After viewing this episode my respect and regards towards sri.palghat ramaorasad ji has increased to1000 times more now. Solid upto the mark argument. Thank you ji
@@dharmaraajramaswamy9541 Also balanced - he (Ramprasad) gives credit when / where it is due. And points out flaws in the arguments or behavior. That is why his words carry weight in my opinion.
Brilliant interview , highlighting the true conviction of every artist . Completely agree with his views which are very responsible & with out any prejudice. Well done RP.
Very clear explanation, appreciate the way he presented the argument ,totally agree with him on his view point. Came to know about the stalwarts in his family and how they upheld the highest principals.
The anchor of this channel, even before TMK controversy, always brings up the Brahmin- non brahmin isuue with every artist he interviews ...he has got a special intetest in this devide more than the music
Late Sri Palakkad Mani Iyer was a trail blazer in the Carnatic music eco system. A mridangist who, rose to dominating an art by being recognized as first amongst equals vis a vis a vocalist on a carnatic music stage without seeking this honor, has left a great legacy! His ability with the mridangam had the well wishers of this art bestow him this stature. No other mridangist has, to date, achieved this feat! He was the 'sambandhi' of another carnatic music great, Smt DK Pattamal. It is at the core of the ethos and culture of this art that the family of this great have stepped up and expressed their unhappiness at this controversial act of the present custodians of the Music academy.
WHY THERE IS NO PROPER COOPERATION AND UNIFIED voice to Against TMK & Music Academy amongst Carnatic fraternity??? They are not united. Though many Senior vidwans feel TMK is wrong, butthey keep their mouth shut because they will lose whatever little chance during the season. RAGA TRICHUR BROTHERS PALGHAT RAMPRASAD AND OTHERS SAID THAT BOYCOTT THIS SEASON AT ACADEMY.THEY SHOULD DO FOREVER. I BLAME ALL MUSICIANS TO OPPOSE ACADEMY FOR THEIR DOMINANCE. TMK NOT PERFORMED IN Academy FOR 10 YEARS IT MEANS NOBODY PERFORMED IN ACADEMY LIKE TMK THEREFORE THEY NOMINATED SK AWARD TO TMK. IT'S TOTALLY INJUSTICE TO TRADITIONAL CARNATIC MUSIC & MUSICIANS.
Brilliant !!! Finally someone has the spine to talk wat is the truth 🙏🙏🙏 Our Respect and pranams to Palghat Ramprasad 🙏🙏🙏 Why TMK has not had accompanying artists from other communities? As Ramprasad has stated, why cant he donate 50%of his income towards downtrodden people from creators in music field ,instead of fancying them on posters ??!! TMK is like actor Surya ( for JaiBhim) , wants his award ,money etc but wont actually do anythjng for economically affected people. TMK is a hypocrite who used all opportunities from carnatic music to get his name, fame and power but now using it in the most horrible way. Senior vidwans are silent as they are worried if their fame( earned all these years) might drop / people might misjudge them for openly pointing out this hypocrisy etc etc. Sad to see Caenatic music in this state. Evil looks cool nowadays.. That's the trend. Really pathetic. Stop going to Music Academy - is the best tribute we can give to all those people who really worked to keep this carnatic music alive 🙏🙏🙏 ( The list of people who really worked to protect its sanctity included non brahmins & people from other religions too, unlike this fake personality TMK )
Hats off to Ramprasad. Very clear thoughts. And well articulated . TMK ia disease . A great talent gone wrong. Tm krishna is a paper rebel. He has not done nothing to Lower castes..only talk. So cheap of him to chafacter aassasination
Well said... T M Krishna despite his talent and accolades he has won is an apology to music society. ஒரு குடம் பாலில் ஒரு சொட்டு விஷம்.... அந்த விஷம் தான் T M கிருஷ்ணா..
எனக்கு இந்த DMK sorry TMK பிரச்சினை வந்தபோது இரு பாடல் வரிகள் தான் ஞாபகம் வந்தது. "காசிருந்தால் தான் சுண்டச் சொல்லும் கண்டவர் வாயைக் கிண்டச் சொல்லும். ( will continue-Running out of time)
T M கிருஷ்ணா இதுவரை ஒரு தாழ்த்தப்பட்டவருக்குக்கூட இசை பயிற்றுவித்து மேடையேற்றவில்லை என்பது உண்மை. மாறாக இவரிடம் படித்தவர்கள் அனைவரும் பார்ப்பனர்கள் அல்லது வெளிநாட்டவர்கள் தான். கிருஷ்ணா வருடத்துக்கு ஒருமுறை ஆல்காட் குப்பத்தில் கர்நாடக இசைக்கச்சேரி நிகழ்த்துவதால் இசையைப் பரப்பமுடியுமா?
Palakad mani Iyer had on many occasions said that musicians should respect their seniors since they were only responsible for keeping the carnatic music alive. In a felicitation to mdr on her s getting padmasri award Sri mani iyer very much emphasized this point.
Welldone Mr.Ramprasad. Somewhere, I had been through a phrase, " We are not supposed to question past legends of carnatic music or the traditions they had set. The quality of carnatic sangeeth is spiralling downward gradually for the past five decades. The 90 kids in Brahmin community, or else where from other communities, if any, are in the name of innovation or research a re pollluting the carnatic music. An advice for Mr.TMK ,please don't break the very old traditions, Leave it as it is. Since you hail from a viable and wealthy family, you can survive with a branch of the business that your family developed. Why you gentleman, toiling with Thodi and Komboji?. Please don't shake and axe down the very core of carnatic music.
Mani Iyer accompanied MLV only on her last stage of career, when the Shruthi of musician came down. Many vidwans had reservations in accompanying female artists due to the high shruthi of the vidwans. To the best of my knowledge Lalgudi Jayaraman did not accompany any female artist and it was rumoured that he was not bestowed with Sangeeta Kalanidhi by MA because he was reported to have refused to accompany M S on her getting the award. T N Krishnan had also not accompanied female artist. There are many mirudhangam artists who were reluctant to accompany women performers.
Sri Mani not playing accompaniment to female artists is SRUTHI ,WHICH IS TECNICAL ; HE MAY NOT LIKE TO COMPROMISE HIS PERFORMANCE LEVEL . ALL WHO DO NOT HAVE GOOD GRASP OF MUSIC CANNOT UNDERSTAND THIS .
The mistake is not with musicians like tmk the mistake is with people who are zero knowledge in music are pampering him. The present music academy doesn't have any honest eminent musicians as judge and the award granted by communist group whose knowledge in music zero with dravida model support
No music teacher stopped teaching to someone due to castism, anyone with interest and commitment can learn from the gurus. We can give numerous example. The winner is carnatic music. Let's put effort to ensure we take this art form to the next generation.
Your family, your award, your decision, your return. Both the anchor and guest are immature. Anchor always intentionally does such interviews and about the guest , less said is better.
Why other community stalwarts like Yesudas has not produced sishyas from their communities? Sirkali Govindarajan should have taught/ brought many chettiar sishyas, but yesudass and sirkali taught their sons only. Dandapani Desikar, Madurai Somu should have groomed many sishyas from their communities but they didn’t. Brahmins on their own interest are learning without worrying about the financial prospects of Carnatic music. Only a very few become rich and famous thru Carnatic music but a large number learn of Brahmins for their interest and commitment towards culture and traditions. Instead of blaming one community, ask questions to other community stalwarts of yesteryears as to why they never bothered to teach music to students of their communities.
Not only that. The listed few non- brahmins had learned the music with Bhakthi, dedication and traditional way. They also taught their children. It is not the caste anymore it is only the three things that they practiced.
😂😂😂😂இந்த நெறியாளரின் கேள்வியும் அதற்கு வரும் பதிலையும் பார்க்கும் பொழுது 😅😅😅வடிவேலுவின் எங்க அப்பா வாசிக்க எங்க அம்மா நடனமாட என்ற காமெடியை ஞாபகப்படுத்துகிறது 😅😅😅😅இவர்கள் இருவருக்கும் உள்ளே இருப்பது சாதிய கட்டமைப்பின் திமிர் 😅😅😅😅இதை எதிர்க்கும் டி எம் கிருஷ்ணாவை பார்த்தால் இவர்கள் வயிற்று எரிச்சல் படத்தான் செய்வார்கள் 😅😅😅😅
Vidwans Vidhushis, who have self respect for their Art, Elders and mumoorthis should give back this award and in future no respectful artist should accept the award .. will anyone do it..I don't think..99.999% will retain it.. Hell will MA
There is another heresay story. Mani Iyer was reported to have rejected the Padma Award when it was announced. His contention was that his guru was not bestowed with such awards and therefore he will not accept. But elderly musicians pleaded with him, that the award is a recognition to the Mirudangam and the art associated with that and he then reluctantly accepted it.
It's only hearsay. Awards like Padma are not announced before the awardee gives his confirmation that he will accept the honour bestowed. These awards are announced in the name of the President, hence any rejection of the award will be considered a big insult to the head of the state, so the govt will personally inform the awardee and then will announce it publicly only after the awardee gives his consent.
@@natarajanb1905 May be it could be , Mani Iyer would have said no when he was sounded. Very recently, one singer did refuse to accept or the offer of Padma Vibhushan stating she deserved Bharath Ratna. It is also a fact that he was the first mirudangam.arrtist to be conferred the Kalanidhi Award by MA.
@@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 Maybe that singer is not aware of the system. Only after a person is given the Padma Vibhushan they become eligible for Bharat Ratna consideration. A person will be first given Padma Shri, then Padma Bhushan, then Padma Bhushan and then the highest honour Bharat Ratna. So if 1000 Padma Shri's are given, only 100-150 Padma Bhushan is given and then 10-15 Padma Vibhushan's are given and then there could be ONE Bharat Ratna which may be given or not given if no suitable person is found.
@@natarajanb1905 I am afraid that you are factually incorrect. Mr Nehru, Mrs Ghandhi, K Kamaraj, Shri Vinoba, Sri C Rajagopalachari, M G R, M Visweswarayya, P V Narasimha Rao 0:01 and host of others were bestowed with Bharath Ratna straightaway. Again there are many who have been bestowed Padma Vibhushan straight away. This post is only to correct the record.
மக்களக்கு மறதி ஜாஸ்த்தி எல்லா துறையிலும். அரசியிலில் உள்ளது போல் திறைபடத்திலம் நடந்து போல் கர்நாடிக் இசையிலும் செய்யலாம் என்ற என்னமாக இருக்குமோ? ஆனால் இசை கலைங்கர்கள் எல்லோரும் அனைவரும் அவர் அவர் எல்லை தெரிந்தவர்கள் ஆகவே இதில் அரசியில் செய்யாமல் எது பாறம்பிறையம் அதை தொடர்ந்தால் நல்லது.
Any cultured talented person will not explicitly reveal his negative 0pinion against other celebrity .TMK is very much lacking in this respect..I or nobody for that matter, expected such mean comments from the grand nephew of Late TTK the past chief of MAn
If Krishna want to have the gimmicks what he is doing let him do in politics, not in music field. No.1 crooked minded fellows better not to be in music field. His saying says...Acharavillada nalige thanna neecha buddiya bidadu nalige, vicharavillade parara dooshisuvudakke chachikondiruva nalige.
No she is not. She has clearly stated in one interview. She is opposed to Tmk’s views and negative comments on the singers and the whole attitude of tmk. In fact in an interview, when asked about teaching Carnatic music to non Brahmins children, (which is another thing tmk went around accusing every singer) Sudha mam’- asked ‘has tmk done it! (meaning - is he practicing what he’s preaching?)
Bhakthi. Is there. But you don’t have the knowledge of what is bhakthi. கோவிலுக்கு போனால் பக்தி உணர்வோடு கடவுளை. வணங்கவேண்டும். அந்த உணர்வை யாரும் ஊட்டவோ திணிக்கவோ முடியாது
ஏழ்மை நிலைமையில் இருக்கும் instruments makers க்கு நீங்க என்ன உதவி செய்கிறீர்கள் திரு ராம்பிரசாத் ? ?.உங்களுக்கு சம்மமாக வாசிக்கும் பக்க வாத்திய கலைஞர்கள் உங்களைப்போல். ஊதியம் கிடைக்கிறதா ?
While there are chunks in TMKs views, this person effuses Brahminical arrogance and intolerance. He is a hypocrite to say that he is a Brahmin because he follows a few practices. Ones caste is determined by birth in Indian society.
After viewing this episode my respect and regards towards sri.palghat ramaorasad ji has increased to1000 times more now. Solid upto the mark argument. Thank you ji
Mr Ramprasad's responses are clear and crisp.... Thanks
@@dharmaraajramaswamy9541 Also balanced - he (Ramprasad) gives credit when / where it is due. And points out flaws in the arguments or behavior. That is why his words carry weight in my opinion.
நன்றி ராம்ப்ரஸாத். நல்ல விளக்கம்
Brilliant interview , highlighting the true conviction of every artist . Completely agree with his views which are very responsible & with out any prejudice. Well done RP.
Excellent interview Replies by Shri.Palghat Ramprasad and you have aptly responded to all Questions
Brilliant reply with subtle surcasm
Very clear explanation, appreciate the way he presented the argument ,totally agree with him on his view point.
Came to know about the stalwarts in his family and how they upheld the highest principals.
Great interview Ram. You spoke so well
The anchor of this channel, even before TMK controversy, always brings up the Brahmin- non brahmin isuue with every artist he interviews ...he has got a special intetest in this devide more than the music
Of course!
I think this interviewer should go and interview Krishna as well.
Never knew Mr. Ram Prasad is such an interesting personality ! Really wonderful.
Ramprasad is talking100% truth. Very logical and honest. All should boycot TMK.
Late Sri Palakkad Mani Iyer was a trail blazer in the Carnatic music eco system. A mridangist who, rose to dominating an art by being recognized as first amongst equals vis a vis a vocalist on a carnatic music stage without seeking this honor, has left a great legacy! His ability with the mridangam had the well wishers of this art bestow him this stature. No other mridangist has, to date, achieved this feat! He was the 'sambandhi' of another carnatic music great, Smt DK Pattamal. It is at the core of the ethos and culture of this art that the family of this great have stepped up and expressed their unhappiness at this controversial act of the present custodians of the Music academy.
Stop saying “no other mridangist has, to date blah blah bullshit” here. In your narrow mind and caste blindness, these words are coming out.
நல்ல clarity ❤
Ram Prasad , I respect you, love your singing,. Everyone in your family is a great artist,
Ramprasad is not against TMK as artist but his attitude and behaviour against artists...
WHY THERE IS NO PROPER COOPERATION AND UNIFIED voice to Against TMK & Music Academy
amongst Carnatic fraternity???
They are not united. Though many Senior vidwans feel TMK is wrong, butthey keep their mouth shut because they will lose whatever little chance during the season. RAGA TRICHUR BROTHERS PALGHAT RAMPRASAD AND OTHERS SAID THAT BOYCOTT THIS SEASON AT ACADEMY.THEY SHOULD DO FOREVER.
I BLAME ALL MUSICIANS TO OPPOSE ACADEMY FOR THEIR DOMINANCE. TMK NOT PERFORMED IN Academy FOR 10 YEARS IT MEANS NOBODY PERFORMED IN ACADEMY LIKE TMK THEREFORE THEY NOMINATED SK AWARD TO TMK.
IT'S TOTALLY INJUSTICE TO TRADITIONAL CARNATIC MUSIC & MUSICIANS.
Brilliant !!! Finally someone has the spine to talk wat is the truth 🙏🙏🙏 Our Respect and pranams to Palghat Ramprasad
🙏🙏🙏
Why TMK has not had accompanying artists from other communities? As Ramprasad has stated, why cant he donate 50%of his income towards downtrodden people from creators in music field ,instead of fancying them on posters ??!! TMK is like actor Surya ( for JaiBhim) , wants his award ,money etc but wont actually do anythjng for economically affected people. TMK is a hypocrite who used all opportunities from carnatic music to get his name, fame and power but now using it in the most horrible way.
Senior vidwans are silent as they are worried if their fame( earned all these years) might drop / people might misjudge them for openly pointing out this hypocrisy etc etc. Sad to see Caenatic music in this state.
Evil looks cool nowadays.. That's the trend. Really pathetic.
Stop going to Music Academy - is the best tribute we can give to all those people who really worked to keep this carnatic music alive 🙏🙏🙏 ( The list of people who really worked to protect its sanctity included non brahmins & people from other religions too, unlike this fake personality TMK )
பன்னியை மனிதர்கள் இன்டர்வியூ செய்யமாட்டார்கள்
@@veeraraghavantr2848 u mean TMK as Pig ! Why are u insulting the Pig.
Excellent responses by Palghat Ramprasad
Hats off to Ramprasad. Very clear thoughts. And well articulated .
TMK ia disease . A great talent gone wrong. Tm krishna is a paper rebel.
He has not done nothing to Lower castes..only talk.
So cheap of him to chafacter aassasination
Well said... T M Krishna despite his talent and accolades he has won is an apology to music society.
ஒரு குடம் பாலில் ஒரு சொட்டு விஷம்....
அந்த விஷம் தான் T M கிருஷ்ணா..
He minted a treasure from many. From SRV School, Samayapuram is one among of his golden treasure.
Excellent and candid views
Very nice sarcastic reply by Shri. Ramprasad in this interview.
Rebels are not Toxic, TMK is Toxic
நல்ல பதிவு
Very good answers. Great questions. Hopefully, the HC will see merit and stop issue of MS Award at the Music Academy.
TMK க்கும் DMK க்கும் ஒரு எழுத்து தான் வித்யாசம்
எனக்கு இந்த DMK sorry TMK பிரச்சினை வந்தபோது இரு பாடல் வரிகள் தான் ஞாபகம் வந்தது. "காசிருந்தால் தான் சுண்டச் சொல்லும்
கண்டவர் வாயைக் கிண்டச் சொல்லும். ( will continue-Running out of time)
T M Krushna should be ashamed to take the award after these many controversies
Clarity 🎉🎉🎉🎉
If MS amma is Barbie doll TMK is Frankenstein
Very well said Sri.Ramprasad
Good Ramprasad God bless you. Maintain the same courage and direct hit talks.
Good Roast 👌by Ramprasad
Dr Ramprasad's clarity is awesome!
உண்மையில் நீங்கள் நல்ல விஷயம் செய்து இருக்கிறீர்கள்
T M கிருஷ்ணா இதுவரை ஒரு தாழ்த்தப்பட்டவருக்குக்கூட இசை பயிற்றுவித்து மேடையேற்றவில்லை என்பது உண்மை. மாறாக இவரிடம் படித்தவர்கள் அனைவரும் பார்ப்பனர்கள் அல்லது வெளிநாட்டவர்கள் தான்.
கிருஷ்ணா வருடத்துக்கு ஒருமுறை ஆல்காட் குப்பத்தில் கர்நாடக இசைக்கச்சேரி நிகழ்த்துவதால் இசையைப் பரப்பமுடியுமா?
@@Arbutham-e6k he is after money to survive
Why use abusive word 'parppanar'. You shouldbe sued.
டி.எம்.கிருஷ்ணா ஒரு திராவிட கலப்படம்.
Hats off Ramprasadji. Along with the way u exposed the stupidity of Krishna, I luv the way u spoke the truth about the NRIs.
டிஎம்கிருஷ்ணா மனதில் ஊனம் உடைய ஒரு மனிதன். THAT'S ALL
Very good interview.
Tmk is spent force.
By taking nonsense TMK wants attention seeking.
🙏💯 correct, Palakkad Ram ji 👍
Palakad mani Iyer had on many occasions said that musicians should respect their seniors since they were only responsible for keeping the carnatic music alive. In a felicitation to mdr on her s getting padmasri award Sri mani iyer very much emphasized this point.
Please in the above remark as mdr on his getting Padma award.
This anchor is a pro dravida. I have seen him ask provoking questions to the guests earlier.
An anchor must extract information from the interviewee by asking suitable questions, sometimes even provoking the interviewee.
I am reddiyar community i did my MA Music as well as my teacher is Cherthala sivakumar
பாலச்சந்தரையும் பாரதிராஜாவையும் "அனைவரும்" ஏற்றுக்கொண்டார்கள் என்று எப்படி கூறலாம்.பலர் ஏற்றனர் என்றுவேண்டுமானால் கூறலாம்.அதே போலத்தான் .
பாரதிராஜா இயற்கையாக படம் எடுத்தார். பாலசந்தர் படங்களில் மிகையும் செயற்கைத தன்மையும தூக்கலாக இருக்கும
Perfect answer
I love this guy.
10:20 சரியான பதில்
Brilliant and bold. Kudos to Sri Ramprasad. But for him,Dirty elements like TMK will destroy our culture and the honour of our musicians.
Welldone Mr.Ramprasad. Somewhere, I had been through a phrase, " We are not supposed to question past legends of carnatic music or the traditions they had set. The quality of carnatic sangeeth is spiralling downward gradually for the past five decades. The 90 kids in Brahmin community, or else where from other communities, if any, are in the name of innovation or research a re pollluting the carnatic music. An advice for Mr.TMK ,please don't break the very old traditions, Leave it as it is. Since you hail from a viable and wealthy family, you can survive with a branch of the business that your family developed. Why you gentleman, toiling with Thodi and Komboji?. Please don't shake and axe down the very core of carnatic music.
Many of us agree with Ramprasad but we have no podium to express
Person who called MS Amma a barbie doll is a narcissist.
TMK is cheap powermonger by adopting least grade publicity
19:42 🔥 🔥 😅😅
அந்தணர் என்போர் அறவோர் மற்றெவ்வுயிற்கும் செந்தண்மை பூண்டு ஒழுக லான்!!!
திருவள்ளுவர்.
Very sarcastic.
Nice
இவருடைய தாத்தா MS / MLV போன்றவர்களுக்கு மிருதங்கம் வாசிக்க மறுத்தாக ஒரு பேச்சு உண்டு. அப்படி இருக்க இப்போது MS க்காக பொங்குவது சற்று வியப்பாக உள்ளது.
He's speaking on behalf of today's situation..
@grajendran4821 seri, appo onnu yaaru pesanum nu sollu illaati nee pesu. ivar pesalama koodadha nu nee solla vendam.
தாத்தா காலத்து பேச்சு உண்மை/பொய் என தெரியாது. உண்மையாகவே இருந்தாலும் கூட, அதனால் இவருக்கு தனது கருத்தை சொல்ல உரிமை இல்லாமல் போகாது.
Mani Iyer accompanied MLV only on her last stage of career, when the Shruthi of musician came down. Many vidwans had reservations in accompanying female artists due to the high shruthi of the vidwans. To the best of my knowledge Lalgudi Jayaraman did not accompany any female artist and it was rumoured that he was not bestowed with Sangeeta Kalanidhi by MA because he was reported to have refused to accompany
M S on her getting the award.
T N Krishnan had also not accompanied female artist.
There are many mirudhangam artists who were reluctant to accompany women performers.
Sri Mani not playing accompaniment to female artists is SRUTHI ,WHICH IS TECNICAL ; HE MAY NOT LIKE TO COMPROMISE HIS PERFORMANCE LEVEL .
ALL WHO DO NOT HAVE GOOD GRASP OF MUSIC CANNOT UNDERSTAND THIS .
During corna period Mr Krishna helped financely for many poor musicians
Hats off to Mr Krishna
கலி முத்தி போய் கொண்டு இருக்கு. அதனால் TMK போன்ற கலக வித்துவான்கள் நிறைய வந்து கொண்டே இருப்பர். அதையும் மிஞ்சி இந்த கலை நிச்சயம் வளரும்.
ரொம்ப முக்கியம் இது. அவனவன் பல ப்ரச்னை ல இருக்கான் .. வித்ஃவான் ப்ரச்னை தான் பெரிய ப்ரச்னை இவனுகளுக்கு
@@-_.0O நாடு என்றால் பல பிரச்சினைகள் இருக்கும். உனக்கு பிடிக்கவில்லை என்றால் இந்த சானல் பார்க்காத.
@@-_.0Oநீ உலக பிரச்சினைகள் எல்லாத்தையும் தீர்க்கற பெரிய பொறுப்புல இருக்கறதாலதான் இங்க வந்து கமென்ட் போடற.
@@-_.0Oclassic music uyirodu irukka ithu romba mukkiyam thaan. Why should u waste your time in this video?
The mistake is not with musicians like tmk the mistake is with people who are zero knowledge in music are pampering him. The present music academy doesn't have any honest eminent musicians as judge and the award granted by communist group whose knowledge in music zero with dravida model support
RamRam. Very logical.👏👏
No music teacher stopped teaching to someone due to castism, anyone with interest and commitment can learn from the gurus. We can give numerous example.
The winner is carnatic music. Let's put effort to ensure we take this art form to the next generation.
Very smart person!!
Your family, your award, your decision, your return. Both the anchor and guest are immature. Anchor always intentionally does such interviews and about the guest , less said is better.
Your comment..your view ..less said the better
@@krajiv23😂... Not surprised
@@madhukacs immature? Then who do you think is mature? You or the lord of social reforms in carnatic music TMK?
@@vijay99401 definitely not the 2 in the video or their supporters
There maslow self esteem needs will play....
But one thing is clear that the carnatic music has not crossed Mambalam Rlyway line
Why other community stalwarts like Yesudas has not produced sishyas from their communities? Sirkali Govindarajan should have taught/ brought many chettiar sishyas, but yesudass and sirkali taught their sons only. Dandapani Desikar, Madurai Somu should have groomed many sishyas from their communities but they didn’t. Brahmins on their own interest are learning without worrying about the financial prospects of Carnatic music. Only a very few become rich and famous thru Carnatic music but a large number learn of Brahmins for their interest and commitment towards culture and traditions. Instead of blaming one community, ask questions to other community stalwarts of yesteryears as to why they never bothered to teach music to students of their communities.
Not only that. The listed few non- brahmins had learned the music with Bhakthi, dedication and traditional way. They also taught their children. It is not the caste anymore it is only the three things that they practiced.
Keep crying …
Take the rail nd go to Alwarpet, mylapore 😂
குத்நு பாடல் பாட வேண்டும்? Seerkazhi govindarajan Vinayagar songs & t.m.soundararajan subramanya songs you can sing ?
If he decides to sing he can sing, but it will be in his own style.
@@sangitasrinivasan1795
You can sing bhakti folk song not others
@@sangitasrinivasan1795
Yesudas learnt carnatic music because of periyar ? Don't lie
@@sangitasrinivasan1795
Periyar has written in his book பார்ப்பான் ஒழிக only imagination creation he fought for others
@@sangitasrinivasan1795
Kanimozhi DMK MP anti caste so cancel reservation quota?
😂😂😂😂இந்த நெறியாளரின் கேள்வியும் அதற்கு வரும் பதிலையும் பார்க்கும் பொழுது 😅😅😅வடிவேலுவின் எங்க அப்பா வாசிக்க எங்க அம்மா நடனமாட என்ற காமெடியை ஞாபகப்படுத்துகிறது 😅😅😅😅இவர்கள் இருவருக்கும் உள்ளே இருப்பது சாதிய கட்டமைப்பின் திமிர் 😅😅😅😅இதை எதிர்க்கும் டி எம் கிருஷ்ணாவை பார்த்தால் இவர்கள் வயிற்று எரிச்சல் படத்தான் செய்வார்கள் 😅😅😅😅
Ram Prasad is an intellectual.
பச்சை சட்டைக் காரரே நீங்க யார் பின்னாடீ இருக்கீங்க...உங்களுக்கு ஊர்வம்பு பேசுவது என்றால் ரொம்ப பிடீக்குமோ
Vidwans Vidhushis, who have self respect for their Art, Elders and mumoorthis should give back this award and in future no respectful artist should accept the award .. will anyone do it..I don't think..99.999% will retain it.. Hell will MA
@16.10…. அநியாயத்துக்கு குசும்பு 😅
Cinema vera. Film is vera..TMK talked bad about MS Amma
Tmk wants awards and rewards but wants to show confrontation...for name sake.
Nethiyadi Ramprasad. In short woke virus has entered carnatic music just like in other areas
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Palghat Mani Iyer was Nandi amsam... MSAmma was a Gandharva amsam... pity TMK - a ignorant rant is getting the same award
excellent replies
There is another heresay story.
Mani Iyer was reported to have
rejected the Padma Award when it was announced. His contention was that his guru was not bestowed with such awards and therefore he will not accept. But elderly musicians pleaded with him, that the award is a recognition to the Mirudangam and the art associated with that and he then reluctantly accepted it.
It's only hearsay. Awards like Padma are not announced before the awardee gives his confirmation that he will accept the honour bestowed. These awards are announced in the name of the President, hence any rejection of the award will be considered a big insult to the head of the state, so the govt will personally inform the awardee and then will announce it publicly only after the awardee gives his consent.
@@natarajanb1905 May be it could be , Mani Iyer would have said no when he was sounded. Very recently, one singer did refuse to accept or the offer of Padma Vibhushan stating she deserved
Bharath Ratna. It is also a fact that he was the first mirudangam.arrtist to be conferred the Kalanidhi Award by MA.
@@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 Maybe that singer is not aware of the system. Only after a person is given the Padma Vibhushan they become eligible for Bharat Ratna consideration. A person will be first given Padma Shri, then Padma Bhushan, then Padma Bhushan and then the highest honour Bharat Ratna. So if 1000 Padma Shri's are given, only 100-150 Padma Bhushan is given and then 10-15 Padma Vibhushan's are given and then there could be ONE Bharat Ratna which may be given or not given if no suitable person is found.
@@natarajanb1905
I am afraid that you are factually incorrect.
Mr Nehru, Mrs Ghandhi, K Kamaraj, Shri Vinoba, Sri C Rajagopalachari, M G R,
M Visweswarayya, P V Narasimha Rao 0:01 and host of others were bestowed with Bharath Ratna straightaway.
Again there are many who have been bestowed Padma Vibhushan straight away.
This post is only to correct the record.
@@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 They are all politicians and for them no rules or regulations apply.
மக்களக்கு மறதி ஜாஸ்த்தி எல்லா துறையிலும். அரசியிலில் உள்ளது போல் திறைபடத்திலம் நடந்து போல் கர்நாடிக் இசையிலும் செய்யலாம் என்ற என்னமாக இருக்குமோ? ஆனால் இசை கலைங்கர்கள் எல்லோரும் அனைவரும் அவர் அவர் எல்லை தெரிந்தவர்கள் ஆகவே இதில் அரசியில் செய்யாமல் எது பாறம்பிறையம் அதை தொடர்ந்தால் நல்லது.
20.21 ....super
There is a famous saying in Treasure island. Dead men don't talk. Wondering how this is so true here.
Blind don’t see, deaf don’t hear🥱🥱
Any cultured talented person will not explicitly reveal his negative 0pinion against other celebrity .TMK is very much lacking in this respect..I or nobody for that matter, expected such mean comments from the grand nephew of Late TTK the past chief of MAn
ராம்பிரசாத். உங்க பதிலில் நக்கல் தெரிகிறது. கோபம் காரணம் என்றாலும் அது சரியில்லை. டி எம் கிருஷ்ணா வுக்கு உங்கள் கோபம் உதவி செய்யும் .
If Krishna want to have the gimmicks what he is doing let him do in politics, not in music field. No.1 crooked minded fellows better not to be in music field. His saying says...Acharavillada nalige thanna neecha buddiya bidadu nalige, vicharavillade parara dooshisuvudakke chachikondiruva nalige.
Will he reduce 50% of his fees..
A correction in my remarks above. In place of mdr on her padma award it mah be read as mdr on his padma award.
Make corrections in original comment, using edit option available in the vertical 3 dots on the right. Separate correction will largely go unnoticed.
How come Sudha ji is performing in music academy this season .is she ok with Tmk views
No she is not. She has clearly stated in one interview. She is opposed to Tmk’s views and negative comments on the singers and the whole attitude of tmk. In fact in an interview, when asked about teaching Carnatic music to non Brahmins children, (which is another thing tmk went around accusing every singer) Sudha mam’- asked ‘has tmk done it! (meaning - is he practicing what he’s preaching?)
She is slated to sing this year
@@Ozmailabala oh, is it?
Sudha is after fame so she will never miss MA. Even her slot is down graded to 12 noon.
As sri Ramprasad says
established artists are not opening their mouth even Sowmya madam and Sri Sanjay are singing in MA
🎉🎉
Music is bakti and devition which krishna doesnt hv..
Bhakthi. Is there. But you don’t have the knowledge of what is bhakthi. கோவிலுக்கு போனால் பக்தி உணர்வோடு கடவுளை. வணங்கவேண்டும். அந்த உணர்வை யாரும் ஊட்டவோ திணிக்கவோ முடியாது
கிருஷ்ணாவுக்கு கொடுத்த சவுக்கடி
ஏழ்மை நிலைமையில் இருக்கும் instruments makers க்கு நீங்க என்ன உதவி செய்கிறீர்கள் திரு ராம்பிரசாத் ? ?.உங்களுக்கு சம்மமாக வாசிக்கும் பக்க வாத்திய கலைஞர்கள் உங்களைப்போல். ஊதியம் கிடைக்கிறதா ?
Krishna’s mouth need to be shut by not giving importance to his verbal farts.
Why no chat wrth TMK
Krishna is a great singer. Its painful to see the man of todays generation openly supporting casteism.
He is not a great singer.....
@@AsuriSaranyes
Sinner
While there are chunks in TMKs views, this person effuses Brahminical arrogance and intolerance. He is a hypocrite to say that he is a Brahmin because he follows a few practices. Ones caste is determined by birth in Indian society.
Palakad Mani Iyer
இவர் யாருடைய பேரன் அறிமுகம் இல்லாமல் பேட்டி
Mridanga Vidwan Palghat Mani Iyer aiyya oda peran
@@nroutemusic7783 oh I see
See what happened to பலான சந்து, பக்கிராஜ், பாரதிராஜா JK. TM கிருஷ்ணா will be ....... சத்தியம்
Aga, Ramakrishna murthy nema nistayoda PhD padichela?? Adhan Behavioral economics..
Y is he claiming as brahmin then...does he do gayatri...
Exuthukkum paduvatharkum vithyasam