly truly loved this...thanks everyone for making this kind of heart touching video...i loved this
Oh my god... This silent shortfilm conveyed thousands of words...
Everything is at its best..👍
Hy
9929542343
Long awaited and very heartfelt. I can feel the pain of the characters as I'm also part of the LGBTQ society. 😭
nice
It's ok.enjoy ur life.i know it's difficult bt still it's ur one and only life,so fight for urself.have a good life.
💕💕
We need part -2,3,4 please 🥺🥺🥺🥺 I just want to see how these beautiful people take things together ❤❤
It mostly end up in pain
@@TheRahulsaran😢
Woow wow just Woooow what a pure romance and said a lot of things even without saying a word. Hats of to actors and director they nailed it. Simply magical.
Yaaaaa
Lovely! The scene where one cries and the other one has tears in his eyes. I Iiterally cried.
Anubhav Verma give me your no I like u
U no send me dost
Silent but powerful. A beautiful story. I wish they would smile at each other. You could just feel the love between them. I loved this story. It did bring tears to my eyes.
The best LGBTQ movie ever i have seen. No words needed to express love or feelings, this movie has proven it and it lifts a hope for somebody. Great work by the team of sisak. Looks like they were known to each other before the guy in suits got married, and now the silent journey in the train rekindle their romance.
I smiled when they smirked ❤️ So pure and beautiful! Well done Faraz and crew!
I have ridden the train to work almost every day for 19 years. I have seen a lot, heard a lot, and yes even did...a little. But this movie, the sound of the train, the visuals of passing views from the door and windows, the music that helps to lead you through the anticipation, the looks to each other, their lips and eyes tell so much. To experience the wonderful joy of love, true, love without a word is humbling and exhilarating all at the same time. My heart was pounding as I watched...wanting more for both. Simply beautiful............
First and foremost Kudos to the team who made this movie happen.There is so much free flow of emotions that i literally could feel all of it.In the end i felt a lot of pain when they stood far apart in 2 different platforms filled with emotions but unable to convey it.I hope things change for the better in every nation.Love is love , it has no differentiation no caste no creed no gender.The will to be free and to be loved is the right of everyone.After long i watched something so beautiful yet so painful.
This made me cry. I hope and pray our country will be more open and accepting in the coming days.
When the boy cries he cries , when the boy laughs he smiles...
This made me cry, it’s so pure and strong and beautiful! I’ve Been waiting for a long time to watch this, it was worth it !
This is so intense in the end! My heart almost sank!! That quietness speaks volume! Great film! Want Part 2 😍😍😍👌👌
I think this video represent all the silent voice who cannot express themselves in Asia except Taiwan.
This is remarkable video that should be watched by anyone in this world!
Plus thailand ..that both country not homophobic
Yaa😢😢😔😔😔😔😔
I am pleasantly surprised at how well this was made.… exceeded all of my expectations! Superb…
Breathtaking and emotional. Yes it made me tear up and ripped at my soul. Thank God that I live in American where love is love is love. Thanks for making such a touching film.
So wonderfully expressed!! Loved to hear that screaming voice in Silence. Kudos to you for expressing so vociferously for a Cause. India isn't still that Modern and Open.
Speachless... I'm so overwhelmed by the beauty and the poetry of this short....
Greetings from the Republic of India.
Vielen Dank Dear.
💐
Hy
Hi enio how r u
I started off thinking, oh no, it's silent and I'll switch off in a minute or two. But this masterpiece didn't need dialogue. It had everything else. Visuals, emotion and movement. Like a beautifully choreographed dance. I could watch this again and again. The movement of the two characters, the emotional connection without touching. Stunning. A fitting tribute to what was until recently, forbidden love. Absolutely brilliant.
Hay
Hay
Excellent!!! Easily one of the best short films I have ever seen. Mr. Ansari, I can't thank you enough for making and sharing this movie. Amazing how powerful the storyline was with zero words! Truly brilliant!
Just curious, did you have to get special permission to shoot the movie on the train? Or did you have to coordinate with the train's schedule and regular daily passengers?
Absolutely beautiful! I’m so glad I finally had a chance to see it ❤️
O my god despite of being a straight also my eyes got teary so heart touching story it is...the society doesn't let u live your way this is the modern world where one doesn't has the right to live his life his way until this society will not change these kinda sacrifices will be continuously happening...... but love is love
#live your life and let others live
Speechless.....no words to express my feelings after watching this.....so intense so deep....so meaningful and yet so heart wrenching...bitter truth.....heart just aches looking at them separated by the train tracks....such purity in the emotions...well done to the crew....amazing job
Being the part of this community I know how hard is it to hide the real u!!!!
And this story really touched me badly😭
We should not be hiding our real selves, that is what I feel. Please don't hide the real you! Be happy!
@@satyamchaurasiya8121 What makes what happen?
are u gay ?
@@satyamchaurasiya8121 ???
@@armansaikh7931 yes.
Ru?
What a masterpiece...... Brilliant acting and expressions💯💯
OMG. This was happend to me in subway when i was a student. He stand behind me and touch my hand. We just looked each other about 15 minutes. Same emotions as here happened to us. But next station he is left and I never meet him againe. 30 years past and I am still remember that eyes. Real storyline and wondefull acting. Well Done guys. 👍
Oh....so touching!
Congratulations to the whole team of this film. I wasn't expecting such perfection......but it's brilliant!
Acting, direction, concept, almost everything.....I really loved it.
The music was so powerful...It was so overwhelming, heart wrenching and heart touching at the same time , as if not only the characters but the music itself is trying to portray, trying to speak the enormous mix-up of feelings that the characters were willing to show towards each other... As if there is no need of words, words will only become futile but to feel, the feelings of no end~
*And can we also talk about that how good looking our actors are...Jitin is so dashingly handsome and Dhruv has those cute innocent charming looks....Oh my God they got so damn Good looks and their chemistry was like water, so smooth and so natural...Did anyone notices that their appearances got to improved each passing day and they both started to carry themselves more attractively, It's just my thinking but they could make a good couple ☺️
I love their acting *soooo* much that I can't help but to want a full movie which will probably be the sequel of this short film and want a Happy Ending with these two end up together* Lots of love to ♥️Jitin and Dhruv♥️
Their voices deserve to be heard and understand fully for their love stories need to be told
I'm never gonna emotionally recover from this. Just so beautiful.
Probably the very first indian short film on LGBTQ love made so beautifully and executed perfectly... No need of explicit content to express the love.... Loved it seriously... Do make more like this...❤️
It's been 6 years I travel in train to my college many mens see me but I wait for one at 5:45 wadala to Panvel to see my man coming from where I don't know but when ever I see him my heartbeat becomes faster than before 🤪#silentlove
Awww 😭💓🌈
@@satyamtiwari1174 now cause of lockdown I don't know!😕
@@takshkunchikorve4382 I hope you meet him soon !
That's so sweet !! So much of raw emotion ...best wishes man 😊
Yeah even i had that kind of heart beat being a man
Love in any form is just beautiful...seeing all the positive comments now it feels like India is finally evolving..
Finally, its on youtube, waited so long for the masterpiece. No words in the story and no words to describe that beautiful piece of work.
within seconds the characters took our heart, within minutes we fell all into their silence, and at the end without even knowing we also cried silently in their pain. this is such a masterpiece , the creator of this is just so brilliant
Words wouldn't have made this any better. The emotion said everything.
Right
I don't know how many times I have watched it. No words, no touch, still connected at much deeper core. Silence is definitely underrated. All the best Faraz for Sheer Qorma. Wishing success like Sisak 💙❤️💚
Hi shekhar
I Watched this film so many years back. Absolutely beautiful film ❤
Hiii😊
Beautiful! Wonderful script, direction, actors and locations! How to say everything, without using the word. The attitudes and actions of the actors/characters overflow with desires, with love. Desire and libido in full bloom. There is a lot of truth and honesty in their love. The soundtrack is beautiful. I loved! I loved! Congratulations! - Lindo! Roteiro, direção, atores e locações maravilhosos! Como dizer tudo, sem usar da palavra. As atitudes e ações dos atores/personagens transbordam de desejos, de amor. O desejo e a libido a flor da pele. Há muita verdade e honestidade no amor deles. Linda a trilha sonora. Amei! Amei! Parabéns!
Wow, some of the moments shown were really powerful. The background score added so much character to the entire film. Great work ❤
This is beyond amazing! No words needed, a story so beautiful, I'm sure it has resonated in millions of hearts, hopes and dreams! More power to you❤️
I felt every moment of this. Every gaze, every movement, every tear, every breath. EVERYTHING. Thanks Faraz for making this.
Wow. We need more films like this🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈❤️
Watch" I told sunset about u " this series is one of the best bl series I've ever watched 😭❣️🌈
Beautiful portrayal of an unsaid and silenced love story in the *loudest silence* possible. No wonder the repressed and caged emotions can never be put up in words. 🌈❤
9:38 he shows his hand.
In his ring finger. Their is a ring. He is married. Younger person is upset now.
12:16 now he is choosing him. But decision is younger person’s hand. He likes him too but he doesn’t have courage.
Aap Thik Se Samja Sakte Hoo Kya?? thoda Bahot To Samaj Gaya
This short film Beautifully expresses emotions so well without uttering a single word..both actors did a fab job...
I loved it deeply..
That's the purest form of Love, isn't it?
That's something, we sometimes suffer from, while travelling in trains, in metro or in bus. But, we can't do anything. Because our eyes are doing everything.
Beautiful !!
They didn't spoke a single word but at the same time they spoke a million words
OMG OMG Finally I am watching this film, from a long time I was waiting for it, This is one of the best LGBT films I have ever seen. Thank you so much to each and every cast and crew for this beautiful film.
I have been waiting for this to get on UA-cam since the day it was released. Finally, it is here.
Thanks ❤️
Same here.. n finally watching..
Exactly same here!
@@alokkarn5568 hi
@@alokkarn5568 hii
@@shadabqureshi6760 ha bolo
This silent film showed so many raw emotions in just a few minutes, emotions that cannot be said out loud, emotions that are unheard, hated, misinterpreted, and feared by society. Many bigots should understand that it is much more than sex. It's about love and everyone deserves love.
This was such a show stellar performance! Silence, can say so much which words even fail to express! Thank you @Faraz, for this gem!💗
In love with this movie......the pain showed in both the characters is so soothing ....it is so relatable.......more power to u ....❤️
Hi yash
@@amitsinha809 heyyy
@@यशsh Kya tum dosti karoge mujhse
@@यशsh hy
@@यशsh Hy kaise ho Mr janab nhi dya
This is absolutely beautiful- the music, the acting and the longing.
It breaks my heart to think that so many love stories are left unsaid and incomplete...
I really hope that someday all of us find in our hearts the love to accept people for who they are.
Glad that people are more accepting lgbtq+ people and is no more afraid to talk about it 😍
Wishing of a future where lgbtq+ people don't have to come out, as straight people don't come out and say" guys, I'm straight "😬😜
The sooner or later it will happen,justo believe me,We are allí sons of a same God
Best thing on youtube I have ever watch seriously. Loved the concept but the office guy is damm hot lol I wish I could have him looooooove🔥
It was beautiful.. 😍 I was amazed that this short film is Indian. I don't understand why people dislike it? I mean what's wrong with this??
Even if the spectator is straight, he can't deny the fact that the every moment of this short caption is seriously profound......, profound with deep rooted inexplicable emotions.
Background score is undeniably breathtaking.....
It was pleasant to see or have someone who understand u completely,who notices ur loneliness n the shedded tears in d serenity but still holding on to be strong n not let the world overcome u .....Indeed a strong determination to RULE N OVERCOME THE MATERIALISTIC THINGS.........
With tears in my eyes: how impressive, wonderful actors and unfortunately only too true
Worth the wait ❤️❤️❤️.sisak is the reflection of pain of silence. The pain the suffering we deal everyday of our life just because we love someone who happens to same sex as us. Really wanna thank #faraz sir for this amazing short film ❤️❤️. You truly deserved the appreciation you got❤️❤️