Editorial with Sujit Nair: "Vajpayee Told Me Not To Toe RSS Line On Economic Policy": Yashwant Sinha
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- Amid much political attention, Sharad Pawar earlier this month hosted a meeting of leaders of eight Opposition parties apart from some eminent personalities at his residence here, where a decision was taken to formulate an “alternate”, “inclusive” vision for India. The meeting was called under the banner of Rashtra Manch established by Yashwant Sinha. Sinha was earlier in BJP and had also served as the Union Finance and External Affairs Minister during Atal Bihari Vajpayee's prime ministership. However, earlier this year, he joined TMC. In this episode of the Editorial, our Managing Editor Mr Sujit Nair discusses these issues with senior leader Yashwant Sinha.
#YashwantSinha #RSS #Vajpayee #PMModi #TMC #JanataDal #Rafale #Demonetization #$5TrillionEconomy #IndianEconomy #FinanceMinister #OppositionUnity #Mission2024 #PrashantKishor #RashtraManch #SharadPawar #MamataBanerjee
Also Watch :
Editorial With Sujit Nair: Indian Economy's Greatest Crisis| Prof. Arun Kumar | • Editorial With Sujit N...
To Join HW Membership Program: hwnews.in/subs...
To Join UA-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
Download the HW News Network free app available on Android and iOS: onelink.to/bpk42n
For NEWS and POLITICAL updates in English. Send us a ‘Hi’ on our Whatsapp Number - 9820918578
#HWNewsEnglish #HwLatestNews
For advertising related queries write to us at sales@hwnews.in
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
I agree with Mr. Sinha, that any PM candidate at this stage, will indeed be a mistake. No one can be propped up against Mr Modi today. The BJP propaganda machine is way too strong. The only way forward is for the opposition, which has two years to unite, to show that the fight for the principles of the freedom movement are above their own political aspirations. If a united opposition is clearly apparent, then the stature of these leaders will automatically rise. You won't have a TINA effect then. The Opposition will be bigger than any individual leader and the electorate will vote for the United opposition front.
Is projecting a PM candidate against the ethics of democracy, the leader has to be elected from among those who win elections as people's representatives, the one who would be able to lead and. deliver. When we designate the PM face then incapable bunch of self serving sycophants also win. Let every state select the best candidates for elections and then make the claim for for PM .
People don't vote for BJP. They vote against the opposition. It's not a question of whom to vote, it's about whom not to vote. I hope some day the opposition learn a thing from Naveen Patnaik and stop spewing their bile in public before they blame BJP and EVMs for their defeat.
The TINA factor is just a farce of the BJP. Anyone would be a better alternative, even the Common man on the street. He would be guided by the Bureaucrats and would have the Country's interests in his heart. He would not destroy the Nation. For all we know, even you would be a much better alternative.
yes, the TINA factor was first propagated by Mrs, Margaret Thatcher. But that is history. In a nation of 139 crores, where more than 30% of the CEOs of the top 100 companies of the world are Indians, there is no dearth of people with leadership abilities amongst Indians. Not all leaders need have political bent of mind !!
Mr. Vaypayee, handled the politics and allowed bureaucracy to guide the governance. Dr. Manmohan Singh, handled the governance shoulder to shoulder with the bureaucracy and let the politics be handled by Mrs. Sonia Gandhi.. Everyone worked for growth.. there were pitfalls, but not as bad as they were portrayed. Now there is utter chaos waiting to be set on fire with communal polarisation. BUT the Indians for all their cultural roots coupled wit a good section being educated are not inflammable.. there is digression but no reaction to leading communal; polarization statements. that is proof of the pie that Indians dont want the current band wagon anymore. This was realized even in 2019.. but the Pulwama attack was orchestrated only to sow the nationalist sentiment combined with TINA factor.. Added to it was the bungled EVM and VVPAT. What is the guarantee the the EVM and VVPAT will capture the right choice ????????
@@sunitasunil1744 very well said. I agree. I don't agree with Tina factor, but I trust the rustic mind of our people. India is a great country with a great culture n diversity. We will find our way out, the nation is going through its learning curve and it will come out strong. In the interim we may suffer a lot. History teaches us.
There was loose talk about Prof. Raghuram Rajan being our PM candidate. Unfortunately, he didn't get into politics, stuck to academia and spends all his time in the USA. So, the TINA factor is a reality, and cannot be dismissed. Would I like Mamata Bannerjee as my PM in 2024? - very difficult to see her being our PM!! Can people here give me better alternatives?
@@01shamit I wouldn't worry..... cometh the hour cometh the man (or woman) ;)
Ours is a great country.... Historically it's produced great leaders n people... Let's have trust in our people!!!
@Nidhi Roy maybe not like the developed West, whose measure tape we use to assess ourselves. But we have done better than most countries. Just look around n c the countries who got independent along with us or later. Don't only look at it economically only, but Also from the point of view that where we started, our diversity, poverty, famines etc. The country threw up great leaders then. It will do so in the future.
As the subject was Tina factor... We have to look into our past to understand the future too.
I know things look depressing around but with time things will work out. I'm positive.
Sangh represented Only the Landed
Zamindar Section which was Loyal
to the British Raj till the End. 😁👍
Prosperity of All Indians isn't their Plan. 🤷♀️
All Indian Muslim League had many Muslim landlords
@@rs-sl1tn two sides of the same coin
@@rs-sl1tn : rss n Muslim league are two sides of same coin .......during partition they exchanged their offices .... before independence the Muslim league fought elections on Muslim-card just as the Hindu Mahasabha fought on Hindu-card, and after the elections they formed coalition government with each other in various states ....
"Sab ka sath sab ka vikas" is applicable only on paper and never in practice. The demonetisation scheme flopped so miserably that the ecomomy of India was never the same. Infact all political parties in the history of India showed no true intentions of establishing economic uniformity and harmony among the people.
@@rs-sl1tn And most of those zamindar were not loyal to Britishers and they also went to Pakistan unlike you sanghis who were loyal and Britishers and derived pensions
For the first time I feel, a seasoned political leader is talking of taking on idiology and not personality. In my opinion this was bound to happen some day because, personalies failed to deliver time and again. This is a good beginning for our country
The perception now prevailing in the country that there seems to be no alternative to Mr Narendra Modi should be buried . Leaders like Mr. Yashwant Sinha, Mr Sharad Pawar and others should go the extra mile towards stitching a combined formidable opposition to take on BJP in the 2024 elections
Mr. Yashwant Sinha is one of the leaders who can make a good Prime Minister. He did drive the point home when he gave the example of Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee who chose professionals to look after their respective field of expertise. It's time our people were educated to know the difference between personality soaked politics from an issued based one.
The most comprehensive analysis of Narendra Modi. Kindly watch: ua-cam.com/video/nYJ46WZ8ekg/v-deo.html
Would love to see a good interview with Mr Sharad Pawar also
😂😂😂 That's why BJP formed the Early morning Govt.with NCP
That wily fox will evade all direct honest answers and will play safe😁
@Vijay Manjrekar 😂😂😂 that proves फडणवीस betrayed Maharashtra people and you as a Maharashtrian proud of that.....so sad
As always interesting discussion with a very important personality.. who is still very young at heart and full of energy to start a new manch .. augurs well for our country.. hope the new manch gains in strength.
What Mr. Yashwant Sinha said right, prime minister candidate it's a BJP Trap
Now it's time for all oppositin parties to UNITE as ONE SOLID Democratic Party with full effort and intention to preserve the democracy of our country, which has been destroyed by the inefficient, vision less leadership of ruling party.
And this will be the real desh bhakthi and desh seva.
Hope our opposition leaders will struggle to save India.
Vajpay was realistic and wise. That was indeed the reason for his glory and greatness.
Vajpayee was directly responsible for the demolition of the disputed babri masjid (“nukiley patthar samatal karneka waqt aayaa hai” - hope u know who said and about whom) & the 2001 Gujarat carnage of the Muslims because he was PM and had the opportunity and power to dismiss Modis govt n impose governors rule but he merely did bhaashanbaaji about Raj-dharm. There was no one and never will be a politician as hypocrite as Vajpayee....Vajpayee was also a coward who preferred to turn approver, instead of facing punishment for hoisting national flag on government premises, and caused the imprisonment of freedom fighters ..When this was published by The Hindu magazine vajpayee threatened them of court action but when the editor stood by the evidences published with the article Vajpayee had to row back
@@123xyzabccba Hey, that's not fair. Even Advani in his autobiography says openly that these were the two issues Vajpayee and he differed strongly on - Babri Masjid and Modi post-2002 riots. For complex reasons, Advani prevailed...
@@debashishmukerji : please listen to his provocative speeches leading to babri demolition. Advani did what he believed in but Vajpayee was a weakling hence succumbed to whatever pressure he was subjected to. The sign of vajpayees cowardice were displayed during his youth when he was the only one to hv turned approver causing the arrests of the other freedom fighters. So try as much as u can Vajpayee-bhakts to glorify the inglorious; Vajpayee will always be remembered as a hypocrite and a coward by his critics .....
Bajpai wisdom: India Shining.
What Vanity
I met Mr. Yashwant Sinha on a hotel lobby when I was rushing to catch a flight.... years ago and wanted to spend a minute with him, me being an ordinary citizen .... he just touched me shoulder and said " Go run catch your flight .... your children are waiting for you". Such a gentle man !!!
I respect the wise words of Mr. Sinha, with comparison of the then leadership of bjp led by Vajipaye n present...
But the central govt IS extreamly efficient but only in implementing their own narrow agenda and not in governance
Very informative editorial.. 🙌🏻 We need such brilliant leaders to lead our country
You a tall leader sir. I am a congress man fully agree with your openion. Stand out for the betterment of our country. I salute you sir.
I salute Shri Sinha Sir for sticking to truth and true values of Indianness. Shri Vajpayee Sir was one my role model after Smt Indira Gandhi and we Indians must protect our true identity at any cost. Long Live our Democracy. Jai Bharath. Jai Hind.
Waiting for yet another interesting and informative conversation.
Indeed Mr. Sinah is a highly intellectual person. Most suitable for PM post.
Sincerely agree with you. But won't happen.....he's a great strategist and a game changer, and he's the king maker!
congratulations on actually getting mr. Sinha here! love to see it
Mr Singha's opinions are very valuable for the country. He has been playing a critical role of awakening the opposition leaders as well as exposing the reality of present political crisis to the people of India. Interviewing him and Arunji is the best episodes you made currently. These two persons have pointed out what's broken and needs fixing. I think a mass revolution is brewing in India where we want to not only replace modi-shah but also bring in proper democratic processes in which we are less dependent on a leadership. Many European countries run governments which are not depending on one main leader but a whole battery of leadership. SO SINGHAJI MAY BE RIGHT IN HIS THOUGHTS AND SUCCESSED IN HIS AIM.👍
BJP from day 1 was a communal party and it was established based on a hindutva ideology and till day it is the same. Several attacks took place on minorities even during Mr. Vajpayee rule.
Ok but he respected minorities
Your editorials are mindgasmic sir, keep it up ...Online media is last hope of this country's free voices
Mr. Sinha was so perfectly clear in his words. It's nice to hear a person speak so logically after a long time. Most of BJP's politicians only talk Hindu vs Muslim or how we are at a threat from some external force.
Vajpayee was one of the very best prime minister of India in his tenure truly humble clean man in BJP he never went to divide india but peace loving man people of india will never forget him 🙏
I totally agree with you Congress jindabad 🙏
It’s high time for the real desh Bhakts to join hands and restore the spirit and soul of INDIA we badly need the lost India back.
Wonderful interview Sujit.
Thanks for this good interview
Very straightforward reply. Courageous
Sujit Sir, I don’t miss your single editorials. Information provided are so informative and awareness for all of us. Not to miss out on Arti, too good. God Bless you both and your HW channel.
My suggestion would be: This alliance should go with PM face. My bet would be in Rajan R. We need to fix our economy and he is the best guy.
Mind blowing revelations what a shame wer we stamd now...
Indians seem to have forgotten that India is a parliamentary democracy. The Congress and the BJP have made it presidential, which it isn't.
Sir, India had a Strong opposition And alternative PM Candidate with a Single Party. The count Down has Already started. Wait till 2024.
Sir YS TRUE INDIAN THANKS FOR YOUR SPEECH
Namaskar sujitji, thank you very much for your excellent editorial, thank you very much appreciated
23:54 & 24:09 is what is my query as a citizen aswell, since few years. I'm glad Yashwant Sinha, is very clear on this and that he has said it, so simple and clear.
On the TINA factor, I'm with the opinion of Yashwant Sinha as all he is saying is. It is not necessary to choose a party leader as the PM. Rather a efficient person too can be a PM from the 'United Front', by consensus, which may be believing in the constitution laid down by Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar and the constitution framing committee, and work for the strengthening of the nation with the strengthening of the 'unity in diversity'.
I sincerely hope a United Opposition comes to Power and Yashwant Sinha ji becomes PM.........
I do agree with the fact that there is a TINA factor and that there shall be no strong opposition until a Strong Personality is pitted against Narendra Modi for the PM's post.
The United Front should genuinely gel among themselves and find a Consensus PM Candidate much before 2024 to become a force to reckon with.........
After his join TMC, post poll there was crime against BJP workers and non bengali people. Thank you Sir.
Even though in our country, India, where criminal activities reported maximum, it is solid truth that we having a few flawless Gentlemen (economists) in active politics.
This gentleman, Hon. Yashwant Singha is a man having full of economy knowledge and long sighted skills and striving always for this country's progress and unity.
I strongly believe, opposition party's reigning state governments can enjoy several kinds of benefits by utilising this gentleman's views.
He was the most intelligent minister in Vajpayee cabinet.
Modi is allergic to such people.
We need opposition together against this regime. Leader will come up from the elected government.
@Vijay Manjrekar What?? Modi is a tyrant running a country. He is destroying our diversity, tolerance and inclusivity.
We require a strong, qualified, able, experienced, capable to think for the country, and a decent educated person to be in the PMs post..no matter which religion or caste he may come from...
But not definately a destructive and stubborn person....
Religion, caste is important thing in indian politics,,capability is not necessary, see Modi's 2 tenure..
Religion, caste is important thing in indian politics,,capability is not necessary, see Modi's 2 tenure..
Good talk with Mr. YS, every BJP Voter should see this, what was BJP & What is BJP now....
Any extreme ideology, be it right wing or left wing, can never be successful in running a nation. Our leader has to be everyone's leader. Imagine the head of a corporate office saying I am only so and so's boss, not yours. Once a person joins an organisation, he expects to be treated fairly and is entitled to all rights and privileges mentioned in the HR manual. So why does a citizen of India get treated differently based on his or her religion/class/caste??? Despite there being a ready manual (the constitution) for ready reference??? It is only a moderate party that can ensure the rights of all citizens.
Atalji was legend we all are proud of
Fekoo is joker we like minded people ashamed of.
Loved the conversation....
What a leader...clear vision
Only yashwant sinha and sujit nair aware about neighbouring countries relationship.
I AGREE with YASHWANTH JEE BECAUSE I DO RESPECT SHRI ATAL JEE AND WHEN YOU RESPECT ELDERLY INDIANS ESPECIALLY THOSE WHO ARE HAVING MORAL VALUES AND THEY SHOULD ALWAYS BE RESPECTED CONSIDERED AT ALL TIMES AND LONG LIVE GOOD INDIANS 🙏🙏
God bless you sir
It's a bogus reply to why he joined BJP post Ayodhya demolition.......He was well aware of his party's plans.....yet he keeps on repeating mellowing down of ABB and LKA.......Advani was the pioneer of carnage caused by Rath Yatra....
It's all about his lost identity in BJP and fight for survival......exactly same applies to Shatrughan Sinha too
He had no problem and rath yatra was mellow as long as he held a juicy portfolio.
If Yashwant Sinha was accommodated by Modi in his cabinet in 2014 or 2019 , this gentleman would be talking differently. Like Advani, Yashwant was also ignored. The former made some feeble noises earlier and is quiet now while the latter continues.
Yes. Their age thus their days are over. They should have gracefully. Yes, even Great Advani slipped tongue unnecessarily but reconciled to the fact, but this man not, unfortunately and harming his party and country as well by supporting these people who made country corrupt.
This guy one of the finest politician.
I don't understand one thing why should one give explanation to RSS why give that much importance to them.
Because the scourge happening right now is because of RSS. If not Modi, there would be some other. Vajpayee was too moderate.
@Vijay Manjrekar
Females dont need goons to protect them, we fear them only. Unity ka mtlb bhi RSS ko ni pta hai, all they know is divide and rule. And a lot of people dont have a problem with a heterogeneous society, ye log apna Hindu rastra le kr yaha se bahar nikal le tb India shanti se rhega kyunki vaise bhi India ink baap ka toh hai ni. Anpadh log chale sbko padhane, irony of India.
@@anweshapandey7463 very true...
Let us all Collectively stand up and observe a minute SILENCE for the decimation of INDIAN ECONOMY which will continue unabated till 2029... Gone it is Just Gone....
Good questions sir
I will rather vote for third front if third front openly project him (mr. Yashwant Sinha) as next Prime minister Candidate. I will not vote for third front if Mamta banarji will project herself for the PM candidate, in this case I would be okay Voting to Rahul gandhi.
If kejriwal comes forward to contest LS election then I will vote him.
Yes, you're on the right track. Vote for anyone else except BJP who have made our country poorer.
Very informative interview.
I think this team is doing the right thing
Good interview..
Yaswant sinha deserves and competent to be the PM.
Sir Vajpayee is states man with People Focus is Real Des bhakthi ❤️
Wish Yashwanth Sinha should be PM candidate
Good that you demanded our suggestions, my take on TINA factor is- India certainly needs a leader to stand up to this challenge of TINA factor, sooner rather than later, it's going to be failure of present Opposition of not getting United, having consensus on leadership, otherwise coming together for Constitution, Country would be hollow words, which no one is going to buy in India, and status quo will continue.
Agree.
Wonderful analysis of the situation
All we need today is a Jay Prakash Narayan personality toemerge and motivate and mobilise the country as a whole to fight against this authoritarian and undemocratic rule of the day.. Whether a Yashwant Singh or someone else who has similar viewpoint or the governance experience will emerge in the coming days? That's the question of the moment..
Congress Party has to come forward to unite all the opposition parties and make Yashwant Sinha the next PM.
A legendary journalist interviewing a legendary leader 😀
Mr.Yashwant Sinha should hv been made the FM in the present Government
Mr Sinha is very forthright and the way BJP under Shri Vajpaiye hi is destroyed by this current RSS controlled BJP
Mr Sina is 100% right you must first fight your immediate advisanary and only elect your leader by consenses
Choose your leader by consensus later
Good conversation
Interesting discussion.
I think Mr.Sinha is right. This seems to be a trap by the BJP. As any candidate put forward by th opposition in advance may be ridiculed or even hounded by the various agencies of the Govt.
Correct... They are already trying to destroy Kejriwal, Didi, and, ofcourse, RG.
Will check with Vajpayee when I meet him next.
Great that he is taking the lead to bring an alternative.
There needs to be a consensus on PM candidate and a clear roadmap of their policies and programmes.
Otherwise like last time it would be said that it's unclear who will be the leader in Jan, Feb and so forth.
If they cannot decide on leader before then how later?
At present the chosen people will be targeted in every way by the centre, by sold media etc We can already see that happening in Maharashtra. We saw TMC leaders leaving the party before elections. We can see the attitude of the Bengal governor. .
It is actually possible to draw up a list of potential PM candidates from the opposition coalition.Almost all of them,with the exception of Rahul Gandhi,are (or have been)CMs or Cabinet Ministers.Most of these parties (except for the Shiv Sena )also have a record of having worked reasonably well together in the UPA under Manmohan Singh and Sonia Gandhi.After the recent catastrophic experience of having just 2 people taking all the decisions (as pointed out by Mr Yashwant Sinha)…. I think a lot of voters should now be realising that a government which is formed by the coalition of quite a few strong leaders is better than one where everyone else is spineless.There are bound to be some tensions in the organisational dynamics,but the fact is looking back,one would agree that the coalition governments led by both Manmohan Singh/Sonia Gandhi and Vajpayee/Advani were much more competent and responsive to the needs of the people than the present one.In my opinion,it is now only the hard core Modi supporter who is still looking for a “ strong leader “ to singlehandedly call all the shots….everyone else is realising that shared responsibility (and power) as envisaged by our parliamentary system is a more humane option.After all “participatory decision making” is how most modern families and even good companies/organisations function.And a Nation should feel more like a family to its citizens,then being in the military or working for a soulless corporate head honcho !
Mr . Nair its a good topic to listen
You want to sound grown up?.... Have some humility to give MMS his due like your giving your old boss ( ABV ) his due.History has judged our two former prime ministers. You let go to Sir
@Vijay Manjrekar you are so uneducated about politics are insulting MMS. YOU have inadvertentky endowed Mrs Gandhi with excellent economic sense and yet call her all names. How ironic.
Shri. Manmohan Singh is a intelligent honest humble and visionary leader.
And glad that Mrs. Sonia Gandhi had the vision to make him PM.
MMS,one who oversaw corruption seeing other way, especially on coal scam etc. 2G was big scam which only a judge of Delhi who failed to comprehend it to support 0 loss in it. SC cancelled auction, why? It fetched a lot after cancellation though that much as companies exploited the delay happened by quoting lower rates, but still was more than before auction under Raja, whom MMS, Sonia failed to discipline to save government. What about Commonwealth scams etc, many bomb blasts etc.
Dr. Manmohan singh was really good
He is an excellent human being. Man of few words but a great person/politician.
Moni Shankar Aiyar said : Vajpayee govt was the best Congress govt ! HarHarMahadev
I feel Kejriwal should be the PM Candidate.. He is a well educated minister with good experience in administration.. And he is well recognised all over India..
Nice show
Mr. Yeshwanth Sinha is such a noble person, a man of ethics and integrity, it's pity that his son happen to be a filthy and unethical person, even though he had high education abroad. It's Tue that nothing can change a person's integrity.
Yashwantji ressembles 100% my father! He should be a good person!!
Super interview.
Really great person...,
Govt s unashamed favour 😎
Excellent video kindly see to it that the audio quality is improved on the other side...mr. Sujit sir
Mr.Sinha is still to understand that BJP is taking advantage by propaganding that the opposition is void of a strong leadership. Let's put an end to it!
I respect this kind of journalism.
Excellent Analysis.
Rightly said Claim of 5 Trillion Economy and Doubling the income of Farmers Nothing more than "Jumlas".
A true statesman !!!! Kya bolte hain YS sir !!! Biting, succint !!! And a do-er !!!!
The kra of majority of Indian minded citizens should be to get rid of the evil "gujju gang" .... Throw judge loya's murderers into jail forever and throw away the key (to name just one of many, many)
The opposition pm candidate should not become a bugbear .... A cohesive opposition is more important
Prime minister candidate is really a trap as Mr Sinha said. Any leader from the opposition is acceptable to me except modi ,shah n yogi
Now Rahul Gandhi is real person who has understood the pulse of the people of India. So he must be the PM of India. The real face of the modi and Amit shaw will come to light in the next election -Through Editorial people will know the truth. Good attempt.
Mr Sinha, You say Mr. Advani had "mellowed down". Had he mellowed down enough that the deaths of the Mumbai riot victims can be forgotten? We cannot forget that you were his colleague consciously and never uttered a word against the rath yatra and its aftermath.
Decided on future PMs name is most important . People want to know clear message
Lalu!?
Strong opposition is required. Good effort
Arvind Kejriwal must be the face of the PM candidate.
AK is one of the heads of a hundred-head monster called RSS.
How will the people know there is unity in the opposition unless there is a consensus on one person leading the group. Mr Sinha himself could be the face!
Very candidly discussed without jumlas .