The Lost Inqalab: The Lack of Revolutionary Thought in Subcontinent !
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- The Lost Inqalab: Lack of Revolutionary Spirit in Subcontinent's Youth and it's Reasons.
تلاش انقلاب: نوجوانوں میں سیاسی انقلابی فکر نہ ہونے کی وجہ کیا ہے؟
#revolution #pakistan #india
Don't worry about the views. If you changed the thoughts of one single person in a positive way, you succeed. And you really succeed bro, you changed mine.
❤️❤️❤️
And he changed many... Lots of love for muzammil bhai♥️♥️
Me too!
Not sure if inciting violent revolution is ‘positive’ advice. The French Revolution was a bloodbath that led to the instatement of a litany of corrupt misogynistic governments. Just like the Arab Spring. Change charged by violence breeds more violence and no positive change.
@@nadiashireensiddiqi To be honest all revolutions have been bloodbaths. That is the sacrifice it takes.
Pakistan could do with more people like you. Keep it up and stay safe.
Also in india
Muzammil bhai, if there would be only one person left watching your videos I want to be that person!!!.you have no clue how much i admire and adore you. please never stop making videos for this deep rooted patriarchal society with scores of male chauvinists in it. never get discouraged about the views and reach of your content.as revolution takes time!!!!
❤️
@@syedmuzammilofficial7067 Assalamulaikum Muzzammil, what are your thoughts about engineer Muhammad Ali mirza. I know i can't draw a parallel between Martin luther and him, but in terms of liberating people to think rationally and try understanding religion themselves, hes done a lot of work.
There is fear of revolution among us Pakistanis. Being a citizen of Gilgit-Baltistan and not Pakistan when we talk for our rights and to change the system, people of our own communities make us fear that a tag of Anti-state will be put on you, because this has happened in the past with our leader from Gilgit-Baltistan. If Pakistan wants to thrive it’s very important to let youth choose for themselves, And for the sake of Allah stop putting anti state tags on people who talk about change.
Indeed, everytime I've tried to talk about the need of changing the system in college, a lot of other kids have totally ignored my point and forced me to keep quiet with one ignorant and hopeless claim:
"The system doesn't change, you just have to do things according to it."
right
Don't talk about separatism. Talk about your problems. There are alot of problems in Pakistan we need to fix, if there's a problem in Pakistan, it doesn't mean that you break Pakistan.
Zakir, I hold the same views. Respect for GB from Lahore.
Separatism is not revolution, we will fight till death against separatists
I was studying but this seemed more important
@@nadiashireensiddiqi thx
If there is no leeway for clergy in islam how come the mullahs are so powerful all over the islamic world ?
🙏🙏
Bro i am pakistani but i also see indian channel like these .
Study iq
Dhruv ratee
Soch by mayank ..
Knowledge has no boundary❤
@@victorysonhidden Islam is not complicated but some people defined and explained it according to their evil and ill will.
So you can see them in the form of islmaic terrorists and some extremist clerics .
It's an utter shame for the subcontinent that we haven't learned anything from history and now common people are being oppressed by the establishment and Ministers.
In Kerala it's Exactly the Opposite.
Here we Over-Protest for every Small Small Issues for No Reason.
I don’t think patriarchs have any right to play victim
@Rohit Kumar lol religion is still a big issue in india .I think you guys haven't Learnt .BJP won election because they support hindu rashtra (or whatever that sh!t is )Same way PTI won by chooran of Riyasat e Madina .Both countries in general are sh!tholes
@Rohit Kumar i dont have that much knowledge of indian politics . Dhruv rathee thinks otherwise
Absolutely right it’s shameful we haven’t learnt anything from our western masters
People like you are the only hope left for this country. I am glad that I am following gems like you.
I agree with you totally , very few debates I watch from Pakistan but this person speaks from the heart ❤️ long live Pakistan and India
oray march main jisam bech ja k
u r very ignorant,read the international news,dont jsut listen to him,he is taking advantge of the weaker points,looka t the bigger picture.
I haven't any fear. But the problem is i've just finished my 2nd year. I hadn't any idea before. But now i'm putting my best in reading and understanding the history. You are also playing an important role in my point of view. I hold with you.
Please do study contemporaries schools of thought in islam as well which fundamentalists dont like particularly. ♥️
Same here bro
The Mullaism issue is same in India. I have heard them on TV saying that music is haram, acting , yoga is haram and many regressive things, giving unneccesary fatwas . I don't know when will muslim community comes out of shackles of this. History in india is hijacked by communist/ marxist historians who glorify butcherers that is why there is constant conflict. Pakistan has additional problem of being governed by military, unless civilian govt takes over completely there is almost no hope for change
Jo haram h so h tme kyun problem h
@@moeen8283 Share me a Quranic verse that says music is haram.
@@moeen8283 get out this regressive ideology. To have a religious life is important but not religion as they say it
@Name Can't Be Blank see ua-cam.com/video/U8z1ZDFTJhM/v-deo.html
@@moeen8283 to haram khene valey tum kon hotey ho logo ko shi galat sochne do tum haram ko jo haram boltey ho useky peeche religious thought h jese yoga yoga insan ki bhatari key liye hota h na ki haram.
Absolutely amazing. ❤
I hope No black Vigo finds you ever to update your software like they have done to many.
Massive respect.
From Balochistan.
good video I hope young generation see this as a motivation and this ignites a passion of revolution in their hearts
You are such a knowledgeable person with logical reasoning.
I don’t think it’s logical to glorify violent revolutions and ignore the fact that China is a dictatorship, that France is also in trouble; that hijabs are being banned in greater Europe. That wherever and whenever women are oppressed, silenced etc there is no genuine freedom and currently nowhere in the world are women free, safe and truly emancipated
@@nadiashireensiddiqi france's a hypocrite towards muslim women in the name of secularism.
But still women have far better living standards in other western and east asian countries compared to Pak, Afg, India and Iran and so on.
@Jamal K exactly..
Very fruitful analysing
Allah bless you son thought provoking discussion.
Totally agree with, it's time that we should take a stand & raise our voices against injustices in this country
Ye kis city me rhte he
that's true that if someone wants to share ur videos they will think 100 times b4 sharing it
Shat shat Naman aur Pranam.! Assalamualaikum
🙏🙏🙏🙏 Great 🙏🙏🙏
Very true, After Osho Rajnish, if I have connected with someone, then it is intellectual.
He is very right. Majority of Pak youth is apolitical
Actually its the opposite. Our is youth is so politicized it has corrupted them. During my time as a student in 2010s, boys often skipped classes to attend MQM rallies. Today we see kids as young as 7 raising religio-politico flags, hurling abuses at each other and disturbing the peace at every neighborhood.
How did we create such a situation? Our youth were deprived of proper upbringing, mannerisms had their innocence stolen. Zara sochiye?
@@azeeminator literally youth dont know about politics in Pakistan .They just support parties based on race .Urdu speaking support MQM and Sindhis support PPP .
They are just Islamic radical
Bht kch sochnay pay majboor kr deti hen apki videos.. Outstanding.. Yiu are one of the intellectual persons in Pakistan.
The courage you have is the courage of Martin Luther, the audacity is exceptional. You are standing with the truth. Truth is still the truth, even if no one believes it and a lie is still a lie even if everyone believes it. I can't believe a revolutionary like you who dare to think differ and then expressed it boldly without any fear, resides in this rotten unsecured society of Pakistan.
More strength more power to you Sir. ❤
❤️
@@syedmuzammilofficial7067 I have a recommendation to make which is important. Please bring alternate new voices like CHACHA ABDUL SHAKOOR who will tell your members of the channel the ultimate truth about PAKISTAN. He has the channel called Chacha The Commando. He will add the gloss to your channel.Plus nine seven one is the code. Five four three three two four three zero two. You can WHATSAPP him directly
@@syedmuzammilofficial7067 I have something 4 u! I have a recommendation to make which is important. Please bring alternate new voices like CHACHA ABDUL SHAKOOR who will tell your members of the channel the ultimate truth about PAKISTAN. He has the channel called Chacha The Commando. He will add the gloss to your channel.Plus nine seven one is the code. Five four three three two four three zero two. You can WHATSAPP him directly
بہت عمدہ اور متعلقہ تاریخی دلائل کے ساتھ گفتگو کی آپ نے
Well done, And more power to you. You are doing a very great job.
Keep it up.
Revolutionary spirit is high in Pakistan's youth but because they aren't in any position of power even in their own home,they are unable to change the policy....
This is called frustration not revolution . They know there is something wrong happening they can sense it but they don't what is solution , the goal , the ideology .. they are just frustrated oppressed youths
@@wojak5308 you need a catalyst for a revolution e.g sino Russo war and world war 2 were the catalyst for the Russian Revolution ... Pakistan hasn't had such a catalyst event at large scale...
Mai apke views se hundred percent muttafiq hun 🙏. From Pakistan.
I am very optimistic sir, indeed, it will happen one day!
Bitter truth.
حقیقت میں میں بھی یہی چاہتا ہوں کہ پاکستان کی عوام ا اٹھے اپنے حق کو پہچانے اور یہ کیسے ممکن ہے
Your word cause goosebumps
Curiously waiting for your vedio. God bless you brother. You are a great thinker and logical person.
India is deeply democratic but we are an emotional and poor country. There is a financial, social, and educational system in both India and Pakistan that crushes the soul of its majority population and makes them succumb to the power of the state. I have great empathy for these people because each and every day this system tries to kill the basic desire to live yet these people survive this. This mere act of living is something courageous in these countries if you are socially, financially, or educationally challenged. The worst part is that these people are made known to their own courage by the state.
We need more people like him in Pakistan
Be one
@@bushraejaz9409 trying but can't match his level
@@Kamranali046 yeah man same here . But something is better than nothing
@@bushraejaz9409 yup, let's hope for the best
@@Kamranali046 send him to india, we need him here.
Revolution is there and will remain in India....
1. We revolted against the old government on the issue of corruption...
2. People revolted against a controversial farm bill which was abolished after the revolt
Bhai if it is called true revolution to itni bahut to pakistan mein bhi aa jati hain
Syed Muzammil for Prime minister ✊
President is nominal head .. he holds no power in parliamentary democracy
Chief of Army Staff*
@Islamabadi Atheist abhe chief of army staff ke pass real power ha .chief of staff bnn jaye
thank god you don't make him your papa.
Changed it :)
Ohh Man you changed my whole perception about our society. Thanks a lot
This is hands down one of your best videos. Loads of respect.
Indian public ki soch pr media ne parda dal rakha h
mere bhai, pakistan mein media kaun sa behtar hai? yeh jo india pakistan ka issue hai, media hi tau is agg pe tale dalta hai
1947 se 2014 tak parda dala hua tha, abb jaake false parda hata hai..
Asli history india ki ab aa rahi hai, jai hind
Love to watch your programs..
Your videos are really thought provoking, it gives different perspectives every time I see your video, which otherwise wouldn't have crossed my mind. And things you discuss are true for India also...keep going man!
Much respect for you from India.
Wow, you have really opened up my thoughts on a lot of topics, for that I thank you. Please never stop making these videos.
I'm usually called 'A Negative Person' because I question.
I'd lost hope in this society a long time ago. I'd to fight with people and to come at their stage to explain my point, but everything in vain in the end. Their minds are set at one point.
I was shocked to see the status of the top management of the organization in favor of Taliban. And then I uploaded my status against Taliban and the very same people replied me and called me 'Fasadi Liberal.'
Sad state of affairs but it is what it is.
Ah, different country same type of people ( more or less) if I say something against the government ( even if it's clear that government did something wrong) I'll be called "librandu"
Like, no buddy I speak negative about the government when they have done something wrong and I also speak positively for the government when they do something right.. But this would go unnoticed.
@@SubsDoWonder One of the quality of a prophet (Daud A.S.) was his singing. How can Allah ban singing while a major quality of his Prophet is the very same singing?
I'm laboural and secular but I am supporting Taliban, it's my political view and no one have the courage to ask me why as I never ask from any one who is not supporting them, every one is free in his choices,
@@comradehasnainkhan1247 by this logic France people have right to make cartoon of Prophet Monammad...
Or it is because you following religion of convinience..
I am from India..and i can safely say.. without bias that our democracy is working smoothly
Yes.. politicians are hopeless but well..what else they can be
But the pressure of civil society and people is very real..as it was evident from farm law protest.
Youth here..is vibrant
They are getting liberal mindset and very few get hyped up in the name of religion. Many people think Modi was elected because of religion but our youth elected him for his development policies in his home state Gujrat. Society is not radicalised.. sometimes there are voices of hatred from various sections of society but well.. it's a huge country..so not everyone is perfect here
But by large..a peaceful and modernised culture is developing. People only think about growing and making best of their life. And this opinion is completely unbiased.
Average Pakistanis have become too much pessimistic because of poor economy,huge debt and poor education standard. Average Indians have become optimistic precisely because of the opposite reasons. Growing economy, huge foreign reserve,high education standard, improving health sector, huge foreign direct investment resulting higher employment scopes, new innovations , booming IT sector, world standard space research , improving agricultural sector thus producing surplus yields, improving industrial sector including revolution in auto sector , breakthrough in commercial hydrogen production, booming telecom sector, improving connectivity with world standard freight corridors, enhanced defence production and started to export so many instances,we have reasons to be optimistic. We are keeping it in our mind that we are not competing with Pakistan but China. China's downturn has been started simply because it is almost impossible to maintain double digit growth decades after decades. So their economy is inching towards Japanese economy where there is stagflation . Huge debt and unnecessary construction boom is the reason for downturn in Chinese economy. Bad relation with few other super power and neighbours will accelerate their downturn faster than imagined. Under such conditions, Indian youths will never indulge any sorts of revolution in this crucial juncture when everything is going on smoothly.
@@partha9752 👍
Well explained 👏
Very true 👍
😂😂😂
I am proud of you muzammil bhai.Prayers for your safety!!!
Student politics Pakistan m aana chahia, aise to nayi soch aaygi hi nae
You are doing well .
Muzzamil bhai chaaa jatay ho aap. It's a miracle in itself tht a person like u is born in this rotten society...wht clear minded, logical, educated and forward looking person you are.....Love you !
Syed Sahab is a diamond. We love him as a critical thinker.
Behtreen....!
Highly appreciated I remember that day when I contradict with father on the base of mullahism my father gave me shut up call and after that I can't express my critical point front of someone's 😑 our teachers and parents just make us slave
What a amazing video great muzzamil bhai really touch our sense great more power to you ♥️👏🙌
well done, you are amazing
Awesome points .... Bru . 🔊🔊
Salute hats off to you
Your 💯 right We're subjected to a subtle process of subjugation from a young age this starts at home and continues throughout school, even into college. When we are raised and indoctrinated within these microcosms of society , how can we expect to emerge as empowered individuals capable of defending our rights in the wider world
We become accustomed to unfair situations because they become the norm . So when we step out into the wider world and see them everywhere, it just feels normal ,that's what we've been conditioned to accept.
Just discovered your channel and love your message. Inspiring to see people like you waking up the potential in our Youth. God bless you 🙏
I can go on listening to your talk, so much to learn, thanks for the video,,,keep going
Usually I wait for videos of your channel... More power to you bro Syed Muzammil ❤️
Sir you changed me my thinking level. Thank you so much sir 💓
I respect your intellect.
Once I talked about social issues at my University's platform, all the university's staff, teachers and students started criticizing me and they even called my parents that I am going political, etc.
But that wasn't that I was going political, I was the one in whole university to make a voice against prevailing social evils but for the people I was doing they themselves rejected me and stopped me from doing anything and everyone started bullying me. At the end, I preferred to move and let the things unresolved.
This nation doesn't want to change it's condition!
And God doesn't help those who don't help themselves.
Same happend to me in one family function I speak about Our CM ( Who is total Dustbin) and issues in maharashtra in india all my relatives scolded me and says Badi aayi Jhaasi ki Raani 🙃
Hmri awaz ko bi daba dete hai toh kaise aa skta hai Inquilab wali soch 🥺
Seb say ihem baat ya hay kay ap aik women ho
System kay khilaf to mai bhi uni mai bolta hoon lakin kisi ki juret nahi mujay gelet bol sekay logic kay sath conversation skills bhi matter kertay ap kis trah baat ko byan kertay hain jis trah muzamil bhai ka ap ka damag kitni taizi say respond kerta hai aglay banday kay question per
Audience ka dmag perhna bhi bht zarori hota kay wo kis trah soch rahay hain aur un kay zahen mai kya sawal a rahay hain agr ap in swalon kay jwab un kay pochay bgair dain gay to is ka bht strong impact perray ga aur logon ka mental break down ho ga aur wo ap say swal tek kernay say derain gay
@@doggee09 agr discradit kernay ki koshish kerray to back foot pay janay ki bjay counter attack kiya kero kay ap logon nay ya ap logon kay baron hud kon say teer marray hain aur apni baat ko bar bar repeat ker kay us per zor diya kero agr koi baat ko gumani ki koshish kerray to point out kiya kero kay mairi baat ka jwab nahi diya tum nay
Highly appreciate your point of view, most importantly on positive image building part :D
👍👍👍
But we needs more peaceful and rational minds like you. Fabulous job.
GREAT PRESONLATIY IN MY LIFE
The greatest gift someone can give to this nation is critical thinking and you are such a gem ❤️
Extreme love and respect for your work ❤️❤️
Keep it up please 👍
May,God keep you, under his deep consideration & blessings,
+respect
I applaud your courage Muzammil sahib.
I HOPE ONE YOU WILL LEAD PAKISTAN ONE DAY SOON!!! LOTS OF ADMIRATION AND RESPECT FROM CANADA!!!
Really amazing.
Pakistan ma inqalabi soch rakhna ghunha Hai jo inqalabi soch rakhega wo Utha leya jai ga
One of the sane voice in Pakistan for sure.
#longliverevolution #longlivestruggle #longliveresistance
While I am watching this video my father has been praising neighbours' son for he has got a job after masters and his elder brother being an engineer in a foreign country about to married in november
I am an engineer in foreign country. Nothing glamorous about this life trust me.
@@xyzmediaandentertainment8313 i m ready t marry you. then life will be glamorous!
@@kumarincome2226 lol
He is right , getting employable is more difficult than spouting revolutionary slogans on Papa's money
@amit exact situation
No doubt that you are a brave soldier and InshaAllah we'll be there on the front line soon
InshaAllah
Agreed. Well researched. Background has some marvellous personalities
Thanks again for this awareness. You are always guidance for me to overcome my fear and speak the truth.❤😊😊😊
Good v good
Great
Wow! Amazing journalism.
Good content
Absolutely true! We have become sheep
soon their will be a revelation in Pakistan InshAllah
More power to you sir. 💪 You are just incredible 😍
آپ ہماری غیرت کو جگانے کی چاہے جتنی کوشش کریں لیکن کامیاب نہیں ہوسکیں گے۔ لیکن آپ کو داد و تحسین اور دعا دیے بغیر یارانہ نہیں۔ 👍
کامیابی کیلئے انسان کی سوچ سب سے پہلی چیز ہے۔
آپ کے اندر وہ سوچ ہے ہی نہیں تو کامیاب کیسے ہوگی۔۔؟
مجھے یقین ہے کہ انشاء اللہ پاکستان میں عوامی انقلاب آئے گا۔۔۔!
Well said buddy
@Nisha chambiyal no its not like that every one here in pakistan is not like that I'm a pakistani by nationality but an indian by race and I'm proud of my ethnicity because most of arabs see pakistanies ,bangladeshie and indian muslims as second class muslims .
@Nisha chambiyal not really. I admit, there’s a lot of Turk/Arab complex, but not so much. I’m a Baloch Pakistani by nationality and racially an Iranian, so?!?
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
I am a big fan of yours Muzammil Bhai. Are you sitting in Pakistan or somewhere aborad?
I totally agree with you, but there's a whole lot of youth on Twitter who are standing and opposing the situation occuring in our country but still that isn't enough cause half of the youth keeps on trending #indiaisnotsafe and blames the ones standing up for "defaming" Pakistan.
M ur Greatest fan.Your every words are priceless ❤️
Indian youth also lack revolutionary zeal.Busy with their superfluous lives and media gadgets
Great video Muzammil. Please next video on cultural industry.
Britishers looted us ( India).
But, I am thankful to them because they wiped out Mughals from India, our freedom fighters wiped out these goras( though, these freedom fighters also got renaissance from those schools set up by Britishers), and we got India..a place where we dream and we are working to achieve that dream..slow, but yes working.
Partition saved India.
Great sir❤
Well
You forgot to mention Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza
جس نے اس مذہبی مافیا کے خلاف آواز اٹھائی ہے۔
Your courage of resistance is highly appreciable ❤️
Please make a video some day, on some good books you refer in most of your videos Muzammil.
Hi Muzammil, again it was an amazing video, people must listen what u r saying. I would like to add 2 cents in your view. Democracy is a complete ecosystem and this ecosystem runs in healthy way when we have strong opposition, strong and independent courts, strong vocal unbiased media, and 4th voters who r aware. As u asked about India, we don’t have strong opposition some media houses are biased not all, but still courts r independent and strong. Public i say it depends but majority is aware of what government is doing. Next election results will tell how much public is aware. Also intellectuals also keeps the check and balance on government if they r doing anything wrong which not good or not good for interest of nation and public they r vocal. So India is not in that bad position, some cases r there but we should also know we r just 75 year old democracy and still country is building up and changes in society will come for sure. As per my age and experience i saw tremendous change in system and society, so i m hopeful lot more about to come and 1 day will be in line with developed countries. Thanks once again it worth listening your views.
Great sir👍
indian and pakistani on one platform, and ziadatar rationalist viewers hain aur agree hain muzammil ki soch se, progressive society ban'nane ki tarf yeh ek chhota sa kadam hai, subcontinent ko aise kayi kadmon ki zaroorat hai.
Agree
U from u city
Kuch nhai bus india se view Aur subscribtion Lena chahta hai
Chutiya bana rha hai
Sahi bhai
Too good