You're doing a disservice by calling them names and making the situation worse. You don't seem to understand how psychology and physiology work in tandem. Malevolent channel is what I think since you asked.
Do people seriously believe these idols don't have eating disorders? Momo said in her trainee days, she had to only eat ice so that she could lose weight. Dahyun was almost kicked out of JYP during several occasions for not meeting weight standards. Y'all don't think the harsh diets and workout they go on will develop into disorders? It's not fast metabolism. And for the ones that are saying "they love eating, they ate on vlive", they could be throwing it all up when the cameras are off.
because not everything is eating disorder eating disorder eating disorder. stop generalizing. some idols are skinny due to dieting, and others are skinny due to fast metabolism and genetics. metabolism is not an impossible reasoning for weight. ur stereotyping is very dangerous, stop doing it, it’s so gross. some people who are skinny due to metabolism/genetics are thinking they are abnormal for something they can’t control because of people like u, so just imagine what naturally thin idols like sunmi, rosé, lisa think when millions of people tell them this?! can u ppl just stop accusing idols of having eating disorders when it’s not always the case. u need to consider how the idols a part of the minority feel too
@@hnyuq4049 its not generalizing because we acknowledge the fact that it is possible for idols to be naturally skinny which isnt a bad thing and i agree that its not always good to jump to conclusions. but we are talking about the fact that eating disorders are way more common in the kpop industry than someone just being lucky enough to have good metabolism. we're brining to light all the problems going on as many idols have even admitted to all the dangerous dieting that does eventually lead to the development to an eating disorder
That's exactly what i wanted to say. People actually believe that those are just "fast metabolism and genes"?! It probably has affect too but not that much! They literally even admitted that they are forced to do unhumane diets like eating only one apple a day or only ice cubes... this is not normal when will people open their eyes??
as someone with an ed: if these idols truly have an ed, you're not doing them any favor by calling them "paper thin" "skeleton" or "scary skinny" or other things like that. you're actually just encouraging them to lose even more weight. that's how eating disorders work.
@@pennymikk i'm not only referring to the comments in this video, I'm talking about the comments in general. Yuna from itzy did learn about the comments about her body, didn't she?
when people say something like that about your body in your head it processes as “oh they noticed i lost weight. it’s working ! keep going !” and it only makes it worse especially when it’s a rude comment
I love Wonyoung but I’m very scared for her and agree with the netizens. She is so busy recently not only being idol, MC but also traveling so much for promoting IVE. Also her fancam from the recent fanmeet it is a bit concerning, she looks very tired though she’s smiling. I REALLY HOPE WONYOUNG ISNT BEING OVERWORKED AND SHE GETS ENOUGH REST AND SLEEP!
And also her mental health to be all good not to take to much stress and not to (Self-torture) /pushing herself beyond the limit and actually being happy from THE INSIDE!
There's a difference between concern and just straight up hating. Telling idols that they look paper thin and are going to snap anytime is not helpful. Fans who are actually concerned would acknowledge it and hope that they will get healthier, not criticizing and comparing the idols' bodies to inanimate objects, that's just rude.
1. Too much pressure for perfection; 2. Under a lot of stress; 3. Loneliness; especially in the case of GD. He seemed to be happier in the military because he had a lot of company. Idk 🤷♀️
I get that being in the military might sometimes feels better than being an idol but no way it is that great .You need to do a lot of trainings in there and it is really challenging too .Don't take it like it's a vacation or something
If you listen to idols they're all naturally skinny and have a fast metabolism even though when you compare their debut/predebut pictures and videos vs now they definitely weren't that skinny, same thing with the "natural beauty" and "babyfat loss" argument
exactly, maybe not all idols are anorexic, but you got to admit it looks more than just fast metabolism. But delusional fans will defend their idols and pretend like these idols don't benefit from being sticks.
It makes me viciously angry that so many people will scream if idols gain weight, scream if they lose weight, scream if they date, scream if they smoke, scream if they get a tattoo. You know who else does this to people? Abusers! It’s downright abusive to try to control every single thing someone does!
Bruh, no one screams if they gain weight but their company 🙄 and fans scream if they lose all that weight out of concern and not at the idols but at the companies who ruin these women's bodies and health.
@@DiamondsRexpensive that’s true outside Korea, but the comments from many Korean fans seem FAR more critical of everything idols do. It’s like they think they own the idols.
I’m really concerned about wonyoung, she cares a lot about her image and I’m really scared she might be starving herself to look pretty. She’s so young, I want her to be healthy and happy 😥
I think she is not eating and is over exercising. I knew a girl like that in high school. Same height and weight as Wonyoung literally smh I pray for little Wonyoung
@@ao1162 the thing is, wonyoung was known for being “tall and skinny” ever since her izone days. having such titles thrown on you and being expected to upkeep that image is so damaging, especially for a young girl. i wouldn’t be surprised if wonyoung has developed an obsession with looking perfect. the kpop industry is recipe for mental illness.
@@Khushie1891 yeah, I’m pretty sure that it’s not JYPE who forces idols to loose their weight (bcoz there are a lot of healthy idols there) and especially because of Ryujin’s strong personality… she used to say that she wants to increase her performance efficiency by loosing weight (that was the reason), but I’m afraid she has lost too much weight too fast 😔
@@JaneJannie she probably lost weight due to preparing for the fan meet,I'm pretty sure she said in a recent itzy Itzy episode or somewhere that loosing weight makes her dance better. I really don't think u need to worry because Itzy have a good relationship with food and they eat well
As someone who has suffered from anorexia, you don’t have to never eat, seeing Wonyoung eat on camera, or Yuna sending photos of food, does NOT mean they aren’t suffering from an ED. Wonyoung, for example, no one is naturally that thin. If she is eating, then she more than likely isn’t eating enough, or is purging and is forcing the food back out of her body each time she does eat or drink anything. Her knees are so red! That isn’t a good sign. A long term anorexic will suffer with things like that, the blood is going to her knees because it isn’t being properly pumped throughout her body. I suffered with anorexia and I know for a fact how these things work. It’s sad that so many idols, male and female, have to suffer from these awful mental illnesses. I really hope that they get help.
it's sad because we know that a lot of these female idols are getting starved to the point that they don't get their periods (and that's really unhealthy) :(
I was extremely worried about GD cause even though he’s towards the skinny type, I do not believe that he’s dieting. I really hope that he’s doing okay and that his weight is not a side effect of something he might be going through. Being an idol is extremely tough and being someone who’s looked upto by other idols even more so. I really hope that all these idols are doing okay physically and mentally and pray that they can lead a happy life
I worry he is depressed. His best friend got married and who can you trust if he makes friends with him now he’s rich and famous can you trust any new friends in your life so I really worry he’s depressed he doesn’t you know they were a duo and now he’s not part of the family sure he can be the fun uncle but I worry he misses his life with Taeyang
I don’t think that calling them “skeleton” or “alarmingly thin” will help them with their mental health. All this trend of body positivity it’s clearly helping a lot of people with their body image, but being harassed all day long with comments about how you are not curvy or thick enough for the new beauty standards it’s right. Skinny shaming exist and it’s a problem too, it’s not funny when people are saying that you are not pretty or even attractive just because you don’t have honey thighs, wide hips and overall the proportions of the Kardashian family. People seriously need to stop pressuring idols to look like western singers.
well its not really possible for Far East Asian women to look like Non Far East Asians, since its very well known that the majority of East Asian women are not capable of having big feminine hip sizes, bottom and bra sizes. So no one really expects them to look like westerners (or anyone Non East Asian) since they can't reach that peak of feminimity.
i feel so bad for wonyoung... she's been in the public eye since she was 13, with all eyes of the nation on her. she's the current "IT" girl with millions of female fans all over the world, being in an industry where so many eyes are on you and how you look is paramount to your job. the pressure she faces everyday must be INSANE.
Everytime I see how thin Wonyoung is I remember that tv show where a guy told Sulli she needed to lose weight especially in her arms, and it was absolutely ridiculous since she was already slim, I mean there must be many people like that man in Korean society that put pressure on idols like Wonyoung to be very skinny, it's really sad
What’s alarming is the “before” and “after” photos to me. It shows that these young idols have changed from what they once looked like to what could be detrimental to their health.
I hope that you will feature lesser-known/underrated acts in your channel such as Yukika, Jeong Dong-won to name a few. Your channel might help them to attract new fans. :) More power to your channel.
@@tsuyuasui7297 So true. :) I might shout for joy if ever they will feature her in their future videos. Jeong Dong-won from Mr. Trot should be featured here as well. :) He's so damn good!
I understand that fans are worried about their idols(which is understandable) but can we please stop commenting on idols bodies(any human being in general)them being public figures also doesn't make it okay for anybody to comment on their bodies
I worked with people who had eating disorders for years….all of these idols are definitely worrying. Also, the impression it gives young kids (that your worth is directly related to your weight) is horrible. Hope they get the mental and physical help they need.
Seeing Jackson Wang recently also got me really worried because he lost so much weight. He never really had a healthy relationship with food. There are multiple videos where he talks about his diet and boy oh boy it is not good. That paired with his recent depression really makes me concerned. I think there are a lot of Idols who feel enormous pressure to reach certain standards because they feel obligated to their fans to do so when in reality they are hurting their bodies and their health tremendously. I hope he will find a healthy work life balance and understand that he doesn't have to put so much pressure on himself, we as fans just want him to be happy and healthy 🥺❤️
Yeah when I saw Jackson on Good Mythical Morning he looked so tiny. I know Rhett and Link are both giants but I always think of Jackson being well se and buff by Kpop standards. But now he looks thin and delicate
@@marionpeebles3836 Jackson actually is pretty thin and relatively small. When he is next to Lucas for example he always looks super tiny. He is very sportive and very muscular but when I think of "tall and buff" in the K Pop world I usually think of Wonho XD (Not that there is anything wrong with either body type. We all are different people. I was just vocalizing my concern for Jackson because there is such a pressure in the K Pop world to stay thin etc. As an update though: please listen to his recent interview with Eric Nam. It was a really great interview and he was given a lot of space to talk about his mental health struggles and he is a bit better now, but still continuing to heal so we wish him all the best on his mental health journey
I feel like those toxic fans will attack them either way if they're skinny they're "too skinny",if they're chubby they're "too fat to be an idol" ,if they're a visual they're "only a eyecandy" so the idols have to exceed their limits to achieve that "perfect" qualities the toxic fans would love I mean they are those people who can't even get off their bed to be productive and actually be successful in their life so they just bring other's self esteem down by these comments in order to feel good about themselves I'm sorry if I made any mistakes, English is not my first language
Im actually pretty skinny too but my ribs don't even show like how yuna's are showing as a midzy im really worried for her and the other idols but its just because of toxic standards and strict diet i hope they eat whatver they want but since yuna is saying that shes fine I'll believe her
Well I’m not skinny and my ribs shows. It our body types, if you were a Midzy you would know how Yuna always eats her ass off no matter what. She is on itzy ! The non stop group who dance and give out content every single day, if she was at the verge of breaking and dying I’m pretty sure we would know.
Nurse here - a "fast metabolism" isn't a thing in the way you're saying it. In fact, the more you weigh, the FASTER your metabolism because of how hard your body has to work to just pump your blood area, carrying the weight with you etc. Basically, to maintain weight a person weighing 200lbs would need to eat double the amount of calories of a person weighing 100lbs who was maintain weight. Also, NO these idols don't natural weigh that little! Nobody is naturally that severely underweight. The fact the they all recently, suddenly lost a lot of weight should make that obvious, too.
I'm more concerned looking at Ryujin next to Yuna right now. Tbh a lot of idols are concerning. It's the industry. Being underweight is a beauty standard and K pop fans either accept it and keep the industry going or they demand change with rights to health and wellbeing , as well as mental health support, for the artists and performers who make the industry money and keep us entertained.
Seungeun from BVNDIT had a time similar to wonyoung now. When the group debuted she was so thin just like wonyoung and i was very scared of her health but when she participanted on girls planet 999 her body condition was so much better and i hope wonyoung can reach to her old health body like before ( btw BVNDIT is making a comeback now and from the photos seungeun became thinner again but not as thinner as when she debuted tho but lets wish the best for her health)
I'm not a fan of Wonyoung or IVE, but I support her and I cared for her, I hope she can be healthy both physically and psychologically and emotionally, that she can lose weight and love herself in a way not harm her in any way. God, I really wish that for any idol who is going through a difficult process that I got to hurt them. Words affect, let them live as they wish, these situations would be avoided if people learned to respect idols and people in general.
@@winddragonlundholm1792 this person probably wanted to say "God, I really wish that for any idol who is going through a difficult process that hurts them"
As a big sister with a younger sister who had anorexia I’m really worried that she keep seeing some groups that indirectly promotes unhealthy food habits. She always said that she dreams be pretty and thin as those girls (she was skin and bones, she got so sick that went to mental hospital). I really get sad and annoyed when I saw some of my idols talking about those things in public because it is WRONG, most of them are adults who has younger fans, little people who are learning to accept and love themselves so I hope they can get better and be healthy, and really love the way they are
First of all, food photos doesn't prove anything, but I don't think Yuna is sick or having an ED , I don't have fat around on waist either, never had no matter how much weight I gained, like now I have 15 kg of overweight but nothing on my tummy or waist, all the fat goes to my tighs and hips.
I personally think the fans have a lot of power and we can all make a stand that we don’t wanna see unhealthy idols because we actually care about them???? Like I understand the skinny people get attention but can’t we change that standard???
Some “Fans” make fun, some throw ridiculous hate comments and some show concern when an idol is fat and also when thin/skinny. It’s ridiculous cause they lose weight so they don’t criticised and get “fat” shamed but get shamed again for being “skinny”. Don’t judge idols by their body…yall become some medical expertise when it comes to weight 😂😂 I DO NOT HAVE ANY INTENTION FOR THROWING HATE ON ANY IDOL
look I don’t like it when the companies force their idols to starve or lose weight in a unhealthy way but I also don’t like it when ppl cyber bully idols weight just say I wish they’re healthy and happy rather than saying hurtful things about their weight that might hurt them or pressure them to get the ideal body y’all want.
i really hate that these channels and people online say that these idols are "promoting eating disorders" etc. when they are thin when they likely are either forced to diet or they may in fact have an eating disorder themselves. so to these people who need help, others look at them and say "well, they're hurting others" while conveniently choosing to ignore that they're likely sadly hurting themselves but may not have support
Dancing Skeleton is too much disrespectful. It will hurt them mentally a ton. Those People should stop taking Drugs and Alcohol then only they will become healthy
I always hate myself when I see idols or western celebrities look like this as I struggle with a binge eating disorder and bulimia so my mind automatically says “goals”. I know it’s awful, especially because I can see how unhealthy it really is and what it means to be that skinny wether it’s due to diet or not ❤️ If you think what I think, I’m sorry. You are beautiful no matter your size, anyone who says otherwise is lying to you. It’s ok to get help and ask for it, you are enough just the way you are
me too :( their slim appearances aren't even prettier to me than people who aren't slim, but whenever i see them i think "i wish i was that skinny", i don't know what it is. maybe it's the attention that they get along with the preconceived notion that skinny=more attractive to other people. or maybe i want people to worry about me without me having to say anything?
As someone who has fast metabolism, it’s hard to look fit. No matter how much we eat, we still look skinny and that sucks. And also, it’s hard to gain weight especially if you’re really active just like yuna. She’s very active, dancing, practice etc
Yeah, I understand what you may be saying about how it’s difficult to gain weight for those with fast metabolism, but I don’t think eating may be the only way to gain weight. You can try supplements and exercise that help gain mass. Please correct me if I’m wrong.
@@suga3774 I think you can still gain muscle, by strength training and eating a high-calorie protein diet and take extra supplements, even though you may be very skinny.
@@sea-of-skies_ if you eat as much as you burn, your weight remains the same. You can be underweight and eat 2000 calories a day (using that as a general guideline as that is the recommended amount), to gain weight you’d have to eat more than what you need which is when gaining weight becomes hard
@@sea-of-skies_ it's complex enough for you to not understand it, you eat when you're hungry which is enjoyable, but people trying to gain weight with a fast metabolism would have to eat when they're not hungry which isn't enjoyable, like the feeling of being full but without the nice relaxing feeling and only leaving you with the discomforting feeling of the food expanding in your stomach. too much or too little of something is never pleasant
rose and lisa were born skinny. they have always been skinny, what can they do? there are many people like that it’s not like they try to lose weight, they just dont gain weight no matter what they eat.
Lisa has a healthy slander but full of muscles body. She has chubby cheeks and big muscular thighs because she dances everyday. But rose's legs are really thin from top to bottom. Her face/chin also become thinner/sharper compared to her debut time. I know she shows us she is a foodie but we don't know what's bts. Just hope she gains more weight before the next cb.
They eat almost nothing. the portions sizes that Blackpink post on social media are tiny. feed them 2000 calories a day and you're gonna see how they aren't "naturally skinny"
@@amandakong5937 As I know Rose’s body looked the same from the first debut time, which me she didnt try to loose any weight. And she is trying to show off she is a foodie because people are saying she has anorexia and trying to prove them wrong. Why people cannot just accept she is naturally like that? My body is exact same as hers and I eat but do you know how struggle it is to gain weight and telling people you are not anorexic all the time?
@Day Day it's not a face shaming. I am just telling that they are trying to look more mature and old which they are not yuna is only 18 but she try to look like 25 and no one can ever say that wongyoun is only 17 she looks like 20+ because of her makeup and body
All of them don't have hourglass body type in reality.. But they become so thin that it appears as... Every bodytype is beautiful and we need to embrace it 💖
I haven’t finished watching the video yet but from this video and other videos is that “fans” hate on the idol’s for being “fat” but they are “worried” when they are to skinny so it doesn’t make sense
yeah because i bet you live with her and see her eat everyday. stop being delusional. i also make my friends and family believe i eat a lot when i don't. i'm not saying she has an ed or she's lying for sure but saying that you know for sure that she eats a lot is just plain dumb.
But I think it goes for those idols who are so skinny and companies force diet on them not everyone is super slim some are forced literally so tht is where problem is
@@jihosz yes and that's same industry is people like us most but let's not assume all with companies like big 4 it's really a bad move for them to force strict diets since the cameras always on them and their idols
1. Some of you guys need to stop calling them “skeletons” “sticks” and etc. That could cause a whole other Ed or make them worse. 2. I feel that we should know when to stop talking about someone’s weight. 3. I too am so worried for these girls and boys. It’s so sad seeing this and I feel horrible for them bc it’s not their fault. I see ppl saying it’s not our place but would they rather watch these idols hurt themselves?
What scares is the fact that a camera is believed to add 10 pounds but they look really thin and y'all might say it's the camera angle but if u watched the vid or even google which shows multiple angles they still look very thin. And you're all probs gonna say their body their choice but all I'm doing is voicing out my concerns cuz their weight loss might be due to stress from all the hate, and not only that majority of kpop fans are minors and seeing their idol look this thin might affect them mentally and sure it's not their fault nor am I blaming them or bashing them but I do hope they would remain in healthier size cuz it would affect their health.
We’re honestly just concerned but In no way should someone call them skeletons...that’s just wrong- being to skinny Can cause heart failure, organ failure, loss of hair, dizziness, weakness-etc hopefully there healthy and just yk naturally thin :)
For yunas situation, she ate well but in one live she said she noticed she had some belly fat and I’m guessing she decided to eat less and at a specific time so now she lost a lot since her fast metabolism helped her loose weight fast. That’s why she lost it easier.
Btw according to yuna other fancams still her rib cage was seen in every fancam and wonyoung i feel like she try to fit in idol imagine so much she doesn’t know how much she have lost weight I shouldn’t comment to her body but as a fan its really worrying like is the company are they mentally fine?
As someone who also suffered ED, I used to eat pizza slices fastfood and overeat like everyone would but I would feel so bad after I would make myself throw up so yeah you can’t just judge on what people eat
Some of these "fans" are the same that point out whenever a idol gain a little bit of weight or doesn't meet society beauty standards. I realize that there are fans who are not like this, but the audience of these idols sometime is really toxic. They always says "she's too skinny"/"she's to fat", WTF, decide yourself?
Some of these drive me nuts. Everyone has different body types and metabolisms. It IS possible for you to see someone's ribs at certain angles and yet they're still not necessarily starving themselves. My sister has been tiny her whole life, and her and I both have weirdly large rib cages for our bodies. As a result, you can DEFINITELY see her rib cage sometimes depending on what position she's standing in. And yet she eats plenty, and is a healthy mother of two. While there are definitely issues among idols and celebrities in general with dangerous dieting and such, I feel like when people pick apart and critique these photos and then even go so far as to attack the individual it's no different than fat shaming or attacking someone for another physical attribute. 😬
we can’t really use the fast metabolism card in some cases. at wonyoungs height and age there is literally no way she is eating healthy to maintain her weight she is definitely in an extreme caloric deficient
I see my rib cage yet i eat.. alot maybe two much but im healthy so ima be me ( and you should be you as long as you know your healthy otherwise stay you but work on your health)
@@keylaali tbh i do worry for them and all my skinny friends as i worry commenting on it could make them eat less but i also worry that if i dont theyll eat less so i notice then i think wait what if they have no eating disorders so with the kpop idols i do worry, just dont want to say anything as a fear that theyll keep going when we piont it out... if someone used to have an eating disorder tell me what to do
I would like to point out that there are health issues that cause one's body to not be able to absorb what it needs to from your food, which can result in being malnourished. I feel concerned for idols that appear to be struggling with some sort of disordered eating but sometimes people will end up looking that way due to health problems that they have no choice in.
Fun fact : Most idols who are skinny are main/lead dancers , they eat properly but since they practice dance a lot, they lose weight, but for some, it's a natural thing.
Yes I also noticed that the visuals or the face of the group have to go through a lot 😭 And still people have the audacity to complain how they are centre..
If one idol is comparatively healthier then people talk how they look bad in MVs and pictures and how they need to loose weight. People bully idol to the point they don't eat at all. And now what they are alarmingly thin. Yess they will be thin not to get soooo much of body shaming things. Like what the fuck are they supposed to do huh?
As someone who had anorexia nervosa and has went to therapy with other people suffering from the same disorder. I can tell you that comments like “she/he is stick thin” and other comments like that will just encourage them if they have an ed. they will think “hey! They noticed that I lost weight! That’s amazing”
Jiyong recently said he is doing okay. If you watch videos and photos from the past, he is really REALLY skinny guy. During M.O.T.T.E, he lost so much weight he even himself said that he wasn't doing good then and was really depressed, tired and lonely. Even though he is the reason why my type in men is skinny without muscles, i was really worried about him in 2017. But he gained weight since then and now looks much healthier and it's cause of his happiness. He is doing good and people shouldn't be so worried about him. He is doing things he loves and you can see from his posts that he actually is really happy. He has always been and still is skinny but that's why we love him. He is what he is and he is perfect that way. He is doing good. My baby.
It's even sadder how young they are. Nowadays Yuna is 18, Wonyoung 17, they were even younger in these clips. These companies starve minors. I doubt a single one of these girls have periods... They make money young just to retire at 30 with many health issues...
I'm personally very concerned with Wonyoung(also angry bc fans are saying she's just "naturally skinny", which I don't think that's the case) but telling them, if they are suffering with an eating disorder, that's not gonna help in fact it's just gonna do the opposite. I don't have an eating disorder, but I know that if you have one, telling that someone "you're getting too thin!", their brain has taken a lot of damage from starving themselves and they'll take those concerns as "compliments" and encourage them to continue starving themselves
The sad thing about this when idols loose weight drastically some fans says their too skinny but when gain a little bit of fat they would say they're too fat/chubby.. 🙄
I think if the idols who claims that they are healthy then we should just let them be I mean if they don't feel unhealthy , then that's another thing Just people shouldn't bully them for having slim body Some people just naturally have slim body and don't gain weight easily
Bro in yuna's case i think it was just the lighting since you can see her ribs in the dalla dalla era as well with strong lightning she has always been skinny yes she looks a bit skinnier but overall she's okay and even if she gained weight she's still beautiful af
I don’t 100% believe that they don’t have some kind of eating disorder… but stress also tends to cause weight-loss and since a lot of idols could be pressured and busy, they might also forget to eat their meals. I’m not diagnosing… but I hope the companies take well care of these idols to make sure they don’t get sick or hurt
People pretending to be concerned for certain Idols while calling them a Skeleton in the same sentence makes me feel so sick... being skinny doesn't equal being Anorexic. As someone who is extremly skinny ever since birth, I had to Deal with people body shaming me ever since I was a child. Some people simply don't gain weight as easy as others plus these Idols work out all the time.... Yuna being so skinny at the Moment could basicly be a result of a busy scedule. Please stop hating on people that you concider to skinny for your liking and if you’re really concerned for them please be respectful. You can be concerned for them without calling them a Stick or Skeleton because let me tell you these comments really hurt. (Sorry for my bad english)
Yes bodyshaming is bad calling someone stick, paper, skeleton, elephant etc is so bad when I was chubby (65kgs) people used to call me elephant and now I'm skinny af and weight 53kgs (I'm 5'8) people love to call me skeleton and it fvcking hurts
yheyre not skinny tho. that's the issue. making up excuses doesn't help either. we saw before pics and none of them were skinny skinny. thier skinnier is achieved by other means that doesn't match qorh someone that dances and stuff for a living. literally look at pro dancers and they don't look like that.
As a skinny person that can eat a lot it's sad to see just our existence can cause people to get worried even tho I'm perfectly healthy. It's literally body shaming i don't know why people don't get it
I really don't understand why they want to be as skinny as possible. Do koreans really think that looks good? "Fast metabolism" isn't as common as people think. Either you're eating enough to balance out the calories you're burning, or you're not.
If they're a healthy weight the fans tell them they're fat and if they lose that weight the fans tell them they're too skinny. There is no way to win in an industry that scrutinizes their bodies in this way and a lot of it is the fans' fault.
Ofc i used to be envious of their body but at some point i became concern about it. Its like not healthy at all. People must appreciate all types of bodies on idols . On the side how hard they work and train to become an idol we must respect it
For Yuna I just wanna say she’s still in her growing age she dances alot and has been into sports ever since she was a kid,Even though she eats pretty healthy her body doesn’t store fat drastically,in one of her Vlives she said she got a little belly so she’s been exercising for that the pictures do look scary and the reason for that is because the lights were directly above her and were harsh.Secondly even if you have some body fat if your flex you’re waist out you will see your rib age and the quality of these pictures isn’t that great either So it just added more definition to the dark areas or her rib cage.The timing if these pictures was just really bad
I hope those netizens know, camera contribute on making idols appear 5 to 10kg heavier than their actual weight. Those idols they bashed for looking "too heavy" are looking just fit and healthy in real life.. that's why they should stop dragging idols for their weight, their main job are to sing and perform not as an 'eye candy barbie'
I‘m really just curious as to how they are still able to dance when they are that slim. I once was quite underweight and I definitely did NOT feel like dancing at all :c
Hi I'm 38 international age. I weigh 105. My mother is 62 and weights 98. Please stop just stop this crap. Theyre to skinny. Look I'm in recovery and I have over 8 years clean and threw out the years my weight dropped not gained. I feel that people are looking at me as if I'm using drugs again when I'm not. This could hurt these people. Please stop telling people were to skinny 😭😭😭 isn't that what people want for these people?? Yet when they are skinny y'all say they're to skinny??? Make that make sense please
they are under alot of pressure and it´s alarming that labels always knack on them to loose weight but shouldn't they do the same then they become too skinny? it´s so unhealthy and scary
So... what do you think? Are they trying to lose weight on purpose or there were some uncontrollable reasons? 😕
@Day Day Maybe she should Decrease her amount of Drugs and alcohol that she takes. It will help her become healthy
Idk about others but for yuna it's just her body type .
You're doing a disservice by calling them names and making the situation worse. You don't seem to understand how psychology and physiology work in tandem. Malevolent channel is what I think since you asked.
I'm 13 and I'm 47 kg
G DRAGON
THE KING
Do people seriously believe these idols don't have eating disorders? Momo said in her trainee days, she had to only eat ice so that she could lose weight. Dahyun was almost kicked out of JYP during several occasions for not meeting weight standards. Y'all don't think the harsh diets and workout they go on will develop into disorders? It's not fast metabolism. And for the ones that are saying "they love eating, they ate on vlive", they could be throwing it all up when the cameras are off.
only “eat” ICE??? wtf thats just straight up water😭😭 now i wonder what will happen to jeongyeon? since she gained weight bc if the medicine she takes.
fans also forget that laxatives exist too which can help companies fake the fact that their idols are “eating well”
because not everything is eating disorder eating disorder eating disorder. stop generalizing. some idols are skinny due to dieting, and others are skinny due to fast metabolism and genetics. metabolism is not an impossible reasoning for weight. ur stereotyping is very dangerous, stop doing it, it’s so gross. some people who are skinny due to metabolism/genetics are thinking they are abnormal for something they can’t control because of people like u, so just imagine what naturally thin idols like sunmi, rosé, lisa think when millions of people tell them this?! can u ppl just stop accusing idols of having eating disorders when it’s not always the case. u need to consider how the idols a part of the minority feel too
@@hnyuq4049 its not generalizing because we acknowledge the fact that it is possible for idols to be naturally skinny which isnt a bad thing and i agree that its not always good to jump to conclusions. but we are talking about the fact that eating disorders are way more common in the kpop industry than someone just being lucky enough to have good metabolism. we're brining to light all the problems going on as many idols have even admitted to all the dangerous dieting that does eventually lead to the development to an eating disorder
That's exactly what i wanted to say. People actually believe that those are just "fast metabolism and genes"?! It probably has affect too but not that much! They literally even admitted that they are forced to do unhumane diets like eating only one apple a day or only ice cubes... this is not normal when will people open their eyes??
as someone with an ed: if these idols truly have an ed, you're not doing them any favor by calling them "paper thin" "skeleton" or "scary skinny" or other things like that. you're actually just encouraging them to lose even more weight. that's how eating disorders work.
I agree a lot with this comment it’s unnecessary remarks that make someone insecure about their body image,,,
They kinda do that often
As someone who used to have An ed, I disagree.
@@pennymikk i'm not only referring to the comments in this video, I'm talking about the comments in general. Yuna from itzy did learn about the comments about her body, didn't she?
when people say something like that about your body in your head it processes as “oh they noticed i lost weight. it’s working ! keep going !” and it only makes it worse especially when it’s a rude comment
I love Wonyoung but I’m very scared for her and agree with the netizens. She is so busy recently not only being idol, MC but also traveling so much for promoting IVE. Also her fancam from the recent fanmeet it is a bit concerning, she looks very tired though she’s smiling. I REALLY HOPE WONYOUNG ISNT BEING OVERWORKED AND SHE GETS ENOUGH REST AND SLEEP!
And also her mental health to be all good not to take to much stress and not to (Self-torture) /pushing herself beyond the limit and actually being happy from THE INSIDE!
I agree with you
Yes
Completely agree! I don't know when she has time to sleep and be a normal teen!
What fancam ?/genuine
There's a difference between concern and just straight up hating. Telling idols that they look paper thin and are going to snap anytime is not helpful. Fans who are actually concerned would acknowledge it and hope that they will get healthier, not criticizing and comparing the idols' bodies to inanimate objects, that's just rude.
when fake stans try to look nice but dont know how and just attack channels because some actually toxic channels called them bad...
@@pruitv2857 wait ✋ was you reply a hate reply to this comment owner?
Very true.
@@arandomarmy2202 Yea, that's what I'm wondering too lmfao. I'm so confused whether to agree or be offended😂
@@aizzaasen6465 yeah😂
1. Too much pressure for perfection;
2. Under a lot of stress;
3. Loneliness; especially in the case of GD. He seemed to be happier in the military because he had a lot of company. Idk 🤷♀️
i always thought gd has a lot of friends. is he not friends with big bang anymore?
G DRAGON
THE KING
I get that being in the military might sometimes feels better than being an idol but no way it is that great .You need to do a lot of trainings in there and it is really challenging too .Don't take it like it's a vacation or something
Your name to be honest💀💀
@@whatever9274 his best friend are in the jail, that's sad
some people really need to understand the difference between being worried and hating on them smh
@@huguettemutombo9710 stop saying bruh to sound cool.. you wouldn't say that to your parents 🙄
@@alaneofmyown
Wth, u ok? U got some issues u need to fix.
@@alaneofmyown LMAO WHAT it’s an internet people can decide themselves how to talk
@@alaneofmyown bruh 💀
Like, seriously. Are these netizens not happy until their favorite idol is dead or something?
Many people says these idols are naturally skinny but when it is compared to the old picture it is something else
Lol , those fans are clown
If you listen to idols they're all naturally skinny and have a fast metabolism even though when you compare their debut/predebut pictures and videos vs now they definitely weren't that skinny, same thing with the "natural beauty" and "babyfat loss" argument
@@Arithekiller Yeah, it’s ridicoulous
exactly, maybe not all idols are anorexic, but you got to admit it looks more than just fast metabolism. But delusional fans will defend their idols and pretend like these idols don't benefit from being sticks.
They previously look skinny, but not dangerously skinny.
It makes me viciously angry that so many people will scream if idols gain weight, scream if they lose weight, scream if they date, scream if they smoke, scream if they get a tattoo. You know who else does this to people? Abusers! It’s downright abusive to try to control every single thing someone does!
Bruh, no one screams if they gain weight but their company 🙄 and fans scream if they lose all that weight out of concern and not at the idols but at the companies who ruin these women's bodies and health.
@@DiamondsRexpensive that’s true outside Korea, but the comments from many Korean fans seem FAR more critical of everything idols do. It’s like they think they own the idols.
Best comment, so true. The most toxic thing here is believening the public owns a human being.
I’m really concerned about wonyoung, she cares a lot about her image and I’m really scared she might be starving herself to look pretty. She’s so young, I want her to be healthy and happy 😥
I think she is not eating and is over exercising. I knew a girl like that in high school. Same height and weight as Wonyoung literally smh I pray for little Wonyoung
The thing is Wonyoung always has been naturally skinny, however now it just looks like its just bones, only her face still looks the same.
@@tsuyuasui7297 if we compare to izone debut days she looked a pretty normal weight tbh but now
@@ao1162 the thing is, wonyoung was known for being “tall and skinny” ever since her izone days. having such titles thrown on you and being expected to upkeep that image is so damaging, especially for a young girl. i wouldn’t be surprised if wonyoung has developed an obsession with looking perfect. the kpop industry is recipe for mental illness.
@@ao1162 She started losing weight in iz*one
Currently, I'm more worried about Ryujin's significant weight loss...
She looked so amazing in wannabe-not shy era!
@@Khushie1891 yeah, I’m pretty sure that it’s not JYPE who forces idols to loose their weight (bcoz there are a lot of healthy idols there) and especially because of Ryujin’s strong personality… she used to say that she wants to increase her performance efficiency by loosing weight (that was the reason), but I’m afraid she has lost too much weight too fast 😔
@@JaneJannie she probably lost weight due to preparing for the fan meet,I'm pretty sure she said in a recent itzy Itzy episode or somewhere that loosing weight makes her dance better. I really don't think u need to worry because Itzy have a good relationship with food and they eat well
Bruh I’ve Stan her ever since debut. I miss her curvy thicc look :/
ryujin is a smart babe I trust she makes good choices, with that said I hope she's staying under a healthy weight, yuna too
As someone who has suffered from anorexia, you don’t have to never eat, seeing Wonyoung eat on camera, or Yuna sending photos of food, does NOT mean they aren’t suffering from an ED. Wonyoung, for example, no one is naturally that thin. If she is eating, then she more than likely isn’t eating enough, or is purging and is forcing the food back out of her body each time she does eat or drink anything. Her knees are so red! That isn’t a good sign. A long term anorexic will suffer with things like that, the blood is going to her knees because it isn’t being properly pumped throughout her body. I suffered with anorexia and I know for a fact how these things work. It’s sad that so many idols, male and female, have to suffer from these awful mental illnesses. I really hope that they get help.
it's sad because we know that a lot of these female idols are getting starved to the point that they don't get their periods (and that's really unhealthy) :(
I was extremely worried about GD cause even though he’s towards the skinny type, I do not believe that he’s dieting. I really hope that he’s doing okay and that his weight is not a side effect of something he might be going through. Being an idol is extremely tough and being someone who’s looked upto by other idols even more so. I really hope that all these idols are doing okay physically and mentally and pray that they can lead a happy life
I feel like it might be depression perhaps?
I worry he is depressed. His best friend got married and who can you trust if he makes friends with him now he’s rich and famous can you trust any new friends in your life so I really worry he’s depressed he doesn’t you know they were a duo and now he’s not part of the family sure he can be the fun uncle but I worry he misses his life with Taeyang
I don’t think that calling them “skeleton” or “alarmingly thin” will help them with their mental health. All this trend of body positivity it’s clearly helping a lot of people with their body image, but being harassed all day long with comments about how you are not curvy or thick enough for the new beauty standards it’s right.
Skinny shaming exist and it’s a problem too, it’s not funny when people are saying that you are not pretty or even attractive just because you don’t have honey thighs, wide hips and overall the proportions of the Kardashian family.
People seriously need to stop pressuring idols to look like western singers.
Lol
thank you, a very needed comment
People want k pop idols to look like western singers and like anime character at the same time
G DRAGON
KING
well its not really possible for Far East Asian women to look like Non Far East Asians, since its very well known that the majority of East Asian women are not capable of having big feminine hip sizes, bottom and bra sizes. So no one really expects them to look like westerners (or anyone Non East Asian) since they can't reach that peak of feminimity.
i feel so bad for wonyoung... she's been in the public eye since she was 13, with all eyes of the nation on her. she's the current "IT" girl with millions of female fans all over the world, being in an industry where so many eyes are on you and how you look is paramount to your job. the pressure she faces everyday must be INSANE.
TIMESTAPS :
0:29 - Itzy Yuna
2:24 - Ive Wonyoung
3:39 - Blackpink Rosé
5:14 - Taeyeon
6:34 - G-dragon
I don't think wonyoung is having her menstruation. I'm seriously worried for her.
Everytime I see how thin Wonyoung is I remember that tv show where a guy told Sulli she needed to lose weight especially in her arms, and it was absolutely ridiculous since she was already slim, I mean there must be many people like that man in Korean society that put pressure on idols like Wonyoung to be very skinny, it's really sad
2:21 ofc it wasn’t touched yet, why would she take a picture of an empty plate? Everyone takes pictures before 💀
What’s alarming is the “before” and “after” photos to me. It shows that these young idols have changed from what they once looked like to what could be detrimental to their health.
You can be concerned but please don't bodyshame them
Yes😢
She simply pointed out what you people commented
@Rachna Sharma yup
@@arnoldculz2393 wait....
I didn't saw Comment body sh@ming Them
that's not body shaming people are just worried for them
I hope that you will feature lesser-known/underrated acts in your channel such as Yukika, Jeong Dong-won to name a few. Your channel might help them to attract new fans. :) More power to your channel.
Thank you for suggesting ^^ We'll try to include them in our future videos :x
@@BeBossTV Thanks much :) Looking forward to see them and other underrated acts on your future videos.
G DRAGON
KING
Yukika is so damn underrated
@@tsuyuasui7297 So true. :) I might shout for joy if ever they will feature her in their future videos. Jeong Dong-won from Mr. Trot should be featured here as well. :) He's so damn good!
I understand that fans are worried about their idols(which is understandable) but can we please stop commenting on idols bodies(any human being in general)them being public figures also doesn't make it okay for anybody to comment on their bodies
I worked with people who had eating disorders for years….all of these idols are definitely worrying.
Also, the impression it gives young kids (that your worth is directly related to your weight) is horrible.
Hope they get the mental and physical help they need.
Seeing Jackson Wang recently also got me really worried because he lost so much weight. He never really had a healthy relationship with food. There are multiple videos where he talks about his diet and boy oh boy it is not good. That paired with his recent depression really makes me concerned. I think there are a lot of Idols who feel enormous pressure to reach certain standards because they feel obligated to their fans to do so when in reality they are hurting their bodies and their health tremendously. I hope he will find a healthy work life balance and understand that he doesn't have to put so much pressure on himself, we as fans just want him to be happy and healthy 🥺❤️
Yeah when I saw Jackson on Good Mythical Morning he looked so tiny. I know Rhett and Link are both giants but I always think of Jackson being well se and buff by Kpop standards. But now he looks thin and delicate
@@marionpeebles3836 Jackson actually is pretty thin and relatively small. When he is next to Lucas for example he always looks super tiny. He is very sportive and very muscular but when I think of "tall and buff" in the K Pop world I usually think of Wonho XD (Not that there is anything wrong with either body type. We all are different people. I was just vocalizing my concern for Jackson because there is such a pressure in the K Pop world to stay thin etc. As an update though: please listen to his recent interview with Eric Nam. It was a really great interview and he was given a lot of space to talk about his mental health struggles and he is a bit better now, but still continuing to heal so we wish him all the best on his mental health journey
Top visuals have way more pressure and that's the reason of most of them being unhealthy
Agreed!!
I feel like those toxic fans will attack them either way if they're skinny they're "too skinny",if they're chubby they're "too fat to be an idol" ,if they're a visual they're "only a eyecandy" so the idols have to exceed their limits to achieve that "perfect" qualities the toxic fans would love
I mean they are those people who can't even get off their bed to be productive and actually be successful in their life so they just bring other's self esteem down by these comments in order to feel good about themselves
I'm sorry if I made any mistakes, English is not my first language
People shaming idol on their bed, yeah, the worst
Too fat to be an idol? Irony! To be an idol, you should have talent not a skinny body.
Im actually pretty skinny too but my ribs don't even show like how yuna's are showing as a midzy im really worried for her and the other idols but its just because of toxic standards and strict diet i hope they eat whatver they want but since yuna is saying that shes fine I'll believe her
Well I’m not skinny and my ribs shows. It our body types, if you were a Midzy you would know how Yuna always eats her ass off no matter what. She is on itzy ! The non stop group who dance and give out content every single day, if she was at the verge of breaking and dying I’m pretty sure we would know.
If you were doing what she was doing like dancing, your ribs would show. Its normal
I’m not all that thin and mine do show like that, bone structure plays a huge role.
@@mayoecilpes8027 Her ribs were showing when she basically just standing. did you even watch the video?
@@jihosz Thats when she was standing in a weird pose, if she was standing normally her ribs wouldnt show.
Nurse here - a "fast metabolism" isn't a thing in the way you're saying it. In fact, the more you weigh, the FASTER your metabolism because of how hard your body has to work to just pump your blood area, carrying the weight with you etc. Basically, to maintain weight a person weighing 200lbs would need to eat double the amount of calories of a person weighing 100lbs who was maintain weight.
Also, NO these idols don't natural weigh that little! Nobody is naturally that severely underweight. The fact the they all recently, suddenly lost a lot of weight should make that obvious, too.
I'm more concerned looking at Ryujin next to Yuna right now. Tbh a lot of idols are concerning. It's the industry. Being underweight is a beauty standard and K pop fans either accept it and keep the industry going or they demand change with rights to health and wellbeing , as well as mental health support, for the artists and performers who make the industry money and keep us entertained.
Seungeun from BVNDIT had a time similar to wonyoung now. When the group debuted she was so thin just like wonyoung and i was very scared of her health but when she participanted on girls planet 999 her body condition was so much better and i hope wonyoung can reach to her old health body like before ( btw BVNDIT is making a comeback now and from the photos seungeun became thinner again but not as thinner as when she debuted tho but lets wish the best for her health)
agreed, she looks gorgeous!! i remember gasping after seeing her during their debut… i hope she’s doing well mentally. so proud of her
Amazes me how rose dances soooo well considering she's so long and thin! She dances so strong!
Maybe bcos she's healthy 🤷
I'm not a fan of Wonyoung or IVE, but I support her and I cared for her, I hope she can be healthy both physically and psychologically and emotionally, that she can lose weight and love herself in a way not harm her in any way.
God, I really wish that for any idol who is going through a difficult process that I got to hurt them.
Words affect, let them live as they wish, these situations would be avoided if people learned to respect idols and people in general.
*that I got to hurt them* ???????
What are you trying to say man, to hurt them? And you hope for their health but say people should mind their own business 😅
English is obviously not their first language so something must've gotten mixed up in translation
@@lovechoerrymotion5086 its true
@@winddragonlundholm1792 this person probably wanted to say "God, I really wish that for any idol who is going through a difficult process that hurts them"
As a big sister with a younger sister who had anorexia I’m really worried that she keep seeing some groups that indirectly promotes unhealthy food habits. She always said that she dreams be pretty and thin as those girls (she was skin and bones, she got so sick that went to mental hospital). I really get sad and annoyed when I saw some of my idols talking about those things in public because it is WRONG, most of them are adults who has younger fans, little people who are learning to accept and love themselves so I hope they can get better and be healthy, and really love the way they are
First of all, food photos doesn't prove anything, but I don't think Yuna is sick or having an ED , I don't have fat around on waist either, never had no matter how much weight I gained, like now I have 15 kg of overweight but nothing on my tummy or waist, all the fat goes to my tighs and hips.
The thing is Yuna has no fat or muscles anywhere in her body. she lost weight.
I personally think the fans have a lot of power and we can all make a stand that we don’t wanna see unhealthy idols because we actually care about them???? Like I understand the skinny people get attention but can’t we change that standard???
Some “Fans” make fun, some throw ridiculous hate comments and some show concern when an idol is fat and also when thin/skinny. It’s ridiculous cause they lose weight so they don’t criticised and get “fat” shamed but get shamed again for being “skinny”. Don’t judge idols by their body…yall become some medical expertise when it comes to weight 😂😂 I DO NOT HAVE ANY INTENTION FOR THROWING HATE ON ANY IDOL
@Day Day exactly, some rock stars are as skinny as k-pop idol.
@Day Day fr
Bruh wonyoungs legs are creepy
look I don’t like it when the companies force their idols to starve or lose weight in a unhealthy way but I also don’t like it when ppl cyber bully idols weight just say I wish they’re healthy and happy rather than saying hurtful things about their weight that might hurt them or pressure them to get the ideal body y’all want.
i really hate that these channels and people online say that these idols are "promoting eating disorders" etc. when they are thin when they likely are either forced to diet or they may in fact have an eating disorder themselves. so to these people who need help, others look at them and say "well, they're hurting others" while conveniently choosing to ignore that they're likely sadly hurting themselves but may not have support
Dancing Skeleton is too much disrespectful. It will hurt them mentally a ton. Those People should stop taking Drugs and Alcohol then only they will become healthy
I always hate myself when I see idols or western celebrities look like this as I struggle with a binge eating disorder and bulimia so my mind automatically says “goals”. I know it’s awful, especially because I can see how unhealthy it really is and what it means to be that skinny wether it’s due to diet or not ❤️ If you think what I think, I’m sorry. You are beautiful no matter your size, anyone who says otherwise is lying to you. It’s ok to get help and ask for it, you are enough just the way you are
me too :( their slim appearances aren't even prettier to me than people who aren't slim, but whenever i see them i think "i wish i was that skinny", i don't know what it is. maybe it's the attention that they get along with the preconceived notion that skinny=more attractive to other people. or maybe i want people to worry about me without me having to say anything?
I think GD heard about his fans worrying. His been exercising every morning and giving update. GD so sweet❤
The skinny shaming words amuse me
As someone who has fast metabolism, it’s hard to look fit. No matter how much we eat, we still look skinny and that sucks. And also, it’s hard to gain weight especially if you’re really active just like yuna. She’s very active, dancing, practice etc
Yeah, I understand what you may be saying about how it’s difficult to gain weight for those with fast metabolism, but I don’t think eating may be the only way to gain weight. You can try supplements and exercise that help gain mass. Please correct me if I’m wrong.
@@suga3774 I think you can still gain muscle, by strength training and eating a high-calorie protein diet and take extra supplements, even though you may be very skinny.
That's why you have to eat as much as you burn or you're undereating. It's not that complex.
@@sea-of-skies_ if you eat as much as you burn, your weight remains the same. You can be underweight and eat 2000 calories a day (using that as a general guideline as that is the recommended amount), to gain weight you’d have to eat more than what you need which is when gaining weight becomes hard
@@sea-of-skies_ it's complex enough for you to not understand it, you eat when you're hungry which is enjoyable, but people trying to gain weight with a fast metabolism would have to eat when they're not hungry which isn't enjoyable, like the feeling of being full but without the nice relaxing feeling and only leaving you with the discomforting feeling of the food expanding in your stomach. too much or too little of something is never pleasant
rose and lisa were born skinny. they have always been skinny, what can they do? there are many people like that it’s not like they try to lose weight, they just dont gain weight no matter what they eat.
Pretty savage
Lisa has a healthy slander but full of muscles body. She has chubby cheeks and big muscular thighs because she dances everyday. But rose's legs are really thin from top to bottom. Her face/chin also become thinner/sharper compared to her debut time. I know she shows us she is a foodie but we don't know what's bts. Just hope she gains more weight before the next cb.
They eat almost nothing. the portions sizes that Blackpink post on social media are tiny.
feed them 2000 calories a day and you're gonna see how they aren't "naturally skinny"
@@amandakong5937 As I know Rose’s body looked the same from the first debut time, which me she didnt try to loose any weight. And she is trying to show off she is a foodie because people are saying she has anorexia and trying to prove them wrong. Why people cannot just accept she is naturally like that? My body is exact same as hers and I eat but do you know how struggle it is to gain weight and telling people you are not anorexic all the time?
@@qwertz666 yes, clown
Visuals of G3 are looking like they are 20-25 ( Irene, jisoo, jennie) but the visuals of G4 are looking like they are 25-30
True
True, kids nowadays looks older...
Maybe because of unnecessary heavy makeup?
@Day Day it's not a face shaming. I am just telling that they are trying to look more mature and old which they are not yuna is only 18 but she try to look like 25 and no one can ever say that wongyoun is only 17 she looks like 20+ because of her makeup and body
@@Ai99573 no they don't, agencies are obsessed with the "debut at a young age" and end up reducing their age
All of them don't have hourglass body type in reality.. But they become so thin that it appears as... Every bodytype is beautiful and we need to embrace it 💖
I haven’t finished watching the video yet but from this video and other videos is that “fans” hate on the idol’s for being “fat” but they are “worried” when they are to skinny so it doesn’t make sense
Those fans who say they are worried about yuna are not even midzys because real midzy know how she eats . And it's just her body type.
yeah because i bet you live with her and see her eat everyday. stop being delusional. i also make my friends and family believe i eat a lot when i don't. i'm not saying she has an ed or she's lying for sure but saying that you know for sure that she eats a lot is just plain dumb.
Korean don't know about BMI too
Like they want both idols who are highter and have short height have same weight 🙄
You can be a healthy weight and still have ribs that stick out. That’s the case for me as well.
Me as well, some people only view skinny as unhealthy and it shows
But I think it goes for those idols who are so skinny and companies force diet on them not everyone is super slim some are forced literally so tht is where problem is
Its so normal for that to happen, people are overreacting
@@Jungkook_fr It's the k-pop industry we are talking about, so in this case is most definitely not healthy.
@@jihosz yes and that's same industry is people like us
most but let's not assume all with companies like big 4 it's really a bad move for them to force strict diets since the cameras always on them and their idols
i'm worried about Wonyoung
1. Some of you guys need to stop calling them “skeletons” “sticks” and etc. That could cause a whole other Ed or make them worse.
2. I feel that we should know when to stop talking about someone’s weight.
3. I too am so worried for these girls and boys. It’s so sad seeing this and I feel horrible for them bc it’s not their fault. I see ppl saying it’s not our place but would they rather watch these idols hurt themselves?
This channel is disgusting,they also like using famous idols for clout, you'll never see them feature lesser known idols in their "series"
There’s concern and then there’s body shaming.
What scares is the fact that a camera is believed to add 10 pounds but they look really thin and y'all might say it's the camera angle but if u watched the vid or even google which shows multiple angles they still look very thin. And you're all probs gonna say their body their choice but all I'm doing is voicing out my concerns cuz their weight loss might be due to stress from all the hate, and not only that majority of kpop fans are minors and seeing their idol look this thin might affect them mentally and sure it's not their fault nor am I blaming them or bashing them but I do hope they would remain in healthier size cuz it would affect their health.
Its not our place to be talking about idols bodys, no matter how worried you are.
We’re honestly just concerned but In no way should someone call them skeletons...that’s just wrong- being to skinny Can cause heart failure, organ failure, loss of hair, dizziness, weakness-etc hopefully there healthy and just yk naturally thin :)
For yunas situation, she ate well but in one live she said she noticed she had some belly fat and I’m guessing she decided to eat less and at a specific time so now she lost a lot since her fast metabolism helped her loose weight fast. That’s why she lost it easier.
Btw according to yuna other fancams still her rib cage was seen in every fancam and wonyoung i feel like she try to fit in idol imagine so much she doesn’t know how much she have lost weight I shouldn’t comment to her body but as a fan its really worrying like is the company are they mentally fine?
As someone who also suffered ED, I used to eat pizza slices fastfood and overeat like everyone would but I would feel so bad after I would make myself throw up so yeah you can’t just judge on what people eat
Some of these "fans" are the same that point out whenever a idol gain a little bit of weight or doesn't meet society beauty standards. I realize that there are fans who are not like this, but the audience of these idols sometime is really toxic. They always says "she's too skinny"/"she's to fat", WTF, decide yourself?
Some of these drive me nuts. Everyone has different body types and metabolisms. It IS possible for you to see someone's ribs at certain angles and yet they're still not necessarily starving themselves. My sister has been tiny her whole life, and her and I both have weirdly large rib cages for our bodies. As a result, you can DEFINITELY see her rib cage sometimes depending on what position she's standing in. And yet she eats plenty, and is a healthy mother of two.
While there are definitely issues among idols and celebrities in general with dangerous dieting and such, I feel like when people pick apart and critique these photos and then even go so far as to attack the individual it's no different than fat shaming or attacking someone for another physical attribute. 😬
we can’t really use the fast metabolism card in some cases. at wonyoungs height and age there is literally no way she is eating healthy to maintain her weight she is definitely in an extreme caloric deficient
@Liz yeah but clearly they had other intentions commenting that under a video like this, let’s not act oblivious now babe 😭
@@keylaali exactly.
I see my rib cage yet i eat.. alot maybe two much but im healthy so ima be me ( and you should be you as long as you know your healthy otherwise stay you but work on your health)
@@keylaali tbh i do worry for them and all my skinny friends as i worry commenting on it could make them eat less but i also worry that if i dont theyll eat less so i notice then i think wait what if they have no eating disorders so with the kpop idols i do worry, just dont want to say anything as a fear that theyll keep going when we piont it out... if someone used to have an eating disorder tell me what to do
I honestly hope they’re healthy, and resting well enough. We don’t know what happens off camera
I can’t see GD’s transformation, it hurts me. He’s lost the King look.
GD be healthy,eat healthy.
happy to tell you he gained a lot of weight & looks so healthy now he’s always a king tho
I would like to point out that there are health issues that cause one's body to not be able to absorb what it needs to from your food, which can result in being malnourished. I feel concerned for idols that appear to be struggling with some sort of disordered eating but sometimes people will end up looking that way due to health problems that they have no choice in.
Fun fact : Most idols who are skinny are main/lead dancers , they eat properly but since they practice dance a lot, they lose weight, but for some, it's a natural thing.
Momo being the exception 🤠
is it really necessary for kpop idols too loose such weight??
IT IS REALLY WORRYING ME A LOT!!!I LOVE KPOP WITH ALL MY HEART!!
Low BMI isn’t considered as “healthy.” The deficiencies are too obvious.
Yes I also noticed that the visuals or the face of the group have to go through a lot 😭
And still people have the audacity to complain how they are centre..
"Her legs looks like 2 sticks!"
"Skelletonic"
"Lifeless"
"Scarily sharp"
"Bony"
"Scary when smiled"
"Anorexy image"
*Yeah body shaming isn't helping it.*
This shouldn't be normalized 🙁
If one idol is comparatively healthier then people talk how they look bad in MVs and pictures and how they need to loose weight. People bully idol to the point they don't eat at all. And now what they are alarmingly thin. Yess they will be thin not to get soooo much of body shaming things. Like what the fuck are they supposed to do huh?
As someone who had anorexia nervosa and has went to therapy with other people suffering from the same disorder. I can tell you that comments like “she/he is stick thin” and other comments like that will just encourage them if they have an ed. they will think “hey! They noticed that I lost weight! That’s amazing”
Jiyong recently said he is doing okay. If you watch videos and photos from the past, he is really REALLY skinny guy. During M.O.T.T.E, he lost so much weight he even himself said that he wasn't doing good then and was really depressed, tired and lonely. Even though he is the reason why my type in men is skinny without muscles, i was really worried about him in 2017. But he gained weight since then and now looks much healthier and it's cause of his happiness. He is doing good and people shouldn't be so worried about him. He is doing things he loves and you can see from his posts that he actually is really happy. He has always been and still is skinny but that's why we love him. He is what he is and he is perfect that way. He is doing good. My baby.
It's even sadder how young they are. Nowadays Yuna is 18, Wonyoung 17, they were even younger in these clips. These companies starve minors. I doubt a single one of these girls have periods... They make money young just to retire at 30 with many health issues...
I'm personally very concerned with Wonyoung(also angry bc fans are saying she's just "naturally skinny", which I don't think that's the case) but telling them, if they are suffering with an eating disorder, that's not gonna help in fact it's just gonna do the opposite.
I don't have an eating disorder, but I know that if you have one, telling that someone "you're getting too thin!", their brain has taken a lot of damage from starving themselves and they'll take those concerns as "compliments" and encourage them to continue starving themselves
The sad thing about this when idols loose weight drastically some fans says their too skinny but when gain a little bit of fat they would say they're too fat/chubby.. 🙄
I think if the idols who claims that they are healthy then we should just let them be
I mean if they don't feel unhealthy , then that's another thing
Just people shouldn't bully them for having slim body
Some people just naturally have slim body and don't gain weight easily
Ikr
How would they feel if they are criticised for loosing weight and also for gaining weight
They have perfect bodies.
"especially girls" yup that's where you lost me
i really felt bad for all these idols i hope they eat well now
Bro in yuna's case i think it was just the lighting since you can see her ribs in the dalla dalla era as well with strong lightning she has always been skinny yes she looks a bit skinnier but overall she's okay and even if she gained weight she's still beautiful af
Nah, she’s not that skinny before look at her legs.
I don’t 100% believe that they don’t have some kind of eating disorder… but stress also tends to cause weight-loss and since a lot of idols could be pressured and busy, they might also forget to eat their meals. I’m not diagnosing… but I hope the companies take well care of these idols to make sure they don’t get sick or hurt
People pretending to be concerned for certain Idols while calling them a Skeleton in the same sentence makes me feel so sick... being skinny doesn't equal being Anorexic. As someone who is extremly skinny ever since birth, I had to Deal with people body shaming me ever since I was a child. Some people simply don't gain weight as easy as others plus these Idols work out all the time.... Yuna being so skinny at the Moment could basicly be a result of a busy scedule. Please stop hating on people that you concider to skinny for your liking and if you’re really concerned for them please be respectful. You can be concerned for them without calling them a Stick or Skeleton because let me tell you these comments really hurt.
(Sorry for my bad english)
Yes bodyshaming is bad calling someone stick, paper, skeleton, elephant etc is so bad when I was chubby (65kgs) people used to call me elephant and now I'm skinny af and weight 53kgs (I'm 5'8) people love to call me skeleton and it fvcking hurts
yheyre not skinny tho. that's the issue. making up excuses doesn't help either.
we saw before pics and none of them were skinny skinny. thier skinnier is achieved by other means that doesn't match qorh someone that dances and stuff for a living. literally look at pro dancers and they don't look like that.
As a skinny person that can eat a lot it's sad to see just our existence can cause people to get worried even tho I'm perfectly healthy. It's literally body shaming i don't know why people don't get it
I really don't understand why they want to be as skinny as possible. Do koreans really think that looks good?
"Fast metabolism" isn't as common as people think. Either you're eating enough to balance out the calories you're burning, or you're not.
If they're a healthy weight the fans tell them they're fat and if they lose that weight the fans tell them they're too skinny. There is no way to win in an industry that scrutinizes their bodies in this way and a lot of it is the fans' fault.
Fans want too much. Then the idol is thin: Too thin or l fat.
Ofc i used to be envious of their body but at some point i became concern about it. Its like not healthy at all. People must appreciate all types of bodies on idols . On the side how hard they work and train to become an idol we must respect it
For Yuna I just wanna say she’s still in her growing age she dances alot and has been into sports ever since she was a kid,Even though she eats pretty healthy her body doesn’t store fat drastically,in one of her Vlives she said she got a little belly so she’s been exercising for that the pictures do look scary and the reason for that is because the lights were directly above her and were harsh.Secondly even if you have some body fat if your flex you’re waist out you will see your rib age and the quality of these pictures isn’t that great either So it just added more definition to the dark areas or her rib cage.The timing if these pictures was just really bad
I hope those netizens know, camera contribute on making idols appear 5 to 10kg heavier than their actual weight. Those idols they bashed for looking "too heavy" are looking just fit and healthy in real life.. that's why they should stop dragging idols for their weight, their main job are to sing and perform not as an 'eye candy barbie'
I‘m really just curious as to how they are still able to dance when they are that slim. I once was quite underweight and I definitely did NOT feel like dancing at all :c
Pills maybe?
Its not our place to be talking about idols bodys, no matter how worried you are.
I'm almost underweight tho but still can dance...
@@shooky_bxnny3773 „almost“, so you’re not in the „dangerous“ bmi range.
@@lea5308 hmm ik but some people say I'm under weight back then and yet I can dance ...
But now I gained my weight so yeah..
i used to not eat and tell my friends i eat a lot… it’s so weird how naive people can be and how they believe skinny people are always natural
Please can you make a video on best female dancers please🥺
Great idea, tysm! But since there were too many videos about this topic, maybe we should only include Gen 4 idols ^^
Plz include gen 3 ....or just lisa
Hi I'm 38 international age. I weigh 105. My mother is 62 and weights 98. Please stop just stop this crap. Theyre to skinny. Look I'm in recovery and I have over 8 years clean and threw out the years my weight dropped not gained. I feel that people are looking at me as if I'm using drugs again when I'm not. This could hurt these people. Please stop telling people were to skinny 😭😭😭 isn't that what people want for these people?? Yet when they are skinny y'all say they're to skinny??? Make that make sense please
Being skinny doesn't promote anorexia, just like being fat doesn't promote obesity.
they are under alot of pressure and it´s alarming that labels always knack on them to loose weight but shouldn't they do the same then they become too skinny? it´s so unhealthy and scary
Those idols look better with a more healthy figure
knetizens hate on idols if they're average weight but then also hate on them if they are underweight?