The "Beginning" typo slipped past me. This is really the second part of the previous dungeon design video. That video touched on my philosophy and an overview of the basics. Now beginning with this video we'll look more closely at the details. The next video takes you inside the dungeon. To again quote The Dungeon Builder's Guidebook from 2nd edition AD&D, "Historically, a dungeon consisted of underground chambers for the confinement of prisoners. However, as a convention used liberally throughout the D&D game, "dungeon" means any bounded setting within which player's characters interact with each other, nonplayer characters, traps, puzzles, monsters, and/or other challenging situations. Thus, this term applies to everything from subterranean mines and burial chambers to castles, cities, and extraplanar abodes." Thanks for watching.
Lots of great stuff in this video! Thoughtful dungeon creation really helps with allowing players to come up with creative plans. If the dungeon makes sense the players can start to reason about how things work and what effect their interactions will have. I really like dungeons designed this way!
Nice rundown and interesting tips, I usually use humans or some of the other base humanoid player races as the bad guys in about half of my dungeons-though I didn't always. Originally I was just throwing monster combat encounters together to see what groups of players could handle at various levels, but as I read more and more of my AD&D 2nd edition Monster Manual(My very first D&D book.)I began to feel bad for a lot of the creatures. And so from there I began designing encounters where often times the monsters were innocent and misunderstood, there are some of course that I still only use as bad guys like skeletons and zombies or oozes, slimes and jellies. But overall I tend to treat the ones that have sentience as more than just targets for the party to slaughter, this usually throws new players for a loop. Anyways, can't wait for the next video. Take care and have fun. =^_^=
I love all We Love TTRPG VIDEOS! This design strategy works even when you aren't playing fantasy. A crime lord's hideout, a wrecked spaceship, the abandoned mansion taken over by cultists. These are all reskinned dungeons.
Per the first dungeon design video, "To quote The Dungeon Builder's Guidebook from 2nd edition AD&D, "Historically, a dungeon consisted of underground chambers for the confinement of prisoners. However, as a convention used liberally throughout the D&D game, "dungeon" means any bounded setting within which player's characters interact with each other, nonplayer characters, traps, puzzles, monsters, and/or other challenging situations. Thus, this term applies to everything from subterranean mines and burial chambers to castles, cities, and extraplanar abodes."
As an old student of philosophy and mythology, I appreciate the thoughtful approach you take to dungeon design. Keep up the good work, I look forward to seeing more of your videos.
I watch a fair bit of DnD stuff on UA-cam and yours really stands out. It is concise, well organized, and easy to understand. A lot of DnD videos ramble on without saying much or feel like the video was created entirely to sell a sponsored product. Your videos do neither and its very refreshing and helpful.
That's very kind of you. Thank you very much! I'm just somebody who enjoys sharing my passion for this hobby and I love helping others! Not selling anything and I'll never create a patreon - I'm not knocking those who do - it's just not anything I'm interested in. I think of everyone joining me here as family. Thanks again!
I play AD&D “by the book”. One of the things that comes up fairly often is item saving throws. This mechanic seems to be a tool for causing magic items to be destroyed whenever the person wearing or holding an item gets caught up in a lightning bolt or fireball, for example. I think we have gone through at least 4 suit of magic armor and at least 5 different magic swords in this manner. Anyway, this could be one way to “undo” the magic item hordes that players can accumulate in a heavy magic game.
@@apatheticrabbit thanks. Fun Fact, back in 2017 I was picked as "The spookiest thing in Seattle" for a national ad campaign by T-Mobile for their "30 days to Halloween" promotion
@@welovettrpgs I'm certain your likeness was conjured in the minds of every terrified aunt by the words "Dungeon Master" during the satanic panic. It tickles me to think about.
I hear Wear Rats taste like chicken! 🤣. I've always enjoyed designing Dungeons just for the fun of it. Even if I never use them. Especially with your recent video series. It's given me idea's and made me more mindful during creating. Thanks again Aten 👍. 🤘☺️🖖🇨🇦
I appreciate your general TTRPG advice and content! I have been marking all wizards content as "do not recommend" when they use titles conflating TTRPG and wizards game.
My problems with WotC go back to the mis 90s. I originally was calling this channel "We Love D&D" because I do however I really am not happy that D&D is owned by people who truly do not love D&D. I wish so much a company like Goodman Games or Kobold Press owned D&D.
@@MikeLemmons Also, in copyright law if that happens too much the company will lose its hold over the name. This happened a few times in our history. So it's possible D&D will eventually come to mean any ttrpg and no longer that specific game.
@@MikeLemmons i agree with you. I have many TTRPGs in my collection and I'll be covering them all. (I have a couple videos up already). To build the channel I'm doing a lot more D&D content but after I hit 5k subs i'll be talking more about other games and why it is important to play them.
Thanks. Between us, I prefer to just sit and share the info (part of my "real life" work involves a lot of public speaking) however I also have to feed the algorithm and if using the "pope in a pool" method of story telling and editting helps get my videos to a wider audience then why not.
@@welovettrpgsI totally get that. Always enjoyed your earlier videos for the content. I will say, to me, that the "upping" of the game is more about your animation/excitement level than the drop-cuts and sound effects and such. I'm old, so I don't mind a dry delivery of cool and clever info, but you do seem more peppy in the videos of late!
I bet happiness burns more calories than depression. (And yes, I'm still 30lbs overweight but hopefully I'll start using that gym membership. Turns out just having a membership doesnt work. I actually need to go there!
I got into dungeon ecology around the time I stumbled into AD&D and then Traveler, of all things. It sort of started my journey through simulation game play. I spent way too many hours trying to be architecturally and biologically 'accurate' until I discovered 40k and realized that there was NO WAY 10 Space Marines, as modeled, are going to fit inside a RHINO. Actually it was around the time games like TWERPS, MEKTON and BEYOND THE SUPERNATURAL landed on my table. There was little concern about the minutia but still, there had to be some verisimilitude to ground the events and encourage immersion. I still enjoy mapping out complexes and holds and setting up some kind of ecological or political structure for an area.
The "Beginning" typo slipped past me. This is really the second part of the previous dungeon design video. That video touched on my philosophy and an overview of the basics. Now beginning with this video we'll look more closely at the details. The next video takes you inside the dungeon. To again quote The Dungeon Builder's Guidebook from 2nd edition AD&D, "Historically, a dungeon consisted of underground chambers for the confinement of prisoners. However, as a convention used liberally throughout the D&D game, "dungeon" means any bounded setting within which player's characters interact with each other, nonplayer characters, traps, puzzles, monsters, and/or other challenging situations. Thus, this term applies to everything from subterranean mines and burial chambers to castles, cities, and extraplanar abodes." Thanks for watching.
Lots of great stuff in this video! Thoughtful dungeon creation really helps with allowing players to come up with creative plans. If the dungeon makes sense the players can start to reason about how things work and what effect their interactions will have. I really like dungeons designed this way!
I love all We Love TTRPG VIDEOS! Aten is smart, experienced and contributes so much to the community!
That's very kind of you. Thank you very much!
Nice rundown and interesting tips, I usually use humans or some of the other base humanoid player races as the bad guys in about half of my dungeons-though I didn't always. Originally I was just throwing monster combat encounters together to see what groups of players could handle at various levels, but as I read more and more of my AD&D 2nd edition Monster Manual(My very first D&D book.)I began to feel bad for a lot of the creatures. And so from there I began designing encounters where often times the monsters were innocent and misunderstood, there are some of course that I still only use as bad guys like skeletons and zombies or oozes, slimes and jellies. But overall I tend to treat the ones that have sentience as more than just targets for the party to slaughter, this usually throws new players for a loop. Anyways, can't wait for the next video. Take care and have fun. =^_^=
thanks wolf! I too enjoy moral dilemmas in my ttrpgs
I love all We Love TTRPG VIDEOS! This design strategy works even when you aren't playing fantasy. A crime lord's hideout, a wrecked spaceship, the abandoned mansion taken over by cultists. These are all reskinned dungeons.
Per the first dungeon design video, "To quote The Dungeon Builder's Guidebook from 2nd edition AD&D, "Historically, a dungeon consisted of underground chambers for the confinement of prisoners. However, as a convention used liberally throughout the D&D game, "dungeon" means any bounded setting within which player's characters interact with each other, nonplayer characters, traps, puzzles, monsters, and/or other challenging situations. Thus, this term applies to everything from subterranean mines and burial chambers to castles, cities, and extraplanar abodes."
As an old student of philosophy and mythology, I appreciate the thoughtful approach you take to dungeon design. Keep up the good work, I look forward to seeing more of your videos.
Thank You
I watch a fair bit of DnD stuff on UA-cam and yours really stands out. It is concise, well organized, and easy to understand. A lot of DnD videos ramble on without saying much or feel like the video was created entirely to sell a sponsored product. Your videos do neither and its very refreshing and helpful.
That's very kind of you. Thank you very much! I'm just somebody who enjoys sharing my passion for this hobby and I love helping others! Not selling anything and I'll never create a patreon - I'm not knocking those who do - it's just not anything I'm interested in. I think of everyone joining me here as family. Thanks again!
Worth it solely for the question, "What are the monsters eating when they're NOT eating adventurers?" *high5*
Thanks!
_Deliveroo_ 😊
I play AD&D “by the book”. One of the things that comes up fairly often is item saving throws. This mechanic seems to be a tool for causing magic items to be destroyed whenever the person wearing or holding an item gets caught up in a lightning bolt or fireball, for example. I think we have gone through at least 4 suit of magic armor and at least 5 different magic swords in this manner.
Anyway, this could be one way to “undo” the magic item hordes that players can accumulate in a heavy magic game.
The durability of magic items in 5e is a bit much. They're nearly indestructable. I'm used to the AD&D mechanics.
Brilliant! :)
Thank you!
I love All "We Love TTRPG´s!" videos. I totally agree on the resemblance of realism approach. It gives so much more texture to the game world
Thank You!
I am currently designing a one-page design document for generating a one-page dungeon. Brevity is the sole of wit.
William Shakespeare was not wrong but explaining nearly 50 years of experience in a tik tok video isnt what i do here.
Great video. The production quality has vastly improved. Now we just need to get you an audio library to match your aesthetic. Great work!
People would fall asleep and then have nightmares if I used the music I actually listen to ( le mystere des voix bulgares, for example)
Actually I think it would be great if you leaned into your style more.
@@apatheticrabbit thanks. Fun Fact, back in 2017 I was picked as "The spookiest thing in Seattle" for a national ad campaign by T-Mobile for their "30 days to Halloween" promotion
@@welovettrpgs wow. That is awesome.
@@welovettrpgs I'm certain your likeness was conjured in the minds of every terrified aunt by the words "Dungeon Master" during the satanic panic. It tickles me to think about.
I hear Wear Rats taste like chicken! 🤣. I've always enjoyed designing Dungeons just for the fun of it. Even if I never use them. Especially with your recent video series. It's given me idea's and made me more mindful during creating. Thanks again Aten 👍. 🤘☺️🖖🇨🇦
thanks!
Definitely worth a subscribe I love videos from We Love TTRPGS!
Thanks!
When I think of skulks, I think of the UK2-3 series of modules. Fun adventures. :-)
The Sentinel and the Gauntlet. Yes, I've incorporated those into the game .. sort of ..
@@welovettrpgs Ha! Nice choice! ;-)
Your videos have a lot of gameable content.
Great! TY
I appreciate your general TTRPG advice and content! I have been marking all wizards content as "do not recommend" when they use titles conflating TTRPG and wizards game.
My problems with WotC go back to the mis 90s. I originally was calling this channel "We Love D&D" because I do however I really am not happy that D&D is owned by people who truly do not love D&D. I wish so much a company like Goodman Games or Kobold Press owned D&D.
@@welovettrpgsI totally get you. I play PF2e myself, and other TTRPGs, so I would like youtube to stop conflating TTRPG and wizard's game.
@@MikeLemmons Also, in copyright law if that happens too much the company will lose its hold over the name. This happened a few times in our history. So it's possible D&D will eventually come to mean any ttrpg and no longer that specific game.
@@welovettrpgsI understand what you're saying, but I don't think conflating TTRPG and their game helps.
@@MikeLemmons i agree with you. I have many TTRPGs in my collection and I'll be covering them all. (I have a couple videos up already). To build the channel I'm doing a lot more D&D content but after I hit 5k subs i'll be talking more about other games and why it is important to play them.
You're really upping your game Aten and it shows! Great work!
Thanks. Between us, I prefer to just sit and share the info (part of my "real life" work involves a lot of public speaking) however I also have to feed the algorithm and if using the "pope in a pool" method of story telling and editting helps get my videos to a wider audience then why not.
@@welovettrpgsI totally get that. Always enjoyed your earlier videos for the content. I will say, to me, that the "upping" of the game is more about your animation/excitement level than the drop-cuts and sound effects and such. I'm old, so I don't mind a dry delivery of cool and clever info, but you do seem more peppy in the videos of late!
@@dmcdraws thanks!
Great videos, kudos
Thanks!
Nicely done as always!
Thanks again!
very inspirational work
Thanks!
This has been helpful to me.
That's great!
Thanks for the ideas to nosh on. Very much looking forward to your thoughts on Star Frontiers.
Oh I love that game! I do believe Starfinder had to have at least been somewhat influenced / inspired by it as they seem to have a very similar tone.
Currently, a long forgotten temple to Tiamat, occupied by a Rat King 🐁
nice!
*beginning (for correction on the chalkboard)
Yeah i knew that was wrong but it slepped past - I was so darn tired thanks
Most all of us who love TTRPG need a calorie tracker! 😂. How many calories are in happiness ?
I bet happiness burns more calories than depression. (And yes, I'm still 30lbs overweight but hopefully I'll start using that gym membership. Turns out just having a membership doesnt work. I actually need to go there!
I got into dungeon ecology around the time I stumbled into AD&D and then Traveler, of all things. It sort of started my journey through simulation game play. I spent way too many hours trying to be architecturally and biologically 'accurate' until I discovered 40k and realized that there was NO WAY 10 Space Marines, as modeled, are going to fit inside a RHINO. Actually it was around the time games like TWERPS, MEKTON and BEYOND THE SUPERNATURAL landed on my table. There was little concern about the minutia but still, there had to be some verisimilitude to ground the events and encourage immersion. I still enjoy mapping out complexes and holds and setting up some kind of ecological or political structure for an area.
If you catch my prior Dungeon creation video I do discuss verisimilitude.
You sound like the narrator to fire coming out of the monkeys head
I recognize the words but I have no idea what they mean when placed in that order.
@@welovettrpgs it's a Gorillaz song.
@@unclesteez2934 ah! OK, thanks for the info