@@lick3227 This is an inspiration of Obon Matsuri festival of Awa Odori dance from Shikoku (as I have heard), so no he is right this is not a victory dance or war dance but rather a funeral.
@coinínbán so they've weakened them in order to conquer them. You know, with all the manipulative shite going on nowadays, and how fucking soft we're getting, and with everything that's going on with the UN, depopulation, world state etc I wouldn't mind a bit of nationalism again.
The allies didn't punish the Axis because of their war crimes and they wanted to control the world. They punished them so THEY could commit war crimes and rule the world. But the difference is they do it while blinding their population with consumerism.
@@memegod4433 You prefer it from afar. Very much afar. Everyone loves talking about nationalistic glories perched on their sofa, in the comfort of capitalist liberalism. If you were a slave-labourer in some Japanese concentration camp, you'd talk differently.
Title is a bit misleading. This isn't a victory dance, it's a form of venerating their fallen brethren. A sort of funeral procession, historically at least. The movie may differ (it's China-produced after all).
@Rando Namo Here you go: ua-cam.com/video/pimugZ_TthY/v-deo.html This is from the Japanese 'Day of the Dead', where Buddhists celebrate people that have passed. There's no footage of the military doing this back then because it's a religious practice (that was considered a regular thing) and they were more concerned with recording themselves being strong for propaganda. The movie's dance seems more intense and solemn because 1. it's the military, 2. they've seen some messed up stuff, and 3. it's a movie.
@@OrionSlaveGirlUWU I'll have you know I have nothing but respect for His Imperial Japanese Emperor's Very Own Special Elite Ladyboy Death Detachment. I find it very anime. Very otaku. Iro iro arigatou gozaimashita.
@VS257 Originally, yes, but then the creators kinda backtracked and also included other Asian influences, including Thai, so it wouldn't be seen as anti-Japanese.
I disagree, all the other countries in the show also has mixes of other Asian (and in some instances non-Asian) cultures in it. I do think it is mostly modelers after Japan (similar to how the Earth Kingdom was broadly modeled after China) but I do think all the respective countries were made to be mostly unique and not based entirely off of one country or another. @@TheManWithThePsychoGun
@noco7243 The clothes worn by Fire Nation citizens have more similarities with traditional Thai clothes than with traditional Japanese clothes. Fire Nation cuisine is hot and spicy, like Thai foods, while Japanese cuisine tends to be pretty mild.
I think this is more of a pseudo-religious ceremony rather than a victory March. Their victory parade in the Philkipines is much different compared to this and more western appearing
I think the point of the film is to show the determination and terrifyingness of the Japanese for their ruthless and unmercifulness in the nanking siege via this dance performance.
Historically, the sack of a city was until recently an incredibly brutal affair. Some more Brutal than others. In medieval times it was common for a large proportion of the men to be murdered, the women to be abused, and many of the inhabitants sold into slavery. But even by those standards, what happened in Nanjing was chilling.
Waging of war in Asia compared to the West is vastly different. Much more brutal. You might check what Japanese did during Sengoku Jidai or Chinese way during their rebelion suppression campagings. Have you ever hear about Taiping rebellion? Most Westeners never had. Live loss only second to WWII. I do not know if this is because vast population or because their faith in reincarnation, where killing is not that big deal compared to Western understanding of the world.
@@lahvancz I think it is important not to get trapped by the fallacy that the Asian mind is somehow different to that of the West. We are human! The Taiping rebellion was extraordinarily brutal. But so was the 30-year war just after the reformation (smaller death toll, but only because it occurred over a smaller overall population)! The extermination of the indigenous populations of the Americas and Australia, along with the subjugation of Africa, was equally pretty brutal over that time period. Some rules for war did start to appear more humane in Europe by the end of the 19th century - but it was only for western Europeans vs western Europeans. By WWII, arguably, things were improving in some theatres, but that was over a relatively short timescale compared to the previous few thousand years of military culture.
@@patrickdegenaar9495 That is not what I have meant. What I meant is that cultural beliefs and education might play role in it - if someone believes, that killing someone else is merely putting him at the beggining of a new cycle, it is easier to do than simply end someone's existence. Look at eating habits - most of the world eat beef, while for many Indians it is sacrilege, same with eating pork and muslims or eating dogs in the West...
@@lahvancz I follow your point but respectfully disagree. The Norse Vikings had a strong martial culture, as had the Greeks, Romans, Azetcs, Mongols etc etc. All committed awful atrocities in their time. Aztec, Norse, and pre-Buddhist Asian religions certainly favoured limited human sacrifice, and Christianity wins, hands down, for historical intolerance. In the end, however, nearly all the major world religions have a strong taboo on killing. My experience with living several years in Japan and spending a lot of time in China and the Middle East is that while cultures can be very different, the same fundamental desires, hopes and dreams exist in us all! What happened in Japan in the 20th century was initially a colonialism no better or worse than that in Europe, followed in the 1930s by a dark descent into a totalitarian fascist state similar to Germany and Italy.
While I cannot excuse what was done during and before WW2, this "victory" dance never happened. What took place was more or less a traditional military parade through the city. This is a movie after all.
@@かこうえん-l4l The director created this scene to try guiding the audience to understand that Japanese soldiers were also normal people who would mourn their dead colleagues.
@@rol8062 日本人は祭りで踊ったり太鼓を叩きますが、葬儀で踊ったり太鼓を叩きません Japanese people dance and beat drums at festivals, but Japanese people do not dance and beat drums at funerals
When I first watched ATLA as a kid I thought for sure the story of war with the Fire Nation was symbolic of the Sino-Japanese war that started in 1937. Seeing scenes like these reenacted really drives home that I must have been correct to some degree. The Fire Nation is clearly inspired by Imperial Japan to some degree. Beyond just the general aesthetic, the dance moves of the soldiers really seems reminiscent of fire bending techniques and postures.
That is Japanese soldiers dance to send fallen comrades the last trip to heaven. They do not look like the happy dancers we see on TV. In Real history, they didn't do this right after the city fall to their hands. The first thing they did was trying to build a "local Chinese government", invited a lot of famous Chinese people to join that government. They didn't dance on the street, the lest thing they wanted to do was scare all the survivors to flee.
In real history they collected a lot of people stand near the city gate wave both Japanese flags and Chinese flags to welcome them. Army Officers promised peace and order. Said they came here not for occupy China but for resist the western influence, They are the people care about China's future and willing to take actions and protect yellow people. They didn't do weird things like this dance
An amazing scene from a great movie. Even as a piece of theater it represents the Japanese approach to the war pretty accurately. Flags and drums of samurai, all marching in a predatory-yet-methodical march into the city. Their movements in the march mimic hunters stalking through tall grass, building up to the blasts (claps) of gunfire. They are a medieval host taking a city and subjecting it to their will. But beginning at 4:02 we see a lowest-ranked modern soldier being asked to celebrate like afellow conquering feudal warrior. The film does a great job of showing the respectable soldiering that was needed to capture a capital city, while making no excuses for the barbarity that followed that success. Beginning at 4:02 we see a modern day soldier who isn't seduced by the flag waving, drum beating-attempt to convince him that his feudal ancestors would think of this as a noble victory. Instead he and his comrades murdered, raped, and robbed, like conquerors
Just like what Russian soldiers are doing right now on Ukrainians. Well, a lot of them are war criminals. But I'm sure there are Russians with noble spirits, good people even in Russian army. Some of them do not support the invasion.
@@jasonl4218 Yes, there was no name for the Indonesian nation during World War 2... because our nation fought alone against the ferocity of colonialists from the VOC, the Netherlands, England and Japan... and the world must know... our nation is a nation that fought alone...
@@chipid4571 Not really true, there is no concept of Indonesia nation in WW2. Java, Sumatra and Borneo have been fighting among themselves for a thousand years until the Brits and Dutch came. If the Brits and Dutch are not here, most likely during WW2 you would not fight and join Imperial Japan and end up at the losing side.
omg calm down karen no one is asaying the maascare didnt happen or anyone is celebrating it. well the japs did at that time and they have appologised for it numerous times. The chinese are no saints either their leader MAO killed more people than the whole world war 2 combined. so chill war is bad and people who come after the war are also equally bad case in point mao and stalin
In July 1937, the Japanese Empire launched a full-scale invasion of China. In December of the same year, the Japanese army attacked Nanjing, the capital of China at the time, and was fiercely resisted by the Chinese army. However, due to the disparity in military and national strength between the two sides, China lost the battle and the capital. After entering Nanjing, the Japanese army massacred Chinese prisoners of war and civilians from December 13, 1937 to February 1938 (the International Military Tribunal for the Far East determined that the serious massacre lasted for 7 weeks, of which the first 3 weeks were particularly severe). There was also a large amount of looting and rape of civilians. In 1948, the International Military Tribunal for the Far East and the Nanjing Military Tribunal estimated that more than 200,000 Chinese were killed by the Japanese army in the Nanjing Massacre. Since the Nanjing Military Tribunal trial in 1947, the general consensus in China is that about 300,000 people died in the massacre. This movie describes this tragic history, and its name is "Nanjing, Nanjing".
At my hometown in North-East China there's a pile of 10,000 skeletons which are the remains of slave miners killed by the Japanese, and a museum of various corpses frozen underground or died during torture. My hometown is a minor coal town with a very small population that no one cares, and the Japanese killed off half of its population, forcing the other half to do hard labor, digging the coal empty and transferring it to Puyi.
At the beginning of the clip, lot of men, each carry a box-like item on their chests probably contain fallen soldier ashes. An elderly friend who was a former Japanese soldier during WWII in China told me, years ago, he quite often carried container with the fallen soldier’s ash hung from his neck. And sometime hung many boxes around his neck as to keepsake in order to send the ashes back to Japan later.
Japan believes it is confident in its history, but you should immediately see and think about the wounds Japan has done to Asian countries such as China, Korea, and Vietnam. I remember that Japan has not yet apologized for the Nanjing massacre, but it denies the facts about the wounds to Korea and Southeast Asian countries as if it were a lie. Japan doesn't know how cowardly the world looks at Japan. Of course, Korea also has a past where they went to Vietnam and killed civilians. The Korean government should properly apologize and compensate. But it still seems to take time. However, since there are many movements in Korea that need to be confident in front of history, there will be a little more change. All countries must work for their people, respect each country and live with each other. A good history takes a lot of time and courage from people.
oh name any nation or race that HASNT spilled blood for its own bullshit reasons,no one in this world is innocent,and no one has the right to take any moral high ground
@@aestheticswim3397 True,other countries probably also have committed atrocities that they probably wont admit and then proceeds to seek apologies from other countries lol.Its all about who has the biggest victim mentality at this point
- Funny how you talk about what Japanese did in Vietnam, While Korean did the same things, and acted the same way. - Korean did nothing in Vietnam. Just like Japanese did nothing in Korean. 🙂
@Deenie Beenie the ONLY thing that I am interested in this video is that Awa odori is not what the Imperial Army would perform. My people is suffered genocide during WWII by Croatians, Muslims and Bulgars and 1999. by NATO.We lost 60% of our population in XXth century but it is not the subject related to this video.
Awa odori is also pretty specific to Shikoku (not that it matters but most of the units in the Nanking campaign were from northern Kyushu and also Aizu)..really completely inappropriate thing to show for this scene. I think it's rooted in misunderstanding of Japanese culture by the film maker
@@ikanzaki9293 This movie is a state funded propaganda.They not care about the truth,just how to make an interesting and attractive movie.They are not the first to do something like that.Everybody do that...just few of us care about the truth.
a great movie. They have the full movie on YT - City of Life and Death. One of the best war movie to depict the brutality of war that vacillates between humanity and utter brutalness
Nothing wrong for kawaii parts. As long as people are happy. The only sad part is Japanese had getting rid of their past but Germans are still suffering for the past. Well, CCP China's cruelty and ugliness helped Japan a lot. Maybe Russia's cruelty also will help Germany to become a normal country soon. Considering what they are doing in Ukraine.
The tyranny of guilt in Germany has no end. They’ve used it to finally dismantle the rest of Europe and destroy western civ. The 1917 Bolshevik take over of Russia failed after tens of millions of Russian and Ukrainian Christians died at their hands. These outside, foreign agitators are back at it again to destroy Russia and depopulate the Ukraine so they can buy up real estate for pennies on the dollar. Most people know who they are, but for the most part it’s criminal in most western countries to say who, and soon will be a crime in the U.S. Your enemy are those who you are not allowed to talk about, but this ilk has the “chutzpah” to define everyone else’s identities.
That is a slightly changed "卍“ or “卐” Which is from Buddhism, means eternal peace, good fortune, Balance and harmony. been used by a lot of Japanese clans
Nanjing Massacre During the Japanese occupation of China, an estimated 30 million Chinese were killed. In the Nanjing Massacre,at least 369,366 people were slaughtered and 80,000 women were raped by Japanese invasion troops. The horror began on the morning of December 13,1937, when the Japanese Imperial Army captured Nanjing, which was then China's capital. Thousands of women were raped by Japanese soldiers; death was frequently the penalty for the slightest resistance by a victim or members of her family. Many women were killed after the act and their bodies mutilated. For the next six weeks, while horrific rape continued, wholesale murder of male civilians was conducted with the apparent sanction of the Japanese high command.
Although we are friendly to Japan, it does not mean that we have forgotten history, and everyone in China will not forget the Japanese war of aggression against China.
Japan is a country that does not recognize its cruelty during the world war, including in Indonesia and China as well as several other countries, Indonesia was controlled for 3.5 years, our ancestors experienced war crimes and Japanese cruelty, much crueler than the Dutch, Japan created slavery in Indonesia named Romusha, he was crueler than any bastard, the Dutch built several systems including radio transmitters, railway systems, petroleum, but the Japanese just came and destroyed them, even robbing what the Dutch had built, even in modern times the Japanese education system doesn't teach history their country and Japanese students automatically don't know about the dark history and cruelty of their leaders until now
logika simpel masak ngak paham kamu jugak ngak bakal mengauki dan menceritakan hal buruk yang pernah kamu lakukan ke anak mu sama jugak negara lagi pula sejarah indonesia jugak ngak di tulis dan di ajarkan di sekolah berdadarkan fakta😅 tapi di edit dan di pilih-pilih sesuai kebutuhan negara kalau ngak di edit dan di pilih-pilih dan langsung di sajikan berdasarkan fakta, ahh jangan di bahas😫 negara lain jugak melakukan hal yang sama,beberapa hal buruk yang ngak baik dan positif bagi negara bakal di sekip😂 jangan naif dek😅
They know lol, I’ve yet to meet to meet a Japanese person that is unaware of the bad things Japan has done in the past. They don’t feel good about it. It’s a common talking point for politicians in former colonies to get people riled up By the way, 25,000 Japanese soldiers after the war stayed in Indonesia and fought alongside Indonesians against the Dutch for the independence of Indonesia. Most of those soldiers stayed and assimilated into Indonesia.
I probably will get downvoted on this reply. As a former soldier...showing respect to fallen comrades means more than allegiance to some stupid government thousands of miles away.
This is not historically accurate, it is a metaphor of some sort from movie directors' imagination. Japanese army would not waste resources on this in such a war situation.
This is one of the best movie scenes I have ever watched. I stumbled on it last night and kept watching it over and over. I didn't know this movie existed. I am going to watch the full movie. 👍👍👍
A sensationalised portrayal by the (Chinese made, no surprise there) film about the actual ceremony, which was more of a normal military parade with them bowing in the emperor's direction a few times. I'm told this particular ceremony is actually a funeral or memorial one for their fallen troops, not a victory one.
What Japan did in China was a War Crime on parr with Nazi Germany. What the Imperial Army did in Nanking managed to cram the horrors of years of Dachau into a month and then some. BUT; This ceremony/victory dance never happened. The film makers took an old Japanese festival dance and transposed it into a celebration of the slaughter done in Nanking. It is important to tell the truth of what happened in China. It is terrible enough without inventing things that didn't happen.
"Buddy you're a boy make a big noise Playin' in the street gonna be a big man some day You got mud on yo' face You big disgrace Kickin' your can all over the place Singin' We will we will rock you We will we will rock you" Watch it again with that in mind.
We will never see the likes of such men again in our time, men willing to sacrifice themselves for their country and a living God. The totality of their brutality was fierce, they would fight to the last man if necessary! It was a Matter of honour! Something that we don’t see much of today!
Today's Ukrainian soldiers are as hard as them, but fight for protect what they love which they know as justice. I would say that is more meaningful. Doing wrong things would eat you up from inside and burn your human side dry. Just like today's Russian soldiers.
It's strange how many people believe at face value a movie made by China about this incident. Of course it will have a bias, it is only natural. The truth is somewhere between the two sides.
My grad father also know us lolo in tagalog tell a story about that kind of victory dance when the japanese conquered half of the philippines during world war 2. But it cut short becouse when they were in the middle of the dance? 3 F4F wild cat arrived and immedietely attacked them and boomed them. He said that the dead & wounded are scattered around the place Many are asking for help.
They are dancing for the past aways in the war as they are telling the spirits to go forward to where they are supposed to, not celebrating for the victory. They are making this movie to raise hatred.
a nazi party member in nanjing saved hundreds of students, and he recorded the massacre in his diary, a movie was made about this dark episode. it was regarded as the Shindler's list of china, in a much ironic but horrific fashion.
"A frightening scene, I can't imagine whats going through the minds of the remaining chinese captives watching. " xD They were probably as afraid as the Tibetan people were when the chinese invaded and occupied Tibet.
THere very well may have been a victory dance and celebration - but tis is not it 0 this so obviously staged and is patently s propaganda film shot in a staged environment in Japan some where - if you want a debate then don't use these types of re-enactments.
@@Lesimes-2055 Yeah china used to the the neighborhood bully. Calling itself "middle kingdom", calling everyone else "barbarians". They'd got what's coming to them.
It's a shot of the movie《Nanking!Nanking!》,not the real documentary l,but it have historical orgin.Form this movie ,you will know why do Chinese will never forgive the Nazi of Japan and the Japanese who never adimit this period of invasion in world war II!
When you win as Japan in HOI4
Hearts Of Iron 4 yeah thats ri- Banzai! ✋Banzai! ✋ Banzai! ✋
This is not a victory dance.
This is the funeral dance.
I'm pretty sure this is the formal and official japanese entry into China, correct me if I'm wrong.
@@lick3227 This is an inspiration of Obon Matsuri festival of Awa Odori dance from Shikoku (as I have heard), so no he is right this is not a victory dance or war dance but rather a funeral.
@@SuzutakeJP thanks for the info my guy.
@@SuzutakeJP Awa Odori dance wasn't a funeral dance but rather a form of dance that derivate from an ancestor worship period
And yet most of us only come here to play this at 2x speed and laugh
The stark contrast between the national identity and mentality of Japan before the bomb and after is crazy.
I prefer the old one, the new one is a bit softcore for me.
They were getting a little too big for their britches.
@coinínbán so they've weakened them in order to conquer them. You know, with all the manipulative shite going on nowadays, and how fucking soft we're getting, and with everything that's going on with the UN, depopulation, world state etc I wouldn't mind a bit of nationalism again.
The allies didn't punish the Axis because of their war crimes and they wanted to control the world. They punished them so THEY could commit war crimes and rule the world. But the difference is they do it while blinding their population with consumerism.
@@memegod4433 You prefer it from afar. Very much afar. Everyone loves talking about nationalistic glories perched on their sofa, in the comfort of capitalist liberalism. If you were a slave-labourer in some Japanese concentration camp, you'd talk differently.
Friend: *clutches a 1v5*
Me and the boys: 1:50
when you steal others comment... I get it that joke is gold but not when repeated
@@disnuts4665 Honda dealership employees when they sell a Civic🤣
Oof
Come on man be original
@@HelloThere-bj9rw ok then
Title is a bit misleading. This isn't a victory dance, it's a form of venerating their fallen brethren. A sort of funeral procession, historically at least. The movie may differ (it's China-produced after all).
@Rando Namo Here you go: ua-cam.com/video/pimugZ_TthY/v-deo.html
This is from the Japanese 'Day of the Dead', where Buddhists celebrate people that have passed. There's no footage of the military doing this back then because it's a religious practice (that was considered a regular thing) and they were more concerned with recording themselves being strong for propaganda. The movie's dance seems more intense and solemn because 1. it's the military, 2. they've seen some messed up stuff, and 3. it's a movie.
And yet most of us only come here to play this at 2x speed and laugh
have no conscience
so it is a dance glorifying their war criminals
@@OrionSlaveGirlUWU I'll have you know I have nothing but respect for His Imperial Japanese Emperor's Very Own Special Elite Ladyboy Death Detachment.
I find it very anime. Very otaku. Iro iro arigatou gozaimashita.
The Fire Nation when they took Ba-Sing-Se
The Fire Nation was literally modeled after Japan - the Sun Nation.
私は日本人でアバターシリーズ全部見ましたが、火の国はどうみても日本がモデルだと思いました
島国だし火山だらけだし、過去にアジア各国を支配していたこと考えると
昔の名前が日の元の国ですから
@VS257 Originally, yes, but then the creators kinda backtracked and also included other Asian influences, including Thai, so it wouldn't be seen as anti-Japanese.
I disagree, all the other countries in the show also has mixes of other Asian (and in some instances non-Asian) cultures in it. I do think it is mostly modelers after Japan (similar to how the Earth Kingdom was broadly modeled after China) but I do think all the respective countries were made to be mostly unique and not based entirely off of one country or another. @@TheManWithThePsychoGun
@noco7243 The clothes worn by Fire Nation citizens have more similarities with traditional Thai clothes than with traditional Japanese clothes. Fire Nation cuisine is hot and spicy, like Thai foods, while Japanese cuisine tends to be pretty mild.
new Zealand enters the rugby world cup with the haka japan "hold my sake"
Honda dealership after selling a car
😂😂😂
so
Wkakakak
You know I saw a Honda with the license plate #666 the other day. Never realized the #AntiChrist drives a Honda! 😅
*1940s - Most Hated Country*
*2000s - Most Polite Country*
When I was a teenager..I was scared by my freinds.. in my 20s people laugh at me 🤣
@@kck0611George Armstrong Custard also a devil
Most hated country...
Germany has entered the chat.
@@kck0611No. You are racist.
@@Herla-CyningExcept no
And that kids, was how the Japanese introduced RnB (Rhythm & Bass) to the World. Good times, son. Good times.
If BTS had any testosterone :-
XD
Isn’t one of them in the Korean Army Special Forces?
No wonder it's a desi chapri inserting BTS in a non related video.
Reminds me of the North Korea squad vs South Korea squad pictures lol
idk why these indian men are so insecure. these guys always mention about bts and it looks gay.
I think this is more of a pseudo-religious ceremony rather than a victory March. Their victory parade in the Philkipines is much different compared to this and more western appearing
I think the point of the film is to show the determination and terrifyingness of the Japanese for their ruthless and unmercifulness in the nanking siege via this dance performance.
That’s why there’s soldiers with white boxes around their necks. They are carrying the ashes of their dead war brothers.
@Taurus Tong perfect
Not pseudo
Yeah it’s a funeral…
For those who don't know, this is a 2009 Chinese movie filmed from a Japanese soldier's angle.
Having a victory dance through the city you just pillaged is kind of a power move.
卒塔婆あったり米に箸が刺してあるからこれは葬式の踊りだと思います。葬式で踊ることはないけど所詮韓国か中国がつくった映画だしなぁ。
@@天安門事件習近平プーさん maybe reflect why they want to portray imperial Japan like this?
It's a funeral dance
@@天安門事件習近平プーさん 30万人の民間人が虐殺されたことをなかったようにしたいのです結構、改心していない日本人、歴史は証明して、同じことがあなたたちに降りてきます。加害者は忘れることもできますが、被害者は忘れません
@@天安門事件習近平プーさん 是的··您没有看错！·这是 你们日本人在屠杀30多万中国南京人之后，为了 纪念你们攻城和杀戮中死去的日本军士亡灵的舞蹈 ，这种祭祀舞蹈，我们中国古代也有··············并且··我们在千年前···就是以杀死十几万人 为一祭！ 哈哈···你们学的很好，但 ··你们没学到骨髓，教是教不会的···
素晴らしいシーン。このシーンを観るだけでこの映画は"鑑賞に値しない"と判断できるという点において非常に優れている
Historically, the sack of a city was until recently an incredibly brutal affair. Some more Brutal than others. In medieval times it was common for a large proportion of the men to be murdered, the women to be abused, and many of the inhabitants sold into slavery. But even by those standards, what happened in Nanjing was chilling.
Waging of war in Asia compared to the West is vastly different. Much more brutal. You might check what Japanese did during Sengoku Jidai or Chinese way during their rebelion suppression campagings. Have you ever hear about Taiping rebellion? Most Westeners never had. Live loss only second to WWII. I do not know if this is because vast population or because their faith in reincarnation, where killing is not that big deal compared to Western understanding of the world.
@@lahvancz I think it is important not to get trapped by the fallacy that the Asian mind is somehow different to that of the West. We are human! The Taiping rebellion was extraordinarily brutal. But so was the 30-year war just after the reformation (smaller death toll, but only because it occurred over a smaller overall population)! The extermination of the indigenous populations of the Americas and Australia, along with the subjugation of Africa, was equally pretty brutal over that time period. Some rules for war did start to appear more humane in Europe by the end of the 19th century - but it was only for western Europeans vs western Europeans. By WWII, arguably, things were improving in some theatres, but that was over a relatively short timescale compared to the previous few thousand years of military culture.
@@patrickdegenaar9495 That is not what I have meant. What I meant is that cultural beliefs and education might play role in it - if someone believes, that killing someone else is merely putting him at the beggining of a new cycle, it is easier to do than simply end someone's existence. Look at eating habits - most of the world eat beef, while for many Indians it is sacrilege, same with eating pork and muslims or eating dogs in the West...
@@lahvancz I follow your point but respectfully disagree. The Norse Vikings had a strong martial culture, as had the Greeks, Romans, Azetcs, Mongols etc etc. All committed awful atrocities in their time. Aztec, Norse, and pre-Buddhist Asian religions certainly favoured limited human sacrifice, and Christianity wins, hands down, for historical intolerance. In the end, however, nearly all the major world religions have a strong taboo on killing. My experience with living several years in Japan and spending a lot of time in China and the Middle East is that while cultures can be very different, the same fundamental desires, hopes and dreams exist in us all! What happened in Japan in the 20th century was initially a colonialism no better or worse than that in Europe, followed in the 1930s by a dark descent into a totalitarian fascist state similar to Germany and Italy.
@@patrickdegenaar9495 Thank you for explanation. At least we can all agree that war is bad regardless how or why it is prosecuted...
While I cannot excuse what was done during and before WW2, this "victory" dance never happened. What took place was more or less a traditional military parade through the city. This is a movie after all.
中国人の監督はインド映画のように仕上げたかったのでしょう
このゴミの様な映画に少しでも日本人がかかわっていればもっと正確な歴史描写が可能だったでしょう
@@かこうえん-l4l The director created this scene to try guiding the audience to understand that Japanese soldiers were also normal people who would mourn their dead colleagues.
@@rol8062 日本人は祭りで踊ったり太鼓を叩きますが、葬儀で踊ったり太鼓を叩きません
Japanese people dance and beat drums at festivals, but Japanese people do not dance and beat drums at funerals
Gotta say, the Awa dance usually don't go this hard
When I first watched ATLA as a kid I thought for sure the story of war with the Fire Nation was symbolic of the Sino-Japanese war that started in 1937. Seeing scenes like these reenacted really drives home that I must have been correct to some degree. The Fire Nation is clearly inspired by Imperial Japan to some degree. Beyond just the general aesthetic, the dance moves of the soldiers really seems reminiscent of fire bending techniques and postures.
3：45 У китайцев такие лица каменные как будто уже знают что сейчас с ними сделают Японцы просто аллюзия какая-то на азиатскую версию "Иди и смотри".
un popor arogant, care se crede coborator din zeul soarelui.
Вообщето японские фашисты убили 37млн китайцев во время войны. Это больше чем 35млн советских граждан, со стороны немецких фашистов.
Танец красивый.
@@Adam270978 日本の事をよく知らない人達が、現代も日本で行われている「阿波踊り」と「盆踊り」を参考にして変な映画が完成したのだと思います。
This scene is unfortunately entirely fictional.
Yes, they didn't dance.
That's a shame really.
Why?
It’s made in china😅
I know this is probably fucked up but i want a loop of just the fucking drums damn
There is clean version of it at the start, so by looping that over and over with any software it'll be just that
the mystical aura is so strong
When you as a kensei clutch a 1v5 death match against an entirely Wu Lin team.
🤣
The dance in this war zone setting is really scary as if the ghost of the dead actually were dancing!
That is Japanese soldiers dance to send fallen comrades the last trip to heaven. They do not look like the happy dancers we see on TV. In Real history, they didn't do this right after the city fall to their hands. The first thing they did was trying to build a "local Chinese government", invited a lot of famous Chinese people to join that government. They didn't dance on the street, the lest thing they wanted to do was scare all the survivors to flee.
In real history they collected a lot of people stand near the city gate wave both Japanese flags and Chinese flags to welcome them. Army Officers promised peace and order. Said they came here not for occupy China but for resist the western influence, They are the people care about China's future and willing to take actions and protect yellow people. They didn't do weird things like this dance
Play it at 2x speed. It's hilarious, like an episode of Looney Tunes
こんなプロパガンダ映画を信じるバカがいる事にびっくりです、あなたたちは本当に無知ですよ。
An amazing scene from a great movie. Even as a piece of theater it represents the Japanese approach to the war pretty accurately. Flags and drums of samurai, all marching in a predatory-yet-methodical march into the city. Their movements in the march mimic hunters stalking through tall grass, building up to the blasts (claps) of gunfire. They are a medieval host taking a city and subjecting it to their will. But beginning at 4:02 we see a lowest-ranked modern soldier being asked to celebrate like afellow conquering feudal warrior. The film does a great job of showing the respectable soldiering that was needed to capture a capital city, while making no excuses for the barbarity that followed that success. Beginning at 4:02 we see a modern day soldier who isn't seduced by the flag waving, drum beating-attempt to convince him that his feudal ancestors would think of this as a noble victory. Instead he and his comrades murdered, raped, and robbed, like conquerors
The Japanese don't rape
@@theultrabasedputin9099 comfort women
Just like what Russian soldiers are doing right now on Ukrainians. Well, a lot of them are war criminals. But I'm sure there are Russians with noble spirits, good people even in Russian army. Some of them do not support the invasion.
@@theultrabasedputin9099 Are you for real nitwit??
@@theultrabasedputin9099they are the worst vile creatures on earth, I'd say the only people whom the nuclear bombs are justified.
World War 2...Indonesia was a country that fought alone without allies. The world must understand the colonialism of the Netherlands and Japan!!!
there is no nation name indonesia in world war 2
@@jasonl4218 Yes, there was no name for the Indonesian nation during World War 2... because our nation fought alone against the ferocity of colonialists from the VOC, the Netherlands, England and Japan... and the world must know... our nation is a nation that fought alone...
@@chipid4571 Not really true, there is no concept of Indonesia nation in WW2. Java, Sumatra and Borneo have been fighting among themselves for a thousand years until the Brits and Dutch came. If the Brits and Dutch are not here, most likely during WW2 you would not fight and join Imperial Japan and end up at the losing side.
@@OnMusicSoon1Or joining the fight as the winner...or not joining any side as neutral power, who knows...
negaramu belum ada pas perang dunia ke-2, badut overproud.
"We shall await you at Minatogawa."
Hahaha
3:43 damn, that looks so hopeless. We once had that looks too. Forgiven, not forgotten.
a moment of silence for the people of Nanjing who were victims of the massacre and mass rape of the Japanese army
omg calm down karen no one is asaying the maascare didnt happen or anyone is celebrating it. well the japs did at that time and they have appologised for it numerous times. The chinese are no saints either their leader MAO killed more people than the whole world war 2 combined. so chill
war is bad and people who come after the war are also equally bad case in point mao and stalin
1:49
BANZAI! 🇯🇵⛩️
@@SørenZeleaMishima Nazist, come to China to say this. You are a coward and mentally retarded person.
@@SørenZeleaMishimabanzai ur m
Is this from like a movie or something if so please tell me what movie
In July 1937, the Japanese Empire launched a full-scale invasion of China. In December of the same year, the Japanese army attacked Nanjing, the capital of China at the time, and was fiercely resisted by the Chinese army. However, due to the disparity in military and national strength between the two sides, China lost the battle and the capital. After entering Nanjing, the Japanese army massacred Chinese prisoners of war and civilians from December 13, 1937 to February 1938 (the International Military Tribunal for the Far East determined that the serious massacre lasted for 7 weeks, of which the first 3 weeks were particularly severe). There was also a large amount of looting and rape of civilians. In 1948, the International Military Tribunal for the Far East and the Nanjing Military Tribunal estimated that more than 200,000 Chinese were killed by the Japanese army in the Nanjing Massacre. Since the Nanjing Military Tribunal trial in 1947, the general consensus in China is that about 300,000 people died in the massacre. This movie describes this tragic history, and its name is "Nanjing, Nanjing".
City of life and death
中国のプロパガンダ映画です。
日本軍が南京市に入る前の人口は20万人以下でした。
日本軍は軍隊として規律が厳しく、略奪や強姦や一般市民の殺害は厳しく禁じられていました。
日本軍が南京市に入ってテロリストを駆逐した1か月後には治安が回復して26万人に増えました。
死んだはずの30万人は中国の工作機関が作り出した嘘でしかありません。
At my hometown in North-East China there's a pile of 10,000 skeletons which are the remains of slave miners killed by the Japanese, and a museum of various corpses frozen underground or died during torture. My hometown is a minor coal town with a very small population that no one cares, and the Japanese killed off half of its population, forcing the other half to do hard labor, digging the coal empty and transferring it to Puyi.
1:59
Me and the Boys Dancing Of Freedom Agaisnt School
YEA.
JUST YES.
At the beginning of the clip, lot of men, each carry a box-like item on their chests probably contain fallen soldier ashes. An elderly friend who was a former Japanese soldier during WWII in China told me, years ago, he quite often carried container with the fallen soldier’s ash hung from his neck. And sometime hung many boxes around his neck as to keepsake in order to send the ashes back to Japan later.
A very dark episode in world history. We all have to learn from the past.
Do you know:
These Japanese Soldiers Victory Marching are Japanese Prison Guards
Thx for the info
I think that makes it a little bit worse
and how do you know that
1:50 with full respect to this video (not the history fact), at this moment I thought they were going to dance " we will we will rock you"...
Does anyone know what are they screaming through the dance?
Japan believes it is confident in its history, but you should immediately see and think about the wounds Japan has done to Asian countries such as China, Korea, and Vietnam. I remember that Japan has not yet apologized for the Nanjing massacre, but it denies the facts about the wounds to Korea and Southeast Asian countries as if it were a lie. Japan doesn't know how cowardly the world looks at Japan. Of course, Korea also has a past where they went to Vietnam and killed civilians. The Korean government should properly apologize and compensate. But it still seems to take time. However, since there are many movements in Korea that need to be confident in front of history, there will be a little more change.
All countries must work for their people, respect each country and live with each other.
A good history takes a lot of time and courage from people.
oh name any nation or race that HASNT spilled blood for its own bullshit reasons,no one in this world is innocent,and no one has the right to take any moral high ground
@@aestheticswim3397 True,other countries probably also have committed atrocities that they probably wont admit and then proceeds to seek apologies from other countries lol.Its all about who has the biggest victim mentality at this point
And how about the western colonizer . Dont you see the image of this western troops hahahaha
nobody cares and the weak should fear the strong. ibe hiroshi did nothing wrong and so did hirohito
- Funny how you talk about what Japanese did in Vietnam, While Korean did the same things, and acted the same way.
- Korean did nothing in Vietnam. Just like Japanese did nothing in Korean. 🙂
This is funeral ceremony based in traditional Samurai tradition.
This is anti Japanese movie.This dance is Awa odori - BUDDHIST Dance.I doubt Japanese Imperial Army would do this.
@Deenie Beenie I don't care what Chinese think about this movie.It is their show.
@Deenie Beenie the ONLY thing that I am interested in this video is that Awa odori is not what the Imperial Army would perform.
My people is suffered genocide during WWII by Croatians, Muslims and Bulgars and 1999. by NATO.We lost 60% of our population in XXth century but it is not the subject related to this video.
@Deenie Beenie you missed the point.It is insulting for Japanese Imperial Army to be in the contest with anything Buddhist .
Awa odori is also pretty specific to Shikoku (not that it matters but most of the units in the Nanking campaign were from northern Kyushu and also Aizu)..really completely inappropriate thing to show for this scene. I think it's rooted in misunderstanding of Japanese culture by the film maker
@@ikanzaki9293 This movie is a state funded propaganda.They not care about the truth,just how to make an interesting and attractive movie.They are not the first to do something like that.Everybody do that...just few of us care about the truth.
When 媽你媽 joins your chat
ไม่กล้าพิมพ์ครับ😢
a great movie. They have the full movie on YT - City of Life and Death. One of the best war movie to depict the brutality of war that vacillates between humanity and utter brutalness
Thank you. I was looking for the title of the movie
We Germans, and the Japanese used to be so badass. 70 years of consequent brainwashing
and we are all whimsical Kawaii - go green softies...
Nothing wrong for kawaii parts. As long as people are happy. The only sad part is Japanese had getting rid of their past but Germans are still suffering for the past. Well, CCP China's cruelty and ugliness helped Japan a lot. Maybe Russia's cruelty also will help Germany to become a normal country soon. Considering what they are doing in Ukraine.
You were never badass . Just murderous .
The tyranny of guilt in Germany has no end. They’ve used it to finally dismantle the rest of Europe and destroy western civ. The 1917 Bolshevik take over of Russia failed after tens of millions of Russian and Ukrainian Christians died at their hands. These outside, foreign agitators are back at it again to destroy Russia and depopulate the Ukraine so they can buy up real estate for pennies on the dollar. Most people know who they are, but for the most part it’s criminal in most western countries to say who, and soon will be a crime in the U.S. Your enemy are those who you are not allowed to talk about, but this ilk has the “chutzpah” to define everyone else’s identities.
@@武當山-f6d
Bro we're doomed at least Japan didn't accept thousands upon upon thousands of migrants.
Anyone know the historical context behind the dance and drums tune? Or is this just Hollywood flare?
This is not from Hollywood.
日本軍の南京占領式典についての描写について
陸川監督は，セバスチャン国際映画祭での公式会見の式場で，記者からの「どこまでが真実 で，どこまでがフィクションなのか?」との質問に対し，「この映画は企画の立ち上げから完成 まで 4 年かかってます。その間，私は何度も日中を往復し，ある元日本兵にもインタビューしたり， 彼らが残した日記や膨大な数のプライベート写真などを徹底的にリサーチしました。なので，あ くまで真実がベース。唯一，フィクションがあるとすれば映画の後半，南京を政略した日本兵た ちが儀式をするシーンのみ。あれは(天皇を崇める)メタファーとして取り入れました」と答え ている。 では，その南京占領を祝う式典はどう描かれているだろうか。(少なくともおそらく今の日本 人から見て，)いかにも古臭く，時代がかっていて，異様なものに見える。少なくとも筆者はそ う感じた。この場面を見た中国人(日本人以外の者)の多くは，日本が(むろんマイナスの意味 で)異質な(「異様な」というべきか。)国だということを強く感じるであろうと思う。 この式典の場面は，天皇を崇める日本を描く意味があったというが，実は，南京入城の式典は 1937 年 12 月 17 日に現実に行われており，ニュース映画・ラジオ・新聞・雑誌を通し，日本でも 非常に大々的に報道されている12)。実際のところ，映画における描写は，史実と比べてどうであ ろうか。 実際の式典の様子は，松井石根大将の陣中日記によると，「中山門より国民政府にいたる間両 側には両軍代表部隊，各師団の指揮のもとに堵列，予はこれを閲兵しつつ馬を進め，両軍司令官 随行す。未曾有の盛時，感慨無量なり。午後二時過ぎ国民政府に着，下関より入場せる長谷川長 官と会し，祝詞を交換したるのち，一同前庭に集合，国旗掲揚式につづいて東方(つまり東京の 皇居:近藤注)に対し遥拝式をおこない，予の発声にて，大元帥陛下(天皇:近藤注)の万歳を 三唱す。感慨いよいよ迫りついに第二声を発するをえず，さらに勇気を鼓舞して明朗大声に第三 声を揚げ，一同これに和しもって歴史的式典を終了す。」13)といったものであった。映画におい ては，そこまで明確で目立った天皇崇拝の式典とはなっていない。実際の天皇崇拝実際の式典を そのまま描いた方が，よほど明確に，日本を批判的に，つまり遅れた異様な天皇制軍国主義国家 として描くことができたように思われる。皮肉なことに，当時の現実の日本は，場合によっては 監督の想像を超えるほどの天皇中心の軍国主義国家であり，映画のこのシーンは，日本を実際の それ以上に痛烈に批判するものとはなっていないといえそうである。
ngu.repo.nii.ac.jp/record/527/files/genbun_vol2201_04.pdf
👍
今でも日本は日本国憲法で国民の象徴となっている、天皇は空気のような存在であり、普段意識することは少ないが、なくなると非常に苦しく、空気をありがたく思う。
そういうものであると思う。
Does anyone know what the sign on the drums at 1.23 means? I have been trying to find this out for years.
That is a slightly changed "卍“ or “卐” Which is from Buddhism, means eternal peace, good fortune, Balance and harmony. been used by a lot of Japanese clans
it’s called 三つ巴(mitsudomoe kamon)
And now they dance for pokemon lol ..
Nanjing Massacre During the Japanese occupation of China, an estimated 30 million Chinese were killed. In the Nanjing Massacre,at least 369,366 people were slaughtered and 80,000 women were raped by Japanese invasion troops. The horror began on the morning of December 13,1937, when the Japanese Imperial Army captured Nanjing, which was then China's capital. Thousands of women were raped by Japanese soldiers; death was frequently the penalty for the slightest resistance by a victim or members of her family. Many women were killed after the act and their bodies mutilated. For the next six weeks, while horrific rape continued, wholesale murder of male civilians was conducted with the apparent sanction of the Japanese high command.
資料ないけどね
@@天安門事件習近平プーさんまず、原爆で死んだ日本人は誰一人として濡れ衣を着せられなかった。 彼らは生きているべきだ、第二次世界大戦中は悪魔だった。 見つけた史料をあなたに証明することを許可します。
@@天安門事件習近平プーさん南京大虐殺において30万人が犠牲になったことを証明できる関連史料について。
南京大虐殺で30万人以上の犠牲者数は十分な史料的証拠によって裏付けられています。
1. 慈善団体及び組織の遺体収容記録：
- 世界赤十字会南京分会：遺体43123体を収容し、データは『民国二十六年から三十四年までの慈善事業報告書』に由来します。
- 世界赤十字会八卦洲分会：会長の劉蓝田、責任副会長の趙静仁などが中華総会に提出した書簡によると、洲の江岸沿いで敵艦の機関銃に撃たれて死亡した者は184名、沿江両岸の浮き屍は1218体、江中から打ち上げられた遺体は157体で、合計1559体を収容しました。
- 南京市崇善堂：戦後、戦犯裁判軍事法廷に提出された統計表によると、1937年12月下旬から1938年4月上旬まで、市街地で遺体7548体を収容しました。4月7日から郊外地区に移り、5月1日までに合計104718体を収容し、計112266体を収容しました。
- 中国赤十字会南京分会：同会の1938年7月14日の業務報告によると、収容隊は1937年12月から下関の沿江及び和平門外付近一帯で収容作業を行い、合計22691体の軍民の遺体を収容しました。
- 南京同善堂：収容班長の劉徳才が戦犯谷寿夫の軍事法廷に出廷し証言し、同善堂が軍民の遺体7000余体を収容したことを証明しました。
- 南京代葬局：収容隊長の夏元芝が1946年10月の証言によると、首都が陥落した後、虐殺された軍民の遺体約1万余体を収容しました。
- 順安善堂：その調査登録表と当時の計件賃金による計算によると、約1500体の遺体を収容しました。
- 明德慈善堂：堂主の陳家偉が1940年12月26日に偽南京市長に送った手紙によると、1938年春に700余体の遺体を収容しました。
2. 市民グループの収容状況：
- 城西市民収容隊：盛世征、昌開運が1946年1月9日に南京市抗戦損失調査委員会に提出した文書によると、合計28730体の遺体を収容しました。
- 城南市民収容隊：市民の芮芳縁、張鴻儒、楊広才などが述べたところによると、合計7000余体の遺体を収容しました（その中に難民の遺体は約5000余体、国軍兵士の遺体は約2000余体）。
- 回民収容隊：イマームの沈錫恩の回想録によると、少なくとも400体の遺体を収容しました。
- 市民胡春庭が難民と連携：300余体の同胞の遺体を収容しました。
- 市民グループが自発的に収容：国際赤十字会南京委員会のマージ牧師がある書簡の中で、一部の遺体は親戚や友人が自発的に収容したと述べています。
3. 汪偽政権の収容記録：日本の南京特務機関が作成した収容隊の作業統計表によると、偽南京市の衛生機関、各区及び偽南京市政公署督弁などが合計1.6万余体の遺体を収容しました。
以上の各種収容ルートの収容記録を合計すると303269人になります。実際には、まだ大量の日本軍による川に投げ込まれ焼却された遺体、万人坑に埋められ破壊された遺体、民間による自発的な収容や統計されていない死難者がおり、南京大虐殺の犠牲者総数ははるかに30万人を超えています。
また、1947年3月10日、中国国防部戦犯裁判軍事法廷は『谷寿夫戦犯事件判決書』の中で、南京大虐殺で約19万余人が日本軍によって集団的に射殺・焼却され、別に15万余人が慈善団体によって収容され、犠牲者総数は30万人を超えると判定しました。これらはすべて南京大虐殺で30万人以上の犠牲者がいたことを十分に証明しています。私たちは歴史を銘記し、平和を大切にし、南京大虐殺を歪曲し否定するいかなる行為にも断固反対しなければなりません。
@@天安門事件習近平プーさん中国人民抗日戦争時代、住民の死亡は全部で3500万人ぐらいで、そのうち3100万人ぐらいは民間人です。
@@天安門事件習近平プーさんでも幸いなことに、あなたたちは今何でももともと日本人が犯した他の犯罪について話しましょう，例えば731部隊と旅順大虐殺ですが、もう関係ありません。ありません。アメリカの犬です。 アメリカの軍人が日本の娘をレイプしても罰せられることはない。
I wonder if they had a rehearsal. This is very coordinated.
You ll never see the Afghan Army celebration of life like this.... especially nowadays
This was very interesting.
Dude can someone please tell me what the name of this dance is? I've been trying to find out for a long time now
Awa odori.
The grapeist’s dance
"阿波舞"
これ作った監督はどんな思想の持ち主なんだろうね
Although we are friendly to Japan, it does not mean that we have forgotten history, and everyone in China will not forget the Japanese war of aggression against China.
南京事件 (1927年)。国交を活発に行うために作られた領事館を中国人は暴徒化して襲った。
上海日本人僧侶襲撃事件(1932年)。抗日運動家による日本人襲撃事件。
右傾化した国民の暴走が、他国が軍を送る理由になります
ウクライナにロシアが軍を送ったのも同じような理由です
ハワイやフィリピンやインドネシアやベトナムやタイやシンガポールでも同様の事を白人国家が行い1000万人以上が殺害されました
中国共産党が日本だけを侵略者とみなす洗脳教育を行っているのは有名です
支那猪
so?
it is all in history books and you Chinese are far from innocent yourselves, we in Tibet will ALWAYS remember !
@@JackTenrec-qk4zp滚远点
140年前からの日本の軍事行動が無かった場合、中国人だけでなく全てのアジア人は白人の奴隷にされていたでしょう。
白人の影響力が大きかったインドや東南アジアでは度々白人国家からの収奪によって飢饉が発生していたことをあなたは知っていますか？
大日本帝国の軍事力が無ければ中国大陸の全てが植民地にされていたでしょう。
日本人だけが危機感を持って対策を行いました。
So even the Japanese were saluting the angry Autrich back then 😂. Chanting his name even.
Japan is a country that does not recognize its cruelty during the world war, including in Indonesia and China as well as several other countries, Indonesia was controlled for 3.5 years, our ancestors experienced war crimes and Japanese cruelty, much crueler than the Dutch, Japan created slavery in Indonesia named Romusha, he was crueler than any bastard, the Dutch built several systems including radio transmitters, railway systems, petroleum, but the Japanese just came and destroyed them, even robbing what the Dutch had built, even in modern times the Japanese education system doesn't teach history their country and Japanese students automatically don't know about the dark history and cruelty of their leaders until now
logika simpel masak ngak paham
kamu jugak ngak bakal mengauki dan menceritakan hal buruk yang pernah kamu lakukan ke anak mu
sama jugak negara
lagi pula sejarah indonesia jugak ngak di tulis dan di ajarkan di sekolah berdadarkan fakta😅
tapi di edit dan di pilih-pilih sesuai kebutuhan negara
kalau ngak di edit dan di pilih-pilih dan langsung di sajikan berdasarkan fakta, ahh jangan di bahas😫
negara lain jugak melakukan hal yang sama,beberapa hal buruk yang ngak baik dan positif bagi negara bakal di sekip😂
jangan naif dek😅
@@narutokhun This cannot be the reason why Japan continues to deceive and still prays for war criminals after they committed the crimes of ww2☠️
They know lol, I’ve yet to meet to meet a Japanese person that is unaware of the bad things Japan has done in the past. They don’t feel good about it. It’s a common talking point for politicians in former colonies to get people riled up
By the way, 25,000 Japanese soldiers after the war stayed in Indonesia and fought alongside Indonesians against the Dutch for the independence of Indonesia. Most of those soldiers stayed and assimilated into Indonesia.
日本人じゃ思いつかない追悼ではあり得ない愉快な演出だと思った。
大日本皇軍👍
笑ってちゃダメだよ、コメントみたら信じてる外国人結構いるよ、こんな風習ねえよ！！って否定しなきゃ。
Best anime moments:
The drumming is great but can you make it a one hour video
荒廃した街を兵士に護衛されながら踊るのシュール過ぎる
もっと怒った方がいいよ、これを信じる人がいるからね。
こんなふざけた風習はないよ、ってはっきり言ってあげて下さいね。
I probably will get downvoted on this reply. As a former soldier...showing respect to fallen comrades means more than allegiance to some stupid government thousands of miles away.
me and the bois hitting the 1940s fortnite dance
This should be in Fortnite
then there were the Imperial Japanese soldiers dancing, now there are the Japanese Yakuzas dancing…
プロパガンダ映画はノンフィクションじゃないよ
This is not historically accurate, it is a metaphor of some sort from movie directors' imagination. Japanese army would not waste resources on this in such a war situation.
It's fictional. This kind of dance procession didn't happen. There was a military procession, but not like this.
There is another vid of this same clip and it was stated that this was meant to honer the soldiers lost in the battle.
This is nothing compared to what the Qing Dynasty and Revolution did to their own people, forever changed.
Don't compare different things.
@@AlejandroPikoulasPlata There is nothing after these events to compare to, completely shattered the people in soul and mind.
This is one of the best movie scenes I have ever watched. I stumbled on it last night and kept watching it over and over. I didn't know this movie existed. I am going to watch the full movie. 👍👍👍
ua-cam.com/video/Yx_ervF7h7w/v-deo.html A movie worth seeing
中国人の想像力はハリウッドを凌駕しそうです。歴史を改変し政治利用するのは韓国人だけだと思っていました。
Pls tell me name of this movie
City of Life and Death
Be careful. This movie is China produced. So lots of lies and propaganda against Japan.
Can someone explain to me what all the symbolism means so I can fully appreciate this very moving display. Thank you so very much
A sensationalised portrayal by the (Chinese made, no surprise there) film about the actual ceremony, which was more of a normal military parade with them bowing in the emperor's direction a few times.
I'm told this particular ceremony is actually a funeral or memorial one for their fallen troops, not a victory one.
@@MoreEvilThanYahweh
日本軍はこのような踊りを、軍隊の葬儀や式典で行っていません。中国のプロパガンダにより、観た方がその様に勘違いされています。
What Japan did in China was a War Crime on parr with Nazi Germany.
What the Imperial Army did in Nanking managed to cram the horrors of years of Dachau into a month and then some.
BUT;
This ceremony/victory dance never happened. The film makers took an old Japanese festival dance and transposed it into a celebration of the slaughter done in Nanking.
It is important to tell the truth of what happened in China. It is terrible enough without inventing things that didn't happen.
南京大虐殺なんて共産党のプロパガンダ信じてる時点でやばい！！
30万もどーやって殺す？
@@雅昭坂口You should be shamed by your saying.
何言ってんだおめえ！！
今の共産党のがだいぶ恐ろしいわ。
5 minutes after this
*big plane flys over head, it drops something you hear a whistling sound*
Did they dance like that in Nagasaki?
You think they really danced like this in Nanjng?
What are all the gestures in that dance supposed to represent?
2x speed. actually sounds like a good song.
0・25倍推奨
Was there camera footage when done then?
This what I do always after I win
Endou is that you
Funeral dance after you win?
What did you do when you lost?
"Buddy you're a boy make a big noise
Playin' in the street gonna be a big man some day
You got mud on yo' face
You big disgrace
Kickin' your can all over the place
Singin'
We will we will rock you
We will we will rock you"
Watch it again with that in mind.
We will never see the likes of such men again in our time, men willing to sacrifice themselves for their country and a living God. The totality of their brutality was fierce, they would fight to the last man if necessary! It was a Matter of honour! Something that we don’t see much of today!
And those men lost the war
And they murdered 300000 innocent Chinese in Nanking and this is them celebrating
@@KTSMORI ok may God bless you anyway 😷
@@leeeby2719 Perfect
Today's Ukrainian soldiers are as hard as them, but fight for protect what they love which they know as justice. I would say that is more meaningful. Doing wrong things would eat you up from inside and burn your human side dry. Just like today's Russian soldiers.
They say that if you dance this dance for a long time, a nuclear bomb will fall from the sky.
Ain’t gonna lie this was hard
Every strong legs they have
As a korean, I can feel fear through my dna
1:53 play this with 2x speed for real club sensation
Damn💀
Yahoooo!
😱😱
Fr
Thanks bro 🤝
Her: Where were you?
Me: Dancing with the boys...
戦時中にこんな事してたん？って戦争経験者の曾祖父に聞いたら「してるわけねーだろ、バカか」って言われた😅
哈哈哈，我也这样认为。
It's strange how many people believe at face value a movie made by China about this incident. Of course it will have a bias, it is only natural. The truth is somewhere between the two sides.
@@jyagariko99999
まぁ中国人が製作した映画だしね。発想がおバカさんよねw
日本の踊り＝阿波踊りって安易で幼稚すぎる発想だもんねw
It’s a Chinese movie
@@ZeroRequiem47
I agree
My grad father also know us lolo in tagalog tell a story about that kind of victory dance when the japanese conquered half of the philippines during world war 2.
But it cut short becouse when they were in the middle of the dance? 3 F4F wild cat arrived and immedietely attacked them and boomed them. He said that the dead & wounded are scattered around the place Many are asking for help.
Damn its friday already?
.
.
My liver: HAJIIMMMEEEEEEEE 1:03
They are dancing for the past aways in the war as they are telling the spirits to go forward to where they are supposed to, not celebrating for the victory. They are making this movie to raise hatred.
如果有人闯入你的家里，杀害你的家人，奸污你家里的女性，抢夺你的财产，焚烧你的房产。。。。。你就不会这么没有人性的说出：“煽动仇恨”这几个字里！
Why does they ran and yelled in the end of video?
a nazi party member in nanjing saved hundreds of students, and he recorded the massacre in his diary, a movie was made about this dark episode. it was regarded as the Shindler's list of china, in a much ironic but horrific fashion.
"A frightening scene, I can't imagine whats going through the minds of the remaining chinese captives watching. " xD
They were probably as afraid as the Tibetan people were when the chinese invaded and occupied Tibet.
西藏自古是中国的，但是强盗们不会这么认为，他们会认为白皮猪是世界上最最伟大的民族，在他们眼里拳头就是一切，他们喜欢对别人发出战争进行侵略！
It's a Shinto practice. But would Christians, Buddhist and atheist Japanese soldiers join in such practice?
THere very well may have been a victory dance and celebration - but tis is not it 0 this so obviously staged and is patently s propaganda film shot in a staged environment in Japan some where - if you want a debate then don't use these types of re-enactments.
The movie was shot in Tientsin , China and is a Chinese movie
Imagine knocking out a bully and dancing this around his body
Bully?
@@Lesimes-2055 Yeah china used to the the neighborhood bully. Calling itself "middle kingdom", calling everyone else "barbarians". They'd got what's coming to them.
It's a shot of the movie《Nanking!Nanking!》,not the real documentary l,but it have historical orgin.Form this movie ,you will know why do Chinese will never forgive the Nazi of Japan and the Japanese who never adimit this period of invasion in world war II!
Put in on 1.75 speed it's sounds so cool
No
1.25x and normal are the best
SuperDuck oh I'm gonna put it on that speed
Lol
Indonesian when their Chinese Boss call them Fangui:
If bts and kpop idols had testosterone 😂
What is the name of the movie?
This is not the real history video ,this is just part of a Chinese Movie.