WWII 📜 Sophie Scholl - How a young woman defied Hitler
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- 🚩Install Mech Arena for Free 🤖 IOS/ANDROID: clcr.me/HistoryMarche_MA and get a special starter pack 💥 Available only for the next 30 days
🚩 This is the story about Sophie Scholl, a young German student who defied Adolf Hitler by printing leaflets in opposition to the Nazi regime. She was arrested in February 1943, tried, conviced and beheaded by guilotine. She was only 21 years old.
🚩 Consider supporting my work on Patreon and enjoy ad-free videos: / historymarche
📢 Narrated by Anna Chloe Moorey & David McCallion
📜 Research and script by: Skylar J. Gordon
📜 Sources:
Holocaust Resistance: The White Rose - A Lesson in Dissent, by Jacob G. Hornberger (2021)
www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/...
Beheaded by the Nazis at age 21, Sophie Scholl died fighting against white supremacy - Laura Smith (2017)
timeline.com/sophie-scholl-wh...
Sophie Scholl (2021)
spartacus-educational.com/GER...
Sophie Scholl
www.holocaustresearchproject.o...
Sophie Scholl and the White Rose - Tanja B. Spitzer (2020)
www.nationalww2museum.org/war...
#ww2 #whiterose #sophiescholl
🚩Install Mech Arena for Free 🤖 IOS/ANDROID: clcr.me/HistoryMarche_MA and get a special starter pack 💥 Available only for the next 30 days
Finished.... Well done HistoryMarche!!! .. too many heroes are in the shadows, you just illuminated another (at least for myself)
[and when I say I did not like your humanist video I always love your videos HistoryMarche. Please do not Excommunicate me :( Ha]
"This is the story about Sophie Scholl, a young German student who defied Adolf Hitler by printing leaflets in opposition to the Nazi regime. She was arrested in February 1943, tried, conviced and beheaded by guilotine. She was only 21 years old."
Think you mean convicted?
As by no way did she ever get convinced by the Naz PR.
ps loving the videos by the way, keep it up
You misspelt "Convicted" in the description
This video was a great one. I've heard of this woman before. She was brave to do what she did. Shame about what happened to her.
Such brave and unbelievable voices that cried out against the evil. May those, like Sophie, who stand against the monster, know peace. Excellent video as always.
Amazingly done HistoryMarche!
I am from Munich and I love Sophie Scholl and the White Rose. True heroes and role models.
Your video is a high quality tribute to her. Thank you!
God loves you bro John 3:16
@@denisewoodell7543
Stone Cold Says So
Austin 3:16
I must say that you are so versatile when explaining history no matter if you are covering battles or other events. Thank you again Mr History!
May they Rest In Peace. 🥀
Well, in hell, where they belong
@@appleratpipe u might meet them there
Where are You at now? Europe? Australia, USA, New Zeeland?
@@keiththomas1180 I might, but at least I'm not a traitor
@@appleratpipe least I'm not a Nazi
I'm also intrigued by pianist Maria Yudina that dare to write her disapproval to Stalin 🧐
@Bronski Turboski though it wasn't as in the film 'The death of Stalin' she donated the money of her Stalin Prize to the ortodox church (which was oppressed by the goverment then) to pray for the victims of Stalin's crimes
I dont see how you can execute someone as pure as Sophie and not wonder if you're really the bad guy.
history is repeating itself
Interestingly, Sophie's executioner, instead of being punished as you might expect for complicity in the Nazis' crimes, was recruited by the Allies after the war to execute top-ranking Nazis.
Totally unexpected but such an amazing and insightful video. I think I've seen a documentary on them either on UA-cam or TV.
"Sometimes for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing!"
Excellent video. Extremely well done. Thanks for sharing a story that all must remember. RIP Sophie Scholl, Hans Scholl, Christoph Probst, Willi Graf, Kurt Huber and Alexander Schmorell. You are not forgotten.
She never got to play Mech Arena...
Seriously though, the courage it takes to stand up to a regime that just kills whoever they please. Especially as a young woman, who wasn't going to get drafted & ordered to personally commit atrocities. And a young woman at that, who still had her whole life ahead of her (although perhaps she envisaged being complicit to Nazi Germany as not much of a life)
Heavy vid in all senses. Morally, emotionally, quality speaking at least if not more. And thanks for not only bringing out another banger but letting me know of a story that i didn't know about.
I once saw a comment about the film 'Sophie Scholl - The Final Days' saying the Naziz showed estraint before the executions as there was no violence in the 'true story'. !! The three DID get badly tortured but never gave up anyone else. Sophie even had a broken leg at the trail.
Torture was used by both sides. The Allies were just as bad.
@@Willy_Tepes yer you're right, it's absolutely fine that they tortured her... 😆 Pathetic.
@@JohnDoe-tx8lq Well yes, that is my honest opinion. If you have not figured out that it is all a lie, I'd say you are the pathetic one..
@@Willy_Tepes so according to you it's ok they tortured her AND it's all a lie? It did happen and it's ok, AND it didn't happen anyway. Brilliant.
@@JohnDoe-tx8lq Nope, the entire narrative about the war is a lie and Sofie got what she deserved for supporting evil.
This video is amazing, and the timing could not be any better in more ways than one. Thankyou.
A heavy but important topic. Great job covering one of the many brave souls of the war.
Amazing women but terribly sad story. Executed with her brother. As someone with sisters I can't even imagine...
Absolutely excellent.
I've read much about the resistance, her name and the white rose.
To my recollection, this is the first video. And a bang up job! Well done.
She is one of my personal hero's. perfect video so well detailed i had never seen a picture of the janitor before or knew the detail she got to she her brother one last time! She is a modern saint
She's no saint and clearly you have no intellect whatsoever
Neither was Oscar Shindler you don't have to be saint to make a difference.
@@appleratpipe so...like u?
@@appleratpipe I hate so much about the things you choose to BE -Michal Gary Scott
@@appleratpipe Can you explain why she wasn't a Saint she seems like an independent spirit, which is much more Noble than any political robot from any side no matter my disagreements with her. The element of Independence is the greatest trait of the human soul wherever and in whatever costume it appears
One of the most inspiring people in history. This girl has shown a bravery, defiance, and morality that has been terribly scarce.
“I'm not scared of the Maos and the Stalins and the Hitlers. I'm scared of the thousands of millions of people that hallucinate them to be "authority", and so do their bidding, and pay for their empires, and carry out their orders. I don't care if there's one looney with a stupid moustache. He's not a threat if the people do not believe in "authority".”
― Larken Rose
This (very good) comment and the whole video probably will be censored in 2022. People in power do not like such thoughts and words. Dark times are here again.
Or a short man, born in Leningrad.
The fact that so many in our own country display so much hate for those who protest their country to change it for the better makes this all the more relevant today. Thanks for sharing this.
Which country and which protesters are you talking about?
@@georgebailey8179 the United States
@@nikoarcher1243 Protesting is ok.... Rioting and destruction of public property is not
@@saveushiral so the Boston tea party was rioting and looting? Not a protest?
@@saveushiral are you saying that the Boston tea party wasn’t okay?
much heavier topic than you guys usually do, but you did really well! Interesting video as usual. Too bad it has so many dislikes tho, seems like you attracted a bunch of idiots but well. Sophie Scholl truly was a hero, she's well remembered here in Germany too
Where do you see dislikes UA-cam removed the dislike counter
@@nicknmm09 I see 146 out of 870 at the moment.
@@lupiniii7025 wth, how??? Is this different from country to country?
The dislikes probably have to do with fact this video is singling out one person in a major group that was against the nazis. And of course, as it is 2021, the creator has to make a video title that makes it seem like this woman was the biggest anti-hitler person in Germany.
@@herbthompson8937 History is the story of great individuals not groups you dam socialist.
Thank you very much for your documentaries! Such a nice work.
Great video as always! Ignore the haters. I love that you are covering new things
This video was amazing, introduced me to someone very inspirational!
Ps the song is pretty good; which song is it?
4:04 - the dates are interesting for her family member's births and deaths. But Sophie, seems to have 'The 22nd of March, 1925 - The 7th of January, 1926'.
Haha, I saw that too. the dates seems to be for her sister, Thilde.
Yes, definitely a typing error!
Sophie was 9 May 1921 - 22 February 1943, while her sister died while still an infant.
I don't care about what I was watching. I see that History marche uploaded.
good and important video but the ad was more than tone deaf.
Introduces sad story... Brought to you by MECH ARENA!!!!! LOL!
@3:59 you have Sophie Scholl at the same lifespawn as her sister Thilde, 1925-1926. That's an error? Or do i get this wrong? :)
Yes, definitely a typing error!
Sophie was 9 May 1921 - 22 February 1943, while her sister died while still an infant.
Great as always HM!
Hitler: If I am to be considered a revolutionary, I am a revolutionary against the revolution!
*uses Guillotine*
Great subject. Sophie Scholl deserves a wider audience and I applaud you for covering the less visited topics.
There is a very good german film "Sophie Scholl - The Final Days" which I highly recommend.
Keep up the good work :)
edit:
I see you got some hate comments, some from frat boys who only want to see battle history and some from nazi lovers who want to forget some parts of history.
Ignore those sad people. Neither are worth thinking about. The internet is a cesspool and UA-cam is certainly no exception.
You should make whatever videos you want that interest you and not concern yourself with small minded people.
I am sure you know all this already but sometimes its good to know that others know it too.
Love your vids dude.
War is stupid unless it's in defense.
I really do enjoy learning new things like this about the WW. When you learn history at school, i find it to be very uniformed, you don't get to learn about these things.
Really enjoyed this video, thanks.
Thanks for covering this. The Scholls are some of the most underreported / under celebrated figures of WWII.
This was absolutely great. You should do one on William Wilberforce, Thomas Clarkson and the Society for the Abolition of the Slave Trade. These men were responsible for the end of the Slave Trade and the abolition of Slavery in the UK. The United Kingdom, the first civilization to abolish slavery.
Could of chosen a more tasteful ad, but ok
Authoritarianism is on the rise in europe once again and we've learned nothing from the past
A lot heavier than your normal videos but also such an important topic. Great video and thanks for deciding to make it.
the ad really tarnishes the solemnity of this video ☹
i think a video about the kievan rus or other medieval eastern european fights would be great
It's a very narrow-minded bunch who look at the entirety of human history, the very building blocks of our modern world, and only see a collection of battles. I'm grateful you're trying new things
The more battles iv learnt about the more iv realised in the end they don't matter all that much in the grand scale. Empires rise and fall, borders move, or are created or dissolved. Sort of calming when I get too caught up in world affairs and politics
Wise words.
@@dariusghodsi2570 You're not even trying to be a clown are you?
Holy shit.
@@dariusghodsi2570 Says who? Are you damaged?
Por siempre Sophie
They really should have been voiced in German. Otherwise great!
Nice video and very informative and very entertaining and very satisfaction more videos.
I didn't realize there was a college exemption from the draft in WW2. They boys had to spend 1 year on the Eastern Front and then the army just let them leave and go to school?
great video which needed to be talked about
4:00 I think the date of death of Sophie's got mistyped
Dam I feel very stupid, I was not happy upon clicking this wanting another antiquity power struggle [was not a fan of the humanist video], but I stfu after that intro...
And adjusted my assumption meter
Do a vid like this about William Joyce.
Amazing video. Some comments are just sad wanting only war videos, history is all wonderful.
Agreed.
People might be upset because the title only mentions Sophie but not her brother. Both fought against the ns-regime.
@@nemofunf9862 It's not about that.
@@romelnegut2005 yeah, i'm just scrolling trough the comments. the dislikes seems to be divided between people who see her as a traitor and people who only care about battles. weird.
@@nemofunf9862 Really weird.
Brilliant Historymarche does Historymarche have a Patreon page to help with more History. As a Scot the back story to a lots wars battles etc is as interesting as the battles themselves. Keep up the great work. There is a great film German film about Sophie and the white rose.
Shekels!
HistoryMarche... please make a video on the best leaders of all times.. and best military generals in history.. thank you very much for your valueable and informative videos.. i always wait eagerly for your videos.. once again thank you very much
It kinda sucks that History Marche's audience didn't give this video the engagement it deserved, probably because there were no "epic battles" or military strategy. This stuff is equally important in my opinion.
Thank you very much for the kind words.
@@HistoryMarche You're welcome, thanks for making the documentary!
Ideas are what this is about. War has and will always be about ideas.
That she was so enthusiastic for the nazi cause initially was quite common, the youth organizations were incredibly effectively. If you like to you could make a video about why that was, I would be very interested to see that.
I think part of the reason was that they bridged the deep devisions in society, everyone was the same in the Hitler youth and the League of German girls, which does not sound very appealing to us but I think it was perceived as freeing by many young people back than.
I know this was the case for my grandmother. As an illegitimate child in a small, religiously conservative village, she was always sidelined in school, church etc. and at times humiliated by the local priest in front of the other girls. In the League of German girls (and its young girls section) however nobody seemed to care, as long as they wore their uniforms everyone was the same.
In the end the league would also contribute to her disillusion though. They had an event called something like „knitting for the front“, where they made gloves and other winter clothing. I have no idea wether it was actually send to the eastern front but that is what they were told and she came to the conclusion that if THAT was the best they had to offer for their soldiers than all that talking about superiority and coming victory could not carry much truth
2:53 really hit home.
An amazing story and well made video.
*Sigh* Why did I not listen to the common wisdom of not looking at the comments.
Well, at least the majority of them are smart and rational and support your different videos. I had never heard of Sophie Scholl before, I'm glad to have learned her story.
Just a small problem though, the graphics and sound weren't quite well synced up. Don't know if it can be fixed without re-uploading the video.
Great video! I hope you're not intimidated by the awful comments or the number of dislikes.
maybe some people are troll-pressing the dislike-button, because youtube removed the like-bar? I am surprised, you can even see the dislikes...
3:49 I see the wrong date of death of Sophie there should be 22 of february 1943 not 07 january 1926
24 Mei
22;50 Nonton UA-cam 22:52 HAI How Sommeliers Can Taste Which Year Wine Is From 23:03 Nonton yg dulu belum selesai History Marche Sophie Scholl How A Young Woman Defied Hitler
Sophie Scholl has proven that you can be a rebel without violence. So should we be. Both Russia and Ukraine are fighting for power. We should side with neither.
Great job HM team for making this video and such a shame that they got caught and died fighting against one of the most evil regimes in history. And holy crap are there a lot of fascists in the comments, don't be discouraged by their negative feedback for covering an interesting and inspiring topic.
Dates at the @4:00 are off… fyi
And to imagine that in Germany in 2020 "Jana aus Kassel" (that's what the young woman has been called since then) dared to stand on stage during a "Querdenker" demonstration (the German equivalent of the Qanon movement) and say "I feel me like Sophie Scholl" because she is supposed to wear a mask when shopping, that really makes me doubt humanity. Fortunately, a young security worker grabbed the microphone and said that he doesn't do security for such nonsense.
I am sad I didn't come across this video sooner, I thought it was just military history you did, now I can see how wrong I was, and I wish there was more of this, if you could as I know it doesn't gain as much traction, this being your least popular video, could you make more videos such as this?
Started with low expectations but loved it. More to come?
Hopefully not
Her name and her ideas should live on forever.
Und ich denk immer an Jana aus Kassel...
I love your content
What a brave woman, incredible. So many people were "following orders", while she followed humanity and decency.
Propaganda, dodo!
Get out the matrix of fake history!
A war hero, in her own right
@@arkhammemery4712
You went to my channel to inslut me! Lol
For real grow up, mate!
@@GabrieLight Stop being pathetic.
@@hUCK-
Your all 5 comments on this channel is only against my person!
While I'm an old subscriber, have 111 comments (8 top comments) and received 3 hearts, and still didn’t offend anyone here yet!
For real grow up, dude!
This was an amazing story, job well done telling it 👍
An amazing young woman. How different the history of Germany may have been if she had lived past the Nazi tyranny
She was truly a hero.
Propaganda, dodo!
Get out the matrix of fake history!
@@GabrieLight You’re saying that none of that happened?
@@GabrieLight The White Rose happened. (my grandfather had one of their leaflets, it's how he got out)
@@misterarchaeopteryx7223
There was a movement with that name but the details you'll be surprised, as americans say the devil is in the details, most of these stories we grow up hearing, is completely fake, as example schindler's list they broadcasted it to millions of kids as a true story while it's completely fictional, and still we've people believe the story is true without searching just because they watched a movie in their childhood!
We have jewish people defend hitler and one of them debunked such stories in his book about this era, but you'll never hear that in mainstream media or common history because obviously the winner write the history.
@@GabrieLight You said it was fake history and then sort of admitted that the White Rose was real and then started talking about other things that aren’t related. Which part was the fake history? Scholl? The trial? The execution? The accusations? The actual events that lead to their arrest?
Try to keep your answers on topic. I’m genuinely curious.
And Garibaldi?
There is no one can challenge you with history lessons You are the best 🌹👍🏻 .
Such brave family in a storm of conflicts and lands of wars 💐
Great video thanks for sharing. Also I’m really happy your branching out and not just posting battles I mean don’t get me wrong I love em but history is not solely composed of battles. And don’t let idiots and nazi sympathizers try to intimidate you , your fans will support you.
Such great humans
Wow that was powerful!!
A cautionary tale always people ask would you follow the Nazi party oh no... Not me its not about the easy its about the hard....
great work
Thank you so much for this video.
How you gonna have paid sponsorship on a video like this? At least forward the proceeds to an appropriate/connected/associated charity in Sophie's name.
Let the guy earn his money, he puts a lot of effort into his videos. Who are you to judge.
mech arena is trash game ...... just adding
The holocaust brought to you by MECH ARENA
George smith it happened
This story is depressing and HistoryMarche deserves much praise for its presentation. She was a Hero of a willing to face torture and execution for what she believed was right.
Those hating on you aren’t true fans of this channel. Ignore them and do whatever you find most interesting.
This should ring loud for the russian people
Great content, great channel. Sounds like a time we have just experienced. We still suffer from prejudice in these times. Nationalist Socialist, whole different kind of socialist then modern Socialist. Fascism, on the hand hasn't changed much since before the fall of Rome.
It is literally no kind of socialism
Hans‘ last words before the execution were: „Es lebe die Freiheit!“ (long live liberty). The White Rose were real heroes, unlike all the supposedly „war heroes“!
Awesome as always
نريد ترجمة عربية
Just di it!
@@dittmannrudolfrohr2149 what?
Let's not forget that her foundation and strength was in Jesus Christ.
AMEN!!!
The waif is that you!?
Well, at least that dislike counter is going away.
1984 :(
Poor guy can't handle has favorite content creator receiving criticism
@@hazzmati Nazis aren't criticism
Probably better to name video "the white roses" or something. I had to search her name, had never heard of it, and she's part of a group of college students that were against the Nazis. Not even a founder, just a member.
Wow Captain Obvious. Aren't you smart
@@tilltronje1623 what was so obvious???
Herb Thompson. Point is she and the others stood up to the Nazis.
@@juliemerritt5144 this video makes it seem like one woman took on the nazis. She was part of a group and a very insignificant member
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
You speak it like "Haans" or "Hahns", but it's should sound like "Hanns" or "Han's". ;)