The fact that I watched Cleo’s POV first and nothing Grian did struck out of the ordinary other than when Grian asked Etho what he ate for breakfast. I thought that was weird but nothing else until I saw this.
Observation. Jimmy spent most of the time just kinda playing around with Grian. but the instant genuine danger gets presented to him, he drops the light tone and warns him The canary stopped singing to warn him
MY EXACT THOUGHT also etho at the end ... "I thought he was talking to his audience" ... considering watcher lore................ ALSO the viewers(aka watchers) were called voices in grians head more or less in evo as well.... AND jimmy was in evo.....
Knowing Etho's strategy has been to do weird things so people couldn't guess his task, he probably just assumed Grian was doing the same thing, on top off Etho just being a chill person in general and not minding other peoples business too much.
I genuinely, honestly wondered if something like that was happening. Not just Etho, I thought it'd be a great opportunity for everyone to get a postscript in their books of "Grian has to do everything Jimmy tells him to do. Go along with it and act like you don't notice, no matter how strange it gets" as like... a prank on Grian
This is honestly such a good representation of Jimmy's quick wit. Every sort of situation Grian was in he managed to find something hilarious for him to do
Skizz was right back in limited life at Affirmation Station. Jimmy has such amazing quick wit, he can make some of the drabbest things seem so interesting.
Funny how the secret keeper allowed jimmy back as a ghost instead of letting rejoin in a different name with a mustache just like in the hardcore series grian did with scar and joel 😂😂😂😂😂
I would love to see a future installment of the Life Series use a gimmick where dead players can stick around as guardian angels for the living players.
Afterlife? Or since that is taken, 4th life? If you die a third time(while on red) you come back to haunt a random player, if that player kills another player you take that newly deceased soul and live a 4th life said deceased soul then haunts you. If a haunted player dies both them and their spirit are banished permanently. How does that sound? I am not very creative
Main problem with that is the gimmick wouldn't do anything until the end of the series. But it could definitely be part of an overall gimmick, maybe like each life having some sort of ability.
Lowkey feel like dead players should continue to log on during sessions and essentially did commentary or gave their reactions to certain things. May also enable viewers to see later episodes focusing on everyone and what's happening across a session. Just feels like it would be a slice of life type thing.
@@SolidarityGaming I really hope Grian watches your episode and at least gets some satisfaction out of knowing how much you enjoyed messing with him :D
@@SolidarityGaming Jimmy, if you haven’t seen it yet, check out a hilarious fan-animation of this by “Shakly” called “Grian’s Questionable Guardian Angel!” Martyn already reacted to it, but it’s really funny and creative, and shows your fun friendship with Grian😊
The main thing that makes it basically impossible for anyone to realize this task is going on is almost everything tim suggested was just stuff grian would do anyway, grian tim joel and scar all have this like 4 brothers sort of dynamic when they play
@@tylermercado1445 the canary curse was never all about him dying first. It was about the chaotic apocalypse and bloodbath that followed his death. Dying first was just a side effect.
@@koo2463i count EP7 as the bloodbath that came after, rather than the warden / wither thing. EP6 had 2 deaths, and didnt have any rather long lasting consequences. (Well, other than mumbo's and jimmy's deaths) In comparison, EP7 had a LOT of deaths, and had resulted in no greens left, and the majority now being red.
The sheer fiendish glee on Solidarity's face the first few times Grian instantly obeys his commands....I hope Grian watches this episode and at least sees how much joy he brought Jimmy here.
“This must be a surprise to you. Yes it’s me Jim, and I’m dead, but I’m coming back today” 😂😂 so glad they threw the little pup a bone and let him back in the series
I just watched your "which Hermit are your" vid the other day and I think the fact that no one (including myself) thought Grain was acting weird really proves the result of that vid.
Lovely seeing more of Jimmy! +10 for Star Trek reference too! I really think this should be the premise of the next life series. Some players as ghosts, or players that die become ghosts, and they get to interact with live players. Personally I think Extra Life would be an excellent name.
im so glad it was grian who got the ghost task, because the two of you have such a fun dynamic. loved this episdoe, glad to have jim back even if only temporarily
Honestly was not expecting this but I can promise this just made my day to see you in another secret life episode. What a great early birthday gift 😂 No but seriously, you’re awesome Jimmy! I’m excited to watch the episode
I have a funny theory where the watchers didn’t kill Jimmy first because they already held a funeral for him and thought he was already dead. So when they saw that he was still alive after Lizzie they quickly took him out
@@AstralSpectre Lizzie fell into the void, the void is endless. Lizzie is still alive, just stuck. Jimmy still went out first. And since Mumbo was in the series he had to go out seconds after Jimmy because reasons (someone make one up, he died seconds after Jimmy the last season he was in, and seconds after this time too. It's now a Lore thing too). I don't think they'd do it but it would be hilarious if the winner clicked their succeed button at the end and Lizzie pops in instead of the loot and bops them dead. (Secret Keeper has to get all that loot from somewhere). To keep the Canary curse going.
Oh this was really cool!!! Ive always thought the ghosts should fly around and upload their perspectives anyway, being in spectator mode theyd have great views of battles and such.
@@garbagedataraccoon I've thought the same thing? But then I realized that'd mean taking three hours out of their day to record themselves watching something passively and commenting on it, and that's kind of a big ask for something they can't directly participate in. ...ooh, as a _group_ though? _That_ could be great.
Coming here straight from Grian's video because I need more of this, I loved this session so much, the dynamic between these two mixed with this challenge is just perfect :D
this episode was so funny from both of your perspectives. thank you for the laughs king. what skizz said in limited life about your comedic timing is so true and this episode is a great example of it
I live for any sort of ghost pov of the life series! The ones BigB and Martyn released in 3rd life were so funny. It's like a bonus unique perspective on events!
Limited Life animatics were like... dramatic team love and self-sacrifice... Secret Life animatics are gonna be like... Etho & Cleo dancing and twirling around... Can't wait.
This has been my favorite task yet, and that is saying something with all the fantastic tasks people have gotten this series. Whoever came up with this is brilliant.
To be fair, Grian does a lot of weird random stuff anyway. It seems like he always has some sort of little troublemaking angel on his shoulder 90% of the time
The fact that I watched Cleo’s POV first and nothing Grian did struck out of the ordinary other than when Grian asked Etho what he ate for breakfast. I thought that was weird but nothing else until I saw this.
Same here, honestly I clicked this one not reading whose channel it was thinking it was grians ... nice surprise. Got to finish the rest now.
I didn't even think the breakfast thing was out of character!
True. Jimmy was too nice to him. With all that power at his command he could have been a total menace
It’s great you can watch multiple povs and get a totally different experience
i watched gem first and "the leaves are all pointing upwards" did not even register
Jimmy somehow manages to weasel his way back in 😭😭😭😭
hes like a little worm 😭
Can't get rid of him
lil slippery eel
Like a true big dog
lmao @@puffin-talks-alot
Observation. Jimmy spent most of the time just kinda playing around with Grian. but the instant genuine danger gets presented to him, he drops the light tone and warns him
The canary stopped singing to warn him
"The canary stopped singing to warn him"
Why do I find the best lines in the comments section?!
14:15 I like how instantly the mood changes even if Tango was excited about slimeballs
bro is NOT beating the canary allegations
No wait that's such a banger line
There's an animatic in here somewhere I'm sure of it
Out of everyone to be paired together, Jimmy with Grian is the best because now Jimmy can torment Grian freely.
hi
@@rainbowmeifwa6469 Hello there
@@All54321general kenobe
That’s a bonus for Jimmy 😆
Torment is a STRONG word, hes kinda just making Grian be Grian since no one questioned it like at all.
" the ghosts all stay above the clouds and *watch* "
whoa, Jimmy, you just created lore.
As a artist, I am feeding off this one sentence
@@CometWasHere lol, YES
Glad I found a friend!
Also the fact Jimmy in this one was called an angel...
@@citra1885 I DIDNT THINK OF THAT!!!
So much lore potential… I’m losing my mind I can’t take this
MY EXACT THOUGHT
also etho at the end ... "I thought he was talking to his audience" ... considering watcher lore................ ALSO the viewers(aka watchers) were called voices in grians head more or less in evo as well.... AND jimmy was in evo.....
Knowing Etho's strategy has been to do weird things so people couldn't guess his task, he probably just assumed Grian was doing the same thing, on top off Etho just being a chill person in general and not minding other peoples business too much.
Yellows can only guess Green tasks tbf, so that's not even on the table anymore as an option for anyone
You're still probably right though yeah :P
@@Idran yeah, I thought of that, but Etho was doing it before there even was any yellows, so I could see him still have this way of thinking :P
Exactly what I was thinking XD
Jimmy and Grian are such brothers I swear! I love seeing them interact and seeing Jimmy get so excited to mess with Grian is always so funny
they really are like brothers from other mothers or something so good LOL
@@bunyan4.20 i love their dynamic
They do definitely act like siblings to each other 😆
@@mysticfox9718 man if I could get away with having my siblings do what i tell them, i’d be just as giddy as Jimmy 😂
grian sounded really panicked as soon as he found out lol 😅
It’s finally Jimmy’s turn to torment him, so it makes sense, really
Kinda cute that Jimmy used Grian to woof at Martyn from beyond the grave
i know rightt
i was thinking the same
Woah....I didn't realize how poetic that was....😢
he did too wait 😭
Etho's task must have been: Jimmy is telling Grian what to do, act as if everything is completely normal
I genuinely, honestly wondered if something like that was happening. Not just Etho, I thought it'd be a great opportunity for everyone to get a postscript in their books of "Grian has to do everything Jimmy tells him to do. Go along with it and act like you don't notice, no matter how strange it gets" as like... a prank on Grian
nope he just thought he was talking to his viewers lol
From what he said I assume it was: someone has a guardian angel, figure out who it is
@@coyotesvods3841I so wish this actually happened
He’s just quirky
This is honestly such a good representation of Jimmy's quick wit. Every sort of situation Grian was in he managed to find something hilarious for him to do
Yeah it was great
Skizz was right back in limited life at Affirmation Station. Jimmy has such amazing quick wit, he can make some of the drabbest things seem so interesting.
And then Grian found a great way to execute it. That Knock-Knock joke was top notch.
@@ritasonka330 these two really were the best duo we could have gotten for this task XD
This is the furthest that Jimmy has ever made it in a Life series. He may not be there in physical form, but he's there in spirit!
Lol
He was always there in spirit
7 in 3L 7 in LaL 5 in DL 7 in LiL and now to 8 in SL
Literally
"The leaves are all pointing upward."
*Etho and Cleo appear out of nowhere*
From gems perspective it seemed like some kinda code phrase lol
That’s awesome 😂 what was the time stamp?
@@AbbyX3652:35
Etho is such a sweetheart. Not questioning anything grian does lol.
Says he hates Etho's favorite Mario character and no reaction
Woofs when asked. No questions.
I like how Timmy tries to embarrass grian but it backfires.
Everyone is too used to each other being weird
@@darkdragoness5grain in the other hand EVEN IF HE IS OUT OF CHARACTER they still think its grian being grian
@@ser_ifwho is this grain character
@@SourVR- its the bread from hermitcraft season 7
Being weird is the new normal.
Funny how the secret keeper allowed jimmy back as a ghost instead of letting rejoin in a different name with a mustache just like in the hardcore series grian did with scar and joel 😂😂😂😂😂
Idk what you're talking about, that was clearly Grien, totally not just Grian with a mustache
@@meowtain9566exactly who would confuse grian and grien, have you seen grien's glorious moustache
I would love to see a future installment of the Life Series use a gimmick where dead players can stick around as guardian angels for the living players.
That would be an interesting concept: Ghost Life
Afterlife?
Or since that is taken, 4th life?
If you die a third time(while on red) you come back to haunt a random player, if that player kills another player you take that newly deceased soul and live a 4th life said deceased soul then haunts you. If a haunted player dies both them and their spirit are banished permanently.
How does that sound? I am not very creative
Main problem with that is the gimmick wouldn't do anything until the end of the series. But it could definitely be part of an overall gimmick, maybe like each life having some sort of ability.
@@ked49 That was the name of a whole other SMP that scott, joel, lizzy, gem, and jimmy were part of.
Call it: Life Guard
Seeing an episode from spectator mode is actually really fun, not to mention this particular task was fantastic
It makes it feel like a proper movie. It was awesome.
Lowkey feel like dead players should continue to log on during sessions and essentially did commentary or gave their reactions to certain things. May also enable viewers to see later episodes focusing on everyone and what's happening across a session.
Just feels like it would be a slice of life type thing.
The absolute sheer joy jimmy had doing this is absolutely making my day
Literally loved it so much
@@SolidarityGamingI really thought etho's task was:
'Grian has to do everything Jimmy tells him,pretend it's normal' lmao
@@SolidarityGaming I really hope Grian watches your episode and at least gets some satisfaction out of knowing how much you enjoyed messing with him :D
@@SolidarityGaming Jimmy, if you haven’t seen it yet, check out a hilarious fan-animation of this by “Shakly” called “Grian’s Questionable Guardian Angel!” Martyn already reacted to it, but it’s really funny and creative, and shows your fun friendship with Grian😊
The main thing that makes it basically impossible for anyone to realize this task is going on is almost everything tim suggested was just stuff grian would do anyway, grian tim joel and scar all have this like 4 brothers sort of dynamic when they play
Just imagining Jimmy as a tiny little angel sitting on grians shoulder and giving him tasks
That’s probably how most of the animatics will visualize it
And when he goes through the nether portal he gets knocked off 💀
@@LaughingOutLoud-lol OMG YES
He was pretty much just being Grian's intrusive thoughts and Grian was forced to let them take over lmao
LMAO
Dude he basically POSSESSED Grian to do that stuff lol
The Secret Keeper has let Jimmy live (via ghost) another day and he chooses to make it Grian's problem lmao-
To be fair, it was kinda Grian's fault that Jim died. He kinda had it coming!
I came from watching Martyn's POV and him getting caught suddenly made a LOT of sense. Good on you Jimmy.
Love how Jimmy’s thumbnail is an angel following grian , whilst grians’s thumbnail is just him getting haunted by a ghost
I noticed that too :D
LONG LIVE THE CANARY! He is the ghostly angel of secret life!
But he didn’t die first this time. Lizzie did, but he was the 2nd to die followed by Mumbo.
@@tylermercado1445 the canary curse was never all about him dying first. It was about the chaotic apocalypse and bloodbath that followed his death. Dying first was just a side effect.
@@tylermercado1445he passed the curse to Lizzie when he killed her
@@goldenwitherphoenix1389but the chaos happend after lizzies death, not jimmys. You know the warden vs wither fight.
@@koo2463i count EP7 as the bloodbath that came after, rather than the warden / wither thing.
EP6 had 2 deaths, and didnt have any rather long lasting consequences. (Well, other than mumbo's and jimmy's deaths)
In comparison, EP7 had a LOT of deaths, and had resulted in no greens left, and the majority now being red.
Grian went through the 5 stages of grief at the start
Something tells me that the Secret Keeper didn't like how the angel and devil quest from the previous session ended up
😂😂😂😂
I watched Joel first and seeing him dig in the background without Jimmy noticing is absolutely hilarious XD
Time stamp?
@@noimnotgoingtoenteraname 8:25
8:25@@noimnotgoingtoenteraname
8:24@@noimnotgoingtoenteraname
8:24
@@noimnotgoingtoenteraname
this was so good! i love how grian instantly and calmly said whatever jimmy told him to, no matter how weird it was.
I love how the episode Jim comes back as a ghost, he technically dealt posthumous damage (Bdubs took 5.5 hearts from his glass water)
@@falsnamae3511 give him 5 hearts for the last episode xD
@@LavenderTownsGhostbeing him back with 5 hearts lmao
@@LavenderTownsGhostjimmy just digs out of his grave in session 9
The sheer fiendish glee on Solidarity's face the first few times Grian instantly obeys his commands....I hope Grian watches this episode and at least sees how much joy he brought Jimmy here.
Jimmy: Be on time to my streams
Grian: *instantly rerolls to hard*
When the world needed him the most, he came back
XD YES
Yeeeees
“This must be a surprise to you. Yes it’s me Jim, and I’m dead, but I’m coming back today” 😂😂 so glad they threw the little pup a bone and let him back in the series
“The leaves are all pointing upwards.” -Grian, 2023
jimmy's commands are too good and perfectly timed its so hilarious
It's funny how Jim is just like "Etho isn't reacting at all" like dude, he's * Canadian *, he's too polite to say anything lmao
Can this trope die already? I went to Canada to avoid the jab and they shamed me for being a proud Texan. Hateful anti-American country
Jim is the kind of angel to ruin your social life but at least he'll keep you alive
Man Etho is such a trooper, just goes with things with no question
Cleo= Mom
Etho= dad
Scar= son
Bdubs= son
Grian= adoptive son 19:38
I'd say Grian is like the neighbor's kid who spends more time at your house than their own
then Bdubs just blow his parents house down into the dust to rid the adopted sibling. such a dark stories......
grian's scar and bdubs cousin remember, probably Etho's nephew 😆
it's funny how Bdubs, Grian, and Scar were the top 3 of thirdlife and now their all adopted by the same two people.
@@FineSeasoningCleo and etho like their children to winners what can I say
I just realized this: in secret life Jim was the second yellow, the second red, and the second dead
How did you make that rhyme?
I just watched your "which Hermit are your" vid the other day and I think the fact that no one (including myself) thought Grain was acting weird really proves the result of that vid.
Who'd you get?
"Who is this 'Grain' character?"
- Grian, Hermitcraft Season 7
So THATS why jimmy was chilling at the end of a bunch of other people's POVs
Lovely seeing more of Jimmy! +10 for Star Trek reference too!
I really think this should be the premise of the next life series. Some players as ghosts, or players that die become ghosts, and they get to interact with live players. Personally I think Extra Life would be an excellent name.
Stop because I LOVE this
Also to add: You could even have a mechanic that could let ghost players respawn once a certain action is completed
After Life
@@andrevandervlies5700 there's actually a series called that already, which would make it fairly confusing
Next life maybe?
im so glad it was grian who got the ghost task, because the two of you have such a fun dynamic. loved this episdoe, glad to have jim back even if only temporarily
Etho is so nice he didn't even question any weird thing grian doing
Grian being weird is normal. It canon
Getting Jimmy back for an episode was such a treat!
This is the first time Jimmy is in Ep8 in this entire series 💀💀
Jimmy fans are absolutely winning this season
HE'S BACK ON SECRET LIFE?? THIS IS SO COOL I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE
Just as a spirit though. He gets to tell Grian what to do for the whole session.
You can hear Martyn getting excited to get a woof woof from Grain lol
"Who is this 'Grain' character?"
- Grian, Hermitcraft Season 7
Honestly was not expecting this but I can promise this just made my day to see you in another secret life episode. What a great early birthday gift 😂
No but seriously, you’re awesome Jimmy! I’m excited to watch the episode
HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY TO YOU!
@@Capelinfshh AWWW THANK YOU!
@@s1lly_p0p
“Say something wacky.”
Grian: *the leaves are all pointing upwards*
2:39
1:15 tim you have NO idea how insane tumblr went over that line
Jimmy: random throwaway sentence
TUMBLR:
I love that the task was for Jim to just tell Grian what to do but he ended up telling Etho and Cleo what to do as well
15:12 “When is that ender pearl gonna-“ 😂 cut perfectly
I have a funny theory where the watchers didn’t kill Jimmy first because they already held a funeral for him and thought he was already dead. So when they saw that he was still alive after Lizzie they quickly took him out
CANON
@@AstralSpectre Lizzie fell into the void, the void is endless. Lizzie is still alive, just stuck. Jimmy still went out first. And since Mumbo was in the series he had to go out seconds after Jimmy because reasons (someone make one up, he died seconds after Jimmy the last season he was in, and seconds after this time too. It's now a Lore thing too). I don't think they'd do it but it would be hilarious if the winner clicked their succeed button at the end and Lizzie pops in instead of the loot and bops them dead. (Secret Keeper has to get all that loot from somewhere). To keep the Canary curse going.
This is honestly adorable that you participated in Grian's task, and I love that you were a pretty good guardian angel by the end there.
Oh this was really cool!!! Ive always thought the ghosts should fly around and upload their perspectives anyway, being in spectator mode theyd have great views of battles and such.
Yeah! The commentary would be pretty funny.
@@garbagedataraccoon I've thought the same thing? But then I realized that'd mean taking three hours out of their day to record themselves watching something passively and commenting on it, and that's kind of a big ask for something they can't directly participate in.
...ooh, as a _group_ though? _That_ could be great.
@@Idran i guess, but I know at least a couple of them ahve logged on after, I wouldnt be surprised if they watch more than we realize
I think this mainly doesn't happen to encourage watching other perspectives. if you wanna see how it ends you have to go to the other channels
Skizz did it in one of the previous seasons. Partially. When it was a lot of death in the fight with wither.
The Canary Curse really couldn't stop you this season; Lizzie died first, and now even though you're out, you still get to mess with the server.
Coming here straight from Grian's video because I need more of this, I loved this session so much, the dynamic between these two mixed with this challenge is just perfect :D
it wouldve been so funny if someone had a task like, "someone is being haunted by a ghost, find out who it is and exorcise them!"
HES BACK,HES BACKKK!!
LONG LIVE THE CANARY
Martyn so sneaky even a cam account couldnt spot him
it’s so funny watching joel’s perspective first and then seeing his hole in the ground the entire time jim is watching grian underground
8:28 perfect shot of joel in the back
I couldn’t stop smiling this video, it was so funny watching Jimmy react to how no one even batted an eye at grian being weird 😂
jimmy not noticing in time the rigged bed, or the end crystal trap, is surprisingly fitting for someone that dies first _almost_ every season!
“Yes, it’s me, Jim. And I’m dead” what a way to start a video
He underestimated teammates ability to be like “yeah that’s probably for a task so i don’t care”
The sheer joy on Jimmy’s face when he found out it was Grian is so funny
this episode was so funny from both of your perspectives. thank you for the laughs king. what skizz said in limited life about your comedic timing is so true and this episode is a great example of it
I live for any sort of ghost pov of the life series! The ones BigB and Martyn released in 3rd life were so funny. It's like a bonus unique perspective on events!
I watched this episode from Cleo's perspective first, so I just thought Grian's task was; "convince Etho to do the weirdest things."
this was so fun, i hope lizzie and mumbo get to be angels as well
I love how around 8:25 you can see Joel building his trap because of the spectator mode
Oh, year! Jimmy was so preoccupied trying to make Etho to react, he(Jimmy) didn't notice!
Limited Life animatics were like... dramatic team love and self-sacrifice...
Secret Life animatics are gonna be like... Etho & Cleo dancing and twirling around...
Can't wait.
You said that before the finale.
Jimmy's face throughout the episode looks like Christmas came early!
The fact that on stream before the secret life recording, we were roasting him that he won't be recording ...
When Grian said “the leaves are all pointed upwards” I died of laughter 😂😂
Loved this episode! I hope you know that Joel was avenging you last episode by killing all the horses 😂
It was great to see you again, Jimmy! Thanks for swinging back around; I enjoyed it immensely
This has been my favorite task yet, and that is saying something with all the fantastic tasks people have gotten this series. Whoever came up with this is brilliant.
16:14 "For the bad boys" 😭😭😭 sobbing rn
Joel saying “For The Badboys” right at the session where Jimmy came back is such a coincidence
9:00 Favorite bit in the episode.
Poor Jimmy 😂💔
I still wander if Etho guessed something like this. We'll probably never know. He didn't post on that week, and he still didn't post the finale...
To be fair, Grian does a lot of weird random stuff anyway. It seems like he always has some sort of little troublemaking angel on his shoulder 90% of the time
etho's reactions to all the stuff jimmy made grian do are golden, he really did not question it at all kkkkkk so wholesome
Whoever came up with that idea, that was genius to let a dead person come back as a ghost
8:26 the fact jimmy saw Joel setting that trap and said absolutely nothing is sending me
He didn't notice - 100%!
OH I WAS NOT EXPECTING THIS BUT I AM SO HAPPY THAT JIM STILL GETS TO PARTICIPATE YAYY ❤
WHATTT HES BACKKKK!!! THIS IS SO GOOD JIM! THE CANARY RISES AGAIN
Jim getting to experience what the later episodes of a life series feel like for the first time.
Lol! Lizzy tried so hard to get Cleo and Etho to notice her being weird, too!
I love how all of this just went fully unquestioned because everyone's had seven weeks to get used to the oddest little things :D
"He is like Obi Wan Kenobi: he is more useful dead than alive!"
I'm glad Jimmy gets a bit more time on the Life Server in a way.
grian literally acts just as bonkers all the time naturally 😂😂😂
This is the best thing in this series thus far 😂
8:25 I love how Joel creating a trap and sneaking near Etho and Grian XDD