Wonderful lecture. Nice to see you returning back to theoretical frameworks instead of wasting time on perty affairs of current politics. Waiting for next episode in economic crisis series, really enjoyed lecture on Financial Reserve Banking I request you to please do detailed video on 1. Frankfurt school and their development of critical theory and neo-Marxism 2. Neo-Marxist critique of Classical Marxism and your response 3. Post-Structuralism and Derrida's 'deconstruction' 4. Michael Focault's concepts of discourses and power relations 5. Postmodern critique of Epistemology, science and metanarratives 6. Ideological roots of Woke movement and its destructive effects on society and politics of traditional left And specifically Trotsky vs Lenin I hope you will consider this request. You are a great teacher anyway. Also, please keep educating us on modern economy and Marxist alternatives
Please comrade sb make a video on all economic growth theories,best suited economic model for Pakistan education model best suited for Pakistan,how class difference can be minimized to get stronger social integrity...
It would have been important to refer to the Egyptian Social Pyramid. It's all encompassing and comprehensive which gives the framework for understanding the modern social class that emerged into the late 19th century.
Every now and then crisis in Pakistan triggers a debate on the form of government in Pakistan "Presidential vs Parliamentary". There are tendencies though dormant that Presidential form of government if placed can deliver on long-standing aspirations of masses. Sir please spare out time for this important debate. We are desperately waiting for your insights in this regard.
Sir plz start analysis videos series of left perspective on hot issues of Pakistan as well as world issues... And also solutions from Left people......
پاکستان میں شاعروں ادیبوں اور نئے لکھنے والے وہ لکھاری جو کتاب شائع کرانے کی ہمت اور استطاعت نہیں رکھتے ۔ ان کے لیے اب زبردست خوش خبری۔ میری نئی ویڈیو میں ملاحضہ فرمائیں
سر اگر ایک بندے کے پاس تھوڑی بہت زمین بھی ہو اور وہ کوئی ٹھلہ بھی لگا کے کما رہا ہو۔۔۔تو اسے کس کلاس میں رکھا جائے گا۔۔۔یعنی کہ ایک انسان کے ذرائع آمدن مختلف ہوں تو اس کی کیسے تقسیم کیا جائے گا
please sir phly hm comrades ko economic system k tamam lectures jo apny strt kr rkhy bnking sector sy agy.. wo prha k.. phr jo out of the box solution apk pas h wo dy k hmain phr ap ksi aur topic p jayein.. please sir dont mind
The debate of capitalism, socialism & communism confuses many. Let's have a look at it through the eye of taxes. Communism: 100% taxed on income Socialism: anything above 33% Capitalism: 0-33% Communism and Socialism has failed miserably and every time it fails communists will always blame the people who did not implement it properly. Let's stop propagating the unrealistic utopian world of equality and make progress by working hard and not by stealing money of those who work hard by taxing them.
@@Taimur_Laal I really admire your lectures and have great respect for you, however, to its core we have difference of opinion. Communism can never succeed, all the 20th century experiments have failed. The reason why communism and socialism look so attractive to many people is that either the institutions are too weak or people are just too lazy to acknowledge their inability to improve. Unfortunately, Pakistan is infested with both problems.
@@Taimur_Laal When everything is state owned and there is no private ownership then how come is it not 100% taxed? How can an individual thrive when there is no private ownership . The concept of common property ownership has never worked.
Bhai jan when everything is state owned the state doesn’t need to tax. More importantly, tax rate does not define a mode of production. OECD countries have extremely high tax rates (about 40-50%). In France about half the GDP is managed by the state. In US it is about 40%. According to your definition US is already socialist. Think about it.
Your capacity to explain difficult subjects in easiest possible narration is certainly commendable. Keep it up.
بلکل درست اس میں دو رائے نہیں۔۔ جیو کامریڈ
Wonderful lecture. Nice to see you returning back to theoretical frameworks instead of wasting time on perty affairs of current politics.
Waiting for next episode in economic crisis series, really enjoyed lecture on Financial Reserve Banking
I request you to please do detailed video on 1. Frankfurt school and their development of critical theory and neo-Marxism
2. Neo-Marxist critique of Classical Marxism and your response
3. Post-Structuralism and Derrida's 'deconstruction'
4. Michael Focault's concepts of discourses and power relations
5. Postmodern critique of Epistemology, science and metanarratives
6. Ideological roots of Woke movement and its destructive effects on society and politics of traditional left
And specifically Trotsky vs Lenin
I hope you will consider this request. You are a great teacher anyway. Also, please keep educating us on modern economy and Marxist alternatives
Sure. I teach all these in various classes. Will do a series.
Please comrade sb make a video on all economic growth theories,best suited economic model for Pakistan education model best suited for Pakistan,how class difference can be minimized to get stronger social integrity...
It would have been important to refer to the Egyptian Social Pyramid. It's all encompassing and comprehensive which gives the framework for understanding the modern social class that emerged into the late 19th century.
the editing skills is
improved, the man learning staff very well.
Dr Sahib. Pleasure seeing and listening you. You have wonderful communication skills.
یہ کلاس میرے لئے ہے واللہ۔۔۔❤️❤️
Zabardast. I had never heard the term petit bourgeoisie. Because of you I am learning something new. Salute
Love from india Kashmir anantnag kokernag vailoo checki gohan darpora
Loving this Change of Making Video with Words & Pictures explaining themselves👍
Sir please make videos on political philosophy....ur very great teacher...and ur way of teaching is excellent
Thanks sir , Detailed Short Explanation.
Gr8 sr...your ways of interpretation is 2nd to none
Very Informative lecture
Ur lectures r always enriching.
hum besbri say part 3 ka wait kr rahy thy... apny ye daal di vdeo
please jald part 3 uploaded krein.. waiting thanx sir
Good to learn. Thank you
Good analysis On capitalism
Keep working on socialism the peoples are listening you.. 👍👍❤️
good information with simple way,good effort
A captivating account
Happy teachers day sir ... lots of love,respect and gratitude
Wonderful lecture
We love ur lectures sir ??
Thanks
Thanks for this informative lecture .
How does one invest their money from a communist/socialist perspective in a capitalistic country?
Sir why dont you deliver a lecture on Baluchistan, Its political instability and above all its Severe issues
No word on what's is going on in IRAN ???
Apko kia kakleef ha?
Do you really think things are as worst as western media is trying to potrait?
Jahanam main jye iran 🤣😂
Sir plz make vdios on modernism and postmodernism
So much in a short video. Keep educating us sir. I wish you to also cover the topic of sustainable development in Pakistan.
Thank you.
Thanks Sir
Great Sir🌹
Every now and then crisis in Pakistan triggers a debate on the form of government in Pakistan "Presidential vs Parliamentary". There are tendencies though dormant that Presidential form of government if placed can deliver on long-standing aspirations of masses. Sir please spare out time for this important debate. We are desperately waiting for your insights in this regard.
great
surkh salamunas comrade v v informative for me though I'm a khandani working class Marxist communist . . . .
Some critique on the religions.
Very informative!
Great Sir👍♥
Sir also discuss start philosophy series plz plz plz.... Topic wise..
Sir plz start analysis videos series of left perspective on hot issues of Pakistan as well as world issues... And also solutions from Left people......
👌
Do make video on Social Structure;Determinants and Social Structure of Pakistan.
اب کیا بولے بندہ؟! بس سر جی تُسی گریٹ ہوں! جی کردا اے دو چار سو سال ہور جیوندے رَو
Sir who can be called as capitalist??? Are farmers,street vendors can be called capitalist ??
Who do ever has enough resources to employee labour in order to produce for the market to make a profit.
Asslamualikum Sir.kindly modren thoughts p ak lecture dn
پاکستان میں شاعروں ادیبوں اور نئے لکھنے والے وہ لکھاری جو کتاب شائع کرانے کی ہمت اور استطاعت نہیں رکھتے ۔ ان کے لیے اب زبردست خوش خبری۔ میری نئی ویڈیو میں ملاحضہ فرمائیں
Very nice
سر اگر ایک بندے کے پاس تھوڑی بہت زمین بھی ہو اور وہ کوئی ٹھلہ بھی لگا کے کما رہا ہو۔۔۔تو اسے کس کلاس میں رکھا جائے گا۔۔۔یعنی کہ ایک انسان کے ذرائع آمدن مختلف ہوں تو اس کی کیسے تقسیم کیا جائے گا
Comrade. ♥️
kindly make a video on Iranian revolution
In Pakistan we have insects, people, Corrupt People, more corrupt, and most corrupt on top. Unfortunately
sir g wo economic series p banking sector prhty prhty ye khn s agya lecture
please sir phly hm comrades ko economic system k tamam lectures jo apny strt kr rkhy bnking sector sy agy.. wo prha k.. phr jo out of the box solution apk pas h wo dy k hmain phr ap ksi aur topic p jayein.. please sir dont mind
sara haramTob academics me hota hai ruling elite ka alakar bnte hai chote mote Karpenche ke lei ?
sir how you edit your videos?
I have an editor
What's app group link plz
Ok...No Rich class and No Poor class.... only Middle class....Tax the Rich and give it to the poor so everyone ends up in the Middle 👍
your kind honour has not mention about handecrafats(HUNAR MUNDS) WHOES WER WISE PERSONS COUNTED
درمیان میں جو زمین دکھائی تھی ۔۔کیا وہ آپ کی اپنی تو نہیں 🤣
Lol. No I don’t own any land.
Ye hove na baat comrade shady kronga tu opre tbqa me kronga ?
I wish I could understand the language. 😢😭
Also there are English lectures
Labour Class.
Halate hazra k masile our un hal kiya hai is pr musalsal baat krte rehen
The debate of capitalism, socialism & communism confuses many.
Let's have a look at it through the eye of taxes.
Communism: 100% taxed on income
Socialism: anything above 33%
Capitalism: 0-33%
Communism and Socialism has failed miserably and every time it fails communists will always blame the people who did not implement it properly. Let's stop propagating the unrealistic utopian world of equality and make progress by working hard and not by stealing money of those who work hard by taxing them.
Sorry. That is totally incorrect.
@@Taimur_Laal I really admire your lectures and have great respect for you, however, to its core we have difference of opinion. Communism can never succeed, all the 20th century experiments have failed.
The reason why communism and socialism look so attractive to many people is that either the institutions are too weak or people are just too lazy to acknowledge their inability to improve. Unfortunately, Pakistan is infested with both problems.
Bhai if you want to criticise communism at least learn what it is. It is not 100% tax. That is absurd.
@@Taimur_Laal When everything is state owned and there is no private ownership then how come is it not 100% taxed? How can an individual thrive when there is no private ownership . The concept of common property ownership has never worked.
Bhai jan when everything is state owned the state doesn’t need to tax. More importantly, tax rate does not define a mode of production. OECD countries have extremely high tax rates (about 40-50%). In France about half the GDP is managed by the state. In US it is about 40%. According to your definition US is already socialist. Think about it.
Communist governments ny ko zulam cambodia Russia china Cuba solvikia ny kiya yeh nazam bhi koi khas Acha nhi hy
Very impresive lecture