5,000-year-old industrial hub-Binjor excavation shatters myths about ancient Indian manufacturing
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
- "About 4 km away from the India-Pakistan border that divides the Ghaggar-Hakkra river, in the Anupgarh tehsil of Sri Ganganagar district of Rajasthan, is a site that brought to light the unknown facet of Harappan culture. Binjor is an archaeological site located in village 4(MSR). This site was reported by A Ghosh in his famous exploration of Rajputana in 1950-52, where he mentions four mounds, namely Binjor 1, Binjor 2, Binjor 3 and Binjor 4. Katy Dalal set up a trail trench at Binjor 3 and noticed Pre-Harappan deposits at a depth of 1.75m in the 1970s", says Disha Ahluwalia.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
The audio needs to be fixed. The echo makes it almost incomprehensible.
Yup, a simple mike would have done it.
Same issue of voice. She needs to speak in Mike. The voice is echoing.
It's the Print. Mic provided by the politburo of chyna
print needs to ger her a microphone, any microphone....any kind of microoooophhhhhoooooooooone. great content
These days good microphones can be bought for very cheap. Even built in microphones in earphones and headphones have improved a lot. Poor quality audio should not be tolerated for any reason today.
Could you also excavate The Print's office and find out why they are so adverse to good quality audio? They got the LSD backgrounds, least they could do is get a good directional mic.
🤣🤣
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Can I request Print to redo and reupload this video. Its a topic I want to hear. But a pre presentation proper script, a few practice runs before the shoot so that the delivery is legible, and finally a right audio system, would be a great help.
I’m a big fan of the print and a member too. However, most of their videos suffer from poor audio quality and makes their excellent content a little difficult to follow. I’m sure a quality organisation like print can fix such a small thing quickly basis our our feedback 2:33
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Audio quality is too bad and too much background noise😢
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Please take care of the sound quality. I can understand Shekhar crisply even at 2x speed. This one however was garbled, words tripped on one another, and there was something off about both the diction and delivery. This over and above the recording quality. An extremely interesting video that I was looking forward to, ended up becoming a drag.
Mam, the content is good. Happy to listen to a expert.
It will be nice if you can redo this video with better Acoustics . Please.
You just need one Rs 200 mike to sound better...... Sorry to be harsh...
Disha is a wonderful archeologist. She flawlessly and flowingly presents her subject. Addition of some sketches and photographs to make the topic more clear will help. One thing Print must take care of is the echo in PA system. It mars the presentation. Makes it hard at places to catch what she is saying. Video has to be rewound.
No context and no proper structure makes it difficult to understand what the point is and what is being conveyed. Please prepare a proper presentation for effective communication, thanks 🙏🏼
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Next time, could you please include some pictures to help us visualize the site?
You guys can turn on subtitles to help if you are having difficulty hearing.
Thanks Print for making content on Archeology 😊.
Sound quality is so bad
This is second video i watched. It is important information. But very difficult to follow what she is saying. It would really help if she presents slides with important points which can be explained. Changing the format will sirely help
Plenty of scope of improvement in presentation and technical work
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Information on the main topic comes only after 8 mins into the podcast!!!
Very interesting topic but the production and audio could be better
Audio needs to be fixed!
U guys need to invest big in the production team.
Wish that the GOI can put more resources to ASI to complete these archaeological digs at the same pace as they are building roads. It is so important to get out the authentic history of Bharat as it tries to again become a world power.
Harappa, the first archeological of many site in the Indus Valley Civilization.
It is very encouraging find new sites and relevant facts outside the previously defined area, conforming to the specifics of the IVC.
However, adding mythological features and misleading histories to the IVC may not be very respectful of the very advanced and well accomplished IVC that ended in 1900bc, long before
the Vedic culture became effective, in 1500bc.
Great presentation as always.
Sound quality needs improvement not very clear
Sound recording is not good for this video
please pay for the subscription so that a better sound proofing can be done
I would love to hear this report, however as others have shared the audio is really bad. There’s lot of echo and background noise. I would urge the print team to ensure their uploads meet an acceptable video and audio baseline!
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Good content but poor audio quality makes it a terrible experience.
An outline should be included in school syllabuses
Thank you for the information
Horrible noise audio and this video needs some kind of map graphic
BEST WISHES FROM RAVINDER TALWAR JALANDHAR CITY PUNJAB INDIA 🍀
Re-upload with better audio
Very poor quality audio quality and acoustics. Pls use a room which does not resound
Not good audio quality...
Please improve audio. Nice topic but cant understand
Please improve audio quality
horrible sound system☹
Why is the audio so poor?? Traffic noises over lapping the content making it hard to hear. This is a Print video and not some amateur one.. expected better quality.
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Audio needs fixing
Amazing content.
Poor audio makes this video uninteresting 😢
Poor quality sound. Had to exit after trying to focus for a minute or so.
Please increase audio
Mic quality is pathetic
Please buy a mic!!
It's not that expensive....
The pre Harappan inhabitants of ancient Bharat could be the ancestors of the guys claimed to be sneaked in from "steppe". Interesting indeed!
I wanted to see the comments concerning the voice, honking in the background, etc. You should review the comments. But I want to concentrate on what you are presenting. It's seems to be important stuff but your presentation needs to be improved. Spend more time showing what you are talking about not just a quick picture of it which vanishes before you offer an explanation of what you are showing. It is difficult to understand what you are speaking about unless you take all the time showing and discussing its implications. So I had to leave without watching the entire presentation. But remember, this is a show and tell, not a tell only. Catch you another time.
Poor presentation and no context makes it less interesting for common folk. Thank you
She is an intern so you must encourage her 👍
@@tigerking2742 critical feedback ? I did say thank you
It's like the houses are built with stencil.
Audio is "Work From Home" Quality
What was the fuel for industrialisation?
hay from your brain
Wood is easy assumption, No?
Please invest in a mic when you want to make a video!
Please use a mic. This is so unprofessional. Mr Shekar your teams need some basic needs of a mic yaar
Who'll explain this to Irfan and Romila
Mam, your subject matter is very interesting and enlightening. Can you please work on your delivery ? It sounds too much like a teacher. Turns you off. Better delivery will definitely make this interesting
whats wrong with "The Print" young reporters? arent you supposed to say how indian civilization was exactly as Western Influenced historians and archaeologist's suggest? are you taking BJP's line?
Poor audio
Indus valley could be the Aratha referred to in Sumerian text.
Print, you are a famous media.
Pls buy a strap-on mic.
This voice is muffled.
What myths? Who spread such myths and why?
can't understand a thing. My ears hurt after just 3 min into the video
Too much echo
Lot of echo effect
Too bad audio
ua-cam.com/video/DfnkStp9FtU/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared video on the 4 msr
Poorly compered. It is extremely difficult to understand due to very poor pronounciation with a put up accent. Hindi would have been better.
ಯವ್ವ, ನೀನು ಮಾತಾಡಿದ್ದು ಸರಿ ಕೇಳಿಸುತ್ತಿಲ್ಲ.
Horrible audio
Audio not good
Get it approved by Romila Thapar and Irfan Habib.
As if Print want to convey something they have no interest as such
Don't peddle fake narrative s.
Dre Brak abt the manfraing mañana harappa
New lkinzn os ajnbxn mjznxbn.
Hope every one understood.
This is what understood from the print.
SG often asks for donations for what ? Making this sort of shoddy work ?
Extremely exaggerated outright bogus claims clothed in wooly nebulous words and ideas.Basically this lady wants to thrive by questioning the present ideas on Indian pre history from the point of Hindu rightwingers but the arguments and methods used by her are highly suspect.Making a mole hill of small things is one of her tried tricks.
Very Very dubious individual without academic rigor
I wanted to see some facts and not your speach
She is not a good communicator
Did your forefathers where from Africa? ??
Out of africa is the present accepted theory !
So much of talking
then the aryans came and enslaved the Indians
yes aryans destroyed cities and enslaved peaceful indian people
not the Indians, only your brains
,,,, the color coded them red and brown Indians... Arya simply means respected elder in indic language but anywy smart historians seem to be believe it was race..
Show more pictures rather than just your narration . Will make videos more successful