Hey all, thanks for all the support on this video! It's been incredible. Real quick, two corrections I want to make that I got wrong in this one: 1. Nea should have been paired with Nurse since they are in the same DLC. Oops 😅😅messed that one up! Honestly not sure how I did that 😅😅 2. I said Onryo's chapter was based on the book, it was actually based on the original Ringu movie, I got that flipped in my head and misspoke.
The version of Onryo in game is from the book. It was hinted at in the King and Paulie Esther video when Matt Cote mentioned twice that "book properties were eligible to be licensed chapters." You were correct to begin with. As a Nea main who regularly catches the Nurse's attention, nodders, hits on hook, and moris, I'm glad you acknowledged they are supposed to be paired.
The entity makes it so the thought of fighting back never even crosses the survivors mind otherwise you would get people like boulder punching Chris Ash and ofc Bill and many others wreaking havoc
Unironically, Yun-Jin would absolutely escape Trickster. She's knows how to take care of herself and make sure she survives, and she's definitely much smarter than Trickster is, as he only gets away with murder because of his status, and Yun-Jin had him more or less figured out despite it Trickster has only ever killed people he's taken by surprise and haven't been able to fight back, in a scenario where his potential victim is aware of him and can fight back I genuinely think he would struggle to actually kill them
That's a good point that Trickster has always had the element of surprise. He was about to get Yun-Jin, but she was also paralyzed at the time because he had taken them by surprise, a mistake she likely would not repeat.
I wouldn’t say she’s smarter than Trickster. They are intellectual equals. Trickster has fooled Yun-Jin plenty of times, most notably in his tome. He knows Yun-Jin just as well as Yun-Jin knows Trickster.
Doubt. She clearly had no idea who she was dealing with. He outsmarted her in the tome, he trapped and nearly killed her in lore. If he knew that she knew, he would hold no stops. During all the presented lore I'd say he went easy on her
Okay as much as I love Pinhead, remember the weakness to Cenobites is Magic. Mikaela is a witch. She has been known to do magic before she was taken and her perks are all witch based. So she would have the best chance out of all the survivors, minus maybe Vittorio, to survive the Pinhead.
Sort of true, but Nemesis also takes out anything standing in his way, which lets be fair, Leon would fight to help Jill too. (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
That's a good point, perhaps I'll run that one just for fun soon. I kept it just to the actual Survivors themselves and didn't include Legendary skins, but it would be interesting to see how the community reacts.
This is RE1 Chris by lore even if the model is RE5 Chris with stars outfit. This Chris didn't take steroids and become infertile inorder to defeat Wesker
Wellll Wesker kinda has the power of 8 nemesis’s combined Wesker could have killed chris,Sheva,Jill,and josh within 10 seconds litteraly Chris won because wesker was messing with him He has the ability to move extremely fast, dodge bullets at will and also has super human strength and agility. But in an all out battle with no restrictions, Albert Wesker couldn't take on two opponents or let alone 4 skilled agents in a wide battle ground like at the end of RE5. As you saw from the battle, they managed to pin him down and poison him. Chris and Jill didn't stand a chance in the Spencer Estate because of the small space to battle and it didn't take him much to charge dash at them and dodging incoming bullets at the same time and totally destroy and almost killing Chris Redfield. His weakness is the dark aswell, (his sunglasses don't help the cause). You could shoot him in the back in the dark because he can't see you but if the spotlights were still on, SOMEHOW he can dodge bullets without seeing them. Perhaps its a gameplay mechanics or perhaps it isn't either way, it was that technique that got Albert Wesker to go into serious mode
@@Aquaviousyuri you fail to mention one thing!! Just like ash and Laurie. The characters have thick plot armour. It would be interesting having a resident evil game where you play as the villains to infect and destroy the world
@@Aquaviousyuri but seriously I get what you mean. In raw strength he would win. In speed he wins In the end their Witt is their downfall and Chris and sheva had to think of a different way of winning.
Given that cheryl is essentially a survivor with killer perks (gen block, obsession and hex perk), thats like fighting fire with fire! She defs stands a chance!
Few ramblings on several pairs x) 3:50 I believe in-game lore states that Quen was taken quite some time after the events of remake movie (when Nancy's mom is dead and Nancy isn't around for whatever reason). So by that point he's beaten Freddy in the "dream game" a lot of times already. And with DbD's Freddy being much weaker power-wise than his movie-self - it feels like Quentin has a huge chance of winning. Especially if requirement is to escape Freddy, rather than kill him. 4:19 Amanda and Tapp don't really interact in movies at all, but both have 1v1 fights (albeit with different characters). Tapp loses his fight because of opponent's hax (twice actually), while Amanda comes out victorious (even though barely and her opponent had broken leg). Based on this, I'd give an edge to Mandy - she is more agile, quite resilient and willing to fight dirty. Besides, she has a blade and Tapp has only his hands. 13:59 This is a tricky one, because survivor-Haddie we get to play as is not the same character as tome-Haddie. Haddie from Archives would absolutely obliterate Dredge into oblivion, as she does with many creatures in Tomes. Survivor-Haddie isn't quite there in terms of experience, but if her adventures were broadly the same as tome-Haddie's prior to Alps - I'd say she still has an upper hand in at least escaping Dredge, if not full-on defeating him. 14:05 I actually feel like if the goal for survivor is to escape and killer - to kill, then Ada might win this one, given Ada's huge experience in yeeting herself out of tough situations and her overall knowledge of how Wesker might think (their business partnership lasts many years after all, as iirc DbD's Ada is taken during RE4). In actual fight, though, Wong will stand zero chance against Wesker, especially w/o her devices - it took a whole active volcano and two RLs to get this guy after all lol. As for Rebecca - I feel like she'll get killed either way unless Wesker decides to make her his pet - but even then she won't necessarily escape. Especially if we take her RE0-self, when she doesn't have lots of battle experience. Granted, she knows how to handle a gun, but there aren't any guns in Entity's Realm, and even if there were - Wesker literally can dodge any projectiles easily.
Ahh thank you for that info on Quentin. I have not seen the movie so I was assuming that part of his lore overlapped with the movie itself. That makes sense. Thanks for correcting me. I rely on those of you who have seen the Saw films to fill in my gaps. Most of you seem to agree that Amanda would win. The Haddie one is tricky I agree, I honestly can't remember what I said (I know, it's been a bit and I'm behind on comments 😅). One tidbit I did pick up on researching for Haddie's lore video is that the Observer notes that the tome version of Haddie that fights the supernatural creatures is a version of Haddie that is legend, not historical. So that version probably never actually existed. But then there's the other tome version of Haddie who is older and fights against the Black Vale that very likely did exist in another universe. But the more I've learned about all versions of Haddie, I agree with you that she would stand a good chance of escaping it. I think you've described Wesker v Ada / Wesker v Rebecca very well. Again, can't remember what I said in the video, but after reflection I'd agree 100%. Ada escapes, Rebecca doesn't (aside from plot armor of course), but Ada could also not defeat Wesker one-on-one. Sorry it took so long to respond. I really appreciate you sharing your thoughts!
Technically speaking, Pyramid Head serves as a physical representation of the powers of Silent Hill enacting its punishment on James, so while Pyramid Head proper would never run into Cheryl, "Cheryl vs Pyramid Head" can also arguably be interpreted as "Cheryl vs Silent Hill in general" (which Cheryl still wins, because, well, SH3)
For legion vs Jeff, there are only 2 scenarios and no, the legion(2 of them at least) won't hesitate killing Jeff even if they were acquainted at one point. So that leaves us with 2 scenarios a 1v1 and a 4v1. If it were a 1v1, Jeff would win based on his build againts individual members of the legion. Sadly if it were a 4v1 yeah, my guy is ded af.
I agree, 100%. 1v1 Jeff is more experienced and he's a capable fighter in his past. 1v4 though, Legion wins by sheer numbers. And since I thought of this more in terms of lore than gameplay, I'd assume it'd be 1v4. (Once again, sorry this reply took so long😅)
One thing that should be noted is the different layouts of the entitys realm. Depending on where the 1v1 happens, there could be more or less hiding spots for the survivors. Anyway this was another entertaining video even for a non DBD player. Love to see what other lore videos you are going to do next.
LOL yup Ghost Face would be no trouble for Ash, and that's how I feel about Steve v Demo too, assuming there is meant to be a difference between S1 and S4 Demo's
i'm a big quentin enjoyer and i'm extremely excited about him winning in the poll against freddy. i have some thoughts about it, so: quentin has dealt with freddy already alongside nancy. something a lot of people dislike about the remake is that nancy does very little, unlike her much more capable counterpart in the original. instead, quentin always takes action to help her and himself - he shares his medication with her even though that means he'll run out faster (and iirc he ends up under a lot of scrutiny from the pharmacy for running out so quickly), he steals adrenaline from the hospital, and he's constantly doing research in order to figure out what they're up against. when freddy returns in dbd lore, quentin immediately reverts back to that survival mode, staying awake for as long as humanly possible to prepare to fight freddy once again. he's an incredibly capable and active person and with his experience (and personal motivations) against freddy, i know he's definitely winning, even without plot armour (and even without my extreme bias)
I haven't seen the movie myself so this explanation helps a lot! Thank you. I'm with you that Quentin would definitely survive (I can't remember what I said in the video honestly 😅but since posting I've become more sure of that).
The more I've reflected the more I believe she'd definitely escape. (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Yoichi does also have psychic powers and we know that his father is in the realm with him in ghost form because the end of his lore and his perk it's hinted at strongly and because both have super natural abilities I think this round would be a interesting pair up
The fact Ash vs Ghostface was as close as it is shows how little the DBD community knows about Evil Dead and that's a criminal injustice. Ash wouldn't even break a sweat tossing that skinny little nerd on his neck, even with no weapons and just his mechanical hand
I think Quentin has beat Freddy in DBD lore. The first line of Quentin's lore is 'When he heard that Nancy's mother had disappeared, Quentin Smith knew instantly that their success had been short-lived'. Nancy's mum being killed is the last scene of the movie, so that makes me think that the lore starts after the movie ends. You seem to know your stuff though, so maybe I'm wrong
No, I think you are 100% correct. I haven't seen the movie, so I inferred based on how some of the other licensed lore is written that it overlapped with the movie events. Someone else corrected me too and pointed out his lore picks up afterward. So thank you! (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Indeed it would, I agree! What do you think would be the results? (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
between nancy and steve, nancy would obviously be way harder for demo than steve would, nancy is smarter (she planned a whole set-up trap for demo on season one when she was like, 16yo), she's also more resourceful than steve, since she knows how to shoot. so yeah, nancy would def carry steve if they had to escape demogorgon together edit1: actually, I belive she was 15yo in season 1, since she (as jonathan confirms in season 4) was going to college (which would make her be 18yo in season 4), this makes her be even more impressive by how smart and skilled she was in season 1
and steve almost died to a demo-dog in season 2, which is like, demogorgon but nerfed, meanwhile nancy alone almost killed demogorgon in season 1. she's way more likely to survive than steve
I always feel like Nancy gets underestimated by a lot of people in favor of Steve, so I appreciate you pointing out how intelligent and resilient she is. I think they both stand a descent chance of escaping.
I agree that The Quentin would have absolutely gotten the sacrifice when considering the movies, although Freddy could have escaped had he been able to spawn in more dream pallets to confuse The Quentin during the trials.
the funniest part about ash is his plot armor is CANON, like written in the necronomicon, i mean they basically just state “yeah man main character has plot armor deal with it”
Jeff would possibly be able to hold his own against the legion for a short period of time, just by his stature and build he could throw some haymakers but ultimately would be stabbed a whole fuck ton.
Micaela definitely escapes Pinhead! She’s a witch, that fought entity with a success, she’s clairvoyant, and could cast a spell or do other witchcraft where’s pinhead follows rules, and he isn’t as versatile as her.
What rules does Pinhead follow? In a lot of ways, he breaks the rules of the Entity's realm (so does Mikaela) (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Depending on the timeline Wesker would let Ada go because they have been long time partners, she got the G-Virus sample for him and Wesker helped her escape Raccoon
We're talking RE4 Ada and RE5 Wesker. It's been a long, long time since I've played RE4 and RE5 is one of the few I haven't played, so I'm not sure how that affects things. What are your thoughts?
I think Pig, Clown, and Twins all win and Vittorio has a real good chance of winning especially if Knight doesn't get his guards but even then we see in the cinematic that it's not until he's surrounded that he runs instead of holding his ground.
What makes you think that about Pig, Clown, and Twins? And great point about Vittorio, even though he's a pacifist, not everyone realizes that he's actually a very skilled fighter. He was able to hold off someone attacking him with only defensive blocks until the dude tripped and fell on his own sword. That said, I always interpreted his standing his ground in the trailer as him trying to assess the situation, and once he realized he was surrounded he knew he had to run.
Nancy is literally a bad ass, more so than Steve. I love him but she would win. I also do feel that Meg would win against Wraith. She's one of if not the most athletic survivor, no? All of her perks are good for chases, looping and surviving in general.
I agree with you on Nancy and Steve. I don't buy that Steve could survive Demo but Nancy couldn't. I see what you are saying about Meg, and I would agree that she stands a better chance than most because of her athleticism. That said, I feel like Wraith is the one she'd struggle with most because his perks/abilities directly compete/counter hers. She's fast, he's faster, she's sneaky, he is too. That's why I went Wraith personally, but at the same time recognize that Meg is probably one of the stronger Survivors overall.
Honestly for Cheryl vs Pyramid Head another thing to keep in mind is that he is a force of punishment. He goes after someone who feels an intense guilt that makes them feel they need to be punished. Thus I would argue that unless Cheryl feels a need to be punished, that Pyramid Head wouldn't even be able to harm her
For OG Silent Hill 2 Pyramid Head I 100% agree with you on that. That said, the way I read his DBD lore is that the Entity has given him new purpose so that he isn't tied to the feelings of guilt in the realm the way he was to James. That's how I interpret it, not saying that's 100% the correct interpretation.
With Vittorio and the knight, I had voted for the knight at the time. You can also see it quite well in the trailer, that he decides with short hesitation then but for the escape. However, I noticed that again afterwards. I think now would be a meeting once again more interesting between all 5en. The companions of the knight are obviously undead / ghosts. Vittorio, on the other hand, has survived in this world for more than 600 years (well, so have the knight and his people, but they're probably not quite as threatened as Vittorio) and during that time he got the tattoos that... are obviously very powerful. I am curious if this question will be taken up again in the Riftlore by the two.
Vittorio definitely has a lot of experience surviving in the Entity's realm and I definitely would love to know more about those cryptic glowing tattoos. He probably does have an edge with those things considered. I'm excited to keep getting more Knight and Vittorio lore!
Thanks for the feedback, I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it! There is background music in there, but I must have made it too quiet. I'm always tweaking it in every video because it's been too loud before.
Wesker has insane superhuman speed. Remember RE5? He’s easily able to dodge bullets. And that isn’t just reaction speed as we actually see him moving around from place to place at that speed. That’s hundreds of miles per hour. I have no idea how Ada would be able to evade him for even 2 seconds before being obliterated.
@ARoberts pretty sure Capcom during one of their streams said it. I also heard the sane thing from a few of my friends, too. On top of that, Wesker, having a thing for Rebecca was never proven true, at least not that I know of. Their are still loads of theories as to why the picture was their tho. My best evidence is because Wesker manipulated Barry to do his bitting and threatened his family if he didn't do what he said. Barry strongly hats Wesker, just like Chris. So Barry plants the photo in his desk to make it look bad on his part. At the time of that picture, I'm pretty sure Rebecca was under 18 still in school. KEY WORDS (I'm Pretty Sure), not 100%, just like all the other theories. But from what I've heard, that seems to be the best one and makes Wesker seem like less of a pedophile.
@ARoberts Yeah, sorry for the long message. But that's the best to my advantage as to what I can explain. But still, take it with a grain of salt. im still not 100% sure, but it seems the most logical. And what I've heard most about.
People fr always be sleeping on Ghostface. Yes he may just be a dude with a knife but he's a professional knife killer literally can stab you 40 times before you blink
For Onyro vs Yoichi I agree I think Onyro would win I didn't know the chapter was based off the books instead of the movies. A lot of people say its based off the movies so unsure what to believe there. But the whole dbd lore is that Yoichi goes to learn about his heritage and stuff and when he reaches the cabins where the well is we gets sweaped away from the fog as well as Onyro. Because of this im not sure we have the knowledge of the tapes that his parents did since when that happens he is a kid. So I think if my knowledge is correct could be wrong who know Onyro wins that 100%. (Also here is a fun fact! The reasons why Yoichi's parents weren't the survivor for that chapter is because the actors didn't consent to it so that is why Yoichi is instead. One of my friends told me since they are very into dbd stuff.)
I think I actually messed that detail up, I believe the chapter is based on the original Japanese movie. I haven't seen it nor read the books so I'm not 100% sure. I didn't know that about the reason for Yoichi being the Survivor, thanks for sharing that fact.
Ngl I always saw Jake with Wraith and Meg with hillbilly. To me at least the pairing made more sense as Jake was the rich to poor where as Wraith just wanted a decent life and might actually hold it against Jake for choosing a life as a homeless outdoors person as spoilt. For meg and Hillbilly I feel like their lore sort of matches up as Meg and Hillbilly both revolve around their families. One wants to actively save her mother where as one wants to actively kill their abusive parents.
I had actually not heard of there being pairings of the originals before I made this video, apparently there are defined pairings. I think Meg is with Hillbilly, but Trapper is with Jake. I could be wrong though. (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
@@theARoberts Yoichi is a child in the original movies, and he is very closely connected to Sadako because his relationship with his parents becomes a very clear mirror to Sadako's relationship with her parents. In the first film he only escapes Sadako because Reiko (his mother) saves him from the curse after learning how to survive it, and then again in the second movie he's saved by the spirit of his father who drains away his fear so he can escape Sadako for good. In terms of actual ability Sadako easily crushes anything Yoichi can do. Yoichi has some psychic abilities from his father, but Sadako inherited her mothers psychic abilities and her father is implied to be a sea demon. DBD Yoichi can't top that imo.
The thing with Steve and Nancy is more like, Nancy hasn’t taken the physical beatings Steve has. Steve’s got the endurance and the strength to hold his own for a decent amount of time. Even if it is the s4 Demo, s4 Steve is also much, much tougher than he was in s1. Steve has gone up against dozens of upside down monsters and has come out victorious every time. Nancy hasn’t ever faced any of the monsters by herself. Nancy also doesn’t have the athleticism Steve does
Based on your username I can certainly appreciate your line of argument here 😂 (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
LOL Don’t sweat it! I don’t mind if you don’t reply, and I’m actually shocked that you did. Tbh, I forgot about this comment 🤣 And yeah, I *might* love Steve a little too much 🤣🤣🤣
I think tapp wins because hes a trained cop and would probably have more experience taking down other people especially normal human beings. Amanda may be cunning but in the movies, it is stated that she needed help from Hoffman carrying people in traps and stuff which suggests shes not that physically strong
Fair points. Most Saw fans seem to side with Amanda, but I'm glad to have a counterpoint. Thank you! (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Tapp would win because his grill master skin implies he can cook pigs easily. In all seriousness, without spoiling too much, while Tapp never met Amanda as the Pig (in fact, he helped her in both of their interactions) Tapp survived an encounter with a weapon extremely similar to Amanda’s, and the only reason he was put in that situation was because he wanted to arrest the person who attacked him. In addition, he’s seems extremely proficient in hand-to-hand combat. Since arresting someone may be moot in the Realm, and given his obsession with getting the Jigsaw killer, I don’t think it’s hard to imagine Tapp straight up merking Amanda with his bare hands.
😂 That’s why I rely on people who have actually seen the movie, though to be honest, most who have commented lean Amanda, but I see all your points and they make sense. I wonder if Tapp would still try to be “good” in the Realm and might not fight her as hard as he technically could, and if that would make it more difficult for him?
@@theARoberts it’s really hard to say because the scenario of that kind surprisingly really isn’t elaborated on much by DBD devs. I would imagine he would have a better chance either way since Amanda isn’t as good at fighting as either of the people he fought. I highly recommend watching Saw 1 though, it’s free on Tubi!
I'm kind of on the fence about Leon/Nemi. I love Leon as well, but when Ex-Special Forces, S.T.A.R.S. Jill Valentine has to pull out the stops to fight Nemesis, then I have a hard time rooting for my man on potentially his first week as a cop. I also should say that I'm not very well read on RE lore tho. I do want to throw in the caveat that like I'm sure many of the people who voted yes, my first thought was "fuck yeah i love leon he wins"
I see you point totally. I base it mostly on the fact that Leon beat the mutated Birkin and Mr. X on his first day as a rookie, which both are a lot like Nemesis in terms of strength and lethality. One might argue Nemesis is more dangerous, but I wouldn't say by much, that's why my money is still on Leon... plus the plot armor is DEFNITELY on Leon's side😂 But I also think you are right, people saw Leon and straight up voted for him regardless of the question😂
I agree that Leon wouldn’t have escaped the Nemesis however I also think Jill wouldn’t have escaped considered Jill actually lost to the nemesis in the game, she got infected with the T-virus and if it were not for Carlos, she would have died.
@@theARoberts I’d say nemi is significantly stronger than birkin because he has all the same kind of mutations but also control and decent intelligence
Arguably, Jill and Leon would have serious problems if they didn't have access to heavy weaponry. Jill was actually pretty terrible at escaping Nemesis, he pursued her everywhere, she only stopped him by killing him (several times). If the entity isn't nice enough to provide her and Leon an arsenal of heavy weapons... well I don't really like her chances tbh.
I think Quentin wins against Freddy bc Quentin was going against Freddy at FULL power in the movie while still winning. The entity played with freddy and modified his powers, while Quentin was basically kept the same (except given the survivor rules of dbd) Bro destroys Freddy like 9 times out of 10 imo
One thing others do forget at times, is that Pinhead went into the realm THROUGH HIS OWN MEANS! He entered the realm by himself and pretty much said, "I'm home bitch!"
Another thing that you have to remember, this Wesker is STILL RE5 Wesker. As a veteran, Ada could slip away, but she would have to calculate well or die. Rebecca has no chance, Wesker would know how to take her out, I LOVE Rebecca, she's one of my favorite characters along with Wesker and Leon, but Wesker would kick her ass. She's a healer with a pistol, that's it...
Valid point. One of the reasons I’d say he’s in the top 3 most powerful. I agree with you 100% on Wesker, the more I think about it Ada would get out, but like you said she’d have to calculate well or she’d be done. Rebecca stands no chance, much as we love her.
@@theARoberts Yeah :\ cause even after everything, she is just a college teacher still, she's got training, but it still wouldn't be enough. As for Jake, I feel he's got like 85% chance tbh.
Not a chance Vittorio survives The Knight. Vittorio may have been trained, but that was years, potentially decades prior to his arrival in the fog, and he hasn't used a weapon since he swore them off. Meanwhile, the Knight is known to be a hulking brute, and handily beat several warriors at once by himself when he went to get the Lapis Paradisus out of the crypt and while leaving. Plus, he's infuriated by weakness and cowardice; just the sight of Vittorio would likely set him off. Vittorio's only chance is to use his rift-hopping to bail.
Knight would definitely see Vittorio's pacifism as weakness and cowardice, agreed, but Vittorio isn't weak or cowardly in reality. You make a good point about Vittorio being rusty with his combat skills, that's fair. But he doesn't have to defeat Tarhos, just escape him. However, Knight does have the numbers advantage.
So I'm going to pretend that this is why I didn't include Nea and that it had nothing at all to do with the fact that I had a brain fart and somehow didn't remember that Nea and Nurse were in the same DLC 😅
Also, it'd be kinda easy to get away from Wesker since he's more liable to taunt or play with them rather than go straight for the kill, and the survivors aren't trying to fight or beat the killer, just escape them.
Amanda killed 5-ish people for Jigsaw, Amanda survived: The Reverse Bear Trap, The Needle Pit, Being Attacked by Xavier, and being strapped to a chair pumped with poison (in the video game, which I’m 98% sure is canon) Amanda beats Tapp 11/10 times.
Sorry, but the entire time I was like, “Where’s the Lisa VS Pyramid Head poll? Don’t you wanna see what’ll happen? When an ODed hallucinating nurse fights the judge of hell?”
I literally just learned of the video game a few weeks ago, I didn't realize it was canon, thanks for sharing! While not having seen the movies myself, this makes me feel more confident in my pick 😄 And yeah, I felt I had to keep it to the base Survivors so no Lisa
@@theARoberts Hmm... Nea is sneaky, quiet and efficient, and as strong as Nurse could be i don't think she could win against Nea if she doesn't even find her in the first place, it's the same scenario as Jake vs Hillbilly, as long as they stay hidden, they can escape, but if they get spotted they don't stand a chance So yeah, it could go either way
@@catlovesdarkness6646 Not to mention even when found, she could still escape the Nurse, by running out of her vision and then hiding again, not to mention how she knows how to get rid of people chasing her. Not to mention how incredibly painful it is for the Nurse to teleport and the need to recover after teleportation. But if Nurse is able to injure Nea? Then Nea would not stand a chance, alone by the noise she would make and the Nurses given supernatural abilities.
@@theARoberts Honestly I feel like most people don't even know either of them are DLC. They just feel like base game characters at this point. I just remember the trailer for the DLC for some reason. Still a pretty good video regardless though!
I think it Nemesis would handedly win against Jill. Jill never was actually able to properly escape him in the first place he was always a looming threat. The only reason you were able to hold him off is because you had a lot of weapons and also the only reason you were able to kill him is because of the futuristic turbo gun.
That's a fair counterpoint for sure. I still think she could escape him (she doesn't need to kill him like in RE3, just escape the trial) but she'd be at a greater disadvantage without traditional weapons.
@@theARoberts In the games I would say Jill's skill is based off of the cutscenes. Cause if she was as strong as the player, she would just dodge. But in the cutscenes he's fast as hell. Always grabs her and she only gets saved by plot armor or outside forces. I'm steadfast that she'd be screwed.
That would be pre-Entity's realm and I'm not it was "constantly" based on the way I read it. She was even warned against doing it. Her post-realm hexes don't appear to have anything to do with luck, unless you're seeing something I'm not?
@@theARoberts from what i know she always used hexes because she didnt believe there would be no consequences even though her elder warned her against using hexes for minor things, bla bla bla, now shes in the entity realm where she can actually use them without consequences (it's been a long time since i read her lore so it might be different)
Thank you! Multiple people have said I got a few of them wrong but I had no idea where they are getting it from (other than Nurse v. Nea, that one was just a gigantic brain fart on my part 😅)
Only ones I disagree with are David vs Huntress, Nancy vs Demo, Ada vs Wesker, and Rebecca vs Wesker, I think those survivors would all make it. Especially Nancy, Ada and Rebecca. I was hoping legendary characters would be included in this cause I wanted to see how Claire, Chris, Carlos and Sheva would stand against Wesker/Nemmy.
I can't remember what I said in the video, but after much reflection I would agree that Nancy would escape Demo and Ada would escape Wesker. Rebecca I'm honestly on the fence about, I lean more towards Wesker, but she's also one of the RE characters I know the least about because I haven't played RE0 yet. I'd be tempted to agree with you on David v Huntress until I read her lore. I just don't see him escaping her, she's a monster. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I like getting other perspectives for sure. I can definitely understand the disappointment about the Legendary characters. I made the decision to leave them out because it gets a little tricky to decide which ones to include (such as the AoT characters). Perhaps if I ever do a v2.0 update I'll add them then. (Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
I know! 😭I honestly don't know how I messed that one up. Great point on Haddie, that's tomb Haddie who has fought monsters, which is a different multiversal version of the Haddie we have in game. Also, on the stories of tome Haddie fighting monsters, the Observer makes some remarks that those are probably more likely legends than reality. That said, regardless, tome Haddie has gone through a lot more fighting the Black Vale cult than game Haddie, so I would give tome Haddie better odds of escaping the Dredge.
The fact that people thought STEVE has a hugely better change of surviving the Demo over Nancy is such... God it feels like such blatant sexism. I love Steve and he has definitely held his own in the show but he has also regularly been fucked by the monsters. Nancy is the one with the smarts, the literal firepower and goddamn cojones every single time against the bs they run into in the show. If it HAD to be a choice whether Steve survives Demo or Nancy survives Demo it should 10000% be Nancy. The majority of the ideas/strategies in the show come from her and she has great fuckin aim with her damn guns.
Yun Jin would definitely beat trickster. She’s smart and selfish which could actually give her a way to survive. The trickster was only able to ever rlly kill ppl due to them being caught off guard.
Wait...what did you say about Onryo? AT LEAST SECOND STRONGEST KILLER IN THE REALM?!?!?! WHAAAAAAAT?? Anyway, being serious, i liked the majority of community choices and i even liked more your comments on the ones I didn't agree, there's only one thing i didn't like, you messed up some of the pairs, where the f is Nea? She's Nurse's survivor and not Claudette! Plus, imo, I don't know if Jake would survive against Hillbilly honestly (i don't think so), David/Huntress and Yui/Oni should be at least 50/50 cause David and Yui are really strong, I don't know if Ash could defeat Ghostface and lastly Mikaela, Jonah and Haddie need some more appreciation, they are really strong survivors, maybe they wouldn't survive against their killers but surely have more opportunities instead of survivors like KATE (please, don't get me wrong, i love Kate and her tenacity but she have nothing on her side, like boons or visions or even CIA training) Instead I really loved how you defended Nancy
Yup, lol, lore-wise. The only one I feel is stronger is Pyramid Head, though they are very close in my mind and I could be convinced to flip them, honestly. I appreciate that, and yes, you are absolutely correct, I don't know why I spaced it and didn't pair Nea and Nurse🤷♂️ For me Jake is entirely dependent on if he could remain hidden. If not, Hillbilly definitely wins. I agree that both David and Yui are incredibly strong people, 100%, but Huntress has taken down squads of soldiers single-handedly so I think she'd take David, and as much as I love Yui, I think Oni's just going to be too fast and brutal (though I'm less decided on Yui v. Oni to be honest). I agree too that Mikaela, Jonah, and Haddie are strong Survivors lore-wise. Mikaela is an incredibly powerful Survivor compared to most of the others with her boons, she's one of the few who can actually alter the rules of the trial (Cheryl may be the only other one I'd say is more powerful). I also grew in respect for Haddie after I just wrote the script for a video on her lore and she's stronger than I gave her credit for in this video. Jonah was a CIA analyst, so I'm not sure how much training he would have or how good it would do him in the realm, but he's incredibly smart. The only problem for all three of them in this setup was that they went against incredibly powerful Killers. But I agree that they are strong and deserve recognition for that. And yeah, I feel a lot of people underestimate Nancy. Thanks for watching!
@@theARoberts PH is stronger mystically but as far as being a better killer, I think Onryo beats him. Thing with PH is that James beats him in SH2. As a physical manifestation he can be defeated with weaponry and PH's main form of killing people is hacking them with his very slow cleaver. Compared to Sadako's psionic attack, Sadako is just better. Personally I'd suspect it would be between Onryo and Pinhead for who is stronger as a killer. As for who is better at potentially taking on the entity, I think PH is a clear favorite.
Hey all, thanks for all the support on this video! It's been incredible. Real quick, two corrections I want to make that I got wrong in this one:
1. Nea should have been paired with Nurse since they are in the same DLC. Oops 😅😅messed that one up! Honestly not sure how I did that 😅😅
2. I said Onryo's chapter was based on the book, it was actually based on the original Ringu movie, I got that flipped in my head and misspoke.
The version of Onryo in game is from the book. It was hinted at in the King and Paulie Esther video when Matt Cote mentioned twice that "book properties were eligible to be licensed chapters." You were correct to begin with. As a Nea main who regularly catches the Nurse's attention, nodders, hits on hook, and moris, I'm glad you acknowledged they are supposed to be paired.
Lore wise, Bill does not survive against killers
The killers survive against Bill
The entity makes it so the thought of fighting back never even crosses the survivors mind otherwise you would get people like boulder punching Chris Ash and ofc Bill and many others wreaking havoc
lmao love that
🤣🤣
@@rockett2953 this is my head Canon rn
Give him a gun. Then even the entity gonna fear him
Unironically, Yun-Jin would absolutely escape Trickster. She's knows how to take care of herself and make sure she survives, and she's definitely much smarter than Trickster is, as he only gets away with murder because of his status, and Yun-Jin had him more or less figured out despite it
Trickster has only ever killed people he's taken by surprise and haven't been able to fight back, in a scenario where his potential victim is aware of him and can fight back I genuinely think he would struggle to actually kill them
Also as its states in her lore, she embraces the darkness within her and she wants revenge because the Trickster ruined her career
That's a good point that Trickster has always had the element of surprise. He was about to get Yun-Jin, but she was also paralyzed at the time because he had taken them by surprise, a mistake she likely would not repeat.
And this is why i love Yun Jin 🌹
I wouldn’t say she’s smarter than Trickster.
They are intellectual equals.
Trickster has fooled Yun-Jin plenty of times, most notably in his tome.
He knows Yun-Jin just as well as Yun-Jin knows Trickster.
Doubt. She clearly had no idea who she was dealing with. He outsmarted her in the tome, he trapped and nearly killed her in lore. If he knew that she knew, he would hold no stops. During all the presented lore I'd say he went easy on her
Okay as much as I love Pinhead, remember the weakness to Cenobites is Magic.
Mikaela is a witch. She has been known to do magic before she was taken and her perks are all witch based. So she would have the best chance out of all the survivors, minus maybe Vittorio, to survive the Pinhead.
That's a fair point! I always appreciate when people don't underestimate Mikaela.
Nemesis wouldn’t even try against Leon, he’d be to busy trying to find Jill
Sort of true, but Nemesis also takes out anything standing in his way, which lets be fair, Leon would fight to help Jill too.
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
I wish you'd done a Chris vs. Wesker poll. It'd be interesting to see how the community would react.
That's a good point, perhaps I'll run that one just for fun soon. I kept it just to the actual Survivors themselves and didn't include Legendary skins, but it would be interesting to see how the community reacts.
i mean if chris can move huge rocks by punching them.. hm kinda op
Chris scares boulders, Wesker couldn't dodge Chris's punches yet can dodge bullets. I need not say more.
This is RE1 Chris by lore even if the model is RE5 Chris with stars outfit. This Chris didn't take steroids and become infertile inorder to defeat Wesker
Ash won’t just escape Ghostface, he will just humiliate ghost face all day long and take pics
I can definitely see this 🤣
Chris and Sheva pull out rocket launchers from the lockers.
Wesker starts to sweat
LOL right!
Wellll
Wesker kinda has the power of 8 nemesis’s combined
Wesker could have killed chris,Sheva,Jill,and josh within 10 seconds litteraly
Chris won because wesker was messing with him
He has the ability to move extremely fast, dodge bullets at will and also has super human strength and agility.
But in an all out battle with no restrictions, Albert Wesker couldn't take on two opponents or let alone 4 skilled agents in a wide battle ground like at the end of RE5. As you saw from the battle, they managed to pin him down and poison him.
Chris and Jill didn't stand a chance in the Spencer Estate because of the small space to battle and it didn't take him much to charge dash at them and dodging incoming bullets at the same time and totally destroy and almost killing Chris Redfield.
His weakness is the dark aswell, (his sunglasses don't help the cause). You could shoot him in the back in the dark because he can't see you but if the spotlights were still on, SOMEHOW he can dodge bullets without seeing them. Perhaps its a gameplay mechanics or perhaps it isn't either way, it was that technique that got Albert Wesker to go into serious mode
Funny but I am just gonna mention
ua-cam.com/video/5bu25iS7r14/v-deo.html
@@Aquaviousyuri you fail to mention one thing!!
Just like ash and Laurie.
The characters have thick plot armour.
It would be interesting having a resident evil game where you play as the villains to infect and destroy the world
@@Aquaviousyuri but seriously I get what you mean. In raw strength he would win.
In speed he wins
In the end their Witt is their downfall and Chris and sheva had to think of a different way of winning.
Given that cheryl is essentially a survivor with killer perks (gen block, obsession and hex perk), thats like fighting fire with fire! She defs stands a chance!
She's the strongest (or at least one of the strongest) on the Survivor roster IMO
Few ramblings on several pairs x)
3:50 I believe in-game lore states that Quen was taken quite some time after the events of remake movie (when Nancy's mom is dead and Nancy isn't around for whatever reason). So by that point he's beaten Freddy in the "dream game" a lot of times already. And with DbD's Freddy being much weaker power-wise than his movie-self - it feels like Quentin has a huge chance of winning. Especially if requirement is to escape Freddy, rather than kill him.
4:19 Amanda and Tapp don't really interact in movies at all, but both have 1v1 fights (albeit with different characters). Tapp loses his fight because of opponent's hax (twice actually), while Amanda comes out victorious (even though barely and her opponent had broken leg). Based on this, I'd give an edge to Mandy - she is more agile, quite resilient and willing to fight dirty. Besides, she has a blade and Tapp has only his hands.
13:59 This is a tricky one, because survivor-Haddie we get to play as is not the same character as tome-Haddie. Haddie from Archives would absolutely obliterate Dredge into oblivion, as she does with many creatures in Tomes. Survivor-Haddie isn't quite there in terms of experience, but if her adventures were broadly the same as tome-Haddie's prior to Alps - I'd say she still has an upper hand in at least escaping Dredge, if not full-on defeating him.
14:05 I actually feel like if the goal for survivor is to escape and killer - to kill, then Ada might win this one, given Ada's huge experience in yeeting herself out of tough situations and her overall knowledge of how Wesker might think (their business partnership lasts many years after all, as iirc DbD's Ada is taken during RE4). In actual fight, though, Wong will stand zero chance against Wesker, especially w/o her devices - it took a whole active volcano and two RLs to get this guy after all lol. As for Rebecca - I feel like she'll get killed either way unless Wesker decides to make her his pet - but even then she won't necessarily escape. Especially if we take her RE0-self, when she doesn't have lots of battle experience. Granted, she knows how to handle a gun, but there aren't any guns in Entity's Realm, and even if there were - Wesker literally can dodge any projectiles easily.
Ahh thank you for that info on Quentin. I have not seen the movie so I was assuming that part of his lore overlapped with the movie itself. That makes sense. Thanks for correcting me.
I rely on those of you who have seen the Saw films to fill in my gaps. Most of you seem to agree that Amanda would win.
The Haddie one is tricky I agree, I honestly can't remember what I said (I know, it's been a bit and I'm behind on comments 😅). One tidbit I did pick up on researching for Haddie's lore video is that the Observer notes that the tome version of Haddie that fights the supernatural creatures is a version of Haddie that is legend, not historical. So that version probably never actually existed. But then there's the other tome version of Haddie who is older and fights against the Black Vale that very likely did exist in another universe. But the more I've learned about all versions of Haddie, I agree with you that she would stand a good chance of escaping it.
I think you've described Wesker v Ada / Wesker v Rebecca very well. Again, can't remember what I said in the video, but after reflection I'd agree 100%. Ada escapes, Rebecca doesn't (aside from plot armor of course), but Ada could also not defeat Wesker one-on-one.
Sorry it took so long to respond. I really appreciate you sharing your thoughts!
Technically speaking, Pyramid Head serves as a physical representation of the powers of Silent Hill enacting its punishment on James, so while Pyramid Head proper would never run into Cheryl, "Cheryl vs Pyramid Head" can also arguably be interpreted as "Cheryl vs Silent Hill in general" (which Cheryl still wins, because, well, SH3)
Interesting thoughts! Thank you for sharing!
For legion vs Jeff, there are only 2 scenarios and no, the legion(2 of them at least) won't hesitate killing Jeff even if they were acquainted at one point. So that leaves us with 2 scenarios a 1v1 and a 4v1. If it were a 1v1, Jeff would win based on his build againts individual members of the legion. Sadly if it were a 4v1 yeah, my guy is ded af.
I agree, 100%. 1v1 Jeff is more experienced and he's a capable fighter in his past. 1v4 though, Legion wins by sheer numbers. And since I thought of this more in terms of lore than gameplay, I'd assume it'd be 1v4.
(Once again, sorry this reply took so long😅)
If you put Chris against all the killers in the game. He would beat like half of them just by punching
Unless they are stronger than a 3 ton boulder, they stand no chance against Chris
One thing that should be noted is the different layouts of the entitys realm. Depending on where the 1v1 happens, there could be more or less hiding spots for the survivors. Anyway this was another entertaining video even for a non DBD player. Love to see what other lore videos you are going to do next.
Thanks man! And yeah, that's a great point, it really does matter what map they are on (just like the game itself)
Ash would eat Ghostie for breakfast,but im not sure about Steve and Demo,Season 1 Demo=Steve wins,Season 4 Demo=Demo wins
LOL yup Ghost Face would be no trouble for Ash, and that's how I feel about Steve v Demo too, assuming there is meant to be a difference between S1 and S4 Demo's
I agree with another guy that says if ghostie did his whole stakeout bit for ash after about a day he'd be like "nah" and find someone else.
I think everyone is forgetting that Nancy fought against the demogorgon and the rest of the monsters more times than Steve did
Yeah, honestly I think it's that a lot of people do not like Nancy mains in DBD 😬
i'm a big quentin enjoyer and i'm extremely excited about him winning in the poll against freddy. i have some thoughts about it, so:
quentin has dealt with freddy already alongside nancy. something a lot of people dislike about the remake is that nancy does very little, unlike her much more capable counterpart in the original. instead, quentin always takes action to help her and himself - he shares his medication with her even though that means he'll run out faster (and iirc he ends up under a lot of scrutiny from the pharmacy for running out so quickly), he steals adrenaline from the hospital, and he's constantly doing research in order to figure out what they're up against. when freddy returns in dbd lore, quentin immediately reverts back to that survival mode, staying awake for as long as humanly possible to prepare to fight freddy once again. he's an incredibly capable and active person and with his experience (and personal motivations) against freddy, i know he's definitely winning, even without plot armour (and even without my extreme bias)
I haven't seen the movie myself so this explanation helps a lot! Thank you. I'm with you that Quentin would definitely survive (I can't remember what I said in the video honestly 😅but since posting I've become more sure of that).
Ada is a super agent she can definitely get out of Wesker's hands
The more I've reflected the more I believe she'd definitely escape.
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Yoichi does also have psychic powers and we know that his father is in the realm with him in ghost form because the end of his lore and his perk it's hinted at strongly and because both have super natural abilities I think this round would be a interesting pair up
I completely forgot Yoichi's psychic abilities when recording this, doh 🤦♂️
Yun Jin escaping trapper was he best part of the lore fr.
LOL I totally thought I had edited that out 😂
@@theARoberts it’s alright😂 lol we all make mistakes
The fact Ash vs Ghostface was as close as it is shows how little the DBD community knows about Evil Dead and that's a criminal injustice. Ash wouldn't even break a sweat tossing that skinny little nerd on his neck, even with no weapons and just his mechanical hand
Lol, yeah, Ash has this one in the bag, easy.
“Im not biased, shes just my main”
yeah i totally get you there
I'm glad you can understand 😂
I think Quentin has beat Freddy in DBD lore. The first line of Quentin's lore is 'When he heard that Nancy's mother had disappeared, Quentin Smith knew instantly that their success had been short-lived'. Nancy's mum being killed is the last scene of the movie, so that makes me think that the lore starts after the movie ends. You seem to know your stuff though, so maybe I'm wrong
No, I think you are 100% correct. I haven't seen the movie, so I inferred based on how some of the other licensed lore is written that it overlapped with the movie events. Someone else corrected me too and pointed out his lore picks up afterward. So thank you!
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
New poll idea:who can beat/escape their killers outside the realm
This would change a lot of things!
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
@@theARoberts your fine
Cheryl vs pinhead or Ash vs Pinhead would be a great debate to see lore wise
Indeed it would, I agree! What do you think would be the results?
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
between nancy and steve, nancy would obviously be way harder for demo than steve would, nancy is smarter (she planned a whole set-up trap for demo on season one when she was like, 16yo), she's also more resourceful than steve, since she knows how to shoot. so yeah, nancy would def carry steve if they had to escape demogorgon together
edit1: actually, I belive she was 15yo in season 1, since she (as jonathan confirms in season 4) was going to college (which would make her be 18yo in season 4), this makes her be even more impressive by how smart and skilled she was in season 1
and steve almost died to a demo-dog in season 2, which is like, demogorgon but nerfed, meanwhile nancy alone almost killed demogorgon in season 1. she's way more likely to survive than steve
I always feel like Nancy gets underestimated by a lot of people in favor of Steve, so I appreciate you pointing out how intelligent and resilient she is. I think they both stand a descent chance of escaping.
“The thickest plot armor you’ve ever seen.” Have you ever seen Batman?
lol fair point
I would love to see this again but with randomized pairs. Might be fun to see what it churns out.
You may have seen it but I did another one about who is most likely to survive each Killer, some overlap but also some variety.
I agree that The Quentin would have absolutely gotten the sacrifice when considering the movies, although Freddy could have escaped had he been able to spawn in more dream pallets to confuse The Quentin during the trials.
I'm never living that one down 🤣🤣🤣
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
You accidentally said that Trapper was on his was to kill Yun-Jin. I had to listen a couple of times to realize you meant the trickster 😂
LOL I actually caught several of those in editing, I totally thought I had edited that out, but must have missed one!
the funniest part about ash is his plot armor is CANON, like written in the necronomicon, i mean they basically just state “yeah man main character has plot armor deal with it”
LOL right?
Jeff would possibly be able to hold his own against the legion for a short period of time, just by his stature and build he could throw some haymakers but ultimately would be stabbed a whole fuck ton.
Yeah, agreed. He knows how to fight but he's too rusty to take them all on at once
Micaela definitely escapes Pinhead! She’s a witch, that fought entity with a success, she’s clairvoyant, and could cast a spell or do other witchcraft where’s pinhead follows rules, and he isn’t as versatile as her.
What rules does Pinhead follow? In a lot of ways, he breaks the rules of the Entity's realm (so does Mikaela)
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Depending on the timeline Wesker would let Ada go because they have been long time partners, she got the G-Virus sample for him and Wesker helped her escape Raccoon
We're talking RE4 Ada and RE5 Wesker. It's been a long, long time since I've played RE4 and RE5 is one of the few I haven't played, so I'm not sure how that affects things. What are your thoughts?
@@theARoberts I belive the one in DbD is RE2 Ada. By RE5 she has already betrayed Wesker so he might take that into consideration
In her lore she's taken during the events of RE4. That said, it's very weird then that her default outfit is still her RE2 outfit.
Ash mopped Jason and Freddy at the same time. Ghost face is dead 💀
Exactly!!!😂
GF stands no chance 😂
At the beginning. As long as Laurie survives im happy
I honestly can't remember 😅 did she?
"If DBD was a movie" my man's got foresight
I've said for a long time DBD is perfect for a movie. I'm pretty excited for this one.
I think Pig, Clown, and Twins all win and Vittorio has a real good chance of winning especially if Knight doesn't get his guards but even then we see in the cinematic that it's not until he's surrounded that he runs instead of holding his ground.
What makes you think that about Pig, Clown, and Twins? And great point about Vittorio, even though he's a pacifist, not everyone realizes that he's actually a very skilled fighter. He was able to hold off someone attacking him with only defensive blocks until the dude tripped and fell on his own sword. That said, I always interpreted his standing his ground in the trailer as him trying to assess the situation, and once he realized he was surrounded he knew he had to run.
Nancy is literally a bad ass, more so than Steve. I love him but she would win. I also do feel that Meg would win against Wraith. She's one of if not the most athletic survivor, no? All of her perks are good for chases, looping and surviving in general.
I agree with you on Nancy and Steve. I don't buy that Steve could survive Demo but Nancy couldn't. I see what you are saying about Meg, and I would agree that she stands a better chance than most because of her athleticism. That said, I feel like Wraith is the one she'd struggle with most because his perks/abilities directly compete/counter hers. She's fast, he's faster, she's sneaky, he is too. That's why I went Wraith personally, but at the same time recognize that Meg is probably one of the stronger Survivors overall.
Honestly for Cheryl vs Pyramid Head another thing to keep in mind is that he is a force of punishment. He goes after someone who feels an intense guilt that makes them feel they need to be punished. Thus I would argue that unless Cheryl feels a need to be punished, that Pyramid Head wouldn't even be able to harm her
For OG Silent Hill 2 Pyramid Head I 100% agree with you on that. That said, the way I read his DBD lore is that the Entity has given him new purpose so that he isn't tied to the feelings of guilt in the realm the way he was to James. That's how I interpret it, not saying that's 100% the correct interpretation.
With Vittorio and the knight, I had voted for the knight at the time. You can also see it quite well in the trailer, that he decides with short hesitation then but for the escape.
However, I noticed that again afterwards.
I think now would be a meeting once again more interesting between all 5en.
The companions of the knight are obviously undead / ghosts.
Vittorio, on the other hand, has survived in this world for more than 600 years (well, so have the knight and his people, but they're probably not quite as threatened as Vittorio) and during that time he got the tattoos that... are obviously very powerful.
I am curious if this question will be taken up again in the Riftlore by the two.
Vittorio definitely has a lot of experience surviving in the Entity's realm and I definitely would love to know more about those cryptic glowing tattoos. He probably does have an edge with those things considered. I'm excited to keep getting more Knight and Vittorio lore!
@@theARoberts Cant wait the next 2 days to read more..
As was expected Mr A your knowledge is legendary 👍👍
Always appreciate your support SRG!
This is a unique video style. All that's missing is some background music in my opinion. Other than that, I enjoyed it.
Thanks for the feedback, I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it! There is background music in there, but I must have made it too quiet. I'm always tweaking it in every video because it's been too loud before.
Why is Claud against Nurse when Nurse is literally paired with Nea in the trailer xD
Yup, I screwed that one up 😭
Nea doesn't lose, she is the neantity
We'll pretend like that's why I forgot... er... I mean didn't include Nea on this list 😅😅😅
This makes me want to see animated fights between people and their counterparts.
Please BHVR give us the ability to do cinematic spectator modes
Probably could've had Nancy and Steve together like Legion since they're both technically against Demo in the show.
That's a fair point, but since none of the others had someone else with them I figure keeping them separate maintains the fairness of the polls.
The new ghostface while most likely stand more of a chance against ash
I was operating primarily off of lore.
@@theARoberts that makes more since thank you
Wesker has insane superhuman speed. Remember RE5? He’s easily able to dodge bullets. And that isn’t just reaction speed as we actually see him moving around from place to place at that speed. That’s hundreds of miles per hour. I have no idea how Ada would be able to evade him for even 2 seconds before being obliterated.
Quite easily actually... she has plot armor 😉
I'm pretty sure the picture of Rebecca was placed in Weskers' desk by Barry, who wanted to get Wesker fired. Back when they all worked for S.T.A.R.S.
Do you have any lore reference that makes you think that or is that a theory you came up with?
@ARoberts pretty sure Capcom during one of their streams said it. I also heard the sane thing from a few of my friends, too. On top of that, Wesker, having a thing for Rebecca was never proven true, at least not that I know of. Their are still loads of theories as to why the picture was their tho. My best evidence is because Wesker manipulated Barry to do his bitting and threatened his family if he didn't do what he said. Barry strongly hats Wesker, just like Chris. So Barry plants the photo in his desk to make it look bad on his part. At the time of that picture, I'm pretty sure Rebecca was under 18 still in school. KEY WORDS (I'm Pretty Sure), not 100%, just like all the other theories. But from what I've heard, that seems to be the best one and makes Wesker seem like less of a pedophile.
@@thetopdogrob9366 This is good info, thank you!
@ARoberts Yeah, sorry for the long message. But that's the best to my advantage as to what I can explain. But still, take it with a grain of salt. im still not 100% sure, but it seems the most logical. And what I've heard most about.
People fr always be sleeping on Ghostface. Yes he may just be a dude with a knife but he's a professional knife killer literally can stab you 40 times before you blink
For Onyro vs Yoichi I agree I think Onyro would win I didn't know the chapter was based off the books instead of the movies. A lot of people say its based off the movies so unsure what to believe there. But the whole dbd lore is that Yoichi goes to learn about his heritage and stuff and when he reaches the cabins where the well is we gets sweaped away from the fog as well as Onyro. Because of this im not sure we have the knowledge of the tapes that his parents did since when that happens he is a kid. So I think if my knowledge is correct could be wrong who know Onyro wins that 100%. (Also here is a fun fact! The reasons why Yoichi's parents weren't the survivor for that chapter is because the actors didn't consent to it so that is why Yoichi is instead. One of my friends told me since they are very into dbd stuff.)
I think I actually messed that detail up, I believe the chapter is based on the original Japanese movie. I haven't seen it nor read the books so I'm not 100% sure. I didn't know that about the reason for Yoichi being the Survivor, thanks for sharing that fact.
Ngl I always saw Jake with Wraith and Meg with hillbilly. To me at least the pairing made more sense as Jake was the rich to poor where as Wraith just wanted a decent life and might actually hold it against Jake for choosing a life as a homeless outdoors person as spoilt.
For meg and Hillbilly I feel like their lore sort of matches up as Meg and Hillbilly both revolve around their families. One wants to actively save her mother where as one wants to actively kill their abusive parents.
I had actually not heard of there being pairings of the originals before I made this video, apparently there are defined pairings. I think Meg is with Hillbilly, but Trapper is with Jake. I could be wrong though.
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Why was Claudette paired with the Nurse? I thought the nurse was from Nea's dlc
Yeah, about that.... I totally spaced it on that one... 🤦♂️
Nea doesnt appaer....because she escapes vs all killers! She is to strong 😎
There it is! That would explain why I forgot to include her! 😅
Yoichi definitely escapes onryo I read the novel saw the movies and even his dbd version is just escaping
Can you please expand on what from the original movie gives him good odds of escaping? I haven't seen the Japanese version so I wasn't sure.
@@theARoberts Yoichi is a child in the original movies, and he is very closely connected to Sadako because his relationship with his parents becomes a very clear mirror to Sadako's relationship with her parents. In the first film he only escapes Sadako because Reiko (his mother) saves him from the curse after learning how to survive it, and then again in the second movie he's saved by the spirit of his father who drains away his fear so he can escape Sadako for good. In terms of actual ability Sadako easily crushes anything Yoichi can do. Yoichi has some psychic abilities from his father, but Sadako inherited her mothers psychic abilities and her father is implied to be a sea demon. DBD Yoichi can't top that imo.
This is my first time learning Claudette's counterpart was Nurse idk why I didn't put this together sooner. It literally makes all the sense.
It's actually not 😅 I screwed that one up big time 🤣
@@theARoberts Oh 💀
The thing with Steve and Nancy is more like, Nancy hasn’t taken the physical beatings Steve has. Steve’s got the endurance and the strength to hold his own for a decent amount of time. Even if it is the s4 Demo, s4 Steve is also much, much tougher than he was in s1. Steve has gone up against dozens of upside down monsters and has come out victorious every time. Nancy hasn’t ever faced any of the monsters by herself. Nancy also doesn’t have the athleticism Steve does
Based on your username I can certainly appreciate your line of argument here 😂
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
LOL Don’t sweat it! I don’t mind if you don’t reply, and I’m actually shocked that you did. Tbh, I forgot about this comment 🤣 And yeah, I *might* love Steve a little too much 🤣🤣🤣
I think tapp wins because hes a trained cop and would probably have more experience taking down other people especially normal human beings. Amanda may be cunning but in the movies, it is stated that she needed help from Hoffman carrying people in traps and stuff which suggests shes not that physically strong
Fair points. Most Saw fans seem to side with Amanda, but I'm glad to have a counterpoint. Thank you!
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Tapp would win because his grill master skin implies he can cook pigs easily.
In all seriousness, without spoiling too much, while Tapp never met Amanda as the Pig (in fact, he helped her in both of their interactions) Tapp survived an encounter with a weapon extremely similar to Amanda’s, and the only reason he was put in that situation was because he wanted to arrest the person who attacked him. In addition, he’s seems extremely proficient in hand-to-hand combat. Since arresting someone may be moot in the Realm, and given his obsession with getting the Jigsaw killer, I don’t think it’s hard to imagine Tapp straight up merking Amanda with his bare hands.
😂 That’s why I rely on people who have actually seen the movie, though to be honest, most who have commented lean Amanda, but I see all your points and they make sense. I wonder if Tapp would still try to be “good” in the Realm and might not fight her as hard as he technically could, and if that would make it more difficult for him?
@@theARoberts it’s really hard to say because the scenario of that kind surprisingly really isn’t elaborated on much by DBD devs. I would imagine he would have a better chance either way since Amanda isn’t as good at fighting as either of the people he fought. I highly recommend watching Saw 1 though, it’s free on Tubi!
Poor Nea not getting her poll against Nurse
I know, I messed that one up 😭
Ash is the only one to be able to kill a lot of these killers i bet
A lot of the RE survivors and bill are op
Possibly Cheryl too
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Jeff is an adult the legion is a group of teenagers I think Jeff can take em
One v one, absolutely. One v four, Jeff with no weapons, the Legion all with knives, they overwhelm him just by numbers.
I'm kind of on the fence about Leon/Nemi. I love Leon as well, but when Ex-Special Forces, S.T.A.R.S. Jill Valentine has to pull out the stops to fight Nemesis, then I have a hard time rooting for my man on potentially his first week as a cop. I also should say that I'm not very well read on RE lore tho.
I do want to throw in the caveat that like I'm sure many of the people who voted yes, my first thought was "fuck yeah i love leon he wins"
I see you point totally. I base it mostly on the fact that Leon beat the mutated Birkin and Mr. X on his first day as a rookie, which both are a lot like Nemesis in terms of strength and lethality. One might argue Nemesis is more dangerous, but I wouldn't say by much, that's why my money is still on Leon... plus the plot armor is DEFNITELY on Leon's side😂
But I also think you are right, people saw Leon and straight up voted for him regardless of the question😂
I agree that Leon wouldn’t have escaped the Nemesis however I also think Jill wouldn’t have escaped considered Jill actually lost to the nemesis in the game, she got infected with the T-virus and if it were not for Carlos, she would have died.
@@theARoberts I’d say nemi is significantly stronger than birkin because he has all the same kind of mutations but also control and decent intelligence
Arguably, Jill and Leon would have serious problems if they didn't have access to heavy weaponry. Jill was actually pretty terrible at escaping Nemesis, he pursued her everywhere, she only stopped him by killing him (several times). If the entity isn't nice enough to provide her and Leon an arsenal of heavy weapons... well I don't really like her chances tbh.
it should’ve been.. nea vs nurse , claud vs billy , meg vs trapper
Nea v Nurse I just screwed up 🤦♂️However, the others I didn't know had canon pairings until many viewers have been pointing that out.
I think Quentin wins against Freddy bc Quentin was going against Freddy at FULL power in the movie while still winning.
The entity played with freddy and modified his powers, while Quentin was basically kept the same (except given the survivor rules of dbd)
Bro destroys Freddy like 9 times out of 10 imo
That's a great point.. I'm on board with that
One thing others do forget at times, is that Pinhead went into the realm THROUGH HIS OWN MEANS! He entered the realm by himself and pretty much said, "I'm home bitch!"
Another thing that you have to remember, this Wesker is STILL RE5 Wesker. As a veteran, Ada could slip away, but she would have to calculate well or die. Rebecca has no chance, Wesker would know how to take her out, I LOVE Rebecca, she's one of my favorite characters along with Wesker and Leon, but Wesker would kick her ass. She's a healer with a pistol, that's it...
Valid point. One of the reasons I’d say he’s in the top 3 most powerful. I agree with you 100% on Wesker, the more I think about it Ada would get out, but like you said she’d have to calculate well or she’d be done. Rebecca stands no chance, much as we love her.
@@theARoberts Yeah :\ cause even after everything, she is just a college teacher still, she's got training, but it still wouldn't be enough. As for Jake, I feel he's got like 85% chance tbh.
I think if left unchecked Dredge would just kill and consume everyone and everything in the realm, with the exception possibly being Pinhead.
You're probably right, though I'd throw Sadako and Pyramid Head in the untouchable category too along with Pinhead.
4:20 in the saw movies tapp is defeated, although he is persistent. Amanda would win the fight though, lore accurately.
This is what most Saw fans say, which has influenced me quite a bit. I still have yet to watch them, but it's on my list
You also said trapper instead or trickster😂. No worries ur still a great content creator
Yeah, I didn't catch that till it was too late 😂
Not a chance Vittorio survives The Knight. Vittorio may have been trained, but that was years, potentially decades prior to his arrival in the fog, and he hasn't used a weapon since he swore them off. Meanwhile, the Knight is known to be a hulking brute, and handily beat several warriors at once by himself when he went to get the Lapis Paradisus out of the crypt and while leaving. Plus, he's infuriated by weakness and cowardice; just the sight of Vittorio would likely set him off. Vittorio's only chance is to use his rift-hopping to bail.
Knight would definitely see Vittorio's pacifism as weakness and cowardice, agreed, but Vittorio isn't weak or cowardly in reality. You make a good point about Vittorio being rusty with his combat skills, that's fair. But he doesn't have to defeat Tarhos, just escape him. However, Knight does have the numbers advantage.
technically nurse came with nea. but neas is the entity so its not a fair fight
So I'm going to pretend that this is why I didn't include Nea and that it had nothing at all to do with the fact that I had a brain fart and somehow didn't remember that Nea and Nurse were in the same DLC 😅
@@theARoberts so real for that! Great video anyways and i like the claudette and nurse pairing :)
Also, it'd be kinda easy to get away from Wesker since he's more liable to taunt or play with them rather than go straight for the kill, and the survivors aren't trying to fight or beat the killer, just escape them.
That's a very good point! Something I've said over and over is that they just need to escape the Killer, not take them out.
Another one you messed up is having Meg against wraith even though her ability’s are ment to counter hill billy
Yeah, I had not heard of the default pairings until someone brought it up in the comments.
Amanda killed 5-ish people for Jigsaw, Amanda survived: The Reverse Bear Trap, The Needle Pit, Being Attacked by Xavier, and being strapped to a chair pumped with poison (in the video game, which I’m 98% sure is canon) Amanda beats Tapp 11/10 times.
Sorry, but the entire time I was like, “Where’s the Lisa VS Pyramid Head poll? Don’t you wanna see what’ll happen? When an ODed hallucinating nurse fights the judge of hell?”
I literally just learned of the video game a few weeks ago, I didn't realize it was canon, thanks for sharing! While not having seen the movies myself, this makes me feel more confident in my pick 😄
And yeah, I felt I had to keep it to the base Survivors so no Lisa
What happened to Nea vs Nurse?
Right? I was looking forward to that one. It's a better faceoff, too, because Nea is all about being sneaky, which is a good counter to Nurse.
Yeah, I just botched that one. Don't know what I was thinking. Sorry y'all. So what do you think the outcome would be?
@@theARoberts Hmm...
Nea is sneaky, quiet and efficient, and as strong as Nurse could be i don't think she could win against Nea if she doesn't even find her in the first place, it's the same scenario as Jake vs Hillbilly, as long as they stay hidden, they can escape, but if they get spotted they don't stand a chance
So yeah, it could go either way
@@catlovesdarkness6646 Not to mention even when found, she could still escape the Nurse, by running out of her vision and then hiding again, not to mention how she knows how to get rid of people chasing her. Not to mention how incredibly painful it is for the Nurse to teleport and the need to recover after teleportation. But if Nurse is able to injure Nea? Then Nea would not stand a chance, alone by the noise she would make and the Nurses given supernatural abilities.
@@darkblossum4379 Mhm, that's true! Taken that into account... I think Nea has a pretty big chance of escaping
Nurse is actually paired with Nea though, not Claudette. Nurse and Nea come from the first DLC and were released together.
You're 100% right, I just screwed that up somehow 😭
@@theARoberts Honestly I feel like most people don't even know either of them are DLC. They just feel like base game characters at this point. I just remember the trailer for the DLC for some reason. Still a pretty good video regardless though!
Huntress is definetly one of the strongest killers
In terms of the mostly human characters, absolutely yes. Not compared with some of the supernatural ones though.
I think it Nemesis would handedly win against Jill. Jill never was actually able to properly escape him in the first place he was always a looming threat. The only reason you were able to hold him off is because you had a lot of weapons and also the only reason you were able to kill him is because of the futuristic turbo gun.
That's a fair counterpoint for sure. I still think she could escape him (she doesn't need to kill him like in RE3, just escape the trial) but she'd be at a greater disadvantage without traditional weapons.
@@theARoberts In the games I would say Jill's skill is based off of the cutscenes. Cause if she was as strong as the player, she would just dodge. But in the cutscenes he's fast as hell. Always grabs her and she only gets saved by plot armor or outside forces. I'm steadfast that she'd be screwed.
for honor had ruined me, when i heard 4v1 my thoughts were anti gank
Haven’t played For Honor myself
I'd like to see Jeff and the legions interact
I'd like to see all of these tbh
1:46 but in the lore hag constantly used luck hexes!?
That would be pre-Entity's realm and I'm not it was "constantly" based on the way I read it. She was even warned against doing it. Her post-realm hexes don't appear to have anything to do with luck, unless you're seeing something I'm not?
@@theARoberts from what i know she always used hexes because she didnt believe there would be no consequences even though her elder warned her against using hexes for minor things, bla bla bla, now shes in the entity realm where she can actually use them without consequences (it's been a long time since i read her lore so it might be different)
Would like to see an expansion to this video with the legendary skin survivors & killers too like James, Chris, Armored Titan, Mordeo, etc.
Yeah, the Legendaries get tricky so I decided to leave them out, but perhaps I'll include them if I ever do a 2.0 update
not to sound like a nerd but the archives actually state which killer is assigned to a survivor
Thank you! Multiple people have said I got a few of them wrong but I had no idea where they are getting it from (other than Nurse v. Nea, that one was just a gigantic brain fart on my part 😅)
Jill never should have survived re 3
Like suddenly re protagonist are out here tanking rocket launcher
It's the RE protagonist plot armor 💪😎
Only ones I disagree with are David vs Huntress, Nancy vs Demo, Ada vs Wesker, and Rebecca vs Wesker, I think those survivors would all make it. Especially Nancy, Ada and Rebecca. I was hoping legendary characters would be included in this cause I wanted to see how Claire, Chris, Carlos and Sheva would stand against Wesker/Nemmy.
I can't remember what I said in the video, but after much reflection I would agree that Nancy would escape Demo and Ada would escape Wesker. Rebecca I'm honestly on the fence about, I lean more towards Wesker, but she's also one of the RE characters I know the least about because I haven't played RE0 yet. I'd be tempted to agree with you on David v Huntress until I read her lore. I just don't see him escaping her, she's a monster. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I like getting other perspectives for sure.
I can definitely understand the disappointment about the Legendary characters. I made the decision to leave them out because it gets a little tricky to decide which ones to include (such as the AoT characters). Perhaps if I ever do a v2.0 update I'll add them then.
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
Nurse is actually Nea's antagonist.
I know, I messed that one up somehow 😭
@@theARoberts it's ok
What about Nea vs Nurse? Nea came with the nurse, like Ik Nea would lose but y’know
I know, I messed that one up somehow 😭
You forgot nea!
Also imo haddie would win the fight against the dredge, since she's thought monsters before hasn't she?
I know! 😭I honestly don't know how I messed that one up.
Great point on Haddie, that's tomb Haddie who has fought monsters, which is a different multiversal version of the Haddie we have in game. Also, on the stories of tome Haddie fighting monsters, the Observer makes some remarks that those are probably more likely legends than reality. That said, regardless, tome Haddie has gone through a lot more fighting the Black Vale cult than game Haddie, so I would give tome Haddie better odds of escaping the Dredge.
Claudette isn't the survivor nurse came with
I know, I somehow spaced it and screwed that up 😭
The fact that people thought STEVE has a hugely better change of surviving the Demo over Nancy is such... God it feels like such blatant sexism. I love Steve and he has definitely held his own in the show but he has also regularly been fucked by the monsters. Nancy is the one with the smarts, the literal firepower and goddamn cojones every single time against the bs they run into in the show. If it HAD to be a choice whether Steve survives Demo or Nancy survives Demo it should 10000% be Nancy. The majority of the ideas/strategies in the show come from her and she has great fuckin aim with her damn guns.
People massively underestimate Nancy for sure. And there is 0% chance Steve escapes without her on top of that.
And the last one, would Nea escape against the Entity? Or are they the same?
That is the big question, isn't it 🤔
I'm sorry Wesker but Ada always get out as Ada main 😊
I mean, Ada has to escape, right?
I thought Nea would be against nurse since they came out at the same time lol
She should be, I messed it up 😭
I think Adam would throw a pebble at spirit
I'm interested to know what would happen then 😂
(Also, sorry this reply took so long, I've been behind on comments and doing my best to catch up 😅)
its nea vs nurse? dk where u got clod from
I know, not sure what I was thinking 😅 just messed that one up, plain and simple
I think you skipped Nea
LOL I sure did! 😅 Oops
good
Yun Jin would definitely beat trickster. She’s smart and selfish which could actually give her a way to survive. The trickster was only able to ever rlly kill ppl due to them being caught off guard.
Where's Nea vs Nurse they came together in chapter 1
I know, I messed that up somehow 😭
Wait...what did you say about Onryo? AT LEAST SECOND STRONGEST KILLER IN THE REALM?!?!?! WHAAAAAAAT??
Anyway, being serious, i liked the majority of community choices and i even liked more your comments on the ones I didn't agree, there's only one thing i didn't like, you messed up some of the pairs, where the f is Nea? She's Nurse's survivor and not Claudette!
Plus, imo, I don't know if Jake would survive against Hillbilly honestly (i don't think so), David/Huntress and Yui/Oni should be at least 50/50 cause David and Yui are really strong, I don't know if Ash could defeat Ghostface and lastly Mikaela, Jonah and Haddie need some more appreciation, they are really strong survivors, maybe they wouldn't survive against their killers but surely have more opportunities instead of survivors like KATE (please, don't get me wrong, i love Kate and her tenacity but she have nothing on her side, like boons or visions or even CIA training)
Instead I really loved how you defended Nancy
Yup, lol, lore-wise. The only one I feel is stronger is Pyramid Head, though they are very close in my mind and I could be convinced to flip them, honestly.
I appreciate that, and yes, you are absolutely correct, I don't know why I spaced it and didn't pair Nea and Nurse🤷♂️
For me Jake is entirely dependent on if he could remain hidden. If not, Hillbilly definitely wins.
I agree that both David and Yui are incredibly strong people, 100%, but Huntress has taken down squads of soldiers single-handedly so I think she'd take David, and as much as I love Yui, I think Oni's just going to be too fast and brutal (though I'm less decided on Yui v. Oni to be honest).
I agree too that Mikaela, Jonah, and Haddie are strong Survivors lore-wise. Mikaela is an incredibly powerful Survivor compared to most of the others with her boons, she's one of the few who can actually alter the rules of the trial (Cheryl may be the only other one I'd say is more powerful). I also grew in respect for Haddie after I just wrote the script for a video on her lore and she's stronger than I gave her credit for in this video. Jonah was a CIA analyst, so I'm not sure how much training he would have or how good it would do him in the realm, but he's incredibly smart. The only problem for all three of them in this setup was that they went against incredibly powerful Killers. But I agree that they are strong and deserve recognition for that.
And yeah, I feel a lot of people underestimate Nancy. Thanks for watching!
@@theARoberts if you are talking about lore, maybe you are right, but Sadako is one of the weakest killer in the game if you're talking about power
@@theARoberts PH is stronger mystically but as far as being a better killer, I think Onryo beats him. Thing with PH is that James beats him in SH2. As a physical manifestation he can be defeated with weaponry and PH's main form of killing people is hacking them with his very slow cleaver. Compared to Sadako's psionic attack, Sadako is just better. Personally I'd suspect it would be between Onryo and Pinhead for who is stronger as a killer. As for who is better at potentially taking on the entity, I think PH is a clear favorite.