esta es mí canción favorita, las versión de Metallica la tenía de tono de llamada, de despertador y la sigo escuchando y me encanta, esta versión es muy buena tambien.
kakvi su bili prije 10 a i vise godina..tako isto imaju energiju i sada..Hrvatski duh osjeca istu glazbu i uvijek ju isto voli..kao da su dvije duse..jedno tijelo😙
Had to check out Celtic Thunder after seeing some of the Comments posted - out of a sense of scientific curiosity. I'd go see them but I would do so with an image in my mind of the expression on Phil Lynott's face up in music heaven :-) Liking High Kings - hell it's all good music!!!
These guys are good. Some of their versions are the best I've heard, but I have to say for "Whiskey in The Jar" check out the Kilkennys. You may or may not agree but give a listen to this and some of their other songs and see if you don't also become a fan.
They're far from it There are other artists out there who are more like the Dubliners George Murphy for example He's even performed on stage with them a few times and recorded an album with them So if u think these guys are like the Dubliners u haven't heard anything
Any song by the high kings are good and cheerful, the celtic thunder band might be just as good but i wont give an oppinion because i havn't heard them, i hate it when people insult a band or person they have never seen or heard before.
@MetallicAyManowaR The song is a centuries old traditional song. See the wikipedia article. After the Dubliners brought it to international attention, Thin Lizzy made a version of it, which Metallica covered.
I am doing a little research on different version of the lyrics of Whisky in the Jar and this is close to being my favourite. I would change a few words and slip in an extra verse. I think the longer the story it tells, the better a song it is. I did like the little musical nod to Thin Lizzie in this.
There's no "nod" to Thin Lizzie. The song in its entirety is an Irish folk song first commercially released by The Dubliners in 1968. The actual story of the song dates back to the 1600s.
Cliff Ryan Five for me. The Dubliners, Thin Lizzy, The High Kings, Metallica, and Darby O'Gill. Favorites would definitely be The Dubliners and Darby's versions. Metallica comes in third. A moderately distanced forth would be thin lizzy. They lose points for electric guitar noodling before the intro and at several points during the song. I think the high kinds have done other songs better. They did this okay, but it isn't my favorite iteration of this song by a long shot. Kinda sad because I like the high kings.
jason sexton I love the high kings version, as well as Ryan's Fancy. I was thinking more of different versions of the song. As an example, some versions mention Molly, and others Jennie. Another is how the song starts..some say "..the far farmed Kerry Mountains..." other versions say ..the Cork and Kerry Mountains..."
@MetallicAyManowaR No it's an irish traditional song, and the origin is unknown. :) High Kings covered it from the Thin Lizzy version. Listen it that is very good too :)
@jdg120789 I found this on wikipedia. "The song's exact origins are unknown. A number of its lines and the general plot resemble those of a contemporary broadside ballad "Patrick Fleming" (also called "Patrick Flemmen he was a Valiant Soldier") about an Irish highwayman executed in 1650....In the book The Folk Songs of North America, folk music historian Alan Lomax suggests that the song originated in the 17th century..."
Coming from a percussionist/drummer standpoint, the time signature is the same for both songs. Thin Lizzy/Metallica do a slower rendition that has a different set of lyrics and a story that has a different out come. The only thing here that is similar to Thin Lizzy's is the little lead melody before the song. The rest of it is closer to someone like the Dubliners, just a little slower.
I do love this song but where had the actual music video of this gone? It was deleted and I want it back because it was better quality, this just sounds all muffled and quiet.
No darrin and brian are not related tho i thought so 2 which is y i checked their bios out! I like brian! So cute! Love all the instruments they play banjo and drum are my favs!
"This isn't to my taste These people suck, they do it wrong. Only X can do it right" Come on people. It's cool not to like it, but others do, and that's what matters. Besides, people here have an interesting definition of "pop music"
Celtic Thunder didn't want to be The High Kings and the High Kings didn't want to be CT. They sing different stuff have different styles and achieve different things with it. I think both shouldn't be compared, and both should be only enjoyed. I love both.
They use the correct version of the song. I must give them proper due for that. The way the perform it is a different matter entirely. They have excellent showmanship. I find their style detracts from the song though. Far too much pop influence. The Dubliners do a live version of this song that is exemplary.
@MissSunFlower94 i've only listened to the high kings so i cant criticize CT but neither should be compared to the other or else arguements will break out with some saying their band is better. Why cant we all get along with each other?
@tallwoman76 I think the guys in Celtic Thunder have awesome voices and while I wish they sang more actual Irish stuff, I think they sing very well. The High Kings are marvelous and I love listening to them sing, but I wish you wouldn't put down one group in the praise of another.
@thelegendohara i don't agree with you, i like The high kings, i really do, but no way in hell they can replace The Dubliners, it's impossible, even though they are great musicians, The Dubliners have that special touch that nobody will be able to play again.
![Gary Moore - Whiskey in the Jar (Tribute to Phil Lynott) [HQ] [9/10]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-jEUq3hEjus/mqdefault.jpg)
Does anyone see my comment?
I'm from Japan.
I love this song, because I'm one of a person who loves whisky.
Japanese whisky is sooo good
@@25zer _whisky_
ユキ Japanese whisky ....not bad but not as good as speyside malt , cheers from bonnie Scotland .
Welcome!
Thank you Dave Kavanagh brilliant yet again. You will always be missed . 😘😘😘😘😘😘😘
Irish music is in your blood, the Dubliners, Wolfe Tones , Davey Arthur and Tommy Clancy etc, you either get it or you don't 😀
but a 6 string banjo?
Michael Hayes so very true!!
I agree with that point very much so
The High Kings ar best my favorite ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Great song love it ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
One of the great songs in this world as far as I concerned!!! Great video!
Regardless of who sings it, this music is fucking brilliant. I'd forever rather be in Ireland.
Even then, one of the people that sings it is related to the Clancy Brothers.
Watch their faces - the joy they are having stands out all over! Darren in particular looks like he's about to burst into laughter from 0:36 - 0:38.
Great song. I find irish and Newfoundland music so similar. Luv it!!!!
Love you, guys! ❤❤❤❤
Greetings from Moscow.
Svetlana🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
I saw them when the performed this song at the ICC in Canton, MA and they were AMAZING! EVERYONE was up singing along and clapping. It was great.
I would be tempted to believe that, these lads are good and they can certainly get the crowd going.
Wow! It's the Coolest Irish folksong! I love this cool music!
It still amazes me that Darren can sing and play the Accordion.
esta es mí canción favorita, las versión de Metallica la tenía de tono de llamada, de despertador y la sigo escuchando y me encanta, esta versión es muy buena tambien.
I love the High Kings! Cant wait for their new cd to make it to the united states!
Yes'am these guys are awesome!
Great stuff. Like it!!
kakvi su bili prije 10 a i vise godina..tako isto imaju energiju i sada..Hrvatski duh osjeca istu glazbu i uvijek ju isto voli..kao da su dvije duse..jedno tijelo😙
Brawo. Super. Brawo bravo super irish. Irlandczycy są fajni i fajnie śpiewają....... Pozdrawiam serdecznie Irlandzki zespół 🎵🎶🌝🌛🎵🎶🌝🌛💓💖💖🎵🎶🌝🌛💐💐💐😃💐
send these lads to eurovision,im sure they could write a great tune for it.
Great energy!
one word =AWESOME
that was brillant, i luv the high kings
great group enjoy there music .
Their is used to describe the property of a group of people. There is used to describe a location.
Broken soffa And the location is ireland :P
Had to check out Celtic Thunder after seeing some of the Comments posted - out of a sense of scientific curiosity. I'd go see them but I would do so with an image in my mind of the expression on Phil Lynott's face up in music heaven :-) Liking High Kings - hell it's all good music!!!
High Kings are the next generation of the Clancy Brothers and the legecy is in good hands.
Lyrics should be at the TOP of the comments halfway done with the song and still scrolling 😂
@MissSunFlower94 I agree. This is a great version also. Every group should be enjoyed for their uniqueness.
I want to come in your country and listen to this song!
Best Version of this song ever
These guys are good. Some of their versions are the best I've heard, but I have to say for "Whiskey in The Jar" check out the Kilkennys. You may or may not agree but give a listen to this and some of their other songs and see if you don't also become a fan.
This song reminds me a lot of the song brennan on the moor, if you guys havent heard of it look it up... might be talking about the same guy...
I still love the title of that song
Oh I get it buddy. This is terrific stuff. What a great version.
great group-they do this song well slan, Jim
My dream is to one day be as enthousiastic about something as that one guy is about hitting that drum
His names Brian
no way dude. Im not denying that that these guys are great cos they are but The Dubliners are a one and only.
wow!
well done, lads!
@MissSunFlower94
That was the most reasonable thing you could say. Thumbs up!
And yes, me too love them both :)
Love this
Bleedin Legends! MUP DA IRISH!!!
The High Kings are the best Band on world. I love there music, they have great voices
Hello, Frodo, Sam, Merry, Pippin! Glad to see you guys got a band together! xD
@madfortrad5958 This song is an Irish pubsong from the 1870`s. It was taken ons-tage in the mid 1900`s but it was about long before.
@MetallicAyManowaR Specifically, they covered Thin Lizzy (from Dublin), but the song is an Irish traditional folk song
the high kings are the new dubliners !!
They're far from it
There are other artists out there who are more like the Dubliners
George Murphy for example
He's even performed on stage with them a few times and recorded an album with them
So if u think these guys are like the Dubliners u haven't heard anything
Excellent!
Wonderful!
This was a brutal version
Any song by the high kings are good and cheerful, the celtic thunder band might be just as good but i wont give an oppinion because i havn't heard them, i hate it when people insult a band or person they have never seen or heard before.
My uncle is unreal singing that
@MetallicAyManowaR The song is a centuries old traditional song. See the wikipedia article. After the Dubliners brought it to international attention, Thin Lizzy made a version of it, which Metallica covered.
I am doing a little research on different version of the lyrics of Whisky in the Jar and this is close to being my favourite. I would change a few words and slip in an extra verse. I think the longer the story it tells, the better a song it is. I did like the little musical nod to Thin Lizzie in this.
How many different versions have you come across? I know of 3
There's no "nod" to Thin Lizzie. The song in its entirety is an Irish folk song first commercially released by The Dubliners in 1968. The actual story of the song dates back to the 1600s.
Cliff Ryan Five for me. The Dubliners, Thin Lizzy, The High Kings, Metallica, and Darby O'Gill. Favorites would definitely be The Dubliners and Darby's versions. Metallica comes in third. A moderately distanced forth would be thin lizzy. They lose points for electric guitar noodling before the intro and at several points during the song. I think the high kinds have done other songs better. They did this okay, but it isn't my favorite iteration of this song by a long shot. Kinda sad because I like the high kings.
jason sexton
I love the high kings version, as well as Ryan's Fancy.
I was thinking more of different versions of the song. As an example, some versions mention Molly, and others Jennie. Another is how the song starts..some say "..the far farmed Kerry Mountains..." other versions say ..the Cork and Kerry Mountains..."
+jason sexton also listen to jerry garcia and david grisman version. it was great.
@MetallicAyManowaR
No it's an irish traditional song, and the origin is unknown. :) High Kings covered it from the Thin Lizzy version. Listen it that is very good too :)
@jdg120789
I found this on wikipedia.
"The song's exact origins are unknown. A number of its lines and the general plot resemble those of a contemporary broadside ballad "Patrick Fleming" (also called "Patrick Flemmen he was a Valiant Soldier") about an Irish highwayman executed in 1650....In the book The Folk Songs of North America, folk music historian Alan Lomax suggests that the song originated in the 17th century..."
I love the Indian, Irish and Hungarian legends - Dylan Zoli Deven - go on ya good thing:)
Yeah ❤
I am American but I like these songs. I am glad I am not Irish though.
Darren looks so young and handsome here. He's still handsome, just a little older.
Is it just me who listened to this and just couldn't stop laughing?
Yep, this song's been around awhile.
tune !
Coming from a percussionist/drummer standpoint, the time signature is the same for both songs. Thin Lizzy/Metallica do a slower rendition that has a different set of lyrics and a story that has a different out come. The only thing here that is similar to Thin Lizzy's is the little lead melody before the song. The rest of it is closer to someone like the Dubliners, just a little slower.
Happy St. Patrick's Day boi
The first version of this I ever heard was Roger Whittaker's. :)
Not a drop of Gaelic blood do I have in me, but I love the music!
I do love this song but where had the actual music video of this gone? It was deleted and I want it back because it was better quality, this just sounds all muffled and quiet.
It's ok I found it.
+Rosie Shaw where?
+Mitoki Ookami /watch?v=RF9vECI7aMo
Royalrosewolf. N
wilhelmrk
No darrin and brian are not related tho i thought so 2 which is y i checked their bios out! I like brian! So cute! Love all the instruments they play banjo and drum are my favs!
@madfortrad5958 I think it's a lot older than that. For these kind of songs it's impossible to put a date on them...
1:23 he's gettin' into that accordion
I stand Corrected
@madfortrad5958 Yeah... I love this version, but nothing beats the Thin Lizzy version
Eles se apresentaram no programa da Eliana o Raul Gil ?
"This isn't to my taste
These people suck, they do it wrong. Only X can do it right"
Come on people. It's cool not to like it, but others do, and that's what matters.
Besides, people here have an interesting definition of "pop music"
@madfortrad5958
This is old drinking song made in XVII century actually
Celtic Thunder didn't want to be The High Kings and the High Kings didn't want to be CT. They sing different stuff have different styles and achieve different things with it. I think both shouldn't be compared, and both should be only enjoyed.
I love both.
❤❤❤
Did anybody else see that thug play his accordion like a boss at 1:23?!
Can't beat the Brothers Four version
gary moore and friends at self-aid is No.1 (modelled after the great thin lizzy version)
METALLICA!
They use the correct version of the song. I must give them proper due for that. The way the perform it is a different matter entirely. They have excellent showmanship. I find their style detracts from the song though. Far too much pop influence. The Dubliners do a live version of this song that is exemplary.
Well, when it comes to the pop influence, you have to think of their competitors.
What is the wrong version of the song?
@@legosoilder3621 don't forget the difference between pop and Celtics
@MissSunFlower94 i've only listened to the high kings so i cant criticize CT but neither should be compared to the other or else arguements will break out with some saying their band is better. Why cant we all get along with each other?
@tallwoman76 I think the guys in Celtic Thunder have awesome voices and while I wish they sang more actual Irish stuff, I think they sing very well. The High Kings are marvelous and I love listening to them sing, but I wish you wouldn't put down one group in the praise of another.
THE LADS WAS A BIT NERVY BUT THEY SETTLED DOWN .GOD BLESS
@MetallicAyManowaR Not an original song of the High Kings, quite an old Irish Song, dates back many years, there are many many covers :)
@thelegendohara No one can replace the dubliners FACT :)
search the "The young dubliners" too
@madfortrad5958 And Thin Lizzy made the rock cover famous before metallica.
Is that a 6-string banjo?
Why would finding his brother in the army help him after an armed robbery? I have always wondered that...
Ken Bishop because his brother knows how to fight and could bust him out of jail
Musha-ring dum-a-doo dum-a-da.
Whack-for my daddy-o. Whack-for my daddy-o!
There's whiskey in the jar....
Have you heard the Darby O'Gill version from their live album?
و فناء من قبلة عهدا بفناء غير مكذوب واني البني و اني اليماني و المنسلخ و جيش باليماني و هو شعب الخائنة.
.
قلت اعربي مخينيث
@MetallicAyManowaR no its an irish classic
6 sting banjos always make me sad...
Jenny waterlogged his gun in an earlier verse. :) At least that's my understanding. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong!
these guys r ok at this song but the dubliners will always be here
@Freyja1133 they've been together over 30 years what are you talking about
@thelegendohara i don't agree with you, i like The high kings, i really do, but no way in hell they can replace The Dubliners, it's impossible, even though they are great musicians, The Dubliners have that special touch that nobody will be able to play again.