Hindi: The National language of India? | But Why
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- National language is not an important aspect of a country or society. It is merely a tool for communication and does not hold any inherent value or significance.
There are many countries with multiple national languages and this has not affected their progress or unity in any way. In fact, it has allowed for a more inclusive and diverse society, where people from different cultural backgrounds can communicate and interact with each other.
Furthermore, the concept of a national language is often used as a political tool by governments to impose a certain language and culture on its citizens. This can lead to discrimination and marginalization of certain groups, leading to social tensions and conflicts.
Opinion Personal, please don't get offended.
Checkout KuKu FM: kukufm.sng.lin...
The first 250 users get 50% discount using this code: BW50
Follow me on Instagram and Twitter so I get sponsors for my videos and make videos frequently.
/ butwhyoutube
/ butwhyoutube
-For direct Support
/ butwhy
www.instamojo.... (Supports UPI)
Books I Recommend:
amzn.to/3lGpZ3n
amzn.to/40hiFKB
amzn.to/3K6BnyO
amzn.to/3FQkJRK
amzn.to/42H9hBs
How I Film:
Camera:
amzn.to/3K9qWLe
amzn.to/3K7eBqI
Light:
amzn.to/42CF5HP
amzn.to/3K8VxIO
Audio:
amzn.to/42CuZqr
Mic:
amzn.to/3JLXqcY
amzn.to/40xOcrj
Stands:
amzn.to/3K816qK
amzn.to/40BOnlp
Trivia Question so I know how many people actually read this section.
"How many official languages in Switzerland?"
Sources:
www.jstor.org/...
www.jstor.org/...
www.jstor.org/...
www.jstor.org/...
www.jstor.org/...
www.jstor.org/...
There are a couple of things which are not correct:
1. Hindustani is not a mixture of Urdu and Hindi but parent of these 2 languages. This language got split in 1850a during the Hindi Urdu controversy when the british wanted to make local languages as official language and in north India Hindustani was written in Devanagari by Hindus and nastaliq by Muslims which later on became Hindi and Urdu
2. Bangladesh didn’t separate because of Urdu. Bengali and Urdu both functioned as Pakistan’s national language from 1956 onwards and that issue got settled. Bangladesh separated due to socio economic injustice meted to east Pakistan between 1947-71 which resulted in Awami league calling for their 6 points which practically meant virtual separation of east from west which resulted in political deadlock of 1971 and subsequent independence of Bangladesh
the first point is not true. Hindustani isn't the parent of Hindi and Urdu. Khari Boli or the Dehlvi Dialect of Delhi is. Hindustani is an indepence movement effort by mostly upper-middle class of India to unite Hindus and Muslim on a major point of difference, i.e. the national language of what was to become independent India. Mostly progressives of the Congress party and writers of progressive writers association came up with the term and suggested it's replacement in place of Hindi or Urdu. You have Gandhi, Premchand and Manto championing that idea. Today Hindustani is seen both as the common place of Hindi and Urdu and also as therefore the parent but historically there was no such language as hindustani, aka mixture language.
But forceful compensation of Urdu language in Bangladesh was a problem which hurt of a lot of Bengali Pride due to that protest by Bengaladeshi students the un officially decleared that day as world mother tongue day
.....world was amazed by see love of bengalis for their laguage
@@sulusukta3935 more people were killed during the anti Hindi agitation in 1960s in south india then Bengalis in 1952 but yet only Bengalis got a day for themselves?! Why? Second everyone loves his or hoer mother tongue. Third Bengali language movement could have been considered the key or even one of the reasons for Bangladesh’s independence had Pakistan not given any status to Bengali as they demanded and kept on forcing Urdu on them but that didn’t happen and ultimately both the languages were given official status. Finally even sheikh mujeeb’s 6 points didn’t mention anything about Urdu Bengali or language Etc. Proving that the isssue was settled. I feel that Bangladeshis deliberately use language issue to harp up nationalism for Bangladesh’s cause (which is not required as Bangladesh’s independence movement was based on socio economic injustice metted towards them and thus the movement was justified esp when govt refused to transfer power to Mujeeb) you don’t need to bring ethnic nationalism but the same has been brought in to highlight the differences between the 2 wings and to fan hate towards Pakistan and ordinary Pakistanis esp the Urdu language. They don’t even spare Jinnah (a person due to whom even Bangladesh today stands as an independent country, had Pakistan not been created by him there would have been no Bangladesh today but Bangladeshis conveniently forget this fact and made him a villain only because he supported Urdu, he never said Bengali would be banned and told the people that they can have it as their provincial language , he chose Urdu as the national one because it was the only language which could have worked as a lingua Franca in a multi ethnic country like Pakistan).
yes u are right i also studied this in class 10 ICSE history
Hindustani is not a parent of Urdu and Hindi. The norther western Indian creole(common language) is called Hindustani. It is language that was born from the influence of Persian brought by the Mughals. Persian effected what ever was the creole at the time and it became hindustani it was also written in the Perso-Arabic script, thus this is essentially what Urdu is. Many Hindu nationalist may find what I'm about to say as heresy but in the late 1800's many Hindus out of racism/fascism or what ever started writing Hindustani with Devanagari to dissociate from muslims and called it Hindi and also started adding more sanskrit words in place of persian ones in formal contexts/liturature/education.
Now the issue with Bangladesh and Urdu is complex as the largest native Urdu speaker of Pakistan were in East Pakistan (EP: 3% is, WP: 0.8 % at the time, even today native urdu speaker make like 4% of Pakistan's population)
Great Effort bhai!!
Thank you so much 😀
aare bhai aap yaha
कंगना दीदी को कोई बताओ संस्कृत पुरानी भाषा नहीं है, उससे पुरानी पालि भाषा है,पाकृत पालि है
@@shubhanshuchandrakapure8629 wo ganja fuk ke bolti hai, kya bol rahe ho, conclude kya karna hai ye to samaj honi chahiye na 😂!
Bas sab bolke last me boldiya hindi ko banao. Gadhi
@@shubhanshuchandrakapure8629 unko ye bhi batao ki hebrew bhi purani bhasha h, or wo wapas zinda ho gyi
being a bengali I dont know how to read or write hindi, though i can understand hindi only while listening. This doesnt make me " Less Indian"
Joy bangla joy bharot
আমি পারি কিন্তু বলিনা । ওরা আমাদের ভাষা বলে ? না । তাহলে আমরা ওদের ভাষা ব্যবহার করবো কেন ?
আমিও তাই..পড়তে পারি না
জয় শ্রী রাম
@@psc3672জয় শ্রী রাম
We aren't buying 3 language propaganda. We are happy with English and our local language which is Bengali in my case. No one from the North belt is going to learn Bengali , Assamese or Tamil so why should we learn Hindi ?
Let unity in diversity remain forever.
Yay I found like minded people.
I mean I don't know bengali but urs idea coincides mine.
@@ispacie what's your mother tongue bro ?
@@Subho99817 it's a variant of hindi which is magadhi/magahi
But schools been teaching Hindi only
My identity Kannada my nation Karnataka ❤
NATION 😆😆😆😆😁
Switzerland have 4 official languages
• German
• french
• romansh
• Italian
You need to understand switzeland is a confederacy .
It means state govt>>> national governmnet.
likin switzerland me lon indian jese bebukov nahi hai 😆 jo har bat pe lare😡😡😡
India is 20 times bigger than Switzerland
@@nitishyadav4037 average self hating Indian
difference between official and national language
and moreover
idk india has 19000 officially recongnized languages
unofficial languages , idk how many there might be
so a same scenario cant be implemented
Shoutout to KuKu FM for supporting me in making this video.
Checkout KuKu FM: kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/jkun/85w3
The first 250 users get 50% discount using this code: BW50
I have a question. Does private colleges encourage quality of education through competition with other colleges? Or is it a myth? Why is India public college don't perform better than private colleges like Harvard? Could you please explore this topic?
Kindly make 1 video on women, child trafficking, prostitution and child labor/begging.
In these times of Hindu-Muslim hatred everywhere.. government should consider reviving these animations like "hind desh ke nivasi sabhi jan ek hai".. I'm a 2004 born i never saw these but really appreciate if we also got the chance to see such harmony stablishing initiatives.
@Ronit Mehta your state, Rajastan is also included in BIMARU. lol
@Ronit Mehta Rajasthan is A BIMARU state (Bihar Madhya Pradesh Rajasthan Uttarpradesh)
Wow..... thankfully someone think's what I've been thinking for so many year's.......it started with UP then MP, RAJASTHAN,BIHAR....now Karnataka also...... Hindu radicalism is approaching........I also believe in Islamic radicals....but their structure is different
Please don't talk like this. You are young and don't know many things. This forced,one sided secularism is never good for anyone
@@avibcci1297 its no more a bimaru state!!
Secondly it boasts royalty, grandeur..people across the world flock to rajasthan to see it's beauty and grandeur!!
Rich people ( not you) prefer to do weddings here!!
Come here and see the class of people..their appearance, physique, determination!!
We are excelling everywhere!!
Defence,civil services, business,services...just everywhere!!
Despite minimum resources and geographical disadvantages!!
Who are you by the way? Some ignorant south Indian with no life?
Many idli dosas live here,please take them back!!
I gradually become addicts of this channel.u really doing great job 👌👍🇮🇳
It’s a great day when ButWhy upload.
Hindi is also a foreign language like English for majority of Indians.
Source? Hindi is foreign language only for southern India and extreme north east. It's intelligible to max in north and central india from gujrat to Arunachal and from Kashmir to Chhatisgarh, Orissa till northern karnatka and Maharashtra.
@@avibcci1297 Nope. Hindi is native to around 40% Indians. Just because Hindi is intelligible to a lot of people doesn't mean that it's their native language.
@@Ishpreetb264 even its not native people are more comfortable in Hindi then English. That's why you don't see sub nationalism in northern part of India. That's what I want to say. Even if you're from different part in north people will prefer to communicate in Hindi then English untill ofcourse your upbringing was in privilege family.
@@avibcci1297 🤦♀️ Ever heard of Punjabi sub nationalism? Most Punjabis are Punjabi first and Indian seconds. Also, only urban class from Punjab can speak Hindi comfortably.
@@Ishpreetb264 yea and I bet they are more comfortable in Hindi than English, untill they are from a privilege background. The recent language debate itself started by Ajay Devgan who belongs to Punjab itself. 🤷
sir i am from Telangana one of the reason Telangana separated from Andhra Pradesh is because of dialect,both states speak Telugu but both state have different dialects, Telangana people did not accept Andhra telugu dialect,how do people from North think they will accept another language.
I am Gujarati, we Gujarati speak our own language, but still Hindi and English been taught in school, English for globalization and Hindi for interstate connectivity. I just only seen south Indian been stubborn and too conservative to accept new things and learn different things. Even south Indian conflict with other south Indian state for language. I mean seriously, you people are not progressive as we think, we don't fight with other states for language or haven't seen any countries rivaling for language. South Indian can keep three languages, one English, Hindi, and regional language. Even in US, most of my friends from the Middle East, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, to Nepal, to different state of India, we can connect easily, but with south Indians friends, I have to speak in English. Even South Indians from different states such as person from Kerala and Tamilan, they speak language in English. Modi is right, colonization is still deeply rooted in our Indian minds, and we're always looking for certificates from this white western media propaganda. British are the true winner, because technically India's constitution and national language in English.
@@j.r.j-ia802 bro in Telangana and Andhra we are learning Hindi from 1969i
@@veereshwarraomadasu5354 well, I have friend from Andhra in US, I have communicate him in English. Well anyway if Telangana and Andhra have Hindi as second or third language after regional and english language, consider sharing my message to your neighbour state Tamil Nadu or kerala. Never ever I have seen politician play politics on language and create hatred towards other state members or a country for langauge. We need one language to connect. English is not a language that makes a connection, there is honestly no fun in english.
@@j.r.j-ia802 no one can convince tamils even modi
@@veereshwarraomadasu5354 well, for this I agree with you. You are right, no one can convince tamilans.
Language no doubt helps in making us feel connected to others. But the issue is that India is more like a continent like Europe rather than a nation.
@Ronit MehtaWell you do understand Rajasthan is included in BIMARU state. Isn't it? no one killed it, just there is no sub nationalism for language in northern part. People will happily use both hindi and their language, also Language don't get killed by using different language. It itself become extinct if the next generation stop speaking or there is no future prospect with that language.
It's pretty wrong to say india is like europe, it's just a weird narrative that even some indians believe in. India somewhere lie between China and Europe.
@Ronit Mehta Marwaris themselves need to save their language and heritage.
@Ronit Mehta no one kills a language. Language don't get killed by using different language. It itself become extinct if the next generation stop speaking or there is no future prospect with that language. There is no point of making a language survive only for aesthetics. It should be just digitally stored in every details so, that it could be used for historical survey and studies.
@Ronit Mehta The government won't promote any language except Hindi (maybe Sanskrit) and we can see how badly Hindi is devolving despite that. You can't depend on the government, Marwaris need to launch an initiative like Rekhta to preserve and promote their language. Maybe go back to the original script instead of Devanagari.
Why people from north don't understand that 9-11 states are not whole India. If so please make your seperate country and do whatever changes you guys want to do
I don't understand the narrative of "English is a foreign language and hence we should not promote it in India". Like it or not, English is now the lingua franca of the world. It is the language of education, international politics and trade. It will be detrimental to Indians if we suddenly stop using English.
100 percent agreed
Toh fir cheen mei kyaa hai??
English ek colonialism kaa zariya tha.. apna brand Hindi toh chalao pehle
@@user-yb3ui7wo6v உங்களின் மறுமொழி எனக்கு முழுமையாகப் புரியவில்லை. நீங்கள் பயண்படுத்தியுள்ள ஆங்கிலச் சொற்களைவைத்து தோராயமாகப் பதிலளிக்கிறேன். சீனாவும் இந்தியாவும் ஒன்றல்ல. இந்தியாவில் வெவ்வேறு மொழிக்குடும்பத்தைச் சேர்ந்த மொழிகள் பலநூறு ஆண்டுகளாகப் பேசப்படுகின்றன. திடீரென்று இந்தியை அனைவரும் கற்றுக்கொண்டு பேசவேண்டும் என்பது மூடத்தனம். அது இயலாத ஒன்று. அதுமட்டுமல்ல, ஆங்கிலம் கற்பதினால் உலகத்தரக் கல்வி, வேலை, மற்றும் வனிகம் பேன்றவை எளிமையாகிறது. இந்தி மொழியால் தென்னிந்தியர்களுக்கு எந்தப் பயனுமில்லை. உங்களுக்கு ஆங்கிலத்தை அறவே ஒழிக்க வேண்டுமானால், வடக்கர்களாகிய நீங்கள் மிகவும் மூத்தமொழியானத் தமிழ்மொழியக் கற்றுக்கொள்ளுங்கள். புரிந்துகொண்டமைக்கு நன்றி!
@@user-yb3ui7wo6v bhai me maharashtrian hu aur meri language Hindi nhi he. Lekin fhir bhi bolni padti he. English hi ek language he jo sb accept krte he, aur one nation ka motto fulfill krta he.
Why are u so weak that you can't make your language your identity dominant?
✯தமிழ்(Tamil)🇮🇳
✯తెలుగు(Telugu)🇮🇳
✯മലയാളം(Malayalam)🇮🇳
✯ಕನ್ನಡ(Kannada)🇮🇳
✯ᱥᱟᱱᱛᱟᱲᱤ(Santali)🇮🇳
✯বাংলা(Bengali)🇮🇳
✯ଓଡିଆ(Odia)🇮🇳
✯ગુજરાતી(Gujarati)🇮🇳
✯ਪੰਜਾਬੀ (Punjabi)🇮🇳
✯আসামি(Assami)🇮🇳
✯Konkoni🇮🇳
✯Manipuri🇮🇳
✯Kashmiti🇮🇳
✯Bodo🇮🇳
✯Dogri🇮🇳
✯Maitheli🇮🇳
✯Nepali🇮🇳
✯اردو (Urdu)🇮🇳
✯سنڌي (Sindh)🇮🇳
It's অসমীয়া
yes all are indian languages
im sindhi from sindh ik urdu sindhi hindi engllish
Only Hindi
@@parvinsancheti What is Bihari language, Bihari is an identity, Chhatishgarhi, Rajasthani, Haryanvi are not all languages but local identity. The language of these states is not a constitutional language; that language cannot do official work.In Jharkhand, official work cannot be done from Kurmali because this language is not only constitutional, But the Santali language is a constitutional acceptance language; This language can be the first official language of Jharkhand state. but not happening . But leaving the Santali language, Hindi is being forcibly imposed on them.Is this happening right ? Why Tamil, Kannada Malayalam people will learn Hindi and what will be the benefit for them. Will the Hindi people learn the South Indian language because they don't need to? Similarly, the southern people do not need Hindi. Don't shake the emotion of Hindi, English language is fine, the country has progressed in the matter of science for English. Don't play the game of domestic and foreign. Hindi is a mixture of half Urdu, half Parsi, half Sanskrit language. From where did it become the native language?
@@parvinsancheti Why do you teach English? Won't you teach English to your next generation? How many people in India became doctor and engineer after studying in Hindi medium. Maybe not even one. Is any university studying science through Hindi medium? Do not give knowledge of the native language.
Please explain - why Tamil language is Sthaniya Bhasha and why Panjabi, Bengali, Hindi, Assamese language are Deshi language ? Please explain what is the different between Sthaniya Bhasha and Deshi Bhasha.
Every time someone talks to me in Hindi, I feel insulted insecure and second class citizen of India. There is nothing humiliating than to listen to Hindi which I don't understand a word.
Lol then just get the hell out from India, india doesn't need people like you we are already overpopulated. My President speaks Hindi Prime minister speaks Hindi our cinema is Hindi then who the hell are you angrezi gandu
@@Frozen_flames_ bro hindi is not even a natural indian language. (I am not saying hindi is a foreign language) It is a heavily persianised language. Hindi was seperated from hindustani only in the 19th century. Hindustani was a hindi sounding language using Persian script. Hindustani was the result of Mughal rule in india, where Farsi was used as the official language.
Dravidian languages originated within the indian sub-continent. Dravidian languages are true indian languages.
You are portraying hindi like it is the only language of India but in reality is far from that discription.
Then the problem lies in your own mindset भाई
Absolutely, Hindi as a language is poor and unsophisticated.
Liberty to choose their language should not be questioned. Just this don't force anything by enacting a law. It's an individual who gonna decide which language will make their life financially and societally prosperous. Personally I believe local mother tongue and english is what we need, coz india has basically lots of language.
As someone who speaks my mother tongue(sino - tibetian) which is not the state language, it difficult as my mother tongue is native to the region but not the majority speaking language.
Today’s Hindi is more of Urdu than Sanskrit.
It's my opinion....
Every Indian should know atleast 3 languages....
1) ur mothertongue
2) Hindi ( common Indian language)
3) English....
My mothertongue is BENGALI bt I hv learned Hindi....
Right now if a north indian needs to speak to a South Indian, the communication should be in English, bt the fact is even English is a foreign language to them....
So, I think there should be a common INDIAN LANGUAGE LIKE HINDI....IN India in which every indian no matter the demography can communicate....
Learning a new language doesn't discredit ur mothertongue, ALWAYS REMEMBER THT....
Tbh mother tongue and english is enough...if everyone know english then u dont need hindi...its just our selfishness i guess...people just dont wannna support forign language
@@confirmed1778 nop hindi should be there
@@manthanpatel6295 nah
@@nuppanuppa does it really matter?u and me r using english rn...english is easier to learn and can be used in other countries too its like an investment....and i dont want division bruh...its better to learn english as a linking language than forcing people to learn hindi.
@Shameek Barman For spoken Hindi , u can bt for proper grammatical written Hindi...u hv to hv proper study....
I think Python ...
HTML, JavaScript and Python... these should be languages to teach in schools...
🤣
Great! You know what we had a computer class in our school from 5th standard to 10th standard in those 5 years we learnt nothing 😂 because our computer teacher had almost no knowledge about computer! Even we had a textbook and we used to give exam but after those 5 years of learning some of my friends didn't even know how to create a Gmail account 😂🤦
While you learn hate in Madrasas, right!!
@@kesardogra5529 Narrow minded comment
@@mayankbisht7691 not at all bro is spitting facts
We should try to learn as many indian language as possible, my self being bengali, i can speak and wite Hindi english also, I can understand Sanskrit and trying to learning it by reading scriptures. I am also trying to learn Nepali as Darjeeling is my favourite holiday destination and i often go there.
Learning every language is not possible india is full of many different different languages
I'm an Odiya speaking Bengali Hindu. Because in the southern most portion of Paschim Medinipur district is Odiya speaking but the official language is Bengali in all official documents.
Two languages is enough to both communication and heritage.
English is most effective communicative language in the world.
BANGALI DETECTED , OPINION REJECTED
No ... you should learn hindi ... to communicate
@@manthanpatel6295
🤣
Fuck it
Im from UP{speaks hindi}.....i completely agree with u..nobody should enforce any language on you but please don't demand for english as link language....we may existed as different kingdoms but ethnically we are the descendants of the great BHARAT sometimes rules by great cholas, pandyas, vakataks and sometimes by mauryans/ kushans and by lord RAMA himself...our DNA IS SAME ...don't let language divide us please bhai....we had existed for Millenniums even with differences in language and we will keep existing but with BHARTIYA language no matter for me whether is it tamil or hindi....kannada or malayalam or gujrati or any other language.
@@nuppanuppa
With English you can communicate with the whole world. With just one language so stop this emotional drama and be practical.
Rich people's children are learning German, Spanish, French as third language in top private schools where they already have excellent command on English.
As an Spanish learner I m sure what your point is for !!!!😅❤❤❤
Estonian, Italian, Greek, Norwegian, Swedish and Russian will complete their hollow minds with the right dose of the superior European languages.
Why should we remain limited to learning only English? All European languages are far superior and should be taught to every Indian student to teach them the right culture.
@@parjanyashukla176 how are they superior? In fact the number of speakers is low?
Awesome video!
Also the few countries like France, Spain etc aren't as diverse but the Israel example was great!
Also being from UP it just weirds me out when people tell me Urdu is a Pakistani language 😅
The top down imposition of Hindi might cause a lot of fractures in the Indian society.
But I guess with this new wave of regional cinema other languages will gain widespread acceptance in the hearts of even da most rigid Hindi speakers.
इतिहास उन्हीं का जीवित रहता है, जिनकी भाषा जीवित रहती है
- स्टीफेन स्प्लेंडर
"योग" को जब यूरोप-अमरीका में पहचान मिली, उसके बाद भारत के लोग भी उसका महत्व समझने लगे। हिन्दी के बारे में भी वही बात है। संयुक्त राष्ट्र में मान्यता मिलने के बाद भारत के लोग भी हिन्दी के प्रति सम्मान दिखाना और व्यवहार करना आरंभ का देंगे। भाषा एक एसेट्स है,दुसरे लोगों से interact करने का 85% भारत मे सर्वाधिक रूप समझने व बोलने मे हिंदी सहज भाषा है,अधिकांश सभी क्षेत्रीय भाषाओ मे हिंदी के बहुत से शब्द घुल मिल गए है। हमारी सबकी प्यारी न्यारी हिंदी ।।🎈🎈🌍 Global पहचान बनाएगी ।
जय भारत 🇮🇳
Finally you remembered the password
I am from gujarat and Hindi is foreign language to us...and it should be remove cause outsiders who migrate here don't learn out language,every non-hindi state should follow like south indians
honestly bro ur content is really really good and premium i must say and the kind of explanation in a story format make it more connective to the viewers , and yaa ur content is limited with no. of videos upload but still ur doing better then other youtuber's explainer videos ..
wish to meet you soon
😊
3 language formula works in Maharashtra, Gujrat, Odisha,West Bengal, Kerala and telugu states.
You are right brother that's why I believe in BJP
@@abha_official bjp is not in these states
NO..in odisha .We have option Sanskrit.So. Max . students choose Sanskrit over hindi .It's Difficult To write..and speak..so we avoid it after 8th..But People Understand Hindi Through Movies
U r Wrong..in Kerala.nd Telugu states..Totally Diff .. Dravidian language... Don't Understand Hindi ...hindi only works in Capitals..- Hyderabad...( Also Bcoz muslim majority ).not Everywhere..
@@patrickbatemanfromohio I mean bjp 3 language ideology.....
I’m from Uttarakhand and lived there for 3 years in Covid time. Uttarakhand has 3 major native language Garhwali, Kumauni and jaunsari
But State language is Hindi.
Problem with promoting hindi is that it is always at the expense of other languages.
I lived in Ranikhet, it was so sad and painful to see young kids not speaking in Kumauni (native language) but Hindi. They can’t speak Kumauni at all though they can understand
As per Indian Govt, Kumauni is just a dialect of Hindi. However as per linguist kumauni is part of Western Himalaya same as Nepali
Same has happened to Marwari,Bagri, Bhojpuri, Saraiki, Maithili, Garhwali etc
All grouped together as Dialect of Hindi just to increase Hindi percentage
BTW मेरी मातृभाषा हिन्दी है दिल्ली में परवरिश होने के कारण
11:35 First Indian Animation broadcast on tv 1974...
I think making English as our official language is better than Hindi. Making Hindi makes sense as much as making Telugu or any other languages.
What about Sanskrit??
@@kesardogra5529 impractical
@@Dev-re6fp No thanks first pay our tax share equally and stop breeding like dogs.
@@ak-th5xt ITS PRACTICAL
@@Dev-re6fp how about no?
Bro you should collaborate with *India in Pixels*
Your content is always on top❤.. thanx from Assam.
Love your channel bro. I hope I can learn a thing or two from your channel love the great work.
Loved it! Nostalgic feeling with songs.. mile sur mera tumhara and hind desh ke niwasi.. we used to sing them during school times.. good old days :)
English should be the national language
If we want to develop
Yesss
It already is. We just don't acknowledge it. 😅 People fight whether or not we should make Hindi the national language in... wait for it... ENGLISH! We Indians can't even fight without the help of English language. It's sad that some people want to label it as a foreign language. Even China is learning English today. The usage of English will not fade away anytime soon.
@@தமிழோன் exactly.
Nah we aren't slave of British
@@kat-hm7gv good for u✌✌
Every language in india should be the national language. I'm from Tamil Nadu but eventhough i can speak hindi it is as foreign language to me as English is.
I am addict your way to express your massage..thank you..please upload regularly
Hindi is not the National language of India & there's no such national language of India.. But article 343(1) says that It is an official language like other 21 languages..
So It is needed to be understand by the people who're claiming that Hindi is our national language..
Jay Hind!
Hindi is the north Indian Language, should be banned to speak in other states
@@subodhkene3696 that's not fair I think cause It is a multi cultural nation..
Switzerland has 4 official languages.
Namely German,French, Italian and Romanish.
Your voiceover is equally good as of video editing... Lots of love from Kashmir.
You are My best editor
Bhai what is the situation in kashmir right now?
@@randomturd1415 it's as usual bro
I like watching his videos . The way he tells us every information is just so good. His videos more feel like a documentary 👍🏻
My formula is that .. every indian should learn 4 language.. for north local , regional (hindi), English and any south language ( which is not included as test but only learning ) and southern states should learn local, English and any northern language including hindi , Gujarati, Marathi, bagali or northeastern language... and sanskrit Is mandatory for Northern state everyone will happy
Waste of time...just learn english
If I learn kanadaa then how can I survive in Tamil Nadu? But if u learn Hindi u can easily survive in any north states
@@Uda_dunga North States are not really survivable. That is why even Pakistani language people are not able to stand there and migrating to Non Pakistani language states of South...but they are in the process Pakistanifying and spoiling the place they go. These people are a big danger and hence business dealing with them must be reconsidered. They are already involved in too many murder cases in TN.
@@iis9822 ok
@@Uda_dungaIf In don't to move in UP/ Bihar, why do I need to learn hindi then?
This whole national language debate is nonsense. india is multilingual country it's fact accept it and move on and learn java, c++, HTML, paython it will help you more
kuch yaha bhi hindi ka support english me karenge...
😂👏
There are 4 official language in Switzerland..
Hindustani nahi jante wo bharat ke log nahi hai what irony yeah yeah bhai true they are pakistanis bcz they speak hindustani, 😂 don't forget why Ukrainians fighting invasion of Russia...why east Pakistan formed to bangaladesh...I do speak hindi I have learnt on my own ...not through education why it's thier even in the study for non hindi state do you know how many just fail in thier exams due to Hindi language...I wish children learn languages on their own not through imposition in study...it is ridiculous...i do love and respect hindi language but hegemony of it northerns and govt doing is unacceptable...
रवींद्रनाथ ठाकुर ने भी संपर्क भाषा के रूप में पूरे भारत के लिए हिंदी को उपयुक्त बताया था और गुजरात के एक मंच पर उन्होंने थोड़ी देर हिंदी बोलने का भी प्रयास किया था।
If you're a Bengali, why are you typing in Hindi ? This is the mindset that's destroying our Bengali culture. Why do people randomly start using Hindi here ? Do you think it makes you more of an Indian ?
America is thriving country because of diversity in talents brought up by migrants. It's no use to make groups more homogenous rather than promoting diversity. Unity is one thing and being alike is another. People don't need to speak same language to belong to same nation.
I agreed most sensible and positive comments ❤❤❤❤❤
Hamare yaha logo ko unity by assimilation ki jagha unity in diversity par dhyan dena chahiye or ye tab hoga jab Hamri ek identity Indian hogi 😀 Tamil, Hindu,shudra ye sab second identity honi chahiye
@@Stellar_lnsights bhai it's reference to cast language and religion nothing else but I think you losed your Indian identity
@@zomvier-maraxavier7113 fuck I overjudged you. Sorry
No, we won't let you clowns assimilate us.
@Alexios I Komnenos but it's a cast
Learning Hindi will diminish the Cultural Identity. But Learning English won't. Great Logic👏🏻
Both will but English can just act as a link language.
Becoz English is a foriegn to everyone so it will never become our identity.while hindi is main language to certain group, it gives clear advantage to certain group and it becomes our identity and we have to carry that in outer countries too unlike today where we proudly say our language name and also it will make South Indians as second class citizens and we will be seen with nationalism eyes like you are seeing Muslims today we don’t want such situation.
@@Attitudezero884 Oh for God sake I am repeating it again, everytime and everywhere. *Hindi is not a Regional Language* . It's in the Metropolitans or Tier-2 cities where you see People speaking Hindi. Everybody in the North has their own Language other than Hindi
@@rahulgupta9975 it is regional language of you people and which language north have you mean the dielects of hindi oh sorry the languages made as dielects of hindi, those languages are not even used outside nor they are taught in schools, how can you compare those dielects with South Indian languages which have separate identity.
@@Attitudezero884 There more Language in UP alone than whole of South India. But they might sound 'Dialect' to you as you are living in your own Barbie World. But still let me tell you more North Indian Language who have Completely Different Script and are very well Taught in Schools.
1. Punjabi (ਪੰਜਾਬੀ)
2. Gujrati (ગુજરાતી)
3. Bengali (বাংলা)
4. Santali (ᱥᱟᱱᱛᱟᱲᱤ)
5. Magadhi (𑂧𑂏𑂡𑂲)
There are more, Kashmiri for eg, but it's Script nowadays is kind of from Foreign. There is Sindhi, Haryanvi, Bhojpuri, Bundeli, Maithli, Himanchali Pahari. But they have Hindi Script. They are completely different language to Speak and Understand. Maybe your Definition of Dialect in your Madras Dictionary is different (Which I can guess by your English). A Hindi Dialect would be a Language even Hindi Speaker can understand. But these are not. Every one of these Language has different Vocabulary and sometimes Sentence Structure too. And I am guessing you must be Tamil, which is spoken in Singapore and Malaysia. That's why you Jumping around on why Hindi or other North Indian Language is not spoken Outside India. Let me tell your Tiny Chicken Head that Bhojpuri and Hindi are spoken in huge Percentage in:
1. Fiji (Official Language)
2. Mauritius
3. Trinidad and Tobago
4. Suriname
5. Guyana
6. Nepal
Apart from these Hindi language is also spoken Largely in Malaysia, Singapore, South Africa, Afghanistan. So make sure to Do your Homework before making Remarks on YT comments next time
I am from Tamilnadu and I have completed 8 exams in Hindi upto Praveen Uthrath in Hindi in my 8th grade itself and got the certificate as well.They say it is equal to a Undergraduate level.😂 But after that I never spoke Hindi , didn't watch Bollywood movies which I am not a big fan of as present Kollywood movies are good enough for my liking. Now I can't speak in Hindi😂 because I lost the practice but I can read name plates, address etc 🤣.I never regretted abou it because I don't care 😂 Hindi Theriyathu poda with a Undergraduate Degree in Hindi🤣😂
What an irony. Today, when we want Marathi name plates to be used for shops in Maharashtra , there are many who feel incorrect.
Urdu is not a symbol of Muslim identity. It's a symbol of India's syncretic culture.
Well people see it that way cause it's the language of Pakistan and then Ofcourse the hatred toward a muslim country.
@@avibcci1297 It's the language of India. Urdu has been in existence far longer than Pakistan.
@@Tajdar645 no. India and Pakistan both have equally long history of Urdu. Mughal empire spread through north india and pakistan. Anyways this fact doesn't change the way it's perceived by many people in India.
Ha ha
50 percent Urdu is foreign language because Farsi , Arabic , aaj hume thodi bahut urdu esliye samaj aati hai kyoki , urdu ka bahut se words hindi mai mix ho chuke hai ,
I loved all ur videos but only disagreed your russo-ukraine war video where u blatantly supported Russia, the country responsible for thousands of deaths and justified those war crimes
Jai shree Rama 🚩 love from Karnataka 🇮🇳❤
Hindi is Originally Urdu,which is Used with Two Scripts Devnagari and Nasatalic
The production quality of these videos never ceases to impress me
Hindi and Urdu are same languages with different scripts. Hindi is not our national language and will never be. We will accept only English as a link language. For people of Karnataka, Kannada is our national language and is considered as supreme in our state. We will respect all the languages but will not accept any forceful use of any language. One should keep in mind that we were a separate kingdom with our own rich language and culture and joining Indian union we are not going to kill it.
Im from UP{speaks hindi}.....i completely agree with u..nobody should enforce any language on you but please don't demand for english as link language....we may existed as different kingdoms but ethnically we are the descendants of the great BHARAT sometimes rules by great cholas, pandyas, vakataks and sometimes by mauryans/ kushans and by lord RAMA himself...our DNA IS SAME ...don't let language divide us please bhai....we had existed for Millenniums even with differences in language and we will keep existing but with BHARTIYA language no matter for me whether is it tamil or hindi....kannada or malayalam or gujrati or any other language.
We will impose 🤣
English as linking language?absurd
@@Jatin-vy5dx maybe for you, but not for South Indians. We are happy with our mother tongue and english to communicate with rest of the world.
You guys should stop studying English and learn only Hindi.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 🤡🤡🤡
In our school we were taught -odia, English, Sanskrit/hindi.
Today we all love our national language but rationally thinking if we were an English speaking country it would have contributed more in our developing country.
In school assembly, we used to sing these lines "हिन्द देश के निवासी सभी जन एक हैं
रंग रूप वेष भाषा चाहे अनेक हैं |"
We united by diversity.
Hame ek national language chahiye kyu ki isase india ekjut ho jayega ham ek dusare se easily communicate kar payenge ek dusare ke sath understanding badegi ek communication se language sikhana bhi aasan ho jayegi language sikhana ki struggle kam ho jayegi padhai me other language subjects kam ho jayege padhai ka load kam ho jayega other countries me jo knowledge hai usaka one language books me aasani se conversation ho payega apani bhasha me samajane me aasani ho jayegi concepts aasan tarike se samajane lagege jisase people intelligent banenge shiksha me badotari hogi knowledge badega literacy rate me badotari hogi jisase innovations hoge.
🇮🇳★ INDIAN🇮🇳HINDI+LANGUAGE ★🇮🇳
🚩★💐★🇮🇳★🇮🇳★💐★🚩
🇮🇳★ INDIAN🇮🇳HINDI+LANGUAGE ★🇮🇳
The politically singular India was a result of territorial consolidation by the British. We are not a nation, we are a super-nation, and we should take pride in that. I'm a Citizen of India and I'm part of the Assamese Nation. Long Live the Republic of India and Long Live Assam.
@Alexios I Komnenos not exactly
That's not exactly true. The unification of princely states was done by Indian leaders and then the partition on the basis of religion gave us what modern day India is. It's an indestructible union of destructible states. It's the result of nationalism manifestation of India which had a clear objective of a strong political entity containing indian values and civilisations so, that no foreign power will ever control or invade us again.
No Rohan, gravely wrong. Territorial consolidation of India was NOT done by British. Their territory included Myanmar, Pakistan, Bangladesh and parts of Afghanistan too. Most of these are not part of India today, which means that modern India is a consolidation of Dharmic culture or places with a Dharmic history BY Indians themselves.
Secondly, we are NOT a super-nation. The 'super-nation' is called "Akhand Bharat", which includes all countries across the world where Indic culture has reached - Indonesia, Thailand, Tibet Autonomous Province of China, Myanmar etc. And actually even the Chinese Buddhism which spread to Japan and Korea has an Indian origin so many count China, Japan and Korea in it too even though the culture significantly changes there. India is a normal nation, and with due respect, Assam is a state/province of India, just like my home state Uttarakhand is.
Historically though, I accept, respect and take pride in the fact that Assam was a separate kingdom and hence, a separate 'country', which has centuries of legacy of its own. Those Indians who know of the Tai Ahoms take supreme pride in them even if they're not Assamese.
BRITISHERS CREATED MASS GENOSIDES THROUGHOUT BHARAT !!LOOTED 45,000TRILLION POUNDS
இந்தி இந்தியாவின் தேசிய மொழியாக இந்தி இருக்க வேண்டும் என்றால், தமிழர்களும் சுதந்திர திராவிட நாடு வேண்டும்
நீங்கள் வீடியோவைப் புரிந்து கொள்ளவில்லை அல்லது முழு வீடியோவைப் பார்க்கவில்லை என்று நான் உறுதியாக நம்புகிறேன்.
yes bro we will make 20 country in india beacuse telugu state will never accept tamil as a common language .
so i think for every language we should make a seprate language .
Every regionals languages have their own legacy . No one can tolerate imposing other languages on theirs mother tongue.
Has not have with every also on their not theirs
I humbly support the diversity of Indian languages,we should not force any language on India , because South and eastern States have different languages and we should support the diversity India because India is an unity of States 😍
I wonder Pakistan speaks Urdu same as Hindi If we make Hindi as official language then it's same as Pakistan only South Indian languages are pure form of Sanskrit and are considered as classic languages Hindi is not a Classic language Just official languages this ends the Debate of making Hindi official language it's more Arabic and Persian than Sanskrit TQ,
This is another proof that BJP is an ISLAMIC CULT and the same party as CONGRESS. Pakistani language is part of Islamification of India.
I don't think Hindi imposition is the result of hatred or superiority complex toward regional languages but insecurity of coloniser's or elite class language as a link language in India. You believe it or not but despite Hindi not being actual mother tongue of many it's intelligible to Gujrati, Marathi, Bengali, etc. but Hindi is not intelligible to Dravidian languages so, there is basically no point of learnings it untill necessary. Many people say use Sanskrit but it's not intelligible to Dravidian language either way. North Indians themselves don't speak proper Hindi, mix 75% English into that, so better focus over there. Also if people want the other guy to learn Hindi then it should be done in mutual way. Learn Tamil it has its legacy in south east asia and other places and have a very long history without much interference of invaders from outside. It's most probably the only language which wasn't influenced by either Sanskrit or Hindi/Urdu.
50 percent of tamil is sankskrit
God knows what world are you living in! Bro almost all of the Indian languages, including the Dravadian ones have a good and significant portion of Sanskrit. The day Hindi is sanskritized, more south Indians would love to try and learn the language as a lot of common link would be established. The current Hindi has some foreign (urdu, Persian, etc) flavour which is totally alien to the people of the southern part of India. That's also one of the reasons..
Aryan Dravidian this is all nonsense, this was divide and rule by the British
@Islam Virodhi lol a northie calling a classical language by names the biggest i have ever heard.🤣🤣😘😘😘😘
@Islam Virodhi ye it is unpleasant to your ears becoz you have been used to listen one of the worst language thats why.
Language is root of any culture
I am a Bengali and I can read, write and speak in Hindi. Kudos to my friends at school. Never felt like imposition back then. Now it does. And it makes me want to avoid Hindi whenever possible.
I think English should be seen as a skill rather than language. Just learning that makes you open to new knowledge. It is not that hard to teach 3 languages in 1st 5 years.
Well no thanks.
माफ करना दोस्त तुमहारी बात नही मानता
How English can be a skill??? are'nt chinese/koreans/japanese progressing without ur so called english skill.
@@runajain5773 Why dont you yap in Pakistani language in your home country of Pakistan....you will have several mullahs for company speaking the same Pakistani language.
@gansubram4584i agree with you...but for in case if you will to learn Hindi you can it's just depends on your choice... No one needed to force any language.....😅❤❤❤
03:04 after that speech South Indian peoples were like okay fine we don't want to be a part of India, that exactly what happened at that time it was that serious
Looking at the status of North India, they should have created a separate Nation including Maharashtra & West Bengal. Period.
@@A_Responsible_Citizen what the hell are you taking about
@@A_Responsible_Citizen but the democracy of India has kept us together
@@A_Responsible_Citizen India is an indestructible union of destructible states. It's no lesser than pipe dream imao and stop suggesting that either way.
Dravida Nadu
Never ever should alanguage be imposed on Indian population. In the Heartland of Hindi, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, Hindi served to erase local mother tongues from many areas. Language imposition is like religion imposition, I feel
Considering the diversity, 2 language policy, English and mother tongue is good thing
We himachalis dont want kangana, i pass her to the gadwali community
Between Hindi & Urdu Fight....... Our Dravidian Languages are Dying Day by Day...... Like Kannada, Tamizh, Telugu, Malayalam, Brahui, Tulu, Kodava & Many more 80+ Languages!!!!....... Single Language for National Integration is one of the worst & Biased Idea for National Integration!!!...... Especially in Diverse Country Like INDIA!!!!!
How your language dying there is no hindi imposition are there how can be
@@runajain5773 Madam Please! Don't Reply Like Voluntary Illiterates!!! Do some Homework than Reply
@@nsharat5498 what do mean I just ask the question how south indian language dying there is no hindi imposition how illiterates question is
@@runajain5773 Shayad Aapko Angrezi Nahi Aaati Hain, Krupaya Hindi Mein hi Boliye...... Aapki Angrezi Vyakarn main Samajh Nahi paa Raha hun....!!!
@@nsharat5498 dikhi abjib pata karte ho ise acha tumse bat nahi karo bye
If we people of India is used the other countries material why don't like English
Thanks for
I impress your intention for Nation
India really needs this type long video
creators
And ha chnada b ek Suraj b ek tare b ek hai hum sab ek hai 😍
United Nations General Assembly Adopts Resolution On Multilingualism, Mentions Hindi Language For First Time.Welcome to the superpower future of india modi's dream national language HINDI 🇮🇳Every country has one dominant language, in India there is Hindi!!! Also we support local language!! Shame on those who are doing politics in India especially Tamilnaidu Dravidian party as they want to fool people by language politics
If Hindi speaking people are 40% of Indian population
Than , don't forget that Dog population of India is 40 %
And Tiger population of India are only 3000
Now , You should tell us .
What should be the National Animal of India ?
India should use India language and not Pakistani language. First of all the Pakistanified people should be thrown to their Paki land.
সুন্দৰ explanation... 👏
The last minute song just touched my heart.
India ki national language Sirf love ho sakti hai....😊 😍
great video 👍
I am personally a RWinger but support English as national language
Ye english is better
Then Britain is best for you
Tamils will not accept. Sanskrit ok as national language
Fool hai anek lekin mala to ek hai. Yahi hamara Bharat hai.
Finally the video which we all needed about our national language and everyone should know that India doesn't have any national language we have to official language is which is Hindi and English but they are some Bhakts who believe that Hindi is our official language. According to the survey less than 50% of the Indian population he can be only 43% people in India speak Hindi as the mother tongue language and rest 53% are of different languages spoken in our Country. Love from Kolkata brother 👍
@Islam Virodhi first of all I have talked about that how many people in India have their mother tongue as Hindi not how many people can understand if you calculate in that point of view that how many people can listen or understand Hindi then there are more than 30% of Indian population who can understand English so from that point of view English should also be our national language but it's not ?. My point is that only 43% of Indian population have their mother tongue as Hindi not even half of Indian population so how can it would be our national language it is perfect to be our official language which it is!, But the rest 57% citizens of India have different mother languages, understood (Bhakt) ?
@Islam Virodhi so what ?, Everyone in this country love the mother language which they speak and why we will listen to your mother tongue language which we didn't want to speak even if we understand it, than also for what reason ?, For you North Indians only India is going to be divided because you are continuously forcing every law on other states, how will you feel if Tamil becams the national language of India will you be able to tolerate it ?
@Islam Virodhi Hindi is your mother tongue language that's why it is easier for you to understand or to speak but for different regions of India their people have different languages which they finds it easier to understand and to speak.
@Islam Virodhi only North India is not the whole India okay ?, South India is much more developed and better than North India.
@Islam Virodhi this is what I was talking about you not the India are totally intolerant people and you people only fight on religion and caste but we are not like you, South Indian are the most secular people we believe in equality, liberty and dignity but you not Indians are racist and sexist people but the South Indians are not like you, because South Indians live peacefully together with respective every religion and culture but you not Indians only fight on the name of religion and destroy people and by the way South India is much more economically developed them not India and South Indians are the most educated people in India not like you uneducated and uncivilized people like you 🤣.
Since childhood Hindians have been fed this lie that Hindi is the national language, OMG, I can't say about the arrogance of these Hindians coming down South for jobs and demand us to speak in Hindi stating that Hindi is the national language, I had to enlighten so many of these individuals that Hindi is not the national language, and these same people don't even learn four words of South languages even when they are working in South
@Islam Virodhi Lol, why do you think Hindi is sooo pleasing to ears?. Yes, if I go to Chennai I would love to learn Tamil or if I go to Kolkata I would try my best to learn Bengali
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Knowledgable content, loved it
Sanskrit as the national language? Lady you do realise that current Hindi is a mix of Sanskrit and Persian right?
I would rather learn English than Sanskrit, because
A) it is significantly more useful
B) Its a pretty 'neutral language' in India because of its foreign origin so no state can claim it
Neutral to who?? You realise Sanskrit is the language of Hindustan.
How it can be neutral , it symbolize the Slavery of British and India being Land of Language, we have to make a Foreign Language as our main language.
SANSKRIT WILL BE NATIONAL LANGUAGE.
@@NetajiSubhash265 No lol I'm not that sentimental to think "Its the language of the opressor". It's a pragmatic decision it's the most spoken language in the world hence I shall learn it also everyone hates the British so this might even unite us under a common banner lol not divided by language
@@kesardogra5529 yeah Sanskrit is Hindustan language or whatever the fuck. But the script of Tamil, telgu and Malayalam is so vastly different than the Sanskrit script it's illogical to use that as a "national language" sure there are loan words in Tamil from Sanskrit but well, it's not the same script. I don't know why everything is about Sanskrit these days, it's like Latin and virtually extinct language( don't tell me about that one village in Karnataka or some place that speaks Sanskrit I mean it's one village) that should be learn out of interest. It doesn't make sense to make it a 'national language'
This content sir
Your like mini vox😎
Wah I simply love your content
Switzerland's national languages are German, French, Italian and Romansh